The scene where the husband was conflicted between the rapist that turned out to be a ill old man and the love for his wife is exactly why this film deserved an Oscar. Farhadi explores the morality of humans with such complex elegance.
I did. Argo was pretty much a propaganda piece. And now Salesman and Moonlight won against much better films just so The Oscars could show that they're Anti-Trump.
Completely deserved. A Great movie and such a humane story. You can feel the pain of the characters through masterful performances and masterful directing. It might have had some political reasons, but in the end, it was definitely the best movie in that category.
One of mine too, along with Spielberg (from US), Almodovar (Europe) and Miyazaki (Asia). For me, movies by any of these 4 guys is an event. Like, waiting all year to see their film type of thing. And Farhadi is probably my favorite of the 4.
@@diwanmal2335 i truly think if “The Salesman” came out, after “Parasite” it could actually win Best Picture. Since the Oscars has there eyes open for Films out of US.
South Korea chose a different movie for foreign film submission (something more patriotic) but yeah The Wailing is an awesome movie that could have gotten nominated.
Synopsis of the "hero" of Asghar Farhadi's new film: Rahim is a man who is in prison due to debt. Taking a two-day leave, he goes to the debtor to persuade him to drop his complaint and offers to pay part of his debt, but things do not go according to plan. Rahim finds some money and goes to the owner of the money to give him the money
as an iranain, i loved A Man Called Ove more, but more importantly, I'm sad that a government approved film & script represents us, films made about issues that can't show the reason of the issues (the government) and shows the people as the problem, Jafar Panahi is the director that deserves Farhadi's received attention.
80 different! Damn not fair this year 15 finalists were there, not sure if to feel proud (Mexico) or should we raise the category. This year a documentary took "La Llorona" and a Mexican movie to be part of it..not fair! We are a world
Here after the Academy apologized for the Indigenous people. They should apologize for this too. But ot was the law then that Farhadi could not come. I still think they should apologize
Where the heck is Elle? It was for me the winner. It won the Golden Globe, and I know it didnt win because of its moral ambiguity, but c'mon, they let Birdman won and it is a Hollywood critic...
When Marlon Brando refused the Best Actor award in 1973 for The Godfather to take a stand for Native Americans, the girl who gave the speech for him was booed. 44 years later, another awardee is absent to take a stand for his people and this time the woman who's giving his speech is being applauded. Either the society has changed a lot, or the Sound Technology has advanced enough to silence the boos 😄.
This is not a political film Of course, the Nader separation from Simin is not a political film, but a very social film.He lives in suffocation, that is, my society is Iran
I saw Ayla the daughter of war movie. for first time I saw a Turkish film. like Turkish serials it wasted my time. and another thing I like to say is, I think Ayla the daughter of war Insulting the Turkish nation because in this movie Turkish soldiers are in serving America, but all of us know the Turkey have a Great history(Othman Empire). love all Turkish people. its my opinion. Respect Turkey, from Iran.
jajceboy No. That's what happens when you want more publicity. If you noticed... the filmmaker decided to boycott the ceremony. He was able to attend but chose not to.
Have seen this movie on Amazon Prime, and still searching for at least one reason why it won an Oscar. Surely other movies in the same category might deserved the award.
![[Watch Party] RoV Pro League 2024 Winter | with Moowan ( Bacon Time Vs Talon )](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/CCEDhu6dPN8/mqdefault.jpg)
that woman who took farhadi's Oscar is a first middle eastern woman in space..and that guy with him is also a NASA scientist
She's actually Iran-born, she emigrated to the US on her teens along with her family
So what?
@@redroses6522 know this so u wont tell urself who the f are these guys
Wow! Fascinating.
The Salesman is a great movie. It deserves to win at any platform in the world. Case closed.
Abbas Kiarostami is smiling down at those 2 wins
Woah 😭man 😭😭😭
@Mahabub Zihad an iranian director;probably the best of all time;actually hes dead by now
@@a.m.naghdefarsi9129 He is definitely one of the best of all times in the world, I think even Scorsese praised him
Who the faaking that person?
One of his movies is considered to be by some, the best movie of the 90s@@redroses6522
Anyone who thinks this movie winning was a political move clearly haven't seen the movie. The Salesman is one of the best movies I have ever seen.
literally
As an iranian I didnt like it at all;A man called owe was much more deserving
Not good movie i watched it. It was sh*t
No, "A separation" from Iran won too...they are all amazing!
One of the***
The scene where the husband was conflicted between the rapist that turned out to be a ill old man and the love for his wife is exactly why this film deserved an Oscar. Farhadi explores the morality of humans with such complex elegance.
That is considerate
That is why it turned out to be an humane and genuine story
Intense scene.. intense climax
This guy is the best director going around now in my opinion and it started with 'A Separation.' He is just a brilliant story teller.
Watch ABout Elly, if you haven't yet. I believe that is where it started...
Have you seen "about elly... " ?
watch "the past 2013" it was directed by him, a masterpiece
lol. people claiming that this was a political move. but when Argo won best picture nobody Complained.
kasra khatir yep people have weird double standards
I did. Argo was pretty much a propaganda piece. And now Salesman and Moonlight won against much better films just so The Oscars could show that they're Anti-Trump.
But The Salesman had nothing to do with politics. Neither did Moonlight.
So was that garbage.
@@mateil2277 Moonlight didn't win against much better films
I'm so proud both my countries (Sweden, Iran) were nominated, with one winning 💕
@aboobacker siddique
She could have roots in Iran, or one of her parents might've been of Iran. You have brain, use it.
Same
Completely deserved. A Great movie and such a humane story. You can feel the pain of the characters through masterful performances and masterful directing. It might have had some political reasons, but in the end, it was definitely the best movie in that category.
Jasmim Bettencourt nah
A near perfect movie, I was absolutely floored when it ended.
Toni Erdmann was the deserving winner - and critics over the globe agreed.
Only one person to thank for The Salesman oscar - Donald Trump.
100%
Asghar Farhadi is one my favorite directors along with Ingmar Bergman, Wong Kar Wai, Edward Yand, Jean Luc Godard, and David Lean
One of mine too, along with Spielberg (from US), Almodovar (Europe) and Miyazaki (Asia). For me, movies by any of these 4 guys is an event. Like, waiting all year to see their film type of thing. And Farhadi is probably my favorite of the 4.
asgar farhadi is beast the god film making
Americans clapping when she read "I am absent in respect of the refugees who were banned bh America" Tells how progressive these people are.
Yesss Iran!!!
hahahha really sweden is an iranian country ? just kidding i m in sweden i watched both too EN man som heter ove and the sepration
Noooooo iran
For anyone who liked this movie watch "About Elie" it's the director's first big film
OMG! Her and his speech...wonderful!
The Salesman is a masterpiece!
Congratulations Iran
I became a fan of Asghar Farhadi's films. I will try to watch all his films
The salesman is a fabulous movie. There's something about the movie that can only be realised if you watched it.
Yes again him
We proud of you man
Too bad he didn't show up
The first big hint that a surprise was coming in the Best Picture category that night.
So this is his 2nd oscar
OMG!!!!
Charlize Theron and Shirley MacLaine!!!!
Kinda wish Train to Busan was nominated.
So proud of Iran...viva Iran!
The fact the handmaiden wasn’t nominated is a joke
I agree
For me, The Salesman is better than Moonlight
Yass moonlight was good shocking silent but salesman is something else
@@diwanmal2335 i truly think if “The Salesman” came out, after “Parasite” it could actually win Best Picture. Since the Oscars has there eyes open for Films out of US.
There are some haters in the comments. Haters gonna hate :/ but people with taste are always going to win in the end!
Why does Tanna say Australia instead of Vanuatu?
Gosh! Calm down!!! People are misunderstanding politics and the act of art here!
And please stop talking about Iran’s government by saying Iranians...
We proud of you Mr Farhadi jooooooon بوس بوس
Would anyone believe me if I said that the woman who accepted this award is my mom's friend.
And the 1st actress of movie is my cousin too. Taraneh Alidousti
Mia Khalifa is my ex girlfriend
@@ashkan318 😂😂😂😂
@@ashkan318 bade 1 sal hanooz daram be cmentet mikhandam :DDDD
Kudos to the Man🔥👏
How did the Wailing not get nominated ?
Its seriously one of the best horror films of the 21st century.
South Korea chose a different movie for foreign film submission (something more patriotic) but yeah The Wailing is an awesome movie that could have gotten nominated.
I didn't know they chose a different film for submission, I suppose that one's on Korea.Thanks for the info man.
Horror films don't get nominated
Synopsis of the "hero" of Asghar Farhadi's new film: Rahim is a man who is in prison due to debt. Taking a two-day leave, he goes to the debtor to persuade him to drop his complaint and offers to pay part of his debt, but things do not go according to plan. Rahim finds some money and goes to the owner of the money to give him the money
Where did you find this?
@@101theminecraft From art channels inside Iran
@@101theminecraft Memento Film Company, producer and distributor
Movie Synopsis
Printed the hero
Do you have any links to this?
@@101theminecraft No..sorry
1:50
It was difficult for me to breathe after the movie ended .
waiting for history to repeat with “a hero”
Yes indeed!
Here after Taraneh Alidoosti arrested
Handmaiden not even nominated 😒
As an Iranian I tell you Toni Erdmann was better
as an iranain, i loved A Man Called Ove more, but more importantly, I'm sad that a government approved film & script represents us, films made about issues that can't show the reason of the issues (the government) and shows the people as the problem, Jafar Panahi is the director that deserves Farhadi's received attention.
Where are Indian film directors and screen play writers lol 😂😂😂😂 they are busy in Dishoom Dishoom
if you gonna send movie like gully boy in place of tumbaad..ghanta oscar milega lol
İ wanna see "ayla" actually👋🏻😩
Under sandet should have won
🇮🇷❤️congratulations
80 different! Damn not fair this year 15 finalists were there, not sure if to feel proud (Mexico) or should we raise the category. This year a documentary took "La Llorona" and a Mexican movie to be part of it..not fair! We are a world
Here after the Academy apologized for the Indigenous people. They should apologize for this too. But ot was the law then that Farhadi could not come. I still think they should apologize
Where the heck is Elle? It was for me the winner. It won the Golden Globe, and I know it didnt win because of its moral ambiguity, but c'mon, they let Birdman won and it is a Hollywood critic...
Where is Tuntematon sotilas?
Congratulations 🇮🇷🇮🇷
IRIAN FILM❤️❤️❤️ 👌👌 🇮🇳
Land of mines was a masterpiece
When Marlon Brando refused the Best Actor award in 1973 for The Godfather to take a stand for Native Americans, the girl who gave the speech for him was booed. 44 years later, another awardee is absent to take a stand for his people and this time the woman who's giving his speech is being applauded. Either the society has changed a lot, or the Sound Technology has advanced enough to silence the boos 😄.
For me the best movie of this year is aquarius of the director Kléber Mendonça filho. Temer out!!!!
Land of mine desserve the Oscar !
Land of mine desserve to win an oscar ! It’s a masterpiece ! This is not acceptable !
Recount!
German movies are garbage, sorry, you should stop trying making movies.
NICE
Asghar Farhadi oscarına leke sürdü, çok üzücü...
🤩🤩🤩
This is not a political film Of course, the Nader separation from Simin is not a political film, but a very social film.He lives in suffocation, that is, my society is Iran
Ayla should have been here,it was a spectacular Real story come to life
I saw Ayla the daughter of war movie.
for first time I saw a Turkish film. like Turkish serials it wasted my time. and another thing I like to say is, I think Ayla the daughter of war Insulting the Turkish nation because in this movie Turkish soldiers are in serving America, but all of us know the Turkey have a Great history(Othman Empire). love all Turkish people. its my opinion. Respect Turkey, from Iran.
The Swedish film was by far the best.
I don’t get why the other one won.
Greets from Germany.
Linda Jürgensen can’t agree with u there ash hat farhadi has the best films love from ireland
Swedish film? Of course you think that, as a German you’re used to dry, stupid movies.
Because it's an amazing movie, duh
WHERE'S ELLE? that would have won if nominated
Sweden or Denmark should’ve won.
You’re diligence on repeating yourself is laudable. If it didn’t go to The Salesman, it should have gone to Germany’s Toni Erdmann.
asgard
either this or toni erdmann
🙂🇮🇷♥️
Toni Erdmann should've won
Matei L Pretty much better film, but they have to go on the politics way, you know.
lobiapolo2012 What are you on about, you lunatic SJW troll?
nah
put cold water on burned area
The boring, dry german movie? Why? Bc it was german?
I think Sweden or Denmark should’ve won.
Tonni erdman💔
Tired of political speeches at artistic events.
Deal with it, that's what happen when you ban countries.
lobiapolo2012 What an eloquent way to present your really important point...
jajceboy No. That's what happens when you want more publicity. If you noticed... the filmmaker decided to boycott the ceremony. He was able to attend but chose not to.
No, it's called solidarity. Don't think you know what it means. He chose not to go since citizens of his country were banned to enter US.
Sure... keep believing that. :)
Toni Erdmann lost to THIS? lol
THIS is a great movie lolll
What do u mean "THIS"?
Land of Mine deserved to win. This is BS!
Tanna should have won hands down
Who even saw it tho?
Boo!!!
Toni Erdman was the better film.
That typical boring, dry german movie? Not even Germans would watch that and they are used to that kind of sleep pills.
@@mosu2973 lmaoo
Allahu Akbar Toni Erdman. Ok no
Cynderella man Iran is not Muslim only the presidents and... are muslims
Idiot
Have seen this movie on Amazon Prime, and still searching for at least one reason why it won an Oscar.
Surely other movies in the same category might deserved the award.
Rohit Jadhav I can think of few reasons.
I would recommend that you watch the movie several times to understand it and then you may realize why it deserved to win Oscar.
Maybe you’re blind, no won can fix that my friend, not even a director.
Land of mine and A man called Ove are better