I took my Shahada on the 8:th of January this year. I just realised that this might be one of my toughest challenges going forward. I'm thankful for the explanation and I now know what has to be done. Goodbye Disco. Goodbye Funk and Goodbye Jazz. It will be hard, but I can do it. Inshallah. Love from Sweden.
May Allah bless you There are born Muslim into Muslim family and they still justify using it without any evidence, and then we have Muslims like you who reverted very recently and acknowledges its Haram and is also willing to quit it for the Sake of Allah! Keep going brother, Pleasure of Allah is more than anything.
exactly, when one knows he's committing a sin.... there's a chance that he will repent for the sin. but if you think of it as halal.... how would one repent for this particular sin? i heard somewhere... he said that he prefer that his son commit sin and know it is sin, rather than bid'ah. no one would ever repent for the bidáh they are in, because they actually think this is sunnah !!
I used to listen to music on spotify etc. all the time, even to sleep. I was a singer- opera and jazz, and played violin and piano. After recently reverting to Islam (from athiesm) I haven't listened to music or felt the need to. That was just natural, I didn't know till now that it's haram, I'm just starting Islamic studies now. As a neuroscientist I know how frequencies affect the brain and body (they are connected of course) so I can understand the haram reasoning scientifically. Looking at it that way it is really interesting and understandable that there is evidence for it being haram. When Islam entered my heart, music naturally left as if there was no need or space for it, Alhamdullilah. Just sharing my personal experience. Only Allah SWT knows best
You have a very interesting story brother. May Allah put Baraka in your life and rectify your affairs. I woild suggest learning basic aqeedah first like kitaab at tawheed. Maybe sheikh tim humble has an explanation on that
Alhamdulillah Allah has created people like you so that people like me wouldn't go astray. May Allah give barakh to your ilm and may we keep benefiting.
I agree, I stopped listening to music completely and I was more focused on my salah and reading the Quran and now when I hear music my head hurts so I try distincing myself away from it as much as I can. Alhamdullah now I am focused more on what I am supposed to do and I rely on the Quran and salah instead of music to motive and heal my heart.❤️🤲
Uthman says traditionally music by ijma is haram, recently to Nouman Ali Khan opened up his mistakes this topic. Uthman spoke to nak in a chat with eddy, nak brought a faqih and muhadith to view the evidence music is haram or show us evidence otherwise. NAK and his crew left the group and didn't reply. CIip : Nak says i want to know why music is haram, i am not an expert in hadith and know my limit. I research Quran, it's not talked of but it can tie to Quran 31.6, ibn Abbas's opinion is music is haram but this view is not sahih, the isnad has a drunk. Uthman says you say you are not an expert but then you go on to talk about it, then you call someone a drunk and you don't even mention who it is, this is not academic. I in the chat asked him who is the drunk & he didn't reply. There are many chains, it's not just ebn Abbas there are other sahabas and there is no contradiction. Ibn Hatim has a hadith of ebn Abbas, Musat tafsir Mathu Qatada, Mujahid all said Quran 31.6 is a reference to music. 6 independent chains, Saaed ibn Jubair, Abu saleh, Aitiyah, Mujahid all with independent chains says ibn Abbas held this view. (6.40 - picture of this 6 chains) ibn Abbas from Hasana al Basri from Ata other scholars from tabi'un said this ayat means Music! Hadith Prophet peace and blessings be upon him made du'a for ibn Abbas to understand Quran. Ebn Masud, Prophet peace and blessings be upon him said take Quran from him, also said this. It's not scholar to say i heard from anonymous who hides the truth! Sunan Kabir Bayhaqi, Abdullah ibn MD or Abi dunya, from Zuhair ibn Hard (faqih), Jarir ibn Hazir (strong scholar per dhahabi), Ata ibn Sa'eb (tabi'in) , Saeed ibn Jubayr (scholar of Madina) to ibn Abbas Uthman asks where is the drunk (oh Nouman)? How dare you? Ebn Masud said Wallahi it means music, authentic by jariri and ibn Abi dunya! Bagawi we will mention later. 10 :30 - From greatest scholar of hadith authentication, ibn Hajr, he has takrij or hadith checking werk called talqis, he said hadith of ebn Masud i sahih, ibn abi Shayba, Hakim and Bayhaqi all said it's sahih. Mustadark ibn Hatim has the chain. Uthman says I will go through the chain with you again. Is there any da'if or drunk in this isnad. Abul Abbas Md Yaqub (hafeth, faqi Shafi'i), from Baqkkar ibn Qutaybah (hanafi judge), from Safwan ibn Isa al Qadi (abut Hatim said he was saleh, MD Saad said he is saleh & Qadi) from Humayd Kuraat (YahYa Ma'in said he is thiqqah) from Saeed ibn Jubayr to Ebn Masud! Al Hakim & Dhahabi said it's sahih! Many says this includes tahrim or prohibition of music! Nak cIip : I asked Akram Nadawi , he said there is no sahih hadith! Uthman : there is hadith in Bukari, it even has the entire chain so if you are not an expert why talk about it. Best popular explanation is fathul Bari ibn Hajr, he says this hadith is Sahih! 15 :10 - Sh Albani in his Masu, says this isnad is sahih. Ibn Uthaymin says in shar al Mumteh says this hadith is sahih! Nak cIip : hanafi and south asian imams say no issue with music but we won't say it in public. Uthman : if this was private why do you speak, and if they are ashamed to speak publicly there is something wrong. Mathhab isn't a random scholar. you have to reference the books of that mathhab. you can't just say this secret person said Umar Abdul Aziz said you openly allowing instruments is an innovation in Islam! (found in sanai) abu Layth Samarqandi Hanafi says i't ijma of umma music is haram Abdul Barr Maliki says Music is haram to all the faiths. Bagawi in Shar sunna Shafi'i there is ijm3 wind, string and all other instruments are haram. ibn Hajr Haytham shafi'i in ijm3 music is haram ibn Qudama Hanbali in Mugni v12 page 457 20 :00 - ibn Rajab in his shar Bukhari says ijm3 music is haram Qurtubi says flutes, drums no iktilaf it's haram to listen to. Ruhual M3ni Alusi says Abu Hanifa forbid musical instruments, sticks. Say don't say hanafis are ok with music, Abu Hanifa and his students aren't! ibn Qayyim said Hanafis are strictest on music, and said it's a fisq to listen to string or drum or other music to reject their testimony, to enjoy music is kuffer. Shafi'i in umm said music is haram Ibn Jawzi said ibn Hanbal said all music is haram except few exceptions. Ibn Taymiyyah in majmua fatawa say all 4 mathhab say Music is haram. Ibn Baz, Uthaymin, Albani, Fawzan all say it's haram there maybe a random imam that says it ok. Ibn Hanbal said if you took the mistake of every scholar you will gather every eviI. a doubt ppl bring, hadith a girI played a duff for Prophet Muhammad peace and blessings be upon him. there is general and specific ruling. like zhur is 4 rakat & when traveling it is 2, you can sit at home and take the specific travel ruling and do it all the time. Bukhari 949, reported by Aisha there were lil girIs playing duff talking about a battIe, Abu Bakr said instruments of deveI in house of the prophet, *Prophet peace and blessings be upon him said leave them it's Eid.** So Sahaba knew music is haram but this is an exception is duff on Eid or in another hadith for nika! supported in ibn Majah Hadith use duff is halal to announce the nikah. another doubt by nak not ok, there is music playing everywhere. Uthman says there is difference between unintentionally listening to music or going to listen to it. if you go to a job and music plays that's not in your control. other sins are everywhere, gossiping, zina does that make it halal. seeing a girI loosely cIothed and going to watch videos are different, same way hearing music in pubIic and then going to listen to music on the net is different! to do a sin isn't kuffer to make halal what is haram is a Iine you shouldn't cros ( & is kuffer)
Honesly when i listen music the more i listen and avoid quran but when i listen and read quran i avoid music most of the time this is a lesson for me and understanding how music isnt good for me
I am a big admirer of both Sheikh Uthman and brother Nouman. That's why it was very sad to see brother Nouman say these things. I still like to believe he is a sincere Muslim and a good person, so I will pray that Allah guides him further
If Nouman is sincere he should repent not only for saying music is halal but wrongly calling a person a drunk, this are our Muslim elders who struggled so we can practice Islam today, I am shocked he said he won't mention names and he says his imams hide the truth, this is not Islam. Our Quran and hadith are preserved and open!
There are several other controversies surrounding NAK which I don’t want to get into. I suggest you dig deeper. I was always listening to NAK until these issues came up and now prevent me from taking knowledge from him anymore.
@@staypatient2816 he is using Salafi abridged references!! That’s not proof it’s like when they say this was authenticated by Albani that doesn’t make sense
I once was a musician, wielding the power of orchestras to create everything from progressive metal to cinematic soundtracks. Yet, I chose to silence that, destroying my instruments and leaving music behind. Now, in this quiet, I've found a profound peace. Alhamdulillah. 🤲🏼
From Oshawa, Ontario…Jazak Allahu Khairan, Brother for your researched response to this matter. I love and respect the scholars in Islam…I have benefited tremendously from Ustath Nouman’s Qur’anic lectures…I ask Allah for His Guidance for the Ummah of His beloved Rasul (SAW).
Desert bandit,never heard that one😂😂 May Allah guide you ! Out prophet didn't "ban" anything, he basically told us to stay away from things which distract us from the remembrance of Allah .
He took a married woman into his house then married her before her divorce and it was a woman married to a friend of his at the time. Is this a line that Allah allows to be crossed ⁉️⁉️⁉️
Br. Naumans opinion is pretty popular in Canada and I started to think the same that music is not haram. Glad you made this video Sheikb Uthman. This is very helpful
@@khaledhussain3214 it actually a prophesy of the prophet PBUH that peoples from his Ummah will consider it permissible. It's sad and it's a sign of the Hour.
Stop watching these people for detailed Fiqh issues. They literally have no idea what they're talking about... LITERALLY! No offense, but these individuals are Dawah specialists. (I think Naumans is Quran Science specialist) But Fiqh is a completely dark place for both of them. Fiqh is not "Quran and Hadith", Fiqh is an entirely separate science. I wasted too much time reading about music in Islam in Arabic Fiqh books, just out of curiosity. But eventually, I found the best source you can check: the Egyptian Dar al-Ifta. I wish I had read their article first because it summarizes everything so well. And yes, if you say music is Haram, you are CORRECT. If you say it is Halal, you are also CORRECT. It’s one of those issues where both opinions are valid. What’s wrong, though, is believing that your opinion is the ultimate truth and accusing others of committing Haram just because they don’t follow your perspective. This is called "Ignorance". So, if you want proper Fiqh, follow the established schools of thought, not TH-camrs. These people are good for Dawah, which is great, but Fiqh is another field entirely. You need to look into the opinions of Al-Azhar and the Egyptian Dar al-Ifta.
@@Funblend-zd6dt what load of rabbish, Fiqh is based on Quran and Sunnah, if you ignore Quran and Sunnah then you are not a muslim, without evidence from Quran or Sunnah, your opinion is worth less, and listening to Egypt ifta' which says RIBBA is halal is a sign of misguidance.
Main problem is that people are taking NAK’s “opinion” when he isn’t qualified to even hold an opinion of his own. And then he doesn’t name the supposedly scholar he takes from which in and of itself is a red flag.
*"The love of the Quran and the love of music cannot coexist in the heart of a believer, for they are two opposites. One drives out the other, and the heart must choose between them."* -Ibn al Qayyim
Who are we the common people without our teachers, without our ăleem, explaining the Quran, explaining the religion. They are our shepherds after the departure of our Prophet Muhammad(saw). We pray to Almighty to grant them knowledge, understanding, and wisdom.
I am grateful that Allah let Ustadh Nouman, a popular speaker, talk about Music when it is not his expertise. And in reaction to that, we got a high quality and deep academic discussion video from Sheikh Uthman about this subject. May Allah bless both with rahmah and guide both to stay on the straigh path.
Music is not Haram, Nobody can prove it is Haram. These are evidences..👇 So Fear Allah not the Sectarians. 1. Whatever ALLAH leaves without saying Haram are halal by default. General Fiqh rule. 100s of Scholars including Imam Al Gazzali, Shiekh Ibn Hazm, Sheikh Ibn Arabi, Sheikh Khardavi, etc., openly said "music in itself is not haram". 2. HADITHS - Prophet(SA) allowed music with instruments in his own house during Eid - Sahih Bukhari 987, 988, 3931, 949, 952. 3. HADITHS - Prophet(SA) compared the quran recitation of a companion Abu Musa(r) to the musical rhythmic sound of Mazamir(wind instruments, flute). - Sahih Bukhari 5048, Al Adab Al Mufrad 805, Al-Adab Al-Mufrad 1087. 4. HADITHS - Prophet Muhammad(SA) invited singers to a wedding function to sing - Sunan Ibn Mājah 1900. 5. That "Bukhari hadis 5590 which says musical instruments are haram in an indirect way" is a hanged hadis or an un-numbered hadis in bukhari text. Classical Scholar Sheikh Ibn Hazm stated that the chain of this hadith is broken. Also this hadith is an indirect statement, we cannot take this hadith as a solid evidence. 6. Only ALLAH has the authority to declare Haram. Scholars do not have that authority. Inorder to consider anything as Haram it requires solid authentic evidences. Do not falsely declare with your tongues, “This is lawful, and that is unlawful,” ˹only˺ fabricating lies against Allah. Indeed, those who fabricate lies against Allah will never succeed. - Quran 16:116
@@Abigoria1 Music is not Haram, Nobody can prove it is Haram. These are evidences..👇 So Fear Allah not the Sectarians. 1. Whatever ALLAH leaves without saying Haram are halal by default. General Fiqh rule. 100s of Scholars including Imam Al Gazzali, Shiekh Ibn Hazm, Sheikh Ibn Arabi, Sheikh Khardavi, etc., openly said "music in itself is not haram". 2. HADITHS - Prophet(SA) allowed music with instruments in his own house during Eid - Sahih Bukhari 987, 988, 3931, 949, 952. 3. HADITHS - Prophet(SA) compared the quran recitation of a companion Abu Musa(r) to the musical rhythmic sound of Mazamir(wind instruments, flute). - Sahih Bukhari 5048, Al Adab Al Mufrad 805, Al-Adab Al-Mufrad 1087. 4. HADITHS - Prophet Muhammad(SA) invited singers to a wedding function to sing - Sunan Ibn Mājah 1900. 5. That "Bukhari hadis 5590 which says musical instruments are haram in an indirect way" is a hanged hadis or an un-numbered hadis in bukhari text. Classical Scholar Sheikh Ibn Hazm stated that the chain of this hadith is broken. Also this hadith is an indirect statement, we cannot take this hadith as a solid evidence. 6. Only ALLAH has the authority to declare Haram. Scholars do not have that authority. Inorder to consider anything as Haram it requires solid authentic evidences. Do not falsely declare with your tongues, “This is lawful, and that is unlawful,” ˹only˺ fabricating lies against Allah. Indeed, those who fabricate lies against Allah will never succeed. - Quran 16:116
@@syckle33 Music is not Haram, Nobody can prove it is Haram. These are evidences..👇 So Fear Allah not the Sectarians. 1. Whatever ALLAH leaves without saying Haram are halal by default. General Fiqh rule. 100s of Scholars including Imam Al Gazzali, Shiekh Ibn Hazm, Sheikh Ibn Arabi, Sheikh Khardavi, etc., openly said "music in itself is not haram". 2. HADITHS - Prophet(SA) allowed music with instruments in his own house during Eid - Sahih Bukhari 987, 988, 3931, 949, 952. 3. HADITHS - Prophet(SA) compared the quran recitation of a companion Abu Musa(r) to the musical rhythmic sound of Mazamir(wind instruments, flute). - Sahih Bukhari 5048, Al Adab Al Mufrad 805, Al-Adab Al-Mufrad 1087. 4. HADITHS - Prophet Muhammad(SA) invited singers to a wedding function to sing - Sunan Ibn Mājah 1900. 5. That "Bukhari hadis 5590 which says musical instruments are haram in an indirect way" is a hanged hadis or an un-numbered hadis in bukhari text. Classical Scholar Sheikh Ibn Hazm stated that the chain of this hadith is broken. Also this hadith is an indirect statement, we cannot take this hadith as a solid evidence. 6. Only ALLAH has the authority to declare Haram. Scholars do not have that authority. Inorder to consider anything as Haram it requires solid authentic evidences. Do not falsely declare with your tongues, “This is lawful, and that is unlawful,” ˹only˺ fabricating lies against Allah. Indeed, those who fabricate lies against Allah will never succeed. - Quran 16:116
Perfect example of how to correct others and how to protect the deen. Barakallahu fik ❤️ This is how deen has been protected throughout the history of Islam. Wallahi This video itself is a proof for islam being the correct religion. Jazakallahu khairan
Music is not Haram, Nobody can prove it is Haram. These are evidences..👇 So Fear Allah not the Sectarians. 1. Whatever ALLAH leaves without saying Haram are halal by default. General Fiqh rule. 100s of Scholars including Imam Al Gazzali, Shiekh Ibn Hazm, Sheikh Ibn Arabi, Sheikh Khardavi, etc., openly said "music in itself is not haram". 2. HADITHS - Prophet(SA) allowed music with instruments in his own house during Eid - Sahih Bukhari 987, 988, 3931, 949, 952. 3. HADITHS - Prophet(SA) compared the quran recitation of a companion Abu Musa(r) to the musical rhythmic sound of Mazamir(wind instruments, flute). - Sahih Bukhari 5048, Al Adab Al Mufrad 805, Al-Adab Al-Mufrad 1087. 4. HADITHS - Prophet Muhammad(SA) invited singers to a wedding function to sing - Sunan Ibn Mājah 1900. 5. That "Bukhari hadis 5590 which says musical instruments are haram in an indirect way" is a hanged hadis or an un-numbered hadis in bukhari text. Classical Scholar Sheikh Ibn Hazm stated that the chain of this hadith is broken. Also this hadith is an indirect statement, we cannot take this hadith as a solid evidence. 6. Only ALLAH has the authority to declare Haram. Scholars do not have that authority. Inorder to consider anything as Haram it requires solid authentic evidences. Do not falsely declare with your tongues, “This is lawful, and that is unlawful,” ˹only˺ fabricating lies against Allah. Indeed, those who fabricate lies against Allah will never succeed. - Quran 16:116
@@KashifKhursheed-ng1vk of course we are not nobody said so, but Allah chooses whoever he will like the prophet (pbut) the sahaba their students and so on, we are merely his slaves.
Sheikh may Allah bless you in your ability to keep it REAL. Its very refreshing hearing u speak with facts and evidence and not watering down you're message simply because of who who you're speaking in regards to. Hope this message reached you.
What an in impeccable approach! May Allah grant all the Ulamas and us all the thawfick to approach all our matters in such a respectful, academic and diplomatic manner; ameen. Sheikh Uthman setting the bar!
Jazakallahu Khayran My Beloved Sheikh Othman. This was well needed. Because a new fitna is coming out recently about "music is halal" astaghfirullah. May Allah protect us from all kind of fitnah.
A new fitna? Music has literally been around in the muslim world for centuries. There are literally dozens for muslim music genre invented by muslims. It's not new
Music is not Haram, Nobody can prove it is Haram. These are evidences..👇 So Fear Allah not the Sectarians. 1. Whatever ALLAH leaves without saying Haram are halal by default. General Fiqh rule. 100s of Scholars including Imam Al Gazzali, Shiekh Ibn Hazm, Sheikh Ibn Arabi, Sheikh Khardavi, etc., openly said "music in itself is not haram". 2. HADITHS - Prophet(SA) allowed music with instruments in his own house during Eid - Sahih Bukhari 987, 988, 3931, 949, 952. 3. HADITHS - Prophet(SA) compared the quran recitation of a companion Abu Musa(r) to the musical rhythmic sound of Mazamir(wind instruments, flute). - Sahih Bukhari 5048, Al Adab Al Mufrad 805, Al-Adab Al-Mufrad 1087. 4. HADITHS - Prophet Muhammad(SA) invited singers to a wedding function to sing - Sunan Ibn Mājah 1900. 5. That "Bukhari hadis 5590 which says musical instruments are haram in an indirect way" is a hanged hadis or an un-numbered hadis in bukhari text. Classical Scholar Sheikh Ibn Hazm stated that the chain of this hadith is broken. Also this hadith is an indirect statement, we cannot take this hadith as a solid evidence. 6. Only ALLAH has the authority to declare Haram. Scholars do not have that authority. Inorder to consider anything as Haram it requires solid authentic evidences. Do not falsely declare with your tongues, “This is lawful, and that is unlawful,” ˹only˺ fabricating lies against Allah. Indeed, those who fabricate lies against Allah will never succeed. - Quran 16:116
It's clear that music has the power to shift our mood, get us to clicking, taping, or moving our body, and even bring back memories (if we have any). It doesn't even necessarily need lyrics; just the rhythm or frequency alone is enough to influence our emotions or thoughts. Seriously, take a moment to ponder upon this, brothers and sisters in Islam.
Moreover one of the biggest The biggest problem with music is that it keeps playing in your mind even when you aren't listening to it. Those who listen to this know this.
@@ibnefayaz5107, i am a music addict and listen day and night to it and what you said is absolutely true ,even the moments im not listening to music i still hear it in my souĺ , its like some magic thats taken the soul over
This is why so many people are enamored by it and find it hard to leave. They consider it a beautiful thing. Definitely one of the more difficult tests for us.
Who made music haram?. The quran, no! The quran is always in the favour of the middle path. "Don't listen to vain words". Thats very much specific and details. Thats the quran, god words HIM self
I love the engagement and opinions with reference to the HQ and Hadeeth. It’s so respectful and insightful - MAY ALMIGHTY ALLAH BLESS BOTH BROTHERS AND CONTINUE TO INCREASE THRM IN KNOWLEDGE AND WISDOM. Aameen
Noman Ali Khan's video on music has 75k views posted a year ago. Shaykh Uthman's video has 74k views posted 5 hours ago. So glad to see what's more important to Muslims. Barakumullah.
Music takes out the sweetness and enjoyment of prayer and reading/listening Quran out of your heart. You will realize this quite easily if you are sincere to yourself. Once you get rid of music (addiction), you will start enjoying prayer and listening to Quran gradually again, untill you reach a point where you hate listening to music, even if you really used to love those songs in the past.
This is really sad that you believe this. You can enjoy both. Forget about the lyrics : Music is just beauty in certain vibrations of the air. A nice painting is just beauty in certain vibrations of the light. Our creator is an artist of the highest order, just look at the magnificence in the skies. If we follow this "logic" of despising music, why shoud we limit at this art ? If we are to forbid music, even without any lyrics... Lets forbid paintings, architecture, etc. The road to hell is always paved with the best of intentions.
@Onib-q9p Listen, I don't need to dive into nonsense analogies of paintings and buildings or even my emotional argument.. you reacting on this video means you listenend to this clear lecture full of evidence and proof. IF you are still stubborn, rejecting evidences of scripture and prophetic sayings because you just want to justify some stupid desire out of addiction, cravings or entertainment, then there is nothing left to explain or discuss. You heart is sealed even if an angel came down to tell you music is haram. You do as you please.
@@SoufBouchahati We do not know if those are true prophetic sayings at all. There is no way on earth to demonstrate those are authentic sayings. The earliest were written 250 years after his death. While many hadiths may be true, some are demonstrably false by contradicting Quran head on. This is simple common sense. If those prohibitions were valid & important, they would have been included in the Quran, for starters.
@@Onib-q9pthey were written 250 years after the death of the prophet do you think we are chrsitains 😂😂 , al bukhari didnt write the ahadith but he creat a systems where he check every hadtih and his narration tree he goes for every one in the narration and check his biography and based on a lot o facture he got the much of authentification of the hadith , remember saying al bukhari is not compatible to get work with is like saying that sunnah is false and its corrupted and it lead to believe that islam is corrupted and that the prophet is a flase prophet ve careful akhi and go and search how al bukhari got the book and how . Quran says to follow the prophet if you say al bukhari is wrong then gow would you follow the prohet seikh al shaarawi explain the music problem bery good recommende watch his explanation and if you don't understand arabic just tell me here and im gonna give you the translation
SubhanAllah this is amazing. So needed in today’s world, JazakAllahu khairan ya shaykh Uthman. Refuted in a polite and academic way. Compared to "some secret scholar somewhere allowed music whose name I cannot mention who will never say it in public" 😂😂
I just love to see how traditional Islamic scholarship is defended by hook or by crook! May Allah persevere Sheikh Uthman. He is such a blessing for this Ummah!
This is also why we got to avoid ppl attacking the sunna like dan Taqiyajou. He cIaims to be anti Iib but he is an internal Iib that made way for all the devision & external Iib stuff!
Jazak Allahu Khaire. Its sad to see brothers and sisters making halal what was made haram for us, and justifying it. If you are too weak to stop, thats a different topic, may Allah give you the strength to do so. But never ever justify your sins, make them small or even claim its permissible.
Narrated Aisha: Allah's Apostle (p.b.u.h) came to my house while two girls were singing beside me the songs of Buath (a story about the war between the two tribes of the Ansar, the Khazraj and the Aus, before Islam). The Prophet (p.b.u.h) lay down and turned his face to the other side. Then Abu Bakr came and spoke to me harshly saying, "Musical instruments of Satan near the Prophet (p.b.u.h) ? " Allah's Apostle (p.b.u.h) turned his face towards him and said, "Leave them." When Abu Bakr became inattentive, I signaled to those girls to go out and they left. It was the day of 'Id, and the Black people were playing with shields and spears; so either I requested the Prophet (p.b.u.h) or he asked me whether I would like to see the display. I replied in the affirmative. Then the Prophet (p.b.u.h) made me stand behind him and my cheek was touching his cheek and he was saying, "Carry on! O Bani Arfida," till I got tired. The Prophet (p.b.u.h) asked me, "Are you satisfied (Is that sufficient for you)?" I replied in the affirmative and he told me to leave. From Bukhari Volume 2, Book 15, Number 70:
This same Hadith is reported to us again in Sahih Muslim: Book 004, Number 1942: 'A'isha reported: The Messenger of Allah (way peace be upon him) came (in my apartment) while there were two girls with me singing the song of the Battle of Bu'ath. He lay down on the bed and turned away his face. Then came Abu Bakr and he scolded me and said: Oh! this musical instrument of the devil in the house of the Messenger of Allah (may peace be upon him)! The Messenger of Allah (may peace be upon him) turned towards him and said: Leave them alone. And when he (the Holy Prophet) became inattentive, I hinted them and they went out, and it was the day of 'Id and negroes were playing with shields and spears. (I do not remember) whether I asked the Messenger of Allah (may peace be upon him) or whether he said to me if I desired to see (that sport). I said: Yes. I stood behind him with his face parallel to my face, and he said: O Banu Arfada, be busy (in your sports) till I was satiated. He said (to me): Is that enough? I said: Yes. Upon this he asked me to go.
Once again in Bukhari, this event is recorded: Volume 5, Book 58, Number 268: Narrated Aisha: That once Abu Bakr came to her on the day of 'Id-ul-Fitr or 'Id ul Adha while the Prophet was with her and there were two girl singers with her, singing songs of the Ansar about the day of Buath. Abu Bakr said twice. "Musical instrument of Satan!" But the Prophet said, "Leave them Abu Bakr, for every nation has an 'Id (i.e. festival) and this day is our 'Id." And then in Bukhari, another Hadith relates a connection between musical instruments and the family of David (saw). Further evidence that, indeed, the Psalms were musical in nature
Volume 6, Book 61, Number 568: Narrated Abu Musa: That the Prophet said to him' "O Abu Musa! You have been given one of the musical wind-instruments of the family of David .' And on one final note, I thought the following Hadith can also be used in the matter. The Hadith relates of how the adhan came to be, and how the Prophet's companions suggested the use of musical instruments such as the horn or bell like the People of the Book. Now although the Prophet ultimately approved the use of the human voice, there is no mention that the Prophet chastised his companions for suggesting musical instruments for the adhan. And if the Prophet was so very much against musical instruments, then why would his companions dare to suggest the use of such sinful things in the call to prayer????
From Muslim Book 004, Number 0735: Ibn Umar reported: When the Muslims came to Medina, they gathered and sought to know the time of prayer but no one summoned them. One day they discussed the matter, and some of them said: Use something like the bell of the Christians and some of them said: Use horn like that of the Jews. Umar said: Why may not a be appointed who should call (people) to prayer? The Messenger of Allah (may peace be upon him) said: O Bilal, get up and summon (the people) to prayer.
@@OmerAhmed-yw1lg “Whatever the Messenger gives you, take it. And whatever he forbids you from, leave it. And fear Allah. Surely Allah is severe in punishment.”( Quran 59:7)
Alhamdulillah I have quited music since start of October and it's far esaier than what people thought May Allah(s.w.t) make it more easier for the ummah of islam
The Non muslims believe Allah is UNJUST because ALLAH guides whom he wills ➜ but the TRUTH is all those who are NOT guided, should ONLY blame themselves because Allah guides not the wrongdoers ( unjust ) ( 📗Quran 5 : 51 ) Allah does not guide one who is a transgressor & an extreme liar.’ ( 📗Quran 4O : 28 )
Commenting for the Algorithm. May Allah accept it from us. May Allah forgive us, keep us on the straight path, and grant us Jennathul Firdous. I love you, sheikh, for the sake of Allah.
Respectfully the Shaikh has produced what he considers to be 'evidence' and for it to be considered proof one would have to examine the 'evidence' to establish whether it reaches the status of proof. At 25:39 mins the Shaikh talked about generality and exceptions which addresses events at which music would be permitted but if it was a prohibition like all other explicit prohibitions then there would be no exceptions. As an example the Qur'an instructs us to eat unlawful foods if our life is in danger because of hunger unless the exceptions are explicitly mentioned! After all there is no way the Prophet Muhammad SAW would go against an explicit prohibition ( if it was explicitly prohibited) it seems from the evidence there is no explicit prohibition on music.
Jzk khairan for giving a clear and logical explanation. Even without these explanations, I know from experience how my connection with Allah, Salah, Quran , everything gets affected the days I fall short and listen to music. Trying to be better, what we get without music in our lives, is far superior and brings real peace and tranquility that once we realize, we stop looking for loopholes to bring music into our lives. May Allah help us all🤲🏼
It was brother Nouman Ali Khan's work that inspired me but I did fell into a dilemna and confusion about music when I heard that statement from him and it really bothered as I was not able to find any clarification. Jazakallah for the clarification. I still admire him and pray for his forgiveness and further guidance including us
@@shuaibhilal3410 Yea brother, imams are human, when they start to Iie we have to stop listening to them, pray for them like you said and move on to other imams.
Some pages : Sabul as Salam Al Hidaaya Translations Scholarly Subtitles People of knowledge Treasures of knowledge Zayn al Abideen The Guided Path English : Garden of ilm Scottish Revert Teacher (cIass for reverts & sisters too) AbdurRahmanOrg Amau Saajid Liphaam Ilmstitute
Every learned person has an opinion based on his knowledge. Could music be broken down into groups? Is all music haraam? Is too much haraam? Is a little halaal? May ne depends on the type of music.
@@toni8866 There's a condition tho. “I heard the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) say: ‘My nation will not unite on misguidance, so if you see them differing, follow the great majority.’” Follow the majority because there's consensus.
May Allah(swt) remove pride and ego from the hearta of ummah and the scholars. A community is truly doomed if its scholars are not truthful and filled with pride
Alhamdulillah this was such a beneficial video. I thank you Shaykh Uthman on behalf of all us, for this was an issue that needed to be addressed urgently. May Allah preserve you.
What i would say is. Knowledge is deen. We must scrutinise whatever Knowledge we are getting from the Internet if we do not have the chance to go to the scholars ourselves.
@@falsesectslikeshiaarejudeo6543 but some of them have studied under major scholars too and have been told to clarify the truth from the falsehood. This is what shaykh Uthman is doing. Sadly there is a lot of bigotry towards the Salafi Dawah and they dismiss it as people not understanding because it goes aganst their desires
LMAO how can you even say that LOL music is not even known as addictive you are overestimating music and underestimating drugs drugs are way more fkn crazy than some lyrics with some beats
By the title I was afraid you will go angry but this is the best explained video I have been seen from your channel. Thanks for wait and finally explain the best way. ♥️
@@dereckjames4563 I've already told this to someone that Baal is long dead, And tell me what is the good in music because I listen to it everyday even tho I'm a Muslim, Tell me the answer!
See how water responds to music. Realise that certain systems in your body are largely water. Music is from god therefore it can tune you up. The desert bandit knew this, so he banned it.
I'm gonna download this video, in sha Allah. Because a lot of our masjids in our city, started to give this false fatwa too. Just like the Prophet sAaws predicted as a sign of judgement day.
Music is not Haram, Nobody can prove it is Haram. These are evidences..👇 So Fear Allah not the Sectarians. 1. Whatever ALLAH leaves without saying Haram are halal by default. General Fiqh rule. 100s of Scholars including Imam Al Gazzali, Shiekh Ibn Hazm, Sheikh Ibn Arabi, Sheikh Khardavi, etc., openly said "music in itself is not haram". 2. HADITHS - Prophet(SA) allowed music with instruments in his own house during Eid - Sahih Bukhari 987, 988, 3931, 949, 952. 3. HADITHS - Prophet(SA) compared the quran recitation of a companion Abu Musa(r) to the musical rhythmic sound of Mazamir(wind instruments, flute). - Sahih Bukhari 5048, Al Adab Al Mufrad 805, Al-Adab Al-Mufrad 1087. 4. HADITHS - Prophet Muhammad(SA) invited singers to a wedding function to sing - Sunan Ibn Mājah 1900. 5. That "Bukhari hadis 5590 which says musical instruments are haram in an indirect way" is a hanged hadis or an un-numbered hadis in bukhari text. Classical Scholar Sheikh Ibn Hazm stated that the chain of this hadith is broken. Also this hadith is an indirect statement, we cannot take this hadith as a solid evidence. 6. Only ALLAH has the authority to declare Haram. Scholars do not have that authority. Inorder to consider anything as Haram it requires solid authentic evidences. Do not falsely declare with your tongues, “This is lawful, and that is unlawful,” ˹only˺ fabricating lies against Allah. Indeed, those who fabricate lies against Allah will never succeed. - Quran 16:116
, he is great explainer of the Qur'an and that is his area of expertise so take good knowledge from his Qur'an explanations. As far as his own fatawas and opinions are concerned ignore them. Always take good from people. May Allah bless you.
@ Ibn Hazm claimed that this hadith is interrupted in the chain of transition between Bukhariyy and Sadaqa ibn Khalid.' However, Ibn Qayyim replied and made it clear that what Ibn Hazm said was not true. He summarised his answer in six aspects: 1. Bukhariyy met Hisham Ibn Ammar and heard the Hadith from him. If he heard by him through the so-called 'An'ana (chain of tradition), a connection is very likely, because they lived at the same time and heard of each other. When he said: "Hisham said [..]", then there is basically no difference to the statement: ", of Hisham".
@kikikoko607 Brother that hadith doesnt say musical instruments are haram directly. It is saying as if instruments are made haram already. Read that hadith again, bukhari 5590. Silk and Alcohol are haram, Quran says it repeatedly. But where does it say that Musical Instruments or Music is Haram directly? Show me!!! It is clear that hadith bukhari 5590 is fabricated by some to make music haram.
Wow Maasha Allah. May Allah reward Shaykh Uthman for the research and nice way of delivering his opinion on the matter to even teach his audience not just state something is permissible or Impermissible. May Allah increase you and us in knowledge and make it easy for us to follow ameen
Narrated Zayd ibn Thabit: I heard the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) say: May Allah brighten a man who hears a tradition from us, gets it by heart and passes it on to others
Prophet and Sahaaba did not leave behind even one hadith. All extra-Quranic stories of Sunnah, Hadiths and Tafsirs are nothing but hearsay folkloric tales; and a wise will not build his faith, Sharia laws, rites and rituals on such folklore. Quran is enough for Muslim, 16:89. What is not in Quran is NOT part of Islam
Sheikh Uthman is truly a real man in every video of issues of disputes he presents evidences he never says I listened from so and so may Allah protect him and grant him Jannah Ameen
Your observation touches on a very significant issue within the Muslim community. Criticism, if done constructively and sincerely for the sake of Allah, can be a form of mutual advice (naseehah), which is a cornerstone of Islamic brotherhood. However, when criticism turns into obsession, hostility, or public shaming, it often causes more harm than good.
Salamalaykum waramatuLlah am a fan of your channel allahumabareek!! Your wordpress tutorials are one of the best av seen on youtube!!! So happy to see you here!! May Allah(swt) unite us all in jannah!! Amin
Alhamdulillah, music is off the table for me. I used to listen a lot of music, but no it's all gone. Alhamdulillah for making it easy for me to give it up. InshaAllah, awareness on this issue will rise so that it'll become an obvious matter for every practicing muslim.
At this point, (I did it too), people are searching for an opinion to enable them to do it. We should even stay away of grey areas. May Allah guide us further😊 Ameen
Thank you for approaching Brother Nouman in a respectable manner and giving him enough time and curtesy to respond. You provided solid proof in support of your beliefs, which is very important in this social media age when anyone can say anything and then egos get involved, but proof never appears.
I am watching from Bulgaria, ya Shaykh Uthman. May Allah have mercy on every salafi and may Allah protect you and the true scholars of Ahlus Sunnah Wal Jammah
Shame on you! Your comment is an absolute disgrace to Muslim ummah. Asking for Allah’s mercy to extend only to a sect? May Allah guide you to the right path
Sign of Qaymat is also things that were halal would be considered haram. There has always been a difference of opinion regarding music among scholars. Music is not inherently haram or halal it depends on the type of music and usage
@@pandaprrr995 you shouldn't come to us with such nonsense that there is a difference of opinion about music, the sheikh brought the evidence in the video, what is the evidence that it is not haram or your proof is just that there is a difference of opinion, really embarrassing how some Muslims argue just because they want to listen to music
Brother helped misguide you on what the term “ijma” means lol Ijma means NO ONE held a contrary view lol let alone the thousands of Scholars throughout history. Tawus Ibn Kaysan the Great Tabieen student of the Great Sahabi and legendary Mufassir Ibn Abbas said that music is permissible. So his own student disagrees, but there is ijma, let alone Ibn Hazm, Imam al-Ghazali, the Maliki school of the salaf. Like come on man
@@Wise_guy007 Not quite. brother clearly stated it is "almost ijma" not that it was "ijma" with certainty. Also he showed proof of one of the scholars particularly stating that all of the 4 madhahib prohibit listening to music or view it as haram. So the Maliki school of the salaf does not allow it. Furthermore, There is clearly an overwhelming amount of insanely important and major scholars who clearly, according to this video, agree that music is HARAM, one of them even swearing by Allah that in surah Al-Luqman an ayah that speaks of purchasing idle talk is referring to musical instruments if I remember correctly. I'm not sure if you watched the video, music is prohibited, period. Whether you like it or not the facts were stated and that's that. Also if I remember correctly Al-ghazali was influenced by Al-kalam and towards the end of his life ended up regretting his innovation of stating music was halal but take this one with a grain of salt. If I made any mistakes forgive me and they are from me, if I said anything good it is from Allah. Salam!
Terms Ijma and so-called Scholars have no authority in Islamic law. If you have understood the whole Quran, then you are supposed to realize that for Islamic law, Quran is the only authority. And Quran never makes Music Haram
If u have something show it with evidence and References, And btw take this panfit in asool al fiqh, Imam Al-Juwayni stated: “If the disagreement among the scholars occurs within a short period and they then agree upon a particular view, this is considered consensus (ijma‘). However, if the disagreement persists for a long time and they later agree, this does not constitute consensus.” (al burhan fi aswl al fiqh(158/1 )) @@Wise_guy007
@@PGY2000 there is literally no such thing as “almost” ijma from a fiqh stand point. Ibn Hajar wrote in fatul Bari that one side claims ijma music is haram, the other side claims ijma music is halal. The verse of surah Luqman has been interpreted many different ways. But the dishonest part here is any lack of deep research on Uthman’s part. The Scholars who permit music do not discredit those statements, but they contextualize them properly. Indeed music was used to dissuade people from listening to the Quran, revelation came and rather than saying music is haram, Allah in His infinite wisdom declared any and all amusements, entertainment or theatrics that dissuade people from the message of Islam to be haram. Uthman provides many evidences, with context or deeper understanding. He ignores the narrations of Imam Malik singing and playing the drum in Tariq al-Baghdadi. He ignores the known fatwa of abu Hanifa permitting the buying and seeking of musical instruments. He ignores half of Islamic history that doesn’t agree with him. This is why the Scholars take such offence to this man. Slandering the giants of the ummah because they had not understood Islam as good as himself. His pride and arrogance is clear from the rest of his content. We judge according to the thahir, and what is apparent is he is very full of himself and his knowledge. My request, instead of challenging people about music, he needs to accept the challenges of the Scholars who have called him out for pretending to be a Mufti and Shaykh. That is all and may Allah forgive me if I have said anything out of a place of arrogance or enmity Amīn ya Rabb.
Abdullah bin 'Amr bin Al-'As (May Allah be pleased with them) reported: The Prophet (ﷺ) said, "Convey from me even an Ayah of the Qur'an [Riyad as-Salihin 1380]
May Allah reward One Nessage Foundation and those who commented and shared..wasn’t planning to watch this but it came up on my page so Alhamdulilah for the clarification and reminder
@mo9ala7 Remove your image drawing from your profile then, the Messenger of Allah (peace be upon him) said: "Those who make images (musawwiroon) will be punished on the Day of Resurrection; it will be said to them, 'Bring to life what you have created.'" (Sahih al-Bukhari, Book 76, Hadith 104)
@@AbrahamicBrotherhoodHow did you know he made that drawing?, he might've taken it from somewhere on the internet, your statements make it look like you are accusing him of drawing. Fear Allah brother.
I stopped listening to music over 2 years ago. Only Nasheeds now. But not often. Im listening more to recitations. My heart is closer to Allah then I was before. So it only makes sense to cut the distractions from what sticks to your heart. My kids are benefitting.
Yes, Alhamdulillah that is why I like to encourage people to just give it a try. Replace music with the Quran sincerely for even one week and you’ll see a difference Insha Allah.
@UmmMusa-x2g agreed. For the reverts who grew up listening to music though. This takes time to be rid of music and InshaAllah like you said keep trying, keep striving for the sake of Allah and may he ease all of our struggles. Ameen
Jazak Allah'u Khairan ya sheikh Uthman From Egypt By Allah, The Most Glorious.. I love you for the sake of Allah, and nothing else.. Not for material benefit nor biased, enforced stances. May Allah grant you the best rewards in this life and the next. May Allah gather us in the Highest Firdaws, Allah'uma ameen.
This is one of the beauty of Islam in that, you can’t just make up stuff and expect scholars to turn a blind eye. They will debate it and find the your reasons backed by authentic narrations or the Qur’an. If you cannot defend it, it is wrong. May Allah guide our Brother Ali Nouman Khan. I admire him so much Jazakhallahu khair Sheik Uthman From Nigeria 🇳🇬
Masha Allah..That was very important to reply to him..Many people are confused...Your research on this issue is awesome..I got benefitted from it...Jazak Allah khair Brother...
I used to follow nouman ali khan but since i heard him say that music wasnt haram multiple years ago i stoped following him and i was sooo sad cause i liked his kind way to present things etc... but since he said music wasnt haram i started doubting all the things i used to hear from him, i think he is a kind and good guy but what he is doing should stop, may allah guide him and open his heart to the truth in shaa allah and help him acknowledge the truth cause i care about him, thank you so much sheikh Uthman for bringing this up and helping people understand, now i have a reference to send my friends to. May allah in shaa allah make me meet you in person, love in the sake of allah sheikh Uthman from algeria ❤.
His own words are that he is not a hadith scholar.. so stop doubting on him for everything, he is great explainer of the Qur'an and that is his area of expertise so take good knowledge from his Qur'an explanations. As far as his own fatawas and opinions are concerned ignore them. Always take good from people. May Allah bless you.
Exactly brother. I'm sad when people push away the goodness of another just by spotting one single fault. It's ridiculous. We Muslims must not hate another, but we can hate his/her stance or actions. Not the man himself as a human being. @@justhydr
expecting any person to be correct in all jurisdiction is kinda stupid idea. take benefit of his goodness and filter through other scholars. we cannot think like western celebrity followers style.
Sh Uthman the knowledgeable and courageous .he asks us all🎉 do we have the fortitude, courage, and determination to stand up to those who threaten our values?
Ya Sheikh dont die Jahal and read our primary books (Bhikhari/Muslim) Bhukhari 952 Muslim 2061 Narrated Aisha: Abu Bakr came to my house while two small Ansari girls were singing beside me the stories of the Ansar concerning the Day of Buath. And they were not singers. Abu Bakr said protestingly, Musical instruments of Satan in the house of Allah's Apostle ! It happened on the `Id day and Allah's Apostle said, O Abu Bakr! There is an `Id for every nation and this is our `Id. Bukhari 5147 music Narrated Ar-Rabi`: (the daughter of Muawwidh bin Afra) After the consummation of my marriage, the Prophet came and sat on my bed as far from me as you are sitting now, and our little girls started beating the tambourines and reciting elegiac verses mourning my father who had been killed in the battle of Badr. One of them said, Among us is a Prophet who knows what will happen tomorrow. On that the Prophet said, Leave this (saying) and keep on saying the verses which you had been Bhukhari 5162 حَدَّثَنَا الْفَضْلُ بْنُ يَعْقُوبَ ، حَدَّثَنَا مُحَمَّدُ بْنُ سَابِقٍ ، حَدَّثَنَا إِسْرَائِيلُ ، عَنْ هِشَامِ بْنِ عُرْوَةَ ، عَنْ أَبِيهِ ، عَنْ عَائِشَةَ ، أَنَّهَا زَفَّتِ امْرَأَةً إِلَى رَجُلٍ مِنْ الْأَنْصَارِ ، فَقَالَ نَبِيُّ اللَّهِ صَلَّى اللَّهُ عَلَيْهِ وَسَلَّمَ : يَا عَائِشَةُ مَا كَانَ مَعَكُمْ لَهْوٌ فَإِنَّ الْأَنْصَارَ يُعْجِبُهُمُ اللَّهْوُ . mishkat 3153 ‘A’isha reported God's Messenger as saying, “Make this marriage publicly known, solemnise it in the mosques, and play tambourines in honour of it.” Tirmidhi transmitted it, saying this is a gharib tradition.
@@AllahRasool-ISLAM There are those who worship Allah and those who worship the forefathers „Narrators“ I agree worh you brother, Ahadis are contradictory regarding Music, so no strict conclusion conclusion can be made that they are haram, it is also unfaire to say it is all halal. Part of the music that includes haram content is haram Part of it which doesn’t include it is not Wasalam
@hewadsaad1378 exactly brother his point is that it is totally Haraam based on books that irrelevant. If we go by our primary book only then it is very simple to understand that events like eid and Nikah can have music and of course within Islamic rules. For example no mix gathering of men and women, it should not vulgar and the content of the songs should not be vulgar. I am from Punjab Pakistan we have Dhol or drums not Duffs so in our wedding we are going to play Punjabi dhol no A duff from Arab lol... Islam is Quran and Sunnah not 4 sects (Hanfi, Shafi, maliki, Hambali from Sunni, or Jaffery from Shia
@@AllahRasool-ISLAM and they tell us that there are 4 mazaheb and 4 ways, forgeting that every time they pray, they recite surat al fatiha, and they recite to guide us to the ONE Strainght path....so only those who guess in the unseen, or make up new stuff, be it us, be it our forefathers, all of them say that there 4 ways to the truth, 4 mazib, well i dont care 2 peanuts for your mazahib...i dont. all i care is Quran and Sunnah..i dont want to know anything about mazahib...i want to know Quran and sunnah and th teaching of our best teacher prophet Muhammad pbuh....so while everytime when they stand up in salah they pray for the straight path....there is only ONE PATH, and that is straight path....i am not a follower of my forefathers..but these people are...they are no different than the saying of foremer people who used to follow their forefathers..... i am follower of Allah and his messenger, and I am muslim...the word muslim is enough for me, unlike many that are not comfrotable with this word, for some it is not even enough, they want to add stuff to it saying: ok you are muslim but which muslim? have these people lost their minds or are they taken for a ride by our former people, by forefathers...these are following the saying of their forefathers and left Quran and sunnah...these are equivalent to Mushrikin...a crime that Allah will never forget...for their ignorance of Quran...and they are the first to come and tell us that you cant handel the quran...it is too dificult for you... I tell them: well you shut up! my language is harsh against them, because they are a people who do not understand, a people who wont think nor allow anyone else to think...Quran declares of such people as worst of all. they are the people who will accuse my beloved prophet muhammad of marring a child...i tell them: wait and see what is awaiting for you on judgment day, they are a poeple who raise narrators above Quran! i departed from them..all of them...and i dont engage with them except for those who are sound in their judgment....they are a wasallam :)
Music is not Haram, Nobody can prove it is Haram. These are evidences..👇 So Fear Allah not the Sectarians. 1. Whatever ALLAH leaves without saying Haram are halal by default. General Fiqh rule. 100s of Scholars including Imam Al Gazzali, Shiekh Ibn Hazm, Sheikh Ibn Arabi, Sheikh Khardavi, etc., openly said "music in itself is not haram". 2. HADITHS - Prophet(SA) allowed music with instruments in his own house during Eid - Sahih Bukhari 987, 988, 3931, 949, 952. 3. HADITHS - Prophet(SA) compared the quran recitation of a companion Abu Musa(r) to the musical rhythmic sound of Mazamir(wind instruments, flute). - Sahih Bukhari 5048, Al Adab Al Mufrad 805, Al-Adab Al-Mufrad 1087. 4. HADITHS - Prophet Muhammad(SA) invited singers to a wedding function to sing - Sunan Ibn Mājah 1900. 5. That "Bukhari hadis 5590 which says musical instruments are haram in an indirect way" is a hanged hadis or an un-numbered hadis in bukhari text. Classical Scholar Sheikh Ibn Hazm stated that the chain of this hadith is broken. Also this hadith is an indirect statement, we cannot take this hadith as a solid evidence. 6. Only ALLAH has the authority to declare Haram. Scholars do not have that authority. Inorder to consider anything as Haram it requires solid authentic evidences. Do not falsely declare with your tongues, “This is lawful, and that is unlawful,” ˹only˺ fabricating lies against Allah. Indeed, those who fabricate lies against Allah will never succeed. - Quran 16:116
not like that my brother everyone has their own understanding and knowledge level, and i agree that nauman ali khan is at fault but we should not make fun of him because of this
@@Trait74 Corrupting? What do you know? Look, in Islam we are taught to respect. If you don't know how to respect, don't speak, okay? It's that simple. As the prophet says, if you're not going to say anything, well, shut up. Make constructive criticism, but don't make fun of it. It seems that people haven't been taught to speak well at home.
I sincerely prayed to Allah and asked Him for guidance and correct aqeedah. And Alhamdulilah my heart deviated from NAK when he tried to spin the permissibility of music in an earlier lecture where he didn't elaborate on his stance. The same thing happened with Omar Suleman and Yasir Qadhi when they lectured to join hands with Lgbtqs and others and the issue of beard was elongated just to conclude it is proven authentic to keep a fistful beard. I can't thank Allah enough, now I have completely distanced myself from almost all the western scholars and try to learn from the real scholars who wouldn't put Ustad, Sheikh or Imam before their names.
i wouldnt say to deviate from them but take the good and anything which you feel is not right and of course with the evidences then we make dua and we leave that. but for those names that you have mentioned they have contributed greatly to the teachings and understandings of the Quran and ethics and have clarified where there have been assumptions and accusations made against them so we should always think the best of our brothers and sisters and of course if there are any concerns then make dua and leave the rest to Allah. however what we should not do is write anyone off or keep others away from them when they are benefitting and saying things which align with islam Quran and sunnah inshallah!
Thanks, my brother. You know it's so baffling when the scholar you love acts on issue so clear as this and results in a defense that is unacademic and embarrassing. I love Shaikh Nouman and his lectures for the sake of Allah. I'm not learned in quran and hadith, I only listen to all our scholars as we all can't be as knowledgeable as those that study quran and hadith in colleges for the sake of enlightening the Ummah. I always think that if some of us who love him see his error so clearly, with our level of knowledge, why can't he. I don't know who this scholar is, I guess I'm listening to him the first time, and his way of addressing this issue is brilliant and respectful to Shaikh Nouman. May Allah guide Shaikh Nouman and all of us to the best, he truly needs to be humble with correction. Truly, if there is poison in a delicious meal, it does more harm than good.
![🇦🇪🔥GRAND FINALE‼️ 🇨🇳 PhD Christian Pastor vs. Shaykh Uthman [FAILS MISERABLY]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/NkMaAMm_kgA/mqdefault.jpg)
![🇦🇪🔥GRAND FINALE‼️ 🇨🇳 PhD Christian Pastor vs. Shaykh Uthman [FAILS MISERABLY]](/img/tr.png)
Comment Where You Watching From 👀👇🏼
For Boosting TH-cam Algorithm 📈🔥
Balboa Park, San Diego, California, USA 🇺🇸
germany
San Diego
UK
Kuwait City 🇰🇼
I took my Shahada on the 8:th of January this year. I just realised that this might be one of my toughest challenges going forward. I'm thankful for the explanation and I now know what has to be done. Goodbye Disco. Goodbye Funk and Goodbye Jazz. It will be hard, but I can do it. Inshallah.
Love from Sweden.
May Allah bless you
There are born Muslim into Muslim family and they still justify using it without any evidence, and then we have Muslims like you who reverted very recently and acknowledges its Haram and is also willing to quit it for the Sake of Allah!
Keep going brother, Pleasure of Allah is more than anything.
May Allah make it easy for you 🥰
May Almighty Allah let you and I be steadfast on this Deen
More love & power to you from Kashmir
May Allah bless your journey, keep you in the right path and make it easy for you
Even if you listen to Music, which is Haram, don't justify it saying "its okay, its halal.." etc
YES! A MILLION TIMES YES! it's not so hard to let go of your pride and recognize when something is wrong :)
Exactly, dont transform your sin into an act of kufr
exactly, when one knows he's committing a sin.... there's a chance that he will repent for the sin.
but if you think of it as halal.... how would one repent for this particular sin?
i heard somewhere...
he said that he prefer that his son commit sin and know it is sin, rather than bid'ah.
no one would ever repent for the bidáh they are in, because they actually think this is sunnah !!
I am not a scholar, I listen to music but when asked I always say I don't know search and find out yourself.
The desert bandit banned things which evolve your mind. Look at water and how it responds to music and tell me that is not god.
May Allah grant us sincerity to repent and correct our mistakes Ameen
Allahumma ameen
Ameen, music is haram Alhamdulillah
Ameen
Amin!.
As the hadith says even a bit of pride will Iead to Jahnnum!
Ameen
I used to listen to music on spotify etc. all the time, even to sleep. I was a singer- opera and jazz, and played violin and piano. After recently reverting to Islam (from athiesm) I haven't listened to music or felt the need to. That was just natural, I didn't know till now that it's haram, I'm just starting Islamic studies now. As a neuroscientist I know how frequencies affect the brain and body (they are connected of course) so I can understand the haram reasoning scientifically. Looking at it that way it is really interesting and understandable that there is evidence for it being haram. When Islam entered my heart, music naturally left as if there was no need or space for it, Alhamdullilah. Just sharing my personal experience. Only Allah SWT knows best
You have a very interesting story :) May Allah bless you
May Allāh bless your Islam and continue to guide you towards the path of the highest of Jannah
May Allah SWT bless you too@@sciencehungryAmeen
@@abdullahiqbal7248Ameen. Jazakallah khairan brother, may Allah SWT bless and protect you
You have a very interesting story brother. May Allah put Baraka in your life and rectify your affairs. I woild suggest learning basic aqeedah first like kitaab at tawheed. Maybe sheikh tim humble has an explanation on that
Commenting for the algorithm. May Allah swt put this video in the recommended of those who need to hear this.
May Allāh bless you - your commenting is helping the dawah
Asalam o Alaikum,
I m from Pakistan @@OneMessageFoundation
Wallah it did
Been arguing with my friend on this for months im bouta send him this abomination
Alhamdulillah Allah has created people like you so that people like me wouldn't go astray.
May Allah give barakh to your ilm and may we keep benefiting.
@ummsafiyah7001 Wallah it did
Been arguing with my friend on this topic for months. Bouta send him this abomination
جزاك الله خير، اللّهم أرنا الحق حقاً وَارْزُقْنَا اتّباعه وأرنا الباطل باطلاً وَارْزُقْنَا اجتنابه
May Allah reward you as well for supporting this channel.
Barrakallahu khair
@@Reactify-Official wa iyyakum
حياكم الله و بياكم و جعل الجنة مأوانا و مأواكم
Ameen❤🤲
I agree, I stopped listening to music completely and I was more focused on my salah and reading the Quran and now when I hear music my head hurts so I try distincing myself away from it as much as I can. Alhamdullah now I am focused more on what I am supposed to do and I rely on the Quran and salah instead of music to motive and heal my heart.❤️🤲
Masha'allah tabarakallah, mabruk sister.I am still struggling with it and hope to stop In shaa Allah
May Allāh bless you
May Allah(swt) ease your affairs
Uthman says traditionally music by ijma is haram, recently to Nouman Ali Khan opened up his mistakes this topic.
Uthman spoke to nak in a chat with eddy, nak brought a faqih and muhadith to view the evidence music is haram or show us evidence otherwise.
NAK and his crew left the group and didn't reply.
CIip : Nak says i want to know why music is haram, i am not an expert in hadith and know my limit.
I research Quran, it's not talked of but it can tie to Quran 31.6, ibn Abbas's opinion is music is haram but this view is not sahih, the isnad has a drunk.
Uthman says you say you are not an expert but then you go on to talk about it, then you call someone a drunk and you don't even mention who it is, this is not academic.
I in the chat asked him who is the drunk & he didn't reply.
There are many chains, it's not just ebn Abbas there are other sahabas and there is no contradiction.
Ibn Hatim has a hadith of ebn Abbas, Musat tafsir Mathu
Qatada, Mujahid all said Quran 31.6 is a reference to music.
6 independent chains, Saaed ibn Jubair, Abu saleh, Aitiyah, Mujahid all with independent chains says ibn Abbas held this view.
(6.40 - picture of this 6 chains)
ibn Abbas from Hasana al Basri from Ata other scholars from tabi'un said this ayat means Music!
Hadith Prophet peace and blessings be upon him made du'a for ibn Abbas to understand Quran.
Ebn Masud, Prophet peace and blessings be upon him said take Quran from him, also said this.
It's not scholar to say i heard from anonymous who hides the truth!
Sunan Kabir Bayhaqi, Abdullah ibn MD or Abi dunya, from Zuhair ibn Hard (faqih), Jarir ibn Hazir (strong scholar per dhahabi), Ata ibn Sa'eb (tabi'in) , Saeed ibn Jubayr (scholar of Madina) to ibn Abbas
Uthman asks where is the drunk (oh Nouman)?
How dare you?
Ebn Masud said Wallahi it means music, authentic by jariri and ibn Abi dunya!
Bagawi we will mention later.
10 :30 -
From greatest scholar of hadith authentication, ibn Hajr,
he has takrij or hadith checking werk called talqis, he said hadith of ebn Masud i sahih, ibn abi Shayba, Hakim and Bayhaqi all said it's sahih.
Mustadark ibn Hatim has the chain.
Uthman says I will go through the chain with you again.
Is there any da'if or drunk in this isnad.
Abul Abbas Md Yaqub (hafeth, faqi Shafi'i), from Baqkkar ibn Qutaybah (hanafi judge), from Safwan ibn Isa al Qadi (abut Hatim said he was saleh, MD Saad said he is saleh & Qadi) from Humayd Kuraat (YahYa Ma'in said he is thiqqah) from Saeed ibn Jubayr to Ebn Masud!
Al Hakim & Dhahabi said it's sahih!
Many says this includes tahrim or prohibition of music!
Nak cIip : I asked Akram Nadawi , he said there is no sahih hadith!
Uthman : there is hadith in Bukari, it even has the entire chain so if you are not an expert why talk about it.
Best popular explanation is fathul Bari ibn Hajr, he says this hadith is Sahih!
15 :10 -
Sh Albani in his Masu, says this isnad is sahih.
Ibn Uthaymin says in shar al Mumteh says this hadith is sahih!
Nak cIip : hanafi and south asian imams say no issue with music but we won't say it in public.
Uthman : if this was private why do you speak, and if they are ashamed to speak publicly there is something wrong.
Mathhab isn't a random scholar.
you have to reference the books of that mathhab.
you can't just say this secret person said
Umar Abdul Aziz said you openly allowing instruments is an innovation in Islam! (found in sanai)
abu Layth Samarqandi Hanafi says i't ijma of umma music is haram
Abdul Barr Maliki says Music is haram to all the faiths.
Bagawi in Shar sunna Shafi'i there is ijm3 wind, string and all other instruments are haram.
ibn Hajr Haytham shafi'i in ijm3 music is haram
ibn Qudama Hanbali in Mugni v12 page 457
20 :00 -
ibn Rajab in his shar Bukhari says ijm3 music is haram
Qurtubi says flutes, drums no iktilaf it's haram to listen to.
Ruhual M3ni Alusi says Abu Hanifa forbid musical instruments, sticks.
Say don't say hanafis are ok with music, Abu Hanifa and his students aren't!
ibn Qayyim said Hanafis are strictest on music, and said it's a fisq to listen to string or drum or other music to reject their testimony, to enjoy music is kuffer.
Shafi'i in umm said music is haram
Ibn Jawzi said ibn Hanbal said all music is haram except few exceptions.
Ibn Taymiyyah in majmua fatawa say all 4 mathhab say Music is haram.
Ibn Baz, Uthaymin, Albani, Fawzan all say it's haram
there maybe a random imam that says it ok.
Ibn Hanbal said if you took the mistake of every scholar you will gather every eviI.
a doubt ppl bring, hadith a girI played a duff for Prophet Muhammad peace and blessings be upon him.
there is general and specific ruling.
like zhur is 4 rakat & when traveling it is 2, you can sit at home and take the specific travel ruling and do it all the time.
Bukhari 949, reported by Aisha there were lil girIs playing duff talking about a battIe, Abu Bakr said instruments of deveI in house of the prophet, *Prophet peace and blessings be upon him said leave them it's Eid.**
So Sahaba knew music is haram but this is an exception is duff on Eid or in another hadith for nika!
supported in ibn Majah
Hadith use duff is halal to announce the nikah.
another doubt by nak not ok, there is music playing everywhere.
Uthman says there is difference between unintentionally listening to music or going to listen to it.
if you go to a job and music plays that's not in your control.
other sins are everywhere, gossiping, zina does that make it halal.
seeing a girI loosely cIothed and going to watch videos are different, same way hearing music in pubIic and then going to listen to music on the net is different!
to do a sin isn't kuffer
to make halal what is haram is a Iine you shouldn't cros ( & is kuffer)
Life is a TEST ( Quran 2 : 155 ) ( 1 Peter 4 : 12 )🔹
People will NOT be TESTED beyond what they can handle ( Quran 2 : 286 ) ( Corinthians 10 : 13 )
Honesly when i listen music the more i listen and avoid quran but when i listen and read quran i avoid music most of the time this is a lesson for me and understanding how music isnt good for me
I am a big admirer of both Sheikh Uthman and brother Nouman. That's why it was very sad to see brother Nouman say these things. I still like to believe he is a sincere Muslim and a good person, so I will pray that Allah guides him further
If Nouman is sincere he should repent not only for saying music is halal but wrongly calling a person a drunk, this are our Muslim elders who struggled so we can practice Islam today, I am shocked he said he won't mention names and he says his imams hide the truth, this is not Islam. Our Quran and hadith are preserved and open!
May Allah reward you for your sincerity.
Nouman is a great brother, no one is perfect
But Nouman Ali Khan is misguided though. How can you love him? Do you even know about him at all?
There are several other controversies surrounding NAK which I don’t want to get into. I suggest you dig deeper.
I was always listening to NAK until these issues came up and now prevent me from taking knowledge from him anymore.
This is how you refute and debate: DALEEL! Good work brother. May Allah reward you and keep you firm within the deen, Amin.
lol no it’s not. Uthman was selective with his “proof” don’t be fooled
@@m4fital2you must be blind… did you even listen to the video? Clearly shows your ignorance.
@@staypatient2816 no he doesn’t
@@staypatient2816 he is using Salafi abridged references!! That’s not proof it’s like when they say this was authenticated by Albani that doesn’t make sense
Lie U mean...
I once was a musician, wielding the power of orchestras to create everything from progressive metal to cinematic soundtracks. Yet, I chose to silence that, destroying my instruments and leaving music behind. Now, in this quiet, I've found a profound peace. Alhamdulillah. 🤲🏼
Barakullah ✨✨✨
Allah has prepared for you something much much better and enduring , inshallah
I relate to you, only difference is that I was a beginner, Alhamdulillaah I left it as well
Alhamdulillah ❤
The most knowledgeable scholar today dr. Sh. Aldudo said its haraaam.
May Allah grant you the best of Duniyah and Jannah
From Oshawa, Ontario…Jazak Allahu Khairan, Brother for your researched response to this matter.
I love and respect the scholars in Islam…I have benefited tremendously from Ustath Nouman’s Qur’anic lectures…I ask Allah for His Guidance for the Ummah of His beloved Rasul (SAW).
This is called scholarly approach he showed 20+ evidences
The desert bandit banned things which evolve your mind. Look at how water responds to music and tell me that’s not god.
@@dereckjames4563what are you on about?
Desert bandit,never heard that one😂😂 May Allah guide you ! Out prophet didn't "ban" anything, he basically told us to stay away from things which distract us from the remembrance of Allah .
Yes, is was a very logical and scientific approach to explain the truth, that is what i like about islam ❤
@@dereckjames4563 Just because it vibrates in a pattern doesnt mean it is god you idolator
Leaving a comment to support the algorithm. May Allah S.W.T place this video in the recommendations of those who need to hear it.
"that's a line you shouldn't cross " This is one of the strongest statements I've ever heard. Great job brother
He took a married woman into his house then married her before her divorce and it was a woman married to a friend of his at the time. Is this a line that Allah allows to be crossed ⁉️⁉️⁉️
@@goodkarmaiscomingtoyou1381and from where did you get that?
@@goodkarmaiscomingtoyou1381 what are you talking about?
Dawah is that 80% of ummah is living below poverty line...dont worry u get jannat and 72
Alhamdullilah i really like your approach brother. May Allah guide us and protect us from our weakness 🙏.
Jazaaka'llahu khiran shehu
May Allāh bless you
Br. Naumans opinion is pretty popular in Canada and I started to think the same that music is not haram. Glad you made this video Sheikb Uthman. This is very helpful
Canada is a lot liberal than the UK, even more than the US. I can speak, I have been there.
@@khaledhussain3214 it actually a prophesy of the prophet PBUH that peoples from his Ummah will consider it permissible. It's sad and it's a sign of the Hour.
Stop watching these people for detailed Fiqh issues. They literally have no idea what they're talking about... LITERALLY! No offense, but these individuals are Dawah specialists. (I think Naumans is Quran Science specialist) But Fiqh is a completely dark place for both of them. Fiqh is not "Quran and Hadith", Fiqh is an entirely separate science.
I wasted too much time reading about music in Islam in Arabic Fiqh books, just out of curiosity. But eventually, I found the best source you can check: the Egyptian Dar al-Ifta. I wish I had read their article first because it summarizes everything so well.
And yes, if you say music is Haram, you are CORRECT. If you say it is Halal, you are also CORRECT. It’s one of those issues where both opinions are valid. What’s wrong, though, is believing that your opinion is the ultimate truth and accusing others of committing Haram just because they don’t follow your perspective. This is called "Ignorance".
So, if you want proper Fiqh, follow the established schools of thought, not TH-camrs. These people are good for Dawah, which is great, but Fiqh is another field entirely. You need to look into the opinions of Al-Azhar and the Egyptian Dar al-Ifta.
@@Funblend-zd6dt what load of rabbish, Fiqh is based on Quran and Sunnah, if you ignore Quran and Sunnah then you are not a muslim, without evidence from Quran or Sunnah, your opinion is worth less, and listening to Egypt ifta' which says RIBBA is halal is a sign of misguidance.
Main problem is that people are taking NAK’s “opinion” when he isn’t qualified to even hold an opinion of his own. And then he doesn’t name the supposedly scholar he takes from which in and of itself is a red flag.
*"The love of the Quran and the love of music cannot coexist in the heart of a believer, for they are two opposites. One drives out the other, and the heart must choose between them."* -Ibn al Qayyim
Quote Ghazali now, be fair. But you won’t. Which only shows your lack of sincerity
Who are we the common people without our teachers, without our ăleem, explaining the Quran, explaining the religion. They are our shepherds after the departure of our Prophet Muhammad(saw). We pray to Almighty to grant them knowledge, understanding, and wisdom.
well said @@doityourownway
@@doityourownway so why insult those who do not follow your teacher? But rather follow a different teacher? This is not Islam
@@doityourownway a child can speak the truth, you don't need to be anything special.
I am grateful that Allah let Ustadh Nouman, a popular speaker, talk about Music when it is not his expertise. And in reaction to that, we got a high quality and deep academic discussion video from Sheikh Uthman about this subject. May Allah bless both with rahmah and guide both to stay on the straigh path.
Music is not Haram, Nobody can prove it is Haram. These are evidences..👇 So Fear Allah not the Sectarians.
1. Whatever ALLAH leaves without saying Haram are halal by default. General Fiqh rule.
100s of Scholars including Imam Al Gazzali, Shiekh Ibn Hazm, Sheikh Ibn Arabi, Sheikh Khardavi, etc., openly said "music in itself is not haram".
2. HADITHS - Prophet(SA) allowed music with instruments in his own house during Eid - Sahih Bukhari 987, 988, 3931, 949, 952.
3. HADITHS - Prophet(SA) compared the quran recitation of a companion Abu Musa(r) to the musical rhythmic sound of Mazamir(wind instruments, flute).
- Sahih Bukhari 5048, Al Adab Al Mufrad 805, Al-Adab Al-Mufrad 1087.
4. HADITHS - Prophet Muhammad(SA) invited singers to a wedding function to sing - Sunan Ibn Mājah 1900.
5. That "Bukhari hadis 5590 which says musical instruments are haram in an indirect way" is a hanged hadis or an un-numbered hadis in bukhari text. Classical Scholar Sheikh Ibn Hazm stated that the chain of this hadith is broken.
Also this hadith is an indirect statement, we cannot take this hadith as a solid evidence.
6. Only ALLAH has the authority to declare Haram. Scholars do not have that authority. Inorder to consider anything as Haram it requires solid authentic evidences.
Do not falsely declare with your tongues, “This is lawful, and that is unlawful,” ˹only˺ fabricating lies against Allah. Indeed, those who fabricate lies against Allah will never succeed.
- Quran 16:116
Shaykh Uthman made a lot of mistakes...
@Abigoria1 Salam Brother, May Allah Azza wa Jalla hide our mistakes and pardon our short comings. Aameen🤲
@@Abigoria1 Music is not Haram, Nobody can prove it is Haram. These are evidences..👇 So Fear Allah not the Sectarians.
1. Whatever ALLAH leaves without saying Haram are halal by default. General Fiqh rule.
100s of Scholars including Imam Al Gazzali, Shiekh Ibn Hazm, Sheikh Ibn Arabi, Sheikh Khardavi, etc., openly said "music in itself is not haram".
2. HADITHS - Prophet(SA) allowed music with instruments in his own house during Eid - Sahih Bukhari 987, 988, 3931, 949, 952.
3. HADITHS - Prophet(SA) compared the quran recitation of a companion Abu Musa(r) to the musical rhythmic sound of Mazamir(wind instruments, flute).
- Sahih Bukhari 5048, Al Adab Al Mufrad 805, Al-Adab Al-Mufrad 1087.
4. HADITHS - Prophet Muhammad(SA) invited singers to a wedding function to sing - Sunan Ibn Mājah 1900.
5. That "Bukhari hadis 5590 which says musical instruments are haram in an indirect way" is a hanged hadis or an un-numbered hadis in bukhari text. Classical Scholar Sheikh Ibn Hazm stated that the chain of this hadith is broken.
Also this hadith is an indirect statement, we cannot take this hadith as a solid evidence.
6. Only ALLAH has the authority to declare Haram. Scholars do not have that authority. Inorder to consider anything as Haram it requires solid authentic evidences.
Do not falsely declare with your tongues, “This is lawful, and that is unlawful,” ˹only˺ fabricating lies against Allah. Indeed, those who fabricate lies against Allah will never succeed.
- Quran 16:116
@@syckle33 Music is not Haram, Nobody can prove it is Haram. These are evidences..👇 So Fear Allah not the Sectarians.
1. Whatever ALLAH leaves without saying Haram are halal by default. General Fiqh rule.
100s of Scholars including Imam Al Gazzali, Shiekh Ibn Hazm, Sheikh Ibn Arabi, Sheikh Khardavi, etc., openly said "music in itself is not haram".
2. HADITHS - Prophet(SA) allowed music with instruments in his own house during Eid - Sahih Bukhari 987, 988, 3931, 949, 952.
3. HADITHS - Prophet(SA) compared the quran recitation of a companion Abu Musa(r) to the musical rhythmic sound of Mazamir(wind instruments, flute).
- Sahih Bukhari 5048, Al Adab Al Mufrad 805, Al-Adab Al-Mufrad 1087.
4. HADITHS - Prophet Muhammad(SA) invited singers to a wedding function to sing - Sunan Ibn Mājah 1900.
5. That "Bukhari hadis 5590 which says musical instruments are haram in an indirect way" is a hanged hadis or an un-numbered hadis in bukhari text. Classical Scholar Sheikh Ibn Hazm stated that the chain of this hadith is broken.
Also this hadith is an indirect statement, we cannot take this hadith as a solid evidence.
6. Only ALLAH has the authority to declare Haram. Scholars do not have that authority. Inorder to consider anything as Haram it requires solid authentic evidences.
Do not falsely declare with your tongues, “This is lawful, and that is unlawful,” ˹only˺ fabricating lies against Allah. Indeed, those who fabricate lies against Allah will never succeed.
- Quran 16:116
Alhamdulillah! Right now deleted every song that i had in my device,
Jazakallah u Khair sheikh uthman may Allah grant us Jannath-ul-Firdos....
May Allah guide others as well.
Haram is Haram even if the whole world is doing it
💯
And Halal is Halal, and Music is Halal
@abdar-rahman6965 Keep ur opinion to ur self coz i never asked u
@@Boomslang8073
ok
We needed evidence
Perfect example of how to correct others and how to protect the deen.
Barakallahu fik ❤️
This is how deen has been protected throughout the history of Islam.
Wallahi This video itself is a proof for islam being the correct religion.
Jazakallahu khairan
You are not overseer of Allah's Deen.
Music is not Haram, Nobody can prove it is Haram. These are evidences..👇 So Fear Allah not the Sectarians.
1. Whatever ALLAH leaves without saying Haram are halal by default. General Fiqh rule.
100s of Scholars including Imam Al Gazzali, Shiekh Ibn Hazm, Sheikh Ibn Arabi, Sheikh Khardavi, etc., openly said "music in itself is not haram".
2. HADITHS - Prophet(SA) allowed music with instruments in his own house during Eid - Sahih Bukhari 987, 988, 3931, 949, 952.
3. HADITHS - Prophet(SA) compared the quran recitation of a companion Abu Musa(r) to the musical rhythmic sound of Mazamir(wind instruments, flute).
- Sahih Bukhari 5048, Al Adab Al Mufrad 805, Al-Adab Al-Mufrad 1087.
4. HADITHS - Prophet Muhammad(SA) invited singers to a wedding function to sing - Sunan Ibn Mājah 1900.
5. That "Bukhari hadis 5590 which says musical instruments are haram in an indirect way" is a hanged hadis or an un-numbered hadis in bukhari text. Classical Scholar Sheikh Ibn Hazm stated that the chain of this hadith is broken.
Also this hadith is an indirect statement, we cannot take this hadith as a solid evidence.
6. Only ALLAH has the authority to declare Haram. Scholars do not have that authority. Inorder to consider anything as Haram it requires solid authentic evidences.
Do not falsely declare with your tongues, “This is lawful, and that is unlawful,” ˹only˺ fabricating lies against Allah. Indeed, those who fabricate lies against Allah will never succeed.
- Quran 16:116
Music evolves the soul hence why your leader, the Arabian Diddy, was against it
@@KashifKhursheed-ng1vk of course we are not nobody said so, but Allah chooses whoever he will like the prophet (pbut) the sahaba their students and so on, we are merely his slaves.
@ You should be a standup comedian.
Music is Haram and music is my biggest sacrifice that I have made for the sake of Allah.
May Allah reward you abundantly and keep us all steadfast.
May Allāh bless you ❤
May the Quran suffice you
➜ He 👉🏻🚶♂convinced himself l will repent tomorrow, but tomorrow NEVER came 😭 ⚰
Music is 100% Halal according to Quran. Follow Quran. NOT THESE MULLAHS
Jazakallah khairrr kaseeraaa..
This is a much needed video for all our brothers and sisters..♥️♥️♥️
Sheikh may Allah bless you in your ability to keep it REAL. Its very refreshing hearing u speak with facts and evidence and not watering down you're message simply because of who who you're speaking in regards to. Hope this message reached you.
What an in impeccable approach! May Allah grant all the Ulamas and us all the thawfick to approach all our matters in such a respectful, academic and diplomatic manner; ameen. Sheikh Uthman setting the bar!
Jazakallahu Khayran My Beloved Sheikh Othman. This was well needed. Because a new fitna is coming out recently about "music is halal" astaghfirullah. May Allah protect us from all kind of fitnah.
A new fitna? Music has literally been around in the muslim world for centuries. There are literally dozens for muslim music genre invented by muslims. It's not new
Music is a difference of opinion among the scholars, Sheikh Uthman is a wahabi, that's why he only has one opinion and says it's the only correct one
@@Rafiq45287just because there's difference it doesn't mean that all opinions are valid
@@Rafiq45287 Difference of opinion when the hadiths are clear? Is this a difference of opinion among non-muslims?
@Rafiq45287 a difference of opinion when the quran and sunnah make it VERY clear that all music is haram? Nice one.
Alhamdulillah Sheikh Nouman Ali khan has helped me get back on deen, I have no bad word to say about him, may Allah guide our intention.
Turns out to be the best lecture on music I ever heard.
Music is not Haram, Nobody can prove it is Haram. These are evidences..👇 So Fear Allah not the Sectarians.
1. Whatever ALLAH leaves without saying Haram are halal by default. General Fiqh rule.
100s of Scholars including Imam Al Gazzali, Shiekh Ibn Hazm, Sheikh Ibn Arabi, Sheikh Khardavi, etc., openly said "music in itself is not haram".
2. HADITHS - Prophet(SA) allowed music with instruments in his own house during Eid - Sahih Bukhari 987, 988, 3931, 949, 952.
3. HADITHS - Prophet(SA) compared the quran recitation of a companion Abu Musa(r) to the musical rhythmic sound of Mazamir(wind instruments, flute).
- Sahih Bukhari 5048, Al Adab Al Mufrad 805, Al-Adab Al-Mufrad 1087.
4. HADITHS - Prophet Muhammad(SA) invited singers to a wedding function to sing - Sunan Ibn Mājah 1900.
5. That "Bukhari hadis 5590 which says musical instruments are haram in an indirect way" is a hanged hadis or an un-numbered hadis in bukhari text. Classical Scholar Sheikh Ibn Hazm stated that the chain of this hadith is broken.
Also this hadith is an indirect statement, we cannot take this hadith as a solid evidence.
6. Only ALLAH has the authority to declare Haram. Scholars do not have that authority. Inorder to consider anything as Haram it requires solid authentic evidences.
Do not falsely declare with your tongues, “This is lawful, and that is unlawful,” ˹only˺ fabricating lies against Allah. Indeed, those who fabricate lies against Allah will never succeed.
- Quran 16:116
Big fan from India sheikh
If not in this world I hope we will meet in Jannah insha allah
Together, inshatuallah ❤❤❤
Ameen
May الله promote you to an air conditioner
Ok@@PakiFighter
You will meet someone even better in jannah. The prophet s.a.w
It's clear that music has the power to shift our mood, get us to clicking, taping, or moving our body, and even bring back memories (if we have any). It doesn't even necessarily need lyrics; just the rhythm or frequency alone is enough to influence our emotions or thoughts. Seriously, take a moment to ponder upon this, brothers and sisters in Islam.
Moreover one of the biggest The biggest problem with music is that it keeps playing in your mind even when you aren't listening to it. Those who listen to this know this.
@@ibnefayaz5107, i am a music addict and listen day and night to it and what you said is absolutely true ,even the moments im not listening to music i still hear it in my souĺ , its like some magic thats taken the soul over
no place in the heart for both music and qur’an, only one gets to stay
This is why so many people are enamored by it and find it hard to leave. They consider it a beautiful thing. Definitely one of the more difficult tests for us.
Who made music haram?. The quran, no! The quran is always in the favour of the middle path.
"Don't listen to vain words". Thats very much specific and details. Thats the quran, god words HIM self
I love the engagement and opinions with reference to the HQ and Hadeeth. It’s so respectful and insightful - MAY ALMIGHTY ALLAH BLESS BOTH BROTHERS AND CONTINUE TO INCREASE THRM IN KNOWLEDGE AND WISDOM. Aameen
Noman Ali Khan's video on music has 75k views posted a year ago. Shaykh Uthman's video has 74k views posted 5 hours ago. So glad to see what's more important to Muslims. Barakumullah.
You should see the views on some singers videos, they are in millions. 😂😂. So they are right?
it is more than 178 k in 12 h masha'allah
@@nismo4321 what do you mean? i think you don't have an idea about what's going on haha
Most people know it's wrong. Their's only a loud minority who are not even scholars saying it's not Haram
@@Nove-u7n Morocco, Tinghir city
UTMAN just tells it like it is.This is what muslims in America need and abroad.jazakallahukhair shiekh one day i would love to meet you akhi,inshallah
From Somalia 🇸🇴 ♥️. Jazakallah our sheikh may allah grant you al-firdowsul aclaa🤲
Ameen
Thanks!
I can now put this video in the face of anybody 😎
جزاك الله خيراً يا شيخ عثمان
Me too
Do your own research always. Don’t memorise videos and timestamps without checking references
Except anyone educated on the topic 🤣
@@murdock2012he gave the photos of the original books, go and check them
Alhamdulillah
Music takes out the sweetness and enjoyment of prayer and reading/listening Quran out of your heart. You will realize this quite easily if you are sincere to yourself. Once you get rid of music (addiction), you will start enjoying prayer and listening to Quran gradually again, untill you reach a point where you hate listening to music, even if you really used to love those songs in the past.
This is really sad that you believe this. You can enjoy both. Forget about the lyrics : Music is just beauty in certain vibrations of the air. A nice painting is just beauty in certain vibrations of the light. Our creator is an artist of the highest order, just look at the magnificence in the skies. If we follow this "logic" of despising music, why shoud we limit at this art ? If we are to forbid music, even without any lyrics... Lets forbid paintings, architecture, etc. The road to hell is always paved with the best of intentions.
@Onib-q9p Listen, I don't need to dive into nonsense analogies of paintings and buildings or even my emotional argument.. you reacting on this video means you listenend to this clear lecture full of evidence and proof. IF you are still stubborn, rejecting evidences of scripture and prophetic sayings because you just want to justify some stupid desire out of addiction, cravings or entertainment, then there is nothing left to explain or discuss. You heart is sealed even if an angel came down to tell you music is haram. You do as you please.
Why don't you just stick to the song of nature and not pollute it with something that is forbidden
@@SoufBouchahati We do not know if those are true prophetic sayings at all. There is no way on earth to demonstrate those are authentic sayings. The earliest were written 250 years after his death. While many hadiths may be true, some are demonstrably false by contradicting Quran head on. This is simple common sense. If those prohibitions were valid & important, they would have been included in the Quran, for starters.
@@Onib-q9pthey were written 250 years after the death of the prophet do you think we are chrsitains 😂😂 , al bukhari didnt write the ahadith but he creat a systems where he check every hadtih and his narration tree he goes for every one in the narration and check his biography and based on a lot o facture he got the much of authentification of the hadith , remember saying al bukhari is not compatible to get work with is like saying that sunnah is false and its corrupted and it lead to believe that islam is corrupted and that the prophet is a flase prophet ve careful akhi and go and search how al bukhari got the book and how . Quran says to follow the prophet if you say al bukhari is wrong then gow would you follow the prohet seikh al shaarawi explain the music problem bery good recommende watch his explanation and if you don't understand arabic just tell me here and im gonna give you the translation
SubhanAllah this is amazing. So needed in today’s world, JazakAllahu khairan ya shaykh Uthman. Refuted in a polite and academic way. Compared to "some secret scholar somewhere allowed music whose name I cannot mention who will never say it in public" 😂😂
I just love to see how traditional Islamic scholarship is defended by hook or by crook! May Allah persevere Sheikh Uthman. He is such a blessing for this Ummah!
This is also why we got to avoid ppl attacking the sunna like dan Taqiyajou.
He cIaims to be anti Iib but he is an internal Iib that made way for all the devision & external Iib stuff!
view : **The Wobbling Wobblers**
by ebn Hussein!
Jazak Allahu Khaire. Its sad to see brothers and sisters making halal what was made haram for us, and justifying it. If you are too weak to stop, thats a different topic, may Allah give you the strength to do so. But never ever justify your sins, make them small or even claim its permissible.
Narrated Aisha:
Allah's Apostle (p.b.u.h) came to my house while two girls were singing beside me the songs of Buath (a story about the war between the two tribes of the Ansar, the Khazraj and the Aus, before Islam). The Prophet (p.b.u.h) lay down and turned his face to the other side. Then Abu Bakr came and spoke to me harshly saying, "Musical instruments of Satan near the Prophet (p.b.u.h) ? " Allah's Apostle (p.b.u.h) turned his face towards him and said, "Leave them." When Abu Bakr became inattentive, I signaled to those girls to go out and they left. It was the day of 'Id, and the Black people were playing with shields and spears; so either I requested the Prophet (p.b.u.h) or he asked me whether I would like to see the display. I replied in the affirmative. Then the Prophet (p.b.u.h) made me stand behind him and my cheek was touching his cheek and he was saying, "Carry on! O Bani Arfida," till I got tired. The Prophet (p.b.u.h) asked me, "Are you satisfied (Is that sufficient for you)?" I replied in the affirmative and he told me to leave.
From Bukhari Volume 2, Book 15, Number 70:
This same Hadith is reported to us again in Sahih Muslim:
Book 004, Number 1942:
'A'isha reported: The Messenger of Allah (way peace be upon him) came (in my apartment) while there were two girls with me singing the song of the Battle of Bu'ath. He lay down on the bed and turned away his face. Then came Abu Bakr and he scolded me and said: Oh! this musical instrument of the devil in the house of the Messenger of Allah (may peace be upon him)! The Messenger of Allah (may peace be upon him) turned towards him and said: Leave them alone. And when he (the Holy Prophet) became inattentive, I hinted them and they went out, and it was the day of 'Id and negroes were playing with shields and spears. (I do not remember) whether I asked the Messenger of Allah (may peace be upon him) or whether he said to me if I desired to see (that sport). I said: Yes. I stood behind him with his face parallel to my face, and he said: O Banu Arfada, be busy (in your sports) till I was satiated. He said (to me): Is that enough? I said: Yes. Upon this he asked me to go.
Once again in Bukhari, this event is recorded:
Volume 5, Book 58, Number 268:
Narrated Aisha:
That once Abu Bakr came to her on the day of 'Id-ul-Fitr or 'Id ul Adha while the Prophet was with her and there were two girl singers with her, singing songs of the Ansar about the day of Buath. Abu Bakr said twice. "Musical instrument of Satan!" But the Prophet said, "Leave them Abu Bakr, for every nation has an 'Id (i.e. festival) and this day is our 'Id."
And then in Bukhari, another Hadith relates a connection between musical instruments and the family of David (saw). Further evidence that, indeed, the Psalms were musical in nature
Volume 6, Book 61, Number 568:
Narrated Abu Musa:
That the Prophet said to him' "O Abu Musa! You have been given one of the musical wind-instruments of the family of David .'
And on one final note, I thought the following Hadith can also be used in the matter. The Hadith relates of how the adhan came to be, and how the Prophet's companions suggested the use of musical instruments such as the horn or bell like the People of the Book. Now although the Prophet ultimately approved the use of the human voice, there is no mention that the Prophet chastised his companions for suggesting musical instruments for the adhan. And if the Prophet was so very much against musical instruments, then why would his companions dare to suggest the use of such sinful things in the call to prayer????
From Muslim Book 004, Number 0735:
Ibn Umar reported: When the Muslims came to Medina, they gathered and sought to know the time of prayer but no one summoned them. One day they discussed the matter, and some of them said: Use something like the bell of the Christians and some of them said: Use horn like that of the Jews. Umar said: Why may not a be appointed who should call (people) to prayer? The Messenger of Allah (may peace be upon him) said: O Bilal, get up and summon (the people) to prayer.
I love Noman Ali Khan for his knowledge, how he explain. Hope He would be conscious of his mistakes and rectify it as he teach us.
Follow people or knowledge how not a scholar look up Saudi scholars who have preserved the Deen and fluent in hadith and Islamic jurisprudence
the problem with that is quran says not to forbid anything that Allah never made haram. but you people love adding stuff to Quran
Leave him, safe yourself from wrong understanding they are pushing
@@OmerAhmed-yw1lg “Whatever the Messenger gives you, take it. And whatever he forbids you from, leave it. And fear Allah. Surely Allah is severe in punishment.”( Quran 59:7)
@@OmerAhmed-yw1lgThats what i just wrote in a comment... 100% agree! Allah didn't call it Haram but human know better then Allah of course...
Alhamdulillah I have quited music since start of October and it's far esaier than what people thought
May Allah(s.w.t) make it more easier for the ummah of islam
life is most beautiful than without music
Well done for quiting that.
If you replace it with Quran recitation, not only will it be easy, but also way more enjoyable then music
Masha'allah tabarakallah,I am still struggling with it 😢
The Non muslims believe Allah is UNJUST because ALLAH guides whom he wills ➜ but the TRUTH is all those who are NOT guided, should ONLY blame themselves because Allah guides not the wrongdoers ( unjust ) ( 📗Quran 5 : 51 )
Allah does not guide one who is a transgressor & an extreme liar.’ ( 📗Quran 4O : 28 )
You are a champion Brother Uthman. May Allah protect you and continue using you for his Deen! Much love from Australia
Commenting for the Algorithm.
May Allah accept it from us.
May Allah forgive us, keep us on the straight path, and grant us Jennathul Firdous.
I love you, sheikh, for the sake of Allah.
Amen 🤲🏻❤️🌹
Finally it has been addressed with proof excellent work may Allah guide us all to the right path
Respectfully the Shaikh has produced what he considers to be 'evidence' and for it to be considered proof one would have to examine the 'evidence' to establish whether it reaches the status of proof. At 25:39 mins the Shaikh talked about generality and exceptions which addresses events at which music would be permitted but if it was a prohibition like all other explicit prohibitions then there would be no exceptions. As an example the Qur'an instructs us to eat unlawful foods if our life is in danger because of hunger unless the exceptions are explicitly mentioned! After all there is no way the Prophet Muhammad SAW would go against an explicit prohibition ( if it was explicitly prohibited) it seems from the evidence there is no explicit prohibition on music.
Jzk khairan for giving a clear and logical explanation. Even without these explanations, I know from experience how my connection with Allah, Salah, Quran , everything gets affected the days I fall short and listen to music. Trying to be better, what we get without music in our lives, is far superior and brings real peace and tranquility that once we realize, we stop looking for loopholes to bring music into our lives. May Allah help us all🤲🏼
It was brother Nouman Ali Khan's work that inspired me but I did fell into a dilemna and confusion about music when I heard that statement from him and it really bothered as I was not able to find any clarification. Jazakallah for the clarification. I still admire him and pray for his forgiveness and further guidance including us
@@shuaibhilal3410
Yea brother, imams are human, when they start to Iie we have to stop listening to them, pray for them like you said and move on to other imams.
Some pages :
Sabul as Salam
Al Hidaaya Translations
Scholarly Subtitles
People of knowledge
Treasures of knowledge
Zayn al Abideen
The Guided Path
English :
Garden of ilm
Scottish Revert Teacher (cIass for reverts & sisters too)
AbdurRahmanOrg
Amau
Saajid Liphaam
Ilmstitute
Aameen
Every learned person has an opinion based on his knowledge. Could music be broken down into groups? Is all music haraam? Is too much haraam? Is a little halaal? May ne depends on the type of music.
@@shafserious2805
The video delt with that.
But nak calling a person drunk with no.proof is very bad manners.
advise each other as Muslims in the best way if they do wrong. Hopefully at the end of this era there will be unity of Muslims throughout the world.
0:50
Allah doesen‘t unite the ummah on falsehood, said the prophet ﷺ
@@toni8866 There's a condition tho.
“I heard the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) say: ‘My nation will not unite on misguidance, so if you see them differing, follow the great majority.’”
Follow the majority because there's consensus.
Ameen
May Allah(swt) remove pride and ego from the hearta of ummah and the scholars. A community is truly doomed if its scholars are not truthful and filled with pride
xD
Ameen
Alhamdulillah this was such a beneficial video. I thank you Shaykh Uthman on behalf of all us, for this was an issue that needed to be addressed urgently. May Allah preserve you.
Am glad someone called him out .
People have been calling him out for years for these types of issues and his public statements. This is nothing new
What i would say is. Knowledge is deen. We must scrutinise whatever Knowledge we are getting from the Internet if we do not have the chance to go to the scholars ourselves.
@@SalamCast
Yea but there also many ppl who don't understand public corrections of misguided imams.
@@SalamCastcame here to say this. Nak been saying crazy stuff for more than a decade
@@falsesectslikeshiaarejudeo6543 but some of them have studied under major scholars too and have been told to clarify the truth from the falsehood. This is what shaykh Uthman is doing.
Sadly there is a lot of bigotry towards the Salafi Dawah and they dismiss it as people not understanding because it goes aganst their desires
Music is so dangerous. It's more addictive than drugs.
💯
Indeed
LMAO how can you even say that LOL music is not even known as addictive you are overestimating music and underestimating drugs drugs are way more fkn crazy than some lyrics with some beats
@ u need help
@yitrua that’s exactly what Iblees wants you to think.
Thank you Sheikh for this, may Allah bless/protect you and keep us on siratul-mustaqeem
By the title I was afraid you will go angry but this is the best explained video I have been seen from your channel. Thanks for wait and finally explain the best way. ♥️
Alhamdulillah, may Allah preserve you shaikh Othman, and give you a long life and all the strength to preserve His religion through you 🤲
Aameen
Music is the most powerful weapon of the magicians.
And the evil elite. Look at Hollywood...
Your moon god is the god of mental devolution
@@dereckjames4563 I've already told this to someone that Baal is long dead, And tell me what is the good in music because I listen to it everyday even tho I'm a Muslim, Tell me the answer!
See how water responds to music. Realise that certain systems in your body are largely water. Music is from god therefore it can tune you up. The desert bandit knew this, so he banned it.
@@dereckjames4563 music is trash and a waste of time listening to it.
I'm gonna download this video, in sha Allah. Because a lot of our masjids in our city, started to give this false fatwa too. Just like the Prophet sAaws predicted as a sign of judgement day.
Music is not Haram, Nobody can prove it is Haram. These are evidences..👇 So Fear Allah not the Sectarians.
1. Whatever ALLAH leaves without saying Haram are halal by default. General Fiqh rule.
100s of Scholars including Imam Al Gazzali, Shiekh Ibn Hazm, Sheikh Ibn Arabi, Sheikh Khardavi, etc., openly said "music in itself is not haram".
2. HADITHS - Prophet(SA) allowed music with instruments in his own house during Eid - Sahih Bukhari 987, 988, 3931, 949, 952.
3. HADITHS - Prophet(SA) compared the quran recitation of a companion Abu Musa(r) to the musical rhythmic sound of Mazamir(wind instruments, flute).
- Sahih Bukhari 5048, Al Adab Al Mufrad 805, Al-Adab Al-Mufrad 1087.
4. HADITHS - Prophet Muhammad(SA) invited singers to a wedding function to sing - Sunan Ibn Mājah 1900.
5. That "Bukhari hadis 5590 which says musical instruments are haram in an indirect way" is a hanged hadis or an un-numbered hadis in bukhari text. Classical Scholar Sheikh Ibn Hazm stated that the chain of this hadith is broken.
Also this hadith is an indirect statement, we cannot take this hadith as a solid evidence.
6. Only ALLAH has the authority to declare Haram. Scholars do not have that authority. Inorder to consider anything as Haram it requires solid authentic evidences.
Do not falsely declare with your tongues, “This is lawful, and that is unlawful,” ˹only˺ fabricating lies against Allah. Indeed, those who fabricate lies against Allah will never succeed.
- Quran 16:116
, he is great explainer of the Qur'an and that is his area of expertise so take good knowledge from his Qur'an explanations. As far as his own fatawas and opinions are concerned ignore them.
Always take good from people. May Allah bless you.
@hs6585 Nouman Ali khan is right.
There is no Quran verse or Sahih Hadith which prohibits music directly. Nothimg...
@ Ibn Hazm claimed that this hadith is interrupted in the chain of transition between Bukhariyy and Sadaqa ibn Khalid.' However, Ibn Qayyim replied and made it clear that what Ibn Hazm said was not true. He summarised his answer in six aspects:
1. Bukhariyy met Hisham Ibn Ammar and heard the Hadith from him. If he heard by him through the so-called
'An'ana (chain of tradition), a connection is very likely, because they lived at the same time and heard of each other. When he said:
"Hisham said [..]", then there is basically no difference
to the statement: ", of Hisham".
@kikikoko607 Brother that hadith doesnt say musical instruments are haram directly. It is saying as if instruments are made haram already.
Read that hadith again, bukhari 5590. Silk and Alcohol are haram, Quran says it repeatedly. But where does it say that Musical Instruments or Music is Haram directly? Show me!!!
It is clear that hadith bukhari 5590 is fabricated by some to make music haram.
Wow Maasha Allah. May Allah reward Shaykh Uthman for the research and nice way of delivering his opinion on the matter to even teach his audience not just state something is permissible or Impermissible. May Allah increase you and us in knowledge and make it easy for us to follow ameen
Narrated Zayd ibn Thabit:
I heard the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) say: May Allah brighten a man who hears a tradition from us, gets it by heart and passes it on to others
Prophet and Sahaaba did not leave behind even one hadith. Do not attach concocted tales with the name of Rasool and Sahaaba
@@abdar-rahman6965 Can you elaborate on what you mean?
@@PGY2000
Gentleman: my previous comments are so clear that further elaboration is not needed.
Prophet and Sahaaba did not leave behind even one hadith. All extra-Quranic stories of Sunnah, Hadiths and Tafsirs are nothing but hearsay folkloric tales; and a wise will not build his faith, Sharia laws, rites and rituals on such folklore. Quran is enough for Muslim, 16:89. What is not in Quran is NOT part of Islam
We read in tons of ancients books that Prophet forbade to write his hadiths and 4 Caliphs burned and banned Hadiths
Sheikh Uthman is truly a real man in every video of issues of disputes he presents evidences he never says I listened from so and so
may Allah protect him and grant him Jannah
Ameen
Beautiful example of how to correct others and how to protect the deen.
Barakallahu fik
May Allah swt Reward sheikh Uthman ❤️
Your observation touches on a very significant issue within the Muslim community. Criticism, if done constructively and sincerely for the sake of Allah, can be a form of mutual advice (naseehah), which is a cornerstone of Islamic brotherhood. However, when criticism turns into obsession, hostility, or public shaming, it often causes more harm than good.
From india. A lot of muslims are engaged in qawali(religious songs with musical instruments) in the subcontinent.good video to debunk❤.
From Canada, keep up the good work sheikh Uthman!
وفقكم الله لكل خير
JazakAllahu Khairan Shaykh Uthman
Salamalaykum waramatuLlah am a fan of your channel allahumabareek!! Your wordpress tutorials are one of the best av seen on youtube!!! So happy to see you here!! May Allah(swt) unite us all in jannah!! Amin
May Allah bless you @NayyarShaikh
Alhamdulillah, music is off the table for me.
I used to listen a lot of music, but no it's all gone. Alhamdulillah for making it easy for me to give it up.
InshaAllah, awareness on this issue will rise so that it'll become an obvious matter for every practicing muslim.
At this point, (I did it too), people are searching for an opinion to enable them to do it. We should even stay away of grey areas. May Allah guide us further😊 Ameen
This is why we should check 3 different but legislate sources before ruling something as permissible or non-permissible.
Thank you for approaching Brother Nouman in a respectable manner and giving him enough time and curtesy to respond. You provided solid proof in support of your beliefs, which is very important in this social media age when anyone can say anything and then egos get involved, but proof never appears.
I am watching from Bulgaria, ya Shaykh Uthman. May Allah have mercy on every salafi and may Allah protect you and the true scholars of Ahlus Sunnah Wal Jammah
Lol as a "salafi" myself, stop please replace "salafi" with Muslims. Don't get into this sectarian mentality
Asalamu alaikum how is Bulgaria? I wanted to move for unii
Say : May Allah have mercy on every MUSLIM brother
Why that is sounded like a spy would say ?
Shame on you! Your comment is an absolute disgrace to Muslim ummah. Asking for Allah’s mercy to extend only to a sect? May Allah guide you to the right path
This is a sign of qayamat, that music is going to be called halal .may allah guide all Muslims
Sign of Qaymat is also things that were halal would be considered haram. There has always been a difference of opinion regarding music among scholars. Music is not inherently haram or halal it depends on the type of music and usage
@pandaprrr995 thanks for the information
It is haram. Period@@pandaprrr995
@@pandaprrr995 you shouldn't come to us with such nonsense that there is a difference of opinion about music, the sheikh brought the evidence in the video, what is the evidence that it is not haram or your proof is just that there is a difference of opinion, really embarrassing how some Muslims argue just because they want to listen to music
SubhanAllah
I am glad someone talk about this.
You absolutely roasted his baseless statements 🔥🔥🔥, your big fan from saudi arabia 🇸🇦, you maade me firmly believe that (الحق بيّن و الباطل بيّن)
Wow! Amount of scholars that agreed upon this statement is overwhelming. Brother helped us to feel the power of the ‘ijma’
Brother helped misguide you on what the term “ijma” means lol
Ijma means NO ONE held a contrary view lol let alone the thousands of Scholars throughout history.
Tawus Ibn Kaysan the Great Tabieen student of the Great Sahabi and legendary Mufassir Ibn Abbas said that music is permissible.
So his own student disagrees, but there is ijma, let alone Ibn Hazm, Imam al-Ghazali, the Maliki school of the salaf. Like come on man
@@Wise_guy007 Not quite. brother clearly stated it is "almost ijma" not that it was "ijma" with certainty. Also he showed proof of one of the scholars particularly stating that all of the 4 madhahib prohibit listening to music or view it as haram. So the Maliki school of the salaf does not allow it. Furthermore, There is clearly an overwhelming amount of insanely important and major scholars who clearly, according to this video, agree that music is HARAM, one of them even swearing by Allah that in surah Al-Luqman an ayah that speaks of purchasing idle talk is referring to musical instruments if I remember correctly. I'm not sure if you watched the video, music is prohibited, period. Whether you like it or not the facts were stated and that's that. Also if I remember correctly Al-ghazali was influenced by Al-kalam and towards the end of his life ended up regretting his innovation of stating music was halal but take this one with a grain of salt. If I made any mistakes forgive me and they are from me, if I said anything good it is from Allah. Salam!
Terms Ijma and so-called Scholars have no authority in Islamic law. If you have understood the whole Quran, then you are supposed to realize that for Islamic law, Quran is the only authority. And Quran never makes Music Haram
If u have something show it with evidence and References, And btw take this panfit in asool al fiqh, Imam Al-Juwayni stated: “If the disagreement among the scholars occurs within a short period and they then agree upon a particular view, this is considered consensus (ijma‘). However, if the disagreement persists for a long time and they later agree, this does not constitute consensus.” (al burhan fi aswl al fiqh(158/1 ))
@@Wise_guy007
@@PGY2000 there is literally no such thing as “almost” ijma from a fiqh stand point. Ibn Hajar wrote in fatul Bari that one side claims ijma music is haram, the other side claims ijma music is halal.
The verse of surah Luqman has been interpreted many different ways. But the dishonest part here is any lack of deep research on Uthman’s part. The Scholars who permit music do not discredit those statements, but they contextualize them properly. Indeed music was used to dissuade people from listening to the Quran, revelation came and rather than saying music is haram, Allah in His infinite wisdom declared any and all amusements, entertainment or theatrics that dissuade people from the message of Islam to be haram.
Uthman provides many evidences, with context or deeper understanding. He ignores the narrations of Imam Malik singing and playing the drum in Tariq al-Baghdadi. He ignores the known fatwa of abu Hanifa permitting the buying and seeking of musical instruments. He ignores half of Islamic history that doesn’t agree with him.
This is why the Scholars take such offence to this man. Slandering the giants of the ummah because they had not understood Islam as good as himself. His pride and arrogance is clear from the rest of his content. We judge according to the thahir, and what is apparent is he is very full of himself and his knowledge.
My request, instead of challenging people about music, he needs to accept the challenges of the Scholars who have called him out for pretending to be a Mufti and Shaykh.
That is all and may Allah forgive me if I have said anything out of a place of arrogance or enmity Amīn ya Rabb.
Abdullah bin 'Amr bin Al-'As (May Allah be pleased with them) reported: The Prophet (ﷺ) said, "Convey from me even an Ayah of the Qur'an [Riyad as-Salihin 1380]
May Allah Guide us and Save us from blurring lines. Once the lines get blurred, there is chaos.
May Allah reward One Nessage Foundation and those who commented and shared..wasn’t planning to watch this but it came up on my page so Alhamdulilah for the clarification and reminder
I'm from India. May Allah give you jannatul firdaus and us as well...
Hadith won't get you anything in life. Nothing
There's 1 book in islam the quran
قُلۡ أَطِیعُوا۟ ٱللَّهَ وَأَطِیعُوا۟ ٱلرَّسُولَۖ فَإِن تَوَلَّوۡا۟ فَإِنَّمَا عَلَیۡهِ مَا حُمِّلَ وَعَلَیۡكُم مَّا حُمِّلۡتُمۡۖ وَإِن تُطِیعُوهُ تَهۡتَدُوا۟ۚ وَمَا عَلَى ٱلرَّسُولِ إِلَّا ٱلۡبَلَـٰغُ ٱلۡمُبِینُ
[Surah An-Nur 54]
Ameen
Amazing work by Shaykh Uthman.
Now no one can refute him because our Shaykh brought the receipts 📰
@mo9ala7 Remove your image drawing from your profile then, the Messenger of Allah (peace be upon him) said: "Those who make images (musawwiroon) will be punished on the Day of Resurrection; it will be said to them, 'Bring to life what you have created.'" (Sahih al-Bukhari, Book 76, Hadith 104)
Change the profile photo brother to avoid animations to be safe in Shaa Allah
@@AbrahamicBrotherhoodHow did you know he made that drawing?, he might've taken it from somewhere on the internet, your statements make it look like you are accusing him of drawing. Fear Allah brother.
I stopped listening to music over 2 years ago. Only Nasheeds now. But not often. Im listening more to recitations. My heart is closer to Allah then I was before. So it only makes sense to cut the distractions from what sticks to your heart. My kids are benefitting.
Yes, Alhamdulillah that is why I like to encourage people to just give it a try. Replace music with the Quran sincerely for even one week and you’ll see a difference Insha Allah.
@UmmMusa-x2g agreed. For the reverts who grew up listening to music though. This takes time to be rid of music and InshaAllah like you said keep trying, keep striving for the sake of Allah and may he ease all of our struggles. Ameen
Insha Allah, i would like to try to stop music
May Allah preserve you Sheikh,and use us to protect the deep.. aameen
Jazak Allah'u Khairan ya sheikh Uthman
From Egypt
By Allah, The Most Glorious.. I love you for the sake of Allah, and nothing else.. Not for material benefit nor biased, enforced stances. May Allah grant you the best rewards in this life and the next.
May Allah gather us in the Highest Firdaws, Allah'uma ameen.
How clear u made it. Jazakallahu khyra sheikh❤
❤
This is one of the beauty of Islam in that, you can’t just make up stuff and expect scholars to turn a blind eye.
They will debate it and find the your reasons backed by authentic narrations or the Qur’an.
If you cannot defend it, it is wrong.
May Allah guide our Brother Ali Nouman Khan. I admire him so much
Jazakhallahu khair Sheik Uthman
From Nigeria 🇳🇬
Masha Allah..That was very important to reply to him..Many people are confused...Your research on this issue is awesome..I got benefitted from it...Jazak Allah khair Brother...
I used to follow nouman ali khan but since i heard him say that music wasnt haram multiple years ago i stoped following him and i was sooo sad cause i liked his kind way to present things etc... but since he said music wasnt haram i started doubting all the things i used to hear from him, i think he is a kind and good guy but what he is doing should stop, may allah guide him and open his heart to the truth in shaa allah and help him acknowledge the truth cause i care about him, thank you so much sheikh Uthman for bringing this up and helping people understand, now i have a reference to send my friends to.
May allah in shaa allah make me meet you in person, love in the sake of allah sheikh Uthman from algeria ❤.
Dr Noman Ali is my favourite. May Allah grant grant us wisdom how far are rhythms allowed. Quran recitals are amazing.
@@rhodasmith2586 music used the proper way is not e.g. it converted millions of Indians with songs of the prophets and sahabas
His own words are that he is not a hadith scholar.. so stop doubting on him for everything, he is great explainer of the Qur'an and that is his area of expertise so take good knowledge from his Qur'an explanations. As far as his own fatawas and opinions are concerned ignore them.
Always take good from people. May Allah bless you.
Exactly brother. I'm sad when people push away the goodness of another just by spotting one single fault. It's ridiculous. We Muslims must not hate another, but we can hate his/her stance or actions. Not the man himself as a human being. @@justhydr
expecting any person to be correct in all jurisdiction is kinda stupid idea. take benefit of his goodness and filter through other scholars. we cannot think like western celebrity followers style.
May Allah reward you abundantly.
Thank you from Morocco! جزاك الله خيراً
A.a great video brother thank you for clearing up so many questions for us. May Allah Tala give us jannah Ameen
Sh Uthman the knowledgeable and courageous .he asks us all🎉
do we have the fortitude, courage, and determination to stand up to those who threaten our values?
That is the way to respond.....mashaAllah ....keep uniting the ummah❤
Thank you soo much for calling this out sheikh❤
Ya Sheikh dont die Jahal and read our primary books (Bhikhari/Muslim)
Bhukhari 952 Muslim 2061
Narrated Aisha: Abu Bakr came to my house while two small Ansari girls were singing beside me the stories of the Ansar concerning the Day of Buath. And they were not singers. Abu Bakr said protestingly, Musical instruments of Satan in the house of Allah's Apostle ! It happened on the `Id day and Allah's Apostle said, O Abu Bakr! There is an `Id for every nation and this is our `Id.
Bukhari 5147 music
Narrated Ar-Rabi`: (the daughter of Muawwidh bin Afra) After the consummation of my marriage, the Prophet came and sat on my bed as far from me as you are sitting now, and our little girls started beating the tambourines and reciting elegiac verses mourning my father who had been killed in the battle of Badr. One of them said, Among us is a Prophet who knows what will happen tomorrow. On that the Prophet said, Leave this (saying) and keep on saying the verses which you had been
Bhukhari 5162
حَدَّثَنَا الْفَضْلُ بْنُ يَعْقُوبَ ، حَدَّثَنَا مُحَمَّدُ بْنُ سَابِقٍ ، حَدَّثَنَا إِسْرَائِيلُ ، عَنْ هِشَامِ بْنِ عُرْوَةَ ، عَنْ أَبِيهِ ، عَنْ عَائِشَةَ ، أَنَّهَا زَفَّتِ امْرَأَةً إِلَى رَجُلٍ مِنْ الْأَنْصَارِ ، فَقَالَ نَبِيُّ اللَّهِ صَلَّى اللَّهُ عَلَيْهِ وَسَلَّمَ : يَا عَائِشَةُ مَا كَانَ مَعَكُمْ لَهْوٌ فَإِنَّ الْأَنْصَارَ يُعْجِبُهُمُ اللَّهْوُ .
mishkat 3153
‘A’isha reported God's Messenger as saying, “Make this marriage publicly known, solemnise it in the mosques, and play tambourines in honour of it.”
Tirmidhi transmitted it, saying this is a gharib tradition.
@@AllahRasool-ISLAM
There are those who worship Allah and those who worship the forefathers „Narrators“
I agree worh you brother, Ahadis are contradictory regarding Music, so no strict conclusion conclusion can be made that they are haram, it is also unfaire to say it is all halal.
Part of the music that includes haram content is haram
Part of it which doesn’t include it is not
Wasalam
Calling what someone bro. It's disrespectful he didn't
@hewadsaad1378 exactly brother his point is that it is totally Haraam based on books that irrelevant. If we go by our primary book only then it is very simple to understand that events like eid and Nikah can have music and of course within Islamic rules. For example no mix gathering of men and women, it should not vulgar and the content of the songs should not be vulgar. I am from Punjab Pakistan we have Dhol or drums not Duffs so in our wedding we are going to play Punjabi dhol no A duff from Arab lol...
Islam is Quran and Sunnah not 4 sects (Hanfi, Shafi, maliki, Hambali from Sunni, or Jaffery from Shia
@@AllahRasool-ISLAM and they tell us that there are 4 mazaheb and 4 ways, forgeting that every time they pray, they recite surat al fatiha, and they recite to guide us to the ONE Strainght path....so only those who guess in the unseen, or make up new stuff, be it us, be it our forefathers, all of them say that there 4 ways to the truth, 4 mazib, well i dont care 2 peanuts for your mazahib...i dont. all i care is Quran and Sunnah..i dont want to know anything about mazahib...i want to know Quran and sunnah and th teaching of our best teacher prophet Muhammad pbuh....so while everytime when they stand up in salah they pray for the straight path....there is only ONE PATH, and that is straight path....i am not a follower of my forefathers..but these people are...they are no different than the saying of foremer people who used to follow their forefathers..... i am follower of Allah and his messenger, and I am muslim...the word muslim is enough for me, unlike many that are not comfrotable with this word, for some it is not even enough, they want to add stuff to it saying: ok you are muslim but which muslim?
have these people lost their minds or are they taken for a ride by our former people, by forefathers...these are following the saying of their forefathers and left Quran and sunnah...these are equivalent to Mushrikin...a crime that Allah will never forget...for their ignorance of Quran...and they are the first to come and tell us that you cant handel the quran...it is too dificult for you... I tell them: well you shut up!
my language is harsh against them, because they are a people who do not understand, a people who wont think nor allow anyone else to think...Quran declares of such people as worst of all.
they are the people who will accuse my beloved prophet muhammad of marring a child...i tell them: wait and see what is awaiting for you on judgment day, they are a poeple who raise narrators above Quran!
i departed from them..all of them...and i dont engage with them except for those who are sound in their judgment....they are a
wasallam :)
May Allah swt guide us all on the right path we’re all in this together and learning InshaAllah 🤲
Watching from the Gambia. May Allah protect and preserve you brother uthman. This is really important for addressing this issue.
Music is not Haram, Nobody can prove it is Haram. These are evidences..👇 So Fear Allah not the Sectarians.
1. Whatever ALLAH leaves without saying Haram are halal by default. General Fiqh rule.
100s of Scholars including Imam Al Gazzali, Shiekh Ibn Hazm, Sheikh Ibn Arabi, Sheikh Khardavi, etc., openly said "music in itself is not haram".
2. HADITHS - Prophet(SA) allowed music with instruments in his own house during Eid - Sahih Bukhari 987, 988, 3931, 949, 952.
3. HADITHS - Prophet(SA) compared the quran recitation of a companion Abu Musa(r) to the musical rhythmic sound of Mazamir(wind instruments, flute).
- Sahih Bukhari 5048, Al Adab Al Mufrad 805, Al-Adab Al-Mufrad 1087.
4. HADITHS - Prophet Muhammad(SA) invited singers to a wedding function to sing - Sunan Ibn Mājah 1900.
5. That "Bukhari hadis 5590 which says musical instruments are haram in an indirect way" is a hanged hadis or an un-numbered hadis in bukhari text. Classical Scholar Sheikh Ibn Hazm stated that the chain of this hadith is broken.
Also this hadith is an indirect statement, we cannot take this hadith as a solid evidence.
6. Only ALLAH has the authority to declare Haram. Scholars do not have that authority. Inorder to consider anything as Haram it requires solid authentic evidences.
Do not falsely declare with your tongues, “This is lawful, and that is unlawful,” ˹only˺ fabricating lies against Allah. Indeed, those who fabricate lies against Allah will never succeed.
- Quran 16:116
My Gambian brother
My Gambian brother
Bro literally "*Left the Chat*" 😅
May Allah guide him
not like that my brother
everyone has their own understanding and knowledge level, and i agree that nauman ali khan is at fault but we should not make fun of him because of this
@@Ryuk-s7b Dude is actively corrupting Islamic understanding and preaching a feminist version of Islam but "dOnT mAkE fUN oF hiM"
@@Trait74 Corrupting? What do you know? Look, in Islam we are taught to respect. If you don't know how to respect, don't speak, okay? It's that simple. As the prophet says, if you're not going to say anything, well, shut up. Make constructive criticism, but don't make fun of it. It seems that people haven't been taught to speak well at home.
Yes Allah. Not you!!!
@ Well my brother if we do not know, we should not speak about someone's heart, and, Nauman Ali Khan has been of great service to Islam.
I sincerely prayed to Allah and asked Him for guidance and correct aqeedah. And Alhamdulilah my heart deviated from NAK when he tried to spin the permissibility of music in an earlier lecture where he didn't elaborate on his stance.
The same thing happened with Omar Suleman and Yasir Qadhi when they lectured to join hands with Lgbtqs and others and the issue of beard was elongated just to conclude it is proven authentic to keep a fistful beard.
I can't thank Allah enough, now I have completely distanced myself from almost all the western scholars and try to learn from the real scholars who wouldn't put Ustad, Sheikh or Imam before their names.
i wouldnt say to deviate from them but take the good and anything which you feel is not right and of course with the evidences then we make dua and we leave that. but for those names that you have mentioned they have contributed greatly to the teachings and understandings of the Quran and ethics and have clarified where there have been assumptions and accusations made against them so we should always think the best of our brothers and sisters and of course if there are any concerns then make dua and leave the rest to Allah. however what we should not do is write anyone off or keep others away from them when they are benefitting and saying things which align with islam Quran and sunnah inshallah!
Thanks, my brother. You know it's so baffling when the scholar you love acts on issue so clear as this and results in a defense that is unacademic and embarrassing.
I love Shaikh Nouman and his lectures for the sake of Allah.
I'm not learned in quran and hadith, I only listen to all our scholars as we all can't be as knowledgeable as those that study quran and hadith in colleges for the sake of enlightening the Ummah.
I always think that if some of us who love him see his error so clearly, with our level of knowledge, why can't he.
I don't know who this scholar is, I guess I'm listening to him the first time, and his way of addressing this issue is brilliant and respectful to Shaikh Nouman.
May Allah guide Shaikh Nouman and all of us to the best, he truly needs to be humble with correction.
Truly, if there is poison in a delicious meal, it does more harm than good.
*THAT'S* what I call a video of quality. JazakAllahu Khayran.
Barak-Allahu-feek Sheikh Uthman and OMF team,May Allah guide us All Ameen!