i'm sorry, but there is something that's just so profound abt how Mariah does riffs and runs. she barely oversings them, she doesn't show off, there's constantly musicality in them that she tends to make it fit into the melody, structure, and sound of the song. and the fucking flex that she can do this in basically every register of the human voice. BUT, on top of that, she did all of that while having a vocal injury for most of her life.
AGREED. MARIAH IS THE QUEEN OF MUSICALITY BECAUSE HER RIFFS AND RUNS ARE ALWAYS PRECISE AND APPROPRIATE. not just doing random runs that sounds so out of place lolll
Also mariah's live always sounds different from each other because she constantly improvise things. This is the quality that whitney and celine dont have
Mariah is the Queen of agility. In every register. No one outside of classical music possesses complete agility like hers ( trills, appoggiatura, staccato) While she sings most of the time her runs are so fast and connected with the melody that they go unnoticed.
Very well said! She utilizes riffs and runs more than most vocalists (not mainly as a "ooh look what I can do"/ show stopping moment) but rather as a way of storytelling throughout her music. Her musicality is top-notch and plus her voice is naturally very pleasant, so most don't notice just how many riffs and runs she's going through. Plus we haven't even discussed her *transitions* which are unparalleled in mainstream music.
that's not true. your perspective is probably narrowed to just pop music. take a deep dive into R&B circles and you'll easily find singers with better agility than Tori Kelly who just haven't made it big.
Of this generation Tori Kelly is the best doing riffs, the musicality is INSANE!! Mariah is untouchable, she sometimes sounds like auto tuned because of the speed of her runs but Tori Kelly is the closest one of this generation
The thing I like about Mariah is whenever she do a riff/run she don’t stop and make it obvious it just fits so perfectly in the song you may not even notice
You are absolutely right about this. Not only Tori, but many other vocalists especially of the new generation do that a lot to highlight their vocal agility but with Mariah it's literally a part of the music and complements it excellently.
1st Battle: Mariah Ofc Tori is very good and her riffs and runs are perfect, there's no doubt for that. I truly love her ability. But compare to Mariah, Mariah has more complex riffs and runs, and ,most of the time you need to slow the speed of her singing to hear the riffs and runs because they fit the melody perfectly. Plus, her musicality is on another level. Overall, tori is one of the best of this generation including jojo, while Mariah is always the queen of melismas. 2nd Battle: Christina Ariana is great, she uses her falsetto really good. But there is something that missing im Ariana's falsetto compared to Christina. I mean like Christina's tone for falsetto is very sweet and it just sound very good, I can't express it. 3rd Battle: Whitney Beyoncè is one of the best singer and has perfect technique there's no doubt. I really love her but Whitney's belt is just something else, it just woww, when you hear it you would know "That's Whitney Houston". As an example, 'And I.......... ' there are no one can sing that well other than Whitney. Ofc there are some great but when you hear Whitney's, you can actually feel it. Her depth, tone, power and more just pure perfection. She was one of the best singer of all-time, we miss you Whitney!!
Tori is better in THIS GENERATION, but no one can overcome Mariah, Because she was the one who revolutionized the story, no one has vocals as difficult as hers.
Mariah all the way. I like how she doesn't make it sound overdone, with all extra trimmings, like these new singers take a song and murder it by wanting to do runs, riffs thru out the entire song, it's just ugh!
I wish I could travel to the future just to hear what Tori Kelly would sound like in her 40s and 50s 😭 I am quite confident that her voice will still be in tact just from how well she takes care of it.
Mariah's is fully knowledge about music and vocals,her runs is very different and inhuman.Torry is closest to Mariah coz the way she control her runs and have a little bit twist which it look like inspired by mariah.🦋❤️
Although they both have gospel backgrounds, they are from totally different generations. Mariah's style was sensational and revolutionary during her time in a way that echoed throughout the world. And it inspired/challenged every other aspiring vocalist to step up their game. And they took cues from Mariah. Tori is one of them. But she existed in a time when vocalists like Christina Aguilera, Alicia Keys, Beyonce, and others were already doing their own thing with their own style. And those singers also influenced Tori. If you listen closely, you can hear many influences to her style. Sometimes jumping from Christina, to Beyonce, and adding her own interpretation as well. That's why her style is recognizable. Her technique is admirable as well. But her vocals didn't blow up like the way Mariah did during her time. And even a lot of Mariah's runs in many of her songs are way too intricate to be sung by anyone but Mariah herself because of her unique vocal quality and skillfulness as well.
Tori’s vocals didn’t blow up in her time because amazing vocals are no longer a priority in today’s era of music. Tori debuted only a few years ago in 2015, a completely separate time from Beyonce, Christina and everyone else you mentioned in the early 2000s where good singing was still appreciated. If you look at it today, besides Ariana, there aren’t really that many good vocalists dominating the music scene or being big household names the same way it was in Mariah (90s) and Beyoncé’s (2000s) time. Had Tori been born a decade or two earlier, she would have been more well received by the general public I think.
@@chikoritaleaf *My point was that Tori's style was already influenced by these artists who came before her. If Tori was born a decade or two earlier, I doubt that she would have that same style or technique that she has today. Her vocals didn't blow up in today's generation (like most other vocally talented artists) because we've already had BIG vocals in the past. Some much bigger and more powerful than hers. We already have such an abundance of vocal talent that the market for powerful vocals is already saturated. These days, people want to more creativity than vocals. A lot of those talented vocalist in the past are not even as popular today as they were before because people want more creativity. Creativity in the lyrics, the videos, in the concept, etc. Today, other less talented vocalists (even those that can't sing much) get the spotlight because they are creative. They bring something new to the table. Ariana, on the other hand, still managed to grab the spotlight because, aside from being a vocal powerhouse, she is also very creative in her music. That's what Tori needs to do. If she wants to get the world's attention.
@@Otts287 Of course every singer was influenced by those before them; Mariah didn’t come out of the womb having her own style. She had her own influences. While Mariah had influenced Tori in some ways, her main influences had always been gospel singers as she has mentioned a couple times in interviews. She actually literally studied gospel singers like Crystal Lewis and Jill Scott when she was as young as 6 years old. She would still have the same style if she was born a decade earlier because her main influences pre-dates Mariah and Beyoncé’s eras. The only difference would probably be that she wouldn’t have continued guitar as her artistry because India Arie inspired her to continue learning at a time where there were hardly any female guitar players + singer-songwriters in the R&B/soul genre.
@@chikoritaleaf Dude. Open up your mind. You're stuck in the same argument. To better drive my point across, let's put vocals aside for a moment. When Mariah came out, her style NEW. It was FRESH. And people wanted MORE. Just think about Britney, Avril, Christina, Beyonce, Lady Gaga, Katy Perry, Justin Bieber, Adelle, Miley Cyrus, Taylor Swift, Selena Gomez, Ariana, Demi, Billie Eilish, Olivia Rodrigo, etc... Many of them are vocal powerhouses, bit some are not. Some more successful than others. However, they all exploded when they came out. Because they took a RISK. And they brought something NEW and FRESH. That made you want to listen to them over and over and made you want be like them. And they become your icons and legends, because they have greatly influenced your life. These days, many people can SING. And I mean REALLY SING. Vocals can only get you so far. You won't fly to the top of the charts JUST BECAUSE you can sing.
For me: 1._Mariah carey is more creative and uses her agility in alot of areas, lows, chest, mix, head, falsetto and Whistle, Tori could be as agile as Mariah but she has more control over her falsetto than in others areas. 2._Ariana use her falsetto better and she has more control over it but Christina has the most beautifull falsetto that i've ever heard. 3._Beyoncé just better technique and Less tension, Whitney's voice is more beautifull and loud but she often has alot of tension, sometimes it sounds like shouty and become thin as she goes high. Great video, next time try to use better examples for everyone❤
@@benjaminbawa5273 ariana cant do what christina can do in falsetto and thats her past her prime what more when she was in arianas age. You really think ariana can do what christina did in auld lang sine without breaking her jaw? Then you’re just a biased fan. Cause ariana can’t compete with christinas falsetto especially the complexity of her runs/control on that register compared to arianas simple ones
@@xmantrans4846 I’m actually a Mariah/Beyoncé fan, I only type truth. I’m sorry you don’t like to hear the truth. 🤷🏻♂️ So screaming in that register is what Xtina can do better than Ariana? 💀 Sometimes, doing little is much. Let Christina unlearn to learn. Her techniques are very unhealthy. 🤷🏻♂️
Never compare Mariah's runs with someone else. The completeness of her agility and the musicality with which she inserts each run almost imperceptibly into her songs is pure art. She is the quintessential melismatic singer, the Golden Standard and anyone in this video would agree
*1st Battle:* Mariah *2nd Battle:* Christina *3rd Battle:* Whitney When it comes to *Tori & Mariah's* vocal agility, Tori's riffs & runs put her in that untouchable league with that Mariah, Beyonce, Debelah Morgan, Jazmine Sullivan etc. Mariah's extraordinary ability in transitions, octave jumps plus cramming countless riffs and runs into songs in such a seamless manner, in addition to how she utilizes staccato is what puts her above Tori and in fact most vocalists in mainstream music. Let's just say, she has a more arsenal in her festive vocal agility purse. Tori has a lot of useable range; that combined with her exceptional agility & musicality, there's still a ton of untapped potential with her. *Christina Aguilera's* is more skilled in her falsetto than *Ariana Grande;* she's more consistent with it eg. quite a number of "Everyday" D6's get the best of Ariana. In addition to that, Christina is more agile in it, even at the highest parts of it. Christina is the Queen of Falsetto in mainstream music, Ariana is a resident princess of Falsetto in mainstream music. When it comes to belts, Whitney takes it. She is technically stronger than Beyonce in this area. Yeah I said it. Not even because she supports higher (some will say it's because Beyonce is a Mezzo-Soprano, apparently the verdict is still out on that). Whitney has more TA development and engagement plus she's consistently more resonant. Beyonce is definitely a technical vocalist however so is Whitney and in this area, her technique is stronger plus the bonus of the inherent characteristics of her voice amplifies the superior technical development she already has in this area.
(For the sake of others who may read this, when I use the word resonance, I am referring to “squillo”) Whitney has more TA development along with the fact that she opts to use a more pharyngeal placement as opposed to Beyoncé’s use of mask placement. Nothing wrong with that, it’s just that pharyngeal resonance is generally preferred. Wonder why this video stopped at E5 with them though. Whitney takes C5 and E5 while Beyoncé takes Eb5 but I give a tie on C# simply because Beyoncé opted for that pharyngeal placement there and it was just as resonate as Whitney’s. I find that as Beyoncé’s voice matures, she’s transitioning from mask placement and to a more pharyngeal sound which is allowing her to be more resonate. You can hear that she began to use pharyngeal placement back in 2009 while singing this very song(halo), since then, most of her belts below C#5s have been with this placement. Edit: I forgot to mention D5, I didn’t really like either of them but Whitney raising her shoulders and leaning back created tension therefore I’ll give it to Beyoncé. -Also, the verdict isn’t really out on being being a mezzo, that’s been determined already and is quite undeniable by now.
@@LiTim17 Well said, I appreciate your comment! I would give Eb5 to Beyonce based on the particular clips that were used but after th-cam.com/video/-CbOBgfIevk/w-d-xo.htmlm51s Eb5 goes to Whitney. Mind you, she doesn't use an echo for creating the effect of a larger sound (carrying over more). th-cam.com/video/-Lze7UQSBpk/w-d-xo.htmlm31s - I'm rather hearing less resonance from her these days.
@@GarageStudio7 yes, it’s often a battle between those two on this specific note. Both are beats on it, so it’s really hard to give it to either one honestly. As for hearing less resonance, I disagree, the clip you sent was really compressed, here is a raw recording th-cam.com/video/MaCHEQzeXQw/w-d-xo.html . Now, I will definitely say that during that performance she was really vulnerable and that gave room for imperfections such as her Eb5s.
Mariah is human and therefore touchable. Literally a fact that's well known. If you can't accept that no singer is untouchable than there's no hope of having a productive debate about the abilities of different vocalists.
Mind you that all the melodies and composed melisma which Mariah sings are HERS and everyone else was later inspired by her. She was inspired by Aretha, and Karen Clark Sheard
Tori is a great singer, amazing vocals, range, runs etc...but Mariah is queen and paid her dues over the last 30 years....we all know who wins this hands down
Well that's mostly what they're about and that's what most people including myself thought unless your a music technician or a vocal coach etc other than that that's all I thought they were tbh which is clearly what both Mariah and tori do on a daily basis tbh😊
@@alexandraanderson3988 I understand, many people are ill-informed about Vocal Agility. It's similar to one thinking that vocal dynamics are solely crescendos.
tori's amazing , hands down the best singer of this generation when it comes to riffs and runs but she has no vision of love msg moments for instance, mariah's agility is unmatched and her runs are by far the most complex ones in pop/rnb music, idk why ppl still have doubts about it, ,mariah was serving impossible runs in her first year of career at the age of 20 (see vanishing snl reharsal in 1990) and kept serving impossibly complex runs for years, her runs are not just made of quick notes or scales, mariah's runs are complex not only because of the insane amount of notes that are in them but also because of her ability to switch register so flawlessly that you can't even hear the flip from chest to head voice/falsetto or even whistle register sometimes, also not to mention her musicality and how she could do an octave jump out of nowhere and make it sound pleasent and intricated
Runs and riffs: I'd say Mariah and Tori kelly had the same agillity skills in terms of speed, precision, pitch, musicallity and complexity. But there is something more in Mariah's runs. The way she construct them rlly fits the song she's singing, song genre that she's singing and also have alot of types of patterns, style or type of runs/riffs. While tori is mostly just ascending and descending (well some others were different styles tho) And also Mariah's is less show offy while also having a great complex long runs it does not seem like she's showing them off. (such as lead the way run) And mostly Mariah is comfortable in every register when doing runs and riff (well tori too) but Mariah is still more comfy. So I'm going to Mariah's Vocal agillity Falsettos: I prefer xtina's falsetto (ariana did supper rr great dahhling) but xtina's comfort in her falsetto and I think it's also more consistent and also she's more confident doing it (for me) and xtina's falsetto can be powerful and light too. Also her vibrato in that register Is also great. And her agillity in that register is much mre better compared to ariana (but ariana' s agillity in that register is also rlly great). Belting: Whitney houston ofcourse. She's besically queen of belts Beyonce's belts were rlly great but whitney's power and resonance in her belts were rlly great. And also her vibrato in the belts were always present from Tom to bottom and always smooth and healthy. Her tone and support and consistency in her belts were also great. While Beyonce is like student belter and Whitney is the teacher belter. But Beyonce belts were great it has a great smooth healthy vibrato from top to bottom. Also has a powerful belt with ease in upper belts. And also consistent. But Whitney's belt it alot more bettercomlared to Beyonce for me. (it is just my opinions dahhling)
Tori is absolutely amazing too but dawlinnnggg MARIAH FOR THE WIN!!! Queen of riffs and runs- I dont think she's everrr overdone it. Her improv is also just so smooth and i really like that (listen to "Lead The Way"- it's so pleasant to the ear💞). Tori is honestly great, but in some instances, she may push her talent too far and it doesn't sound very nice..NO SHADE JUST OPINON- LOVE THEM BOTH🐑💓 Next up~ Xtina honeyyy, I LOVE YOU BUT IM SORRY ARI ATE🖤 Her tone is just more angelic and she has a bit more ease with it. I STILL SEE YOU Christina!!! I think you'll have the most perfect falsetto if you just simmer a bit- let your voice flow out and maintain that control at the same time👍Anyways- ILL ALWAYS BE UR LOYAL FAN XOXO LASTLY~ no questions asked. Whitney. PERIODT. But to be honest yes Beyonce is the moment..........but Whitney has been and always will be regarded as the greatest singer of all time. Brighter than any star in the sky in my opinion. Her belts are effortless yet so intense and passionate it doesnt make sense. Thank you Whitney- for sharing your heavenly voice with us. May you rest in peace❤ Just wanted to share my thoughts- maybe even change someone's perspective? Hope so💓💓
Lol it’s clear in the video christina has a better falsetto and has more complex runs if ariana were to do that auld lang sine falsetto run she would break her jaw
I think at this standard it really is splitting hairs, most of it is going to be down to personal preference. Based on these clips alone. I think Mariah's melisma here are more creative and Tori's (to me) seem a bit more polished and have more ease to them. I think I'm gonna go with Mariah though, the level of difficulty and creativity wins it for me. Xtina wins against Ariana. They're both fantastic and it's pretty close however I think Christina is more agile in this area and is able to manipulate the dynamic better. I also think she's more creative with hers. Beyonce wins in the third round for me. Whitney is very chest heavy and to me it comes across as a bit "shouty" and loses that great tonal quality she has especially when it goes higher, whereas Beyonce is more varied in her approach (changing the balance of her mix) and generally retains brightness in her voice whilst still maintaining a great depth. These are some very close competitors and like I said before I think it's all going to come down to personal preference.
What? Whitney is the one who maintains the depth as she ascends lol, show me Beyoncé doin an F#5 with the same amount of core like Whitney did in you give good love, or a G5 with the same amount of core that she in i am changing
1° - i love queen mariah but tori slaaaay so hard. 2° Christina is a master but Ariana take my breath away. She has more control and tone . 3° Whitney... without any coments
8:27 I’m sorry but this just doesn’t sound good to me at all… it sounds squeezed and very tiny. Almost like that of a mosquito. I get that she wants to show off her range, but in instances I personally wouldn’t do that, I’d stick to what sounds pleasing.
Why is Ariana 😢😮 in the middle in between two of the so called Greats 😅😊❤ as you guys would say I'm sorry 😔😐 but get her out she shouldn't be there put somebody else i guess lmaoo no offense just saying!!!
1st round: Mariah - Mariah easily takes this. Agility includes transitions, octave jumps, trills, staccatos and musicality aside from riffs/ runs and she’s superior in all those areas. 2nd round: Ariana - Ariana’s tone in this register is just so angelic especially in 6:22 where she sounds more like a flute than a human. Ease and agility in it I’d say is tie with Xtina but she wins in tone and musicality 3rd round: Whitney - a close one because Bey’s belts are also crazy good but it’s also Whitney’s strongest feat that’s just unmatched. Heavenly resonant tone, insane power and dynamics so she wins this
I'd have to say Tori is more agile. She rarely, if ever, has a bad vocal. Mariah has had some misses when singing live and has been quite shaky. She's much better than Tori is many other ways (belting, tone, maybe even melismas, but agility? No. Tori has never had a bad vocal. I prefer Ariana's falsetto - she can do more. Her rendition of Emotions alone takes the case. And Whitney's just the queen of belting. I would've even preferred to pair Beyonce and Tori up with agility. That would've been a good battle, cause these 2, especially now, never miss a note.
The thing is melisma(which is just runs and riffs) is a part of what makes up agility. Tori may slightly edge out Mariah when it comes to pitch but Mariah does more intricate and creative runs and can showcase the same speed in every register. She also has the best transitions in contemporary music. So overall Tori is not more agile, which isn’t a bad thing… she’s still the most agile vocalist of this generation and can definitely be considered in the same caliber as Mariah when it comes to agility but she is not above
@@kingjuicy3023 I definitely see where ur coming from. Mariah is exceptional. For me, I just think Tori is more consistent. Which for me, is a part of agility. Its not just doing complex riffs and runs. And agility is more than riffs and runs. Its about accuracy, consistency and healthy singing technique. MC is not always as accurate, consistent or has the most healthiest singing technique sometimes. Especially after 1998. I give Tori the edge there. MC is more agile in the studio, but Tori is more agile live. I'd put my money on Tori executing a one take vocal with less errors over MC.
Tori is probably more agile than Mariah tbh. But Mariah is agile in every register, and has superior musicianship. Her runs feel part of the music while you can tell Tori is trying to showcase her agility (rightfully so!) Also, thank you for using post-prime Mariah clips!
Mariah, no question, nor a hard one. I would go with Ariana on falsetto, although I think they are close enough. When it comes to belts, noone wins Whitney, it's truly remarkable how she keeps her absolute strength and chestiness till the very highest note, I've never heard anyone other doing that so greatly, and still retaining her absolutely beautiful tone!!
Tori vs Mariah: I preferred Tori. She has much better note separation than Mariah and and although Mariahs are slightly faster and a bit longer her note separation seems to suffer just as little bit. I think that her musically is slightly better however. Ariana vs Xtina: I preferred Ariana. Now this is mostly a tonal preference which is subjective but I also think that Xtinas overall ease wasn’t as good as Ariana’s. The sound of “freeness” wasn’t as strong. Whitney vs Beyoncé: Whitney. Period.
She just turned 29 a few weeks ago, a couple more years and she would be in her true vocal prime and we won’t be ready for the slayage 😯 And take into account if she has kids and how pregnancy would alter her voice...
Vocal agility: Both are AMAZING but I'm going with Mimi (her runs are much more complex and her musicality is far superior to Tori's, even though Tori is creative with her runs too ❤️). Both riff just as fast as the other and both Mimi's and Tori's runs are incredibly precise. They're both almost always on key (I would say Tori is slightly better in the pitch aspect because Mariah has gone off key a couple of times when singing the Hero high note during the Daydream World Tour; she ended up hitting a flat G#5 instead of a G5... I'm not sure which night but I remember watching a video of her performing the song on tour where she went sharp) Falsetto: Overall, I prefer Ariana's. But if you look at it objectively, Christina's agility in her falsetto (and her lower register, even though low notes don't matter in this case) is far superior to Ariana's (but that first riff that Ariana did... the one in Bang Bang; she SLAYYYYED us all there 😍). Her vibrato in the register is also much better than Ariana's. However, Ariana is more comfortable in the register because her voice sits higher than Christina's and she doesn't thin out until F6 while Christina sometimes thins out above D6. Belting: C5: Whitney (I love Bey but she was clearly using a lot of reverb) C#5: Whitney D5: Tie Eb5: Whitney E5: Tie
I agree with everything you said, but Christina doesn’t thin out at the note you said. D6 is still pretty comfortable for her. In her prime, she was still very strong on G#6 and A6.
When it comes to agility I think Tori is as agile as Mariah. She just is. They’re the most agile and precise vocalists I can think of. Christina can be as agile as them but can get sloppy more often. Having said that, I think Mariah is superior when it comes to musicality and creativity Christina’s falsetto is the most beautiful in the business in my humble opinion. Ariana is great too but she just doesn’t have the same charm. Regarding belts…do I really have to say it? Come on.
It's a battle of vocal agility ie. not just riffs and runs, but also staccato, trills, transitions, octave jumps etc. *Mariah takes it.* Tori's riffs and runs display that she still has a lot of untapped potential.
@@GarageStudio7 Tori has proved to be more than capable of recreating what Mariah can do. The only thing Mariah does that I don’t see Tori doing is the transition from chest voice to whistle. Everything else, Tori can do. Still, I don’t think Tori tops Mariah when it comes to creativity, musicality and stylistic choices. Does Mariah take it for me overall? Yes. Does Mariah take it on a technical level? No. This doesn’t take anything away from Mariah, no need to get defensive.
@@rkngl807 th-cam.com/video/5heDgaQCSVE/w-d-xo.htmlm23s - Seamlessly transition from D6 in head voice to a belt th-cam.com/video/5Rs6TwjeaDo/w-d-xo.html - 3 note appogiatura for 6 secs (53 notes) one breath, upper 6th octave. And in case you want more: th-cam.com/video/oL0gc7UWSiY/w-d-xo.html It's not about being defensive but let's actually consider things that can be proven. You're saying that she's capable of creating anything that Mariah can do and the only thing you haven't seen are chest to whistle transitions, but as I have shown, there's a lot more that she is incapable of doing. At least based on what we've seen thus far. Complex riffs and runs, yes they both have that. Natalie Weiss can break it down and teach people, it may not be easy but one can grasp it. But these vocal feats that Mariah has shown are on a whole other level.
@@GarageStudio7 well, obviously Tori is nowhere near to Mariah’s proficiency in the whistle register, that goes without saying. Whistles taken aside, I still think Tori is capable of doing. Regarding the first clip: I know it sounds like head voice in the beginning but I believe it was a belt distorted by the audio. It’s like the audio settings they used made the overtones extremely loud and so it sounded kinda like head voice.
@@rkngl807 Has she done things like that in head voice then? In all the other versions of the first clip it sounds the same. Plus that didn't happen with any other belts. Also, in that part of the song she always uses an upper register note. She doesn't hit upper belts there.
In my opinion, First Battle! #Mariah vs #Tori: Both are INCREDIBLE songwriters, vocalists, and talented. I LOVE them BOTH sooooo much.♥️ However, l choose Mariah for the win.♥️ Second Battle! #Christina vs #Ariana: Tbh, l prefer Christina more. I LOVE her music, voice and her vocals. Better singer and has better falsetto.♥️ l like her more.♥️ l don’t like Ariana at all. (No offence!😅) Third Battle! #Beyoncè vs #Whitney: Oh, that was a hard one to choose. My first and second FAVOURITE female singers.♥️♥️♥️ however, as much as l LOVE Beyoncé, l choose Whitney, even though l LOVE her just as much.♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️ l LOVE them BOTH so much.♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️ Great video! xD ♥️
It baffles me that ears hear Mariah as the superior riffer 🤔 I think people only say that because "she's Mariah"...it is as clear as day that Tori is superior in riffing, and it's not a small difference either. Sound does not support the lie that Mariah is better. You LIKE her more, and that's fine, but she is not better than Tori. Come on now 🤷
finally someone hears me.. as a trained jazz pianist myself, tori is absolutely insane with her complexity and runs compared to mariah.. tori, christina, jasmin they are incredible when it comes to agility. mariah is boring and repetitive and musically her runs dont really make that much sense within context
@@justevaded Mariah’s runs doesn’t make sense musically? She literally has the best runs musicality wise in the industry just say you hate her and go lmao
Mariah's agility in the lower register makes no sense, definitely unsupported!!!!! Toni Braxton and Xtina have the best agility in the lower register. Great projection and tone as well. I think Tori's agility is faster, like alienish, but Mariah can do more! Especially in the mid range and whistle register. Ofc Christina has a better falsetto, angelic, and when she uses it, she always does acrobatics with it. Whitney's belting is more memorable. When the tone of the voice is quite generic, like Beyonce's, I'd not care whether she belts or not. Out of all 6, Whitney and Christina are most known for belting, the rest mix a lot... and ofc loose the power of the note.
Love Xtina but she’s not known for belting in a positive light. Also Toni Braxton is doing the same thing Mariah is when she sings lower, albeit, she has a lower voice, it’s still the same.
I think you’re not making sense and talking just based in tone. Mariah is a soprano and you are comparing her with two mezzos in the lower register? Obviously hers will be more airy, but she keeps and incredibly fast agility down there which is incredible.
Tje scariest thing i noticed about mariah was her riff n run is well- integrated to song n part of the melody... N most of them are so subtle. Unnoticeable unless u try to sing it to her original
no you got it all wrong in my opinion ive never heard tori over sing and all her ad libs riffs and runs fit the melody and mood of the songs she sings every time. i recommend you dive into her live performances esp. her newer ones for example her live performance ‘in times like these’
Mariah vs Toir: U could say either and u would be correct. Personally I think Mariahs are slightly more just different and creative. I mean both re but something about Mariah's just seems different and almost like unheard of. Like when I watch a vid on her agility all her runs are well executed, creative, and for some reason just sound so distinctive and again creative. Like she play with her voice a lot when riffing and running like she can go softer, go more fuller and powerful adding belts and stuff, g for a more piercing bird kinda sound with her whistles, or for a more bright and pretty tone with her head voice and falsetto. For musicality both again would be correct. Toris are very creative and her runs fit the song (whtv it is) very wel almost if not every time. They are well executed and just perfectly fit the rhythm, key, and vibe. Whether it be gospel, pop, rnb, or whtv other genre. mariah is the same. Her runs always fit the songs, rhythm, and vibe no matter what genre. Both can really change up their runs and adapt them to whtv the genre is like I said whether its gospel, pop, hip-hop, rnb, more ballad slow kinda feel, or anything else. Overall I will honestly just say tie (maybe tori SLIGHTLY actually). Finally speed and precision. AGAIN both would be correct. For speed Mariah can be extremely fast when she wants to and when she does well she can really RUN. Like its hard to see how many notes she actually hits sometimes cause she be going so fast. Tori is the same. She can be extremely fast (if not faster than Mariah at times). Tori is honestly more consistently fast tbh as she is like always doing very fast and quick runs while mariah CAN and HAS but not as often as Tori. She mostly alternates between fast and medium paced runs. I mean tori does as well but she is mostly faster. Precision I will just say a tie bcuz both ladies even when going hella fast always hit every single note. Overall I will say both are kidna just equal. Mariah has the edge (imo) for creativity and versatility, while tori takes speed and musicality, and they both tie in precision. I will say They are both equally great. TIE! Christina vs Ari: Now a lot of ppl consider chirstina the queen of falsetto and i get why but lets see. Personally I prefer aris tone. christinas is really good but aris is brighter and sweeter which is what i prefer.range would be either one of them. i think christina has gone higher like a g6. not sure if it was whistle or falsetto but i'll just say it was falsetto. Overall I prefer aris falsetto but either one would be correct imo. ARI (imo) Whitney vs Beyonce. Okay look Beyonce is amazing she is great especially at belting. they are powerful, full, have a nice vibrato, well sustained and supported and overall just great. but imo Whitney is one of the best belters ever (or atleast in pop/mainstream music). to me she is top 10 if not top 6 or 5. she is just amazing. the power, vibrato, ease, sustaining of the note and just her tone and the way she hits the notes is just impeccable. Especially when it comes to mid belts she is literally ONE OF THE BEST. Few can match her in the mids. even in the upper parts she still holds her own with that power and vibrato. Now this isn't to say that Beyonce is WAY behind whitney cause she ain't she still one of the best fo this gen if not one of the best in mainstream pop and music of the past few decides. but she just ain't as good as whitney.
No hate but the creator of the video actually didnt put many of mariahs most impressive runs. Also tori kelly is phenomenal but very likely to over sing. Technically both are amazing, the best in my humble opinion, mariah is more pleasing to the ears so I ll say mariah In falsetto, both are amazing but personal preference is christina. Belting wise, I dont know why the creator of the video chose beyonce against whitney. It would be better if they chose someone like lara fabian, sohyang or natalie Weiss against whitney. Dont get me wrong, beyonce is one of the best of her time but in terms of belting, Whitney is much much better specially if we look at both of their primes.
Lol Lara and natalie against Whitney I don't know🥴 I personally don't know natalie that well as an artist at all but she seems more like riff and run type of person and Lara seems like she has more of a softer voice don't know her personally as an artist either but these two don't seem to be like the belting type of people.🤷🏾♀️
vocal agility: I like them both, they are the best representatives of how vocal agility should be used, but they use different styles that few people comment on. it's not all about speed, and it's here that things get diversed. I think Tori's faster than Mariah, but the subtle and intricate way that Mariah uses her runs in the middle of the songs make me fell in love with her. Tori uses her runs almost like the climax of her songs, always in evidence while she sings. Not wrong, it's incredible, but I prefer Mariah. falsetto: Definitely Ariana. Ariana's falsetto it's very polished, probably the best part of her voice, the tone it's incredible, like her control. Christina have a good falsetto too, but sometimes get that scratchy sound that annoys me a little. Both great, but I prefer Ariana. Belting: Both of them are "star level" in belting, and it's really hard to say who's better for me. I would say Beyoncé because I prefer the way she uses her belts in R&B songs, but they are equally perfect.
@0:51-pitchy @0:58- the whole run is pitchy @1:53 do I even have to say anything… I did love her proceeding run @1:55 tho, otherwise all are verryyyy pitchy and Mariah often does very glissando or pitchy runs. Whoever says she’s “untouchable” in this category is a Stan. There were much better agile singers during her prime. Honestly Whitney and Beyoncé slayed the agility category as well
Tori, Christina, Whitney Tori is very much just barely passing but she’s got a lot of room to grow. I think Mariah’s runs are more interesting at times but Tori’s got the agility and technique down pat.
In my opinion: 1. Melisma - I feel like Tori wins in this department. Tori's runs are just as fast as Mariah's. The main difference I hear is Tori's runs are a lot more precise, clean, & consistent. Mariah sometimes got lost in the sauce causing her to loose pitch and become sloppy. I have yet to hear a bad run from Tori so yeah. 2. Head Voice - Christina definitely wins in this area. Ariana has a great tone, but she's no where as creative as Christina. 3. Belting - I think Beyonce takes it (with the clips given), but I do think as a whole Beyonce is a lot more refined when it comes to belting. Whitney can sometimes sing with valsalva and her vibrato did her no favors. Beyonce doesn't really have as many issues. She does stay in her comfort zone for the most part, but when she does go above F5 it's not too bad. C5 - Beyonce C#5 - Whitney D5 - Beyonce Eb5 - Tie E5 - Whitney
Mariah's are just so subtle that you don't notice just how many notes she can actually sing. Her runs are sloppy, just extremely subtle and smooth. She can also sing very precise and clean runs too. Her runs are also much more musical and has more musicality to them as well.
I disagree on the Melisma... Tori is VERY technical but the lower part of her range when doing so is thin and not as supported. The emotional quality is not there as well, and sounds very mechanical. Mariah's is very clean, but depending on the style and song choice...it will NOT always be a very clear run because it IS NOT SUPPOSED TO BE. Most people think that every run needs to be "clean," but if you know anything about R&B, jazz, gospel, etc. You will know that. But what seperates the two here is that every aspect of Mariah's range has body of sound, resonance, and clarity, as opposed to Toris range. So again, I disagree in my professional opinion as an artist teacher, musician, and technician. Feel free to speak with me over this, but I think a lot of times, us who "critique and judge" are basing what we hear off of our experiences, priority lists, and knowledge of music. Musicality outweighs technique any day for me.
Daydream Mariah is the perfect singer! But other than that I feel Tori Kelly takes the cake!! Coz she never misses....Mariah does infact...they're so good that just 1 lil note here n there makes all the difference. Ari and Xtina are pretty equal in terms of falsetto and Bey is technically flawless ut Whitney's voice was made to belt so I'd say: 1) Dayream Mariah > Tori > Anyother Mariah 2) Ari = Xtina ( I prefer Ari's tone so, for me it's her) 3) Whitney (Bey is there technically but Whitney was a natural)
Tori’s creativity wins in my opinion, she always changes her runs up and her runs are way clearer to hear than Mariah. She is honestly the best singer of this time in my opinion
hell no lol Tori’s runs are on the same level of Mariah’s in terms of complexity, speed and precision but when it comes to creativity and musicality she’s nowhere near Mariah, sorry. She just isn’t.
@@rkngl807 creativity wise, tori wins. mariah’s agility is slightly better but her runs/riffs have a certain pattern which she uses in every song, just with a different approach
@@chanieee9566 no babes, it’s literally the other way around. Also, every singer has some signature runs/riffs but the “pattern” thing is just bs that you’ve read from a hater’s comment under this video.
You should have included Mariah's rendition of Over The Rainbow where she made the bluebirds fly-ah-ah-uh-ah-ay-ay-ay-ay. . .
True
That is one of my favorite Mariah runs ever!
i'm sorry, but there is something that's just so profound abt how Mariah does riffs and runs. she barely oversings them, she doesn't show off, there's constantly musicality in them that she tends to make it fit into the melody, structure, and sound of the song. and the fucking flex that she can do this in basically every register of the human voice. BUT, on top of that, she did all of that while having a vocal injury for most of her life.
AGREED. MARIAH IS THE QUEEN OF MUSICALITY BECAUSE HER RIFFS AND RUNS ARE ALWAYS PRECISE AND APPROPRIATE. not just doing random runs that sounds so out of place lolll
Also mariah's live always sounds different from each other because she constantly improvise things. This is the quality that whitney and celine dont have
mariah is untouchable but tori is really the closest in terms of musicality among the generation's vocalist
Mariah is actually touchable coz Tori is that good ❤️❤️❤️
Yes! Like this is the way I would describe both of them. And honestly Tori is one of the few vocalists deserving of the Mariah's daughter honor lol.
@@browsethatchannel thank you so much for your honesty
@@felixmwiya7784 pls stop yall sound delusional Tori ain’t no where near Mariah Carey
@@JeremiahandBellaEmpire you just biased. In terms of PURE agility. Tori is definitely as fast and even faster than Mariah in many areas.
Mariah is the Queen of agility. In every register. No one outside of classical music possesses complete agility like hers ( trills, appoggiatura, staccato) While she sings most of the time her runs are so fast and connected with the melody that they go unnoticed.
Very well said! She utilizes riffs and runs more than most vocalists (not mainly as a "ooh look what I can do"/ show stopping moment) but rather as a way of storytelling throughout her music.
Her musicality is top-notch and plus her voice is naturally very pleasant, so most don't notice just how many riffs and runs she's going through.
Plus we haven't even discussed her *transitions* which are unparalleled in mainstream music.
Queen of Vocal
that's not true. your perspective is probably narrowed to just pop music. take a deep dive into R&B circles and you'll easily find singers with better agility than Tori Kelly who just haven't made it big.
Nahh.. Tori Riff are more complex and fast Mariah arent that fast and complex like tori
@@blackwitnessaaa196 Has Tori done anything as complex as this th-cam.com/video/5Rs6TwjeaDo/w-d-xo.html
Of this generation Tori Kelly is the best doing riffs, the musicality is INSANE!! Mariah is untouchable, she sometimes sounds like auto tuned because of the speed of her runs but Tori Kelly is the closest one of this generation
tori is the one who sounds autotuned when doing riffs
@@batch9518 She's amazing but her runs are so clean that I really can appreciate every note, Mariah is brutal with that
@@batch9518 You are seriously out of your mind.
@@batch9518 That's how good she is tbh to the point where she sounds autone but its not😊
@@batch9518 Tori Riff are more faster and complex than Mariah btw
Tori is the closest to Mariah from our generation. In term of agility and musicality
Not really. I haven’t heard much powerful belts from her like mariah did during daydream or music box. But I agree that she is agile
@@mcfanrobinhood They literally said in terms of agility and musicality in the comment lmao
@@mcfanrobinhood that’s the problem with these new singers like Tori, Ariana, Alesia, etc. No power. So their highs sound screechy.
@@jaydel3 who is Alesia? Cara? she is not even a vocalist pls
@@jaydel3 tori has power and resonance, not Ariana though, Ari has a pretty tone
Mariah complements the melody with her riffs and runs while tory do it more like a stylistic choice.
The thing I like about Mariah is whenever she do a riff/run she don’t stop and make it obvious it just fits so perfectly in the song you may not even notice
My point exactly. That’s how it’s meant to be, but these days, singers do it to showcase.
You are absolutely right about this. Not only Tori, but many other vocalists especially of the new generation do that a lot to highlight their vocal agility but with Mariah it's literally a part of the music and complements it excellently.
Mariah Carey her riff&runs,melisma is untouchable 👑🦋 but tori doing great lamb supports lamb 🐑
I feel like Tori technically has better riffs and runs but Mariah's tone and musicality on her runs are untouched
Tori is more soul, but I like Mariah runs more🤔
1st Battle: Mariah
Ofc Tori is very good and her riffs and runs are perfect, there's no doubt for that. I truly love her ability. But compare to Mariah, Mariah has more complex riffs and runs, and ,most of the time you need to slow the speed of her singing to hear the riffs and runs because they fit the melody perfectly. Plus, her musicality is on another level. Overall, tori is one of the best of this generation including jojo, while Mariah is always the queen of melismas.
2nd Battle: Christina
Ariana is great, she uses her falsetto really good. But there is something that missing im Ariana's falsetto compared to Christina. I mean like Christina's tone for falsetto is very sweet and it just sound very good, I can't express it.
3rd Battle: Whitney
Beyoncè is one of the best singer and has perfect technique there's no doubt. I really love her but Whitney's belt is just something else, it just woww, when you hear it you would know "That's Whitney Houston". As an example, 'And I.......... ' there are no one can sing that well other than Whitney. Ofc there are some great but when you hear Whitney's, you can actually feel it. Her depth, tone, power and more just pure perfection. She was one of the best singer of all-time, we miss you Whitney!!
Oh hell no you just chiise the old ladies that its
@@terencegrande8978 they are legends not just old ladies😺💅
@@abellana.kyle.casing and they're still old ladies
@@OpinionatedZoomer69 that are better than this petty generation
ngl Christina’s falsetto can be very shrill sometimes and Ariana’s sounds sweeter
6:21 ariana really said: i'm a flute, bi*ch
The tone in that one is insane she doesn’t sound human
Wow i love how you included obscure mariah vocals from the music box and rainbow tour that not everyone has seen!!
Mariah at all costs, she’s the QUEEN at whistles, agility, and she one of a kind nobody else can touch.
Tori is better in THIS GENERATION, but no one can overcome Mariah, Because she was the one who revolutionized the story, no one has vocals as difficult as hers.
Mariah all the way. I like how she doesn't make it sound overdone, with all extra trimmings, like these new singers take a song and murder it by wanting to do runs, riffs thru out the entire song, it's just ugh!
That second mariah clip is insane. She’s superior but tori is an incredible vocalist. Top notch
OBVUOUSLY Chrisitna has the most complex falsetto runs and her range to be able to go up so fast and on the spot.
lol
Lol
Christina just runs all over the place, Ariana wins without hesitation.
LOL, Christina’s entire voice is even unprecise, not to talk about her falsettos, LOL.
@@bohlalenchabeleng1370 Ariana can barely do a Eb6 falsetto💀💀💀💀
I wish I could travel to the future just to hear what Tori Kelly would sound like in her 40s and 50s 😭 I am quite confident that her voice will still be in tact just from how well she takes care of it.
To me is Mariah, Ari and Whitney. In truth in belting I like so much Beyoncé but Whitney give me chills
Ariana ? Don’t think so.. she is and will never be on beyonce level let alone Mariah and Whitney. Come on now !
@@mcfanrobinhood u dont have to agree with him, its AN OPINION.
@@mcfanrobinhood i bet you didn't watch the video, it's mariah vs tori, ariana vs xtina, whitney vs beyoncé
@@mcfanrobinhoodWatch the video first and then come talk, I'm not saying that Ariana is bigger than anyone.
@@mcfanrobinhood Ariana’s better than Xtina, that’s what he means.
Mariah's is fully knowledge about music and vocals,her runs is very different and inhuman.Torry is closest to Mariah coz the way she control her runs and have a little bit twist which it look like inspired by mariah.🦋❤️
Although they both have gospel backgrounds, they are from totally different generations. Mariah's style was sensational and revolutionary during her time in a way that echoed throughout the world. And it inspired/challenged every other aspiring vocalist to step up their game. And they took cues from Mariah. Tori is one of them. But she existed in a time when vocalists like Christina Aguilera, Alicia Keys, Beyonce, and others were already doing their own thing with their own style. And those singers also influenced Tori. If you listen closely, you can hear many influences to her style. Sometimes jumping from Christina, to Beyonce, and adding her own interpretation as well. That's why her style is recognizable. Her technique is admirable as well. But her vocals didn't blow up like the way Mariah did during her time. And even a lot of Mariah's runs in many of her songs are way too intricate to be sung by anyone but Mariah herself because of her unique vocal quality and skillfulness as well.
Tori’s vocals didn’t blow up in her time because amazing vocals are no longer a priority in today’s era of music. Tori debuted only a few years ago in 2015, a completely separate time from Beyonce, Christina and everyone else you mentioned in the early 2000s where good singing was still appreciated. If you look at it today, besides Ariana, there aren’t really that many good vocalists dominating the music scene or being big household names the same way it was in Mariah (90s) and Beyoncé’s (2000s) time. Had Tori been born a decade or two earlier, she would have been more well received by the general public I think.
@@chikoritaleaf *My point was that Tori's style was already influenced by these artists who came before her. If Tori was born a decade or two earlier, I doubt that she would have that same style or technique that she has today.
Her vocals didn't blow up in today's generation (like most other vocally talented artists) because we've already had BIG vocals in the past. Some much bigger and more powerful than hers. We already have such an abundance of vocal talent that the market for powerful vocals is already saturated. These days, people want to more creativity than vocals. A lot of those talented vocalist in the past are not even as popular today as they were before because people want more creativity. Creativity in the lyrics, the videos, in the concept, etc. Today, other less talented vocalists (even those that can't sing much) get the spotlight because they are creative. They bring something new to the table.
Ariana, on the other hand, still managed to grab the spotlight because, aside from being a vocal powerhouse, she is also very creative in her music. That's what Tori needs to do. If she wants to get the world's attention.
@@Otts287 Of course every singer was influenced by those before them; Mariah didn’t come out of the womb having her own style. She had her own influences. While Mariah had influenced Tori in some ways, her main influences had always been gospel singers as she has mentioned a couple times in interviews. She actually literally studied gospel singers like Crystal Lewis and Jill Scott when she was as young as 6 years old. She would still have the same style if she was born a decade earlier because her main influences pre-dates Mariah and Beyoncé’s eras. The only difference would probably be that she wouldn’t have continued guitar as her artistry because India Arie inspired her to continue learning at a time where there were hardly any female guitar players + singer-songwriters in the R&B/soul genre.
Tori can easily duplicate a Mariah run.
@@chikoritaleaf Dude. Open up your mind. You're stuck in the same argument. To better drive my point across, let's put vocals aside for a moment.
When Mariah came out, her style NEW. It was FRESH. And people wanted MORE. Just think about Britney, Avril, Christina, Beyonce, Lady Gaga, Katy Perry, Justin Bieber, Adelle, Miley Cyrus, Taylor Swift, Selena Gomez, Ariana, Demi, Billie Eilish, Olivia Rodrigo, etc... Many of them are vocal powerhouses, bit some are not. Some more successful than others. However, they all exploded when they came out. Because they took a RISK. And they brought something NEW and FRESH. That made you want to listen to them over and over and made you want be like them. And they become your icons and legends, because they have greatly influenced your life.
These days, many people can SING. And I mean REALLY SING. Vocals can only get you so far. You won't fly to the top of the charts JUST BECAUSE you can sing.
For me:
1._Mariah carey is more creative and uses her agility in alot of areas, lows, chest, mix, head, falsetto and Whistle, Tori could be as agile as Mariah but she has more control over her falsetto than in others areas.
2._Ariana use her falsetto better and she has more control over it but Christina has the most beautifull falsetto that i've ever heard.
3._Beyoncé just better technique and Less tension, Whitney's voice is more beautifull and loud but she often has alot of tension, sometimes it sounds like shouty and become thin as she goes high.
Great video, next time try to use better examples for everyone❤
Christina has more control in falsetto.
@@xmantrans4846 Xtina doesn’t, LOL. She sounds pitchy, LOL.
@@benjaminbawa5273 ariana cant do what christina can do in falsetto and thats her past her prime what more when she was in arianas age. You really think ariana can do what christina did in auld lang sine without breaking her jaw? Then you’re just a biased fan. Cause ariana can’t compete with christinas falsetto especially the complexity of her runs/control on that register compared to arianas simple ones
@@xmantrans4846 I’m actually a Mariah/Beyoncé fan, I only type truth. I’m sorry you don’t like to hear the truth. 🤷🏻♂️
So screaming in that register is what Xtina can do better than Ariana? 💀
Sometimes, doing little is much. Let Christina unlearn to learn. Her techniques are very unhealthy. 🤷🏻♂️
Wow christinas falsetto and her agility on it is freaking amazing… she won that
Never compare Mariah's runs with someone else. The completeness of her agility and the musicality with which she inserts each run almost imperceptibly into her songs is pure art. She is the quintessential melismatic singer, the Golden Standard and anyone in this video would agree
*1st Battle:* Mariah
*2nd Battle:* Christina
*3rd Battle:* Whitney
When it comes to *Tori & Mariah's* vocal agility, Tori's riffs & runs put her in that untouchable league with that Mariah, Beyonce, Debelah Morgan, Jazmine Sullivan etc.
Mariah's extraordinary ability in transitions, octave jumps plus cramming countless riffs and runs into songs in such a seamless manner, in addition to how she utilizes staccato is what puts her above Tori and in fact most vocalists in mainstream music. Let's just say, she has a more arsenal in her festive vocal agility purse.
Tori has a lot of useable range; that combined with her exceptional agility & musicality, there's still a ton of untapped potential with her.
*Christina Aguilera's* is more skilled in her falsetto than *Ariana Grande;* she's more consistent with it eg. quite a number of "Everyday" D6's get the best of Ariana. In addition to that, Christina is more agile in it, even at the highest parts of it.
Christina is the Queen of Falsetto in mainstream music, Ariana is a resident princess of Falsetto in mainstream music.
When it comes to belts, Whitney takes it. She is technically stronger than Beyonce in this area. Yeah I said it. Not even because she supports higher (some will say it's because Beyonce is a Mezzo-Soprano, apparently the verdict is still out on that).
Whitney has more TA development and engagement plus she's consistently more resonant.
Beyonce is definitely a technical vocalist however so is Whitney and in this area, her technique is stronger plus the bonus of the inherent characteristics of her voice amplifies the superior technical development she already has in this area.
you’re very right here
(For the sake of others who may read this, when I use the word resonance, I am referring to “squillo”) Whitney has more TA development along with the fact that she opts to use a more pharyngeal placement as opposed to Beyoncé’s use of mask placement. Nothing wrong with that, it’s just that pharyngeal resonance is generally preferred. Wonder why this video stopped at E5 with them though. Whitney takes C5 and E5 while Beyoncé takes Eb5 but I give a tie on C# simply because Beyoncé opted for that pharyngeal placement there and it was just as resonate as Whitney’s. I find that as Beyoncé’s voice matures, she’s transitioning from mask placement and to a more pharyngeal sound which is allowing her to be more resonate. You can hear that she began to use pharyngeal placement back in 2009 while singing this very song(halo), since then, most of her belts below C#5s have been with this placement.
Edit: I forgot to mention D5, I didn’t really like either of them but Whitney raising her shoulders and leaning back created tension therefore I’ll give it to Beyoncé.
-Also, the verdict isn’t really out on being being a mezzo, that’s been determined already and is quite undeniable by now.
@@allthingspage1498 🥰
@@LiTim17 Well said, I appreciate your comment!
I would give Eb5 to Beyonce based on the particular clips that were used but after th-cam.com/video/-CbOBgfIevk/w-d-xo.htmlm51s Eb5 goes to Whitney. Mind you, she doesn't use an echo for creating the effect of a larger sound (carrying over more).
th-cam.com/video/-Lze7UQSBpk/w-d-xo.htmlm31s - I'm rather hearing less resonance from her these days.
@@GarageStudio7 yes, it’s often a battle between those two on this specific note. Both are beats on it, so it’s really hard to give it to either one honestly.
As for hearing less resonance, I disagree, the clip you sent was really compressed, here is a raw recording th-cam.com/video/MaCHEQzeXQw/w-d-xo.html . Now, I will definitely say that during that performance she was really vulnerable and that gave room for imperfections such as her Eb5s.
Mariah is human and therefore touchable. Literally a fact that's well known. If you can't accept that no singer is untouchable than there's no hope of having a productive debate about the abilities of different vocalists.
Yah tellem they have to know that tori is just as good or even better
Honestly people can get so defensive
yes it’s clear they favor mariah more and havent really seen what tori is capable of/what she can do vocally.
Exactly. Mariah’s tone is amazing and unique but many singers are technically as good as her.
Yeah she’s touchable but to me she clearly won this battle, her riffs and runs actually fits the melody of the song and her musicality is unmatched.
How could you not include "OveeeeEeEeeeEeeeEeeeEeeeeEeeeeEeeeeeEEEEEeeer, then loooooove with lead the waaaaahhhaaaaAaaaaaayeeeeaaaaay" 😂🥺
Exactly! That alone can win over every mainstream vocalist on Earth 😭
@@drewm.2790 haha, right?!
Mind you that all the melodies and composed melisma which Mariah sings are HERS and everyone else was later inspired by her.
She was inspired by Aretha, and Karen Clark Sheard
Mariah (not the best clips though), Ariana and Whitney
Fr they picked some garbage clips for Mariah and Whitney like queens be going off
I just even typed this, so true.
@fishriah Mariah outsold kelly in terms of runs even not in her best. Just like I did to you 😎😎😎
@@DaydreamCarey1234 🤨
Tori is a great singer, amazing vocals, range, runs etc...but Mariah is queen and paid her dues over the last 30 years....we all know who wins this hands down
tori wins on every level cant change my mind
A great teacher and a perfect student. This is.
Not some of y'all thinking agility is only about riffs and runs 💀
If we're talking about the fluidity among registers, Ariana must have one great AGility.
Exactly 😩
It's a battle of vocal agility ie. not just riffs and runs, but also staccato, trills, transitions, octave jumps etc.
*Mariah takes it.*
Well that's mostly what they're about and that's what most people including myself thought unless your a music technician or a vocal coach etc other than that that's all I thought they were tbh which is clearly what both Mariah and tori do on a daily basis tbh😊
@@alexandraanderson3988 I understand, many people are ill-informed about Vocal Agility. It's similar to one thinking that vocal dynamics are solely crescendos.
besides technique, runs etc… It’s just Mariah’s tone for me 🥲✨
tori's amazing , hands down the best singer of this generation when it comes to riffs and runs but she has no vision of love msg moments for instance, mariah's agility is unmatched and her runs are by far the most complex ones in pop/rnb music, idk why ppl still have doubts about it, ,mariah was serving impossible runs in her first year of career at the age of 20 (see vanishing snl reharsal in 1990) and kept serving impossibly complex runs for years, her runs are not just made of quick notes or scales, mariah's runs are complex not only because of the insane amount of notes that are in them but also because of her ability to switch register so flawlessly that you can't even hear the flip from chest to head voice/falsetto or even whistle register sometimes, also not to mention her musicality and how she could do an octave jump out of nowhere and make it sound pleasent and intricated
Tori, Xtina and Whitney for me
But they’re all awesome
Oh mariah and her voice is just really a gift from God but torri kelly is very talented i mean, really2 talented.
Runs and riffs: I'd say Mariah and Tori kelly had the same agillity skills in terms of speed, precision, pitch, musicallity and complexity. But there is something more in Mariah's runs. The way she construct them rlly fits the song she's singing, song genre that she's singing and also have alot of types of patterns, style or type of runs/riffs. While tori is mostly just ascending and descending (well some others were different styles tho) And also Mariah's is less show offy while also having a great complex long runs it does not seem like she's showing them off. (such as lead the way run) And mostly Mariah is comfortable in every register when doing runs and riff (well tori too) but Mariah is still more comfy. So I'm going to Mariah's Vocal agillity
Falsettos: I prefer xtina's falsetto (ariana did supper rr great dahhling) but xtina's comfort in her falsetto and I think it's also more consistent and also she's more confident doing it (for me) and xtina's falsetto can be powerful and light too. Also her vibrato in that register Is also great. And her agillity in that register is much mre better compared to ariana (but ariana' s agillity in that register is also rlly great).
Belting: Whitney houston ofcourse. She's besically queen of belts Beyonce's belts were rlly great but whitney's power and resonance in her belts were rlly great. And also her vibrato in the belts were always present from Tom to bottom and always smooth and healthy. Her tone and support and consistency in her belts were also great. While Beyonce is like student belter and Whitney is the teacher belter. But Beyonce belts were great it has a great smooth healthy vibrato from top to bottom. Also has a powerful belt with ease in upper belts. And also consistent. But Whitney's belt it alot more bettercomlared to Beyonce for me.
(it is just my opinions dahhling)
I think Mariah's musicality and creativity is simply superior.
Tori is absolutely amazing too but dawlinnnggg MARIAH FOR THE WIN!!! Queen of riffs and runs- I dont think she's everrr overdone it. Her improv is also just so smooth and i really like that (listen to "Lead The Way"- it's so pleasant to the ear💞). Tori is honestly great, but in some instances, she may push her talent too far and it doesn't sound very nice..NO SHADE JUST OPINON- LOVE THEM BOTH🐑💓
Next up~ Xtina honeyyy, I LOVE YOU BUT IM SORRY ARI ATE🖤 Her tone is just more angelic and she has a bit more ease with it. I STILL SEE YOU Christina!!! I think you'll have the most perfect falsetto if you just simmer a bit- let your voice flow out and maintain that control at the same time👍Anyways- ILL ALWAYS BE UR LOYAL FAN XOXO
LASTLY~ no questions asked. Whitney. PERIODT. But to be honest yes Beyonce is the moment..........but Whitney has been and always will be regarded as the greatest singer of all time. Brighter than any star in the sky in my opinion. Her belts are effortless yet so intense and passionate it doesnt make sense. Thank you Whitney- for sharing your heavenly voice with us. May you rest in peace❤
Just wanted to share my thoughts- maybe even change someone's perspective? Hope so💓💓
Lol it’s clear in the video christina has a better falsetto and has more complex runs if ariana were to do that auld lang sine falsetto run she would break her jaw
Mariah wins in every category. Her voice is glorious. Period.
1. Mariah Carey - Runs
2. Cristina Aguillera - Falsetto
3. Whitney Houston - Belting
Mimi, X and Whitney
Both amazing! Queens of melisma
I think at this standard it really is splitting hairs, most of it is going to be down to personal preference.
Based on these clips alone. I think Mariah's melisma here are more creative and Tori's (to me) seem a bit more polished and have more ease to them. I think I'm gonna go with Mariah though, the level of difficulty and creativity wins it for me.
Xtina wins against Ariana. They're both fantastic and it's pretty close however I think Christina is more agile in this area and is able to manipulate the dynamic better. I also think she's more creative with hers.
Beyonce wins in the third round for me. Whitney is very chest heavy and to me it comes across as a bit "shouty" and loses that great tonal quality she has especially when it goes higher, whereas Beyonce is more varied in her approach (changing the balance of her mix) and generally retains brightness in her voice whilst still maintaining a great depth.
These are some very close competitors and like I said before I think it's all going to come down to personal preference.
Some people are going to attack you bc you chose Bey over Whitney 😔🥲
What? Whitney is the one who maintains the depth as she ascends lol, show me Beyoncé doin an F#5 with the same amount of core like Whitney did in you give good love, or a G5 with the same amount of core that she in i am changing
@@mooblink4ever899 She’s more agile than Whitney, At least she showcases it more imo
@@audreyf9092 never, i have never seen beyonce sing 34 notes in 4 seconds
@@Das644 both sopranos, Whitney was a higher one, and im talking about belting not mixing, Whitney was the stronger belter period
Mariah always and forever ❤
However everyone here is great, amazing and discipline top-tier singers.
1° - i love queen mariah but tori slaaaay so hard.
2° Christina is a master but Ariana take my breath away. She has more control and tone .
3° Whitney... without any coments
8:27 I’m sorry but this just doesn’t sound good to me at all… it sounds squeezed and very tiny. Almost like that of a mosquito. I get that she wants to show off her range, but in instances I personally wouldn’t do that, I’d stick to what sounds pleasing.
It even sounds like a dog to me like where is the tone honey 😭
oh my god Tori is insane!!! 😍😍😍
1st Battle: Mariah Carey
2nd Battle: Ariana Grande
3rd Battle: Whitney Houston
Why is Ariana 😢😮 in the middle in between two of the so called Greats 😅😊❤ as you guys would say I'm sorry 😔😐 but get her out she shouldn't be there put somebody else i guess lmaoo no offense just saying!!!
Agree!
@@alexandraanderson3988ohhh don’t even. Ariana is incredible.
mariah. xtina. whitney. xx
In term, their vocal agility is good but Mariah's still better
The 2nd clip of Ariana she sounds like a flautist omg
She really does it’s crazy
Why it gotta be a competition? These women are amazing in their own way.
1st round: Mariah
- Mariah easily takes this. Agility includes transitions, octave jumps, trills, staccatos and musicality aside from riffs/ runs and she’s superior in all those areas.
2nd round: Ariana
- Ariana’s tone in this register is just so angelic especially in 6:22 where she sounds more like a flute than a human. Ease and agility in it I’d say is tie with Xtina but she wins in tone and musicality
3rd round: Whitney
- a close one because Bey’s belts are also crazy good but it’s also Whitney’s strongest feat that’s just unmatched. Heavenly resonant tone, insane power and dynamics so she wins this
Tori, Ariana, Whitney
Great video!
Oh god no, this isn’t it
I'd have to say Tori is more agile. She rarely, if ever, has a bad vocal. Mariah has had some misses when singing live and has been quite shaky. She's much better than Tori is many other ways (belting, tone, maybe even melismas, but agility? No. Tori has never had a bad vocal. I prefer Ariana's falsetto - she can do more. Her rendition of Emotions alone takes the case. And Whitney's just the queen of belting. I would've even preferred to pair Beyonce and Tori up with agility. That would've been a good battle, cause these 2, especially now, never miss a note.
The thing is melisma(which is just runs and riffs) is a part of what makes up agility. Tori may slightly edge out Mariah when it comes to pitch but Mariah does more intricate and creative runs and can showcase the same speed in every register. She also has the best transitions in contemporary music. So overall Tori is not more agile, which isn’t a bad thing… she’s still the most agile vocalist of this generation and can definitely be considered in the same caliber as Mariah when it comes to agility but she is not above
@@kingjuicy3023 I definitely see where ur coming from. Mariah is exceptional. For me, I just think Tori is more consistent. Which for me, is a part of agility. Its not just doing complex riffs and runs. And agility is more than riffs and runs. Its about accuracy, consistency and healthy singing technique. MC is not always as accurate, consistent or has the most healthiest singing technique sometimes. Especially after 1998. I give Tori the edge there. MC is more agile in the studio, but Tori is more agile live. I'd put my money on Tori executing a one take vocal with less errors over MC.
@@6ixboss608 It's a battle of vocal agility ie. not just riffs and runs, but also staccato, trills, transitions, octave jumps etc.
*Mariah takes it.*
Of course she will have mishaps, Mariah has been singing since the 90's She is the Greatest Vocalist!
@@6ixboss608 tori also inconsistent throughout her run . Just check all her concert . They all not outdid the studio one . She missed a lot
Tori is probably more agile than Mariah tbh. But Mariah is agile in every register, and has superior musicianship. Her runs feel part of the music while you can tell Tori is trying to showcase her agility (rightfully so!) Also, thank you for using post-prime Mariah clips!
For me I’d have to give it to Tori, Ariana, and Whitney! Everyone here is an amazing vocalist no doubt about that regardless of preference 😄
Xtina D6 tho always get me
Mariah, no question, nor a hard one.
I would go with Ariana on falsetto, although I think they are close enough.
When it comes to belts, noone wins Whitney, it's truly remarkable how she keeps her absolute strength and chestiness till the very highest note, I've never heard anyone other doing that so greatly, and still retaining her absolutely beautiful tone!!
Xtina ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
Mariah, Xtina and Beyoncé
Beyoncé over Whitney??
@@somestevenuniversewell it's my personal opinion
@@somestevenuniverse in terms of agility, yes
@@jeromewilson1048 it was about belting, not agility, Whitney is obviously the stronger belter
@@christiancolo7768 I'm a Beyhive l but I agree 👍 Whitney is a stronger belter but I feel like bey is more smooth and pleasant to my ears.
for me, Tori is the new generation of diva
Mariah creativity is insane everything she does on point, Tori is so good but her runs sounds almost the same
Almost the same? I don't think so
Tori vs Mariah: I preferred Tori. She has much better note separation than Mariah and and although Mariahs are slightly faster and a bit longer her note separation seems to suffer just as little bit. I think that her musically is slightly better however.
Ariana vs Xtina: I preferred Ariana. Now this is mostly a tonal preference which is subjective but I also think that Xtinas overall ease wasn’t as good as Ariana’s. The sound of “freeness” wasn’t as strong.
Whitney vs Beyoncé: Whitney. Period.
Isn't the music mostly stripped when Tori is doing her riffs and runs while Mariah's are infused in the music.
Tori are the best agility vocal
Ariana grande are the beautiful faseltto
Whitney Houston the voice
Why do we have to compare! They are all awesome!
Whitney and Beyonce sound perfect can't take one.
Never compare anyone with the Best female vocalist on Earth
Imagine tori kelly in her 30's
She just turned 29 a few weeks ago, a couple more years and she would be in her true vocal prime and we won’t be ready for the slayage 😯 And take into account if she has kids and how pregnancy would alter her voice...
She's already in her 30's now 😂😅😊❤ how is she doing??? Lmaoo
Mariah,Xtina and Whitney.
Personally I feel that Tori's live vocal runs are much cleaner. Mariah's get a little muddy live. However, I love them both.
Vocal agility: Both are AMAZING but I'm going with Mimi (her runs are much more complex and her musicality is far superior to Tori's, even though Tori is creative with her runs too ❤️). Both riff just as fast as the other and both Mimi's and Tori's runs are incredibly precise. They're both almost always on key (I would say Tori is slightly better in the pitch aspect because Mariah has gone off key a couple of times when singing the Hero high note during the Daydream World Tour; she ended up hitting a flat G#5 instead of a G5... I'm not sure which night but I remember watching a video of her performing the song on tour where she went sharp)
Falsetto: Overall, I prefer Ariana's. But if you look at it objectively, Christina's agility in her falsetto (and her lower register, even though low notes don't matter in this case) is far superior to Ariana's (but that first riff that Ariana did... the one in Bang Bang; she SLAYYYYED us all there 😍). Her vibrato in the register is also much better than Ariana's. However, Ariana is more comfortable in the register because her voice sits higher than Christina's and she doesn't thin out until F6 while Christina sometimes thins out above D6.
Belting:
C5: Whitney (I love Bey but she was clearly using a lot of reverb)
C#5: Whitney
D5: Tie
Eb5: Whitney
E5: Tie
I agree with everything you said, but Christina doesn’t thin out at the note you said. D6 is still pretty comfortable for her. In her prime, she was still very strong on G#6 and A6.
When it comes to agility I think Tori is as agile as Mariah. She just is. They’re the most agile and precise vocalists I can think of. Christina can be as agile as them but can get sloppy more often. Having said that, I think Mariah is superior when it comes to musicality and creativity
Christina’s falsetto is the most beautiful in the business in my humble opinion. Ariana is great too but she just doesn’t have the same charm.
Regarding belts…do I really have to say it? Come on.
It's a battle of vocal agility ie. not just riffs and runs, but also staccato, trills, transitions, octave jumps etc.
*Mariah takes it.*
Tori's riffs and runs display that she still has a lot of untapped potential.
@@GarageStudio7 Tori has proved to be more than capable of recreating what Mariah can do. The only thing Mariah does that I don’t see Tori doing is the transition from chest voice to whistle. Everything else, Tori can do.
Still, I don’t think Tori tops Mariah when it comes to creativity, musicality and stylistic choices.
Does Mariah take it for me overall? Yes. Does Mariah take it on a technical level? No.
This doesn’t take anything away from Mariah, no need to get defensive.
@@rkngl807 th-cam.com/video/5heDgaQCSVE/w-d-xo.htmlm23s - Seamlessly transition from D6 in head voice to a belt
th-cam.com/video/5Rs6TwjeaDo/w-d-xo.html - 3 note appogiatura for 6 secs (53 notes) one breath, upper 6th octave.
And in case you want more:
th-cam.com/video/oL0gc7UWSiY/w-d-xo.html
It's not about being defensive but let's actually consider things that can be proven.
You're saying that she's capable of creating anything that Mariah can do and the only thing you haven't seen are chest to whistle transitions, but as I have shown, there's a lot more that she is incapable of doing. At least based on what we've seen thus far.
Complex riffs and runs, yes they both have that. Natalie Weiss can break it down and teach people, it may not be easy but one can grasp it. But these vocal feats that Mariah has shown are on a whole other level.
@@GarageStudio7 well, obviously Tori is nowhere near to Mariah’s proficiency in the whistle register, that goes without saying. Whistles taken aside, I still think Tori is capable of doing.
Regarding the first clip: I know it sounds like head voice in the beginning but I believe it was a belt distorted by the audio. It’s like the audio settings they used made the overtones extremely loud and so it sounded kinda like head voice.
@@rkngl807 Has she done things like that in head voice then?
In all the other versions of the first clip it sounds the same. Plus that didn't happen with any other belts.
Also, in that part of the song she always uses an upper register note. She doesn't hit upper belts there.
XTINA MY GODDDD😍😍
poor choice of clips , Mariah's runs on My All live in Italy and Australia outid any Tori runs
AND the lead the way run also beats any Tori run
@@drewm.2790 yessss
In my opinion,
First Battle!
#Mariah vs #Tori: Both are INCREDIBLE songwriters, vocalists, and talented. I LOVE them BOTH sooooo much.♥️ However, l choose Mariah for the win.♥️
Second Battle!
#Christina vs #Ariana: Tbh, l prefer Christina more. I LOVE her music, voice and her vocals. Better singer and has better falsetto.♥️ l like her more.♥️ l don’t like Ariana at all. (No offence!😅)
Third Battle!
#Beyoncè vs #Whitney: Oh, that was a hard one to choose. My first and second FAVOURITE female singers.♥️♥️♥️ however, as much as l LOVE Beyoncé, l choose Whitney, even though l LOVE her just as much.♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️ l LOVE them BOTH so much.♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️
Great video! xD ♥️
It baffles me that ears hear Mariah as the superior riffer 🤔 I think people only say that because "she's Mariah"...it is as clear as day that Tori is superior in riffing, and it's not a small difference either. Sound does not support the lie that Mariah is better. You LIKE her more, and that's fine, but she is not better than Tori. Come on now 🤷
finally someone hears me.. as a trained jazz pianist myself, tori is absolutely insane with her complexity and runs compared to mariah.. tori, christina, jasmin they are incredible when it comes to agility. mariah is boring and repetitive and musically her runs dont really make that much sense within context
Exactly like Mariah has untouchable runs 80% of the time while Tori's runs are untouchable 95% of the time
@@justevaded Mariah’s runs doesn’t make sense musically? She literally has the best runs musicality wise in the industry just say you hate her and go lmao
@@drewm.2790 i have no hate towards her, her music doesn't appeal to me and i am most of the times not impressed by her runs. simple as that.
It's a battle of vocal agility ie. not just riffs and runs, but also staccato, trills, transitions, octave jumps etc.
*Mariah takes it.*
niceeee
Mariah's agility in the lower register makes no sense, definitely unsupported!!!!! Toni Braxton and Xtina have the best agility in the lower register. Great projection and tone as well. I think Tori's agility is faster, like alienish, but Mariah can do more! Especially in the mid range and whistle register. Ofc Christina has a better falsetto, angelic, and when she uses it, she always does acrobatics with it. Whitney's belting is more memorable. When the tone of the voice is quite generic, like Beyonce's, I'd not care whether she belts or not. Out of all 6, Whitney and Christina are most known for belting, the rest mix a lot... and ofc loose the power of the note.
Love Xtina but she’s not known for belting in a positive light. Also Toni Braxton is doing the same thing Mariah is when she sings lower, albeit, she has a lower voice, it’s still the same.
I think you’re not making sense and talking just based in tone. Mariah is a soprano and you are comparing her with two mezzos in the lower register? Obviously hers will be more airy, but she keeps and incredibly fast agility down there which is incredible.
It's a battle of vocal agility ie. not just riffs and runs, but also staccato, trills, transitions, octave jumps etc.
*Mariah takes it.*
Idk the i ly thing i dislike abt christina her falsetto is she always goes flat and it sounds incontrolled.
Agility: Mariah
Falsetto: Ariana
Belting: Beyoncé they're both great i just like they way she belts more
Ariana’s falsetto is my favorite part of her voice besides high belts.
Nah christina for falsetto
Christina can do aris falsettos but ari can’t do christina falsettos with those complicated runs
@@xmantrans4846 Xtina’s falsetto is really great but there’s just something about the tone of Ariana’s
@@xmantrans4846 and you know she cannot do them how?
@@drewm.2790 agreed
Tje scariest thing i noticed about mariah was her riff n run is well- integrated to song n part of the melody... N most of them are so subtle. Unnoticeable unless u try to sing it to her original
I would love to collaborate on a remake of this video. I’m a lamb and I could get you much better clips for Mariah dahhling!
The thing is that Mariah does it to express while Tori does it to impress. Mariah wins!
Tori does it to express too 😢😮❤ I guess 😂 you're not a big fan of her 😅😊 to know that because she's amazing too Tori lmaoo
no you got it all wrong in my opinion ive never heard tori over sing and all her ad libs riffs and runs fit the melody and mood of the songs she sings every time. i recommend you dive into her live performances esp. her newer ones for example her live performance ‘in times like these’
Mariah vs Toir: U could say either and u would be correct. Personally I think Mariahs are slightly more just different and creative. I mean both re but something about Mariah's just seems different and almost like unheard of. Like when I watch a vid on her agility all her runs are well executed, creative, and for some reason just sound so distinctive and again creative. Like she play with her voice a lot when riffing and running like she can go softer, go more fuller and powerful adding belts and stuff, g for a more piercing bird kinda sound with her whistles, or for a more bright and pretty tone with her head voice and falsetto. For musicality both again would be correct. Toris are very creative and her runs fit the song (whtv it is) very wel almost if not every time. They are well executed and just perfectly fit the rhythm, key, and vibe. Whether it be gospel, pop, rnb, or whtv other genre. mariah is the same. Her runs always fit the songs, rhythm, and vibe no matter what genre. Both can really change up their runs and adapt them to whtv the genre is like I said whether its gospel, pop, hip-hop, rnb, more ballad slow kinda feel, or anything else. Overall I will honestly just say tie (maybe tori SLIGHTLY actually). Finally speed and precision. AGAIN both would be correct. For speed Mariah can be extremely fast when she wants to and when she does well she can really RUN. Like its hard to see how many notes she actually hits sometimes cause she be going so fast. Tori is the same. She can be extremely fast (if not faster than Mariah at times). Tori is honestly more consistently fast tbh as she is like always doing very fast and quick runs while mariah CAN and HAS but not as often as Tori. She mostly alternates between fast and medium paced runs. I mean tori does as well but she is mostly faster. Precision I will just say a tie bcuz both ladies even when going hella fast always hit every single note. Overall I will say both are kidna just equal. Mariah has the edge (imo) for creativity and versatility, while tori takes speed and musicality, and they both tie in precision. I will say They are both equally great. TIE!
Christina vs Ari: Now a lot of ppl consider chirstina the queen of falsetto and i get why but lets see. Personally I prefer aris tone. christinas is really good but aris is brighter and sweeter which is what i prefer.range would be either one of them. i think christina has gone higher like a g6. not sure if it was whistle or falsetto but i'll just say it was falsetto. Overall I prefer aris falsetto but either one would be correct imo. ARI (imo)
Whitney vs Beyonce. Okay look Beyonce is amazing she is great especially at belting. they are powerful, full, have a nice vibrato, well sustained and supported and overall just great. but imo Whitney is one of the best belters ever (or atleast in pop/mainstream music). to me she is top 10 if not top 6 or 5. she is just amazing. the power, vibrato, ease, sustaining of the note and just her tone and the way she hits the notes is just impeccable. Especially when it comes to mid belts she is literally ONE OF THE BEST. Few can match her in the mids. even in the upper parts she still holds her own with that power and vibrato. Now this isn't to say that Beyonce is WAY behind whitney cause she ain't she still one of the best fo this gen if not one of the best in mainstream pop and music of the past few decides. but she just ain't as good as whitney.
No hate but the creator of the video actually didnt put many of mariahs most impressive runs. Also tori kelly is phenomenal but very likely to over sing. Technically both are amazing, the best in my humble opinion, mariah is more pleasing to the ears so I ll say mariah
In falsetto, both are amazing but personal preference is christina.
Belting wise, I dont know why the creator of the video chose beyonce against whitney. It would be better if they chose someone like lara fabian, sohyang or natalie Weiss against whitney. Dont get me wrong, beyonce is one of the best of her time but in terms of belting, Whitney is much much better specially if we look at both of their primes.
Tori is one of the very few top tier vocalists to not over sing 😭 In fact, I’m always left craving for more
Lol Lara and natalie against Whitney I don't know🥴 I personally don't know natalie that well as an artist at all but she seems more like riff and run type of person and Lara seems like she has more of a softer voice don't know her personally as an artist either but these two don't seem to be like the belting type of people.🤷🏾♀️
vocal agility: I like them both, they are the best representatives of how vocal agility should be used, but they use different styles that few people comment on. it's not all about speed, and it's here that things get diversed. I think Tori's faster than Mariah, but the subtle and intricate way that Mariah uses her runs in the middle of the songs make me fell in love with her. Tori uses her runs almost like the climax of her songs, always in evidence while she sings. Not wrong, it's incredible, but I prefer Mariah.
falsetto: Definitely Ariana. Ariana's falsetto it's very polished, probably the best part of her voice, the tone it's incredible, like her control. Christina have a good falsetto too, but sometimes get that scratchy sound that annoys me a little. Both great, but I prefer Ariana.
Belting: Both of them are "star level" in belting, and it's really hard to say who's better for me. I would say Beyoncé because I prefer the way she uses her belts in R&B songs, but they are equally perfect.
@0:51-pitchy @0:58- the whole run is pitchy @1:53 do I even have to say anything… I did love her proceeding run @1:55 tho, otherwise all are verryyyy pitchy and Mariah often does very glissando or pitchy runs. Whoever says she’s “untouchable” in this category is a Stan. There were much better agile singers during her prime. Honestly Whitney and Beyoncé slayed the agility category as well
Christina Aguilera the most great vocalist ❤
First battle Tori for sure, without question.. second battle Christina, third battle Whitney!
I agree with 2/3. Whitney and Beyoncé are a harsh tie..maybe I don’t know yet
When it comes to agility the 3 greatest of all time IMO is Mariah, Beyonce and Tori Kelly
1: Mariah
2: Christina
3: Whitney
Lol No its Whitney before christina in my opinion
@@alexandraanderson3988they just selecting who dud better in each category , whitney was last so they chose her as the winner in the last category
@@MommyyriahOh okay 👌👍😅😊
Tori, Christina, Whitney
Tori is very much just barely passing but she’s got a lot of room to grow.
I think Mariah’s runs are more interesting at times but Tori’s got the agility and technique down pat.
In my opinion:
1. Melisma - I feel like Tori wins in this department. Tori's runs are just as fast as Mariah's. The main difference I hear is Tori's runs are a lot more precise, clean, & consistent. Mariah sometimes got lost in the sauce causing her to loose pitch and become sloppy. I have yet to hear a bad run from Tori so yeah.
2. Head Voice - Christina definitely wins in this area. Ariana has a great tone, but she's no where as creative as Christina.
3. Belting - I think Beyonce takes it (with the clips given), but I do think as a whole Beyonce is a lot more refined when it comes to belting. Whitney can sometimes sing with valsalva and her vibrato did her no favors. Beyonce doesn't really have as many issues. She does stay in her comfort zone for the most part, but when she does go above F5 it's not too bad.
C5 - Beyonce
C#5 - Whitney
D5 - Beyonce
Eb5 - Tie
E5 - Whitney
Mariah's are just so subtle that you don't notice just how many notes she can actually sing. Her runs are sloppy, just extremely subtle and smooth. She can also sing very precise and clean runs too. Her runs are also much more musical and has more musicality to them as well.
I disagree on the Melisma...
Tori is VERY technical but the lower part of her range when doing so is thin and not as supported. The emotional quality is not there as well, and sounds very mechanical. Mariah's is very clean, but depending on the style and song choice...it will NOT always be a very clear run because it IS NOT SUPPOSED TO BE. Most people think that every run needs to be "clean," but if you know anything about R&B, jazz, gospel, etc. You will know that. But what seperates the two here is that every aspect of Mariah's range has body of sound, resonance, and clarity, as opposed to Toris range. So again, I disagree in my professional opinion as an artist teacher, musician, and technician. Feel free to speak with me over this, but I think a lot of times, us who "critique and judge" are basing what we hear off of our experiences, priority lists, and knowledge of music. Musicality outweighs technique any day for me.
Mariah Carey 1st, 2nd- infinity and beyond. Anyone else is after infinity 😆
Daydream Mariah is the perfect singer! But other than that I feel Tori Kelly takes the cake!! Coz she never misses....Mariah does infact...they're so good that just 1 lil note here n there makes all the difference.
Ari and Xtina are pretty equal in terms of falsetto and
Bey is technically flawless ut Whitney's voice was made to belt so I'd say:
1) Dayream Mariah > Tori > Anyother Mariah
2) Ari = Xtina ( I prefer Ari's tone so, for me it's her)
3) Whitney (Bey is there technically but Whitney was a natural)
Whitney and Mariah >>>>> Seriously, they are the best in pretty much every register
Mariah
Ariana
Whitney
Personally, Mariah, Ariana, and Whitney.
I agree
Tori’s creativity wins in my opinion, she always changes her runs up and her runs are way clearer to hear than Mariah. She is honestly the best singer of this time in my opinion
Lol ...Mariah is 1000 Times superior
hell no lol Tori’s runs are on the same level of Mariah’s in terms of complexity, speed and precision but when it comes to creativity and musicality she’s nowhere near Mariah, sorry. She just isn’t.
@@rkngl807 creativity wise, tori wins. mariah’s agility is slightly better but her runs/riffs have a certain pattern which she uses in every song, just with a different approach
@@chanieee9566 no babes, it’s literally the other way around. Also, every singer has some signature runs/riffs but the “pattern” thing is just bs that you’ve read from a hater’s comment under this video.
@@chanieee9566 this is a lie! Y’all get on this internet and say the stupidest shit lol