I'm pushing 70 and remember and purchased the vinyl when it was released. It was understandable but less so without hearing Mark's explanation. When we returned from Vietnam, which was a real waste, including my cousin who drove his troop carrier over a tank mine. Thankfully I was able to attend his funeral. Mark is extremely talented. For us in the US, HF has made the subject matter very plain. Mark's guitar playing is extraordinary, however, to me the long solos somewhat mask the lyrics and their meaning. One reactor stated he would have preferred Tim sing it similar to "My Maria" he did with Austin. That would have ruined it, in my opinion. In the song, Tim is a dying soldier saying farewell to his comrades and questioning the logic of war. Maintaining a deep but airy low volume sound reminds me of death. I ran a government cemetery for 16yrs before I retired. This hit me HARD.
I forgot what I intended to say!? (I go into a room, can't remember why I'm there, walk out and realize it was the restroom.) If Mark Knopfler did a collaboration like Don McLean, Alabama, The Oak Ridge Boys, Lee Greenwood, and others, that would be surely something.
Thank you so much for sharing your story, intermenater. I haven't heard My Maria yet, so I'll have to wait to understand whether it would have ruined it or not. "Maintaining a deep but airy low volume sound reminds me of death." Well freakin said. WOW. I can't even imagine the emotional stories you have from running the cemetery. Thanks for being kind and hanging out!
"Haunting" is a word that a lot of people have used in regard to the harmonies in this, and it is so appropriate. I think Home Free has outdone themselves this time. But they do that quite often! Great reaction.
This, to me, is a hymn to the dying and deceased. All the boys lost on a field so far away from home. Scared, lonely and soon to be “home”. This is hauntingly beautiful, I cried through the whole thing. It is a stand alone. Totally different from the first one.
This is the Club For Five arrangement, sent to Home Free with their blessings. However, Home Free made it their own during the "echo" sequences. Tuukka the grand bass from Club For Five is one of Tim's inspirations.
Ethereal. Haunting. Gut wrenching. Soul stirring. Angelic. The only thing missing was the seraphic choir backing them up. Excuse me while I track down my soul and stuff it back into my body...
The wind noise, of course, is Adam Rupp's contribution to the song, as well as his beautiful tenor singing voice. No drums, no cymbals, just the haunting sound of the wind blowing. Once again his contribution to the percussion of a song is spot on, and enhances the feeling of the great harmonies of the group.
When I realized what the noise was at the end, it sent chills down my spine. I thought I was hearing stuff at first. Thanks for being kind and hanging out!
It's been said : In peacetime, sons bury their fathers, but in wartime, fathers bury their sons. War upsets the natural balance. Love Homefrees version of this song. Tim and Chances voice were outstandingly beautiful. Thanks for your thoughtful reaction.
Haunting..........and they're depicted as half ghosts, just as the words are coming from a mortally wounded soldier.th-cam.com/video/MPB3lt6vp4o/w-d-xo.html
To me their harmonies make up for the missing guitar..... This was so hauntingly beautiful. I have only been listening to Home Free over a year but I listen to then daily now. I remember the Dire Straights original. I think they paid homage to it very respectfully. They are quite patriotic without being overly preachy. They have done many songs about bringing everyone together.
This really showcase's how amazing Home Free truly are and how much they love our country and they always show such great respect to the original artist that's why they always get permission to cover people's songs and why so many artists collaborate with them
Yes, the bass with the harmonies does have a haunting effect. Tim has that gravely bass that makes me think of a church organ being played in an empty chapel, and it really hits you with emotion.
OOH that really hit me Belinda. "a church organ being played in an empty chapel." Much more precise reaction than what I said. Thanks for sharing, being kind, and hanging out!
This has to be my favorite vocal arrangement by them. No beat boxing - just pure amazing vocals. I am constantly amazed how five people can sound like a 20-strong choir.
The original Acapella version of this song was arranged by Finnish Acapella group Club For Five. They provided a copy of their work to Home Free for this performance. You can find their performance of this song on TH-cam from 12 years ago here th-cam.com/video/Gerr99h0nS8/w-d-xo.html&ab_channel=ClubForFive
Hauntingly beautiful, but you know it's going to be that bit special when Adam's not Beat Boxing, but lending his voice to the harmonies. Absolutely Awesome. 💓💓💓💓💓
My feeling is that with most Home Free videos they have to be reacted to twice: for visuals and for vocals. It is hard not to close your eyes and go with the music, but it can cause one to miss some of the special moments. Thanks for your reaction. Waiting for HF holiday music. "Snowglobe" can be at anytime.
@@carolinpettit7944 Absolutely correct, can not believe I forgot that one. Did you ever listen to Tim with the Hound and the Fox doing " We Three Kings"? It might be too religious for some but the visuals and vocals are terrific. Enjoy the day.
It's hard with words to say something is beautiful when it comes from something tragic, but sometimes it just is... Thanks for being kind and hanging out, Marielle!
thank you for your reaction. It's amazing how they translated that haunting guitar in the original to humming that end up sounding like an organ. Tim's vocals are perfect for this song. His breathy bass brings such gravitas to the whole song. Home Free is so good at picking the right member to sing lead in their songs. IMO
If Home Free does a cover of a song....chances are it becomes your favorite version. Lots of times I've never heard the original if its a country song as I don't listen to country music. I have gone back a few times and listened to the original and Home Free's version...to me....made it better.v
I wish I would've read their comments in the description before I watched it now. Thanks for letting me know. When I finally understood what the wind noise was it sent chills down my spine. Thank you for being so kind and hanging out!
Alriiight, now I've made it through all your Home Free reactions, and I love them all! A few ones that will show you some different sides of them, while keeping their high standards in mind would be "Helpless Hoping", "Winter Song", "Elvira", "End of the Road", "When a Man Loves a Woman", "Folsom Prison Blues".
In the original you said the guitar was singing and I feel like the background voices of Home Free are filling in the words the guitar was singing.🤯🔥🔥🔥🔥🙏 (oops, you just said that!)
Tim and Chance both showed how powerful a gentle, breathy tone can be. And the harmonies carrying such strength and added emotion have had me in tears and shivers the past few days! I'm obsessed with the overall sound and meaning behind this song. Home Free has once again paid homage to our soldiers and in doing this song, they've opened conversations across the globe! I like PTX and Voice Play, but Home Free has earned my respect in their unapologetic approach to social issues and patriotism. Great reaction!
Thanks so much for the background on this cover, It prompted me to check out the Dire Straights version. It strikes me that Home Free has turned into a choral requiem. Props to both versions, of course, but I do find Home Free's more emotionally powerful. The Dire Straights version is strikes me as more "I stand up to testify for my brothers." With Home Free I almost feel as though I died with someone. Tim seems to be talking from the grave.
"Tim seems to be talking from the grave". Dang wish I could take back everything I said and just say that. Thanks for being kind and hanging out, Jennifer!
Awesome reaction Mr. Incredible! Thank you! This one is Special! Hits hard in my gut ! Completely broke me down and cried like a baby! Took me a while to recover! It took my breath away and I'm still crying every time I see it. I lost my Daddy before I got to know him. He was a decorated WW2 veteran and your right war is hell on earth! A living nightmare that so many have never awakened from, past and present soldiers with PTSD ( in years past it was referred to as " shell shocked" ) It's horror! I appreciate Home Free for their stand unapologetically on uncomfortable issues and not shying away from their convictions! They don't make waves politically but by their choice of songs it seems they believe in unity, inclusion of all people no matter what our differences are and encouraging us to care for others and spread good will universally! I think you would enjoy " UNDIVIDED " Written by Tyler Hubbard of Florida Georgia Line and performed by Hubbard and Tim McGraw " EVERYBODY WALKING THIS LAND " " I STILL HAVEN'T FOUND WHAT I'M LOOKING FOR " Home Free and Peter Hollens Have a great week and God Bless You! From a Home Fry friend in South Georgia!❤️🍟
Thank you so much for sharing your story with me, Louise. It's horrifying what the ripples of war do. I've added the ones you've requested to my excel file. Thank you for being so kind, my South Georgia Home Fry friend! I'm now (don't tell anyone else in the comments😛 ) a new Home Fry friend in Northern Alabama!
@@MrIncrediible1 Ok! Good to know that you are a next door neighbor and my lips are sealed my Alabama Home Fry Friend. Don't want to spread rumors lol! Thanks for adding the requests to your files! I think I have noticed that you might be a night owl? As I am also. Worked night shift for many years as a nurse and can't shake the habit! Thank you for all the hard work and effort you give to us subs and to Home Free! They are the best thing around since RC cola & moon pies or drinking a Coke with peanuts poured in it! ❤️😀🍟 South Georgia girl (Georgia Peach 🍑)
LOL Home 🍟. You got me! What happened was I was on medical leave from my work when I started making videos and I starting to stay up later and later. Then when I was cleared to go back my work has swing shifts. So, I've been on night shifts at work for the last couple weeks, and I stay on it until I have to switch again. IT'S HORRIBLE. I'm originally from Michigan, but my wife and I came down to the south to visit some people and loved it. So we hit the road, headed south (avoiding OHIO) and never looked back!
@@MrIncrediible1 I hear you and understand completely! My husband of nearly 40 yrs has worked crazy hrs too! Your wife must be a wonderful woman to live with you and go through all the stuff that goes along with a husband that does night and swing shift! I know because I am wonderful as well to have put up with everything that went along with my man! He's pretty great to have dealt with my work schedule and sleep problems too! It's a two way street! Well, hope you get some good sleep and tell your amazing wife that I've got her back and will be keeping y'all in my prayers! Take care and see you soon!🙃😀😴
As I said in the reaction on Mark Knopfler. I love Dire Straits. And I love this song and I must say that HF has made a great cover. Great reaction. An I agree with you. Tims voice is so good and he has such a soulfullnes and nerv in it in this song.
A stunning masterpiece !!! this is true acapella !! And there are people that can't get past the fact they sing a lot of country stuff. Thank you for taking a chance for reacting to them. Now to get some country....react to their cover of "Some Girls Do" !!!
They enunciated so well you can understand the words. They all have such wonderful voices, and use the ones suited to the song. They and their support staff do soooo well. I can't think of anyone else I like more as a group and their group of work.
Man. This hits hard. First time hearing it is on your channel. Being a combat veteran with PTSD, everyone needs to know more about this Topic. PTSD is a DEMON. Thanks for the reaction.
Loved your reaction! These stunningly beautiful harmonies are so powerful and thought provoking. This could also apply to Neighbors in Arms, Fellow Citizens in Arms....what the hell are we doing to each other.
That's how I feel sometimes. I understand you were speaking on broader terms, but on a smaller scale it's why I try to thank people for being so kind on the internet and when they interact with my videos. It's really easy to pick apart and hate on it, but it's a lot harder to have a nice conversation, explore, and enjoy the world with other people. So I really appreciate when people come in and are kind whether they enjoyed what I had to say or not. Thanks for being kind and hanging out!
I've been watching your Acapella music reactions, especially Home Free, for a few weeks now. I am very picky about who I subscribe to, my standards are high. I just subbed to your channel because of your reaction to this song. Well done! I love how you did just a little research without ruining a "fresh reaction". It actually helped you to appreciate what Home Free does, and in turn I appreciated your reaction too.
I was a Lowlands farmer who answered the call to arms. I always thought I'd die in the Lowlands and be buried there. But here in these mist-covered mountains I and my brothers fought you and your brothers in arms. Now I have fallen here and will ne'er again see my beloved Lowlands. So begins the song.
Home Free is doing a cover of a cover by a Finnish group named Club for Five. Tim asked their bass singer for permission to use it and he got their approval.
I knew you would appreciate this one and that it would Blow your mind. This version, of an already great song, kind of grabs you by the soul. Thanks for the honest review... Peace!
There are not enough adjectives to describe this Masterpiece !! You just did a wonderful heartfelt reaction, the emotion that showed on your face made me cry even more. I absolutely can not watch this without shedding tears. Thanks again and new subscriber here and cant wait for more Home Free.
Thank you for caring enough to get the backstory on the original. I was around for the original. I always thought it was powerful. Knoffler's guitar work is brilliant. This interpretation takes it to another level, and to be honest, I don't miss the guitar. As with most versions done a capella, I can pay attention to the lyrics. So beautiful. Not necessarily better, but different, and relavant to today.
I'm definitely still learning how to appreciate a Capella. This is the first time I've really every explored it. Thanks for being kind and hanign out, Penny!
There are those of us who put on a military uniform and answered our nation's call to arms. The lyrics reach our psyche at a depth we knew not existed. There are those of you who stand on the front lines of this internal Battle For America. I know the lyrics hit you deeply as well. Continue the battle but stay safe. Finally, there are you who are not military, police, firefighters, or EMTs, by your fight is against division. You rise every day to seek better ways to bring unity to our land. God bless you! It is written in the starlight and every line in your palms:. We are fools to wage war on our brothers and everyone is our sibling.
I have always loved this song by Dire Straits but think Home Free did an excellent version of this song. Tim's natural bass was awesome & so were all the guys doing 5 part harmonies.
War is hell, and the wounds go far deeper than the body. I cannot wait for the day when all war will cease, and in men's hearts will only be peace. This song bring tears every time.
The suffering and loss of our soldiers is the reason for anti-war sentiments. The two can’t be separated. I appreciated your reaction to this video. You can always count on Home Free for significant messages in their music. You really want to check out their original Undivided …excellent as always. Brothers in Arms has become my favorite because it is so powerful and moving. The minor chords they use make this very haunting and evokes emotion. Welcome to the HF Rabbit Hole! Enjoy the journey.
After watching and listening to your reaction, I really hope you'll do more from Home Free! I subbed after this! All the other reactors broke it down and commented way too much (imo). You just let the experience take wherever it did. Bravo! How Great Thou Art is fantastic, but I also think you'd enjoy Man of Constant Sorrow. I'm a fan of both you and Home Free! Going to see them in concert this February.
Yes, it’s hauntingly beautiful. I love Home Free -their covers are always so good. While I love Dire Straits version it’s guitar driven, this is voice driven. Not better or worse but different, at least to me. I loved Tim’s lows and yes that’s him on the bass in the background too. Loved the black and white film. Tim and Chance look ghost like in the windows. It’s just stunning. And I heard the wind too. So amazing. Good reaction MI.
😍 I've listened to this over and over on their cd but the video is phenomenal!! Get to see them live next week and again in December. Cannot wait!! Home Fry for life!!
I realized a while back that I need to stop praising the different roles these boys do in each song because they're all so incredible it's senseless to single someone out.
Thank you for actually reacting to the lyrics as well as the singing. It's hard to listen to this or the original and not tear up a little if you're paying attention.
Great reaction.. so heart felt! loved the fact that you did some research before you saw the original and this one.. and loved that you shared that! Such a haunting song.. still with me after yest and the day before! New Sub here.. Thanks!
End of the Road is great to see Rob really show some soul! Elvira with The Oakridge Boys is an older one that is nostalgic & awesome. For a some great laughs The Butts Remix is a favorite for many Home Fries! Enjoyed the background information & perspective you add to the reaction!
They are definitely mind blowing! I've been waiting for them to release this one ever since they released their album, Land Of The Free. This song & video is so hauntingly beautiful. I've always loved Knopfler's guitar through this song, so I was very curious to see how HF would handle that. They did not disappoint. So far, you're the only one who noticed the wind. I was really happy to see you pick up on that because I think it adds so much to the overall feel. Great reaction! Thx! Btw: did you read HF's comments in the description on the song?
You sir, are a fine human being. Your reaction to this was everything I've come to expect from you, maybe even a bit more. Thank you. Also, sorry it took so long but I finally subbed. Keep up the great work.
Chance leads in "Heaven" and "Some Girls Do". Rob leads in "Honey I'm Good" and "Blue Ain't Your Color" and "Bless The Broken Road". Austin leads in " When A Man Loves A Woman " and " Crazy". Tim leads in " Your Man" and "Hillbilly Bone". Adam leads them all on every song with his beautiful percussion.
Such a genius touch to show the silhouette of the fellas in front of the window. I know some see it as a "ghost"y reference but it strikes me as a reflection of the POW/MIA flag. We'll never know just how many of those met the same fate as the soldier of this song. 😥
I am late to this review of "Brothers in Arms" but I appreciate your reaction, especially since you have knowledge of the Dire Straits original. So many reactors have no understanding of the original song or the deep emotional context of the words. If you have any connection to the sacrifice by soldiers throughout history you will be affected by the Home Free version of this song. This hits me hard every time I hear it. Thanks for your reaction.
Thank you for the reaction, absolutely reflected my own except I had the advantage of being alone when I heard it. (No embarrassment for the tears on my cheeks.) if I weren’t a Home Free fan, I would think the last 2 notes were made by a pipe organ, not human voices.
This song is too haunting. I love Home Free, but I'm in need for things to lighten up. This is absolutely my least favorite song of theirs. I understand and completely comprehend it. But, I'm tired of this version of Home Free that is so depressing. I'm ready for Home Free that makes me take all of my worries away and makes me smile. Where are you Happy Home Free?? We miss you.
it is a song that is anti-war, but NOT anti-soldiers. It isn't blaming them for the wars (as happened in real life in the backlash to the Vietnam war that happened in the USA), just declaring them, futile, wasteful and pointless. Reading between the lines, I guess it wants to turn everybody into conscientious objectors. If nobody is prepared to fight, on either side, the politicians will have to find other solutions to their problems, and other means of achieving their objectives, rather than throwing away lives.
I'm not sure where to ask.... but is there any way you'd consider, before the Fall is over, listening to Eva Cassidy "Autumn Leaves" (her acoustic guitar version)? We lost her way too soon. I think it will touch you.
Rights management company for Mark Knopfler manually blocked my video, so the referenced video is not up currently.
It appears to be back or I think you are referring to your original DS reaction video? right?
As many have acknowledged, HF does not do covers, but upgrades. This is an A Capella masterpiece!
I disagree I think Dire Straits was the best.
In no way, shape or form is this an upgrade on the original..
Acknowledging the lost with a moment of silence before the final 2 chords - heartbreakingly beautiful
I'm pushing 70 and remember and purchased the vinyl when it was released. It was understandable but less so without hearing Mark's explanation.
When we returned from Vietnam, which was a real waste, including my cousin who drove his troop carrier over a tank mine. Thankfully I was able to attend his funeral.
Mark is extremely talented. For us in the US, HF has made the subject matter very plain.
Mark's guitar playing is extraordinary, however, to me the long solos somewhat mask the lyrics and their meaning.
One reactor stated he would have preferred Tim sing it similar to "My Maria" he did with Austin. That would have ruined it, in my opinion. In the song, Tim is a dying soldier saying farewell to his comrades and questioning the logic of war. Maintaining a deep but airy low volume sound reminds me of death.
I ran a government cemetery for 16yrs before I retired. This hit me HARD.
I forgot what I intended to say!? (I go into a room, can't remember why I'm there, walk out and realize it was the restroom.)
If Mark Knopfler did a collaboration like Don McLean, Alabama, The Oak Ridge Boys, Lee Greenwood, and others, that would be surely something.
Thank you so much for sharing your story, intermenater.
I haven't heard My Maria yet, so I'll have to wait to understand whether it would have ruined it or not.
"Maintaining a deep but airy low volume sound reminds me of death." Well freakin said. WOW. I can't even imagine the emotional stories you have from running the cemetery. Thanks for being kind and hanging out!
@@intermenater Yes, I remember that reactor thinking it should be in a higher register. I didn’t agree. This is stunning.
@@babyfry4775Today, I watched Peter Barber break this down, he is a professional singer. He agrees with you and I.
Thank you for your service❤️
"Haunting" is a word that a lot of people have used in regard to the harmonies in this, and it is so appropriate. I think Home Free has outdone themselves this time. But they do that quite often! Great reaction.
Adam and Tim just sing this perfectly!!!
This, to me, is a hymn to the dying and deceased. All the boys lost on a field so far away from home. Scared, lonely and soon to be “home”. This is hauntingly beautiful, I cried through the whole thing. It is a stand alone. Totally different from the first one.
This is the Club For Five arrangement, sent to Home Free with their blessings. However, Home Free made it their own during the "echo" sequences. Tuukka the grand bass from Club For Five is one of Tim's inspirations.
Ethereal. Haunting. Gut wrenching. Soul stirring. Angelic. The only thing missing was the seraphic choir backing them up.
Excuse me while I track down my soul and stuff it back into my body...
If you find mine can you send it via post?
The wind noise, of course, is Adam Rupp's contribution to the song, as well as his beautiful tenor singing voice. No drums, no cymbals, just the haunting sound of the wind blowing. Once again his contribution to the percussion of a song is spot on, and enhances the feeling of the great harmonies of the group.
When I realized what the noise was at the end, it sent chills down my spine. I thought I was hearing stuff at first. Thanks for being kind and hanging out!
It's been said : In peacetime, sons bury their fathers, but in wartime, fathers bury their sons. War upsets the natural balance. Love Homefrees version of this song. Tim and Chances voice were outstandingly beautiful. Thanks for your thoughtful reaction.
Home Free has outdone themselfes in this song. Tim's deep voice really hits the feels
"Haunting, desperate, stunning" a perfect summary of this song. I always appreciate your thoughtful reactions, thank you!!
Haunting..........and they're depicted as half ghosts, just as the words are coming from a mortally wounded soldier.th-cam.com/video/MPB3lt6vp4o/w-d-xo.html
you just blew my mind 😳
Tim's bass riding right underneath is mind-blowing. My God.
To me their harmonies make up for the missing guitar..... This was so hauntingly beautiful.
I have only been listening to Home Free over a year but I listen to then daily now.
I remember the Dire Straights original. I think they paid homage to it very respectfully.
They are quite patriotic without being overly preachy. They have done many songs about bringing everyone together.
This really showcase's how amazing Home Free truly are and how much they love our country and they always show such great respect to the original artist that's why they always get permission to cover people's songs and why so many artists collaborate with them
Tim sang from the grave on this one, probably his own!!
Yes, the bass with the harmonies does have a haunting effect. Tim has that gravely bass that makes me think of a church organ being played in an empty chapel, and it really hits you with emotion.
OOH that really hit me Belinda. "a church organ being played in an empty chapel." Much more precise reaction than what I said. Thanks for sharing, being kind, and hanging out!
Absolutly. You must listen to How Great Thou Art. On the last chord when they drop the base in, it's like a grand church pipe organ, stunning
Thank you for continuing with Home Free. All of us Home Fries agree with you that all of their covers are always perfect. Great reaction
This has to be my favorite vocal arrangement by them. No beat boxing - just pure amazing vocals. I am constantly amazed how five people can sound like a 20-strong choir.
The original Acapella version of this song was arranged by Finnish Acapella group Club For Five. They provided a copy of their work to Home Free for this performance. You can find their performance of this song on TH-cam from 12 years ago here th-cam.com/video/Gerr99h0nS8/w-d-xo.html&ab_channel=ClubForFive
Hauntingly beautiful, but you know it's going to be that bit special when Adam's not Beat Boxing, but lending his voice to the harmonies. Absolutely Awesome. 💓💓💓💓💓
“End of the Road” cover is a must listen. Rob’s lead is phenomenal, and he digs deep into his soul. The whole arrangement is spectacular.
I'll check it out, Robyn! Thanks for being kind and hanging out!
The way Tim sings this gently reflects how Mark of Dire Straits sang it, reflecting the suffering of the soldier dying on the battlefield.
This is MASTERPIECE. They should get an award for this. Song of the year.
My feeling is that with most Home Free videos they have to be reacted to twice: for visuals and for vocals.
It is hard not to close your eyes and go with the music,
but it can cause one to miss some of the special moments. Thanks for your reaction. Waiting for HF
holiday music. "Snowglobe" can be at anytime.
'Winter Song' is another of their winter songs that can be played at any time. I love them both!
@@carolinpettit7944 Absolutely correct, can not believe
I forgot that one. Did you ever listen to Tim with the Hound and the Fox doing " We Three Kings"? It might
be too religious for some but the visuals and vocals
are terrific. Enjoy the day.
@@susansundaram6737 I have not, will look for it! Thank You!!!
That's true, but I can't help it Susan! Sometimes I squint to see if what I'm listening to LOL. I'll check out Snowglobe. Thanks for hanging out!
Tim is the deep, haunting sound.
I agree it's haunting. They released it to Veteran's Day. But it suits that it is Halloween too. So painfully beautiful.
It's hard with words to say something is beautiful when it comes from something tragic, but sometimes it just is... Thanks for being kind and hanging out, Marielle!
The guys did a damn good job. Tim`s and Chance`s voices are phenomenal, wow! A very emotional song and Tim's super deep bass gives me goosebumps.
HF consistently manage to top the last song that I thought was their best. I’ve listened to this so many times. My favorite song on the album.
@@MrIncrediible1 Er... I think you are responding to the wrong post. :)
@@samo4003 LOL thanks for letting me know. I don't know what happened.
thank you for your reaction. It's amazing how they translated that haunting guitar in the original to humming that end up sounding like an organ. Tim's vocals are perfect for this song. His breathy bass brings such gravitas to the whole song. Home Free is so good at picking the right member to sing lead in their songs. IMO
I've listened a couple more times and it's honestly mind blowing. Thanks for being kind and hanging out, Marg!
Beautiful song, beautiful harmonies! Thanks for the great reaction !
Chance sounds good in every song they do!
If Home Free does a cover of a song....chances are it becomes your favorite version.
Lots of times I've never heard the original if its a country song as I don't listen to country music. I have gone back a few times and listened to the original and Home Free's version...to me....made it better.v
I wish I would've read their comments in the description before I watched it now. Thanks for letting me know. When I finally understood what the wind noise was it sent chills down my spine. Thank you for being so kind and hanging out!
Awesome reaction thanks for sharing. Just a great rendition by HF.
Alriiight, now I've made it through all your Home Free reactions, and I love them all! A few ones that will show you some different sides of them, while keeping their high standards in mind would be "Helpless Hoping", "Winter Song", "Elvira", "End of the Road", "When a Man Loves a Woman", "Folsom Prison Blues".
In the original you said the guitar was singing and I feel like the background voices of Home Free are filling in the words the guitar was singing.🤯🔥🔥🔥🔥🙏 (oops, you just said that!)
Great Minds, Gayann!
Tim and Chance both showed how powerful a gentle, breathy tone can be. And the harmonies carrying such strength and added emotion have had me in tears and shivers the past few days! I'm obsessed with the overall sound and meaning behind this song. Home Free has once again paid homage to our soldiers and in doing this song, they've opened conversations across the globe! I like PTX and Voice Play, but Home Free has earned my respect in their unapologetic approach to social issues and patriotism. Great reaction!
Thanks so much for the background on this cover, It prompted me to check out the Dire Straights version. It strikes me that Home Free has turned into a choral requiem. Props to both versions, of course, but I do find Home Free's more emotionally powerful. The Dire Straights version is strikes me as more "I stand up to testify for my brothers." With Home Free I almost feel as though I died with someone. Tim seems to be talking from the grave.
"Tim seems to be talking from the grave". Dang wish I could take back everything I said and just say that. Thanks for being kind and hanging out, Jennifer!
@ Jennifer Pearson love your comment! I agree with you on BIA! "Tim talking from the grave" is brilliant! ❤️
When I hear this, it is as if I am the one in the coffin, alone with just a few brothers in a huge empty cathedral.
Wow, more goosebumps with added shivers now. Tim talking from the grave will stay with me.
The bass really hit you in the gut. Loved that! THanks.
Awesome reaction Mr. Incredible! Thank you! This one is Special! Hits hard in my gut ! Completely broke me down and cried like a baby! Took me a while to recover! It took my breath away and I'm still crying every time I see it. I lost my Daddy before I got to know him. He was a decorated WW2 veteran and your right war is hell on earth! A living nightmare that so many have never awakened from, past and present soldiers with PTSD ( in years past it was referred to as " shell shocked" ) It's horror! I appreciate Home Free for their stand unapologetically on uncomfortable issues and not shying away from their convictions! They don't make waves politically but by their choice of songs it seems they believe in unity, inclusion of all people no matter what our differences are and encouraging us to care for others and spread good will universally! I think you would enjoy
" UNDIVIDED " Written by Tyler Hubbard of Florida Georgia Line and performed by Hubbard and Tim McGraw
" EVERYBODY WALKING THIS LAND "
" I STILL HAVEN'T FOUND WHAT I'M LOOKING FOR " Home Free and Peter Hollens
Have a great week and God Bless You! From a Home Fry friend in South Georgia!❤️🍟
Thank you so much for sharing your story with me, Louise. It's horrifying what the ripples of war do.
I've added the ones you've requested to my excel file. Thank you for being so kind, my South Georgia Home Fry friend! I'm now (don't tell anyone else in the comments😛 ) a new Home Fry friend in Northern Alabama!
@@MrIncrediible1 Ok! Good to know that you are a next door neighbor and my lips are sealed my Alabama Home Fry Friend. Don't want to spread rumors lol!
Thanks for adding the requests to your files! I think I have noticed that you might be a night owl? As I am also. Worked night shift for many years as a nurse and can't shake the habit! Thank you for all the hard work and effort you give to us subs and to Home Free! They are the best thing around since RC cola & moon pies or drinking a Coke with peanuts poured in it! ❤️😀🍟 South Georgia girl (Georgia Peach 🍑)
LOL Home 🍟. You got me! What happened was I was on medical leave from my work when I started making videos and I starting to stay up later and later. Then when I was cleared to go back my work has swing shifts. So, I've been on night shifts at work for the last couple weeks, and I stay on it until I have to switch again. IT'S HORRIBLE. I'm originally from Michigan, but my wife and I came down to the south to visit some people and loved it. So we hit the road, headed south (avoiding OHIO) and never looked back!
@@MrIncrediible1 I hear you and understand completely! My husband of nearly 40 yrs has worked crazy hrs too! Your wife must be a wonderful woman to live with you and go through all the stuff that goes along with a husband that does night and swing shift! I know because I am wonderful as well to have put up with everything that went along with my man! He's pretty great to have dealt with my work schedule and sleep problems too! It's a two way street! Well, hope you get some good sleep and tell your amazing wife that I've got her back and will be keeping y'all in my prayers! Take care and see you soon!🙃😀😴
As I said in the reaction on Mark Knopfler. I love Dire Straits. And I love this song and I must say that HF has made a great cover.
Great reaction. An I agree with you. Tims voice is so good and he has such a soulfullnes and nerv in it in this song.
Beautifully haunting is the best description of this video. God bless the broken road is another great cover. Thank you for your thoughtful reaction.
Will be getting to it for sure. Thanks for being so kind and hanging out, Tina!
A stunning masterpiece !!! this is true acapella !! And there are people that can't get past the fact they sing a lot of country stuff. Thank you for taking a chance for reacting to them. Now to get some country....react to their cover of "Some Girls Do" !!!
“…I trust them…” Great heartfelt reaction!
This just touches my heart, it's stunning
So complex and hauntingly beautiful. This one gets me in the feels every time. With Remembrance Day approaching (here in Canada) may we never forget.
They enunciated so well you can understand the words. They all have such wonderful voices, and use the ones suited to the song. They and their support staff do soooo well. I can't think of anyone else I like more as a group and their group of work.
Man. This hits hard. First time hearing it is on your channel. Being a combat veteran with PTSD, everyone needs to know more about this Topic. PTSD is a DEMON.
Thanks for the reaction.
Haunting, Mesmerizing, Magical and a Beautiful Masterpice.
I love Adam's beatboxing but these guys are at their best when they all sing. This is right up there with Hopelessly Hoping.
This is hauntingly beautiful ! Awesome reaction!
Excellent reaction. I am stunned by your ability to convey the emotion you're feeling to this song, with and without words. Thank you. 💕
This rendition has the same effect on me as hearing Taps.
You need to hear the Club for Five version of this song
Loved your reaction! These stunningly beautiful harmonies are so powerful and thought provoking. This could also apply to Neighbors in Arms, Fellow Citizens in Arms....what the hell are we doing to each other.
That's how I feel sometimes. I understand you were speaking on broader terms, but on a smaller scale it's why I try to thank people for being so kind on the internet and when they interact with my videos. It's really easy to pick apart and hate on it, but it's a lot harder to have a nice conversation, explore, and enjoy the world with other people. So I really appreciate when people come in and are kind whether they enjoyed what I had to say or not. Thanks for being kind and hanging out!
I've been watching your Acapella music reactions, especially Home Free, for a few weeks now. I am very picky about who I subscribe to, my standards are high. I just subbed to your channel because of your reaction to this song. Well done! I love how you did just a little research without ruining a "fresh reaction". It actually helped you to appreciate what Home Free does, and in turn I appreciated your reaction too.
Nice to see another person thinking along the same line as I did.
Thank you for being so kind, Rose. The pressure is on now! 😀
@@MrIncrediible1 yep, but in a good way. LOL.
I was a Lowlands farmer who answered the call to arms. I always thought I'd die in the Lowlands and be buried there.
But here in these mist-covered mountains I and my brothers fought you and your brothers in arms.
Now I have fallen here and will ne'er again see my beloved Lowlands.
So begins the song.
Home Free is doing a cover of a cover by a Finnish group named Club for Five. Tim asked their bass singer for permission to use it and he got their approval.
I knew you would appreciate this one and that it would Blow your mind. This version, of an already great song, kind of grabs you by the soul. Thanks for the honest review... Peace!
There are not enough adjectives to describe this Masterpiece !! You just did a wonderful heartfelt reaction, the emotion that showed on your face made me cry even more. I absolutely can not watch this without shedding tears. Thanks again and new subscriber here and cant wait for more Home Free.
Thank you for caring enough to get the backstory on the original. I was around for the original. I always thought it was powerful. Knoffler's guitar work is brilliant. This interpretation takes it to another level, and to be honest, I don't miss the guitar. As with most versions done a capella, I can pay attention to the lyrics. So beautiful. Not necessarily better, but different, and relavant to today.
I'm definitely still learning how to appreciate a Capella. This is the first time I've really every explored it. Thanks for being kind and hanign out, Penny!
Absolute perfection.
There are those of us who put on a military uniform and answered our nation's call to arms. The lyrics reach our psyche at a depth we knew not existed.
There are those of you who stand on the front lines of this internal Battle For America. I know the lyrics hit you deeply as well. Continue the battle but stay safe.
Finally, there are you who are not military, police, firefighters, or EMTs, by your fight is against division. You rise every day to seek better ways to bring unity to our land. God bless you!
It is written in the starlight and every line in your palms:. We are fools to wage war on our brothers and everyone is our sibling.
I have always loved this song by Dire Straits but think Home Free did an excellent version of this song. Tim's natural bass was awesome & so were all the guys doing 5 part harmonies.
great reaction, i could see it hitting you....Semper Fi
War is hell, and the wounds go far deeper than the body. I cannot wait for the day when all war will cease, and in men's hearts will only be peace. This song bring tears every time.
The suffering and loss of our soldiers is the reason for anti-war sentiments. The two can’t be separated. I appreciated your reaction to this video. You can always count on Home Free for significant messages in their music. You really want to check out their original Undivided …excellent as always. Brothers in Arms has become my favorite because it is so powerful and moving. The minor chords they use make this very haunting and evokes emotion. Welcome to the HF Rabbit Hole! Enjoy the journey.
I love your reaction ❤️🇨🇦
After watching and listening to your reaction, I really hope you'll do more from Home Free! I subbed after this! All the other reactors broke it down and commented way too much (imo). You just let the experience take wherever it did. Bravo! How Great Thou Art is fantastic, but I also think you'd enjoy Man of Constant Sorrow. I'm a fan of both you and Home Free! Going to see them in concert this February.
Just beautiful!!!!
Yes, it’s hauntingly beautiful. I love Home Free -their covers are always so good. While I love Dire Straits version it’s guitar driven, this is voice driven. Not better or worse but different, at least to me. I loved Tim’s lows and yes that’s him on the bass in the background too. Loved the black and white film. Tim and Chance look ghost like in the windows. It’s just stunning. And I heard the wind too. So amazing. Good reaction MI.
I'm very glad you do both the original and the cover. It adds another layer to the music. Very well done. Thank you and have a good one.
Tim has a deep voice but the slow and deliberate way he sings it drives home every word of the lyrics
😍 I've listened to this over and over on their cd but the video is phenomenal!! Get to see them live next week and again in December. Cannot wait!! Home Fry for life!!
HAVE FUN AT THE CONCERT LINDA!!!!
I realized a while back that I need to stop praising the different roles these boys do in each song because they're all so incredible it's senseless to single someone out.
Thank you for actually reacting to the lyrics as well as the singing. It's hard to listen to this or the original and not tear up a little if you're paying attention.
Great reaction.. so heart felt! loved the fact that you did some research before you saw the original and this one.. and loved that you shared that! Such a haunting song.. still with me after yest and the day before! New Sub here.. Thanks!
Thanks for being so kind, Sally! And thanks for hanging out!
Mark Knoffler is one of the best guitarist there is. He was against the war in the Fauklands. Home Free's version is amazing.
End of the Road is great to see Rob really show some soul! Elvira with The Oakridge Boys is an older one that is nostalgic & awesome. For a some great laughs The Butts Remix is a favorite for many Home Fries! Enjoyed the background information & perspective you add to the reaction!
Loved your reaction.
They are definitely mind blowing! I've been waiting for them to release this one ever since they released their album, Land Of The Free. This song & video is so hauntingly beautiful. I've always loved Knopfler's guitar through this song, so I was very curious to see how HF would handle that. They did not disappoint. So far, you're the only one who noticed the wind. I was really happy to see you pick up on that because I think it adds so much to the overall feel. Great reaction! Thx! Btw: did you read HF's comments in the description on the song?
You sir, are a fine human being. Your reaction to this was everything I've come to expect from you, maybe even a bit more. Thank you. Also, sorry it took so long but I finally subbed. Keep up the great work.
Hey again Fog Dog. Thanks for being so kind, hanging out, and now 😄subbing! Means a lot to me
@@MrIncrediible1 Y'velkm and then some.
Beautiful reaction, I love that you didn't hide your emotion and passion. Thank you.
Chance leads in "Heaven" and "Some Girls Do".
Rob leads in "Honey I'm Good" and "Blue Ain't Your Color" and "Bless The Broken Road".
Austin leads in " When A Man Loves A Woman " and " Crazy".
Tim leads in " Your Man" and "Hillbilly Bone".
Adam leads them all on every song with his beautiful percussion.
They did a glorious job! Have you seen go rest high upon the mountain the full video is incredible!
Very Good introduction, sir. This song is not going to leave people's minds.
Best reaction I've seen....period.
Such a genius touch to show the silhouette of the fellas in front of the window. I know some see it as a "ghost"y reference but it strikes me as a reflection of the POW/MIA flag. We'll never know just how many of those met the same fate as the soldier of this song. 😥
Thank you for your reaction.
I am late to this review of "Brothers in Arms" but I appreciate your reaction, especially since you have knowledge of the Dire Straits original. So many reactors have no understanding of the original song or the deep emotional context of the words. If you have any connection to the sacrifice by soldiers throughout history you will be affected by the Home Free version of this song. This hits me hard every time I hear it. Thanks for your reaction.
New Sub (and a Home Fry) you're going to need tissues
Thank you for the reaction, absolutely reflected my own except I had the advantage of being alone when I heard it. (No embarrassment for the tears on my cheeks.) if I weren’t a Home Free fan, I would think the last 2 notes were made by a pipe organ, not human voices.
This song is too haunting. I love Home Free, but I'm in need for things to lighten up. This is absolutely my least favorite song of theirs. I understand and completely comprehend it. But, I'm tired of this version of Home Free that is so depressing. I'm ready for Home Free that makes me take all of my worries away and makes me smile. Where are you Happy Home Free?? We miss you.
it is a song that is anti-war, but NOT anti-soldiers.
It isn't blaming them for the wars (as happened in real life in the backlash to the Vietnam war that happened in the USA), just declaring them, futile, wasteful and pointless.
Reading between the lines, I guess it wants to turn everybody into conscientious objectors.
If nobody is prepared to fight, on either side, the politicians will have to find other solutions to their problems, and other means of achieving their objectives, rather than throwing away lives.
Check out the message from Home Free in the description of the original Home Free video. 👍❤️
The silhouettes against the windows remind me of the POW/MIA flag.
Masterpiece
Powerful
I'm not sure where to ask.... but is there any way you'd consider, before the Fall is over, listening to Eva Cassidy "Autumn Leaves" (her acoustic guitar version)? We lost her way too soon. I think it will touch you.
Hey, Elizas. Just added it to the list. Thanks for letting me know. And thanks for hanging out!
@@MrIncrediible1 Thanks so much! I know you'll love it. Eva was a treasure.