Biiron Mansaata Sane I am French(only a quarter, but still) and 12, and I can do a better French accent then the lady(whose name I forgot) can in Unity
Patrick Brennan More well known for potato farming but also cabbage farming. My town started out as majority Russian but Irish came over when cabbage farming became huge. I do agree with you about the accent.
"Even the devil can quote scripture" shouldn't have been a sin, you just didn't catch what he was saying. Essentially, your opposition can use your own word, holy words, or words you live by and twist them to make the opposition seem like they are "good" or on your side.
ShadaX Wolf OMG you people are slow when it comes to figurative language. It's obvious he didn't quote scripture it was analogy. The Devil can quote scripture. The Templar can quote the tenants of the Creed. What he meant was that even if the Templar quote the tenants of the Creed that doesn't make them the real good guys. He was comparing it to a situation where if the Devil quoted something in the Bible, not that the Templar actually quoted the Bible. It wasn't literal.
***** are you talking about _my_ game movies? Because I definitely plan to make an Arkahm Knight movie. If it's like any of the others, it shouldn't be too much work.
I know right? Plus he takes speech out of context and leaves things out. Like when he says that the assassin automatically knows how to sail a ship, but right after that Chevalier comments on how Shay has experience as a sailor, and Shay's database entry says he sailed with his father for many years. Then, when he gives a sin for the "you've had enough war, here pilot this warship" thing, he left out the entire conversation beforehand where they discussed how winning the coming battle could shorten the war. That's when Shay says good because he's had enough of war, and Cook offers to let him pilot his more powerful ship to aid in the victory. Finally, during the cutscene where the assassins are discussing their plans he says that since we are looking through Shay's memories we shouldn't be able to see that, when literally two seconds later the camera pans out to reveal Shay spying on them from the rooftop. The only people who are fooled by these "sins" are people who have never actually played the game.
Jackson Larson Absolutely agree, it was a great game. If they decided to take it into PS4 and increase some features on it, make the graphics even better and just work on it for a little more, it would make Ubisoft a ton of money.
FallingTitan thats weird because I can run rogue on my GT 730 DDR3 with Intel G4400 @ 768p, Med at stable 50 fps. (capped it because my processor lacks threads)
FallingTitan yes true, it was quite repetitive but it was nice from my perspective, it killed lots of time and I had fun failing with my friends at stuff, like suddenly realizing that you can't abandon your ship in a legendary battle like you could in Black Flag lol
Wait, "Assassin's Creed Protagonist knows how to sail a ship cliche?" How is that a cliche? It's only been in one other game! I have a feeling that the user contributor doesn't know what cliche means.
I have a feeling that people who contributed are people who hate assassins creed. What tipped me off? When one of the sins was, "Third boat ride already? This is getting boring now." Seriously, there's nitpicking, then there's shitting on a game.
"Damn, his vision is good". I'm sorry, a holographic map just showed up in the middle of the 18th century and you're worried about his eyes, I'm gunna drop a hint or you here Assassin's creed doesn't always go for realism. And he's an assassin with eagle vision, does that really surprise you?
but how the heck did he know the exact church it was in? even if Lisbon is that easy to see, this is map pointing at the city's location, not a sat cam to know the exact location
Robert Davis also subtract number 36 about enemies only attacking you one at a time because there are times where two soldiers strike at you at the same time you can counter it and get a cool miniature cinematic of you destroying them and sometimes you can be attacked and shot at , at the same time
Robert Davis 38 possibly too because the man did get shot twice but guns were not perfected so they did minimal damage until you were at almost point blank range
Nicolas I suppose, but plans for the first puckle gun were drawn and patented in 1718. Even if the word "blueprint" wasn't in use, the criticism is still invalid in my eyes.
The thing about that devil quoting scripture comment is, he doesn't literally mean scripture. What he's saying is that anyone can quote an important text improperly and out of context in order to suit their own purposes.
@@harryborded5294 You know what's worse? It's true. *GamingSins always mentions the exact same sins EVERY SINGLE GODDAMN AC VIDEO.* It's getting boring. Someday, this format is gonna die. Someday.
Best AC game till date. (Story wise and Character implimentation wise). No doubt on that. This is coming from a guy who played all the AC games except AC1 and Origins. Hope Origins will be the best.
Rodney Bonner II The narrator compares the dialogue in this game to boxed wine (carton if you're from the UK and therefore speak English correctly), saying it does the job but it's not great.
How does being from the UK mean you speak English correctly? English makes no sense when written anyways, plus the primary difference is the way you refer to some things, which is the whole point of a language in the first place. Their is no specific "correct" way to speak English.
Here's one you missed. One of the tavern songs is "Leaving of Liverpool" a song about the 1849 gold rush. In a game set during the mid-1700s... Everything you experience in the Animus is supposed to be based on stuff that Shay would have experienced during his life. So either Shay lived to see the California Gold Rush, the musicians are time travelers, or Ubisoft is just full of crap.
***** I have. I just don't let nostalgia blind me. i actually think the first one is the worst. From worst to best for me it's I III Unity Revalations II Brotherhood Rouge Black Flag
I love AC:Rogue. I love its soundtrack, I love its story, I love its environments, I love its characters. It is just a fantastic addition to the AC franchise, and I stand by my view despite the naysayers and bad feedback. Graphics and performance-wise, Unity will always take the throne, but when it comes to solid gameplay, immersive scenery and a gripping story, Rogue crushes Unity into the dust. Such a good game.
Reckless Redcoat Best soundtrack ever. I played it for my dad, a musical snob of the highest order, and he was like 'this was composed for a video game??' He loved it.
Agree, but the problem I had with the game was that the story was too short. The story was half the length of a regular AC game, and after playing the story, I felt like not collecting everything that I didn't collect or explore.
***** Didn't play it, after the reviews and bugs that I've heard of and watching the story of Unity on TH-cam, I didn't want to play it. The story didn't feel like it connected to the rest of the series like the rest of the games did.
See And Hear Is the issue for him - I believe? As we are in the animus Therefore I believe he rather had one of those annoying tailing missions of Shay's fromer brothers. 🙃
Master Wardrop was speaking of the assassin belief, "Nothing is true, everything is permitted". Therefore Shay was comparing him to the devil, because the devil quoted scripture for his own gain. The belief is like scripture. It's an analogy
This seems like a prequel to assassins creed 3 which got a lot of hate for as well ironically Only good thing about the AC3 was there were a handful sea battles in the storyline thank god for that.
GamingSins Wow! u actually have time to reply to people that comment on your shitty videos? What the fuck do you do all day? No offense to the commenters but all offense to you. No Life.
sin number 39, it wasn't saying that he quoted scripture or anything. it's that evil people can make thier deeds seem logical or good with an applicable line
Rewatching a year later, to the assassins the qoute "nothing is true, everything is permitted" is like scripture so he technically did qoute scripture with the part about everything being permitted thus no one would be safe
Okay so sin 39 bothered me. I'm sure that there are other flawed sins but this one stuck out. No, Wardrobe didn't quote scripture. He was however referencing a saying in the world of assassins. "nothing is true. Everything is permitted". Shay was using an analogy. In this analogy Wardrobe is the devil, the saying is scripture, and his plans are for the templars are his purposes.
Forkont Aerialis yeah, this guy's a king twat. I could make a list of every 'sin' and how this ignorant fk was wrong about it... Theres a difference between nitpicking and shitting on a game
"even the devil can quote scripture to suit his own purposes" is a quote from Shaekespeare "The Marchant of Venice" ... god is it so difficult to make some research ? Oh wait... you're american...
Good for you. I had only simple lessons 7 years ago. I m not used to speak it nor write it every day. I just try to do my best to be understood. Peut-être peut on continuer en français, et je serai alors témoin de votre habileté à usiter de mon idiome natal...
Abidal Sh It had the potential to be one of the best games, but I don't think it really lived up to it. The dialogue was pretty...meh...the voice actors weren't great and hunting for items never really felt worthwhile. That said, I still think the concept of the story is great, the maps are awesome (albeit NS is inaccurate) and the gameplay is fun, and I actually like Shay, despite the forced "Mick" things he says.
you're too much clingy to being a bugisoft fanboy you don't realise it's them who destroyed assassin's creed franchise, don't blame the joker, blame the joke!
That's soooooooooooo wrong i thought it was right too but it's wrong when I played the game again Achilles said to Liam in the Temple Shay was right so that means Achilles don't believe shay
That's soooooooooooo wrong i thought it was right too but it's wrong when I played the game again Achilles said to Liam in the Temple Shay was right so that means Achilles don't believe shay
Darkwolf523 "the last good one" Rogue was shit, the story was shit, and the only reason why people say it's good is because of the game play which was copy and pasted from Black Flag.
Are you kidding me? Rouge's story is better than most, Shay is an interesting and involved character, and while it is like Black Flag, only the ships parts are direct copies, and there are a lot less of them than in Black Flag.
LogCa Games Sure Shay may have been a good character but the story made no sense. Why are the Assassins all of a sudden bad, why are their gangs bad? If the Assassins were so bad then why didn't Shay notice it before, did they wait until after Shay left to be oppressive? Why are the Templars all of a sudden freedom fighters? Why didn't Shay actually try to communicate with Achilles instead of just shouting "you made me slaughter innocents" over and over again? I can guarantee that if Shay had just calmed down and explained what happened the next day that the Assassins would have stopped their search for the precursor temples and would have protected the box and manuscript. Ubisoft tried too hard to make the Assassins the bad guys, and if they were to switch which side did what then it would make more sense. It's like each side switched motives and nobody realizes that flaw.
The Templars are not freedom fighters here, they are trying to create order and restrict freedom. While I do agree with the whole role-swapping bit being a bad idea, the changes could be perspective. Yes, Ubisoft tried too hard, but I, personally, think the plot is more interesting than it is consistent and because it changes it things up from the former Assassin's Creed games, and that might just be enough to be good or at least ok. Also, I do think that the story would have played out differently if Shay did calm down, but I think everyone would be unable to calm down when they just watched hundreds die by their actions.
What makes rogue so good is it sets up the playing pieces to both AC3 AC unity and is the sequel to black flag, whilst realizing the assassin's creed and templars creed have been flawed with every varation
+GamingSins i was thinking about sin number 5, why he looked could of been that he saw the birds taking off, then heard the gun. Just a thought, not a very solid one though
Terius Smith They would be more of an Ethnic group than race. Other wise your logic implies that the Brits, Saxons, Norse, Celts, Goths, Slaves, Balts, Franks, Danes, etc are all their own separate races while all living in modern day Europe and, while being in such close proximity to each other, never interbreeding. There is really only 3 "races": Caucasoid (Aryan, Hamites, Semites, etc) Mongoloid (northern Mongolian, Chinese and Indo-Chinese, Japanese etc) and Negroid (African, Hottentots, Melanesians etc).
He actually quoted form Shakespeare's play 'The Merchant of Venice' at 8:12, it's said to Shylock the 'villain' it could just be a coincidence, but to get the exact wording...?
in an earlier video he said that "expositional dialogue is like boxed wine. It doesn't taste good but it does the job" Meaning that exposition is low quality trash that you should avoid if possible, but it still gets the plot propelled. just like boxed wine tastes worse than bottled wine, but it still gets you drunk
+Muhammed Burak Yavuz boxed wine is a way of saying "something that is shit,but it works!" For instance,the joke itself.It's shit but it gets gamingsins's job done
I'm glad someone decided to a gaming sins channel as I've been a fan of Cinema Sins for a while, it's nice to see that you don't let the haters get you down and the fact that you include fan submitted sins is awesome.
A little constructive criticism at 8:08 - Shay wasn't literally saying Wardrop was quoting scripture. "The devil can cite scripture for his purpose" is a quote from The Merchant of Venice. Wardrop pulled the "everything is permitted" line from the Assassin mantra, so it fits in the context here.
also, since the bullets back then were round balls, instead of what we have today, and didn't have internal propulsion from the gunpowder being in the case, they wouldn't have gone as deep and done as much damage, falling onto his back was litterally the worst of his injuries and the cold water would have helped that too
You missed out another bonus sin when Shay said 'I make my own luck' in the mission Caress Of Steel. He said it to Haytham shortly after the opening cutscene.
How dare you hate on my Shay darling!Rogue is deffinatly not a bad game at all! I love it to death, and it has an amazing story line! I can't get enough of Rogue!! I literally played and finished that game in 3 weeks!It's actually the first AC game I ever played, and what got me addicted to the AC series. Between the playing the game and finishing it, I did alot of research, and I fell in love with it all! Now..., I have AC2, ACB, ACRev, ACBlackflag, and AC3 to add to my ACRogue. ❤❤
+Sarah Henderson 1. calm the f*ck down. 2. the story was ok. 3. you've finished the game in 3 weeks well that took you a while if you like the game so much. 4. this channel is here to find mistakes in games so if you can't take a joke and can't accept that rogue also had mistakes then you are wrong here. btw I like the game to but can also laugh about the jokes that he made in this video.
It's called I had school, so I can't finish it. Also, I know it has flaws. Every AC game has its flaws. And I was really just joking on the "How dare you all" part. I don't really care if you hate on him or not. I was kidding OK? Geeze.. I know.., everyone has their different opinions. And I'm sorry if I offended you some how, it wasn't intended. And I'm sorry, that I can't be excited or happy about explaining my love for AC.. >.>
+Sarah Henderson I'm sorry if I offended you but I thought you were one of those annoying fangirls >_< so I'm sorry that I didn't got the joke xc have a good day
I will say this - I immediately hate that woman who greets us once we are taken out of the animus and the virus trope is introduced. This b tch starts talking to us players like we are slow and acting like an assh*le. She is stupid, surly for no reason, unlikable, b*tchy, and cliched. She calls us "numbskulls" and just has to have coffee. Whoever wrote her part - probably female - should be fired. Fire that awful writer!
piplup2009 Not neccisarily. I mean, there was Torres, for example. That said...she was just annoying. I think her sole purpose was to be annoying. I particularly hate her because of your second modern day part where she just whines at you until you get to the elevator/ office...even if you're poking around the PCs.
at 8 minutes 8 seconds in. "even the devil can quote scripture to suit his own purpouses" "he didnt quote scripture" shay wasnt saying that the dude he was killing quoted scripture, the dude quoted the creed, so what shay said was like a metaphor "devil can quote scripture to suit his own needs" is another way to say a templar can quote the creed to suit his own needs
There's nothing wrong with boxed wine, and though this game isn't perfect, it's bloody good, gameplay wise. And btw, the cabbage farmer thingy - it's an insult, like being called a petty peasant, the ones lowest on social rankings in the old days.
You forgot to mention that they sent Shay on that mission to find what they thought would be an Apple without telling him what an Apple would look like. Also, where did Shay get the idea that the Assassins knew what would happen in Lisbon?
+jp mesquita The entire game is a sin. It's just a DLC for AC4. Hell even the HUD is an exact replica, apart from a colour change lol. There are almost no new assets here. Just a cash-grab for past gen consoles.
+Arno Dorian (Thunder Junior) "there are almost no new assets here." i disagree, the ship has new upgrades ( seriously a ram that break ice sheets is cool) there are new swords and armor the landscape is different YOU CAN HUNT NARWHALS you don't have to play as a assassin anymore therefore you can literally slaughter a civilian and not get crucified by the animus for it and lots more, so this 'cash grab' has quite a lot in it if you think about it
marky mark None of this warrants a new game. DLC's introduce new stuff, and this game is no different. Apart from the large map, this has DLC written all over it. - A ram that breaks ice is not revolutionary. - Some new swords is not enough to warrant a game. - The landscapes are pretty similar actually. - Hunting a different type of animal is not miraculous. The sole purpose of Rogue was to get money from the audience that hadn't moved to next-gen yet.
Cian Byrne Because Shay's VA was inexperienced, and therefore cheap. This game wasn't a focus for Ubisoft - they didn't put a high budget on this game, because they know most are not going to play it.
+GamingSins At 7:46 He was actually comparing the "Devil quoting scripture" to how the Templar was quoting the creed in order to try and persuade Shay to stop.
ANarcher I am Irish and I found it cheesy as hell, it became tedious and stale almost as soon as he said it, however it is not exactly racist(we are Caucasians by and large, Irish is simply a nationality)...the accent on the other hand, now; that was downright shameful. The biggest insult about this game was the fact they charged full retail for what is essentially Black Flag and AC3 squashed together(maps and what not, albeit a new storyline), it was boring and lazy.
Sin #11: He was not calling them sea dogs literally, but just referencing them as sea dogs because they were English naval soldiers
He also calls Shay a cabbage farmer because Shay is as useful as a cabbage farmer, if not less
+Dustin Gyrich "cabbage farmer" is a racial insult to Irish people, I think
+Romi Arkan yes it is
+Romi Arkan it's not racism, it's a stereotype
no need in saying anything these Sins videos are so ignorant
Rogue has better French accents than unity...
Unity didn't even have ANY French accents lol.
O yeah I forgot
Assassins creed syndicate is probably going to have French accents because everyone in unity has english accents.
Biiron Mansaata Sane I am French(only a quarter, but still) and 12, and I can do a better French accent then the lady(whose name I forgot) can in Unity
Ninja Lemur Lol your nationality has nothing to do with your ability to do accents
when Shay is called a cabbage farmer it's to do with him Being Irish
shouldn't it be potatos
well Ireland is known for both
i see
That's so true
Gangster 9011 South America is not USA.
The French guy calls Shay "cabbage farmer" because stereotypically the Irish are cabbage farmers.
The Irish are stereotypically potato farmers, not cabbage farmers, also, worst Irish accent ever
Patrick Brennan More well known for potato farming but also cabbage farming. My town started out as majority Russian but Irish came over when cabbage farming became huge. I do agree with you about the accent.
Jacob Densmore fair enough cabbage farming isn't huge in any parts of Ireland that I know but I'm probably just not paying attention
True potato farmer is used as well
Cabbage is less used as it's not widely farmed but is used in many traditional Irish meals
"Even the devil can quote scripture" shouldn't have been a sin, you just didn't catch what he was saying. Essentially, your opposition can use your own word, holy words, or words you live by and twist them to make the opposition seem like they are "good" or on your side.
It's a sin because the guy Shay was talking to didn't quote a scripture
ShadaX Wolf OMG you people are slow when it comes to figurative language. It's obvious he didn't quote scripture it was analogy. The Devil can quote scripture. The Templar can quote the tenants of the Creed.
What he meant was that even if the Templar quote the tenants of the Creed that doesn't make them the real good guys. He was comparing it to a situation where if the Devil quoted something in the Bible, not that the Templar actually quoted the Bible. It wasn't literal.
Zexion98 I realized that like five minutes after I said it, but I forgot to reply lel
+Zexion98 Perfect explanation
Well it"s a line from Shakespear"s Merchant Of Venice, the drama
A lot of these "sins" seem to come from the fact that the guy playing this appears to have little to no previous experience with the series.
***** are you talking about _my_ game movies? Because I definitely plan to make an Arkahm Knight movie. If it's like any of the others, it shouldn't be too much work.
***** Well the Assassin's Creed games are usually 20-30 hour campaign, and I do those all the time lol
I think he is being a little to picky with some of these.
Andy Gilleand Or even this game, judging by a number of these sins...
I know right? Plus he takes speech out of context and leaves things out. Like when he says that the assassin automatically knows how to sail a ship, but right after that Chevalier comments on how Shay has experience as a sailor, and Shay's database entry says he sailed with his father for many years. Then, when he gives a sin for the "you've had enough war, here pilot this warship" thing, he left out the entire conversation beforehand where they discussed how winning the coming battle could shorten the war. That's when Shay says good because he's had enough of war, and Cook offers to let him pilot his more powerful ship to aid in the victory. Finally, during the cutscene where the assassins are discussing their plans he says that since we are looking through Shay's memories we shouldn't be able to see that, when literally two seconds later the camera pans out to reveal Shay spying on them from the rooftop. The only people who are fooled by these "sins" are people who have never actually played the game.
7:39 you murdered an innocent citizen instead of the messenger,add one sin
OrinXone he did...and that's why he joined templars cause he didn't know that peice of eden would cause all that destruction
"How many times do I have to say Liam, I make my own luck."
I literally burst out laughing!
Shay's templar outfit is sick. The black coat with red accents and a pony tail...
It's sad how overlooked this game is. The should have released this last year and then waited until this year to release Unity.
Jackson Larson Absolutely agree, it was a great game. If they decided to take it into PS4 and increase some features on it, make the graphics even better and just work on it for a little more, it would make Ubisoft a ton of money.
***** Unity was glitchy as hell apparently, so much so that it made the game not playable.
FallingTitan thats weird because I can run rogue on my GT 730 DDR3 with Intel G4400 @ 768p, Med at stable 50 fps. (capped it because my processor lacks threads)
FallingTitan WTF literally I only have an I-5 6198 DU @2.4Ghz and a gtx 930 MX and 4gb of ram and I can run it at 60+FPS on highest settings
FallingTitan yes true, it was quite repetitive but it was nice from my perspective, it killed lots of time and I had fun failing with my friends at stuff, like suddenly realizing that you can't abandon your ship in a legendary battle like you could in Black Flag lol
Wait, "Assassin's Creed Protagonist knows how to sail a ship cliche?" How is that a cliche? It's only been in one other game!
I have a feeling that the user contributor doesn't know what cliche means.
I have a feeling that people who contributed are people who hate assassins creed.
What tipped me off?
When one of the sins was, "Third boat ride already? This is getting boring now."
Seriously, there's nitpicking, then there's shitting on a game.
Cola Boy You must be new here
Alejandro Shadows Yeah, actually. Subscribed a few weeks ago.
Cola Boy I recomend watching CinemaSins EWW CinemaSins. It explains everything.
CasaDeBANG Yeah,I did. It does explain a lot.
"Damn, his vision is good". I'm sorry, a holographic map just showed up in the middle of the 18th century and you're worried about his eyes, I'm gunna drop a hint or you here Assassin's creed doesn't always go for realism. And he's an assassin with eagle vision, does that really surprise you?
Well said
The holographic map is reasonable. First civilization shit
Eagle vision is real but only talented people could do it
but how the heck did he know the exact church it was in? even if Lisbon is that easy to see, this is map pointing at the city's location, not a sat cam to know the exact location
Fliyo MB true
Subtract 1 sin. Cabbage Farmer is an Irish Racial slur. (And old one sure. but still one.)
Robert Davis technically, that sin would stay because he was Shay's superior and a complete asshole
Robert Davis That may be true but he actually says that to Shay because he was previously a cabbage farmer before joining the Assassins.
Hitly German So, in this specific case it was a racial slur.. and accurate. :)
Robert Davis also subtract number 36 about enemies only attacking you one at a time because there are times where two soldiers strike at you at the same time you can counter it and get a cool miniature cinematic of you destroying them and sometimes you can be attacked and shot at , at the same time
Robert Davis 38 possibly too because the man did get shot twice but guns were not perfected so they did minimal damage until you were at almost point blank range
6:55, the puckle gun was invented in 1718, 40 years before the start of this game. Cretons.
SteveCast It's about blue-prints in general I think.
Nicolas I suppose, but plans for the first puckle gun were drawn and patented in 1718. Even if the word "blueprint" wasn't in use, the criticism is still invalid in my eyes.
The thing about that devil quoting scripture comment is, he doesn't literally mean scripture. What he's saying is that anyone can quote an important text improperly and out of context in order to suit their own purposes.
Dude half of these sins aren't even valid or just plain stupid
Rogue fanboy triggered
Holt Hazel Don’t even know there’s a Rogue fanboy word. Rogue has one of the greatest story in the AC franchise.
Because its comedy
@@harryborded5294
You know what's worse? It's true.
*GamingSins always mentions the exact same sins EVERY SINGLE GODDAMN AC VIDEO.*
It's getting boring. Someday, this format is gonna die. Someday.
I know right
8:47 "Damn, his vision's good!"
LOL, he's got Eagle Vision, you know...
I make my own Luck GamingSins.
Ewww
Z E K T O R (kanál neaktívny) ???
Leonardo Cignini right on ma balls...
Hey Shay !! Why are you not wearing hood in game ?
Z E K T O R (kanál neaktívny) why should I wear one?
"he educates shay by sucker punching him in the face" lmao I lost it
assassins creed rogue is good game
He likes the game,actually it was his videogame clips in this video....he just also likes to sarcastic...other than that he enjoys his gameplay
the best game
Best AC game till date. (Story wise and Character implimentation wise). No doubt on that. This is coming from a guy who played all the AC games except AC1 and Origins. Hope Origins will be the best.
Mihael Spajić my second best Ac game after Ac2
Mihael Spajić it's short though
Loved the box wine, it tasted adequate.
I'm about to sound very stupid but can you PLEASE explain that phrase to me I don't get it.
Rodney Bonner II The narrator compares the dialogue in this game to boxed wine (carton if you're from the UK and therefore speak English correctly), saying it does the job but it's not great.
How does being from the UK mean you speak English correctly? English makes no sense when written anyways, plus the primary difference is the way you refer to some things, which is the whole point of a language in the first place. Their is no specific "correct" way to speak English.
It was a joke
Actually Noblesse most o common English today was made by shakespere.............. who was English........ never mind
the sins he put on this some of them were very pointless. anyway this is my favorite Assassins Creed so far. Infinitely better than Unity
Connor and Haytham AC3
Besides let's be honest Shay could literally flatten half of the people we play as in the AC games
I would say yes and no the story and characters yes but graphics Gameplay open world combat Stealth etc not but the story from Unity is underrated
@@keithhaberler4529 im from Germany and I don't understand what you exactly mean what means flatten
@@Sneaky_racoon_sly what I mean by flatten is he would probably be able to kill most of the assassin's we play as that's what I meant
You missed a sin: soon after Achilles told Liam not to touch the First Civ artifact in the cave, he pushed Liam right into said artifact.
F in the chat for the civillian at 7:38 though
Here's one you missed. One of the tavern songs is "Leaving of Liverpool" a song about the 1849 gold rush. In a game set during the mid-1700s... Everything you experience in the Animus is supposed to be based on stuff that Shay would have experienced during his life. So either Shay lived to see the California Gold Rush, the musicians are time travelers, or Ubisoft is just full of crap.
this is still my second favourite AC game.
What's your favorite?
Noob Saibot AC IV: Black Flag
The Banterlope same Black flags my favorite too
Vincent Kelly Me too
***** I have. I just don't let nostalgia blind me. i actually think the first one is the worst. From worst to best for me it's
I
III
Unity
Revalations
II
Brotherhood
Rouge
Black Flag
I love AC:Rogue. I love its soundtrack, I love its story, I love its environments, I love its characters. It is just a fantastic addition to the AC franchise, and I stand by my view despite the naysayers and bad feedback. Graphics and performance-wise, Unity will always take the throne, but when it comes to solid gameplay, immersive scenery and a gripping story, Rogue crushes Unity into the dust. Such a good game.
Reckless Redcoat Best soundtrack ever. I played it for my dad, a musical snob of the highest order, and he was like 'this was composed for a video game??' He loved it.
Reckless Redcoat Completely agree. I also love that you meet all those characters from III and Black Flag.
And how perfectly the end ties in to Unity.
Agree, but the problem I had with the game was that the story was too short. The story was half the length of a regular AC game, and after playing the story, I felt like not collecting everything that I didn't collect or explore.
***** It was pretty good. It filled in the gaps of the years between playing Haytham to playing Connor in AC 3.
***** Didn't play it, after the reviews and bugs that I've heard of and watching the story of Unity on TH-cam, I didn't want to play it. The story didn't feel like it connected to the rest of the series like the rest of the games did.
Light travels faster so Shay sees the gunshot first then hears the sound
"he has good vision"
Well... yes... Eagle vision.
13:56 literally 2 second later you see Shay spying them...
See
And
Hear
Is the issue for him - I believe?
As we are in the animus
Therefore I believe he rather had one of those annoying tailing missions of Shay's fromer brothers. 🙃
Master Wardrop was speaking of the assassin belief, "Nothing is true, everything is permitted". Therefore Shay was comparing him to the devil, because the devil quoted scripture for his own gain. The belief is like scripture. It's an analogy
English Sea Dogs and Cabbage Farmers are derogatory racial slangs. Could do with some research.
"Lucky The Pizza Guy Got Here On Time Isn't It Shay? 'I Make My Own Luck'" I Was Dying At How Perfect That Impression Was XD 😂😂😂
BONUS ROUND! A sin for every time he says "boxed wine"
0:28 ''And if I were any more Irish than my name and accent I would've exploded''
Will you be doing all the assassins creed games? Please do it's my favourite game series! :)
We shall see...
This seems like a prequel to assassins creed 3 which got a lot of hate for as well ironically
Only good thing about the AC3 was there were a handful sea battles in the storyline thank god for that.
awesomergamer27 Yeah, but that lead Ubisoft to realize that people liked sea battles and gave us Black Flag, which was AWESOME.
yes, of course. i want to see everything wrong with it and if i still like it, there is either something wrong with me or its a generally good game.
GamingSins Wow! u actually have time to reply to people that comment on your shitty videos? What the fuck do you do all day? No offense to the commenters but all offense to you. No Life.
sin number 39, it wasn't saying that he quoted scripture or anything. it's that evil people can make thier deeds seem logical or good with an applicable line
6:56
The clip he's playing shows another guard attacking him at the same time he's fighting another, which immediately devalues that "sin."
Chevalier calls Shay cabbage farmer cause Shay's Irish.
Racist sin addition?
ibravosp5 There's at least one racist line in every game, but usually it's either called out, or the whole point is for it to be offensive, so meh.
ibravosp5 I find it rather more stereotypical than racist
He calls him "cabbage farmer" because Shay is Irish Chevalier was being racist. Shay says "I make My Own Luck" too many god damn times
6:55 Actually, there are several times where I get 3 or 4 attacking me all at once. makes for some awesome cinematic battles
Rewatching a year later, to the assassins the qoute "nothing is true, everything is permitted" is like scripture so he technically did qoute scripture with the part about everything being permitted thus no one would be safe
Housekeepers to single men, especially Ben Franklin (who is renowned for his philandering), why not both housekeeper & madam.
I heard that Ben Franklin was a fucking good tail catcher. Banged women more than anyone.
Marco Aurélio Dantas yep so I can imaging him trying to pull Ms.Jensen
Steve Jones Gaming I like rouge story more than the newer assasin creed games plus black flag. Black flag story was meh but I like the characters
“ *AAAAAHHHH* The *cAbbAGe fArMEr* has returned” idk why but that shit kills me every time lmao
Okay so sin 39 bothered me. I'm sure that there are other flawed sins but this one stuck out.
No, Wardrobe didn't quote scripture. He was however referencing a saying in the world of assassins. "nothing is true. Everything is permitted".
Shay was using an analogy. In this analogy Wardrobe is the devil, the saying is scripture, and his plans are for the templars are his purposes.
Was that a French accented character? Now explain Assassins Creed Unity to us Ubisoft.
I sin your spelling of Ben Franklin
8:35
8:15, by scripture he was referring to the Assassins mantra
Forkont Aerialis at least someone knew... phew...
Forkont Aerialis The "nothing is true, everything is permitted" thing?
Cole Thomas yep, im really surprised that there werent as many people raging about it in the comments, but you got it!
Cole Thomas Yes
Forkont Aerialis yeah, this guy's a king twat. I could make a list of every 'sin' and how this ignorant fk was wrong about it... Theres a difference between nitpicking and shitting on a game
7:10 the captains voice is like adewales voice
The first sin was FUCKING HILARIOUS
"even the devil can quote scripture to suit his own purposes" is a quote from Shaekespeare "The Marchant of Venice" ... god is it so difficult to make some research ? Oh wait... you're american...
English is not my native language, I'm from Belgium...
+Greg bres That is irrelevant, I am from the Netherlands and my English is perfectly fine.
Good for you. I had only simple lessons 7 years ago. I m not used to speak it nor write it every day. I just try to do my best to be understood. Peut-être peut on continuer en français, et je serai alors témoin de votre habileté à usiter de mon idiome natal...
There's the difference, I speak English every day.
+Nadeem Lobner And that doesn't imply everyone doing so.I suggest you stop calling people idiots just because you fancy some internet fight
Wow. That boxed wine joke god borring faster then the plot of CoD...
Boxed Wine joke = youtuber sin counter +1 :)
Okay I know I love AC: Rogue but this was really funny xD
Also... I lost it at the Django quip xD
me too
14:06 shay did hear the whole conversation he was in the roof the whole time.
#justsaying
"Lucky the pizza guy got here early" Shay: "I make my own luck" XD
it' not bad tho, not bad at all , it was an awesome game
yea maybe , if talking about the story, the best AC story ever
im not sure, i think it is Revelations , or brotherhood , Those were the best AC games , but i love all the franchise, all of them are awesome
***** me too
Abidal Sh It had the potential to be one of the best games, but I don't think it really lived up to it. The dialogue was pretty...meh...the voice actors weren't great and hunting for items never really felt worthwhile. That said, I still think the concept of the story is great, the maps are awesome (albeit NS is inaccurate) and the gameplay is fun, and I actually like Shay, despite the forced "Mick" things he says.
Abidal Sh man, but someone said that is shitty game? No, just there is some bullshit in it ;)
Mark 1 sin off at 13:44-13:52 because if you even tried to play the f*cking game you would know that Shay is eavesdropping.
Everything wrong with this channel
Check out our EWW Deadpool video, and you might be satisfied.
GamingSins oh yea I remember tha
there many things wrong with this channel
you're too much clingy to being a bugisoft fanboy you don't realise it's them who destroyed assassin's creed franchise, don't blame the joker, blame the joke!
Shay: defects from assassin's after being forced to 'slaughter innocents'
Also Shay: does not desync after killing random people on the street.
That's soooooooooooo wrong i thought it was right too but it's wrong when I played the game again Achilles said to Liam in the Temple Shay was right so that means Achilles don't believe shay
That's soooooooooooo wrong i thought it was right too but it's wrong when I played the game again Achilles said to Liam in the Temple Shay was right so that means Achilles don't believe shay
@13:10 - Oh HELL NAW you didn't go there! 😂😂
Rip assassin's creed series. Rogue was the last good one
Darkwolf523 "the last good one" Rogue was shit, the story was shit, and the only reason why people say it's good is because of the game play which was copy and pasted from Black Flag.
Are you kidding me? Rouge's story is better than most, Shay is an interesting and involved character, and while it is like Black Flag, only the ships parts are direct copies, and there are a lot less of them than in Black Flag.
LogCa Games Sure Shay may have been a good character but the story made no sense. Why are the Assassins all of a sudden bad, why are their gangs bad? If the Assassins were so bad then why didn't Shay notice it before, did they wait until after Shay left to be oppressive? Why are the Templars all of a sudden freedom fighters? Why didn't Shay actually try to communicate with Achilles instead of just shouting "you made me slaughter innocents" over and over again? I can guarantee that if Shay had just calmed down and explained what happened the next day that the Assassins would have stopped their search for the precursor temples and would have protected the box and manuscript. Ubisoft tried too hard to make the Assassins the bad guys, and if they were to switch which side did what then it would make more sense. It's like each side switched motives and nobody realizes that flaw.
The Templars are not freedom fighters here, they are trying to create order and restrict freedom. While I do agree with the whole role-swapping bit being a bad idea, the changes could be perspective. Yes, Ubisoft tried too hard, but I, personally, think the plot is more interesting than it is consistent and because it changes it things up from the former Assassin's Creed games, and that might just be enough to be good or at least ok. Also, I do think that the story would have played out differently if Shay did calm down, but I think everyone would be unable to calm down when they just watched hundreds die by their actions.
What makes rogue so good is it sets up the playing pieces to both AC3 AC unity and is the sequel to black flag, whilst realizing the assassin's creed and templars creed have been flawed with every varation
Yes, ill take a bottle of wine :)
+_Ezio Auditore How about a box?
+GamingSins 😂 Classic
+GamingSins i was thinking about sin number 5, why he looked could of been that he saw the birds taking off, then heard the gun. Just a thought, not a very solid one though
Since light travels faster than sound, maybe he saw the gunshot before the sound reached them
Ezio Auditore Da Firenze But u get to taste only the box. :)
Oh. I get it. He makes his own luck because he's Irish. Racist developers are racist.
Nightingale007 Irish isn't a race.
Nice way to try to start a fight, lad. I'm too stubborn for that.
Nightingale007 You assume because I corrected you that I was trying to start a fight?
Murphdawg1 gaming Irish people are celtic, yes they are a race
Terius Smith They would be more of an Ethnic group than race. Other wise your logic implies that the Brits, Saxons, Norse, Celts, Goths, Slaves, Balts, Franks, Danes, etc are all their own separate races while all living in modern day Europe and, while being in such close proximity to each other, never interbreeding. There is really only 3 "races": Caucasoid (Aryan, Hamites, Semites, etc) Mongoloid (northern Mongolian, Chinese and Indo-Chinese, Japanese etc) and Negroid (African, Hottentots, Melanesians etc).
He actually quoted form Shakespeare's play 'The Merchant of Venice' at 8:12, it's said to Shylock the 'villain' it could just be a coincidence, but to get the exact wording...?
Hearing you struggle to say "thesaurus" is so amazing
i didn't understand the "boxed wine" reference anyone care to explain
in an earlier video he said that "expositional dialogue is like boxed wine. It doesn't taste good but it does the job"
Meaning that exposition is low quality trash that you should avoid if possible, but it still gets the plot propelled. just like boxed wine tastes worse than bottled wine, but it still gets you drunk
i thought there would be a sin for the game having the shortest story in the series
Two words to describe this video: Boxed wine. (What does it mean anyway?)
+Muhammed Burak Yavuz I tried googling it but all that came of it was that miley cyrus is made of it.
Argonisgema XD
+Muhammed Burak Yavuz boxed wine is a way of saying "something that is shit,but it works!" For instance,the joke itself.It's shit but it gets gamingsins's job done
I'm glad someone decided to a gaming sins channel as I've been a fan of Cinema Sins for a while, it's nice to see that you don't let the haters get you down and the fact that you include fan submitted sins is awesome.
The coolest part about this video is that Gaming Sins inadvertently predicted that Violet was an instrument of the first will
The voice actors sound more like they're reading off cue cards than actually trying to act
They really should have hired an Irish actor for shay cause the guy they got can't do an Irish accent for shit
The Scottish Accents In Assassin's Creed 3 Were Worse
+rocknrolllives Wait, those were supposed to be Scottish accents? Ohhhh....
+I'm a geek, not a nerd i was thinking the same lol
Your channel should get a lot of more views and subs
I agree! Tell your friends!
I brought your book, Great New World. I'm about 2 thirds in. An amazing read so far!
Excellent! Tell your friends : D
GamingSins Will Axol write more books?
GamingSins what's it about and stuff
When he has the inspiration.
Michael Raine Also, when you finish, make sure to give it a rating.
On the 66th sin, Shay did see the conversation, he was snooping from a nearby rooftop.
I'm pretty sure for the fire scenario in 3:57 the just break open their (probably) $10,000 fish tank elevator 🤣
is it just me or rouge and black flag is actually in the same time line , they looks the same tho
never mind, adewele is here
Fahrul Rozy it is the prequel to assassins creed 3 and the last mission is the prologue to unity
Rogue uses the same engine and stuff. technically it is the same as black flag, just the story and characters are different.
@@Albert_YTC not only the last szene
This game is good, after black flag I kinda just wanted another black flag, so this worked for me tbh
Another sin, THE CREDITS ARE 12 MINUTES LONG!
i thoght it was 20 but still fellt like an hour just siting there for days
I just finished the game. It's over 20 minutes long
Ah, sorry, I wrote that WHILE watching the credits.
+The Bonnie's if you hold b during the credits it skips it LOL
Merde.
A little constructive criticism at 8:08 - Shay wasn't literally saying Wardrop was quoting scripture. "The devil can cite scripture for his purpose" is a quote from The Merchant of Venice. Wardrop pulled the "everything is permitted" line from the Assassin mantra, so it fits in the context here.
also, since the bullets back then were round balls, instead of what we have today, and didn't have internal propulsion from the gunpowder being in the case, they wouldn't have gone as deep and done as much damage, falling onto his back was litterally the worst of his injuries and the cold water would have helped that too
I didn't mind roge but kinda wished they gave it a DLC or something simllor to the other ac games but just my honest opinion mostly
I MAKE MY OWN LUCK!
How much does he say this 2 times thats not much
every sin in this video except tea is exxagerated. u need to understand that these so called sins make this sequel a perfect game
Fanboy much?
+Kenny Polit yeah. i think its one of the best ac ever created.
You missed out another bonus sin when Shay said 'I make my own luck' in the mission Caress Of Steel. He said it to Haytham shortly after the opening cutscene.
How often dies he said this ? I remember 2 times
How often dies he said this ? I remember 2 times
Lol. You can taste the box.
you dont have to sit on the branch and admire the view
How dare you hate on my Shay darling!Rogue is deffinatly not a bad game at all! I love it to death, and it has an amazing story line! I can't get enough of Rogue!! I literally played and finished that game in 3 weeks!It's actually the first AC game I ever played, and what got me addicted to the AC series. Between the playing the game and finishing it, I did alot of research, and I fell in love with it all! Now..., I have AC2, ACB, ACRev, ACBlackflag, and AC3 to add to my ACRogue. ❤❤
+Sarah Henderson
1. calm the f*ck down.
2. the story was ok.
3. you've finished the game in 3 weeks well that took you a while if you like the game so much.
4. this channel is here to find mistakes in games so if you can't take a joke and can't accept that rogue also had mistakes then you are wrong here.
btw I like the game to but can also laugh about the jokes that he made in this video.
It's called I had school, so I can't finish it. Also, I know it has flaws. Every AC game has its flaws. And I was really just joking on the "How dare you all" part. I don't really care if you hate on him or not. I was kidding OK? Geeze.. I know.., everyone has their different opinions. And I'm sorry if I offended you some how, it wasn't intended. And I'm sorry, that I can't be excited or happy about explaining my love for AC.. >.>
+Sarah Henderson I'm sorry if I offended you but I thought you were one of those annoying fangirls >_<
so I'm sorry that I didn't got the joke xc
have a good day
Lmao, you're totally fine! I mean. I can kind of see how I seemed to be an anoyying fangirl, Lol! ☺
And I wish you a good day as well.
+Hatsune Miku AC is a series intended from brainless people and annoying fangirls. So what do you expect?
I will say this - I immediately hate that woman who greets us once we are taken out of the animus and the virus trope is introduced.
This b tch starts talking to us players like we are slow and acting like an assh*le. She is stupid, surly for no reason, unlikable, b*tchy, and cliched.
She calls us "numbskulls" and just has to have coffee. Whoever wrote her part - probably female - should be fired. Fire that awful writer!
Gerin Sartokeesian is it a requirement to be a dick if you're a templar? she was one, haytham was one, charles lee was one
Gerin Sartokeesian Agreed, her character is the worst I've seen in the series yet.
Same here. I'm glad I'm not the only one who has this opinion. I immediately wanted to punch that bitch. lol
piplup2009 Not neccisarily. I mean, there was Torres, for example.
That said...she was just annoying. I think her sole purpose was to be annoying. I particularly hate her because of your second modern day part where she just whines at you until you get to the elevator/ office...even if you're poking around the PCs.
Why probably female?
when the assassins are talking about their plan, shay was actually there. he was on the rooftop
exactly
at 8 minutes 8 seconds in. "even the devil can quote scripture to suit his own purpouses" "he didnt quote scripture" shay wasnt saying that the dude he was killing quoted scripture, the dude quoted the creed, so what shay said was like a metaphor "devil can quote scripture to suit his own needs" is another way to say a templar can quote the creed to suit his own needs
I make my own boxed wine
why not get proper Irish people to voice the Irish instead of Americans doing a shit job
There's nothing wrong with boxed wine, and though this game isn't perfect, it's bloody good, gameplay wise.
And btw, the cabbage farmer thingy - it's an insult, like being called a petty peasant, the ones lowest on social rankings in the old days.
You forgot to mention that they sent Shay on that mission to find what they thought would be an Apple without telling him what an Apple would look like. Also, where did Shay get the idea that the Assassins knew what would happen in Lisbon?
If I ever meet you, I will drown you in boxed wine, give you some dry water and an MRE to go with some chicken nuggets, ramen, 3 minute fried rice.
shay's accent should be sinned. not because the voice actor couldn't get it right, but because it's annoying even if he did get it right.
+jp mesquita The entire game is a sin. It's just a DLC for AC4. Hell even the HUD is an exact replica, apart from a colour change lol. There are almost no new assets here. Just a cash-grab for past gen consoles.
+Arno Dorian (Thunder Junior) "there are almost no new assets here."
i disagree,
the ship has new upgrades ( seriously a ram that break ice sheets is cool)
there are new swords and armor
the landscape is different
YOU CAN HUNT NARWHALS
you don't have to play as a assassin anymore
therefore you can literally slaughter a civilian and not get crucified by the animus for it
and lots more, so this 'cash grab' has quite a lot in it if you think about it
marky mark None of this warrants a new game. DLC's introduce new stuff, and this game is no different. Apart from the large map, this has DLC written all over it.
- A ram that breaks ice is not revolutionary.
- Some new swords is not enough to warrant a game.
- The landscapes are pretty similar actually.
- Hunting a different type of animal is not miraculous.
The sole purpose of Rogue was to get money from the audience that hadn't moved to next-gen yet.
As an Irishman it's painful to listen to why didn't ubisoft hire an Irish actor
Cian Byrne Because Shay's VA was inexperienced, and therefore cheap. This game wasn't a focus for Ubisoft - they didn't put a high budget on this game, because they know most are not going to play it.
3rd best assassins Creed game
I make my own look
+GamingSins At 7:46 He was actually comparing the "Devil quoting scripture" to how the Templar was quoting the creed in order to try and persuade Shay to stop.
12:11 sounds like LOTR "keep your wits about you Bilbo, there are orcs around here" Gandalf
You forgot to add the luck thing was racist because hes irish
Explain how was that racist towards the irish ?
coziestwall Leprechauns
coziestwall Also, Celtic is a race.
ANarcher I am Irish and I found it cheesy as hell, it became tedious and stale almost as soon as he said it, however it is not exactly racist(we are Caucasians by and large, Irish is simply a nationality)...the accent on the other hand, now; that was downright shameful.
The biggest insult about this game was the fact they charged full retail for what is essentially Black Flag and AC3 squashed together(maps and what not, albeit a new storyline), it was boring and lazy.
***** Thank you for clearing that up. I was a bit confused