ADJLfanatic52 Well no, they do wear clothes sometimes, after all, Rarity is... Rarity. But yes, my point was indeed that them being naked is utterly meaningless.
tfw i thought this song was just about a platonic sibling relationship and even listened to this with my sister until 3 years later i realized this wasn't as wholesome as i thought
This has become one of my favorite villain songs. I mean, not only is it about Twilight's incest fantasies about Shining Armor, but it's the song that details her motivations for sabotaging the perfectly wholesome wedding.
i like how it also sounds really pretty and innocent, as if Twilight views her actions as a good thing, seeing as how she's so full of herself in this dub and thinks everypony is below her in some way. really neat detail and shows how delusional she is :P
It took me years to realize that the last line "So different now from what it seems. Now life has killed the dream I dreamed." was a reference to Les Miserables.
@@LittlepipActual lots of people are here because they're fan of TH-camr Jenny Nicholson, but didn't know her yet when she sang this. And are now realizing she was already a genius when she was like 13.
I’ve literally never watched mlp before and know nothing about it, this song is really good and I hate that. But also I’m glad it exists. I’m having an existential meltdown
I miss my childhood so much. I’d love to relive the fandom again , as much as it came back to haunt me. It was just a time when everything was so much simpler. I loved the fandom from 7-6 years ago. I miss it so much.
@@majiwarusentosenI wouldn’t say it’s being romanticized, honestly… the other ponies are obviously disturbed by the incest and Twilight’s painted like a creep with the lines like “IT’S NOT CREEPY” but yeah this song goes so hard. the weird parts make it better imo
“I watched him grow into a stallion... I watched him sleep in bed at night. It’s not CREEPY” “I threw myself into my studies, to have the wold in my control... I vaporized the competition. It’s not EVIL!” Still a better loves story than Twilight
This song still remains so underrated. The voiceacting is superb and the fact that they're singing makes it even better. The composition is amazing and the rhymes are on point, I wish more MLP fans knew about this song. I'm excited to see what the future brings but MLP: Friendship is magic will have a special place in my heart forever.
I feel like that's technically less specifically, since the person you reply to named the episode title, which feels more specific than the episode number, even though the episode number makes it easier to find, I think, and they didn't mention the episode number even though they mentioned the title so I suppose you are being more specific in the sense that you're adding specific information that was originally omitted. Hmm
For people who have never watched Friend Ship is Witchcraft, it is a parody of the regular show. Twilight is not a good person in this parody, this is not “pro incest” if you watch the episode it parody’s it makes much more sense 😭
Jeffrey Clark omfg I literally came here because I plan on making one someday; this song popped into my head and I was like: "OH MY GOD. Jaime and Cersei!" xD Strange to think alike! [Will be back when editing software is obtained]
as a kid i never got the the “so different now from what it seemed, now life has killed the dream i dreamed” line. now i’m a lot older and elbow deep in a les miserables hyperfixation. i KNEW i dreamed a dream was familiar
Fun fact, the last two lines are pretty much directly lifted from Les Miserables. They're the last two lines of I Dreamed A Dream, to be more specific. Also, it might just be a coincidence, but the Voulez Vouz line might be a shout-out to the ABBA song of the same name. "Since we're not related it'll be okay..." - I mean, they ARE related in the show, but I guess not in Witchcraft. So, technically yeah, I guess.
i cant believe i’ve never noticed the les mis quote at the end “so different now from what it seemed- now life has killed the dream i dreamed” also this song still slaps hard
I mean... dude, it's supposed to be a little creepy. Though I do agree her 'we're not related so it's okay' sentiment, they have no blood relation so the only problem is how other people who have no business having an opinion on it will see it.
When Sherclop was writing this song, he probably got to that bit of the melody, and wrote the notes that you hear, then realized that it shares the same melody (and key) as the a bit from Katy Perry's 'Last Friday Night'. He might have had another idea for lyrics there, but decided to make a joke about how similar the two songs are, and used that line.
This is beautiful. Truly beautiful. The lyrics must have been so difficult to write for the first time for what kind of deep and intense meaning they had..."skinny dipping in the dark" that was just stunning and my heart STOPPED.
I think this Twilight would have understood and agreed with original Starlight Edit: people keep liking and then unliking my comment, probably because while they agree with this statement they don't like thinking about it, cowards
I jumped back in late 2018 and I'm pleasantly surprised (especially with Equestria Girls.) I can't say I've always stayed fandom informed but I am discovering new and old content that I find hilarious. I think the main thing to remember is that you don't need to be a super fan to be a fan.
"We went streaking in the park, skinny-dipping after dark."
YOU LIVE IN A CLOTHING-OPTIONAL SOCIETY.
I don't get it
Katie Sanchez Ponies don't wear cloths. "Streaking" refers to running naked, and "Skinny-dipping" is swimming naked.
ADJLfanatic52
Well no, they do wear clothes sometimes, after all, Rarity is... Rarity. But yes, my point was indeed that them being naked is utterly meaningless.
It's a reference to "Last Friday Night" by Katy Perry...
***** this is a song about incest,silly
I still think the song is incomplete without Applejack's line at the end "that was the creepiest thing I've ever heard."
Sugarcube*
Y E P
I though the same..
Its not
CREEPY
I'm crying remembering that
WHY IS NOBODY TALKING ABOUT THE FACT THAT ANOTHER VIDEO JUST REPOSTING THIS SONG IS ON TH-cam KIDS AND IS STRICTLY ON TH-cam KIDS I CANT-
I don't want to live in this planet anymore...
They didn’t know the song was about incest!!??
@@linasatele8101 yeah, a lot of songs from fiw are marked "for kids" on TH-cam lmao
Oh okay
Oh my god they thought it was really MLP
If you ignore the creepiness factor... This is actually a really great song. Very pretty.
Lol so true
ikr
SuperMaligan - #IncestIsWincest
IT'S NOT
CREEPY
tfw i thought this song was just about a platonic sibling relationship and even listened to this with my sister until 3 years later i realized this wasn't as wholesome as i thought
Tyler Durden
i like your icon
HEY... they're not related, it'll be okay.
Tyler Durden
. NB .
SAME
This is seriously my favorite MLP song for the next couple of months, THANK YOU!
Holy fuck its TLT from 9 years ago holy shit
@@GameGuy667 woah. And your reply was from 10 days ago.
@@Silent0nyx And yours is just today...?
@@scichoiyun why are we all coming back to this video
@@Silent0nyx and your reply was from 11 days ago
"Twilight please make this song end, we're a bunch of floating heads"
XD gets me every time.
Same
If you’re directly listening to the music and not watching the fiw episode, that line is sure weird
best part honest,y
Still my favourite cartoon pony quasi-incest creepy romance song.
...turns out that's kind of a niche genre.
i think they just misspelled cliche
+gentlecomedy
No, that’s definitely meant to say niche, lol.
It makes more sense that way.
For some reason this song reminds me of my best friend
biggeyHDGames your friend is your step brother/sister and a singer?
Welcome to Alabama
*Edit: I REGRET NOTHING! HAHAHAHAHA!!!*
ITS NOT CREEPY
ITS NOT EVIL
That part sounds like something. I don't know what song it sounds like, but it super sounds like a song I've heard before.
ITS INSEST
Thestealthplatypus ikr
@@madi6222 idk why but this had me cackling
@@thestealthplatypus5861 yea
This has become one of my favorite villain songs. I mean, not only is it about Twilight's incest fantasies about Shining Armor, but it's the song that details her motivations for sabotaging the perfectly wholesome wedding.
You mean Francis Sparkle lol
@@SecretRatDestroyer Yeah, he was called Francis in this series, after his original voice actor.
Villain songs? Tf are you talking about Jesse
i like how it also sounds really pretty and innocent, as if Twilight views her actions as a good thing, seeing as how she's so full of herself in this dub and thinks everypony is below her in some way. really neat detail and shows how delusional she is :P
@@barrysteakfriessimp_real
Yeah but, it's still not creepy as they're not related so, it'll be okay.
To this day, "Since we're not related, it'll be okay..." is my FAVORITE closing gag line in a comedy song.
I THOUGHT I FINALLY ESCAPED BUT ITS 2019 AND HERE I AM
Elizabeth Gresham SAMEEEEEEEE
I'm literally crying I don't know why I'm doing this to myself
Elizabeth Gresham tik tok brought you here didnt it?
Levi Mitchell no,and old playlist I have. But good guess! I did see it on there today
Glad to see I'm not the only one making a return trip, despite me not knowing this existed four days ago.
I... I feel unclean
+courtney brian Just...watch Friendship is Witchcraft. It makes sense
Adam Krug I have watched Friendship is Witchcraft, knowing the story behind this song makes all the more distu
+courtney brian rbing?
ok I
Wolves Base Good
It took me over a decade to realize "We went streaking in the park, skinny dipping after dark" is lifted directly from Last Friday Night
And the last two lines are from the Broadway Les Mis lol
@@asuka365 So good
It took me years to realize that the last line "So different now from what it seems. Now life has killed the dream I dreamed." was a reference to Les Miserables.
That was the creepiest thing I ever heard.
+Andrew Addams It's not ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)
CREEPY ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)
+Leo Cruz WP bro. WP *Claps slowly*
And I'm just *V I B I N G*
@@leocruz1688 I want to give you a like but you're sitting at 69 likes, and I don't want to be the one to mess that up.
Without this line the song seems incomplete 😂
Do you think Jenny ever looks back at her horse fame and just listens to her own songs now and then ? Reminiscing on that slice of life
She doesnt seem to look at the series fondly
Source?
@@pugjuice8462 she mentions it in her BronyCon video
@@jasonperez7250 what did she say?
@@amiraissleeping she thinks it’s cringey and it doesn’t hold up
Wait, this is an original? Jesus Christ, I swear that FiW has put out the best songs ever in the fandom. Their songs are worthy of being huge songs.
Yeaaah, I'm so sad a song about incest goes so hard
2020 and this is still the creepiest thing AJ's ever heard
Can you explain it to me because I don't know English that much and I don't get to xD
@@DeejTiuz Applejack: Es la cosa mas espeluznante que he escuchado
@@unextrano9775 legit me amigo
/that's comin from somepony who have an accent like an alabaman
LMAO
"vocals by jenny" the signs were there all along oh my god
I just found out myself! What a surprise.
Was I the only one who always knew?
@@vinetail5735 no it seemed some people who went to cons knew but when i was a brony i was like. 10 years old. so i didnt go or know
Someone explain please.
@@LittlepipActual lots of people are here because they're fan of TH-camr Jenny Nicholson, but didn't know her yet when she sang this. And are now realizing she was already a genius when she was like 13.
Petition to make this the go-to song people bring up when incest happens instead of the Albama one
Oh, my friends and I already do
@@snickerdoodlez9210 nice
no.
like that coffe comercial ?
SIGNED
"It's not... creepy."
Where have I heard that before? I swear I've heard it somewhere before.
Friendship is Witchcraft?
Cinemare Sins
Probably...
Cinemare sins.
I CAME here from cinemare sins XD
I paused Jenny Nicholson’s Last Bronycon vídeo just to re-listen to this goddamn
It’s 2020
She sabotaged us all again
I’ve literally never watched mlp before and know nothing about it, this song is really good and I hate that. But also I’m glad it exists.
I’m having an existential meltdown
I miss my childhood so much. I’d love to relive the fandom again , as much as it came back to haunt me. It was just a time when everything was so much simpler. I loved the fandom from 7-6 years ago. I miss it so much.
Life passes by so fast. Especially the good parts of it.
This song had no business being this good. Deadass 💀
Me: *vibing to “I gave you my heart and then you turned around”*
Shining: “We went streaking in the park, skinny dipping after dark”
Me: 😳
YEAH I WAS LIKE UH....
its a katy perry ref but that waz hecka creepy
@@brycetankthrust clothing is worn only on special occasions in this society
OKAY BUT IGNORING ALL THE *WEIRD* PARTS OF THIS SONG ITS GENUINELY GOOD?? LIKE MAN THIS SLAPS *H A R D*
Yeah no it’s amazing! And hey they aren’t really..romanticizing it I guess? Actually they could be, I, I’m not good at braining.
@@majiwarusentosenI wouldn’t say it’s being romanticized, honestly… the other ponies are obviously disturbed by the incest and Twilight’s painted like a creep with the lines like “IT’S NOT CREEPY”
but yeah this song goes so hard. the weird parts make it better imo
@@hypertension4023 I didn’t really think it was romanticizing it anyway lol
...
that was the creepiest thing i've ever heard
It's not creepy.
I'm just *V I B I N G*
The best thing to come out of the Brony fandom right here.
No
Ben Hale-grandy No one cares to hear your opinion.
CaptainKronkers the best thing to come out of this fandom is SGAP
***** What is that?
***** Ah, I know who you're talking about. He did a collaboration with Griffin. I remember it being quite good.
“I watched him grow into a stallion... I watched him sleep in bed at night. It’s not CREEPY”
“I threw myself into my studies, to have the wold in my control... I vaporized the competition. It’s not EVIL!”
Still a better loves story than Twilight
Still a better love story than Twilight and Flash
No, it's twilight's friendship love story
@@Sobeitut what about twilight and sunset?
how about twilight with that blue bird from another show
@@SoapySoappp mordetwi is worset
THE FIRST ONE IS MARKED FOR KIDS IM CRYING LMAO-
TH-cam, wtf
wait really-- wow.
😂😂😂
LENDJDBSKSBXKDHHD
FAMILY FRIENDLY CONTENT 😩👌
This song still remains so underrated. The voiceacting is superb and the fact that they're singing makes it even better. The composition is amazing and the rhymes are on point, I wish more MLP fans knew about this song. I'm excited to see what the future brings but MLP: Friendship is magic will have a special place in my heart forever.
Same. It makes me sad there will never be another fandom like the MLP fandom.
It’s concerning enough that I memorized all the words at the age of seven but the fact that I still remember them is just 😭
✨trauma✨
bruh
huh 🗿
did you have a sibling
"ignoring all the weird stuff- 🤓" you're allowed to say you like the song. it's not real. it'll be okay.
OK i see what u did there king
LITERALLY!! This
and people are also allowed to talk about the lyrics hope this helps
"We went streaking in the park, skinny dipping after dark"
but.....your already naked. so basicly you walked through the park and swimming after dark
"Since we're not related it'll be okay" is basically the whole premise to Eromanga Sensei.
brothers conflict...
HSJJSHSJJS
"IT'S NOT
...CREEPY" -Eromanga Sensei Creator
"Since we're not related it'll be okay" 💀been listening to this for years and just FINALLY UNDERSTANDING what she meant😭
Guhh
since twilight is adopted…right…
It's been 3 years. Time flies. Memories.
Soon it will be 5 years.
FiW is never coming back.
Yup!
well it’s been 6 years
Now 6
It’s been 3 years. Since you posted this comment. Memories.
I would kill to hear Tara Strong sing this herself.
Well, Somepony got Lauren Faust to sign THAT Lyra plushie. (You know the one) So its not out of the question
knowing her she probably would
@@TheCakesCup26+ she makes 'suggestive' tweets as Twi so yeeaaaah :P
"Twilight please make this song end, we're a bunch of floating heads" is one of my favorite lines of the whole series.
"It's not evil." Yeah i'm pretty sure the changling queen would say that too...
I watched you sleep in bed at night
Sarah Ford-Piety I watched myself sleep in bed. I once videoed myself to see what I talk about in my sleep. It wasn't pretty
I should totally make people listen to this and tell them it's Actually from the show (these people not being bronies)
did this with the song from cherry bomb (Fiw ep. 7) twas hilarious. :)
Cider Crusader nope, TRICK ALL THE NON-BRONIES!
tWiLiGhT pLeAsE lEt tHiS sOnG eNd wErE a bUnCh oF fLoAtInG hEaDs
Gamzee wrote this comment.
Me: What if Twilight liked her brother?
*Watches Episode*
Me: Perf
What episode is it ?
@@isuyu8803 foaly matripony from friendship is witchcraft
@@lilyannelise more specifically Episode 8 i think
I feel like that's technically less specifically, since the person you reply to named the episode title, which feels more specific than the episode number, even though the episode number makes it easier to find, I think, and they didn't mention the episode number even though they mentioned the title so I suppose you are being more specific in the sense that you're adding specific information that was originally omitted. Hmm
I just thought of this
But they don't usually wear clothes unless it's a formal event...
Skinny-dipping is just normal swimming for them
They take off their fur obvi
They shed their skin and indulge in the Drowning of Flesh.
@@silkuut 💀💀💀
I still go back to listen to this bop and it’s been over a decade
For people who have never watched Friend Ship is Witchcraft, it is a parody of the regular show. Twilight is not a good person in this parody, this is not “pro incest” if you watch the episode it parody’s it makes much more sense 😭
my frigin brother is upstairs slacking off not being famous uuuuuhhh
You should vaporize him... LoL
lol yes i should
now he can love you (It's not creepy)
Watch him while he sleeps.
*****
IT'S *NOT*
*_CREEPY_*
I feel like this is the real family song of House Lannister.
Oh God someone make a GoT version of this.
I'm now imagining Jofferey singing a villain song ala Disney. My fucking sides.
XD
"I always wanted my own brother..."
...Cersei, is that you?!?
Jeffrey Clark omfg I literally came here because I plan on making one someday; this song popped into my head and I was like:
"OH MY GOD. Jaime and Cersei!" xD
Strange to think alike!
[Will be back when editing software is obtained]
Craig Tierney It's already a Villain Song :/
as a kid i never got the the “so different now from what it seemed, now life has killed the dream i dreamed” line.
now i’m a lot older and elbow deep in a les miserables hyperfixation. i KNEW i dreamed a dream was familiar
"I always wanted my own brother"
Off to a rollocking good start with the S-tier writing, double meanings flying
Fun fact, the last two lines are pretty much directly lifted from Les Miserables. They're the last two lines of I Dreamed A Dream, to be more specific.
Also, it might just be a coincidence, but the Voulez Vouz line might be a shout-out to the ABBA song of the same name.
"Since we're not related it'll be okay..." - I mean, they ARE related in the show, but I guess not in Witchcraft. So, technically yeah, I guess.
Perfect song, 100/10 masterpiece. Hello from 2024
this is such a creepy ass song but its such a catchy one too
It's not...
Creepy...
11 years later I still listen to this.
i cant stop listening to this. i wish it was on spotify so i could play it and jam while i drive
You can add it to your own spotify if you download the song and then add your local files to spotify.
i cant believe i’ve never noticed the les mis quote at the end “so different now from what it seemed- now life has killed the dream i dreamed” also this song still slaps hard
WHY DOES THIS HAVE TO BE SUCH A BANGER
Gele ab tapi gue mau pergi dari dulu aja
I find it interesting how the background music is almost playing separately from the vocals, yet they fit together so well.
I'm a pretty tolerant guy but what Twilight singing about is far beyond what I can stomach.
It's way to creepy
Congratz You discovered the point
Twitchy Wings the point of no return? Uh uh get it?
Zero 2o1o - Ahhh ... Well you see, it's quite simple really...
Incest is Wincest!
I mean... dude, it's supposed to be a little creepy. Though I do agree her 'we're not related so it's okay' sentiment, they have no blood relation so the only problem is how other people who have no business having an opinion on it will see it.
I'm still obsessed with the fact that the lines from Last Friday Night by Katy Perry and I Dreamed a Dream from Les Miserables are in this
When your happy you listen to the music
When your sad you understand the lyrics...
#deep
Killer queenn
Not even a brony anymore and I STILL sing the Friendship is Witchcraft songs. Those songs are absolute bops.
"We went streaking in the dark, *skinny dipping after dark*"
What the fuck?!
it's a line from last friday night, by katy perry
Why is that bad and not "streaking in the park"?
When Sherclop was writing this song, he probably got to that bit of the melody, and wrote the notes that you hear, then realized that it shares the same melody (and key) as the a bit from Katy Perry's 'Last Friday Night'. He might have had another idea for lyrics there, but decided to make a joke about how similar the two songs are, and used that line.
DeimOS First time hearing this song I actually thought it was a Last Friday Night parody.
Charlie H Really? They sound nothing alike :\
10 years on... still a (brother) banger
O_O
I NEVER CAUGHT THE I DREAMED A DREAM LINE AT THE END OMG
Jenny is such a good singer 🥺❤️
Real talk, the voice of Twilight's vocals are amazing! Very catchy song!
Still completely obsessed with this song eight years on...
*"That was the creepiest thing I've ever heard."*
Nah, it's not creepy...
I’m so glad I haven’t seen any comments saying that they showed this song for show and tell at their school
It's not creepy
It's not creepy
Every single video of the music video for this is on TH-cam kids and I think that’s more disturbing than this song could ever be.
This is beautiful. Truly beautiful. The lyrics must have been so difficult to write for the first time for what kind of deep and intense meaning they had..."skinny dipping in the dark" that was just stunning and my heart STOPPED.
this goes so hard for no reason
Hssh
Still my favorite song of all time.
Is it still?
@@wasuretayaku4348 ironically enough I was on TikTok last night and someone was using this song. Still love it
with or without context
always gives me chills, 10/10, still not creepy
I FORGOT THAT SHINING ARMOR WAS PART OF A BOYBAND IN THE FiW UNIVERSE
I think this Twilight would have understood and agreed with original Starlight
Edit: people keep liking and then unliking my comment, probably because while they agree with this statement they don't like thinking about it, cowards
I forgot how well-made this is
I´m learning how to play this song on guitar for Christmas. Nothing like romantic music at the family dinner
“That was the creepiest thing I’ve ever heard” 🐴 🍎
This is what I love about the songs in FiW. So catchy but so twisted
The saddest thing about this is that every other video has been caught by coppa
Galaxy Dragons IMAGINE KIDS FINDING THIS OMG- THE PONY INCEST SONG FIEBDHWJDVABBAHS LMAO I CAN’T BELIEVE THIS GOT MARKED FOr KIDS
Luneeski Exactly! Like bro 💀💀💀
Bruh winters fucked up is labelled for kids. And I doubt animated James will come back to fix it.
Still have not gotten tired of this song.
“We went streaking in the park, skinning dipping after dark”
WERE YALL LISTENING TO KATY PERRY ON REPEAT?
i’m legit so sad this isn’t on spotify
It's still really weird knowing that's Jenny Nicholson singing.
this song is always in my head I can't stop singing it it's catchy
2019 and this song keeps making me sad. I miss 2013 and 2014, the years when i loved this show.
I jumped back in late 2018 and I'm pleasantly surprised (especially with Equestria Girls.)
I can't say I've always stayed fandom informed but I am discovering new and old content that I find hilarious. I think the main thing to remember is that you don't need to be a super fan to be a fan.
Twilight's head is bigger then Shining Armor's head and neck.
Itsjustthatonegirl
Well, yeah, heads are usually bigger than necks.
This was my skibidi toilet
You mean goofy ahh childhood?
REAL
This is likely the best song so far to have come out of this series.
All the FiW songs are so dang catchy ;_; I can't stop singing them
10 YEARS WTF
I loved this series. So funny.
That was the creepiest thing I've ever heard.
If some of the more incestuous lyrics weren't there, this would be the cutest song ever written.
😊😊😊
When you catch yourself singing Wild Card or Jenny's lyrics, I imagine you'll end up back here like I did, no matter how many years have passed.
If this song came out in 2024, People would call it problematic and try to cancel the artist
100% banger this shit is so timeless
Nostalgia hits HARD!
FR
10 year (+1 day) anniversary lesgooo
change it to 10 years and 1 month