Grandpa Jack is absolutely vital to Heartland. Now that Ty is gone, (and his and Amy‘s relationship went with him), Jack is the glue holding the show together. He is the central anchor point around which the family and satellite characters revolve. Jack’s wisdom has comforted me at times when I really needed it. Both my parents are now gone and of course, my grandparents. Jack’s wisdom and presence anchor the show. He is foundational.
Remember Jack’s words to Amy as months after his death she was still struggling to cope with his loss? Jack said, “What I can tell ya is, pretty soon those memories and dreams of Ty won’t haunt you anymore, be keeping you up at night. They’ll bring you comfort.” I reflect back on that scene and let those words wash over me…. a soothing reassurance that though we lose a loved one, if we lean upon God and seek His comfort, He will never leave us or forsake us. (Hebrews 4:5) Jack is an irreplaceable presence.
I agree he is the grandfather I never had the wisdom and everything that he shares on the show it may be a show but the wisdom he shows and shares is very helpful I never had a grandfather or a dad growing up so the show I'm really is inspirational I don't know about anybody else but I really enjoy the show if I'm upset I watch the show it cost me now if I have something going on in my life like for instance I just lost a sister October 6th this year she hung herself😢😢😢 and I first thing I did was turn on heartland to remind me of family and how important they are and how much we need to spend time with them now because it doesn't matter what age you are how good of health you're in what any of that doesn't matter what matters is time love and family and spending as much as you can before they leave us and I've learn that really quick over this last year over all the losses I've had and my sister passing away my youngest of the four of us so I really really do need the show I need the support the positives and the focus and how Amy comes back after a loss from ty and how the other losses that the family has had over the years of like Jack's friend will and his other friends passed away from the band😢 how they have their family supporting them and helping all the time everybody pitches in to make sure everybody can get everything done for the day I like how that works with this it's the way real family should ❤ each other. I just really enjoy the show the positivity of it how it shows and shares ,guides you through a loss and the different stages of the grief process and so ON. Amy is strong for Lindy after the loss of ty. Around the time that happened my youngest son's dad had passed away from cancer and I had to explain to my 14-year-old that his father was gone so the show really did help me on how to explain how to deal and I mean yes I have counselors and therapists etc but this show is a very positive affirmational and wonderful visions of what life could be like if we choose to have it❤❤❤
Jake needs to stay he has a lot of living left to do , a lot of things to teach the family. Tim’s grown and needs to stay with and learn from Jack Amy needs to move forward , Kaleb needs to move on … if they are shutting down the show she will pick Kaleb and move away which is really not acceptable - adding new blood to the family will bring a lot of happy, drama, and life . Kaleb needs to fall in love with someone that’s been part of but not blood related !!!
Thanks. I thought I was going crazy when they said "Lily." :). Hey, speaking of names, what was the blonde's name again? The one who was married to Kaleb? I actually thought THEY were a great match, at least in Kaleb's youth.
I hope we DON'T LOOSE JACK HE IS THE SHOW MAKES THE SENSE OF IT ALL❤❤❤❤❤!! I LOVE HIM HE THE GRANDPA I NEVER HAD WITH WISDOM KINDNESS HONESTY AND SO MUCH MORE, I HOPE PRAY JACK DON'T LEAVE US❤❤❤ ALSO I THINK CALEB AND ANY SHOULD BE TOGETHER THEY HAVE BEEN THRU THICK AND THIN TOGETHER THROUGHOUT THE WHOLE SHOW AS WELL AS THEY I THINK CAN HELP REACH OTHER THROUGH THEIR LOSSES,HURTING, AND PASSION FOR LIFE LOVE AND HORSES ❤❤❤
Jack is a necessary character on Heartland. The show wouldn't be the same without him. I'm hoping that Amy and Nate get together. there is lots of chemistry there.
I love Caleb. He is such a kind thoughtful man. His two past wives were so selfish and they didn’t desire Caleb. I think Caleb would fit so well into the storyline. And what happened to the Veterinarian? He was a great assist to the story.
I agree Jack is Heartland,please don’t leave. No to Caleb and Amy. Lou needs to get her act together on her love life, where is Peter? Like Jack, Amy is Heartland, so whom ever her love interest is in Season 18 I hope he is awesome, she deserves that….
Lily is Ty's mom you're right and Lindy was Jack's wife and Amy and ty named Lindy after their her grandmother and that had passed that was with Jack prior to Lisa and her name is Lindy she was a famous singer in the show and is that toured with Jack and THEM when younger etc. As well as Jack married Lindy and Lindy passed away they show him remembering her buying him that truck from her first royalty check that she gets from her band thing or something like that he does a flash they do a flashback of that and so on but yes Lily is Ty's mother and Lindy is Amy's grandmother which they named their baby Lindy ,Ty and Amy's child🎉❤❤❤ I sometimes mix them up to😅
I really liked Malory (and Georgie when she got older, when she was young she was self centered, the character change didn't really make much sense I thought)
Have watched every Season 1-17 and every episode multiple times. I adore the roles of Jack, Amy, Ty & Caleb. The loss of Ty was so tragic & painful, so when it's decided that Jack's journey on earth will end, so too the show could as well. Amy & Caleb should find their destiny's joined together for so many reasons. Heartland is a remarkable, outstanding & spectacular show. My admiration & appreciation is always & forever ❤
@craftGal1568 I see 👀 Amy and Caleb as husband and wife. Remember Ty and Caleb were best friends. U may not agree because Amy was married to Ty, and they have a daughter, Lyndy Marion Borden, where Caleb is the God Father
@@napoleonvance1462 .yes. understand he is God father . But he can without being married. Caleb has marriage issues from his last one. Amy does not need that kind of drama in her life.
I love Caleb, but I can’t see them together other than really good friends, almost like brother and sister. I am excited to see what happens. I am not sure if Nathan and Amy will work well together, but I do like him. No, I don’t want to lose Jack. He is great!
I agree but as you said he was tired of best friend Amy's protector and confidence always has been always was always has and still is in the show I feel like in my opinion if it were real I feel that if I were to die and my best friend was able to take care of my husband and my child and I knew they would be cared for I would want them to be together if I had passed cuz I would know that she was safe as well as my daughter I don't know maybe that's just me that's just my opinion I also haven't got to watch the next season just yet either so I don't know quite too much about it yet so but I do feel like Caleb and Amy should be together they have been searching for a lifetime for a long-term relationship especially Caleb the poor guy😢 they had their baby and then he passed and got shot and murdered and then Amy has been on this journey trying to find someone else that she can connect with like she did with ty but she will never find that and I think the closest that she would if it was real as I said I honestly feel it should ,could, would be Caleb❤❤❤❤#TEAMCALEB❤❤❤❤ BUT AS I SAID HAVEN'T WATCHED THIS NEXT SEASON JUST YET THANK YOU FOR POSTING UPDATES IDK WHAT WAS GOING ON YET THIS HELPS🙏🙏🙏✨✨
Caleb is more like Amy’s brother than a love interest. Linking them romantically would be as appealing as having Amy fall for her own brother (if she had one). That’s a “no.”
@@DanaDysart They are so great together. They understand each other, they appreciate each other---grown up love versus the teen years. They warm my heart every time they are in scenes together.
Jack must stay he is a big part of the show we love him. And Amy definitely does not need to be with Caleb they are just friends they are definitely not couple material. I really like Nathan with her he needs to open up and be honest with her. She has been through way too much pain and hurt she deserves someone to be good to her.
I'm definitely not team Nathan. I would like Amy to be happy, but I hope the writers don't go down that path with Nathan. It needs to be an individual that is pro Heartland and not a friendly competitor. The thought of the patriarch of the family leaving only makes us believe this will be last season. Jack is the rock that keeps this family balanced.
@@trishbasler1805 it was the actor who played Finn, not Sam. I believe they were planning on pursuing the Amy/Finn romance before he sadly passed away.
I DO NOT want Caleb and Amy together!!! He’s just too immature and just a friend. I just don’t see it. No great passion. And if there is no Jack? Then end the show.
I personally wanted Amy to date Sam. Nathan is a downer.... As for Lou, well I've never liked her character from the very beginning.....way too controlling and unhinged 🙄🙄 Jack is HEARTLAND. He's my favorite one on the show ❤❤❤❤
I don’t wanna see her with dies best friend. It’s hard to see Amy with anybody except tie so it’s really hard for me to choose. I wish he was coming back from the dead.
Why can’t the producers find a really handsome cowboy who has some of Ty’s personality. Bring him back as a new rancher who puts spark back in the show as well as Amy’s heart. I wish the Vet hadn’t disappeared so ling ago. He loved Lou so throughly and she opted for the two really boring husbands!
Secretly bring Ty in please 🙏 i beg you it would bring more signs of hope and love like how heartland used to be idk how you can bring Ty back but just turn him into a different man and make Amy fall in love with him or just bring him back and pretend in season 14 that never happened please bring Ty back we all want him back
Amy and Caleb is a big no!! It is sad that they never could find a way to bring Ty back into the series even if there are many ways to do that. I stoped whatching en season 13.
I don't know that Amy and Caleb really belong together. Not because he was Ty's best friend. I just don't think he fits in the family that way. But, he's one of my favorite characters, so glad he's back! I was hoping they'd bring Ty back from the dead. I"m not crazy about seeing Amy move on with whoever that other guy is; but, she deserves happiness, so if they aren't reviving Ty...Also, Tim is one of my favorites. He gets too much flack. Lastly, I can understand if Shaun Johnson might be tired of playing Jack. But, he's such a great character. That would be heartbreaking. Now, when can I see the next season on Netflix? I've been waiting all this time! Oh, one last thing. I really like the development in the character of Katie. She's a lot more interesting than I thought she'd be. Love her!
We all love Caleb, just not for Amy!!!! But I’m not at all sure about Nate either… Amy needs someone like Jack!! True to the bone!! And don’t take Jack away from us!!! He is Heartland!!!!!!!!!
Amy should never get married her mother did not so let her daughter grow up with just the two and the memory of ty will remain just between her daughter and Amy. Neither of the two boys are still not good enough for Amy (Stephen).😊
Caleb is Just as great in person. Need to see more of Caleb on the show. Got his autograph for my son's girlfriend. He brought a good character to the show. They need to give him another buddy. One that keeps him grounded at times and gets into trouble with him as well. He should be Amy's best man if she gets remarried.
Amy has not riden Sparten for ages - Spartan is a black horse - this is a brown horse - probably Shadow. Lou does not drop a box on the floor - she is dropping a salt block in a pasture.
First it's not lily it's Lindy! 2nd I don't want to lose Jack he's the man of the show! And I want them to please bring Ty back some how I DON'T want Amy with Nathan or Caleb she deserves her happy ever after with ty and Lindy with their beautiful home! I do like Caleb better than Nathan but as her friend and Ty's best friend! I saw a rumor that ty was coming back but I guess it was a rumor and I am so so disappointed! There's a reason I only watch until season 13 and then start over because I love their love story so much! I really miss Ty!!
I stop watching heartland at season 14 I was in love with ty and amy love story was beautiful they love feel real I can see amy with other man and Caleb was his best friend feel like he betrayed him
There was a podcast about Ty coming back, but I understand it if he doesn’t want too. There was a podcast saying he came back and told Amy he was on a special mission. Crazy I know! 😊
When Amy rides in the video above and the words say she’s riding Spartan. No she’s not she’s probably on Harley or Shadow. Caleb respects Amy too much to be a jerk and cross the line again. Tom was a big pain in the early days and fortunately we only see glimpses of the painful ness and Lou is an ageing teenager as she has a very self centred view of life. And hopefully they don’t kill Jack off as he has earned the right to be in that show for as long as he wants.
Definitely rooting for Nate! I agree that Caleb and Amy should be just friends. Tim has definitely grown on me over the years. He is happily married and a good father. Jack is the cornerstone of Heartland. Losing him would be detrimental and very sad, and I’m not sure the show would survive without him. I do hope that what I heard about bringing Ty back was incorrect as that would be too unbelievable. We all saw him die and saying he was put into a witness protection program is too far out to believe. Just hope it isn’t true! Looking forward to season 18! ❤
This would be the good thing that Ty would return to the series and it would be something exciting for everyone who sees the series, it will be something great.
I love Caleb he not the right man for Amy. Hope Ty come back that's all I hear on Ytube. If he not coming back stop getting all fans hope. I don't look at season 14Th and 17Th because of Ty doesn't seem right to me. I understand he left the show and I'm very happy for him 💯 I love heartland so much 🐎🐂🦬🏍️
10/29/24 time 5:20 PST I am subscribed to UP Faith & Family. I see the episodes of season 18 on my screen, but there’s a lock on it so will we be able to see it here in the United States?
Grandpa Jack is absolutely vital to Heartland. Now that Ty is gone, (and his and Amy‘s relationship went with him), Jack is the glue holding the show together. He is the central anchor point around which the family and satellite characters revolve. Jack’s wisdom has comforted me at times when I really needed it. Both my parents are now gone and of course, my grandparents. Jack’s wisdom and presence anchor the show. He is foundational.
Remember Jack’s words to Amy as months after his death she was still struggling to cope with his loss? Jack said,
“What I can tell ya is, pretty soon those memories and dreams of Ty won’t haunt you anymore, be keeping you up at night. They’ll bring you comfort.”
I reflect back on that scene and let those words wash over me…. a soothing reassurance that though we lose a loved one, if we lean upon God and seek His comfort, He will never leave us or forsake us. (Hebrews 4:5) Jack is an irreplaceable presence.
@@carolanneposey5211 and word is Jack is going to die also !
Nate.
Jack needs to stay! He IS Heartland so do whatever it takes to keep him on the show🙏
I agree he is the grandfather I never had the wisdom and everything that he shares on the show it may be a show but the wisdom he shows and shares is very helpful I never had a grandfather or a dad growing up so the show I'm really is inspirational I don't know about anybody else but I really enjoy the show if I'm upset I watch the show it cost me now if I have something going on in my life like for instance I just lost a sister October 6th this year she hung herself😢😢😢 and I first thing I did was turn on heartland to remind me of family and how important they are and how much we need to spend time with them now because it doesn't matter what age you are how good of health you're in what any of that doesn't matter what matters is time love and family and spending as much as you can before they leave us and I've learn that really quick over this last year over all the losses I've had and my sister passing away my youngest of the four of us so I really really do need the show I need the support the positives and the focus and how Amy comes back after a loss from ty and how the other losses that the family has had over the years of like Jack's friend will and his other friends passed away from the band😢 how they have their family supporting them and helping all the time everybody pitches in to make sure everybody can get everything done for the day I like how that works with this it's the way real family should ❤ each other. I just really enjoy the show the positivity of it how it shows and shares ,guides you through a loss and the different stages of the grief process and so ON. Amy is strong for Lindy after the loss of ty. Around the time that happened my youngest son's dad had passed away from cancer and I had to explain to my 14-year-old that his father was gone so the show really did help me on how to explain how to deal and I mean yes I have counselors and therapists etc but this show is a very positive affirmational and wonderful visions of what life could be like if we choose to have it❤❤❤
Jack on we need him
Jake needs to stay he has a lot of living left to do , a lot of things to teach the family.
Tim’s grown and needs to stay with and learn from Jack
Amy needs to move forward , Kaleb needs to move on … if they are shutting down the show she will pick Kaleb and move away which is really not acceptable - adding new blood to the family will bring a lot of happy, drama, and life . Kaleb needs to fall in love with someone that’s been part of but not blood related !!!
I agree, Jack is heartland, without Jack there is no show!!!!
ABOVE ALL, KEEP JACK. HE IS THE HEART AND SOUL.
I don't know if I can watch a Heartland without Jack!
Lily? Ty and Amy's daughter's name, is Lindy Marion Borden, after her Great-grandmother (GG's first wife). Lily is the name of Ty's mother.
ooopsie...my bad
@emerald637-- exactly what I was thinking !
Yea and she's not riding Spartan she's riding Shadow 😂
She also said Amy riding Spartan, that horse she is riding is brown, spartan is black!
Thanks. I thought I was going crazy when they said "Lily." :). Hey, speaking of names, what was the blonde's name again? The one who was married to Kaleb? I actually thought THEY were a great match, at least in Kaleb's youth.
I hope we DON'T LOOSE JACK HE IS THE SHOW MAKES THE SENSE OF IT ALL❤❤❤❤❤!! I LOVE HIM HE THE GRANDPA I NEVER HAD WITH WISDOM KINDNESS HONESTY AND SO MUCH MORE, I HOPE PRAY JACK DON'T LEAVE US❤❤❤ ALSO I THINK CALEB AND ANY SHOULD BE TOGETHER THEY HAVE BEEN THRU THICK AND THIN TOGETHER THROUGHOUT THE WHOLE SHOW AS WELL AS THEY I THINK CAN HELP REACH OTHER THROUGH THEIR LOSSES,HURTING, AND PASSION FOR LIFE LOVE AND HORSES ❤❤❤
No to Amy and Caleb. Caleb has always been wishy-washy but a good friend to Ty and Amy. Keep it that way.
Thank you, I have someone that sees it my way. Like keep it a friendship. I prefer her and Nathan.
Team Nat!!! Not Kaleb it's to close to home!! He's Tys friend, Amy's as well.... They need to remain friends not life partners!!!
Tim is a really good actor. He can emotionalize his characters. Chris Potter is really cool to watch!
No leave jack on heartland he is the heart n soul of heartland
Please dont leave Heartlands Jack. Caleb has a good heart too.
Caleb needs to remain as friend.
Jack is a necessary character on Heartland. The show wouldn't be the same without him. I'm hoping that Amy and Nate get together. there is lots of chemistry there.
Team Nate! Caleb and Amy are just good friends and leave it that way. Jack IS Heartland without Jack in the show there is no show.
@@bonniegower6928 No Nathan Pryce, Jr., he's a crook
@bonniegower6928 Nathan Pryce, Jr. is trying to steal Heartland Beef from under Jack and Tim. So, therefore, no Nathan Pryce, Jr., for Amy
I agree😊
I 💯 agree. I would rather see Kaleb and Amy get together
I love Caleb. He is such a kind thoughtful man. His two past wives were so selfish and they didn’t desire Caleb. I think Caleb would fit so well into the storyline. And what happened to the Veterinarian? He was a great assist to the story.
I agree Jack is Heartland,please don’t leave. No to Caleb and Amy. Lou needs to get her act together on her love life, where is Peter? Like Jack, Amy is Heartland, so whom ever her love interest is in Season 18 I hope he is awesome, she deserves that….
It`s NOT Lilly....... It`s LINDY!!!
I got a bit too excited by the trailer
Lily is Ty's mom you're right and Lindy was Jack's wife and Amy and ty named Lindy after their her grandmother and that had passed that was with Jack prior to Lisa and her name is Lindy she was a famous singer in the show and is that toured with Jack and THEM when younger etc. As well as Jack married Lindy and Lindy passed away they show him remembering her buying him that truck from her first royalty check that she gets from her band thing or something like that he does a flash they do a flashback of that and so on but yes Lily is Ty's mother and Lindy is Amy's grandmother which they named their baby Lindy ,Ty and Amy's child🎉❤❤❤ I sometimes mix them up to😅
@thenextfilm and that also wasn't Spartan
Without jack I don't think anyone will watch the show and bring Georgie back!!!!
I really liked Malory (and Georgie when she got older, when she was young she was self centered, the character change didn't really make much sense I thought)
Have watched every Season 1-17 and every episode multiple times. I adore the roles of Jack, Amy, Ty & Caleb. The loss of Ty was so tragic & painful, so when it's decided that Jack's journey on earth will end, so too the show could as well. Amy & Caleb should find their destiny's joined together for so many reasons. Heartland is a remarkable, outstanding & spectacular show. My admiration & appreciation is always & forever ❤
Impatiently waiting for Season 18 to air in the US! It's killin' me....😢❤😂
Caleb and I can’t see Heartland without Jack !
NO! Way! Not Caleb! 😭
@craftGal1568 I see 👀 Amy and Caleb as husband and wife. Remember Ty and Caleb were best friends. U may not agree because Amy was married to Ty, and they have a daughter, Lyndy Marion Borden, where Caleb is the God Father
@@napoleonvance1462 .yes. understand he is God father . But he can without being married. Caleb has marriage issues from his last one. Amy does not need that kind of drama in her life.
Two major errors (Lindy not Lily, and the chestnut Amys riding is not Spartan) left me wondering what else did the video get wrong.
When is all seasons going to be available on Netflix I love this show!
I love Caleb, but I can’t see them together other than really good friends, almost like brother and sister. I am excited to see what happens. I am not sure if Nathan and Amy will work well together, but I do like him. No, I don’t want to lose Jack. He is great!
100 % agree
Amy is not riding Spartan, Spartan is blsck. She is riding Shafow.
No No No not Caleb, he is and always will be Ty's best friend. Amy's protector and best friend also.
I agree but as you said he was tired of best friend Amy's protector and confidence always has been always was always has and still is in the show I feel like in my opinion if it were real I feel that if I were to die and my best friend was able to take care of my husband and my child and I knew they would be cared for I would want them to be together if I had passed cuz I would know that she was safe as well as my daughter I don't know maybe that's just me that's just my opinion I also haven't got to watch the next season just yet either so I don't know quite too much about it yet so but I do feel like Caleb and Amy should be together they have been searching for a lifetime for a long-term relationship especially Caleb the poor guy😢 they had their baby and then he passed and got shot and murdered and then Amy has been on this journey trying to find someone else that she can connect with like she did with ty but she will never find that and I think the closest that she would if it was real as I said I honestly feel it should ,could, would be Caleb❤❤❤❤#TEAMCALEB❤❤❤❤ BUT AS I SAID HAVEN'T WATCHED THIS NEXT SEASON JUST YET THANK YOU FOR POSTING UPDATES IDK WHAT WAS GOING ON YET THIS HELPS🙏🙏🙏✨✨
Caleb is more like Amy’s brother than a love interest. Linking them romantically would be as appealing as having Amy fall for her own brother (if she had one). That’s a “no.”
That's the only way to KEEP TY ALIVE, i.e. Amy and Kaleb sharing the memory of him together.
I want her with Caleb
@@DanaDysart They are so great together. They understand each other, they appreciate each other---grown up love versus the teen years. They warm my heart every time they are in scenes together.
Such a great show
That you can watch with anyone In your family
Acting is superb 😎
Can't see Amy and Caleb together. They don't mesh! Hope Jack can stay!!! ❤
Amy was not riding Spartin. She was riding Shadow. Her daughter is Lindy not Lilly.
Team Nate so many directions this could go in. A merge or uniting a family, unless Caleb has a trick up his sleeve😊
Jack must stay he is a big part of the show we love him. And Amy definitely does not need to be with Caleb they are just friends they are definitely not couple material. I really like Nathan with her he needs to open up and be honest with her. She has been through way too much pain and hurt she deserves someone to be good to her.
No to Kaleb and Amy,already been said.Lindy is the daughter's name not Lilley.
Caleb & Amy 'seem' more like brother and sister. I hope it stays that way. They can both use such strong support of each other.
We need Jack !!! And I'm on team Nathannnnnnnnnnnnnnn !!!!
Whoever wrote this really needs to learn the names of characters and be more up to date as she's talking!!
I'm definitely not team Nathan. I would like Amy to be happy, but I hope the writers don't go down that path with Nathan. It needs to be an individual that is pro Heartland and not a friendly competitor. The thought of the patriarch of the family leaving only makes us believe this will be last season. Jack is the rock that keeps this family balanced.
perhaps Nathan and Heartland would join forces thanks to his love for Amy
Miss ty he shouldn't have left not the same
Wish they could bring Georgie back.
I think they could combine Heartland and Pryce together.
I think Nathan is sexy. Love him. Good for Amy!😊
Caleb is a much better fit into Heartland. Please keep Jack. He is Heartland.
I was hoping Amy and Sam would get together.
Pretty sure the guy who played Sam died in real life.
@@trishbasler1805 it was the actor who played Finn, not Sam. I believe they were planning on pursuing the Amy/Finn romance before he sadly passed away.
Please let Amy marry Nathan and they have a baby girl and they are very happy
Lou is no business person. Just a control freak.
I DO NOT want Caleb and Amy together!!! He’s just too immature and just a friend. I just don’t see it. No great passion. And if there is no Jack? Then end the show.
There is Jack and I want them together cause he was there when Ty was there
How will Ty and Amy handle Amy marrying Caleb?
@@willieriley7054 ty ain’t coming back
O@@willieriley7054
Yes, Nathan and Amy belong together...meaning I am team Nathan
I personally wanted Amy to date Sam. Nathan is a downer....
As for Lou, well I've never liked her character from the very beginning.....way too controlling and unhinged 🙄🙄
Jack is HEARTLAND. He's my favorite one on the show ❤❤❤❤
I think Sam would have been a good fit for her
I must agree, both about Lou and the importance of Jack. He’s essential.
Agree with this all. Sam❤️🔥
Sam would be a good fit for Amy. I don't care for Lou's character.
I think Jack is the most important character in the show. Lou is a great actress and director but not my most likeable person she is to bossy.
Nathan and Amy are an excellent match.
I believe Amy needs someone not linked to her past and Amy and Caleb tried early on and there was clearly no spark!
Jack needs to be on the show unless he has to quit he is a older gentle man😢
I don’t wanna see her with dies best friend. It’s hard to see Amy with anybody except tie so it’s really hard for me to choose. I wish he was coming back from the dead.
Why can’t the producers find a really handsome cowboy who has some of Ty’s personality. Bring him back as a new rancher who puts spark back in the show as well as Amy’s heart.
I wish the Vet hadn’t disappeared so ling ago. He loved Lou so throughly and she opted for the two really boring husbands!
Secretly bring Ty in please 🙏 i beg you it would bring more signs of hope and love like how heartland used to be idk how you can bring Ty back but just turn him into a different man and make Amy fall in love with him or just bring him back and pretend in season 14 that never happened please bring Ty back we all want him back
Bring in a dead guy as a new guy in disguise ? Yeah that makes sense 😂😂😂😂😂
Graham Wardel wanted to leave that's why they killed him off.
Team Caleb all the way. Honestly it is more common the people think for spouce to end up in a relationship with the deceased spouses best friend.
It's don't look right for her to get with caleb that was ty friend,and i don't want her with someone else, please bring ty back
it feels weird to see her with caleb
They can’t bring Ty back as he passed away on the show.
Ty has left Amy so many times and been accepted back with open arms. That’s enough! Too much of a roller coaster ride. Amy needs some stability!
Team nate but Caleb is nice to so I'd like him to get back up with Cass they were a perfect couple!! ❤❤
Amy and Caleb is a big no!! It is sad that they never could find a way to bring Ty back into the series even if there are many ways to do that. I stoped whatching en season 13.
He’s dead lol. Sure they could resurrect him like he’s Jesus Christ because that makes sense 🤣🤣.
Did anyone else see caleb go off with ashley at the end? Flashback or new?? 😮
I think ty would be ok with Caleb but he is done married with a son and I think Amy needs someone new and fresh
I feel like Caleb isn’t the one for Amy. We need a match more like Ty
Don't let cable leave
I hope Amy ends up with Sam.
Me too.
Neither for Amy, I like Ty, I thought Ty was coming back in Season 18.
He can't come back , he's dead
I don't know that Amy and Caleb really belong together. Not because he was Ty's best friend. I just don't think he fits in the family that way. But, he's one of my favorite characters, so glad he's back! I was hoping they'd bring Ty back from the dead. I"m not crazy about seeing Amy move on with whoever that other guy is; but, she deserves happiness, so if they aren't reviving Ty...Also, Tim is one of my favorites. He gets too much flack. Lastly, I can understand if Shaun Johnson might be tired of playing Jack. But, he's such a great character. That would be heartbreaking. Now, when can I see the next season on Netflix? I've been waiting all this time! Oh, one last thing. I really like the development in the character of Katie. She's a lot more interesting than I thought she'd be. Love her!
Please bring Georgie back!
She need to be with ty ❤🎉
I see 👀 it as an opportunity for Amy to decide. But I see 👀 Amy with Celab as a husband, more so than Nathan Pryce, Jr
We all love Caleb, just not for Amy!!!!
But I’m not at all sure about Nate either… Amy needs someone like Jack!! True to the bone!!
And don’t take Jack away from us!!! He is Heartland!!!!!!!!!
Amy and Sam, He is gorgeous!
Not Caleb please that just feels wrong, against Ty
Jack needs to stay!!!
Amy is a star that shows she knows what she's doing❤❤❤❤😊
Team Caleb. Jack needs to stay
Amy should never get married her mother did not so let her daughter grow up with just the two and the memory of ty will remain just between her daughter and Amy. Neither of the two boys are still not good enough for Amy (Stephen).😊
Keep Shaun Jonhston. Heartland is a program that needs all the main characters. Love Heartland!!
Lindy!!! Not Lilly. Apparently, it's not a true Heartland ...
Caleb is Just as great in person. Need to see more of Caleb on the show. Got his autograph for my son's girlfriend. He brought a good character to the show. They need to give him another buddy. One that keeps him grounded at times and gets into trouble with him as well. He should be Amy's best man if she gets remarried.
Amy has not riden Sparten for ages - Spartan is a black horse - this is a brown horse - probably Shadow. Lou does not drop a box on the floor - she is dropping a salt block in a pasture.
Looking forward to the new season and all of the new changes, it mirrors life ♥️
Amy's girl is Lindy!
I will prefer to please bring Ty back him and Amy. Where may for each other
Yeah let’s just resurrect the dead guy like he’s Jesus Christ and stick him back on the show 🤣🤣
First it's not lily it's Lindy! 2nd I don't want to lose Jack he's the man of the show! And I want them to please bring Ty back some how I DON'T want Amy with Nathan or Caleb she deserves her happy ever after with ty and Lindy with their beautiful home! I do like Caleb better than Nathan but as her friend and Ty's best friend! I saw a rumor that ty was coming back but I guess it was a rumor and I am so so disappointed! There's a reason I only watch until season 13 and then start over because I love their love story so much! I really miss Ty!!
the only way Ty will return is what they have done already...as a ghostly memory.
I stop watching heartland at season 14 I was in love with ty and amy love story was beautiful they love feel real I can see amy with other man and Caleb was his best friend feel like he betrayed him
I don’t believe that Caleb should be with Amy she needs to find somebody else Caleb was Ty’s best friend
If Jack goes Heartland is finish
There was a podcast about Ty coming back, but I understand it if he doesn’t want too. There was a podcast saying he came back and told Amy he was on a special mission. Crazy I know! 😊
I like Caleb with Amy! He is perfect. He was isn’t Ty but he knows. Amy and understands her!
When Amy rides in the video above and the words say she’s riding Spartan. No she’s not she’s probably on Harley or Shadow.
Caleb respects Amy too much to be a jerk and cross the line again.
Tom was a big pain in the early days and fortunately we only see glimpses of the painful ness and Lou is an ageing teenager as she has a very self centred view of life. And hopefully they don’t kill Jack off as he has earned the right to be in that show for as long as he wants.
Please keep Jack!!!
Like wisdom of Peter. He is crazy to put up with Lou!
Jack needs to hang on because he is the voice of love and reason for his family.
The Flemmings can't carry the show. If Jack goes now its over for sure.They have been struggling since Graham left.
She needs to be with ty. That'd make us happy second Kaleb he's sweet just nit ty n please jack is main curator we all love. Kaleb b4 nate
I.dont think Amy and Caleb should get together. Caleb was Tysbest friend and Amy was his wife. I think it would be VERY Disrestful to Tys memory.
Definitely rooting for Nate! I agree that Caleb and Amy should be just friends. Tim has definitely grown on me over the years. He is happily married and a good father. Jack is the cornerstone of Heartland. Losing him would be detrimental and very sad, and I’m not sure the show would survive without him. I do hope that what I heard about bringing Ty back was incorrect as that would be too unbelievable. We all saw him die and saying he was put into a witness protection program is too far out to believe. Just hope it isn’t true! Looking forward to season 18! ❤
This would be the good thing that Ty would return to the series and it would be something exciting for everyone who sees the series, it will be something great.
I thought ty was coming back so what's up with that..... We know she would desire him over all
I love Caleb he not the right man for Amy. Hope Ty come back that's all I hear on Ytube. If he not coming back stop getting all fans hope. I don't look at season 14Th and 17Th because of Ty doesn't seem right to me. I understand he left the show and I'm very happy for him 💯 I love heartland so much 🐎🐂🦬🏍️
Amy marry Nathan and has a baby girl and they love each other and they are happy to be delivered to Amy.
Amy's daughter's name is LINDY, not Lily. Geeze! 🤦♀️
Team Caleb
10/29/24 time 5:20 PST I am subscribed to UP Faith & Family. I see the episodes of season 18 on my screen, but there’s a lock on it so will we be able to see it here in the United States?
I LIKE MOST BELIEVE IT'S PAST TIME FOR TY TO COME BACK HOME TO AMY & LINDY
Return from the dead? That would totally .ess with what's so great about Heartland, it's reality. Besides Graham Wardle WANTED to leave.
I love Caleb but Nathan has more he brings to the table and I am hoping he breaks his own walls and his character completely changes for Amy's love.