their is no debate bruh arod is a way better version. same type of game brett turn ball wayyyyyy more over then arod. brett not even better then big ben
Aaron Rodgers isn't better than Brett farve if Brett played in this sissy ass nfl he would put up about 5000 yards a season Brett is the man his teammates loved him while Aaron teammates always question his leadership because he's a damn bitch , if Aaron played in the 90's he wouldn't put up numbers like he is now
He was unlucky when his own team couldn't recover an onside kick yes or no? There's no way that hail mary pass against arizona was luck. there's few QBs ever who would've had a chance at making that throw.
how were they lucky? Obviously you need to have the benefit of your guy going up and making the catch but to put them both on the money, especially the 2nd one, was incredible
how are ppl gonna talk about Rodgers play not being as high since the super bowl? they went into the super bowl as the 6th seed and were one loss away from not making the playoffs. if anything, Aaron has played better. but the defense has not performed at the same level consistently since the super bowl year
Ethan Matz big cap offense dominated the playoffs too same w the d you didnt watch that run clearly Rodgers was well deserving of that Super Bowl MVP he dominated the Steelers defense
@@briansavasta9366 kinda hard to build a defense when your whole salary cap is dedicated to one player. That's not just the Packers issue. It's a league issue. Most teams cripple because of that.
The more effecient accurate better quarterback is Aaron rodgers. But Favre...he may be one of the only few players in NFL history that was exciting to watch and he played with such a passion and energy that it made many people love watching/playing with him regardless if you were a packer fan or not.
Aaron is more accurate only in the sense of TD to INT ratio. However, he’s already had more losing seasons that Favre, Brent won 3% more games (close but that’s still a difference), and Brent played hurt over and over again because if he didn’t GB would have lost. Aaron will miss those games and not start and doesn’t care. I’m a GB fan...and I’ll take the gunslinger over 12 anytime.
Driver and Rodgers did too but they forced Driver out even though he still could play. Just like Jordy Nelson more recently. Jordy had to go to Oakland and THEN retire.
@@youlikethat7119 driver and Favre never won a super bowl together. Favre won b4 driver and driver won with rodgers at the end. Sterling Sharpe and Brett favre was amazing b4 driver came but Sterling Sharpe will always be underrated due to lack of longevity.
Dennis Watt It’s still an interesting conversation and I want to hear his opinion.. just a fact that playing with one player when he’s in his prime and the other when he’s over 35 is likely to influence his opinion
Brett played a lot of his career before the league started favoring offenses. If he had started playing in the new era he would have thrown for even more touchdown passes and had less interceptions. During his MVP years 95-97 he was the only QB that threw for 30+ touchdowns each year with the best TD/INT ratio in the league and no ones stats were even close. Now days guys throw 30+ TD's and 15 INT in their sleep and still may not be considered a top tier QB.
If Farve played now he would probably throw even more INTS more Chances to make bone headed mistakes. Steve Young played in the tough era back then an still didnt throw alot of INTS. Before Rodgers lol Steve Young was the highest rated passer in NFL History with 96. So i dnt buy that excuse for Farve
A 96 passer rating in todays NFL is basically just good or above average. Matthew Stafford had a 97.0 past year and he only ranked 9th in the league. Tony Romo has a career passer rating of 97.1 which is higher than Steve Young but do you think he's better than Young? I don't think so, so to say Brett Farve would have thrown more interceptions in todays game when piling up numbers and throwing touchdown passes is easier is ridiculous.
itshiho Matthew Stafford 86 career passer rating. And I think even in today's game Farve would throw alot of INTS alot of Farve INTS was forcing passes into triple coverage
Comparing Matthew Stafford to Steve Young? Wow. Anyway I disagree that in an easier league to throw more touchdowns he would throw more picks. That makes no sense.
Favre had a 106 QB rating with 33TD's against 7 INT's and 4200 yards in his last healthy season, as a 39 year old with the Vikings. This is an old and brittle Favre who never practiced. I think it's safe to say the 94-98 Favre who still had scrambling ability and an absolute cannon for an arm would have been way better in the modern era. I like Rodgers and Favre both but the main differences are mostly circumstance: 1.) Rodgers has never dealt with a coaching change 2.) Rodgers hasn't lost his mobility yet 3.) Rodgers has never had a team that got into long term salary-cap/talent problems like Favre's team did from 99-2005. Or rather, I would say he Rodgers is going through that now, and it shows in his play.
Their division sucks. I'm sure Aaron's record would be a little worse if he faced Randy Moss twice a year. Also, don't forget about Barry Sanders on the Lions. It's not as simple as wins and losses
It really is. The Bears have a diabetic at quarterback, the Vikings have AP past his prime, and the lions don't have anyone good to throw the ball to. I admit the Lions situation is recent and they used to be a little better. Even when AP was good, the team still wasn't because they couldn't throw the ball. Edit-the one exception is when Brett Favre was briefly with the Vikings.
The people who watched him havent forgotten. But were talking about post millenials now who were born after the year 2000. They see aaron Rodgers and hes the greatest damn thing ever, except for the fact he plays in a league your literal finger cant touch a QBs helmet. The offense is so heavily favored its comical. Favre did it when it wasnt. Everybody throws 30 tds now. They think because its qbs getting better. Lmao nope, the defense play with arm and one leg now and every thing is a penalty....
Give Me Favre...The Beating, Hits Alone That Favre Took, Got Back Up And Continued To Play...Rogers Couldn't Take That Beating, Get Back Up And Do It Again...The Last Time Rogers Took A Big Hit He Missed The Remainder Of The Season...
When you wrote this comment, I would have agreed with you. But after last year, I no longer question AR's toughness. Not after watching him post the numbers that he did on a tibial fracture and other injuries.
Both are great but it sure sucked watching farve throw a pointless interceptions to end the season year after year. You forgot this now but it really angered everyone at the time lol
Don't forget 6 ints vs Rams in 2001, the pick vs the eagles in 2004 (4th and 26game), and 4 ints vs Vikings in 2004. He had a great stretch from 92-98 and after Holmgren left he wasn't the same guy.
Derek S Yeah, still a tough choice though, cause Favre for me is somewhere in the top 5 QBs of all time. Having a choice of the two is a win win actually
I'm loving UNDISPUTED! I came for Skip and stayed for Shannon, both gel really well together, speak respectfully and aren't full of themselves like SAS. I wonder what the numbers are right now in comparison, ratings wise?
last I check which was earlier this week espn first take is still killing them in ratings. However, I'm not sure if first take ratings are dropping. I'm not surprised at this. How many people Google and TH-cam skip's new show? More people watch ESPN in general this espn can advertise first take way more . Who watches fsn? So you won't even see commercials for this show. I'm sure it all comes down to that people Still don't know about it. Once skip starts blasting LeBron and Westbrook and it starts trending on Twitter will people find about it
Their both great, but Aaron is product of different rules where you can't press the receiver anymore and the quarterback is way more protected nowdays.
I never watch this show, but this was one of the most interesting segments of football talk i've ever seen. Mostly because of Jennings' willingness to answer some questions honestly and candidly about a unique situation. Love it.
Brett Favre is better he took the Packers 2 Super Bowls should have won against the Broncos but the Packers defense couldn't stop Elway and Davis and he almost took another franchise back to the Super Bowl the Minnesota Vikings
Rodgers better then Farve. Passer Rating Rodgers 104 to Farve 86. Rodgers highest rated passer and best TD to INT ratio in NFL History. Farve most INTS in NFL History. Superbowl MVPS Rodgers 1 to Farve 0. And Farve throw Playoff Games away for his teams. 2002 playoffs Rams 45-17 over Packers an Farve 6 INTS. And 2003 playoffs Eagles 20-17 over Packers and Farve OT INT that lost Packers game. And 2007 NFC Championship Giants 23 to Packers 20 and in OT Farve throw INT in OT last pass in Lambeau that lost Packers game. In 2009 NFC Championship Saints beat Vikings and Farve throw INTS that cost Vikings a shot at going to superbowl.
Gustavo Alba I'm shocked that Brett didn't chase Elway down during the game. I swear Brett would have played linebacker if you told him to. He was the equivalent of Russell Westbrook. He wants to win so much he makes dumb mistakes.
The Vikings were dealt a bad hand in that game. The saints defense kept hitting Favre after passes were thrown and were not flagged whatsoever. People like to say it was his fault because of the late interception but forget that AP fumbled a whole bunch of times during that game.
Favre happened to play when his division was actually good tough. You think about the Minnesota Vikings back in Favre's day and then the Bears with Urlacher. Rodgers hasn't really had to deal with that. Until this past year, there was no defense in the NFC North. Also Favre played the majority of his career in a tougher passing era. Rodgers has played in the most passer-friendly era. That skews stats a lot. I do think Rodgers is amazing and he's top two in the league for sure, perhaps he's better than Favre, but I don't think his numbers would be as pretty if he'd played in the 90s in a way tougher division.
Top 5? How, he has some numbers and 1 ring? Montana Elway Brady Bradshaw Aikman Starr Staubach Unitas Peyton now we get to the cluster fuck Ben Roth Aaron Rodgers Marino Favre Steve Young Drew Brees Jim Kelly he better win another bowl before he's even tier 2. and this is from someone who has Favre first all time.
I'm taking Rodgers all day. Brett was great and was probably the cooler guy to play with but in big moments, he was just as likely to make a big mistake as he was to make a big play
I always found myself holding my breath when Favre dropped back to pass, particularly when the game was on the line. I have more confidence in Rodgers.
Rodgers already has more unexpected 1 and dones than Favre. Favre gets blamed for all of his because they came down to a throw and Rodgers gets a pass because they don't, as if the game being over in the 3rd QTR is a positive. And why is everybody forgetting the 90s??? Not only the best QB but the best player. Period.
This interview aged well. Jennings was 100% correct about Rodgers listening to everything in the media about him and being 100% affected about everything being said. Rodgers is a fragile diva. Jennings nailed it years ago and we've seen it played out over the yrs.
ive seen PLENTY of moments where i see Rodgers looking at his receiver and nodding his head like that was my fault, or sorry. just salty jennings criticizing
Daniel Chachanashvili I agree, people don't realize that Rodgers is harder on himself than he is on anyone else he plays with. Just look at his reaction when he makes an uncharistically poor pass attenpt or throws a pick.
Y’all act like y’all were the ones receiving passes from Rodgers. I think Jennings was being truthful cause he even said he would rather play with Rodgers so he has no reason to lie.
There's no wrong answer here folks. They all had great points. Rodger is a safer choice. Farve is more electric but more riskier. If I needed someone to carry my team all season long, then it's Rodgers. But if I need someone win a big game and make something special happen, then it's Farve.
Favre had a better defense, and better backup QBs. For most of his career, Rodgers didn't have a good defense behind him. In fact, if Rodgers was incapacitated, the Packers would be lucky to win 4 games, since he has never had a good backup QB, and mostly, a lousy defense for the last 10 years. Their defense looks pretty good this season, after they strengthened their LBs with some free agents, and if the Packers can get their players back healthy, they might go all the way.
When people are comparing Favre and Aaron they are really only considering the end of his career and all his interceptions but they don't factor in his prime years when he was a 3time MVP and brought the Packers to back to back Super Bowls. Why don't we wait till Aaron makes it to a second Super Bowl before we consider him GOD and the GOAT. He's good but he's not that good. I'll give Aaron top 10 QB's ever but he's not number 1 Brady Montana Elway Manning Marino Then Rodgers
dude that's the dumbest thing I've ever heard Favre has always thrown double digit TDs, his whole career. 300 ints in 20 years that's 15 picks a year at least 1 a game, he's one of the worst decision makers in NFL history.
o8 shooter 9o lol I'm sorry I forgot when only 15 picks is a bad thing. No he's not super efficient but 15 a year isn't that bad at all it's a good ratio especially when he's throwing about 28-30 TD's
I've been a LIFELONG First Take guy, dating way back to the Jay Crawford/Woody Paige days on cold pizza. I'm making the jump to UNDISPUTED solely because of Skip Bayless and there's no SAS Dude, this is good stuff. There's no "adjective screaming" from SAS, which is a huge plus!
He's tied for first with Peyton for the most wins, has the highest TD differential over a 20 year period, and has the most go ahead touchdowns when trailing ever. But those aren't significant right? You're a fuckboy.
And the fact that you put "if that is a record he holds" in parentheses in your comment shows me you don't know dick. Favres record starts streak is the most impressive record in sports and considered the most unbreakable with Joe DiMaggios hit streak a close second. Step your knowledge up.
Rodgers better then Farve. Career Passer Rating Rodgers 104 to Farve 86. Rodgers highest rated passer an best TD to INT ratio in NFL History. And Brett Farve most INTS in NFL History and not even First in TD passes anymore since Peyton Manning broke his TD pass record. Superbowl MVP Rodgers 1 to Farve 0. Lol Farve threw INTS to lose games for his teams in playoffs 2002 playoffs Rams 45-17 over Packers and Farve throw 6 INTS. And 2003 Playoffs OT loss Eagles 20-17 over Packers and Farve throw INT in overtime that led to loss. In 2007 NFC Championship Giants 23 to Packers 20 and Farve INT in OT his last pass in Lambeau that Lost Packers game. In 2009 NFC Championship Saints 31 to Vikings 28 and Brett Farve threw INT to Tracey Porter that cost Vikings a chance to win game with a FG and a superbowl appearance
Both shows are better, who would of thought, Max Kellerman is great with SAS, Kellerman coming from a boxing background is a bonus, he always brings it up, thanks Max, pure respect to the sweet science.
Give me Brett all day.. ARog is a beast but he's TOO cautious....Brett at least makes the attempt. it was different whn he played with Reggie and Leroy, didnt take as many chances...didn't have to. It was whn that def fell off tht he became reckless because it was mist likely gone be a shoot out. Rodgers, like Jennings said is tryn to b perfect. Sometimes you gotta put the ball in places that is THOUGHT it couldn't get. To ME ...THATS greatness.
There is another very good show I watch, but this is the best. The confrontations are very painful to listen to and accept at times, but it is so raw and honest. Great job. Keep up the good work.
Loved Favre but there were a lot of times when the Pack lost playoff games because of his costly INTs. He did it with the Vikings to. Also Favre's playoff record isn't anything special either. I love how Aaron isn't a turn over machine like Brett was...I'll say that. It's strange how Skip loves to harp on Aaron Rodgers flaws but bushes aside Favre's. Skip is just mad that the Packers saw great potential in Rodgers and told Brett to GTFO so they could start Aaron. Skip somehow thinks Aaron is responsible for that lol. Let's not talk about the drama Favre caused on & off the field lol
Imagine if they had to play in the others respective NFL era. Favre had basically 1 season in the new NFL and killed it. I wonder how Rodgers would have fared in the 90's game.
Ouch. They look really bad saying that Rodgers needed Jordy. Cause this playoffs Rodgers proved once and for all he doesn't need any receiver to be the best.
As a packers, aaron, and Favre fan. I would have to agree with jennings. ever since the superbowl, Rodgers has been falling short when it really matter and I think a large part of that is exactly what jennings explained. overall, I'd take aaron Rodgers 24/7 over Favre but if I had one game and it was on the line I'd take favre.
Yeah that's worked well. I can't even begin to count how many time Favre threw mind-boggling stupid interceptions in those scenarios. At least with Rodgers, I know he won't throw a pick. Plus, he had a couple nice Hail-Mary throws last season with the game on the line. Would've had a chance to win the Cardinals game if the defense doesn't blow the game.
How many of those losses were on Arodg and not the defense? I can think of at least 4 different instances. Rodgers put the packers in position bit the opposing team won on a final possession.
The last 2 playoff games Green Bay lost were in overtime on the road and Green Bay never got a chance to touch the ball. The last game Favre had in Green Bay, he set the Giants up with a fg in overtime. Rodgers would never do that.
@@fasteddycj1980 I disagree Rodgers broke the record for passer rating that year for a reason. He threw more touchdowns and less interceptions If you compare their two best seasons
2012 vs Giants. I don’t recall Aaron Rodgers playing defense and allowing Hakeem Nicks 165 receiving yards and 2 TD. For real, football is a team game and you can play well at your position and still lose. Heck not only was Rodgers the QB but that game he was also the Packs leading rusher with 65 yards. He can only do so much in a game so why put the blame of a loss to the Giants on A-Rod and say he didn’t do enough?
Rodgers is just a more talented quarterback who makes better decisions with the football than Brett did. Personally I liked watching Brett more and enjoyed his playstyle more than Rodgers, but ARod's the guy. And time makes it easy to forget, but Favre came up short in the playoffs many times. Neither QB was/is an all time great clutch player.
I would take Rodgers over Farve all day. Career Passer Rating Rodgers 104 to Farve 86. Rodgers higher rated passer in NFL History and best TD to INT ratio in NFL History. Farve most INTS in NFL history. Superbowl MVPS Rodgers 1 to Farve 0. And Farve throw Playoff Games away 2002 playoff Farve 6 INTS in a 45-17 loss to Rams. In 2003 Playoff OT loss 20-17 to Eagles an Farve threw INT in OT to lose Packers the game. In 2007 NFC Championship 23 to 20 Packers OT loss to Giants and Farve last pass in Lambeau a INT to put Giants in position to win game.
Durability goes to Favre. Aaron is brittle compared to #4. Intermediate and short throws go to Favre. As bizarre as it sounds, Aaron can't throw screens like Brett could. Deep throws go to Aaron. He throws those powerful, high arc spirals that really sail through the air. Ball security goes to Aaron in a big way. He may be the least intercepted qb in nfl history. Throwing on the run, I have to go Aaron. He may be the best I've ever seen. Intangibles go to Favre, since Aaron holds on to the ball far too long waiting for the perfect window. Punts are technically turnovers in a roundabout way. Plus, Brett was the better teammate since he wasn't as high-strung as Aaron is. Aaron's thirst for perfection can wear on younger players in a negative way. It's close, but I have to lean Brett.
Nobody is as tough as Brett Farve only ones who comes close are the Manning Bros, great arm, great playmaker and leader. Rodgers has better accuracy, field vision, best Td:Int ratio but if I had to pick one I'm going Farve
Because he had to! Favre made the packers revelant while Aaron perfected his skills!!! LEADERSHIP MATTERS MUCH MORE THAN YOU THINK!!! NOT TO MENTION THE ABUSE HE WITHSTOOD. AARON WOULD FOLD IN THOSE GAMES Favre mever gave up!!
It's Rodgers who is more skilled and talented, but Favre was a more durable, more clutch, and a far better leader of a team. I hold Favre in more respect than I do Rodgers. Aaron is a bit of a narcissist premadonna
I don't see how Rodgers being better than favre Viks took an 09 Viks to a nfc championship game which Viks got robbed in and I don't thing Rodgers could do
LarryKing there were mutiple late hits on favre and Viks in general. Saints strategy shouldn't of worked people like to blame favre for the loss because he threw the pick but forget to mention ap fumbled a couple times and even with ap fumbles Viks were still in position to win that game but Childress put 12 men on the field out of a time out to take Viks out of field goal range favre didn't cost Viks that game.
I don’t care what Rodgers accomplished. One of the greatest games I’ve ever seen was when favre played right after his father passed and absolutely decimated the Raiders.
I remember watching that game and hearing the announcers talking about his dad's death. Simply incredible that he played, I wouldn't have expected him to even leave his house.
Rodgers has talent to play in any era even in 90s. With Rodgers mobile to buy time and escape and throw rockets downfield outside the pocket. Rodgers can buy time to get WR open downfield even if WR get grab by Corners. And Rodgers more Accurate then Farve. Rodgers doesn't throw bone headed INTS like Farve does. Career Passer Rating Rodgers 104 to Farve 96. Rodgers highest rated passer and best TD to INT ratio in NFL History. Superbowl MVPS Rodgers 1 to Farve 0. Give me Rodgers over Farve
Tod Wilkinson Lmao Lmao Rodgers doesn't have a long ball False. Rodgers Hail Mary vs Lions and Cardinals. Rodgers 61 yard hail Mary vs Lions nearly hit the roof of Ford Field. And Rodgers Hail Mary in playoff game to Jeff Janis in playoff Game. So stop talking until you can come with Facts
Aaron Rodgers is one of the 3 best QB's of all time so the other two are Tom Brady and Peyton Manning not Brett Favre, Aaron Rodgers established he was the Greatest Packers QB ever years ago now the rest of his career will determine if he'll go down as the best of all time.
When you think about the 2010 Packers' recieving corps, and the fact that they got hot and healthy at the right time (10-4 reg season) i think that the recieving corps never got due credit for that SB season. The BACKUP QB has the all-time GB passing yards record with that group. Once they broke up THAT band, the Packers were never the same. AR will never see another Super Bowl in GB.
They're both all time great QBs. But Jennings and Skip have great points, Favre is an electric player or electric playmaker. I would take Favre by an edge. But there is risk with this selection.
Being from wisco I can tell you farve was a pick machine it was disgusting he stuck around way way too long threw way to many risky passes and arguably had better receivers.
I will say, I don’t watch Undisputed, don’t really plan on starting. But it is very refreshing having a moderator that doesn’t interrupt every 5 seconds.
Most people dont know what they are talking about when it comes to packers history. I've watched both play. Brett Favre always had a defense. Favre also had great receivers and tight ends and a good running back. I dont think we can say the same for Aaron rodgers. Stop being emotional.
Beautiful debate. I agree with Greg on everything, especially on Brett being the better overall. he did make more with less. Aaron compliments great wide receiving play.
Henry Street lets see .. BB system in 2013.. gronk out.. dola out... Edelman in and out.. aqib talib out.. mayo and wilkfork out for the season. Collins was a rookie.. Brady's running backs blount and vereen. Neither finished the year with 800 yards rushing.. oh BB system with browns was 36-44 in 5 years.. oh he just didn't go 11-5 without brady.. he went 5-11 in 2000.. and started 0-2 in 2001. Before Brady took over... Hmm 12-4 sounds more like BB doing everything.. and Brady just sitting..
5 years ago this was a fair debate But the fact u said this 2 months ago is hilarious He's borderline the goat Farve isn't even in rodgera convo anymore
This is a question for Donald Driver. The man played with Brett most of his career, but he won a ring with Rodgers.
Greg Jennings also won a ring with Aaron. I mean he said it in the interview
i think dude was implying that donald driver had alot more years with brett.
their is no debate bruh arod is a way better version. same type of game brett turn ball wayyyyyy more over then arod. brett not even better then big ben
Aaron Rodgers isn't better than Brett farve if Brett played in this sissy ass nfl he would put up about 5000 yards a season Brett is the man his teammates loved him while Aaron teammates always question his leadership because he's a damn bitch , if Aaron played in the 90's he wouldn't put up numbers like he is now
It's not a question for either for them. Driver played with Brett on the front end, Greg played with Rodgers on the front end and vice versa.
The last two games Rodgers lost were in Seattle and Arizona and he didn't even get to touch the ball in OT 😒
he also got some lucky ass hell mary passes yes or no?
He was unlucky when his own team couldn't recover an onside kick yes or no? There's no way that hail mary pass against arizona was luck. there's few QBs ever who would've had a chance at making that throw.
how were they lucky? Obviously you need to have the benefit of your guy going up and making the catch but to put them both on the money, especially the 2nd one, was incredible
My point is Rodgers didn't get a chance to win the last two playoff games cuz he didn't touch the ball in OT
+Euan Reynard yes Rodgers why more clutch then favre he wouldn't throw a fucking duck up
Skip always reaching for somebody to side with hin and put down another athlete he doesn't really like.
True
Put in this situation he may have a point. I'd still take Favre first, seems more team oriented
you dont know sports lol
Exactly what I was about to say. Glad I scanned down in the comments a bit.
Thank you Greg for being 100% honest. You can tell he has let go of so much resentment.
how are ppl gonna talk about Rodgers play not being as high since the super bowl? they went into the super bowl as the 6th seed and were one loss away from not making the playoffs. if anything, Aaron has played better. but the defense has not performed at the same level consistently since the super bowl year
Josh Ahrens Rodgers has had 2 top ten defenses in his career one of them he won a Superbowl. That speaks volumes.
That Packes SB team was literally carried by the defense. Defense won 3 regular season games with defensive TD's for them to squeeze in at 10-6.
Ethan Matz big cap offense dominated the playoffs too same w the d you didnt watch that run clearly Rodgers was well deserving of that Super Bowl MVP he dominated the Steelers defense
@@briansavasta9366 kinda hard to build a defense when your whole salary cap is dedicated to one player. That's not just the Packers issue. It's a league issue. Most teams cripple because of that.
Agreed. Aaron has not faltered. Everything around him has.
The more effecient accurate better quarterback is Aaron rodgers. But Favre...he may be one of the only few players in NFL history that was exciting to watch and he played with such a passion and energy that it made many people love watching/playing with him regardless if you were a packer fan or not.
*Rodgers all day everyday*
Aaron is more accurate only in the sense of TD to INT ratio. However, he’s already had more losing seasons that Favre, Brent won 3% more games (close but that’s still a difference), and Brent played hurt over and over again because if he didn’t GB would have lost. Aaron will miss those games and not start and doesn’t care.
I’m a GB fan...and I’ll take the gunslinger over 12 anytime.
That's pretty accurate.
Let's be real though, his TD to INT ratio is ungodly, Brady is second to him by a huge margin.
DC Mc idk man Rodgers is usualy gonna play through injury’s like his calf in those few seasons
Favre had mad chemistry with Donald Driver
Favre and Donald Driver was like Montana and Jerry Rice
Driver and Rodgers did too but they forced Driver out even though he still could play. Just like Jordy Nelson more recently. Jordy had to go to Oakland and THEN retire.
@@youlikethat7119 driver and Favre never won a super bowl together. Favre won b4 driver and driver won with rodgers at the end.
Sterling Sharpe and Brett favre was amazing b4 driver came but Sterling Sharpe will always be underrated due to lack of longevity.
To be fair Jennings played with Favre past his prime and got to play with Rodgers in his peak athletic years
That don’t matter... if that’s the case what’s the point in talking about it
Dennis Watt It’s still an interesting conversation and I want to hear his opinion.. just a fact that playing with one player when he’s in his prime and the other when he’s over 35 is likely to influence his opinion
I mean AP says favres the hardest throwing QB and best QB he's ever played with and Favre was 40 lol
Brett played a lot of his career before the league started favoring offenses. If he had started playing in the new era he would have thrown for even more touchdown passes and had less interceptions. During his MVP years 95-97 he was the only QB that threw for 30+ touchdowns each year with the best TD/INT ratio in the league and no ones stats were even close. Now days guys throw 30+ TD's and 15 INT in their sleep and still may not be considered a top tier QB.
If Farve played now he would probably throw even more INTS more Chances to make bone headed mistakes. Steve Young played in the tough era back then an still didnt throw alot of INTS. Before Rodgers lol Steve Young was the highest rated passer in NFL History with 96. So i dnt buy that excuse for Farve
A 96 passer rating in todays NFL is basically just good or above average. Matthew Stafford had a 97.0 past year and he only ranked 9th in the league. Tony Romo has a career passer rating of 97.1 which is higher than Steve Young but do you think he's better than Young? I don't think so, so to say Brett Farve would have thrown more interceptions in todays game when piling up numbers and throwing touchdown passes is easier is ridiculous.
itshiho Matthew Stafford 86 career passer rating. And I think even in today's game Farve would throw alot of INTS alot of Farve INTS was forcing passes into triple coverage
Comparing Matthew Stafford to Steve Young? Wow. Anyway I disagree that in an easier league to throw more touchdowns he would throw more picks. That makes no sense.
Favre had a 106 QB rating with 33TD's against 7 INT's and 4200 yards in his last healthy season, as a 39 year old with the Vikings. This is an old and brittle Favre who never practiced. I think it's safe to say the 94-98 Favre who still had scrambling ability and an absolute cannon for an arm would have been way better in the modern era.
I like Rodgers and Favre both but the main differences are mostly circumstance:
1.) Rodgers has never dealt with a coaching change
2.) Rodgers hasn't lost his mobility yet
3.) Rodgers has never had a team that got into long term salary-cap/talent problems like Favre's team did from 99-2005. Or rather, I would say he Rodgers is going through that now, and it shows in his play.
Still, Aaron's "bad year" is going 10-6... Haters gonna hate...
Their division sucks. I'm sure Aaron's record would be a little worse if he faced Randy Moss twice a year. Also, don't forget about Barry Sanders on the Lions. It's not as simple as wins and losses
The division isnt as easy as it looks on paper. The Vikes and Bears both come to play every game.
It really is. The Bears have a diabetic at quarterback, the Vikings have AP past his prime, and the lions don't have anyone good to throw the ball to. I admit the Lions situation is recent and they used to be a little better. Even when AP was good, the team still wasn't because they couldn't throw the ball. Edit-the one exception is when Brett Favre was briefly with the Vikings.
Austin Burchett ha! against the easiest schedule in the whole league!
If you want to see a bad division, take a look at the AFC east.
Greg Jennings sounds EXACTLY like Ryan Clark.
Spooky.
I would take Favre. Nothing against Rodgers, but as a 49ers fan I was more afraid of facing Favre all those years...
That’s because you guys sucked in the 2000s but whooped us when you got great
ppl have forgotten how great favre was in his prime from 95 to 98.
The people who watched him havent forgotten. But were talking about post millenials now who were born after the year 2000. They see aaron Rodgers and hes the greatest damn thing ever, except for the fact he plays in a league your literal finger cant touch a QBs helmet. The offense is so heavily favored its comical. Favre did it when it wasnt. Everybody throws 30 tds now. They think because its qbs getting better. Lmao nope, the defense play with arm and one leg now and every thing is a penalty....
@@MosDefnIT88both QBs are great!
Give Me Favre...The Beating, Hits Alone That Favre Took, Got Back Up And Continued To Play...Rogers Couldn't Take That Beating, Get Back Up And Do It Again...The Last Time Rogers Took A Big Hit He Missed The Remainder Of The Season...
facts! He is an iron man and had way more toughness.
When you wrote this comment, I would have agreed with you. But after last year, I no longer question AR's toughness. Not after watching him post the numbers that he did on a tibial fracture and other injuries.
Both are great but it sure sucked watching farve throw a pointless interceptions to end the season year after year. You forgot this now but it really angered everyone at the time lol
Give me Rodgers, if the game is on the line i want a TD to win rather than a famous Farve interception
@Chris Green Who has more MVPs???
Brett is my favorite player ever and Aaron has talent. There's no right answer
Brett Favre all day.
I don't know. After seeing the 2007 and 2009 Brett Favre throw those season ending INTs, I would pick Rodgers over Favre when it all counts.
Don't forget 6 ints vs Rams in 2001, the pick vs the eagles in 2004 (4th and 26game), and 4 ints vs Vikings in 2004. He had a great stretch from 92-98 and after Holmgren left he wasn't the same guy.
Derek S Yeah, still a tough choice though, cause Favre for me is somewhere in the top 5 QBs of all time. Having a choice of the two is a win win actually
OldSchoolLimp remember that's not his prime years
After watching Rodgers repeatedly hold the ball too long, get hit, sacked on 3rd down, and injured, I'll take 90's Favre.
LedZep's X exactly!!
I'm loving UNDISPUTED! I came for Skip and stayed for Shannon, both gel really well together, speak respectfully and aren't full of themselves like SAS. I wonder what the numbers are right now in comparison, ratings wise?
last I check which was earlier this week espn first take is still killing them in ratings. However, I'm not sure if first take ratings are dropping.
I'm not surprised at this. How many people Google and TH-cam skip's new show? More people watch ESPN in general this espn can advertise first take way more . Who watches fsn? So you won't even see commercials for this show. I'm sure it all comes down to that people Still don't know about it. Once skip starts blasting LeBron and Westbrook and it starts trending on Twitter will people find about it
firs take has been destroying undisputed in ratings
+MikeBNumba6 once fsn gets more recognition its over for First Take. might be a year, might be more
thats like empire and power one is one basic cable one isnt.. hard to compare the two as far as ratings
+mike lewis great example, but FS1 is basic cable. Its just hard to find
Their both great, but Aaron is product of different rules where you can't press the receiver anymore and the quarterback is way more protected nowdays.
"You want Apple or you wnat Enron stock??" hahahaha I'm laughing so hard!!
Bruh....Shannon is funny as fuck. "let me drink a lil bit of my water"
😂😂😂😂
At least he still put the team on his back doe
I never watch this show, but this was one of the most interesting segments of football talk i've ever seen. Mostly because of Jennings' willingness to answer some questions honestly and candidly about a unique situation. Love it.
Brett Favre is better he took the Packers 2 Super Bowls should have won against the Broncos but the Packers defense couldn't stop Elway and Davis and he almost took another franchise back to the Super Bowl the Minnesota Vikings
almost yup almost doesn't count warner did it with two different teams as well
Rodgers better then Farve. Passer Rating Rodgers 104 to Farve 86. Rodgers highest rated passer and best TD to INT ratio in NFL History. Farve most INTS in NFL History. Superbowl MVPS Rodgers 1 to Farve 0. And Farve throw Playoff Games away for his teams. 2002 playoffs Rams 45-17 over Packers an Farve 6 INTS. And 2003 playoffs Eagles 20-17 over Packers and Farve OT INT that lost Packers game. And 2007 NFC Championship Giants 23 to Packers 20 and in OT Farve throw INT in OT last pass in Lambeau that lost Packers game. In 2009 NFC Championship Saints beat Vikings and Farve throw INTS that cost Vikings a shot at going to superbowl.
LycanVonWolf Rodgers talent can fit in any era with Rodgers rocket arm and mobility to get outside the pocket and buy WR time to get open.
Gustavo Alba I'm shocked that Brett didn't chase Elway down during the game. I swear Brett would have played linebacker if you told him to. He was the equivalent of Russell Westbrook. He wants to win so much he makes dumb mistakes.
The Vikings were dealt a bad hand in that game. The saints defense kept hitting Favre after passes were thrown and were not flagged whatsoever. People like to say it was his fault because of the late interception but forget that AP fumbled a whole bunch of times during that game.
Favre happened to play when his division was actually good tough. You think about the Minnesota Vikings back in Favre's day and then the Bears with Urlacher.
Rodgers hasn't really had to deal with that. Until this past year, there was no defense in the NFC North.
Also Favre played the majority of his career in a tougher passing era. Rodgers has played in the most passer-friendly era.
That skews stats a lot. I do think Rodgers is amazing and he's top two in the league for sure, perhaps he's better than Favre, but I don't think his numbers would be as pretty if he'd played in the 90s in a way tougher division.
Crazy how much hes changed and yet how the times are the same
By the end of his career Rodgers will be considered a top 5 QB of all time
I can see top 10 but idk about 5
+Tod Wilkinson lol your insane.
1 more ring can do that. He will be a top 10 guy and I'd put him in the same ranking as Steve Young.
Big shock. What else you got? Tom Brady going to the hall of fame? Ugh...
Top 5? How, he has some numbers and 1 ring?
Montana
Elway
Brady
Bradshaw
Aikman
Starr
Staubach
Unitas
Peyton
now we get to the cluster fuck
Ben Roth
Aaron Rodgers
Marino
Favre
Steve Young
Drew Brees
Jim Kelly
he better win another bowl before he's even tier 2. and this is from someone who has Favre first all time.
Better: Rodgers
Greater: Favre
There's a difference...
nah
How is Favre greater
Not to jests fans....he was utterly selfish
I'm taking Rodgers all day. Brett was great and was probably the cooler guy to play with but in big moments, he was just as likely to make a big mistake as he was to make a big play
well Favre has still been to more Super Bowls than Rodgers has.
I always found myself holding my breath when Favre dropped back to pass, particularly when the game was on the line. I have more confidence in Rodgers.
Rodgers already has more unexpected 1 and dones than Favre. Favre gets blamed for all of his because they came down to a throw and Rodgers gets a pass because they don't, as if the game being over in the 3rd QTR is a positive. And why is everybody forgetting the 90s??? Not only the best QB but the best player. Period.
This interview aged well. Jennings was 100% correct about Rodgers listening to everything in the media about him and being 100% affected about everything being said. Rodgers is a fragile diva. Jennings nailed it years ago and we've seen it played out over the yrs.
ive seen PLENTY of moments where i see Rodgers looking at his receiver and nodding his head like that was my fault, or sorry. just salty jennings criticizing
Daniel Chachanashvili I agree, people don't realize that Rodgers is harder on himself than he is on anyone else he plays with. Just look at his reaction when he makes an uncharistically poor pass attenpt or throws a pick.
Jennings isn't the only one that has called out Rodgers. Finely and one of their assistant coaches has said he always blames other players
Maybe because they are to blame?
Daniel Chachanashvili I think he's just answering questions honestly. He gave Aaron his credit also
Y’all act like y’all were the ones receiving passes from Rodgers. I think Jennings was being truthful cause he even said he would rather play with Rodgers so he has no reason to lie.
They both are so entertaining to watch, it would be great to give them both the same offense and watch them go at it in a best of 7.
This is great sports television. I love the entire dynamic between Skip and Shannon.
Greg is brutally honest man lol gotta love him.
There's no wrong answer here folks. They all had great points. Rodger is a safer choice. Farve is more electric but more riskier. If I needed someone to carry my team all season long, then it's Rodgers. But if I need someone win a big game and make something special happen, then it's Farve.
Have you seen Aaron Rodgers play the Hail Mary plays vs Lions an Cardinals talk about Electric. Rodgers bring Electric plays
Favre had a better defense, and better backup QBs. For most of his career, Rodgers didn't have a good defense behind him. In fact, if Rodgers was incapacitated, the Packers would be lucky to win 4 games, since he has never had a good backup QB, and mostly, a lousy defense for the last 10 years.
Their defense looks pretty good this season, after they strengthened their LBs with some free agents, and if the Packers can get their players back healthy, they might go all the way.
When people are comparing Favre and Aaron they are really only considering the end of his career and all his interceptions but they don't factor in his prime years when he was a 3time MVP and brought the Packers to back to back Super Bowls. Why don't we wait till Aaron makes it to a second Super Bowl before we consider him GOD and the GOAT. He's good but he's not that good. I'll give Aaron top 10 QB's ever but he's not number 1
Brady
Montana
Elway
Manning
Marino
Then Rodgers
dude that's the dumbest thing I've ever heard Favre has always thrown double digit TDs, his whole career. 300 ints in 20 years that's 15 picks a year at least 1 a game, he's one of the worst decision makers in NFL history.
o8 shooter 9o lol I'm sorry I forgot when only 15 picks is a bad thing. No he's not super efficient but 15 a year isn't that bad at all it's a good ratio especially when he's throwing about 28-30 TD's
@@o8shooter9o58 1 a game compared to how many attempts... yeah he was just horrible being a 3x MVP and going to back to back Super Bowls...
I've been a LIFELONG First Take guy, dating way back to the Jay Crawford/Woody Paige days on cold pizza. I'm making the jump to UNDISPUTED solely because of Skip Bayless and there's no SAS
Dude, this is good stuff. There's no "adjective screaming" from SAS, which is a huge plus!
FAVRE 🐐!
I agree with him. Aaron is uptight but isn't that what you want
Yes, it's what makes him great. Skips entire argument against Aaron is basically that Skip likes Favre as a person more
He's tied for first with Peyton for the most wins, has the highest TD differential over a 20 year period, and has the most go ahead touchdowns when trailing ever. But those aren't significant right? You're a fuckboy.
And the fact that you put "if that is a record he holds" in parentheses in your comment shows me you don't know dick. Favres record starts streak is the most impressive record in sports and considered the most unbreakable with Joe DiMaggios hit streak a close second. Step your knowledge up.
Favre is WAAAAAY better. People just hate him because he kept coming back. The records that he held says it all.
Rodgers better then Farve. Career Passer Rating Rodgers 104 to Farve 86. Rodgers highest rated passer an best TD to INT ratio in NFL History. And Brett Farve most INTS in NFL History and not even First in TD passes anymore since Peyton Manning broke his TD pass record. Superbowl MVP Rodgers 1 to Farve 0. Lol Farve threw INTS to lose games for his teams in playoffs 2002 playoffs Rams 45-17 over Packers and Farve throw 6 INTS. And 2003 Playoffs OT loss Eagles 20-17 over Packers and Farve throw INT in overtime that led to loss. In 2007 NFC Championship Giants 23 to Packers 20 and Farve INT in OT his last pass in Lambeau that Lost Packers game. In 2009 NFC Championship Saints 31 to Vikings 28 and Brett Farve threw INT to Tracey Porter that cost Vikings a chance to win game with a FG and a superbowl appearance
BRETT FAVRE!!!! AKA THE GUNSLINGER!!!! ALL DAY SON!!!! ALL DAY!!!!
Somebody please .gif Skip at 1:26
You know his ass was LOVIN getting dirt on Rodgers
Brett is my favorite player ever and Aaron has talent. There's no right answer
Both shows are better, who would of thought, Max Kellerman is great with SAS, Kellerman coming from a boxing background is a bonus, he always brings it up, thanks Max, pure respect to the sweet science.
Lmao Skip is loving this with that Joker smile on his face.
Brett played in a different league, Aaron plays in the no fun league.
Brett threw too many ints
Rodgers barely throws picks. He's absolutely gonna go down as Top 3 ever.
Give me Brett all day.. ARog is a beast but he's TOO cautious....Brett at least makes the attempt. it was different whn he played with Reggie and Leroy, didnt take as many chances...didn't have to. It was whn that def fell off tht he became reckless because it was mist likely gone be a shoot out.
Rodgers, like Jennings said is tryn to b perfect. Sometimes you gotta put the ball in places that is THOUGHT it couldn't get. To ME ...THATS greatness.
There is another very good show I watch, but this is the best. The confrontations are very painful to listen to and accept at times, but it is so raw and honest. Great job. Keep up the good work.
Ffs it's Rodgers and it's not even close. Rodgers > Brady >>> Favre, child please
Damn, Skip can be real good when he is not trolling.
Loved Favre but there were a lot of times when the Pack lost playoff games because of his costly INTs. He did it with the Vikings to. Also Favre's playoff record isn't anything special either.
I love how Aaron isn't a turn over machine like Brett was...I'll say that.
It's strange how Skip loves to harp on Aaron Rodgers flaws but bushes aside Favre's. Skip is just mad that the Packers saw great potential in Rodgers and told Brett to GTFO so they could start Aaron. Skip somehow thinks Aaron is responsible for that lol. Let's not talk about the drama Favre caused on & off the field lol
Aaron Rodgers said relax and then ran the table...... 🐐
This made me love Aaron even more
gay huh!
Why
1. Tom Brady
2. Joe Montana
3. Peyton Manning
4. Brett Favre
5. John Elway
Imagine if they had to play in the others respective NFL era.
Favre had basically 1 season in the new NFL and killed it.
I wonder how Rodgers would have fared in the 90's game.
Rodgers worst year, 25 TDs 2 ints 5-11. Favre's worst year, 27 TDs 29 ints. 4-12. The numbers are something like that. Rodgers is better.
Shannon always articulate to the fullest...
Skip seems more open give his point of view.
Shannon comment at 11:50 kill me hahahahaha!!!
Ouch. They look really bad saying that Rodgers needed Jordy. Cause this playoffs Rodgers proved once and for all he doesn't need any receiver to be the best.
An Egg, but whatever
I’m pretty sure all quarterbacks need a WR🤦🏻♂️
George Gomez really they only need an Oline.
Nick rodgers doesnt need jordy, jordy needs rodgers
So is Rodgers gonna actually make the NFC championship this year?
As a packers, aaron, and Favre fan. I would have to agree with jennings. ever since the superbowl, Rodgers has been falling short when it really matter and I think a large part of that is exactly what jennings explained. overall, I'd take aaron Rodgers 24/7 over Favre but if I had one game and it was on the line I'd take favre.
Yeah that's worked well. I can't even begin to count how many time Favre threw mind-boggling stupid interceptions in those scenarios. At least with Rodgers, I know he won't throw a pick. Plus, he had a couple nice Hail-Mary throws last season with the game on the line. Would've had a chance to win the Cardinals game if the defense doesn't blow the game.
How many of those losses were on Arodg and not the defense? I can think of at least 4 different instances. Rodgers put the packers in position bit the opposing team won on a final possession.
The last 2 playoff games Green Bay lost were in overtime on the road and Green Bay never got a chance to touch the ball. The last game Favre had in Green Bay, he set the Giants up with a fg in overtime.
Rodgers would never do that.
remember when brett favre won the super bowl? i think i was 5 LOL
Yea I do, he was overdosing on pain pills. It's crazy that's when he was at his best.
Farve threw the pick in important situations.
People forget that even though Brett Favre had the most interceptions, he completed the most passes ever.
watching this right now for the first time and arod still hasnt changed
ill take Ryan Leaf
give me jamarcus russel
I like how Jennings mentioned that when Jordy went last year Rodgers needed help
96-97 Farve vs '10-.11 Rodgers.... so tough a comparison. But that's where the comparison should be made.
Favre's peak better then Aaron's
@@fasteddycj1980 I disagree Rodgers broke the record for passer rating that year for a reason. He threw more touchdowns and less interceptions If you compare their two best seasons
2012 vs Giants. I don’t recall Aaron Rodgers playing defense and allowing Hakeem Nicks 165 receiving yards and 2 TD. For real, football is a team game and you can play well at your position and still lose. Heck not only was Rodgers the QB but that game he was also the Packs leading rusher with 65 yards. He can only do so much in a game so why put the blame of a loss to the Giants on A-Rod and say he didn’t do enough?
Rodgers is just a more talented quarterback who makes better decisions with the football than Brett did. Personally I liked watching Brett more and enjoyed his playstyle more than Rodgers, but ARod's the guy. And time makes it easy to forget, but Favre came up short in the playoffs many times. Neither QB was/is an all time great clutch player.
Favre has thrown more go ahead TDs in the 4th quarter than any other QB ever. I guess that's not clutch tho right? Fuck outta here.
Bruh Favre was clutch as hell.. All those 4th quarter touchdown. Rodgers with all these clutch touchdowns ain't clutch? Get out of here man
I would take Rodgers over Farve all day. Career Passer Rating Rodgers 104 to Farve 86. Rodgers higher rated passer in NFL History and best TD to INT ratio in NFL History. Farve most INTS in NFL history. Superbowl MVPS Rodgers 1 to Farve 0. And Farve throw Playoff Games away 2002 playoff Farve 6 INTS in a 45-17 loss to Rams. In 2003 Playoff OT loss 20-17 to Eagles an Farve threw INT in OT to lose Packers the game. In 2007 NFC Championship 23 to 20 Packers OT loss to Giants and Farve last pass in Lambeau a INT to put Giants in position to win game.
fvgc454ss Nope I compare whole careers
Harry Garris this was one of the stupidest comments on this video
Durability goes to Favre. Aaron is brittle compared to #4.
Intermediate and short throws go to Favre. As bizarre as it sounds, Aaron can't throw screens like Brett could.
Deep throws go to Aaron. He throws those powerful, high arc spirals that really sail through the air.
Ball security goes to Aaron in a big way. He may be the least intercepted qb in nfl history.
Throwing on the run, I have to go Aaron. He may be the best I've ever seen.
Intangibles go to Favre, since Aaron holds on to the ball far too long waiting for the perfect window. Punts are technically turnovers in a roundabout way. Plus, Brett was the better teammate since he wasn't as high-strung as Aaron is. Aaron's thirst for perfection can wear on younger players in a negative way.
It's close, but I have to lean Brett.
Nobody is as tough as Brett Farve only ones who comes close are the Manning Bros, great arm, great playmaker and leader. Rodgers has better accuracy, field vision, best Td:Int ratio but if I had to pick one I'm going Farve
And get the ball picked off when it counts most because of brett's gunslinger mentality and always trying to make something happen.
Because he had to! Favre made the packers revelant while Aaron perfected his skills!!! LEADERSHIP MATTERS MUCH MORE THAN YOU THINK!!! NOT TO MENTION THE ABUSE HE WITHSTOOD. AARON WOULD FOLD IN THOSE GAMES Favre mever gave up!!
It's Rodgers who is more skilled and talented, but Favre was a more durable, more clutch, and a far better leader of a team. I hold Favre in more respect than I do Rodgers. Aaron is a bit of a narcissist premadonna
Greg: Aaron
Skip: WHY!
Brett was the Best Packers fan from 1963
how was last yr so bad? they lost in ot in arizona... it's not like they went 7-9
Would've won in OT if they won the coin toss TBH.
@@harrygarris6921 no they wouldnt have lol
As a Packer Fan this was a pleasure too watch!!!
I don't see how Rodgers being better than favre Viks took an 09 Viks to a nfc championship game which Viks got robbed in and I don't thing Rodgers could do
Favre also had an opportunity to win that game on the final drive but instead threw a game sealing pick.
And let's remember this was the bountybowl
Thank you.
People so easily dismiss how dirty the Saints were that year.
Yup hitting "too hard" is dirty. Even players from the 2009 vikings team said they had the same system. Actually read into it.
LarryKing there were mutiple late hits on favre and Viks in general. Saints strategy shouldn't of worked people like to blame favre for the loss because he threw the pick but forget to mention ap fumbled a couple times and even with ap fumbles Viks were still in position to win that game but Childress put 12 men on the field out of a time out to take Viks out of field goal range favre didn't cost Viks that game.
Greggs so right
Why do people wear a blazer and tie with jeans. Greg was looking smart until they showed his jeans
I guess he's not a.... "smarty pants"
ok... I'll go kill myself
he may have been under the idea his legs wouldn't show during the taping
He's still presentable. Plus you're allowed to wear jeans in corporate America. "Casual Fridays"
LOL @ Joseph Pullium
+Igbo King Business casual is without a tie as ties are considered formal.
I don’t care what Rodgers accomplished. One of the greatest games I’ve ever seen was when favre played right after his father passed and absolutely decimated the Raiders.
I remember watching that game and hearing the announcers talking about his dad's death. Simply incredible that he played, I wouldn't have expected him to even leave his house.
Aaron Rodgers TD:INT is 4:1, nobody else in nfl history is at 3:1
Derek Carr will be!
RAIDERSSSSSSSS!
nuff said!
aaron rodgers is below 4:1 also russel wilson is above 3:1
Luis Galvez get out of here
It's possible Carr becomes one of the all-time greats. I actually see it coming and yes I do believe he'll be a 3:1 QB one day.
@@luisgalvez4303 Well this comment didn't age well...
They really have similar careers. I can also see Rodgers leaving Green Bay if they miss playoffs next year.
Since 2008 Aaron Rodgers has averaged about 32 TDS and 8 INTS which is the best TD to INT rate in NFL history and way better than Brett Favres
not to mention the receivers who ran drags deep posts and fades up the seam had to be men back when you could lau n ch oh my boy
Rodgers has talent to play in any era even in 90s. With Rodgers mobile to buy time and escape and throw rockets downfield outside the pocket. Rodgers can buy time to get WR open downfield even if WR get grab by Corners. And Rodgers more Accurate then Farve. Rodgers doesn't throw bone headed INTS like Farve does. Career Passer Rating Rodgers 104 to Farve 96. Rodgers highest rated passer and best TD to INT ratio in NFL History. Superbowl MVPS Rodgers 1 to Farve 0. Give me Rodgers over Farve
Tod Wilkinson Lmao Lmao Rodgers doesn't have a long ball False. Rodgers Hail Mary vs Lions and Cardinals. Rodgers 61 yard hail Mary vs Lions nearly hit the roof of Ford Field. And Rodgers Hail Mary in playoff game to Jeff Janis in playoff Game. So stop talking until you can come with Facts
Tod you're a fool he's got #1 defense this year. He's never won a superbowl without a top 5 defense lol.
Aaron Rodgers is one of the 3 best QB's of all time so the other two are Tom Brady and Peyton Manning not Brett Favre, Aaron Rodgers established he was the Greatest Packers QB ever years ago now the rest of his career will determine if he'll go down as the best of all time.
When you think about the 2010 Packers' recieving corps, and the fact that they got hot and healthy at the right time (10-4 reg season) i think that the recieving corps never got due credit for that SB season.
The BACKUP QB has the all-time GB passing yards record with that group.
Once they broke up THAT band, the Packers were never the same.
AR will never see another Super Bowl in GB.
They're both all time great QBs. But Jennings and Skip have great points, Favre is an electric player or electric playmaker. I would take Favre by an edge. But there is risk with this selection.
And what's Aaron, Aaron can do the same thing and even better than favre with his legs
I agree with you Matthew
That's laughable, the guy was a great QB but he also threw alot of int, Rodgers will be the better QB when he retires and have more superbowls
Lol no
Being from wisco I can tell you farve was a pick machine it was disgusting he stuck around way way too long threw way to many risky passes and arguably had better receivers.
I will say, I don’t watch Undisputed, don’t really plan on starting. But it is very refreshing having a moderator that doesn’t interrupt every 5 seconds.
Looking back from years later, this is Skip at his best. And he's right, I'd take Brett Favre over Rodgers all day every day.
LMAOO stop capping
Your coked out
As a Cowboys fan I hate Aaron Rodgers but you can’t blame Rodgers for not getting to the Super Bowl, their defense isn’t that good.
He will never fill Favres shoes
Lmao!!!!!! Rodgers making his own shoes and doesn't care to be in or near Farves shoes. Mr INT in playoff games waiting to happen
Rodgers is in a tier all his own, it's called the highest tier.
Is that why he got sent home in the playoffs?
he already did
Most people dont know what they are talking about when it comes to packers history. I've watched both play. Brett Favre always had a defense. Favre also had great receivers and tight ends and a good running back. I dont think we can say the same for Aaron rodgers. Stop being emotional.
The risk is needed and worth it in playoffs . I'd choose Favre over Rodgers for that reason alone .
I take it your not a Vikings fan if you think the risk is good in the playoffs
Shannon says he is an Aaron guy, but someone should remind him that Aaron's never really been a Tight End kind of guy.
Zero8880 that’s funny. But with Jimmy he’s a tight end guy lol
Aaron Rodgers is the best quarterback of all time
One of the best segments I've seen from any show.
This is an easy one. Hands down, Aarron Rodgers all day any day over Favre.The numbers and results speak for themselves.
What results? Favre lead his team to 2 SB when Rodgers has only been to one
Beautiful debate. I agree with Greg on everything, especially on Brett being the better overall. he did make more with less. Aaron compliments great wide receiving play.
Rodgers is already a top 5 qb ever imo..
no hes not lol
They should have added Donald Drivers, Sterling Sharpe, and Jordy Nelson to this discussion. I would watch all day.
Yall are crazy Aaron Rodgers EZ
I think alot of people arguing Brett is better would change their opinion by now. This was almost a decade ago. Rodgers is by far better then brett
It seems like they thought there was water in the cup but Shannon and Greg didn't realize there wasn't until they lifted the cup.
last year he still threw 30 plus TDs , Brady couple years without gronk wasn't even top 25 in Rating and had only 25 TDs
*ago
and they at least won the division with a 12-4 record.. and went to the afc title game . hmm ill take those 25tds
easy path to the afc title games, afc is a cake walk
Henry Street lets see .. BB system in 2013.. gronk out.. dola out... Edelman in and out.. aqib talib out.. mayo and wilkfork out for the season. Collins was a rookie.. Brady's running backs blount and vereen. Neither finished the year with 800 yards rushing.. oh BB system with browns was 36-44 in 5 years.. oh he just didn't go 11-5 without brady.. he went 5-11 in 2000.. and started 0-2 in 2001. Before Brady took over... Hmm 12-4 sounds more like BB doing everything.. and Brady just sitting..
Derek S easy path... Steelers.. ravens.. bengals... Colts.. broncos... Chiefs.. very easy.. why don't you go play in the afc?
Aaron is incredible but I’m picking Brett
5 years ago this was a fair debate
But the fact u said this 2 months ago is hilarious
He's borderline the goat
Farve isn't even in rodgera convo anymore