5 Boots to AVOID in 2024 (and what to buy instead)
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 4 มิ.ย. 2024
- I've reviewed dozens of boots, and there are some which I'd never recommend to anyone. In this video I list the five boots to avoid in 2024, and what to buy instead.
Brunt Marin: bit.ly/3EVyXzP
Siete Leguas: bit.ly/3vDUzPS
Dr. Martens: bit.ly/2McU1Hb
Solovair: us.nps-solovair.com/
Portland Leather: bit.ly/3HlSPND
Thursday Boots: thursdayboots.com/
Brahma: bit.ly/3SoaECk
Rock Rooster: rockroosterfootwear.com/
Jim Green: bit.ly/3pJrAHc
Read the article: carlmurawski.com/5-boots-to-a...
- Patreon: bit.ly/3CgauCW
- Merch: exlsv.com/collections/carl-mu...
-Website: www.carlmurawski.com
-Instagram: bit.ly/2qIHzaB
-Discord: / discord
-Stridewise article on Portland Leather: stridewise.com/portland-leath...
#Carlmurawski #boots
BEST OF THE BEST (affiliate links):
1. Beard care: bit.ly/3MXMkB4
2. Work boots: bit.ly/3T2FA8f
3. Sunglasses: bit.ly/2IykfS4
4. Casual boots: bit.ly/3LHIRWT
5. Work jacket: carhartt.pxf.io/QOr5Ez
6. Flannel shirt: bit.ly/3PDtBxj
7. Made in USA Tee Shirt: bit.ly/3yAma1p
8. Casual jacket: bit.ly/3RlNOJv
9. Leather jacket: bit.ly/3LAKOUZ
10. Wool Socks: bit.ly/3WyzQpW
11. Outdoor Hat:
12. Flashlight: bit.ly/473dNvq
13. Hoodie: bit.ly/3qXvhV1
14. Leather Briefcase: bit.ly/3dpPkHt
15. Duffle Bag: shrsl.com/4cdjk
16. EDC Pen: bigidesign.com/carlmurawski
17. Work shirt: bit.ly/48deO4P
18. Work Pants: bit.ly/3JEn834
19. Wool Coat: bit.ly/3N2W9Qg
20. EDC Knife: bit.ly/3RBGM4R
Timestamps:
0:00 Worst Boots of 2024
0:41 Brunt Marin
2:47 Dr. Martens
4:01 Portland Leather Boots
4:58 Brahma
6:42 Rock Rooster
Reviews of high quality workwear, boots, and clothing for men to help you own better and own less. I've been working with my hands for my entire life as a mechanic, tow truck driver, and eventually a licensed electrician. Being a blue collar guy, I look for certain elements in a product: is it durable? Is it high-quality? Will it perform well over its service life? Whether boots, pants, jackets, or tools I believe it's best to buy once and cry once by getting the best you can afford. With so many options these days, choosing the best product can become a difficult decision, but that's where I come in. Helping you stay stylish, rugged, and handsome.
I don't care where it's made as long as it's made well and allows you to own less and own better. - แนวปฏิบัติและการใช้ชีวิต
Boots in this video:
Brunt Marin: bit.ly/3EVyXzP
Siete Leguas: bit.ly/3vDUzPS
Dr. Martens: bit.ly/2McU1Hb
Solovair: us.nps-solovair.com/
Portland Leather: bit.ly/3HlSPND
Thursday Boots: thursdayboots.com/
Brahma: bit.ly/3SoaECk
Rock Rooster: rockroosterfootwear.com/
Jim Green: bit.ly/3pJrAHc
Legend of the game.
Bought a pair of Dr. Martens
“ crazy horse” leather. Worn about 3 months. Leather is starting to crack open…
Could you review QLTY out of Denver? They’re under 200 and made in US of imported parts. I wanted to pull the trigger but only saw one review on TH-cam.
I bought the Jim Green razorback steel toe after seeing Rose anvils tear down and haven't looked back. I take them everywhere from work, hiking, or casually walking around. They have by far been the best price to peformamce boots i've had.
I find them way too hard and heavy for hiking. It just feels like it doesn't over any stability. On concrete once again the outsole is very rigid.
That being said, what kind of trails do you hike? In my case it's a mix of plenty rocks, some dirt and plenty tree roots.
i bought their buffalo leather rangers and i absolutely love them for hiking, walking, and casual wear.
@@ano1680 I have a pair as well, they’re in the nubuck Houston leather though. Damn comfortable boot for literally anything.
I've got the steel toe razorbacks for my work where they meet sharp metal, metal dust & shavings, plus lots of oil and sludge. I've had them since November and they're holding up way better than any other boot around the $200 range. Definitely going to keep buying Jim Green.
Thursdays might be "boring" because they're a very popular choice, but as a newbie to the boot scene they are awesome! Very happy with the quality, fitment, feel, and price. Great all around package.
Thursday are amazing for the price , yes I have better/more expensiveboots but for the price I love my multiple pairs of Thursday boots
Yeah Thursdays were kind of my first foray into "real" boots after multiple cheap pairs over the years. They were kind of my gateway boot to the better boot world, before you know it, you're asking the wife for your own boot rack for the Grant Stones, Chisos, Tecovas, Thursdays and Nicks you're adding to your collection.
Hi man, I buy captain, hero and more...never have complain. Very good shoes
Jim Greens rock. I have 11 pairs. Zero complaints.
Being a Minnesotan, I always wanted Red Wing boots. The pair I bought were pretty comfortable, but the soles turned into hockey pucks when it got cold, making them very slippery. Upgraded to a pair of Whites, then got a pair of Nicks... I wear the nicks almost daily, swap in the Whites occasionally. Not sure I'll ever buy a boot at a store again. I have very narrow feet and store boots are too wide. Having these custom measured and built was a life changing experience. Yes... They are expensive. But not when you consider how long they last, they can be rebuilt many times... I think in the long run, they're actually less expensive than buying many pairs of cheap boots that aren't comfortable and don't last very long. I encourage everyone to save up and try a pair of custom sized high quality boots. Especially if you need them every day.
Too bad Some Red Wing boots are made in China with really bad reviews. It's sad that some many companies put profit ahead of quality.
Great advice! It’s better to put some money into something’s from the get go. Like ceiling fans etc.
canada west
I just hit three years on my Jim Green Razorbacks. The soles are worn slick, but the uppers fit like slippers. At their price point nothing else comes close.
Resole?
How do the razorbacks fit, are they true to size? I have 2 pairs of African rangers and they’re so comfortable but I want something a little more durable for work.
@@AG-rk5hj Yes true to size. I wear a 12 in athletic shoes like Nike or Saucony, and the 12 in the Razorbacks is just fine.
You can make them last longer by applying shoe goo on wear spots before they get bad.
i got a pair of Jim Green Razorbacks, (Amazon Black Friday for $89) and could not agree more, very comfortable and tough, frign luv these boots
gotta hop on that sale train
Awesome video Carl, love videos like this, wish more of these brands were readily available in the UK
spaghetti scammetti boots 2024? Made of premuim recycled pleather!
fancy seeing you here
Top 5 loafers vid when?!? 🍞😂
NEVER!!!
When pigs fly over a frozen Hell.
#1 loaf - Pumpernickel. #2 loafer - the latest apprentice....
@@CarlMurawski 1st of April and make it 100% serious
It would be a funny opportunity to do a collaborative video. Could weigh into the conversation with your critiques, not abandon your rugged brand image, but still end up with a good loafer video. Maybe a pros and cons of them where each takes opposing sides
Hello Carl, just found your channel a bit ago and its been quite helpful in the search for my first boot, i think i've settled for the Thursday Explorers as i quite like that military-esque aesthetic and have an outfit in mind for them, do you have any experience using those or know people who have?
As an electrician I can say I have bought wolverines redwing and Georgia boots with EH as a must. But last pair of boots I bought was a Arita boot and I think I have found my new go to boot! For only $180 it’s been awesome and lasted very well the last 14 months! I appreciate your advice and feedback on this Chanel so keep up the good work!
Got my first pair of Thursday Captains in 2019. Worn everyday for 3 years. After that I bought 7 pairs of various boots and they went into rotation. I'm still wearing them today. They could definitely use a resole, but they're in great shape and still look good.
Such a gresd vid with some great input from people. Thanks for saving me from future mistakes.
I have three pair of Jim Greens. I doubt I'll ever buy a different brand.
Thanks a lot Carl. Now I’m going to have the old Stop’n’Shop jingle stuck in my head.
Also, any thoughts on Golden Fox boots? I keep seeing them on Amazon and they look pretty nice, but I’m pretty skeptical about them.
I wore the same pair of Docs from about 1994-2000, loved those boots. Recently I was looking at a pair and yeah, sadly not the same pair I had in the 90s.
Mine did great In the recent icestorm week
I spent 20+ years in wolverine, ariat, Redwing, and others. Never had a pair last over 1 year, I would wear the toes off in 4 months. Eventually I got plantar fascaitse and the pain was unreal. I had to wear sneakers for months to get over that. Then I found Carl's channel and he told me about Nick's boots. I bought a pair of builder pros and they have changed my life! The solid foot bed and arch support are incredible. I've had them 6 months now and they are barely broken in and show almost no wear at all. The way they support my ankle and foot has made my back pain stop as well. You think you need soft soles but they are killing your back. I feel like my feet aren't trying to balance me on every step now they just land correctly and solid. The quality of materials and build is just unbelievable. I can see these lasting many years and I love to put them on every day. Guys listen to Carl he speaks the truth, your body is worth every penny you can spend on it. Boots is not the place to save money, wich you won't anyways when they last months. It's one of those things that takes while to catch you and sink in. Be smart and look out for your money maker you only get one. CARL THANK YOU!!! We love ya man keep em coming!
I thought RedWing was decent??
@decade10hl
They are better not great in my experience.
I’m thinking about a pair of builder pros. Did you get the 55 last?
@shermanclark9757
I got the HNW last. I like the short heel for what I do. Everyone says the 55 has the best arch support and that may well be, but the last I have has more than anything I had before. I don't think you can go wrong in any.
I would consider adding Frye to the list. My first pair of "nice" boots were Fryes from 15 years ago. They were outstanding, I still love them. I have purchased and returned three other pairs in an attempt to buy another of my old favorites. Its way more expensive but it is better to save up for Wesco, Nicks, or Red Wing.
Looking for a pull on wedge sole boot but options seem limited to very little. Suggestions?
Love the Lahouts shirt! I bought a pair of Fabiano Ria hiking boots there in the early 80’s that I had until just a couple of years ago.
Lahouts is a very special place!
Can you tell me your day in the life and would you recommend going into electrician or another trade like welding hvac plumbing or instrumentation tech or p tech?
Carl, your passion is infectious. I admire your attention to detail and craftsmanship. Honestly, I don’t know why I’m drawn to your channel. I think it’s probably your honesty that you convey. By the way this video really rules, I like the personal storytelling that you weave into the boots. You’ve got something here, I think most of us would appreciate it if you added your personal narrative stitched into the fabric.
I have worn all from ariat Justin twisted x and the such... I last month bought a pair of R Watson steel toe boots... they have been comfortable for the most part and wear better than any 200+ dollar boot I have owned... I work in the tire industry and work on mine and commercial equipment so I am on payment and rock and dirt and so fourth... love these last pair and would definitely buy another
So interesting that you mention Siete Leguas. I live in Mexico and have been getting into better boots over the last couple of years. Siete Leguas makes great boots for normal people that don't want to spend $500+ on their boots😉. They started as a western boot company so their chelsea boots and zipper boots kind of reflect that, which is interesting. I have a cool pair of their zipper boots. I also have a pair of their hiker/chukkas, which are WONDERFUL. Most of their "Haiker" line has synthetic liners but their chukkas have traditional pig skin liners. I grabbed a pair of wheat nubuck ones on sale for about 40 bucks!!!
Last year I bought a pair of boots from Academy, I believe it was the house brand, Tactical Performance. They're okay for a budget, haven't worn boots since the late 2000's when I had a pair of Red Wings my brother gave me.
I got them for a metal festival in November and I wore them a while to break them in. So I was not used to them but I managed to withstand the weekend, but they're not waterproof, but you can resole them, which I should do soon.
Any good soles to switch for?
Hey I’m thinking about getting Birkenstock Bryson boots, your opinion on them please?
I bought some Doc Martins about 5 years ago because they were on sale. I was aware that they had a bad name for quality so I wasn't expecting much. After years of daily wear they are still going strong. I even had a car roll over my foot at traffic lights (I ride a motorcycle). No broken toes.
Very interesting to read the comments, not neing a boot guy myself. A couple of years ago, I finally decided that in Illinois I need boots for the wet seasons. I purchased Sperry ankle boots. They are orange and look like a brushed suade. Rubber bottoms. Also, L.L. Bean navy ankle boots. They also look like brushed suade. They have a rubber bottom. Both are perfect to wear outdoors in nasty weather. Both work very well for what I do,being that I am retired. Thank you for your video and thanks to all of the commentators.
Carl, thanks for the music recommendation for Hum the other day. Listened to them while working last night. Bought “Electra2000” & “You’d prefer an Astronaut”. I somehow lived through the 90s and 2000s and had never heard them.
I also recently got a pair of Thorogood Steel toed mocs on discount in Wisconsin. I’m usually a Red Wing guy, but these just might convert me. Great for hours on a salesfloor & stockroom.
Nice!! Yeah man, HUM is fantastic. That new album is just amazing.
@@CarlMurawskiHad no idea you were a fan CM. Most people who were around in the mid 90s know "Stars," but Hum was so much more than that song. I went to college in Nashville back then, and the "6 labels" were the gatekeepers to what got pressed and not, so we had literally every aspiring band through the local clubs at some point. Almost 30 years later, their show at Exit/In that I went to on a whim remains burned into my brain. So many great tracks from that 1st record. "Old man," "Robins," "Pod" and the haunting chords of "I Hate it Too." Their sound was just a little off the mainstream for them to hit it big. I think that's why there's still pockets of mad love out there for them.
Did not so they were back making music, off to check it out. Thanks! And cheers to you and your channel, even if the Doc derbys (Wasn't a boot guy until recent years) I bought in London around that same time are crying in a pint after 25 years of faithful service... 🤣
I wore Keens for years but after several pairs fell apart in months I tried Jim Greens. I will never own another pair of keens again. Jim Greens are my new go-to boots.
I'm in England, on the Northamptonshire borders, got all the classic England shoes and boot makers, Crockett and Jones and Trickers, Cheaney, within 30 miles away, buy at the factory shops, at great prices and unbelievable quality. Another great boot is Australian brand Ian Harold, personally i prefer mine to the RM Williams i had before, and a third cheaper
I bought a pair of Origins fall 2022 and wore them all winter. Started off happy but the tongue is gussetted with the eyelet instead of a stitch. It pulled out and began cutting my socks and feet.
This fall I switched to Jim Green Razorbacks and I am so so happy. Very wide for my ugly feet and love the construction. Only change I'd like to make is an ice grip sole
🤣 Joe Rogans favorite?That Origin?
@@BlueSpirit. Who?
I've had the best Rock Rooster boots, the AP611/VAP611, for about 4 years now, I think. Need to replace the insole and there are holes opening up in the counter cover, but the boot has otherwise held up quite nicely. I also bought some of their Chelsea boots. The chelseas aren't sized at all the same to their lace-ups and I had to return them under warranty after wearing them to work twice when the entire counter cover tore out on one side. My wool socks shouldn't be rough enough to eat through something after walking 6 or 7 miles.
I have the rock rooster pair you mentioned in the video. The insole is so thick that I have to either wear them without it or use a thinner insert from other companies, otherwise I cannot put my feet in. I only wear it for the workwear look while commuting. The only issue I have are the laces. They get loosen really easily.
I have been using Brunt's since September. I changed the insole to a custom insole and they are quite comfortable and have held up well. I'm a commercial electrician, so they don't take a huge beating, but I put a moderate amount of use into them. I'm not a Brunt fanboy, just sharing my experience.
Came here looking for a comment like yours. I have been wearing black lined Marins since around August, and do electric motor mechanic/service work. Also not super rough on them, but I feel like they have been holding up great. My only complaint is that they are lined, and end up being rather warm some days.
New to your channel, loving it so far!! Couldn't agree MORE about Dr Martens. Broke my heart when I notice the quality SUCKS. I used to wear, regularly, their work boot, NO MORE! But the most disappointing and worst have been Carhartt. I bought my 1st pair and within, no lie, the inside were the back of your heel would be, ripped, ON BOTH LEFT & RIGHT. (wish I knew how to put a picture in this text🤪) Keep up the great work
I’ve had a few pairs of boots over the years. I can usually tolerate some lousy designs, but for some reason cemented sole construction and my foot do not get along. I had a pair of “John Deere” boots made by Dan Post that fell apart in three months. A set of Keen steel toes made it 8 months before I literally walked the sole off of it and the outsole separated from the midsole a mile from the truck. Lacrosse boots used to be awesome, I owned a pair of LaGrange boots and they held up for 15 years in the toolbox of the pickup getting worn when needed. They eventually started to dry rot and developed cracks. I replaced them with a pair of LaCrosse Burly with the foam insulation. They lasted a whopping year before they cracked at the sole and started leaking.
I’ve learned my lessons you either spend a little extra or pay the price. I’ve got a set of Franks’s Patriots I absolutely love for in the woods. I wear a Wolverine 1000 mile or Red Wing Iron Ranger in the office. If I need a steel toe I have a pair of Thorogood’s that have held up great over the years, however, they are now so high priced I’m considering spending a little extra and going to a JK 300 next time, but that’s probably a year or two out since they don’t get everyday wear.
I had a Pair of JD and they blow out in less then 90 days too !!
Another option is the Wolverine Men's I-90 DuraShocks Moc Toe Work Boot. Tape up your heel first couple of wears the counter cover is like sandpaper at first. But these things have so much squish and bounce. Now its def not resoleable. But as a after work boot this thing is incredible. Ive done a whole summer in Europe walking miles a day in these things.... This is the one boot with Function, Style but no resoleability so theres that lol..
My most comfortable boots: White's Perry Boots. Comfortable from day one. I'm retired so I can't judge the "workboot" aspect. But for hiking and walking the border collies, everyday wear, these are great! Mine still look new EXCEPT for that junk Vibram Christy sole. Very comfortable sole but wears down like wet chalk. Most uncomfortable boots I have EVER owned: Jim Green Mens Stockman Slip On Boots. Soles have almost no flex. It's like strapping a 2 by 4 on your foot. The boots started out so tight they decreased the circulation in my feet. Now, they are so loose that my feet swim in them. Jim Green's answer was to buy different insoles. I now have 2 insoles in each boot (the original thin Jim Green insole and an expensive Spenco Polysorb Walker/Runner Athletic Insole. I spent over $100 on different insoles trying to get a good fit in these $150 boots! The toe box is really wide, but for my D width feet, they slide side to side when I walk. The exterior is great. They seem to be very water resistant. Now I only wear them to mow the lawn and to walk the dogs on really wet/messy days. An hour of wear is all my feet can stand. Jim Green builds them like tanks, but the comfort level sucks!!
The Whites Perrys are excellent. How have you been sir? Life treating you well?
@@CarlMurawski Freezing my a$$ off! Wind chills have been around -30F here the past week or so. Otherwise, the dogs and I are doing well. How about you? I've been watching your videos, but only commenting if it's about something that directly affects me. I'm too old and too fat for a lot of the things you review!🤣
Appreciate the feedback and support, as mentioned our boys are built like little tanks which fairs well here in South Africa. We are currently working on a softer compound rubber, while still keeping our durability for our lug sole boots.
I have a pair of rock rooster comp toe but they’re not the vibrum sole ones they’re mock toe with the foam sole with the rubber attached to it and while I did have some quality control issues (the boots weren’t the same the look to the moc toe was slightly off and what not like they hadn’t been lasted right maybe?) but the customer service sucked and I just kept them, i work in a warehouse building store front frames so I’m also not too hard on boots but I’ve had them 2 1/2 years, and they’re fine for me, and I really like the rubber on the sole because I hate the way vibrum wedge soles round off and wear away so quickly. That being said I got a new job that reimburses for boots so I think I’m going to get some red back Chelsea boots next
Jim Green Rangers are excellent. I've got the regular ones, & plan to try the barefoot &/or 8 inch versions this year. I've also had great Danner boots. My least comfortable boots ever were Cat's (Caterpillar brand steel toe).
My red wing 411s started out as the most comfortable boots i ever owned but quickly turned into the least comfortable. They gave me the most foot pain I’ve ever had after only a couple months of wear. I guess they use too many synthetic materials and they break down like sneakers instead of breaking IN like good boots. That’s what sucks so bad about synthetic materials. They’re deceivingly awesome in the beginning. I agree the Jim green razorbacks and also vellies are great but hard on the insoles so I needed leather insoles being a heavier guy. Opted for nicks veg tan insoles and once I got those in there they’re great. Also great point about footwear affecting your whole body. I’ve always loved the look of dr martens (obviously not for real work) but they always destroyed my back every single time I wore them. Same with cowboy boots.
Whats your current take on Origin Boots? Do you still think they hold up in the boot market?
I would add Twisted X to the list of not buy. I work on the road. I had a pair for 3 months and they had holes in the side of toe on one and in the front of the toe on the other. I bought some Timberland Pros from your other video based on your recommendation and I am happy with them.
My #1 "would avoid" boot is the Timberland premiums. I bought a pair on a steep discount through my old job, even after having seen Rose Anvil say they were pretty much not worth it. The main draw for me was price, but I definitely needed something fairly water-resistant with a lugged sole and preferably a gusseted tongue; that also wouldn't fall apart after a month or two. (Which to their credit, they're holding up pretty well). The main and really only issue I have is how uncomfortable they are at the end of a long day having walked 5+ miles during my shift. I've tried different insoles, cushioned wool socks, etc etc and they kill me after a long day. I really want a pair of Jim Greens even more after dealing with wearing these trash-ass Timbs all day every day. Oh and, Jim Greens tend to retail for the same or even less money than Timbs lol.
I was a Timberland Pro guy for years because I live in New England and appreciate the insulation. I still own a pair that is at least 15 years old that are still waterproof, but I use them to shovel snow these days! Modern ones are junk though! I'm now a Jim Green guy, picked up my first pair in 2021 after Carl's review. Now I own 6 pairs 😂. Great boots
I bought a pair of bramas also for similar reasons. Was going to a job and realized I forgot my boots at home. Found a Walmart and got the cheapest boots for the one day of use. I could only recommend them for that. Maybe worth keeping as an emergency pair in your truck for you or a buddy if you forget your boots. Also ok for at home concrete work so you can just throw them out when your project is done.
I remember buying a pair of Brahmas for the first week at my job and after my first check I tossed them and bought some timberland pros
Best swap ever!
I have Thursdays Captains. Black (not matte) and they are a bit cramped in the toes. I don’t typically have to buy wide style footwear, but probably should have in this case. The distressing in this particular style isn’t my favorite either. After a year I broke down and bought Redwing Blacksmiths. The perfect amount of movement as long as you aren’t wearing thick socks. Breaking period takes some time and patience. But I am a buy once cry once type of guy so the extra $$ is worth it to me. Also own Red Wing Iron Rangers and am very pleased.
Been wearing my Jim Green AR8s all winter and so far they are amazing. No foot pain, sturdy as heck, no snow getting inside with that fully gusseted tongue. 100% would recommend the AR8s to anyone looking for a solid af boot. Love my Thursdays too. I own 5 pairs from them and they are all awesome.
Did you get them with the wedge or the other sole? How are they in a wet climate?
@@tericottaclay9462 i just got the regular lug outsole (looks like a vibram). Been nice and sturdy in the snow. Ice is a different story. Any boot outsole is slippery on ice lol, unless you got spikes. But i have yet to slip and fall this winter.
I had a pair of Brahma boots. I was walking on concrete all day at my warehouse job at the time. It felt like pins and needles through my foot. I would drive home everyday in my socks just to get them off my feet
Solid picks. I’d add Keen to the don’t buy list, they’re comfortable but lately they fall to pieces far too quick for the price. Brunt, rock rooster and all the cheap Amazon crap is not worth the money. I did however get a pair of carhartt moc toe boots and they’re surprisingly solid and comfortable. I figured they’d blow out in a year or so but I got them in 2020 and they’re still comfortable and are handling heavy use well.
I've got 2 pair of 7-8 yr old keen shoes and they are still going strong. However these are older and American made models.
Carl, size 15 here. I work in commercial and industrial fire alarms, access control, etc. I own my business. I have been following you for 2 years or more now. I am limited on boots. Work boots are the King Toe by Redwing. I have a pair of Thursday Presidents. I try now to buy nice clothing that last. Any new recommendations?
Got your Kevlar vest handy? Or maybe you should go ceramic plates. I have those same Rock Roosters you showed and I've worn them a couple of times. I wasn't real impressed, but I'm gonna wear them again and really pay attention to how they feel. I do remember thinking the leather felt and looked pretty chintzy.
CW: I think your input is pretty good and useful, just keep in mind that every review out there isn't necessarily good. I swear, I have never seen more hopeless people than in recent years, especially when it comes to leather boots. Most of these younger folks today have NO CLUE how to care for leather, and what's worse is they often have ridiculous expectations. I think channels like yours helps to keep things on point for all the people out there who literally have no idea.
Thats absolutely true- good call!
I love Thursday boots. Have 3 pairs of captains from them.
Really want some Solovairs.
Red wing worx with external metatarsal guards. The met guards fell off. I had to warrenty them twice before getting some 4436 red wings. Luckily red wing had great customer service and put the value of the first pair towards these.
Enjoy your show, how about a review of top insulated coveralls? You’ve got a video on overalls but not coveralls. Thanks!
I've had Corcoran marauders, the black jump boots. Took a shine well but were super uncomfortable when you were on your feet all day.
Corcoran boots take a shine well but they are not great for everyday wear.
Some of the best boots I own have been Keen. I wore a pair of Keen Targa's for over 8 years before having to replace them. I have since add an 8" insulated hunting boot which is another winner. The last thing I love is that they are available in size 14 US.
weird every pair of Keen targee I have owned have had the soles delaminate in months. I wont buy junky keen boots anymore.
@@cantbuyrespect that’s really strange. I’m guessing that you are somehow abusing your shoes. I wear my Targa’s everyday and have a woodworking businesses.
@@realsharpknives7988 no I am definitely not "abusing" them. What would you even call abuse on a hiking shoe that is advertised as being durable for extreme use such as hiking? I owned keens for 15 years and these issues only arose in the past 4 or so years. The past 3 pairs of keen hikers I have owned the glue on the sole separates and the soles fall off well before the tread is worn through. Not only did I notice these issues in my targee boots but also the composite toe keen workboots I had as well. The materials they use to build them are not as good of quality as they used to be. I am very impressed with the material and build quality of my Jim Green razorbacks which are way more well built then any keen boot I have ever owned. The Jim Greens have a wide toebox like the keens so they are very comfortable for my foot shape. They use a stitch-down leather construction which is way better than keens cheap rubber glued to eva foam.
@@cantbuyrespect I literally burnt mine and enjoyed watching them go up in flame. They sucked so bad.
I have 3 pairs of quality boots by Viberg, Crocket and Jones and Alden. Pricy but they last a long time.
Fortunately I am one of those people that researches the hell outta everything. My first boot in the electrical trade were Thorogood Moc Toes with the wedge sole. Good boot but over time the weight of the steel toe was fatiguing my legs. I eventually replaced them with some Ariat Workhog XT with the carbon toe. Another good boot, but wish the shaft was narrower. No longer in the field nearly as much but when I am I still use those Ariats or a pair of Danner Tactical boots in tan suede with a comp toe. In the office I’ll wear one of 2 Thursday Western boots (Desperado in AZ Adobe & Maverick in Anejo), my Tecovas Roy (Taupe Suede), Thursday Presidents in Mocha Suede, Danner Skyridge (in Flat Dark Earth) or my Wolverine 1000 mile (these are actually my least comfortable boots).
Worst boots in recent memory are a pair of Golden Fox Boondocker in tan suede. Not they are terrible, but the weight ratios between the upper & sole are so lopsided & the soles feel so damn heavy compared to the upper.
The steel toe not a good idea for electricians.
Hey Carl I wonder if you can do a top winter work boot, or best way/boot to waterproof. I'd rather not ruin a nice pair of nicks or equivalent with mink wax, other waxes, or waterproofing spray. Any advice is appreciated.
Honestly Obenhoffs HDLP is the stuff you want. It conditions and also adds some waterproofing. It will darken the leather, but that is the stuff Nicks and Whites use and sell for their boots. If you have a tan roughout and don't want it to turn in to a brown waxed finish then stay away.
@@mrthesquid Appreciate the advise
Hey Carl how do you feel about the timberland pros? Once I replace the footbed on the inside with something more sturdy. They've been better than my red wings and other more pricey boots in terms of comfort
I had some and my only complaint is that the soles get really hard in the cold. I bit it a few times wearing those in the New England winter.
@CarlMurawski thanks! I work over in NY and I can agree with that! Once I added some super feet insoles they were like magic !
Superfeet are amazing, especially the heel cup!
@CarlMurawski they honestly transform a boot! I work in a shop on the rail road and they definitely extend the life of my boot. Often it's the inside that goes first !
Hey Carl, a great alternative to "Siete Leguas" is Bonanza boots. Also Made in México, but i do know that they sell too un USA. Great customer service btw. Kind regards from Mexico!
Thanks for sharing! See, this is why I love the comments.
@carlmurawski Also, I´m from Mexico and I have a brand called "JACA" that makes GYW boots and have also great quality. 7 Leguas are the king of "quality" boots in Mexico, they're really good and durable as hell, we make great footwear in León Guanajuato; the downside is that the "Haiker" model which I own, has a synthetic cloth lining which makes it super comfy but I would have prefered a leather lining.
My first pair of steel toes was brahmas…they didn’t fit right and were painful. Chucked those soon as I got a different pair of boots
Terrible boots man, you're much better off with whatever you got!
Asolo boots I’ve had 5 pairs the midsole disintegrates on all of them and they will not warranty them .
100.00 per boot to repair what should have been done right in first place.
if you catch a White's Boots sale you can get the Perry Select for just over 300, very comfortable and premium leather. They run a Father's Day and Black Friday sale, probably others too.
That's how I scored mine! I almost ruined them by using Leather Honey (got them darker than I liked) but will be using Bick4 going forward.
Correct me if I'm wrong but I am surprised I have not seen any videos from you on carhartt boots.
I own a pair of solovairs, GREAT! Just stiff and tough to break in about a month off wearing them at work(wearhouse type work) no pain, just good a decent pair of insoles
I feel like most content creators when they post a video like this really milk the time and just go on and on. You went right to the point and didn't beat around the bush. Here's what you liked, what you didn't, here's a better version. Thank you. I got a lot out of this video.
I appreciate that!
I'm an old guy and I'm also a boot guy, and have been for 40 plus years. I remember when Herman Survivors were a quality boot, maybe back in the early 80s. I still have several pairs of my old boots from the 80s and 90s, I rarely wear them but I can't get rid of them. I still have a pair of Chippewa minus 40s from the 80s, LL Beans from the early 90s, and a pair of early 90s moc toe Irish Setters. Today I wear Thorogood 8" 1957 flyways. I wear them year round, but wear them 6 - 7 days a week from October - April. I feel like they're going to last a long time but maybe not as comfortable as my old Irish Setters. They seem to be getting better with time and I really like the look of them. I wear them on construction sites, hunting, and out to dinner. My wife knows it's a waste of time to ask me to wear dress shoes, I'm a boot guy. Before the Thorogoods, I wore Justin lace-up work boots and I still break them out a few times each month. I actually like them, they're really broke in and I have nothing negative to say about them. I take really good care of my boots and I guess that's one reason I get many years of use out of them.
I have 7 pairs of Thursday Boots or sneakers, I cannot say enough good about them, glad they got a shout out.
Yesterday bought a pair of Ariat work boots rebar 6” waterproof. Very comfortable right out of the box. I live in Seattle so it is very wet most of the time. Let see how they hold up? $175.00 on sale for $150.00
Carl,
One thing I would love to dive into is the warranty/service of some of these companies. I have had a fair amount of experience with this, and it turns out that it really ranges from excellent to unacceptable. I’ve reached out to Rose Anvil to so something similar, but got no traction.
Hey man, that's a really interesting topic for sure. Its tough though because beyond the written policy is the human element. Is the person in customer service having a bad day? What is the followthrough? I think there's so much gray area it can be difficult to make an exhaustive video on that, though I think it would be dynamite.
Any Carhartt boot. I've tried several pairs and they might as well have been a Brahma for how uncomfortable and damaging they were to my feet but for Jim Green prices.
They suck! Outsourced Chinese crap. Living off of their clothing reputation!
Question. Are Boot Dryers good to use on a pair of Boots?
Yes, if you’re wearing them everyday. Just be careful with the heat option if it has one
Well dang… after seeing roseanvil’s videos on the rock roosters i was set to buy a pair- you may be the only guy on yt saying different and its giving me pause- what would you recommend for a better option as far as moc toe? Starting a warehouse type job here soon and tho i love my Thursdays i cant imagine standing in em all day
In my opinion its worth saving a little more for the Whites Perry honestly. They might be the best value moc toe going right now, especially their "select" series.
@@CarlMurawskiHow do you feel about the Perry Hybrid? And feedback about the sole?
@@CarlMurawski thanks! Appreciate and respect your opinion
I've owned the soft toe version with the leather welt for several years. They are solid and very comfortable with a Superfeet Green insert. I'm a big guy too, and they are still wearable after being worn several times a week for 3 years in a rotation.. I'd agree that if you can save a bit more ..... go with Jim Green. I have two pairs of Razorbacks, one of which is a wedge sole. Very comfortable, grippy outsole, and they are built like tanks.
Would love a video of mid grade boots: redwing, Danner, Chippewa, thorogoods, etc.
Your missing out on Thorogoods for some absolutely great work boots . I switch from those to either premium ariat or Tony llama TLX depending on the jobsite.
Please review the insulated Danner Rivet
Brunt is one of those brands that if they spent as much on product development as they do on advertising the product would actually be fine
I would add the entry / lower level Tim's to the list. My first pair I loved, maybe not the best boots but I got a number of year out of them. Second pair I got were terrible. Fit wasn't good, QC was bad and in all honesty I got more out of cheapo pair of Kmart workboots than I ever did out of them. I know they do make some quality footware but that's my experience.
It seems rare to find anyone talking good about the Brunts unless it is some sort of paid thing. That Siete Leguas looks like a Patron boot. Patron boots are also made in mexico and at the moment are only available on ebay as some one has to go to mexico and buy them and bring them to the USA and sell them. Although there is also silver bull that are made in mexico that look like those as well and again are also made in mexico and have a usa site. Silver bull has a lot of styles on there site and a lot of sub brands. Oh portland leather, ya I bought one of them because the ads made them sound great and there was a few videos making them sound good as well and this was before rose anvil made a video about them. I would not recommend them either. They feel cheap. they are my least warn boot. I also have a pair of thursday boots. I love them. Another brand that I like just as much that look like a thursday boot is Old mulla. I love Old mulla but I put them on par with thursday. I even made a video kind of comparing them. I have a few rockroosters as well. the first pair I bought caused major blisters on my feet but after rose anvil pushed them a bit more I tried them again and I still kind of have to push my self to wear them. However I love the insoles seems that is the best part of the boot. I even just went to rockrooster and bought several pairs of the insoles and put them in a few other shoes. Also what is strange about rockrooster is there are fakes of them. A brand called Handpoint ( found on amozon and ebay) make fakes of them. Although I almost think hand point boots are actually better than rockrooster but I hate the insoles that hand point has. The hand point insoles are junk. Speaking of jim green I love mine and my jim greens have rock rooster insoles in them. I didn't like the insoles that came with the jim green. My favorite pair of jim green are the barefoot version. As this is long and I was making it as I was watching I will make another comment with my list of boots I do not like that you have not mentioned in this video.
Thank u
Great series
What’s your take on Timberland boots?
I’ve gotten a few great pairs of boots second hand on offer up and ebay. Cause yeah spend $400 for work boots isn’t in my budget, $120 for used redwings that now I’ve had for a year and about it get them resoled
Solovair was the patent holder and original manufacturer (under license) for Dr Martens from 1960 thru the mid '90s. So to say they're simply "made in the old Doc Martens factory" is an understatement.
I fuckin love my Jim Greens they absolutely are the biggest bang for the buck boot in existence just preordered their numzaan and I cannot wait till they arrive
I hate to admit it, but I tried Rock Roosters and Brunt work boots. I truly did this because they were doing plenty of advertising on soical media. The brunt boots I had for a day and returned them. I will at least say the return & reimbursement was very hassle free. The Rock Roosters I still have at my office at work, but have only wore them for a little bit because they completely tore up my feet. I keep them in the office just incase someone forgets there boots. There is a reason why certain work boot brand have been around for a long time, even if there quality has changed over time. I feel like once you find a brand that fits your needs you tend to stick with them. Personally I am a big Carolina Birch Logger boot fan! Works great for me on the ever changing excavation sites in the Cleveland, Ohio area!
I was in a warehouse, and the rock roosters (non waterproof version) were the most comfortable boot I’ve tried by far, but I also stuffed like three insoles inside of them. I’ve tried redwing supersole 2.0s (with custom insoles put in, the redwing traction tread lite, and the Jim green African ranger. Most of the other boots would keep me comfortable to about the 10 hour mark at best, but the rock rooster only started feeling uncomfortable at the 14 hour mark (I’ve only hit that a few times). As for what my job entailed, according to fitness trackers I would walk 20+ miles in a standard 12 hour day (coworkers Apple Watches also agreed with that number) and that was usually while carrying 40-60lbs of stuff with 100+lbs also not being that rare.
Keens we’re great for a short while but wore out very fast, basically fell apart. Merrill Moab we’re great for a short while, breathed very well which was great while working in extreme power plant temperatures. I’ve been very happy with jk superdutys on the farm and thorogoods have been excellent at millstone primarily walking long distances on steel grating and concrete. I think thorogoods would be the only non hand crafted boot I would buy again aside from muck boots.
I wear cowboy boots and Belleville 500s for winter and hunting and the 590s for work
Lems is a great company that makes great boots for what they are. But, as much as it hurts to say it, I'd put them on this list now that their prices have gone up so much. A barefoot boot is essentially a protective sack. It's very difficult to justify paying close to the price of a pair of Thursdays for them, when you compare what you're getting. The product seems worth about half what they charge for it.
When are you going to give us your top five handmade work slides.
The best work boot I have is the JK 300 and a close 2nd Thorogood Mock Toe American Heritage. As far as work boots and being on my feet all day, you get what you pay for.
A top ten list of boots that are comfortable to stand in for 8-12 hours a day would be nice. Maybe you have something like that, and I missed it because there are a lot of videos to go through, lol. Leather footbed boots, to me, don't feel nice underfoot for long periods of time. I think half a dozen pairs of heritage boots in I have learned that I need something that has a soft squishy insert, lol.
Timberland Chelsea boot. It was pretty comfy but I would wear them on a few occasions and they tore apart faster than I expected. Paid $100 for them not knowing anything about boots
I really like your show continue creating great content, I also enjoy your collaboration with the gentleman with the gray hair I'm I don't remember his name.
I would avoid the Thursday boots and go with Grant Stone. Speaking of which, I started a subreddit for GS and we have just over 1300 members. We are almost 1 yr old and we have a lot of experienced users of GS boots/shoes. Should come take a look.
For me, the RedBacks are a no-go. The boots themselves are very comfy, but the customer service was atrocious. I bought 2 identical pairs in different colors, and one pair fit way too tight. When I reached out to RedBack directly, they told me that because I bought them on Amazon, they would not help, and even scolded me more or less. I returned both pairs and have been super happy with 2 pairs of Ariat Turbo Chelsea H20s I have been wearing for almost 3 years, though made in China. I have a pair of Nicks Chelseas on order for months now, looking forward to them (though not the break in).
Thats interesting because I know a lot of people who love their Ariat stuff. I had a pair of Ground Breakers (I think that was the name) and they delaminated from the sole after a cart rolled into my heel on the job.