FM Nirmala Fights With Cong's Kharge Over Budget Jibe I Parliament Showdown
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 15 ต.ค. 2024
- Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman had a fiery faceoff with Leader of Opposition in Rajya Sabha Mallikarjun Kharge after he fired 'Mata, pakoda and jalebi' jibes over budget. Kharge said that the budget was just for the allies to save the government. To which, Nirmala gave a strong reply. Watch.
#nirmalasitharaman #rajyasabha #mallikarjunkharge #budget2024 #trending #latestnews #parliament #bhartiyajantaparty #indiannationalcongress
Subscribe to The Times of India's TH-cam channel: goo.gl/WgIatu
For daily news & updates and exclusive stories, follow the Times of India
Facebook:
/ timesofindia
Instagram:
/ timesofindia
Download the app: toi.in/3SLUCa80
Follow the TOI WhatsApp channel: bit.ly/3RYl0J9
Follow TOI+ for well-researched and in-depth news and analysis
Facebook:
/ timesofindiaplus
Twitter:
/ toiplus
Instagram:
/ toi_plus
All politicians are same...middle class will always remain middle class..you are here to pay taxes and in return you will get zero facilities...infact you will provide houses and schemes to other people 😂😂
WE HAVE ELECTED DAYLIGHT DEPENDENT PROFESSIONAL BEGGARS LOOTING PUBLIC MONEY so DON'T WORRY BEHAPPPPPPY
Delhi Mumbai expressway kis ke liye?
Ham subko
where are you boss, Middle Class is no more, worried and stressed about EMIs and Shcoo Fees all the time.
@@Delhikeladke277 Middle class people should form "Middle class associations" and show thenga to all govt..those who ignore and harras us since 50 yrs
I feel middle class will not be even middle class in future thanks to the government policies and taxes..not seen even a single rupee increase in salaries since 10 yrs. ... The young generation is screwed.
Jilebi was Epic Khargeji 🎉🎉😂😂😂
@@liberaladda4922 Good
BJP IS GOING DOWN! THAT AN EXAMPLE.
Btw who lost recent election 🤣 Mr. Andhbhakt
Keep dreaming. Looks like you expecting Congress pimps back in the capital and it wont happen.
@@sohini-m6d Not just budget, RaGa & his alliance has been caught saying, they wud make fake propaganda for any development by Govt to keep the country divided. Imagine why they are silent about NEET when 3 people were caught red handed from a minority group. Why they didn't revealed their connection with Soros. If anyone reads current budget in detail, all benefits to states are covered. What is shared in house are just the high level highlights as the time to speech is limited. If you watch all the previous budget sessions of the Opp party in last 20yrs they have'nt even uttered any state name. Opp should play a constructive role and not just play minority appeasement politics. Look at what KA has become with new minority appeasement Budgets & Bills.
@@cafeindiana8570 he's actually a l@#$bhakt, pappu ka 😂
Except her language she is a doll for BJP.
She doesn't have a guts to oppose amith sha.
What you are talking, oppose anything..... Means India. Won't give chance for blast.
I can feel your pain... Because you didn't get free Haj allowance like in Karnataka.. 🎉😂 please understand eating too much for free is also haram
@@harishgandham4946 karnataka is part of India and kerala is part of saudi arabia!?
What a joke😝
Open your eyes and see that the kerala is develeped by LDF and UDF by the gulf money.
the badamia and chota mia is doing everithyng for gujarat and kerala sangees are happies and never become near to kerala after 500year.
@@mohammedashrafabdulkader3774 Kerala got developed by gulf money 🤑💰 what a joke.. this clear cut case of mental break down. People like you should sent to Saudi.. you good for licking some sheikhs ass
You Islamists are the only reason ,I'm supporting BJP.. Congress's Muslim appeasement is unbearable
India doesn't need FM
Arrogance+ Ignorance= Nirmal a Sitharaman
Any comments on scamster Chiddu 😅
@@cafeindiana8570whos is chiddu😅
@@padiyar83 MMS/Pranab M could be called better, not the scamster Chiddu. He & his son has ongoing 21 criminal cases ongoing FYI 😂
Then you did not know anything about previous Congress UPA FM. Learn about them. Current Nirmalaji is 100000 times better.
2g,3g commonwealth scam their hallmark.
This type of behavior of the FM is unacceptable . Worst FM.
Pls say something about Chiddu's 21 ongoing criminal cases. 🤣
Behavior of FM is not the issue here
She is so fair
@@cafeindiana8570No time for your nonsense
Even RSS supremo had mentioned about many Minister Arrogance and people also voted against such candidates
Mr. Subramanyam swamy should have been the Finance minister. He's the right person for this position.
LOL... SWAMY AS ANY MINISTER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!...
😄😂😆😁
@dipakchoudhuri4629 no, he was telling that he will abolish income tax
What foolishness
Worst finance minister
The worst and most Corrupt FM of free India is P Chidambaram of Congress party
@@ytrm0904 worst comentator
This FM led the country to 5th largest economy in the world.
Ur curses will turn into boon/ bonanja by the hard work done by the NDA govt.
Shameless comment
Smt Sitaraman - when she speaks it is professional and very well versed… but when Khargeji speaks, it seems he had never been to school
Arrogance was the reason why Ravan died.. What to expect from a FM who says mein lassan piyaz nahi khati... She forgot budget is for the country and not for her home..
She seems like the devil incarnate
Worst FM
Even worst was Chiddu. Check the history dude with 2G, 3G & CWG Scams
@bovikho@ MS.NIRMALA SEETHARAMAN IS THE BEST FINANCE MINISTER I HAVE EVER SEEN IN MY LIFE. I KNOW MR.P.C.CHIDAMBARAM WHO WAS UNFIT FOR THE POST OF FINANCE MINISTER DURING UPA REGIME. PLESSE DON'T COMPARE MS.NIRMALA SEETHARAMAN WITH ANY PREVIOUS FINANCE MINISTERS. IT IS RIDICULOUS.
do you able manage your home budget first? LOL.
That is only politically driver comment
Hellow Mr Karghe! You are the president of Congress party???
Then how come when ever you see anyone from Sonia family nearly 50 feet away you get up from your seat???? Shameful to the president post.😡
Mataji bolne me expert he...😂
Hare Krishna
Why is the speaker not allowing to speak
The lady is barking, does she bite 😂😂😂
Check your dad’s secret part 😅
She has cut it completely 😂
Looks like your family members are all in the category of barking! Isn't it? ROFL
are you listening on Sonia speech
It is not barking
It is an effective presentation by an intectually uplifted person
@@devimaya9133 ✅
Very good Kharge sab
Kharge was hungry that’s why he thought of pakodi and jalebi. That is the great President of Congress party.
BJP corporate minded
i dont think so. even that is better than Congress Scam minded.
Only Farmers and poor , who stays poor.
sorry criminal minded, not corporate
@@satish9912 looks like you don’t understand what is a criminal mind or corporate mind . Or you support the scamster group so you always see bjp in bad light
@@liv4nation781 does a poor farmer drives a bmw in punjab
Why she is barking after hearing the reality.
When Vinci shouts u people appreciate
Reality? READ the budget carefully you ILLITERATE SCUM-GRESSI slave. Bug off
@charumathisanthanam6783 yes we appreciate that gentleman.
Reality hurts
Hare Krishna
What Odisha got ? Double Engine BJP Sarakar in Odisha. ...but Nothing for Odisha. ....NO NEW RAILWAY FACTORY IN ODISHA SINCE 2014 Central BJP......
@@sunilkumarpatnaik6953 don't worry BEEHAPPY ONLY FOR SATHYAEMEVAJAYATHAE
@@sunilkumarpatnaik6953 why yyyyy laloooogandooo railway ministerooothaanaa uskaaa gaand dhokar bitaaathaaakyaa
@@sunilkumarpatnaik6953 yyyyyy lalooooogandoooo railway manthreeethaaanaa uskaaa gaand dhokar bitaaathaaa kyaaaa
What did Nouvin did ? For last 20yrs just 2-3% growth.. the KBK districts are still backward with 1.08% growth.Only 20-25% of the central funds were utillized for the PM development projects per CAG report. Where did the 80% funds go ?😂
@@cafeindiana8570 we ELECTED DAYLIGHT DEPENDENT PROFESSIONAL BEGGARS LOOTING PUBLIC MONEY FOR THERE WIVES AND CHILDREN'S DEVELOPMENTS so
DON'T WORRY BEHAPPPPPPY BOTTLE BIRIYANI 500//1000 THATSALL
The question is what has compelled Ms. Sitaraman to mention only two states leaving others !! She has no justified reply !! Mr. Kharge is right in his argument .
FM absolutely wrong this bagged saving seat nothing else
She has taken india for five years in the right direction
Just building port will not solve many problems of Maharashtra
Arrogance, and ignorance of the actual pain common man goes through, makes a bad leader. Raising voice and shouting does not prove any thing, but only demonstrates weakness hiding behind powerful party. These are the situations were Dr.Manmohan Singh demonstrated confidence and his leadership capabilities.
Very silly comment and personal attack from Khadgeji to Smt. Sitaraman…. Very pathetic being a party leader
వెనుక బడిన రాష్ట్రాల ఏమి అయిపోవాలి మేడం గారు బడ్జెట్ సరిగా లేదు
y are they behind???? first analuyse, just giving money will not help
@@boppanasasikumar5376you have brains did you even saw recent taxes? Do you even know how much debt are we in from the time Manmohan Singh left and last speech was we brought the economy here with all hardship bakwas karna nhi chahiye!
AP venkabadina raashtrame kada😂
Why’s she always arrogant? Did she forget she’s a public servant?
Useless budget..
sPeedo file p0pat Ma mmad follower ?
Great FM 👌🙏
This budget is for Andha and Bihar and Tamilnadu did not get anything in this budget
Why TN which claims to be much better developed by a dravidian model should get more.
They failed to use even Chennai drainage funds diverted to personal kitty
@@krishnanvenkatachari2059 we are talking about this budget .
@@krishnanvenkatachari2059 bcoz we pay more tax to the centre n we get nothing in return.
@@krishnanvenkatachari2059stop getting our money first😂they u can argue
@@krishnanvenkatachari2059pls go n read what they did with those flood relief funds. Don't educate urself with WhatsApp universities 😂
Mr Dhangad doesn't allow Mr Kharge to speak. Totally unfair
Tangdalna
Truly speaking speaker should not allow the Congress fools to speak and waste public money.
even if he allows what he is going to say except shouting and wasting time.
Hare Krishna
This budget, like historically, gave nothing to my state Karnataka. GST collected also is not given to Karnataka. Shame on bjp and shame on modi
@@manojgowda6196 if you want gst collected from karnataka to come back then why are you contributing in the first place.
If I say taxes collected in bangalore should be spent on bangalore not to be distributed to the rest of the state are you ok with that?
@@vishalreddy6144 if we pay 100 rs as GST we get back 10 rs. Can u justify that?!! And one more thing, if Bangalore pays 100rs tax to state government then it gets back atleast 45 rs. Now this is justice. And what central government is doing with Karnataka is betrayal at best. Everything has an end, so does Modi government in centre.
bangalore it is not as simple as 100 rs 10 rs.
It is based on finance commission recommendation. centre cannot has no say in it.
Even if modi Or gowda becomes PM karnataka will get the same money.
If centre starts giving more money to rich states and less to poorer states then UP, bihar, west Bengal, Northeast states became more poorer then start migrating to our states where demographic changes will occur.
Already in bangalore kannadigas are below 50% you want this to accelerate where we may see a day where non localite becaming mla.
We are same people who welcomed hal, beml, bel, headquarters in bangalore.
Which is a cente funded.
It is not included in our 10 rs we get.
Don't parrot politicians solgans.
If congress is in centre and BJP in state they do the same.
Question the numbers.
There are other facilities rich states gets.
@@vishalreddy6144 bullshit..
@@manojgowda6196 if you are biased everything else looks bullshit.
Even if congress comes to power in 2029 same thing will repeat.
Most arogent fm
CHIDHU BEST FM IS IT?
Spellings theek kr le bhai pehle..
It is quite strange and annoying that whenever Rahul Kandi, Garghe or other opposition members speak, treasury bench listens with rapt attention and silence but when the Ministers including PM, Modi, speaks, opposition including top leaders shout and create pandemonium without listening and acts likr hooligans. Is this the way the Congress which ruled and dominated Indian politics. They feel they got elected for this irresponsible behaviour. These fellows should have gone to sell vegetables or fish on the streets. Shame on them, shame😮
Specially fabricated budget for two states, Assam also get nothing.
You got so much in last 10 years. Bridges being built and all.
Kharge forgotten his congress party's paap of dividing Andhra Pradesh into Andhra and Telangana in a hurry without any scientific study on bifurcation and its implications. Reason is Kursi bachane ke liye. Iss paapko dhulana itna mushkil hai ki voh kabhi andhra mei ek seat mei deposit bachana bhi na mumkin hai. Without any shame or conscience he is blaming BJP that it's saving its government. Besharam se baath karna koi inse seekhen
What is the need for state budget every year...Are they not earning revenue from GST...100% they are getting from SGST, ISGST-50%, CSGT-37%... Name all the district of the state and implement big projects for each districts 😏😏🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Tamilnadu gives ₹100 as Income Tax and gets only ₹29 from center.
GST has not been paid to non-BJP States for months together.
@kaka_kaka28. First ask tamil Nadu government tiruppur, coimbatore are paying more tax but tamil Nadu government not giving it back😂😂😂..they are spending it on some villages of tamil Nadu why it so give revenue generated from. Coimbatore 100% itself why need to spend on undeveloped villages😊😊😊
@@parandhamanmargan9527 , I want villages to be developed. When villages get developed, villagers need not come to towns and cities in search of jobs.
Worst budget..worst government..this lady is so weird
What is this old lady saying, the facts are very clear
As per you guys,she is OLD and Kharge is young...same like INDI alliance with 231 seats won over NDA with 303 seats???
Please go though the budget,
Kharge jis development in Kalaburgi 😂😂 itself a big joke (it's the least developed region in entire karnataka with literacy rate under 60%) lol
AS PER KHARGE THE BUDGET IS FOR ANDHRA AND BIHAR AND BALANCE FOR. PAKISTAN.
As per u jumla party and its voters are nationalist......rest are pakistani.......
U are not the only one who can give taunt....
Kharge is coming out with the exact nature of this discriminating 'Save NDA' budget!
@@georgejacob4327 How Rahul with 99 will satisfy Soren. Laloo. Akhilesh. Pawar. Stalin. Udhav. Kejriwal families together got only 201 plus LDF and UDF in Kerala and 8 parties in TN. And Mamatas 29 and it will be only 230 and wait for others.
Khargaji, please don't thnk about kursi always. Think about kursi in 2029.Till that time try to be a constructive oppposition
Nirmala madam don't shout 1:47 we are fed-up with your economic destruction of poor and middle class
Budget allocated to Andhra & Bihar will be used for Agriculture, Capital Development, Airports Construction.
Why Karnataka should he given any funds where they are providing everything for FREE.
Pakoda and jalebi😂😂😂
omg i laughed so hard when he said pakoda and jilebi, almost as funny as mangar sutar, mujra remarks, in the end only two words can make everyone laugh for days.
Kick this rude FM out!
The b is not even elected? I think she is selected because of her nastiness, Modi must be reveling in having a bulldog like her
Nirmala is the best finance minister
FM getting mocked by nearly all, for her discriminating budget.
this is not discriminatory look at all UPA budget. nothing but scams
@@krishna_Bharath please sir we are all educated people watching this, please be neutral in rating, Bharat and Bjp has many good choice for fm
@@senthilkumaranvaratharajan5556 I dont see people are neutral here. Are they? Look at when Congress ruled and how India was at that times and how other nations saw us compared today India. Congress destroyed India, Dravidian Parties are destroying tamil nadu. you are saying we are educated and how many educated caste their vote and elect a proper leader now. YOu cant change the 30+ years mess created by Congress in 5 years or 10 years. it takes time and compared to 2014 we are much better and we will be 3 or 4th largest economy in the world in coming years. So many scandals or scam do you see that now? come on please be open minded too when you see the country what we are and what were we before
@@krishna_Bharath sir bjp must be having a good fm candidate, per capita is more important than 5 trillion economy.
@@senthilkumaranvaratharajan5556 per capita will improve when we indian economy improves with more jobs and exports. it goes hand in hand. Also Comparing the previous Cong/UPA FM's she is better atleast. you cant compare with top notch but compared to people screwing the economy she does better in the prevailing Post Covid.
You cannot make all the people happy all the time. Nirmala sitharaman has given a good budget. Average citizens like it. Opposition parties are worthless lot. They are there te disturb any meetings and waste time. Nitmala ji done good work.
I am with you 💯
This is union budget. Not every state budget. Mallikarjun kharge has like Joe Biden 😢😢.
Why don't you and your party 7:42 not mention Ap and Bihar in the past 5 years budget session
Did not know kharge sir would come up with such a funny and tricky lines hilarious 😂
He is only a mediocre person
This is the best elected FM
Nirmalaji, Be bold. These fellows are only paper tigers without stuff
He is speaking so much now where was he when parliment closed all the door and divided state of AP ? DONT these fool know that andhra will be at loss with the division of state ? We are getting what is rightfully ours we are not beggers . We under state of madras lost chennai as capital again as hyderabad . We are proud andhra people 💪
U got nothing for 10 years.....which u deserved......because of pakoda......this should have been done 10 years earlier.......now it's being done just for sake of kursi
@@aneeshmyneni6409 i don't have enough for bjp Also . if this kind of care and concern is taken for development of Andhra Pradesh in these 10 years this dire situation could not have been arise. 🙂↕️
Where is Mr kharge, when his state got amount for Metrorail
Kharge must be very hungry. Please feed him 😂😂😂
The common people pay income tax for running the Parliament. If this is how Parliament functions then should we pay tax. This time the Opposition is acting crazy
23 lakh crores to be allocated to states. If only Andhra and Bihar is mentioned does it mean the money is not going to other states? What stupidity by opposition?
Absolutely
Congress divided Andhra Pradesh very unscientifically and after 10 years of trouble ,now BJP granted budget .Why Congress is creating ruckus now? Has it got any drudge against Andhra Pradesh? Bad politics.
Because other states were given nothing. I mean that is very partial. If u are allocation resources to andhra and Bihar , why not give it to other states also.
@@diyar8161point is I agree with Bihar budget and it does have political aspect but what can gov do it has to save coalition opposition will ask gov cannot prove majority then everyone is fucked now would they not not favor allies when they come to power talking about nothing for states will the companies based in states don't get funds through these schemes yes there is more budget for allies but opposition is using anger to divert them to their side they didn't even lost what they would do if they were in power in budget why they can't make one which is good or cover it with hypocrisy
@@LAkSHMIPRASAD-c1j opposition is not in power for one . And this budget is bullshit. Middle class get nothing and everything went to bihar and ap. Is the govt so cash strapped that they cannot allocate resources for othe states like ap and bihar. I mean what is the use of other states to stay united as a country if the centre doesn't care
@@LAkSHMIPRASAD-c1j opposition is talking sense. Some of the points were directly out of Congress manifesto like giving money to interns. Kudh dimag nahi dal sakte aur and if they us brain , they do it for destruction
@@diyar8161 yes the cash is tight see the tax collected last year and see the ammount spent. I also said that there is bias for partners but do you think congress wouldn't do it if they came to power
She repeatedly ignores Karnataka even though she is from Karnataka, I don't what grudge she has against her mother, state like mother
😂 she is from Tamil Nadu Not Karnataka...
She is elected by Karnataka .....
@@SarathKumarDev she from Hyderabad not from Tamil Nadu. She got her mp seat from there.she lives in Hyderabad for more than 20 years. She was born in Tamil and did not live with the tamil people . Jayashankar born and brought up in Delhi his father is from Tamilnadu ,his father settled in Delhi after he got the job
I have issues with the budget. But I dont' understand can there be a budget that satisfies everyone. Specially when we have such a big middle and economic backward class + When our ambitions are so high for our future + when we have to fuel such a big military and other gov institution + when reservation+ castism + separatism and hate on different lines is dividing INDIA + when there is so much shit happening in the world and many more issues. Based on my limited knowledge of Indian politics. Opinion on Budget always seems like Half full or half empty kind of situation. Gov always sees it as half full and opposition as half empty i.e. why I absolutely don't care about the opposition rant over the budget. Every one is just trying to control the narrative. I am more concern about the implementation of the policies/free bees. Every year before the budget gov should tell how their previous policies/free bees have affected the people of INDIA. They should also tell what they are trying to achieve with specific policies. I was quite expecting this kind of budge specially after the election result. I am only disappointed by tax on short term capital and long term capital.
I think only Modi is in BJP MP's mind nothing else... And I don't see them taking us somewhere in a more developed state
Were is the senior citizen railway concession
Mr Kharge don’t act too much. First of all give respect to the President of Congress Party. Don’t behave like a slave.
Achar Mami..you have to admit...it's nothing but A for Andhra, B for Bihar budget! The cost you have to pay for the oxygen cylinders from these two states!
Nirmala is an international lier.
And you must be an expert on it yourself to think that you’d recognise another 🤣🤣
Not only lier thief of middle class money
Her weakness is her ego.
She is the dairy milk for them😂😂😂😂😂
खड़गे एक जटिल व्यक्ति हैं। उनका इतिहास भ्रष्टाचार से भरा है।
Look at your own state kharge MP
Your state Government wants 100 percentage reservation for Local Kannada by birth speak and writers reservation
This is definatly a discrimination by FM
Nothing for middle class & senior citizens. Waste budget.
2 lakh crore for jobs how do they Generate? By Giving them to companies of Politicians to set up companies ?
He is also like Manmohan singh. Quite natural
God bless you Finance minister and your family................ammaa....
depth of her understanding is clear ..
One of the worst FM in history of modern India.
Do this Kharge and Indonesian Comodo dragon share DNA? I strongly suspect they do !!!
Except dramatic Rhettoric she doest have brain,
Her rehotoric sounds hollow. She is Good atmaking animation.
Minister is always like that she didn't know how to present good budget 😂😂😂
Minister should be calm
Why Kharge’s plate is having only purgative or what?
Zindabad Zindabad Mallikarjuna Garge Zindabad 🖐️💪🔥🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🌹❤️🤍💚🌹😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍
Emotional will never bring success
FM ur unfit gr politics mis.NSTRM
This sort of question should have been expected by the FM because of BJP's coalition with Bihari and Telangana parties . She should have given some details about other States in the Speech itself.
Nirmala acting like a maths teacher...
Although her eating habit is personal, Why As a Finance minister Nirmala sitharaman said that, she never eat egypt onion and garlic in Parliament?
Nirmala ji You are fentastic... 💪🏻💪🏻💪🏻💪🏻💪🏻💪🏻..... Since 1947 these congress muslim thali mein jelebi de rahe hei and Hindus ko sirf karela(bitterguard) ki achar de rahe hei...
In Modiji Government anything can happen
She gave no jalebis as Khargeji has Diabetes
Budget is favoring two states 😮
Last year 2.2 crore people payed income tax that's a lot of middle class🤣. Just Instagram NPCs doing aimless rant
I so much wish Raghuram Rajan was in politics and the finance minister of India.
When North Indian states got more budget allocations then they were happy..Cong Prime Minister Dr Manmohan Singh promised lot of things in AP reorganisation act but never fulfilled their promises and now they are crying ..
Sometimes, I need to remind myself that someone other than Gandhi’s family is the president of Congress. Strange.
Congress should have brought its own budget proposals (provisional )and presented in a press conference or in social media immediately after the budget for judgment of both parties by the public.
As people of andhra dont believe in congress party they divided ap and gave promises as ap reorganization act. So now bjp fulfilling promises by allocation of budget . Now congress creating issue as budget for ap only
Mr. Kharge has Very rightly said. Nirmala Sitaraman became Scapegoat of Narendra Modi and Amit Shah. If this is not, then She is not fir for FM of India. India dont need such FM in India ...