@@SchmergDergenIdc I still think Gravik as a character is really cool and menacing. The actor played him well and deserved better. Can care less about literally everyone else 😭
Yeah but snoke was a totally fabricated waste of space. The skrulls are cool, marvel studios just absolutely botched it. But yeah. But insanely underwhelming
I really feel like he should have taken a sin off for the fact that during the scene where all the baby flerkins are running amok swallowing all the humans, they're playing the song "Memory" in the background. (For those who don't know, that is a song from the soundtrack of the Broadway musical, "Cats" 😂)
😂 My neighbor back on Longisland is Ron Devito he played Rum Tugger for years when CATS was first introduced in Broadway. I worked with him for a few years and I am absolutely sick of that song! He would play and sing it over and over! But not gonna lie I cracked up at that scene. The music fit perfectly. ❤
Yes, the incongruence of the different level of power of Captain Marvel was jolting. Same thing happens with the Force in Star Wars - Palpatine raised a huge fleet of star destroyers from the depths of the planet. If you have that power then you don't need Death Stars etc.
Pretty sure Palpatine didn't use telekinesis to lift hundreds of Star Destroyers.... antigravity technology exists in the Star Wars universe, after all, those Star Destroyers rose under their own power.
A huge fleet of 1,000 ships. The Imperial fleet had 25,000 Star Destroyers. The Death Star had ‘half the firepower of the fleet.’ So, no, you still needed a Death Star.
@@Vahktang More importantly, why do people think a character having huge powers means it's never taxing to use them? Like, Jeremy asks why Captain Marvel needs a ship. Idk, maybe sometimes she likes having a normal place to sleep and shit and store her A1. Maybe her cat likes having a ship. I'm more frustrated by the fact that the Marvel/Sony relationship means they'll never adapt the storyline where Carnage takes over Carol's cat and eats her. It's weirdly similar to that Ren and Stimpy episode where Stimpy climbs into his own belly button.
2:08 Fury is that person in the grocery store that you get to hear their 40-minute life story they’re having on speaker phone while you’re just trying to get your stuff.
This just might be the first Cinemasins video on a movie that is being released on blu-ray on the same day it's being sinned. Quite impressed with it really.
5:24 I wanna add a sin for the explanation of their powers being "entangled" because they're similar to each other. Kamala's powers are explained as manipulating energy from her ancestors' native dimension which she can do because she is half interdimensional being and half mutant. that has nothing to do with Carol and Monica's vague "light-based" powers that they got from messing with infinity stone energy. But the movie basically counted on everyone not having watched the Ms. Marvel show and hey they were right lol
the better explanation here would be that the same energy Kamala manipulates is the same energy being used to create the jump points so when Monical and Carol both touch it yadda yadda yadda. It's still bullshit but I think that's what they were originally going for before they dumbed it down to "they all do light stuff so... yeah."
yeah I think so too but they don’t explain it like that they explain it like “well we all have light based powers and that’s what connects us” but Kamala’s powers are not “light based” at all
Well, um, so apparently Noor is the energy Kamala draws on from the Noor Dimension (where her ancestors came from), and it's described as "cosmic, photonic and mystical energy" or "hard light".. so, yeah, light. The hard-light thing was mentioned a few times in the Mrs Marvel show. I am not saying the movie's "explanation" makes real sense, tho!
Carol Danvers, Nick Fury, Captain Mar-Vell, the Kree Empire and their Supreme Intelligence, and the Skrulls and their Secret Invasion were better handled by the Avengers Earth's Mightiest Heroes animated series.
The only one on that list I will argue is Nick Fury. And only in that Pre-Infinity War, or at least through Winter Soldier/Civil War, he's on par with EMH, Fury after that point - yeah.... I don't know what the hell their thinking. I'd even go as far with Danvers that Avengers: Assemble or whatever that one that replaced EMH was called (yet seemed to still share some continuity) did a better job, or at the least made her more interesting basically being Maverick with superpowers.
_Avengers: Earth's Mightiest Heroes_ and _The Spectacular Spider-Man_ are both great series. I'd recommend them to anyone who hasn't seen them, even though _SSM_ was cancelled before it could have a satisfying end.
Facts💯💯💯💯💯💯!!!!! For those who never got chance to experience that show, please go watch it if looking for actual marvel comic greatness before Disney/marvel destroyed our beloved characters.
I can't believe you missed the most obvious sin: The Marvels have an enemy with a bracelet that can absorb Captain Marvel's powers to become WAAAAAY stronger; they also have a team member with the EXACT SAME BRACELET, and at no point do they consider maybe charging up that one.
Well, it was really supposed to be to stay a secret until it was finally revealed, so charging up Ms. Marvel’s bracelet wasn’t their plan. And I think that this combination of their powers would mess up with their teleportation thing👍
@@ff_m3570 I think it's a meme, like listing off an actor's full name, their role's full name (civil and superhero identity) and the full title of the movie and the production company... then concluding it's going to be "one of the films". I keep seeing those. "Edward Thomas "Tom" Hardy, CBE as Edward "Eddie" Charles Allan Brock as "Venom" in "Venom" in the Sony Spider-Man Universe is going to act in "Venom", one of the films of all time"
The stupidest thing i thing is when fury tells Monika to fly, yet nobody had idea 1 she ever could. it's like he already had a script of all future powers she will posses
He knows she can turn into energy and also control energy. Once her body is made of energy, she can move said energy wherever she wants within space (not space as in stars, space as in the areas around you), hence flight. Its just common sense
No it's not first you can shoot lasers from your fingers, then you are expected to defy gravity? No that's a big assumption, and he already knew the outcome. Thusly it is already knowing results. @@gingerdog8203
@@gingerdog8203 What is "common sense" about vague undefined superpowers received from being irradiated by an infinite stone or by walking through some equally vaguely defined magic hex? It's simply that "flying without wings" is one of the most common superpowers for some reason, along with various degrees of super-strength.
Her comic powers, that is. The bangles are yet another underwhelming adaptation from the comics. In the comics, Quasar had the bangles and they basically made him Green Lantern but better. By that metric, Kamala is somehow even less creative than Ryan Reynold's Green Lantern.
The frustrating thing is you could have written that character with 100% less moustache twirling, and she could have been one of the best Marvel villains. Like the dude from the first Black Panther, her motivations are pretty logical, her grievance with Captain Marvel entirely justified. They coulda played with shades of grey, if they’d wanted to. They didn’t want to, and fine, it’s a family movie, but there’s a more interesting path there that they didn’t take.
@@GregorBarclay I halfway agree. Killmonger's origin story was good, but I actually thought it was very unclear what his origin had to do with wanting to give high-tech weaponry to street kids or what about his specific history earned that last line about slavery. I feel like he was actually poorly written in a few ways. It just wasn't as obvious because Jordan nailed the performance too well for most people to care. He walks in, says "hello Aunty," and suddenly he's too damn likable to care about how little he's been fleshed out.
And it was so pointless, at that. Carol later explains that the Prince can understand normal speaking tones, so, there was absolutely zero reason to make this movie grind to a halt, so we can throw in a couple of musical numbers (and that's before we get to Kamala and her magic scarf). Even as I was sitting there in the cinema, I was thinking, "get on with it, hurry up already."
I feel sorry for Iman Vellani, she entered the MCU during the start of its decline. I hope that she manages to land much better projects in the future, she deserves better scripts.
That joke existed as a delayed response to that shot in Endgame, where all lesser-powered superheroines inexplicably find themselves in one location on the battlefield to needlessly defend the omni-powered Captain Marvel. She immediately zooms past them.
This movie has already stolen scenes from Star Wars, Spiderman: No way home, High school musical and Wonder Woman. There's NOTHING original about this movie😂
To Protect the world from devastation To United our people within our nation To denounce the evils of truth in love To extend our reach for the stars above Jessie. James Team Rocket blast off at the speed of light Surrender now or prepare to fight. MEOWTH, That's Right.
Her "needing" a spaceship is because its probably more comfortable to hang around in than just floating in a vacuum even if she can. And she needs somewhere to keep her stuff and the cat. Shes still a person, you try living in an open field with no possessions and nobody to talk to and doing nothing but thanklessly saving people all day lol
Yeah. It's basically her apartment. It seems like just an example of trying too hard to find things to sin to appease the people that wanted them to roast the movie. Another example was acting like it was impossible for her to 'really' be super in busy just because she was taking a rest at the time.
I agree, I thought it was obvious that's like her home so she isnt just flying around in space until she reaches a planet that'll house her. Like come on
Its Cinemasins, so not understanding the most basic things and misunderstanding elements described in the movie are the bread and butter of this channel for a long time now. I also think they do it deliberately to get us to comment about it and try and correct what is essentially them acting like morons on purpose just for the sake of easy sins. Its why I rarely watch anymore because it's frustrating and takes away from the entertainment value. Dumb for dumbs sake isn't funny, its lazy.
Space is big. Travelling across space between jump points, even if you could travel near light speed, takes a lot of time with nothing else to do. Also, when a ship is travelling through space, it appears to be standing still.
While surely Carol even with her big missions and mission statements needs the occasional moments to destress, eat, sleep and plan out her next steps (and play with Goose), the travelling times seem a bit inconsistent in the movie, when they seem to be doing fairly well to arrive at their destinations within a few hours when the plot requires it (jump points help, tho, even if these may not be spread out evenly and still leave vast areas to traverse through) and they do not have a training-montage to fill the time with. Do we know how much time elapsed inside the whole movie? Because, it didn't feel very long (based on the fam skipping their earthly responsibilities and hanging out on the space station, but also the rushed'ness of the events depicted), maybe a week or two at most? Either way, I also would not blame Carol to be caught in a moment of seemingly idling.
Or what if someone dressed up a really sinister message in a really upbeat happy-go-lucky sounding melody? Or likewise, how about dressing up a pleasant message in a really ominous and gloomy sounding melody? In either case, wouldn't they just simply hear the words of the message and understand you correctly because of the simple fact that they obviously understand and use the English language? At most, the musical cadence delivering those words would probably make them suspicious of your message. But I get the impression that they would definitely understand the words you used. Anyway, yeah... Plain and simple, the bottom line is that their singing is not inherently a language on its own. Singing in English does not make it a different language from speaking in English. They're using English words to communicate either way. You want to present them as having a language of music, then make it a wordless language where meaning is encoded into every deliberate choice of which pitch / tone / rhythm / etc. that gets used. Like a more natural sounding version of the kinds of beeps that the droids in the Star Wars universe can use for communication (which in that case is meant to be binary code converted to sound waves). They could have made the aliens a race of bird-like people and had the language sound like bird song, or they could have made them a race of dolphin-like or whale-like people and had the language sound like dolphin or whale song. It didn't have to be just humans using a human language.
11:20 - Aerodynamics doesn't care about "upright" versus "on its side". Especially when they're using some sort of anti-gravity technology to stay in the air.
The scene where Hala gets their air and the someone stops another person from taking off their mask. Would have been perfect for "is there air you? don't know!"
I feel like the biggest sin of this movie is how the post credits scene is the most interesting part of the whole movie, same with Black Adam, you could've just released the post credit scene on social media, saved yourself $100 million dollars and spent time on the things people want to see
@@JayAshkevron The planets recovering doesn't mean the people will. If we get wiped out by nuclear war, the planet will recover. We won't. Regardless, when they abandoned the singing planet, they did so thinking they were leaving everyone to die.
10:24 why did Carol’s clothes suddenly change into this? Yeah there’s a throw away 2d effect but it’s basically unexplained who, why and how this happens
Most ridiculous way to say the movie title in the movie. Actually I take that back, the proper word to describe it I don’t think exist. But by all means, give me an example.
@@Crimzon_Nova I don't know about all that. Now that he's done a musical for Disney, I almost wish Will Smith had sung his dumbass line in Suicide Squad. I had a teacher who said that if you can't figure out how to make your movie good, you should do a 180 and work twice as hard to make the most irresponsible movie possible. I actually think there's some merit to that.
The ship's aerodynamics are not any different if on their side. The only advantage would be in generating lift like an airplane wing but they don't require this to stay aloft, so they might as well be upright.
Wow perfect timing, I had just saw this movie last night and was wanting to see a video you did on it edit: Also about them stealing the planet's water... it looked like Hala had salt flats left from when their oceans evaporated Adding salt water on top of existing salt makes the water *super* salty and inhospitable to most life
Wow even in the Cinemasins video… no mention of possible vomited out people in the way too small safety pods which could end up having a lot of people crushed to death. I’m starting to think I was the only one who thought of that possibility.
Also they seem to imply that the cats NEVER use their big tentacle mouths to actually eat things. I call bullshit on that. I’m guessing about half those space people ended up getting regurgitated partially digested.
Either way, it's daylight and they are not illuminating the room in any helpful way. So I think the sin still stands, but at a much smaller scale. Perhaps .1 sins rather than a full sin.
Carol "having to hold back" and not using her supernova powers for fighting individual people ...because a supernova would destroy everything.. will certainly be a very detailed point.
so... you point out that the teleporting gets explained later when you do that sin, but not that it gets explained later why captain marvel doesn't visit monica after endgame? do i have that right?
Sequel Movie with no flashback, CinemaSins: and you expect me to remember what you did from the movie came out last 2 years? Sequel Movie with flashback, CinemaSins: 0:58 What do you want? CinemaSins!!!
Deadpool had already been following the X-Men story already, even featuring Wolverine already as a cameo. Guess they are finally getting ready to merge them.
I unashamedly had a lot of fun watching this movie. My son loved it. It had pacing issues, some of the heavy scenes didn't really land like they should. But the principle cast were just a joy to watch together.
@@CommonTater100 Not in my opinion. In my mind, people who only communicate through song don’t use lyrics. They would use pitch, tone, and the waves of sound to communicate different meanings and purposes
I really liked the idea of forcing Captain Marvel to face the consequences of her “I’m going to solve every problem by blowing it up with my nearly-unbeatable powers” schtick. Execution wasn’t great though, kind of a shame cause I really think that was the growth this character needed to become actually good and compelling instead of a faux feminism icon.
Honestly I think at this point it's more impressive how well they have made MCU Captain Marvel a carbon copy of Marvel Comics Captain Marvel. Everyone hates her, they keep needlessly trying to make the character popular rather than just ditching her and replacing her with one of the already popular female characters.
It's absolutely wild to me that the same studio can make something as utterly brilliant as the Jessica Jones tv show, and then make something completely shit like Captain marvel or she hulk. Like clearly you have people who know how to do this right, so why aren't they writing the scripts?
Yeah I didn't feel that she actually _faced_ any consequences? She didn't feel uncomfortable for what she had done, but only annoyed when people pointed it out? And in the end all those planets are magically restored offscreen in one sentence, so neither the Kree (who were fine with their leader deliberately dooming TWO other planets and a THIRD planet along with its entire solar system, instead of using their tech to transfer Hala to a different and uninhabited solar system with a sun and then terraforming it, or evacuating the already dead planet!) nor Captain Marvel really have to feel guilty or be put in front of a galactic court.
In the comics, she was known by a number of names: Lady of Light, Spectrum, Daystar, Photon, Pulsar. Pretty sure they mentioned at least two of those in the movie (Lady of Light and Pulsar).
Also flerkens and flerkittens have interdimensional portals for stomachs! They can devour anything and will be safely stored in their pocket dimension tummys
I have to say that this some of my favorite commentary from you. That is saying something considering this might be my favorite channel on TH-cam. I get criticized at a steady rate for how critical I am towards movies and can't help calling things out 😅 as ironic as that may be. I know that deep down, my girlfriend actually hates watching movies with me. Surely on some level she just loathes it. Anyway, my initial point was that this commentary was exceptionally hilarious.
I enjoyed the movie but the drop off in villian quality from GOTG3 To The Marvels is insane. Also powerscaling is hilarious cuz like Captain marvel was outdoing thanos but now she needs help
Sin missed: Someone thought it would be great to make the Villain have silver embedded in her teeth, made no sense. Also why are some Kree blue and some not?
I know this is like- all jokes. but the "None of this makes sense" sin can literally be given to literally every movie that isn't 100% grounded EVER. That's such a nothing sin. Besides that though- The only thing that saves this movie for me is Kamala Khan. I can really tell her actor is loving every second of being in a Marvel movie
I didn’t even know; 1. This movie came out already 2. Out long enough for a sins vid 3. Beast was in it I like the MCU but some recently just aren’t the same
Yea here's a question. Why are the jump points IN the atmosphere? The planet is revolving around a star, meaning if they had been any later, they would have jumped INSIDE the planet.
I am STILL trying to figure out how a civil war on a planet extinguishes a SUN? That power to re-start a sun seems like it would have been handy at Nidavillir.
Bonus sin: The cat turning on this particular coffee maker makes no sense since it has a built in feature that makes coffee in the morning at the exact time you set it too, also the cat didn’t click the right button, the switch she flicked is there to control which mode the coffee maker is in not to start the coffee.
Is no one gonna talk about where the frick the giant hand at 15:20 came from? Kamala doesn't have the bangles, they're literally floating in space in the shot
Almost worse is that IF Kamala could do that all along, why have Monica go out there without space suit in the first place and undercut the previous tension of Monica sloooowly catching up with Carol, when Kamala's hard-light fist was faster?
Dar-Benn has zero gravitas. I had already forgotten about her. She should go hang out with Malekith *edit* I think the box office reflects how good this film was. I like to compare it to Spiderman : No Way Home, to understand how hard they dropped the ball
"Why has Captain Marvel not visited Monica any time between the end of Endgame and now?" I don't know, she didn't want Monica to see her as the Annihilator that Dar-Benn and her people see her as or something, I don't know, it's not there's a scene where Captain Marvel literally said that or anything. Also, 5:55 No one can hear her? So the Kree that asked Captain Marvel what she's done just asked if for no reason, totally not cause of what Dar-Benn was saying? Got ya. 12:51 It's Kamala Khan. No.
At like 5:17 the sin of Fury petting the cat I would like to say; my cat, Simon, is responsible for very nearly taking out my eye + scars on my temple and ankles. I still cuddle with him.
I actually thought it was fun and was relieved that it didn't get any Razzie nominations (the Marvel nominations went to Quantumania instead, a movie I'd have a tougher time defending). Flawed for sure but fun.
I'll defend Quantumania on the sole basis that they cast Kathryn Newton. She's fire in basically everything she does. I didn't love some of what they did with her character in Quantumania, but her performance itself was fine.
Can we finally admit that the Skrull are Marvel’s Snoke storyline?? So under welming!!
Yeah they wanted the Skrulls, Secret Invasion was a joke.
@@SchmergDergenIdc I still think Gravik as a character is really cool and menacing. The actor played him well and deserved better. Can care less about literally everyone else 😭
not Marvel, but the mcu.
They can still pull a Skrull queen out and make them awesome in later projects. They probably wont but it is possible to get things back on track.
Yeah but snoke was a totally fabricated waste of space. The skrulls are cool, marvel studios just absolutely botched it. But yeah. But insanely underwhelming
Missed sin: When they said "its easier to round up CATS than humans"!!
I really feel like he should have taken a sin off for the fact that during the scene where all the baby flerkins are running amok swallowing all the humans, they're playing the song "Memory" in the background. (For those who don't know, that is a song from the soundtrack of the Broadway musical, "Cats" 😂)
😂 My neighbor back on Longisland is Ron Devito he played Rum Tugger for years when CATS was first introduced in Broadway. I worked with him for a few years and I am absolutely sick of that song! He would play and sing it over and over! But not gonna lie I cracked up at that scene. The music fit perfectly. ❤
If cats had a sense if justice they would gather their big cat betheren and slaughter the the creative team behind this move😂
It is never addressed that now you have a bunch of alien cats running around on earth
Missed sin: "black girl magic".
Isn't "Steal the Atmosphere" the plot to Spaceballs?
Yes
Honest Trailers literally pointed that out!
TEN THOUSAND YEARS OF FRESH AIR!
"Parri-Air" lol
a much better movie
Yes, the incongruence of the different level of power of Captain Marvel was jolting. Same thing happens with the Force in Star Wars - Palpatine raised a huge fleet of star destroyers from the depths of the planet. If you have that power then you don't need Death Stars etc.
Pretty sure Palpatine didn't use telekinesis to lift hundreds of Star Destroyers.... antigravity technology exists in the Star Wars universe, after all, those Star Destroyers rose under their own power.
A huge fleet of 1,000 ships.
The Imperial fleet had 25,000 Star Destroyers.
The Death Star had ‘half the firepower of the fleet.’
So, no, you still needed a Death Star.
@@Vahktang More importantly, why do people think a character having huge powers means it's never taxing to use them? Like, Jeremy asks why Captain Marvel needs a ship. Idk, maybe sometimes she likes having a normal place to sleep and shit and store her A1. Maybe her cat likes having a ship. I'm more frustrated by the fact that the Marvel/Sony relationship means they'll never adapt the storyline where Carnage takes over Carol's cat and eats her. It's weirdly similar to that Ren and Stimpy episode where Stimpy climbs into his own belly button.
*MALEKITH:* I am the dullest MCU villain audiences have ever seen!
*DAR-BENN:* Um....hold my hammer.
Who's Malekith...?
Wait, who's Dar-Benn?
If you put a gun to my head even then I wouldn't be able to recall the villain of the movie EVEN THO I'M WATCHING YOUR COMMENT!!
Who is Malekith?
I don't know who either of those people are.
Feminist movie, diversity casting. Zzzzzzzzzzz.
2:08 Fury is that person in the grocery store that you get to hear their 40-minute life story they’re having on speaker phone while you’re just trying to get your stuff.
This just might be the first Cinemasins video on a movie that is being released on blu-ray on the same day it's being sinned. Quite impressed with it really.
Because this movie is so easy to sin
5:24 I wanna add a sin for the explanation of their powers being "entangled" because they're similar to each other. Kamala's powers are explained as manipulating energy from her ancestors' native dimension which she can do because she is half interdimensional being and half mutant. that has nothing to do with Carol and Monica's vague "light-based" powers that they got from messing with infinity stone energy. But the movie basically counted on everyone not having watched the Ms. Marvel show and hey they were right lol
the better explanation here would be that the same energy Kamala manipulates is the same energy being used to create the jump points so when Monical and Carol both touch it yadda yadda yadda. It's still bullshit but I think that's what they were originally going for before they dumbed it down to "they all do light stuff so... yeah."
I think cuz she had the other band that the villain was looking for that connected her to the other 2
Still THE DUMBEST part of this entire movie. And that's saying something considering the fucking musical
yeah I think so too but they don’t explain it like that they explain it like “well we all have light based powers and that’s what connects us” but Kamala’s powers are not “light based” at all
Well, um, so apparently Noor is the energy Kamala draws on from the Noor Dimension (where her ancestors came from), and it's described as "cosmic, photonic and mystical energy" or "hard light".. so, yeah, light. The hard-light thing was mentioned a few times in the Mrs Marvel show.
I am not saying the movie's "explanation" makes real sense, tho!
Carol Danvers, Nick Fury, Captain Mar-Vell, the Kree Empire and their Supreme Intelligence, and the Skrulls and their Secret Invasion were better handled by the Avengers Earth's Mightiest Heroes animated series.
Also Hulk, Thor, Malekith, Hawkeye, Ant Man, MODOK and Ultron were all better in that cartoon than the MCU.
I need to rewatch it to remember again...
The only one on that list I will argue is Nick Fury. And only in that Pre-Infinity War, or at least through Winter Soldier/Civil War, he's on par with EMH, Fury after that point - yeah.... I don't know what the hell their thinking. I'd even go as far with Danvers that Avengers: Assemble or whatever that one that replaced EMH was called (yet seemed to still share some continuity) did a better job, or at the least made her more interesting basically being Maverick with superpowers.
_Avengers: Earth's Mightiest Heroes_ and _The Spectacular Spider-Man_ are both great series. I'd recommend them to anyone who hasn't seen them, even though _SSM_ was cancelled before it could have a satisfying end.
Facts💯💯💯💯💯💯!!!!! For those who never got chance to experience that show, please go watch it if looking for actual marvel comic greatness before Disney/marvel destroyed our beloved characters.
I can't believe you missed the most obvious sin: The Marvels have an enemy with a bracelet that can absorb Captain Marvel's powers to become WAAAAAY stronger; they also have a team member with the EXACT SAME BRACELET, and at no point do they consider maybe charging up that one.
Well, it was really supposed to be to stay a secret until it was finally revealed, so charging up Ms. Marvel’s bracelet wasn’t their plan. And I think that this combination of their powers would mess up with their teleportation thing👍
At this stage in the game, Disney sitcom level writing ultimately won't save the MCU.
It's not even a funny sitcom. It's just groan inducing and irritating.
Its cool the coming of Marvel Jesus has been foretold
Which is why they are brining in the big guns with deadpool 3
I think I saw the same comment from filmento 😂
@@ff_m3570 I think it's a meme, like listing off an actor's full name, their role's full name (civil and superhero identity) and the full title of the movie and the production company... then concluding it's going to be "one of the films". I keep seeing those.
"Edward Thomas "Tom" Hardy, CBE as Edward "Eddie" Charles Allan Brock as "Venom" in "Venom" in the Sony Spider-Man Universe is going to act in "Venom", one of the films of all time"
The stupidest thing i thing is when fury tells Monika to fly, yet nobody had idea 1 she ever could. it's like he already had a script of all future powers she will posses
Meanwhile in the comics she had to figure out everything on the ho.
Black girl magic!
He knows she can turn into energy and also control energy. Once her body is made of energy, she can move said energy wherever she wants within space (not space as in stars, space as in the areas around you), hence flight. Its just common sense
No it's not first you can shoot lasers from your fingers, then you are expected to defy gravity? No that's a big assumption, and he already knew the outcome. Thusly it is already knowing results. @@gingerdog8203
@@gingerdog8203 What is "common sense" about vague undefined superpowers received from being irradiated by an infinite stone or by walking through some equally vaguely defined magic hex? It's simply that "flying without wings" is one of the most common superpowers for some reason, along with various degrees of super-strength.
Carol and Monica: "We have the power to fly, absorb and shoot lasers, and tank everything."
Kamala: *"GUM-GUM GIANT PISTOL!"*
I get that reference
lol wow. That was funny
Yup, my thoughts exactly. There are some Marvel heroes with REALLY dumb powers/abilities, but her's is easily the dumbest
Luffy would stomp all three if you offered him a sandwich.
Her comic powers, that is. The bangles are yet another underwhelming adaptation from the comics. In the comics, Quasar had the bangles and they basically made him Green Lantern but better. By that metric, Kamala is somehow even less creative than Ryan Reynold's Green Lantern.
I love how they actually just forgot about Aladna.
Was that OCEAN water supposed to be for drinking? It was hard to pay attention during the movie.
@@IWantToPetYourDog idk but they kinda just forgot about the big hole in the sky that was draining their water.
14:26 I'm gobsmacked at how the Marvel people saw THIS performance and thought this was acceptable
The frustrating thing is you could have written that character with 100% less moustache twirling, and she could have been one of the best Marvel villains. Like the dude from the first Black Panther, her motivations are pretty logical, her grievance with Captain Marvel entirely justified. They coulda played with shades of grey, if they’d wanted to. They didn’t want to, and fine, it’s a family movie, but there’s a more interesting path there that they didn’t take.
You can’t pick on Tom’s wife! 😂💚
@@ZyliceLiddell
Tom's wife ??
@@GregorBarclay I halfway agree. Killmonger's origin story was good, but I actually thought it was very unclear what his origin had to do with wanting to give high-tech weaponry to street kids or what about his specific history earned that last line about slavery. I feel like he was actually poorly written in a few ways. It just wasn't as obvious because Jordan nailed the performance too well for most people to care. He walks in, says "hello Aunty," and suddenly he's too damn likable to care about how little he's been fleshed out.
@@LibellulaireDar-Benn is played by Tom Hiddlesten’s wife
Oh, I forgot how much I hated the Singing Planet! You get 4,000 sins for reminding me.
Shouldn’t that have been typed 4,000 times?
And it was so pointless, at that. Carol later explains that the Prince can understand normal speaking tones, so, there was absolutely zero reason to make this movie grind to a halt, so we can throw in a couple of musical numbers (and that's before we get to Kamala and her magic scarf).
Even as I was sitting there in the cinema, I was thinking, "get on with it, hurry up already."
I feel sorry for Iman Vellani, she entered the MCU during the start of its decline. I hope that she manages to land much better projects in the future, she deserves better scripts.
Did you not see her cringe acting??? The avengers cast acted better then her 😂
@@thatoneginger6480 How was she cringe?
@thatoneginger6480 her acting isn't cringe. Her character is cringe, which is not her fault either
I feel sorry for anyone joining the MCU at this point of time...well maybe Ryan Reynolds is an exception.
@@isaiahwatkins1502a character can be cringe and be made more cringe thanks to a cringe actor
Really thought you had an opportunity during the post-sins section to put in a Space Balls "Suck, Suck, SUCK!" when the water is going up at 17:38
For this movie, I'll use a joke from THE BOYS:
"GIRLS GET IT DONE "
Came here to post this. Left satisfied 😂
Why
GIRLS GET IT ON*
That joke existed as a delayed response to that shot in Endgame, where all lesser-powered superheroines inexplicably find themselves in one location on the battlefield to needlessly defend the omni-powered Captain Marvel. She immediately zooms past them.
This movie has already stolen scenes from Star Wars, Spiderman: No way home, High school musical and Wonder Woman. There's NOTHING original about this movie😂
This is the first CS video I've seen that feels like it's punching down...😂😂
Carol: "Prepare for trouble!"
Monica: "And make it double!"
Kamala: "Marvels, that's right!"
To Protect the world from devastation
To United our people within our nation
To denounce the evils of truth in love
To extend our reach for the stars above
Jessie. James
Team Rocket blast off at the speed of light
Surrender now or prepare to fight.
MEOWTH, That's Right.
If this had been in the film I may have actually liked it, slightly.
Goose is not a cat. + 1 sin for you 😊
Wobbuffet!
Even got the cat, blasting off!
I'm retracting your beast sin because he looks like the animated series X-Men beast. It was one of the few good things.
I want it acknowledged that I love CinemaSins so much that I willfully endured 17 minutes of this film's footage.
Damn that MIB parody was fire 😂
How am I supposed to breathe with no air? No air, no air . . . 🎵
Her "needing" a spaceship is because its probably more comfortable to hang around in than just floating in a vacuum even if she can. And she needs somewhere to keep her stuff and the cat. Shes still a person, you try living in an open field with no possessions and nobody to talk to and doing nothing but thanklessly saving people all day lol
Yeah. It's basically her apartment. It seems like just an example of trying too hard to find things to sin to appease the people that wanted them to roast the movie. Another example was acting like it was impossible for her to 'really' be super in busy just because she was taking a rest at the time.
I agree, I thought it was obvious that's like her home so she isnt just flying around in space until she reaches a planet that'll house her. Like come on
Its Cinemasins, so not understanding the most basic things and misunderstanding elements described in the movie are the bread and butter of this channel for a long time now. I also think they do it deliberately to get us to comment about it and try and correct what is essentially them acting like morons on purpose just for the sake of easy sins. Its why I rarely watch anymore because it's frustrating and takes away from the entertainment value. Dumb for dumbs sake isn't funny, its lazy.
Ouch, when you know "Harder Better Faster Stronger" is from Daft Punk
Knowing how unhinged and deranged Kanye is he might think it belongs to him now
I feel that the reason Captain Marvel didn't use her full powers is the guilt she was feeling for being the annihlator
Well, they could have said it. That's basic Superman in Justice League (cartoon) stuff.
It was so clear to me I'm actually shocked people didn't get it
Counting that almost everyone doesnt like captain Marvel they wouldnt remember nor care
Space is big. Travelling across space between jump points, even if you could travel near light speed, takes a lot of time with nothing else to do. Also, when a ship is travelling through space, it appears to be standing still.
While surely Carol even with her big missions and mission statements needs the occasional moments to destress, eat, sleep and plan out her next steps (and play with Goose), the travelling times seem a bit inconsistent in the movie, when they seem to be doing fairly well to arrive at their destinations within a few hours when the plot requires it (jump points help, tho, even if these may not be spread out evenly and still leave vast areas to traverse through) and they do not have a training-montage to fill the time with.
Do we know how much time elapsed inside the whole movie? Because, it didn't feel very long (based on the fam skipping their earthly responsibilities and hanging out on the space station, but also the rushed'ness of the events depicted), maybe a week or two at most?
Either way, I also would not blame Carol to be caught in a moment of seemingly idling.
Its her Home aswell…
The singing thing bothered me because I immediately thought "does scatting or beat boxing or rapping mean they're saying something?"
Or what if someone dressed up a really sinister message in a really upbeat happy-go-lucky sounding melody? Or likewise, how about dressing up a pleasant message in a really ominous and gloomy sounding melody? In either case, wouldn't they just simply hear the words of the message and understand you correctly because of the simple fact that they obviously understand and use the English language? At most, the musical cadence delivering those words would probably make them suspicious of your message. But I get the impression that they would definitely understand the words you used.
Anyway, yeah... Plain and simple, the bottom line is that their singing is not inherently a language on its own. Singing in English does not make it a different language from speaking in English. They're using English words to communicate either way.
You want to present them as having a language of music, then make it a wordless language where meaning is encoded into every deliberate choice of which pitch / tone / rhythm / etc. that gets used. Like a more natural sounding version of the kinds of beeps that the droids in the Star Wars universe can use for communication (which in that case is meant to be binary code converted to sound waves). They could have made the aliens a race of bird-like people and had the language sound like bird song, or they could have made them a race of dolphin-like or whale-like people and had the language sound like dolphin or whale song. It didn't have to be just humans using a human language.
Living in that planet must be like living in a Juardiance commercial hell all day everyday forever.
11:20 - Aerodynamics doesn't care about "upright" versus "on its side". Especially when they're using some sort of anti-gravity technology to stay in the air.
The scene where Hala gets their air and the someone stops another person from taking off their mask. Would have been perfect for "is there air you? don't know!"
I feel like the biggest sin of this movie is how the post credits scene is the most interesting part of the whole movie, same with Black Adam, you could've just released the post credit scene on social media, saved yourself $100 million dollars and spent time on the things people want to see
Yawn. A plot line marvel will likely never expand and turn into some dry movie or series.
The Enterprise warping in at the last second killed me
This is why they need to be really careful with the power scaling in the movies.
Supposed superheroes abandoning an entire planet to genocide deserves a million sins by itself.
You mean retreating after being defeated?
You better call up Thor Ragnarok too. I didn't like that outcome either, but it seemed necessary at the time.
@@JayAshkevron The planets recovering doesn't mean the people will. If we get wiped out by nuclear war, the planet will recover. We won't. Regardless, when they abandoned the singing planet, they did so thinking they were leaving everyone to die.
@@TYCOM125 In Ragnarok, the people are evacuated before Asgard is destroyed.
@@jedsithordid we not watch the same movie? Pretty sure that ship they left in had a lot of Skulls...
"HALA!!" I understand Jeremy i really do😂😂
10:24 why did Carol’s clothes suddenly change into this? Yeah there’s a throw away 2d effect but it’s basically unexplained who, why and how this happens
9:57-10:10 He asked for it 😂
Most ridiculous way to say the movie title in the movie. Actually I take that back, the proper word to describe it I don’t think exist. But by all means, give me an example.
@@Crimzon_Nova , I can’t think of one 😅
@@Crimzon_Nova I don't know about all that. Now that he's done a musical for Disney, I almost wish Will Smith had sung his dumbass line in Suicide Squad. I had a teacher who said that if you can't figure out how to make your movie good, you should do a 180 and work twice as hard to make the most irresponsible movie possible. I actually think there's some merit to that.
The ship's aerodynamics are not any different if on their side. The only advantage would be in generating lift like an airplane wing but they don't require this to stay aloft, so they might as well be upright.
Wow perfect timing, I had just saw this movie last night and was wanting to see a video you did on it
edit: Also about them stealing the planet's water... it looked like Hala had salt flats left from when their oceans evaporated
Adding salt water on top of existing salt makes the water *super* salty and inhospitable to most life
I had to replay 7:18 a few times because I didn’t know what Jeremy said. But it’s my favorite sin of the movie.
10:12 That disclaimer got me 😂
Wow even in the Cinemasins video… no mention of possible vomited out people in the way too small safety pods which could end up having a lot of people crushed to death.
I’m starting to think I was the only one who thought of that possibility.
Also they seem to imply that the cats NEVER use their big tentacle mouths to actually eat things. I call bullshit on that. I’m guessing about half those space people ended up getting regurgitated partially digested.
They explain it in the movie. The Flerken have pocket dimensions in their stomachs.
@@gothnateuntil they vomit the people out. Did you even read the comment?
Everything other than I guess the 3 mains other then that…everything especially The Cat scene
Idk Captain Marvel sure has started a lot of conflicts and left millions to suffer. Sin for sure.
Those neon lights are actually LED meant to look like neon, so they use surprisingly little electricity.
Either way, it's daylight and they are not illuminating the room in any helpful way. So I think the sin still stands, but at a much smaller scale. Perhaps .1 sins rather than a full sin.
It's not about how much electricity is being used, it's about how stupid and useless it is.
5:25 Jeez! I thought I was the only one who thought so. Thank you Cinema Sins 😂
12:30 He’s holding the writer’s brain! 😆🧠
Wow thebirdman is going to make a really long video out of this one.
Whiteknighting I bet
Carol "having to hold back" and not using her supernova powers for fighting individual people ...because a supernova would destroy everything.. will certainly be a very detailed point.
Should have had the hammer launch scene of Bree and Monica voiced over with, "TEAM ROCKET BLASTING OFF AGAAAAAAAAAAIN!"
@8:37 So this guy can get a cell phone signal in space, and I can't even get a signal in my kitchen!?!
The kree ships would be exactly the same in aerodynamic qualities even if they were diagonal. Sideways up straight up doesn't matter with that shape.
This is the closest I will ever come to watching this movie. I actually started watching it, and just gave up after 15 minutes.
I made it to halftime and then quit. Unwatchable garbage.
I fell asleep when I saw it in theaters
@@nomex9829 I applaud you for going that far.
Me too. I went to bed and let my daughter watch it. I don't know if she even liked it.
I made it to the “Musical” part and immediately turned it off and punished myself
Gotta give you props you synced up the flow of the Men In Black lyrics so well for the Valkyrie scene :D
No sins for every time someone says: “Jumpoint” AND when Kamala hollers: “OH MY GOOOOD!”?
I love your videos, they bring me so much joy. Thank you for quality entertainment
so... you point out that the teleporting gets explained later when you do that sin, but not that it gets explained later why captain marvel doesn't visit monica after endgame? do i have that right?
Sequel Movie with no flashback, CinemaSins: and you expect me to remember what you did from the movie came out last 2 years?
Sequel Movie with flashback, CinemaSins: 0:58
What do you want? CinemaSins!!!
i tried to watch this movie three different times and every time less than half way through i fell asleep
How could you miss the whole ripping off Spaceballs but without actually taking the piss sin?
They heard that Deadpool was having wolverine so they wanted to bring in beast
Deadpool had already been following the X-Men story already, even featuring Wolverine already as a cameo. Guess they are finally getting ready to merge them.
7:45 actually makes a bit of sense. Twin Paradox.
Honestly, those cats were better heroes than the Marvels.
I almost saw the movie in theatres just for the Flerkitten popcorn bucket.
Just say ur mad
I love when these videos are more entertaining than the actual movie :D
7:10 It’s even funnier because Marvel owns MIB
Are you *SERIOUS?!* Disney owns MIB?!
But why didn't Monica stay on her side of the universe to close the gap portal thingy?
Took me ages to realise who dar benn is played by. Time for a freshmeat rewatch.
She’s Loki’s wife irl btw!
I unashamedly had a lot of fun watching this movie. My son loved it. It had pacing issues, some of the heavy scenes didn't really land like they should. But the principle cast were just a joy to watch together.
They had a really cool concept with a people who only communicate while singing and messed it the hell up?
Yeah I’m not surprised.
that is objectively NOT a cool concept. it's a stupid, childish concept that is... well, it's just stupid
@@CommonTater100 Not in my opinion.
In my mind, people who only communicate through song don’t use lyrics. They would use pitch, tone, and the waves of sound to communicate different meanings and purposes
The musical took me right out of the movie!
@@HUFFLE-PUFF I’m also a Hufflepuff
@@shadowhawkrine1947 Then I know you’re a good person! Loyal to a fault! That’s me. lol
And yet, I actually enjoyed this one a lot more than the first Captain Marvel.
I really liked the idea of forcing Captain Marvel to face the consequences of her “I’m going to solve every problem by blowing it up with my nearly-unbeatable powers” schtick. Execution wasn’t great though, kind of a shame cause I really think that was the growth this character needed to become actually good and compelling instead of a faux feminism icon.
Honestly I think at this point it's more impressive how well they have made MCU Captain Marvel a carbon copy of Marvel Comics Captain Marvel. Everyone hates her, they keep needlessly trying to make the character popular rather than just ditching her and replacing her with one of the already popular female characters.
It's absolutely wild to me that the same studio can make something as utterly brilliant as the Jessica Jones tv show, and then make something completely shit like Captain marvel or she hulk. Like clearly you have people who know how to do this right, so why aren't they writing the scripts?
Yeah I didn't feel that she actually _faced_ any consequences? She didn't feel uncomfortable for what she had done, but only annoyed when people pointed it out? And in the end all those planets are magically restored offscreen in one sentence, so neither the Kree (who were fine with their leader deliberately dooming TWO other planets and a THIRD planet along with its entire solar system, instead of using their tech to transfer Hala to a different and uninhabited solar system with a sun and then terraforming it, or evacuating the already dead planet!) nor Captain Marvel really have to feel guilty or be put in front of a galactic court.
@@Mr.Bimgus Right there with you, but my example would be Luke Cage.
You should do bonus rounds again those are hilarious 😂
Just like with Peggy Carter in What If, why won’t they give Rambeau a hero name? It’s not like she’s too good for it.
Um her first name is "Agent".
Because they yanked her original one and gave it to Carol Danvers.
Correction: They gave it to Mar-Vell's son and then eventually Carol Danvers.
In the comics, she was known by a number of names: Lady of Light, Spectrum, Daystar, Photon, Pulsar. Pretty sure they mentioned at least two of those in the movie (Lady of Light and Pulsar).
@@christopherlh4379 Kamala, in a clip used in this very video, suggests Pulsar
I believe they did give her a hero name, it just got deleted from the final cut.
2:26 it’s like a mobile home in space why wouldn’t she
Also flerkens and flerkittens have interdimensional portals for stomachs! They can devour anything and will be safely stored in their pocket dimension tummys
So how do they actually eat?
@@Gerilyn2003 How? not sure, maybe a separate stomach for food storage they never mention it, but they do eat and prefer cat food!
I have to say that this some of my favorite commentary from you. That is saying something considering this might be my favorite channel on TH-cam. I get criticized at a steady rate for how critical I am towards movies and can't help calling things out 😅 as ironic as that may be. I know that deep down, my girlfriend actually hates watching movies with me. Surely on some level she just loathes it. Anyway, my initial point was that this commentary was exceptionally hilarious.
I enjoyed the movie but the drop off in villian quality from GOTG3 To The Marvels is insane. Also powerscaling is hilarious cuz like
Captain marvel was outdoing thanos but now she needs help
They literally showed that Dar Benn's bangle absorbed Captain Marvel's power. Raw power couldn't defeat her.
@@Stile4aly Sure, but Captain Marvel couldnt ohh i dont know blow up Dar's ships and stop her that way?
@@Stile4alyshhhh your making sense
What’s to enjoy? It looks total garbage and a complete waste of time.
@@mrburgess1698I enjoyed it too fight me
Exactly how is it that she’s able to take on Thanos and take his mothership out in one blow but some random like Dar-Benn is able to stalemate her
Sin missed: Someone thought it would be great to make the Villain have silver embedded in her teeth, made no sense. Also why are some Kree blue and some not?
Well some people black , white etc so I guess the kree have an extra race thats blue 🤷🏽♂️
Kree come in human colors, pink, and blue.
I thought she had on a grill or something. Was like wtf IS THAT?
@@to0muchtoan yea it was really strange and made no sense. Well her whole character made no sense tbh. Her weapon made no sense, nothing lol
@@luchamiomaridekakio6429 That's basically right. The Kree used to be all blue. The others evolved over time leaving the blue as a minority.
12:24 damn now I gotta get cable again😂
Now if the MCU had a character that could travel the multiverse…. Caugh… America Chavez… Caugh… 🤔
I know this is like- all jokes. but the "None of this makes sense" sin can literally be given to literally every movie that isn't 100% grounded EVER. That's such a nothing sin. Besides that though- The only thing that saves this movie for me is Kamala Khan. I can really tell her actor is loving every second of being in a Marvel movie
This movie was fun ✨ The villain was a melodramatic meh but I enjoyed the rest.
The actress that plays Kamala is such a delight 😍
Haven’t seen the movie, thank god you exist 😊
Oh right I forgot this movie exists
I saw it at the cinema and still forgot it existed.
Making me remember MiB International is enough for me to want to throw this movie into a septic tank.
MIB International was just Taika’s ‘Thor 5.’ 🙄
I have one question. Why do you do these videos as if you’ve never seen the movie before. It kinda negates most of the sins on this video
I didn’t even know;
1. This movie came out already
2. Out long enough for a sins vid
3. Beast was in it
I like the MCU but some recently just aren’t the same
Because Disney is ruining it along with other franchises!
Yea here's a question. Why are the jump points IN the atmosphere? The planet is revolving around a star, meaning if they had been any later, they would have jumped INSIDE the planet.
Because the villain created them there. That was why they were unstable. They weren't meant to be there, she forced them to be there.
I am STILL trying to figure out how a civil war on a planet extinguishes a SUN? That power to re-start a sun seems like it would have been handy at Nidavillir.
A Beast that looks noticeably different from how he did previously… did that ever happen in the comics?
Yes it did.
Bonus sin: The cat turning on this particular coffee maker makes no sense since it has a built in feature that makes coffee in the morning at the exact time you set it too, also the cat didn’t click the right button, the switch she flicked is there to control which mode the coffee maker is in not to start the coffee.
Is no one gonna talk about where the frick the giant hand at 15:20 came from? Kamala doesn't have the bangles, they're literally floating in space in the shot
Almost worse is that IF Kamala could do that all along, why have Monica go out there without space suit in the first place and undercut the previous tension of Monica sloooowly catching up with Carol, when Kamala's hard-light fist was faster?
It was explained that the bangle just activated her powers, she is wearing it for fashion reasons now.
She doesn't need the bangle. It just activated her powers.
Dar-Benn has zero gravitas. I had already forgotten about her. She should go hang out with Malekith
*edit* I think the box office reflects how good this film was. I like to compare it to Spiderman : No Way Home, to understand how hard they dropped the ball
"Why has Captain Marvel not visited Monica any time between the end of Endgame and now?" I don't know, she didn't want Monica to see her as the Annihilator that Dar-Benn and her people see her as or something, I don't know, it's not there's a scene where Captain Marvel literally said that or anything.
Also, 5:55 No one can hear her? So the Kree that asked Captain Marvel what she's done just asked if for no reason, totally not cause of what Dar-Benn was saying? Got ya.
12:51 It's Kamala Khan. No.
Skrull. The guy asking Carol what she's done is a Skrull. The Kree are the villains here
At like 5:17 the sin of Fury petting the cat I would like to say; my cat, Simon, is responsible for very nearly taking out my eye + scars on my temple and ankles. I still cuddle with him.
Everyone cheered when Kelsey Grammer Beast appeared. And if you say you didn’t you are a liar!
I don't think people have cheered in a mcu movie since endgame
I didn't cheer. It was more of a squeal of glee.
Marvel fans seriously get excited over meaningless cameos? They must have no life.
I didn’t.
Cant cheer when i didnt watch the movie
That US GOVERNMENT almsot killed me. Inwas eating and i almost choked lmao
I actually thought it was fun and was relieved that it didn't get any Razzie nominations (the Marvel nominations went to Quantumania instead, a movie I'd have a tougher time defending). Flawed for sure but fun.
I'll defend Quantumania on the sole basis that they cast Kathryn Newton. She's fire in basically everything she does. I didn't love some of what they did with her character in Quantumania, but her performance itself was fine.
Not taking one sin off for how likable Kamala was is insane