What? Scottish people settled in Ireland and Irish people went to Scotland throughout history. Where do you think Scottish gaelic comes from? Its an Irish language. And one of scotlands biggest football clubs Celtic was founded by Irish immigrants
@@toomuch9762 your an idiot. Scotland has its own version of Gaelic called Scots Galic a completely different language. This idea that Scotland came from Ireland is a heap of absolute shite. We are our own people originally called the Picts and Irish was the gaels. Facts. But yes the 2 countries are celtic cousins.
As an American I don’t think of Scotland as a country they’re more like a state or province of the UK they also got a vote for their independence and voted no a couple years ago which to me is insane most countries in history like us Americans and Irish and to fight and die for their independence
I think there is a debate as to where Whiskey/Whisky comes from? It may have actually originated in continental Europe and brought to Ireland and Scotland via the monks? Distillation is first mentioned in Ireland in 1405 and in Scotland in 1494.....
Yeah, it originated in Ireland, and also the spelling used in America indicates its Irish origin there too. Irish whiskey has the E while Scottish and British whiskey is spelled whisky without the E. Also in the 19th-century whiskey was not considered Scottish but solely Irish, it wasn't until prohibition that the Scottish whisky industry came about after the Irish one went under.
@@MrSchizoid405 there is no such thing as ‘British’ whiskey. Whiskey was invented in Scotland by friar John Corr. We also do it far better. Who’s stuff is on the top shelf ? 🏴
Distallation was invented in the middle east, the Arabic cultures back then were obsessed with perfume, invented distallation to get the essential oils from flowers. Irish monks who were people of learning and knowledge saw this technique and wondered what would happen if they used beer instead of flowers and boom Whiskey in its first form was created
Whiskey originated in Ireland, not scotland along with Guinness. Iron bru didn't originate in Scotland btw. Bagpipes aren't scottish we have them in Ireland also. Tartan isn't scottish either. The loch ness monster is far less mythical and famous than the leprechaun and it was an Irishman who invented the loch ness monster. St patricks day > St Andrews day. There's no metric in which scotland is better than Ireland it's outclassed in everyway. American whiskey comes from Irish whiskey hence spelled with an E as opposed to British spelling. Unless you're talking about the country bumpkin crap. Even by cartoonish stereotypes Ireland wins. Ireland has more history than scotland. Ireland has better music and dance than scotland. Ireland has rich mythology, Scotland has no mythology of its own. Ireland is its own landmass and slightly bigger. Irelands scenery is more beautiful and varied. Ireland is 6 times richer than scotland. Scotland originated from Ireland. Ireland is coke and scotland is pepsi, has to be said.
@@gargantuanclaymore6824 as an American I don’t take Scotland seriously yall are just a state or province of the UK to us Americans you also got an independence vote a couple years ago and voted no which to me is insane most countries like Us and the Irish had to fight and die for independence yall got a vote and said no… insane
@@Chayton_Duffy not one country outside America likes yous. You're a country of European immigrants who then killed and stole the land of people who already lived there. America is far from a real country. 😂 the referendum result was because of scare mongering especially amongst our elderly with things like brexit and vote counts were visibly seen discarded. Like the Irish we also fought for hundreds of years to keep our identity. With them in a lot of cases. So you can sit down chungus
@@Chayton_Duffy That's because Scotland is a pivotal and important part of the UK unlike Ireland which was a colony of the UK, the UK has had 11 Scottish Prime Ministers, in fact the British government is over represented by Scots considering their population in relevance to the rest of the UK. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scottish_mafia
Ireland in the Early Christian period (A.D. 400-1177) was made up of at least 120 chiefdoms, usually described in surviving documents as petty kingdoms, typically having about 700 warriors. One of these petty kingdoms was Dál Riata, which occupied a corner of County Antrim, the island's northeastern most part. Around A.D. 400, people from Dál Riata began to settle across the Irish Sea along the Scottish coast in County Argyll. Other Irish migrants were also establishing footholds along the coast farther south, as far as Wales and even Cornwall, but the migrants from Dál Riata were especially noteworthy because they were known to the Romans as "Scotti" and they would eventually give their Gaelic language and their name to all of what is now known as Scotland. Dál Riata apparently established themselves along the west coast without much opposition. By A.D. 490 the population of Scotti was large enough that the head of the little kingdom moved the family seat across from Ireland. The Scotti alternately cooperated with and fought against the Picts for the next few centuries until the two were unified into a single kingdom under Cináed (Kenneth) mac Ailp'n in A.D. 844. After that the Pictish language disappeared, along with the symbol stones and other archaeological traits that had distinguished them from the Scotti.
Brilliant, I loosely knew all of this, but you guys pieced it together perfectly, and was a great read. Basically the irish went over there and showed them what's what! Nutters. At least they brought whiskey with them and not tea.
The word, "whiskey" comes from the Irish term, "uisce beatha", meaning water of life. Uisce(water) is pronounced, ishkeh. I'm Irish, and I love the Scots. The scots had great engineers and inventors. Ireland is home to Newgrange, older than the Pyramids of Giza - over 5000 years old.
Ireland or scotland lol its not even a competition Scottish orginated in Ireland and most of scottish culture...Scotland just means irishland lol Scotland is lil Ireland
As an Irish-American. Ireland is far better than Scotland, for one Ireland is an independent country Scotland is basically a province, I’ve been to many parts of Ireland and I’ve been to Edinburgh too but Ireland is by far better, Ireland vs Scotland is not even a debate tbh one just Englands little side kick and the other is a free country who’s culture is celebrated world wide every March, Irelands actors include Cillian Murphy, Barry Keoghan, Colin Farrell, Liam Neeson, Brendan Gleason… Conor McGregor is more famous than any Scot too, even singers Sinead O’Connor, U2, Niall Horan, Hozier, The Cranberries who’ve Scotland got Lewis Capaldi ? This debate like ain’t even close man even in sports Ireland were in the top 10 in the Olympics this year a country with such a small population it’s insane, Ireland is just far more iconic too it’s not even close tbh
All historical findings show that whiskey and earlier more crude variations originated in Ireland. Take the testimony of a scab nose 20 year old living in his ma's house the way they have everything in Scotland, with a pinch of salt.
Lol "his last names santino for fuks sake" 😅 Also imma go with scotland. I like their accents better. And the bagpipes will always hit home for veterans. Final roll call sucks.
@@gargantuanclaymore6824 You're in every comment sounding like a bitter clown lad. Most scotts I've met are bang on stop giving them a bad name lad. Ejit.
Ye bankrupted yourselves and had to join a union with the English, plus ye did get conquered by them a few times lol, plus we won our independence in the end while ye still lick the english boot
The irish built America, bagpipes are originally irish culture,ireland is a stunning country, beloved by many, and we have one of the best economies by gdp and scotland's culture is all from Ireland
Wrong. Bagpipes originate in ancient Egypt and were first used there. Bagpipes are now Scottish and Uilleann pipes are Irish. Scotlands culture is not at all from Ireland, that’s an utterly retarded claim
@@Bawitdabadabangdadang yup it comes originally from Ireland and it’s also far better too. I’m French but have worked in the whiskey industries for over 20 years. I think I know my own crafts history🤣
@@risinggael1685 But it doesn't 😂 Scotland came from the Romans and even before that we were known as Pictland, Caledonia, Kingdom of Alba. You lot even kept immigrating here, wannabe Scots 😂
@gargantuanclaymore6824 your taking the piss right lol tell me your taking the piss...you can't know so little...by the way land is a germanic/English word....not a brythonic or Latin word...and the Romans called the irish Scotti...ah god love ya...the irish took over northern Britain and assimilated the picts into irish culture and language...essentially the picts became irish culturally...Scotland means irishland lol or gaelland but same thing as gael are the irish....poor poor lil Scotsman ie irishman 🤣 your irish
Naa Ireland from Arizona, the Irish did Amazing things for our country 🇺🇸 Audie Murphy the most decorated soldier in US history, they came here and worked hard joined our armies built our cities, embraced our culture, Amazing people god bless Ireland 🇮🇪❤️🇺🇸
Aren't the Scottish basically descendants of Irish tribes that came over and settled centuries ago. So most Scots are therefore probably Irish in some way.
@@Shenanigan5 incorrect, Scots are there own people called the Picts Irish are the gaels. Read a fucking book and stop insulting people’s heritage. Scotland and Ireland are there own separate people countries. Both related and celtic cousins but still both different identities and 2 different people.
@@gargantuanclaymore6824 another thing we disagree on,we Irish spell it with the E pal,just look at bottle of the best whiskey in the world, Jameson or tullamore whiskey,any more than that pal I can't say, that's the way ,the Irish educational system has taught us to spell whiskey.😎😁
Whiskey was invented in Ireland
Ireland and Scotland are like two cousins who get on but never want to stay at the other persons house.
What? Scottish people settled in Ireland and Irish people went to Scotland throughout history. Where do you think Scottish gaelic comes from? Its an Irish language. And one of scotlands biggest football clubs Celtic was founded by Irish immigrants
@@toomuch9762 your an idiot. Scotland has its own version of Gaelic called Scots Galic a completely different language. This idea that Scotland came from Ireland is a heap of absolute shite. We are our own people originally called the Picts and Irish was the gaels. Facts. But yes the 2 countries are celtic cousins.
Scotland is a poor mans Ireland.
@@MrSchizoid405pish
As an American I don’t think of Scotland as a country they’re more like a state or province of the UK they also got a vote for their independence and voted no a couple years ago which to me is insane most countries in history like us Americans and Irish and to fight and die for their independence
I think there is a debate as to where Whiskey/Whisky comes from? It may have actually originated in continental Europe and brought to Ireland and Scotland via the monks? Distillation is first mentioned in Ireland in 1405 and in Scotland in 1494.....
Yeah, it originated in Ireland, and also the spelling used in America indicates its Irish origin there too. Irish whiskey has the E while Scottish and British whiskey is spelled whisky without the E. Also in the 19th-century whiskey was not considered Scottish but solely Irish, it wasn't until prohibition that the Scottish whisky industry came about after the Irish one went under.
@@MrSchizoid405 there is no such thing as ‘British’ whiskey. Whiskey was invented in Scotland by friar John Corr. We also do it far better. Who’s stuff is on the top shelf ? 🏴
Distallation was invented in the middle east, the Arabic cultures back then were obsessed with perfume, invented distallation to get the essential oils from flowers. Irish monks who were people of learning and knowledge saw this technique and wondered what would happen if they used beer instead of flowers and boom Whiskey in its first form was created
@@MrSchizoid405wrong 😂😂
@@tennessee_tom6126 Stop talking nonsense, ive debunked this on another comment thread. Whiskey originated in Ireland.
Hey, Theo. Ireland are not part of Britain. That's an insult
Whiskey originated in Ireland, not scotland along with Guinness. Iron bru didn't originate in Scotland btw. Bagpipes aren't scottish we have them in Ireland also. Tartan isn't scottish either. The loch ness monster is far less mythical and famous than the leprechaun and it was an Irishman who invented the loch ness monster. St patricks day > St Andrews day. There's no metric in which scotland is better than Ireland it's outclassed in everyway. American whiskey comes from Irish whiskey hence spelled with an E as opposed to British spelling. Unless you're talking about the country bumpkin crap. Even by cartoonish stereotypes Ireland wins.
Ireland has more history than scotland.
Ireland has better music and dance than scotland.
Ireland has rich mythology, Scotland has no mythology of its own.
Ireland is its own landmass and slightly bigger.
Irelands scenery is more beautiful and varied.
Ireland is 6 times richer than scotland.
Scotland originated from Ireland.
Ireland is coke and scotland is pepsi, has to be said.
Scotland just done it alot better.
@@AndyWoods16 It didn't.
Friar John Corr created whiskey in Scotland.
Scotland just had better marketing and claimed everything to do with whiskey/whisky as Scottish but thats not what really happened.
@@tennessee_tom6126 He factually did not.
Irish people are sounder, happier and more fun, Scottish people more passive aggressive but beautiful country also.
Also not true since Glasgow was voted the friendliest place in the world, its just our accent sounds aggressive 😂
@@gargantuanclaymore6824 as an American I don’t take Scotland seriously yall are just a state or province of the UK to us Americans you also got an independence vote a couple years ago and voted no which to me is insane most countries like Us and the Irish had to fight and die for independence yall got a vote and said no… insane
@@Chayton_Duffy not one country outside America likes yous. You're a country of European immigrants who then killed and stole the land of people who already lived there. America is far from a real country. 😂 the referendum result was because of scare mongering especially amongst our elderly with things like brexit and vote counts were visibly seen discarded. Like the Irish we also fought for hundreds of years to keep our identity. With them in a lot of cases. So you can sit down chungus
@@Chayton_Duffy That's because Scotland is a pivotal and important part of the UK unlike Ireland which was a colony of the UK, the UK has had 11 Scottish Prime Ministers, in fact the British government is over represented by Scots considering their population in relevance to the rest of the UK. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scottish_mafia
Ireland in the Early Christian period (A.D. 400-1177) was made up of at least 120 chiefdoms, usually described in surviving documents as petty kingdoms, typically having about 700 warriors. One of these petty kingdoms was Dál Riata, which occupied a corner of County Antrim, the island's northeastern most part. Around A.D. 400, people from Dál Riata began to settle across the Irish Sea along the Scottish coast in County Argyll. Other Irish migrants were also establishing footholds along the coast farther south, as far as Wales and even Cornwall, but the migrants from Dál Riata were especially noteworthy because they were known to the Romans as "Scotti" and they would eventually give their Gaelic language and their name to all of what is now known as Scotland.
Dál Riata apparently established themselves along the west coast without much opposition. By A.D. 490 the population of Scotti was large enough that the head of the little kingdom moved the family seat across from Ireland. The Scotti alternately cooperated with and fought against the Picts for the next few centuries until the two were unified into a single kingdom under Cináed (Kenneth) mac Ailp'n in A.D. 844. After that the Pictish language disappeared, along with the symbol stones and other archaeological traits that had distinguished them from the Scotti.
The Scotti we're the warriors who followed the Egyptian princess Scotia to Ireland when her husband was killed in battle there.
In Ptolemy first map of Europe, he actually calls Ireland Scotia.. The Rómáns called Scotland Caledonia, and Ireland Hibernia.
Brilliant, I loosely knew all of this, but you guys pieced it together perfectly, and was a great read.
Basically the irish went over there and showed them what's what! Nutters. At least they brought whiskey with them and not tea.
And Pictland/Pictish clans were also about before the kingdom of dal riata 😉
Ireland all day sit down shut up
The word, "whiskey" comes from the Irish term, "uisce beatha", meaning water of life. Uisce(water) is pronounced, ishkeh.
I'm Irish, and I love the Scots. The scots had great engineers and inventors.
Ireland is home to Newgrange, older than the Pyramids of Giza - over 5000 years old.
Who gives a fuck. We are both great people and least we aren’t English.
Scotland all day! Clan Cameron!
Naa Ireland is far better (as an American) love the old country 🇮🇪❤️🇺🇸
Gang gang baby ✌🏻🏴❤
Ireland 😆
Ireland or scotland lol its not even a competition Scottish orginated in Ireland and most of scottish culture...Scotland just means irishland lol Scotland is lil Ireland
As an Irish-American. Ireland is far better than Scotland, for one Ireland is an independent country Scotland is basically a province, I’ve been to many parts of Ireland and I’ve been to Edinburgh too but Ireland is by far better, Ireland vs Scotland is not even a debate tbh one just Englands little side kick and the other is a free country who’s culture is celebrated world wide every March, Irelands actors include Cillian Murphy, Barry Keoghan, Colin Farrell, Liam Neeson, Brendan Gleason… Conor McGregor is more famous than any Scot too, even singers Sinead O’Connor, U2, Niall Horan, Hozier, The Cranberries who’ve Scotland got Lewis Capaldi ? This debate like ain’t even close man even in sports Ireland were in the top 10 in the Olympics this year a country with such a small population it’s insane, Ireland is just far more iconic too it’s not even close tbh
Haha, I like people thinking anyone from the UK has a fancy accent, when often it's the complete opposite.
All historical findings show that whiskey and earlier more crude variations originated in Ireland. Take the testimony of a scab nose 20 year old living in his ma's house the way they have everything in Scotland, with a pinch of salt.
Pizza wisny italian
Scotland
Ireland is God
Your Damn right
Go bless the old country from Arizona 🇮🇪❤️
Ireland obviously lol
Ireland has Titanic lol has Gaelic football and hurling Gaelic sports, leprechauns,Irish dancing, Halloween.
Whiskey started in ireland and when the irish went to Scotland the showed them how make
Wrong. Invented whisky TV and the phone you're on
He really would've regretted that neck tattoo had he gotten it.
That guy at the started hasn’t a scooby
SCOTLAND
Irish whiskey every time
Lol "his last names santino for fuks sake" 😅
Also imma go with scotland. I like their accents better. And the bagpipes will always hit home for veterans. Final roll call sucks.
Ireland has 2 main accents north an south accent I'm irish I pefer scotland 😂belfast is a hole
@@user-dk7zcwise up u muppet
Shame is got a Chelsea shirt on 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Ireland baby 🇮🇪
We gave Scotland the name!!!!!
We gave you the pipes
We gave them the Celts
We gave them
You got ppumpped off the English n conquered n we didn't hahaha
@@gargantuanclaymore6824 You're in every comment sounding like a bitter clown lad. Most scotts I've met are bang on stop giving them a bad name lad. Ejit.
@@undauntable6456 you're no a football casual lad stop saying lad ya fkn banger
Ye bankrupted yourselves and had to join a union with the English, plus ye did get conquered by them a few times lol, plus we won our independence in the end while ye still lick the english boot
The irish built America, bagpipes are originally irish culture,ireland is a stunning country, beloved by many, and we have one of the best economies by gdp and scotland's culture is all from Ireland
True.
Wrong. Bagpipes originate in ancient Egypt and were first used there. Bagpipes are now Scottish and Uilleann pipes are Irish. Scotlands culture is not at all from Ireland, that’s an utterly retarded claim
Has such a strong economy it can’t provide universal healthcare and was destroyed by recession
@@tennessee_tom6126 well robert seeming as Scotland’s is provided via England I don’t see your argument
Also hdi(Ireland 8th) uk(16th)
Gang gang biz buzzzzz!!
Imagine speaking to 2 comedians and not mentioning Billy Connelly
Ireland is an independent country Scotland is part of britain
Whiskey comes from Ireland not Scotland.
wrong
@@Bawitdabadabangdadang yup it comes originally from Ireland and it’s also far better too. I’m French but have worked in the whiskey industries for over 20 years. I think I know my own crafts history🤣
Scottish are wanna be Irish 😂😂😂😭😭😭😭
Whole comment section is Irish trying to claim Scottish history hahahahaha. Yous are diet Scottish
Whole section is yous tryin tae claim oor history diet scots 😂
Scotland means irishland essentially lol your the budget version
@@risinggael1685 But it doesn't 😂 Scotland came from the Romans and even before that we were known as Pictland, Caledonia, Kingdom of Alba. You lot even kept immigrating here, wannabe Scots 😂
@gargantuanclaymore6824 your taking the piss right lol tell me your taking the piss...you can't know so little...by the way land is a germanic/English word....not a brythonic or Latin word...and the Romans called the irish Scotti...ah god love ya...the irish took over northern Britain and assimilated the picts into irish culture and language...essentially the picts became irish culturally...Scotland means irishland lol or gaelland but same thing as gael are the irish....poor poor lil Scotsman ie irishman 🤣 your irish
I can almost guarantee if you've met both, you're choosing Ireland.
Whiskey originated in Ireland 🇮🇪
Scotland all day
Naa Ireland from Arizona, the Irish did Amazing things for our country 🇺🇸 Audie Murphy the most decorated soldier in US history, they came here and worked hard joined our armies built our cities, embraced our culture, Amazing people god bless Ireland 🇮🇪❤️🇺🇸
Scott means Irish
We've got Darby ogill and king Brian in Ireland so fook Scotland 😂😂😂😂
Ehhhh we are not British
McNugget blood line is Scottish
Aren't the Scottish basically descendants of Irish tribes that came over and settled centuries ago. So most Scots are therefore probably Irish in some way.
@@Shenanigan5 incorrect, Scots are there own people called the Picts Irish are the gaels. Read a fucking book and stop insulting people’s heritage. Scotland and Ireland are there own separate people countries. Both related and celtic cousins but still both different identities and 2 different people.
@@Shenanigan5 most on the west side of Scotland are Irish Gaelic descent yeah, the rest will be mixed with English, native britons.
@@sully8317 highland Picts mate
La phroaig
Lá Phadraig .
Alba gu brath
🏴
So we're better. Cheers 😉
Eire abu
Whiskey is Irish lads,fact.
Whisky is Scottish pal. Fact.
@@gargantuanclaymore6824 it sure is Pal, Scott's whiskey,and whiskey was distilled in Ireland first, but I'm sure you don't agree 😜😜😎
@@paulbergin5903 see you're already spelling it wrong. Shows how much you know haha
@@gargantuanclaymore6824 another thing we disagree on,we Irish spell it with the E pal,just look at bottle of the best whiskey in the world, Jameson or tullamore whiskey,any more than that pal I can't say, that's the way ,the Irish educational system has taught us to spell whiskey.😎😁
@@paulbergin5903 Irish educational system is letting yous down if you're the prime example wee man 😂😂😂
ferplé díobh
whiskey comes from Japan
Whisky comes from Scotland
scotland an ireland are not UK there scotland an ireland