They where not underrated why would you underage a band that you chose to see especially double shaxphone through wha wha you’d have to be as mad as a light house keeper’s parrot wearing sun glasses
Pure poetry...And the music rises from the poem. And at last , the music gains its own identity. VDG is one of the most powerful and unique musical projects of the century.
@@normangray3438 it's different for many aspects, first of all the stories are not fairy tales, they are introspective, face social problems and so on. It's just because that was the period of the prog rock and the length of Peter's songs is exactly the same as the songs of other bands. Furthermore, they also have a sort of common thread in every album. These are the only connections I see with prog.
Hard to believe that someone in 1972 actually knew how to properly video record a band playing music of this dramatic complexity, without (actually, some, but not too many) silly camera "accents". The cameras actually hit the right instruments at the right time, which leads me to believe that the producer actually knew the music. An incredible proposition.
yeah, makes a real difference, doesn't it! The bane of my life as a kid was watching Top of the Pops and the BBC camera man would always do something dumb like a close-up on the drummer when I wanted to watch the synth solo.
I saw Van der Graaf many times in the mid 70s but they never played Lighthouse. I always assumed this was because it was too complex to play live so it's wonderful to see this video. I actually roadied for them (sort of). I was sitting in the Poly bar at Newcastle when they came in looking for volunteers to bring their gear up from the truck. That would have been late 74 or early 75....
I'm lucky enough to have seen them do it, albeit as a three-piece, on the Grounding in Numbers tour. The opening was genuinely the most spine-tingling thing in my long and extensive gig-going life.
Yes, because they made it through the piece, and it was no.l in Italy, more importantly they'd made a masterpiece. That's success all round in my book, oh, and they never sold out or otherwise compromised. Quality!
I like the fact that Peter Is clearly already baked a bit (they were notoriously oriented in that fashion) but when he sings and bangs the keys you dont even notice. Great guys, must have been histerical to hang out with at those times.
*A PLAGUE OF LIGHTHOUSE KEEPERS* I. Eyewitness Still waiting for my saviour, storms tear me limb from limb my fingers feel like seaweed...I'm so far out, I'm too far in I am a lonely man...my solitude is true my eyes have borne stark witness and now my knights are numbered too. I've seen the smiles on dead hands, the stars shine, but they're not for me. I prophesy disaster and then I count the cost.... I shine but, shining, dying, I know that I am almost lost. On the table lies blank paper and my tower is built on stone I only have blunt scissors, I only have the bluntest onde I've been the witness, and the seal of death lingers in the molten wax that is my head. When you see the skeletons of sailing-ship spars sinking low You'll begin to wonder if the points of all the ancient myths are solemnly directed straight at you. II. Pictures/Lighthouse (Eddies/rocks/ships/collision/remorse.) III. Eyewitness No time now for contrition, the time for that's long past. The walls are thin as tissue and if I talk I'll crack the glass. So I only think on how it might have been, locked in silent monologue, in silent scream Anyway, I'm much too tired to speak and, as the waves crash on the bleak stones of the tower, I start to freak.... ...and find that I am overcome... IV. S.H.M. 'Unreal, unreal!' ghost helmsmen scream and fall in through the sky, not breaking through my seagull shrieks... no breaks until I die the spectres scratch on window-slits hollowed faces, mindless grins only intent on destroying what they've lost. I craw the wall till steepness ends in the vertical fall; my pail has sailed into the sea, no joking hopes at dawn. White bone shine in the iron-jaw mask lost mastheads pierce the freezing dark and parallel my isolated tower no paraffin for the flame no harbour left to gain. V. The Presence of the Night 'Alone, alone, ' the ghosts all call, pinpoint me in the light. The only life I feel at all is the presence of the night. Would you cry if I died? Would you cry if I died? Would you catch the final words of mine? Would you catch my words? I know that there's no time I know that there's no rhyme... (false signs find me) I don't want to hate, I just want to grow; why can't I let me live and be free? but I die very slowly alone. I know no more ways, I am so afraid, myself won't let me just be myself and so I am completely alone. VI. Kosmos Tours The maelstrom of my memory is a vampire and it feeds on me now, staggering madly, over the brink I fall. VII. (Custard's) Last Stand Lighthouses might house the key but can I reach the door? I want to walk on the sea so that I may better find ashore... but how can I ever keep my feet dry? I scan the horizon I must keep my eyes on all parts of me. Looking back on the years it seems that I have lost the way Like a dog in the night, I have run to a manger now I am the stranger I stay in. All of the grief I have seen leaves me chasing solitary peace but I hold experience in my head I'm too close to the light I don't think I see right, for I blind me. VIII. The Clot Thickens WHERE is the God that guides my hand? HOW can the hands of others reach me? WHEN will I find what I grope for? WHO is going to teach me? I am me/me are we/we can't see any way out of here. Crashing sea/atrophied history: Chance has lost my Guinevere. I don't want to be one wave in the water But sea will drag me deep One more haggard DROWNED MAN... I can see the Lemmings coming, but I know I'm just a man; Do I join or do I founder? Which can is the best I may? IX. Land's End (Sineline) Oceans drifting sideways, I am pulled into the spell I feel you around me, I know you well Stars slice horizons where the lines stand much too stark I feel I am drowning, hands stretch in the dark. Camps of panoply and majesty, what is Freedom of Choice? Where do I stand in the pageantry...whose is my voice? It doesn't feel so very bad now, I think the end is the start. Begin to feel very glad now: ALL THINGS ARE A PART ALL THINGS ARE APART ALL THINGS ARE A PART X. We Go Now Oh, oh Oh, oh, oh, oh...
magic. pure magic. simple fact: there are parts in this performance that surpasses everyting that any band on earth delivered in brutality and devastating, controlled, beautifiul and simply unbearable power. that done without a guitar and/or bass player is simply beyond reason
Legend has it that they were completely caught off guard when the TV station requested this song be played, and they had to completely relearn it. As we can see they were able to do so.
It was the only time they played the complete piece, requested out of the blue by the programme makers. Most Bands would've refused, as it was risky, but V.D.G.G. are rather exceptional, as we know!
I sense this TV broadcast was in proximity to Genesis playing at the same venue. Perhaps the Belgium TV station contracted the two Charisma label bands for showcasing their unique talents. VDGG was so original as was Pete Hammill's vocal. When I think of the prog years, Pete had the most unique vocal style of them all.
Much better live than recorded. I finally saw them in Milan two days ago. Nothing to share with the young bands. The magical Peter is 73 years old, Banton too, while Evans is 74. A concert like only VDGG can do, and fifty and more years lafer. Unbelievable! Forever young, forever love 🎶🎹💙💜
I have just seen Peter live in Milan, too..❤ he's not sung Lighthouse, but My Room, many other great songs from his solo albums, and finished with Still Life as an encore... Absolutely heartbreaking 💔🥰 I love him with my whole heart!
I witnessed this band live in all it's glory around that time in Brussels. A once in a lifetime, sublime and unforgettable concert! Thanks for the memory ,Van Der Graaf Generator!
Van Der Graaf Generator - A Plague Of Lighthouse Keepers (1972) Live for Belgian TV, March 21st 1972 Drums, Percussion - Guy Evans Keyboards, Backing Vocals - Hugh Banton Saxophone, Flute, Backing Vocals - David Jackson Voice, Piano, Electric Piano, Acoustic Guitar - Peter Hammill
Jackson and Banton aren't singing any backing vocals, ya fule - they don't even have vocal mics! Peter is singing and playing a Hohner Pianet N - no piano, no acoustic guitar. Guy is playing a drum kit. :)
This is what music is about - This is the base line of everything we are looking for in music - we are not alone, our solitude is shared ... we are one!
"If you were after a girlfriend, by the time you’ve got ten minutes into A Plague Of Lighthouse Keepers she’s usually jumped out the window." Bruce Dickinson on his prog heroes VanderGraafGenerator
I saw 3 quarters of them live in Birmingham 2 days ago and of course they didn`t play it , but I will never forget the experience of seeing one of the greatest groups ever -better late than never. An absolute masterpiece of an album ,hairs on the back of the neck.
it's fascinating to know, they were highly influenced by an alternate state of reality when composing this masterpiece, infact the whole of "pawn hearts". a true "one off" classic.
Sadly very few people listen to prog rock anymore. At 41 I feel like I’m alone talking about this. Luckily my husband is likeminded, and our son is growing up listening to our collection.
I'm a guitar player and total guitar geek or dork or whatever. For me to dig a band that so little of their output contains any guitar shows how badass these guys are. I know they had Robert Fripp on a couple of their things but I bet some Steve Hackett or Howe would sound amazing.
from Wikipedia entry on this piece: Robert Fripp provided a cameo appearance on electric guitar, which can be heard from 8:10-10:20 into the song and near the end of the song. // not shown in this video as David Jackson plays the guitar solo notes on his sax.
Un gruppo che si discosta da tutti i loro contemporanei il non perseguire il commerciale dona una libertà di ricerca unica e impareggiabile volutamente rumorosi caotici connessi nella trama
FANTASTIC...Im so grateful... I wasted 3 minutes before listening to a bass player from some worthless death metal band that was completely forgettable. Found this by accident to save me from being annoyed by a no-talent nobody.
Such an adventurous time for music it was. While bands like King Crimson and Yes were filling arenas, music of such audacity as this was also being made. I'm not sure anyone ever combined piano and organ to such dramatic effect since Benjamin Britten. The periods of glorious chaos in this piece have me laughing hysterically, only to stand in awe at its glorious conclusion.
@@dihh7230 Not at all! Yes and King Crimson were the moon and the stars of my youth. But they managed to succeed in the all too fickle world of the music business. Too often, the truly great are overlooked and forgotten.
@@Katehowe3010 If I'm not mistaken I'd say that this emanated from a conversation with Neil in The Great Frog in London in the mid 1970s, in fact, if I found the right diary I would have written this down.
@@Katehowe3010 è palese sia così continua a guardare altro dei vdgg se non ne sei sicuro qui c'è una quadratura del cerchio impressionante. non lasciarti ingannare dal fatto che non abbiano fatto brani più in linea con i tempi. ovviamente nessuno vuole né può parlare negativamente di neal peart sarebbe un ignorante o un idiota comunque io amo il jazz rock ma non penso sia la sede di parlare di peter erskine con gli steps ahead né di phil collins con i brand x o di chuck burgi....
My 1st time here. Steven Wilson's podcast, The Album Years, 1972, brought me here. I knew, I knew this voice. Peter Hamill collaborated with Jakko Jakzyk on some later stuff, that I was familiar with and have saved on a playlist. As I was listening, with headphones, mind you, I was mesmerized. Always looking for music that is new to me, even if it's 52 years old.
quelle epoque fantastique je suis ne trop tard (1965 ) cette musique me le rappele cruellement j adore ce "rock progressif" j ai ete fan de uk king crimson mais ce groupe inconnu avait l air d etre vraiment en avance.....
Talvez seja o melhor disco deles, muito introspectivo e sinistro, os demais obscuros, um amigo meu tem álbuns solo do Peter Hammill, ele canta muito bem, nas para mim Van Der Graaf é uma banda de rock progressivo underground ou experimental!
Literally one of the best performances I've ever seen in my 40 years of life. Pawn Hearts is life changing and Peter Hammill is one of the greats.
agreed
@@h.p.dominocus definitely yes!!! 🎶❤️
What a criminally underrated band
Amen to that
They were beyond incredible
\m/ ....Yup
They where not underrated why would you underage a band that you chose to see especially double shaxphone through wha wha you’d have to be as mad as a light house keeper’s parrot wearing sun glasses
Найпотужніша група всіх часів і народів!
I check in on this every so often - NEVER fails to floor me.
2 pirates a lynyrd skynyrd reject and a 19th century insane man make one of the greatest songs of all time
I like "a lynyrd skynyrd reject".
I just laughed like a mad man
Hilariously accurate
Nice! Is Jaxon the Lynyrd Skynyrd reject?
@@AlbertoVO5 batton
As a Prog fanatic, this is one of the greatest things I've ever seen in my entire life!
What is the next down the line?
@@barakcohen3612 there is nothing else. this is it
@@barakcohen3612Look for RIO (rock in opposition) bands, like Henry Cow and Univers Zero
Unique and Amazing at the same time ❤
Pure poetry...And the music rises from the poem. And at last , the music gains its own identity. VDG is one of the most powerful and unique musical projects of the century.
This is not progressive rock.
It heart , soul and head of Peter getting together with the
fellow musicians of Van der Graff Generator.!!
@@normangray3438 it's different for many aspects, first of all the stories are not fairy tales, they are introspective, face social problems and so on. It's just because that was the period of the prog rock and the length of Peter's songs is exactly the same as the songs of other bands. Furthermore, they also have a sort of common thread in every album. These are the only connections I see with prog.
Pure Magic! Van der Graaf Generator was the first band I ever saw live, back in 1975. Loved them then and love them now.
Semplicemente fantastici questo video mi ricorda la mia gioventù bei tempi che non si ripeteranno più
Hard to believe that someone in 1972 actually knew how to properly video record a band playing music of this dramatic complexity, without (actually, some, but not too many) silly camera "accents". The cameras actually hit the right instruments at the right time, which leads me to believe that the producer actually knew the music. An incredible proposition.
yeah, makes a real difference, doesn't it! The bane of my life as a kid was watching Top of the Pops and the BBC camera man would always do something dumb like a close-up on the drummer when I wanted to watch the synth solo.
I even am convinced nobody is able to make this anymore. Both music and camera
Brilliant band. One of the best ever.
Bloody good group. Year
2000+ reunion live gigs, astounding! Plus
Hammill solo a must. Buy them all..
It's a masterpiece of contemporary music. No word more to say.
I've loved this band for over 50 years now.... Totally underrated. Amazing fantastic.
Me too
I saw Van der Graaf many times in the mid 70s but they never played Lighthouse. I always assumed this was because it was too complex to play live so it's wonderful to see this video. I actually roadied for them (sort of). I was sitting in the Poly bar at Newcastle when they came in looking for volunteers to bring their gear up from the truck. That would have been late 74 or early 75....
I'm lucky enough to have seen them do it, albeit as a three-piece, on the Grounding in Numbers tour. The opening was genuinely the most spine-tingling thing in my long and extensive gig-going life.
man, when he raises that wine glass at 22 mins.......that's what success looks like
Yes, because they made it through the piece, and it was no.l in Italy, more importantly they'd made a masterpiece. That's success all round in my book, oh, and they never sold out or otherwise compromised. Quality!
They did it there way and we are all better for it. TU VDGG!
Grandissimi... Pawn Hearts è un disco da isola deserta!
the coolest thing ever is at 22:00 when Peter takes a sip of wine, toasts to the camera and walks away to let the band play on.
He didn’t spill a drop either when he got up sharply and was walking around. 🍷 🎼😂
I like the fact that Peter Is clearly already baked a bit (they were notoriously oriented in that fashion) but when he sings and bangs the keys you dont even notice. Great guys, must have been histerical to hang out with at those times.
I love it
*A PLAGUE OF LIGHTHOUSE KEEPERS*
I. Eyewitness
Still waiting for my saviour, storms tear me limb from limb
my fingers feel like seaweed...I'm so far out, I'm too far in
I am a lonely man...my solitude is true
my eyes have borne stark witness
and now my knights are numbered too.
I've seen the smiles on dead hands,
the stars shine, but they're not for me.
I prophesy disaster and then I count the cost....
I shine but, shining, dying, I know that I am almost lost.
On the table lies blank paper and my tower is built on stone
I only have blunt scissors, I only have the bluntest onde
I've been the witness, and the seal of death lingers in the molten wax that is my head.
When you see the skeletons of sailing-ship spars sinking low
You'll begin to wonder if the points of all the ancient myths
are solemnly directed straight at
you.
II. Pictures/Lighthouse
(Eddies/rocks/ships/collision/remorse.)
III. Eyewitness
No time now for contrition, the time for that's long past.
The walls are thin as tissue and if I talk I'll crack the glass.
So I only think on how it might have been, locked in silent monologue, in silent scream
Anyway, I'm much too tired to speak
and, as the waves crash on the bleak
stones of the tower, I start to freak....
...and find that I am overcome...
IV. S.H.M.
'Unreal, unreal!' ghost helmsmen scream and fall in through the sky,
not breaking through my seagull shrieks... no breaks until I die
the spectres scratch on window-slits hollowed faces, mindless grins
only intent on destroying what they've lost.
I craw the wall till steepness ends in the vertical fall;
my pail has sailed into the sea, no joking hopes at dawn.
White bone shine in the iron-jaw mask
lost mastheads pierce the freezing dark
and parallel my isolated tower
no paraffin for the flame
no harbour left to gain.
V. The Presence of the Night
'Alone, alone, ' the ghosts all call,
pinpoint me in the light.
The only life I feel at all is the presence of the night.
Would you cry if I died?
Would you cry if I died?
Would you catch the final words of mine?
Would you catch my words?
I know that there's no time
I know that there's no rhyme...
(false signs find me)
I don't want to hate, I just want to grow;
why can't I let me live and be free?
but I die very slowly alone.
I know no more ways, I am so afraid,
myself won't let me just be myself and so I am completely alone.
VI. Kosmos Tours
The maelstrom of my memory
is a vampire and it feeds on me
now, staggering madly, over the brink I
fall.
VII. (Custard's) Last Stand
Lighthouses might house the key
but can I reach the door?
I want to walk on the sea
so that I may better find ashore...
but how can I ever keep my feet dry?
I scan the horizon
I must keep my eyes on all parts of me.
Looking back on the years
it seems that I have lost the way
Like a dog in the night, I have run to a manger
now I am the stranger I stay in.
All of the grief I have seen
leaves me chasing solitary peace
but I hold experience in my head
I'm too close to the light
I don't think I see right, for I blind me.
VIII. The Clot Thickens
WHERE is the God that guides my hand?
HOW can the hands of others reach me?
WHEN will I find what I grope for?
WHO is going to teach me?
I am me/me are we/we can't see
any way out of here.
Crashing sea/atrophied history:
Chance has lost my Guinevere.
I don't want to be one wave in the water
But sea will drag me deep
One more haggard DROWNED MAN...
I can see the Lemmings coming, but I know I'm just a man;
Do I join or do I founder? Which can is the best I may?
IX. Land's End (Sineline)
Oceans drifting sideways, I am pulled into the spell
I feel you around me, I know you well
Stars slice horizons where the lines stand much too stark
I feel I am drowning, hands stretch in the dark.
Camps of panoply and majesty, what is Freedom of Choice?
Where do I stand in the pageantry...whose is my voice?
It doesn't feel so very bad now, I think the end is the start.
Begin to feel very glad now:
ALL THINGS ARE A PART
ALL THINGS ARE APART
ALL THINGS ARE A PART
X. We Go Now
Oh, oh
Oh, oh, oh, oh...
The more I listen to this band the more I love there music 🟤
Stunning performance
Nice to see you here. Btw i recommend listening to vdgg’s album previous to H to He called the least we can do is wave at each other.
@@123agidee_2 any album is recomended if it is ok listen vdgg
Love it at the 3.30 mark candles to sparklers! But seriously with all the ideas that went into the writing this, it is a compressed opera.
Peter has some amazing poetry published.........bought some in London ages back........
magic. pure magic. simple fact: there are parts in this performance that surpasses everyting that any band on earth delivered in brutality and devastating, controlled, beautifiul and simply unbearable power. that done without a guitar and/or bass player is simply beyond reason
You're right, but Banton plays bass and keyboards etc Auth its magical organ... And they are unique, Peter a genius 💙🎶🎹
Unique and True Genius’
Agree
@@SilviaAMaestri strange that they don't show him in the video
@@andreassorg7294@ 2:49
Absolutely amazing. This suite still makes an electrifying impression after so many years.
And the voice is pretty much still there !.
I know everything is amazing about this performance, but his singing is something magnificent.
One of the greatest songs ever by one of the greatest bands ever.
I was searching the url of deleted videos from my playlist just to find this masterpiece again, ty god i found it
Absolutely love this. I'm amazed that they were able to play it live. bearing in mind all the cross-fades on the studio version.
They split the execution in two parts.That still doesn't take anything away from this stunning performance!
Legend has it that they were completely caught off guard when the TV station requested this song be played, and they had to completely relearn it. As we can see they were able to do so.
It was the only time they played the complete piece, requested out of the blue by the programme makers. Most Bands would've refused, as it was risky, but V.D.G.G. are rather exceptional, as we know!
@@nmk8475 True. The actual lyric insert from Pawn Hearts is on PH's keyboard to remind him of the lyrics.
@@lemming9984 Well it's pretty long
I sense this TV broadcast was in proximity to Genesis playing at the same venue. Perhaps the Belgium TV station contracted the two Charisma label bands for showcasing their unique talents. VDGG was so original as was Pete Hammill's vocal. When I think of the prog years, Pete had the most unique vocal style of them all.
The 70s Genesis and Vdgg Belgium performances were on tv early 80s. Taped them
Pure class. Music so beautifully composed and played. I never tire of this album.
Much better live than recorded. I finally saw them in Milan two days ago. Nothing to share with the young bands. The magical Peter is 73 years old, Banton too, while Evans is 74. A concert like only VDGG can do, and fifty and more years lafer. Unbelievable! Forever young, forever love 🎶🎹💙💜
I have just seen Peter live in Milan, too..❤ he's not sung Lighthouse, but My Room, many other great songs from his solo albums, and finished with Still Life as an encore... Absolutely heartbreaking 💔🥰
I love him with my whole heart!
@xe_chri and not Forsaken Gardens? I love it so much 🎶❤️ even if my favorite song is, and will remain forever, Man-Erg.
the final scene with the glass of wine haha such a genius
I witnessed this band live in all it's glory around that time in Brussels. A once in a lifetime, sublime and unforgettable concert! Thanks for the memory ,Van Der Graaf Generator!
Quite simply BRILLIANT
Van Der Graaf Generator - A Plague Of Lighthouse Keepers (1972) Live for Belgian TV, March 21st 1972 Drums, Percussion - Guy Evans
Keyboards, Backing Vocals - Hugh Banton
Saxophone, Flute, Backing Vocals - David Jackson
Voice, Piano, Electric Piano, Acoustic Guitar - Peter Hammill
Jackson and Banton aren't singing any backing vocals, ya fule - they don't even have vocal mics! Peter is singing and playing a Hohner Pianet N - no piano, no acoustic guitar. Guy is playing a drum kit. :)
@@feline1973buddy, studio version they mean.
One of the most inspiring bands ever! Or one of the top bands ever!
Totally agree!
Amazing Group
A very ambitious piece to perform live!
they were are van del graaf generator
Wow, amazing footage! VDGG one of the best prog-group ever!
The best video on youtube imo
Peter Hammil, Hugh Banton, Jackson with his two saxos, are all pals from my youth and they will be forever
This is what music is about - This is the base line of everything we are looking for in music - we are not alone, our solitude is shared ... we are one!
All the different groups that came out from late 60 and up to mid 70 was a wide music heaven...so many...
Love the bit at rhe end where peter has played his part,takes a sip of wine and strolls around lost un the aura that vdgg produce
How can something so amazing have so little views?
One word: normies.
Because we're in the Kali Yuga...everything turned on its head! Values, ethics...and the masses are lost like the Lemmingz, slaves to the Algorithms.
A video thats now removed had lots of views
Because normies are stupid and are incapable of appreciating great works of art like this
"If you were after a girlfriend, by the time you’ve got ten minutes into A Plague Of Lighthouse Keepers she’s usually jumped out the window."
Bruce Dickinson on his prog heroes VanderGraafGenerator
Best thing ever. I've been watching the dvd version religiously.
a good DVD! I saw them in Naples 1972....
Simply the best
There is prog rock..............and then there's VAN DER GRAAF
Grande hammill,grande band,hanno fatto loro strada senza cercare successo mediatico,solo per la musica
The Hohner Pianet. Not just an excellent electric piano, but aesthetically pleasing as well.
I saw 3 quarters of them live in Birmingham 2 days ago and of course they didn`t play it , but I will never forget the experience of seeing one of the greatest groups ever -better late than never. An absolute masterpiece of an album ,hairs on the back of the neck.
Guy Evans is such an underrated drummer. He is perfect here.
È veramente pazzesco! Conosci la sua performance in "Gog", da "In Camera" di P.H.? ❤
the intro with all the candles is just perfect.
I check in on this every so often - Always delivers.
Wow! Thank you so much for uploading this! Really takes me back...
it's fascinating to know, they were highly influenced by an alternate state of reality when composing this masterpiece, infact the whole of "pawn hearts". a true "one off" classic.
perhaps the best live performance ever recorded
Super GREAT Legends !!! ART thank You!! Share
Yeh.............even a young john lydon liked VDGGG.,........proves their genius........loved by so many & so varied fans............
Mon chanteur et mon groupe préférés !
A masterpiece like this with only 910 views?
I know right? And only one comment. One of the best songs ever written.
Wonderful
In my top 10 all time songs...and such beautiful sympathetic drumming
Sadly very few people listen to prog rock anymore. At 41 I feel like I’m alone talking about this. Luckily my husband is likeminded, and our son is growing up listening to our collection.
@@georgianagligor2350 at least we are three
Uno dei più grandi momenti della musica d'autore da sempre. Incredibile vederlo dal vivo dopo quasi cinquant'anni con delle immagini così vive
c'è il dvd con questo e godbluff e w 65 minuti da sturbo
La vanguardia en su máxima, pero máxima, expresión.
Obra cumbre de esta maravillosa banda.
concuerdo con usted
Uno se da un buen viajaso con esta rola
@@666migueledward En verdad que sí
They were in my home in Milan 1972.
Beyond phenomenal and incredibly musical!
Que banda más cruda y envolvente que escuchado en toda mi vida
so very good, and might I add, such a tasteful production!
Mindblowing, this track really got me into their music along with Theme One. I can't stop playing this track as it is musical perfection.
I'm a guitar player and total guitar geek or dork or whatever. For me to dig a band that so little of their output contains any guitar shows how badass these guys are. I know they had Robert Fripp on a couple of their things but I bet some Steve Hackett or Howe would sound amazing.
long electric guitar solo in "Meyrglus iii The Songwriter's guild" from World Record album. so-called "reggae section"
from Wikipedia entry on this piece: Robert Fripp provided a cameo appearance on electric guitar, which can be heard from 8:10-10:20 into the song and near the end of the song. // not shown in this video as David Jackson plays the guitar solo notes on his sax.
I’m so far out, I’m too far in
Well, they kept me wanting more. Stunning.
Quel souvenir ! L'émission Pop Shop de la RTB, Van Der Graaf Generator m'avait boulversé
Awesome!!! Class and genius...Great VDGG!!!
still love your sounds!!
Wow! What an unexpected treat
Un gruppo che si discosta da tutti i loro contemporanei il non perseguire il commerciale dona una libertà di ricerca unica e impareggiabile volutamente rumorosi caotici connessi nella trama
FANTASTIC...Im so grateful...
I wasted 3 minutes before listening to a bass player from some worthless death metal band that was completely forgettable.
Found this by accident to save me from being annoyed by a no-talent nobody.
The most important discovery I've EVER found. I was forever 'changed'.
Such an adventurous time for music it was. While bands like King Crimson and Yes were filling arenas, music of such audacity as this was also being made. I'm not sure anyone ever combined piano and organ to such dramatic effect since Benjamin Britten. The periods of glorious chaos in this piece have me laughing hysterically, only to stand in awe at its glorious conclusion.
You make it sound like Yes and King Crimson(!) weren't audacious, ha!
@@dihh7230 Not at all! Yes and King Crimson were the moon and the stars of my youth. But they managed to succeed in the all too fickle world of the music business. Too often, the truly great are overlooked and forgotten.
King Crimson never filled arenas in the 70s.
Holy shit did they ever kick ass
21:39 Hugh Banton's Hammond sounds insane here; it must be the "psychedelic razor" effect?
Impresionante!!!que obra maravillosa, gracias!!!
this is. best music ever. best performance too. best.
13:49 the chaos of the music manifests symbolically in the real world
Gloriously dark!
Saw them live, probably 1972, in Watford, and they were great.
So is no one going to point out that glass of red at the end 22 minutes in? A whole mood right there.
Guy Evans is the drummer's drummer. Neil Peart knew this. Peerless stuff. I once saw him on a train to Exeter. Speechless.
Neil Peart knew this? According to which source?
@@Katehowe3010 If I'm not mistaken I'd say that this emanated from a conversation with Neil in The Great Frog in London in the mid 1970s, in fact, if I found the right diary I would have written this down.
@@callycallomon867 Fair play. My favourite is Pierre Moerlin!
@@Katehowe3010 moerlin ? ekkekatz....
@@Katehowe3010 è palese sia così continua a guardare altro dei vdgg se non ne sei sicuro qui c'è una quadratura del cerchio impressionante. non lasciarti ingannare dal fatto che non abbiano fatto brani più in linea con i tempi. ovviamente nessuno vuole né può parlare negativamente di neal peart sarebbe un ignorante o un idiota comunque io amo il jazz rock ma non penso sia la sede di parlare di peter erskine con gli steps ahead né di phil collins con i brand x o di chuck burgi....
Manic prog rock at its best.
My 1st time here. Steven Wilson's podcast, The Album Years, 1972, brought me here.
I knew, I knew this voice. Peter Hamill collaborated with Jakko Jakzyk on some later stuff, that I was familiar with and have saved on a playlist. As I was listening, with headphones, mind you, I was mesmerized.
Always looking for music that is new to me, even if it's 52 years old.
Listen to the two following albuns: Godbluff and The silent Corner and the empty stage
You're going to like it!
quelle epoque fantastique je suis ne trop tard (1965 ) cette musique me le rappele cruellement j adore ce "rock progressif" j ai ete fan de uk king crimson mais ce groupe inconnu avait l air d etre vraiment en avance.....
Best band ever!! Peter Hammil is very close to genius
Magnifique!
Talvez seja o melhor disco deles, muito introspectivo e sinistro, os demais obscuros, um amigo meu tem álbuns solo do Peter Hammill, ele canta muito bem, nas para mim Van Der Graaf é uma banda de rock progressivo underground ou experimental!
Unbelievable, just unbelievable..
Amazing band...........
superb musicianship and sonic sensitivity !!!
VDGG is a must be in evry record collection !!!
tra le prime cinque migliori band di tutti i tempi.