_“Me, playing old MR SMITH, travelling through TIME and SPACE in a little BOX”_ _“Oh, I was just PASSING THROUGH”_ I love how desperately 12 was trying to signal to 9 that he was also the Doctor 😂
12: . Yes of course it's....its you. 9: Yes, I'm me hello. Now who the hell are you? 12: I'm exhausted. 9: How'd ya get here Exhausted? Too brilliant XD
the theory as I understand it is all the 9th doctor comics and audio dramas take place in between as they never actually separate during the 1st season
And in Rose, he hadn't seen what he looks like yet, but was documented in all those photos by that other guy, I forget his name. All of 9's stuff that doesn't include Rose, takes place there.
In a world where Christopher Eccleston will likely never reprise his role as the Ninth Doctor; The Ninth Doctor lives on, in this audio drama! The Ninth AND the Twelfth, together. This was, frankly, amazing. The acting, superb. The writing, brilliant. All told, just fantastic! I'm so glad that it popped up in my recommended feed. 👌👍👍
The sad part is, that it wouldn't be that difficult to actually make it happen. Both actors are still alive and well and one of them I'm sure it's eager to return any episode now. There would be a bit of difficulty getting Christopher Eccleston to agree, but then again it would be the same with the BBC.
As a fan of 9th and 12th Doctors, this fan derived story of two-parts was delivered beyond my expectations. The story kept engaged me to listen and wonder what would happen next. And how you have made a cliff-hanging ending from the first part was excellently executed, which it felt as if I was watching a real episode of Doctor Who. The voice actors has done a *fantastic* job as well. I could not have asked more from this audio drama. I also enjoyed how you tried to made this story fit in with the canon story-line of the Drama series of Doctor Who, and surprisingly it appears to fit in very well. I look forward to your future audio dramas.
Big Finish are gods at Doctor Who stories. But they're not the only ones. The fact this is fanmade with proper impressionists and an engaging plot and everything... This is glorious sir. Glorious. This, to me, is the official 10th anniversary of the revival. Be proud of it. And I must say I love the cheeky idea that John Smith may be common because of the Doctor, meaning when Jamie first sees it in The Wheel in Space it might be the Doctor's influence that name is used there...
@@lukeoliver2785 You're very welcome. This fandom can be a vile place but it can also birth some glorious talent. Doctor Who fans can create the most wonderful pieces of entertainment if they put their minds to it and you end with things like this. Just great to listen to. Honestly.
I love this. It captured the individual personalities of both Doctors just as well as the voice acting. I could totally see this as canon. Matter of fact, I don't care what anyone says. I'm counting it as canon.
When I heard Krakatoa I thought, "I wonder if this is gonna tie back into the last few minutes of "Rose" and it did! The voices were incredibly well done and Carley as Capaldi was spot on. Nice touches with "A Good Man?" theme at points in the story. A really good story, too! And whoever did Clara's voice sounded just like Jenna Coleman. We know where this takes place for 9 so where do you have this adventure happening for 12? I was thinking between "Sleep No More" and "Face The Raven".
Ah, thanks! Glad you enjoyed it :) I'm afraid Clara's lines were lifted from TV episodes. For me, this story sits somewhere between 'The Husbands of River Song' and 'The Return of Doctor Mysterio'. I imagine he made the tape whilst he was with Clara, but the kept it in his pocket until it was required. But to be fair there are a number of places this could fit in 12s timestream!
This is the most fantastic audio drama I've heard!! Amazing, realistic interaction between the Doctors and with such impressive imitations of the actual actors. The story was really well written as well! I'm TOTALLY accepting this storyline as canon!! 😍😍😍😍😍😍
This was completely awesome - or should I say fantastic? Cause it was. Can't believe these weren't actually the voices of Christopher Eccleston or Peter Capaldi. Sounded just like them. Both audios were great to listen to but this second part had the best lines 😊
This was absolutely fantastic! Legitimately one of the best DW audio dramas I’ve heard. The story was compelling and very well written with great pacing. I’m very impressed by the storytelling, as well as the overall production. The guy who plays 12 isn’t bad, but the guy who plays 9 actually sounds MORE like the 9th Doctor than Eccleston does in his recent official audio dramas. I’m blown away. You’re a very talented writer, good sir. Better than the writers working on the DW show right now, in my opinion. Even if you only release it as fan fiction, you should write a lot more, though I think you could make a career out of it, assuming you aren’t already a professional writer.
Thanks for leaving such a lovely comment! Yes, Pete's 9 is very impressive. Jonathon (who voices 12 in this, and War in the prequel) is actually now doing official Doctor Who stories for Big Finish as the War Doctor...! Well, there's another project currently in the works, but that won't be finished till next year. In the meantime, have you listened to my Doctor Who poem? Ode to a Timelord. That features impressions of all the Doctors...!
This is headcanon now. I love Doctor Who and Big Finish, and this is just too good not to accept as the real deal. The audio quality is fantastic, the voice acting and impressions are very believable, and the story... oh, the story is just brilliant. I hope to see more from you in the future. Thank you for this amazing adventure.
A story like this is fantastic, it's so hard to write time travel stories, but one where they're sending people back in time to be their own fossil fuels, so clever
As someone who adores Doctor Who and Big Finish, I think this is truly outstanding! Brilliant plot, dialogue, pratically spot on manerisms and great voice acting; a real shame it has yet to get attention it deserves but has made me very much interested in whatever this channel makes next, I would love some more Doctor Who stories by this creative team!
That was fantastic! Felt like 9 and 12 were certainly there together and the characteristics of each were right on in the story. Would certainly listen to more!
This audio drama was absolutely amazing, I love nearly everything about it. The fact that at first, it seems like the 9th and 12th doctors are in completely different stories only for it to be revealed they're connected down to the temporary companion their both traveling with, the characterization of both doctors as well as the interactions between the two and the plot itself, everything. The only small thing I disliked was I wished 9 and 12 had gotten to interact a bit more, but I understand why they needed to be split up again. Finally, I absolutely love the ending. I've always thought it was such an interesting idea that the 9th doctor actually left after Rose said no and traveled alone for a pretty long time, but this audio drama made it even better since the doctor didn't just remember that he forgot to tell Rose that the Tardis could travel in time, and instead he was actually encouraged by his future self to go back and talk to Rose again, I just absolutely love it.
Amazing! Glad you enjoyed it :) Haha, yeah, I understand, but it's tricky putting the two Doctors together - there's only so much you can do with them before the plot unravels...! I was also keen for a tight story, so tried to avoid too much fan-service, and just keep to the plot as much as possible!
I love it. Doctor roasts himself, then the Doctor parents himself, then they do the time paradox thing that's very on-brand with Doctor Who, especially Twelve. It's going EVERYWHERE! And I love every second of it. This is getting saved for later.
That was great! I loved the 12th doctor voice! I loved the story! The refrences! I loved it all! The world need more multiple doctor stories! It was fantastic, abolutely fantastic!!!
I've heard it all in a breath. Part 1 and 2. I loved it. The ending was so perfect that I just rewatched the end of 1x01 with Rose and Nine. Fantastic. Epic. Thank you for this.
Woah! So the nice doctor went through the entire adventure of a Rose, then went through this, and then came back for the ending of that episode? That's awesome!
I thought this was an official episode! The writing is great, the acting is nearly perfect and the sound design is super immersive! As the 9th Doctor would say, it’s absolutely fantastic! Great work!
Big Finish should totally hire you guys. This is one of the best audio adventures I've heard. (Aside from most of the EDA), great story, nice twists and even with the impression of Twelve (Really good, but just a tad off in places) and 9 (INCREDIBLE) it feels like I am listening to something canon. Are there plans for any more? PLEASE tell me there are more on the way!
How have I just found this now?! This is amazing! The VA for Nine is on point, and Twelve has his mannerisms on point. Would love to see a Thirteen one if you find a VA for her(though because of this she’d have to be really close to how Nine’s is)
I take my hat off to you guys. Perfect voice-acting, spot-on characterisation, and the twist at the end - using one of the few continuity gaps in the 9th Doctor's series to set a story in. Fantastic!
@@darkhall8227 Our Ninth Doctor, Pete Walsh, also worked on somebody else's Doctor Who fanfiction audio drama (set before Rose) - It's called 'Cold Open' and you can listen to it here... th-cam.com/video/Z6EH95tXZg8/w-d-xo.html
Even years later, this stands up as one of the best audio productions I've heard.. Up there with some of my favorite BF stories, this is much more than just a fan made production. The story is awesome, the Doctors are so well written and acted, plus the sound design is brilliant.. Great job to everyone involved, and thank you :)
Ah, thanks ever so much for coming back for another listen! Those are some very kind comments :) I've got another story on the way, but it'll probably be another year before it's all finished...!
This was a really nicely done script. Among the things it does very well, I love that it acknowledges that Nine had an entire run as the Doctor at the end of the first episode, Rose, and traveled alone before he gave her a second chance to say yes.
Thanks very much :) In retrospect I think my characters are a little two-dimensional, but I'm still happy with the overall concept. Took a lot of careful planning in the script stage to ensure there weren't any major plot holes...!
God the larger story manifesting into a personal arc for the Doctor was great and something a lot of writers don't pick up on. It's that final touch that makes this so satisfying.
It's a weird one, isn't it? The younger Doctor always acts the more senior. Like the War Doctor in Day of the Doctor, or the 1st Doctor in the Three Doctors :)
14:58 “so insulation- hold up. Haven’t we seen something like this before?” “Quite probably it is a finite universe” Me: OOH OOH OOH! This was how they tackled the VERY VERY first Dalek story in the Hartnell years. Cheeky.
This is brilliant. The voices are so close. The woman who accompanies the 9th Doctor sounds like Linda from Bad Wolf. The storyline felt very RTD imo and i really enjoyed it. Thank you for going into such effort.
All I have to say for this is "FANTASTIC!" I took to listen to this at the gym, and the whole thing kept me engrossed! A good Doctor Who mystery, as it should be. I found myself trying to piece together everything that was going on. What is the dead world? Who are the Council? Every moment you're with the Doctor and trying to figure it out with him. Brilliant writing from true fans. Now for SPOILERS - I LOVED how Selly got a happy ending. I first put her down as being one to be killed off - but no - she gets to live a happy life (albeit aged up considerably) but at least she can live in content now that she knows the truth. - I LOVED how you handled 9 and 12 interacting. I didn't realise until now, that 12 is more "chirpier" than 9 - and the latter practically ready to beat him up thinking he doesn't care about what happened to Gallifrey, and the way 12 handled it was wonderful. He can't tell 9 the truth unfortunately, but what he says about the hurt getting better - it really reads true for 12. He knows Gallifrey is safe now, but the pain he went through as 9 was still real, and that can't ever go away. All in all - Brilliant writing - brilliant story
In a world where the BBC and Chibnall are destroying Doctor Who, it's good to see the fans still care enough to pour their souls and talent over amazing work like this.
The fact this is fan made and feels totally canon is amazing, and especially now that i've heard Eccleston actually play the Ninth Doctor for big finish, it actually only proves more how perfect the impression done here is.
when I found out the 9th Doctor already knew Rose, I thought he only knew her up to when he blew that building up, and I thought the cassette was going to be the holographic recording the 9th Doctor gave to Rose in Parting of the Ways to remind him to go back to Rose. But this ending was good too, and a lot less complicated.
Brilliant! The twists got me chilled, the resolution is truly satisfactory and the voices are wonderful which is perfect for practice listening. Thank you for making this!
Love how the guy playing 9 got the impression bang on, but rather than sounding Scottish, 12's VA sounds like a Cardi, straight out of Ceredigion. Love it
This was absolutely awesome work. As soon as I heard the first 5 mins I totally called it as Soylent Green (Energy instead of food of course) with a Timey-wimey edge. Pete Walsh as Ecclestone's doctor was amazing, you could genuinely fool yourself it was Ecclestone, Jonathon Carley was good as Capaldi but there was a few areas the voice didn't match but otherwise was excellent. Excellent work by the other voice actors playing the other parts as well.
Truely fantastic! An excellent performance by Pete Walsh and Jonathon Carley. This really captured the essence of both doctors, I hope that there are more of these to follow. Well done to all involved, this is truely first class and a testament to the creative talents of fans out there. like others I would love to see audio plays by the likes of big finish based on these. Certainly better than the 'official' 9th doctor series.
Cant believe how well written this is, and how well Eccelston & Capaldi's Doctors are played by other actors. Excellent sound design, excellent acting and excellent writing. Better written than some of the Big Finish work, (and definately better than the BBC). The dialogue around 12:30 makes me laugh so much ! This drama goes to show how good something can be when it's made by fans, instead of the lollipops in the BBC, many of who it is painfully obvious have never watched a single episode. Keep up the good work !
This is so fucking brilliant!! You should write the script for a few episodes mate, I'm glad you included the 12th doctor in this , he hardly ever gets a good story🔥
Ok. That w,as, to borrow a word, fantastic. A well crafted, well-written story that captures both Doctors perfectly. And they play off of each other so well. There were only a few moments where the impressions didn't sound just like Capaldi and especially Eccleston. And it leaves me wanting more of both. And that ending... It worked so well and fits so well. I only wish I'd have heard about this sooner. Brilliantly done.
I love this for a very specific reason. There are two doctors in the same place, but not because there’s a fracture in time or something, but because of a coincidence. There is literally no reason for these two to be here besides pure chance
It's fascinating how in the first few minutes of the first ep, i couldn't stop thinking about the differences between capaldi/eccleston and these VAs-and how by the end of this episode, there was no difference at all. A truly good characterization, a story that draws you in, the sort of humor that absolutely defined 9 and 12-Well, this is canon now. That simple!
@lukeoliver2785 Can I just mention-the bit about the Doctor choosing John Smith as an anonymous name, wondering if he's the reason it's an anonymous name-I LOVED that. That was infuriatingly clever and lives in my head rent free.
This is truly one of the best pieces of doctor who related media official or fan made, the ending was very satisfying and the concepts explored were truly unique and exciting. And of course thank you very much for bringing more ninth doctor related media into existence. Definite 10/10.
This has definitely been said before but that was absolutely fantastic. All sound and audio effects were superb, sounded completely professional. The voice acting was also very well done. Most importantly the story was very well written, very clever plot and that ending was quite clever. Well done
Considering this is never going to happen on-screen, this is the best thing I could have wished for. My two favorite Nu-Who doctors in one story together. Well done on the impressions. Well done on the writing for each doctor, and the concept in general. Just bravo.
Thanks very much! Yes, Pete's 9th and Jonathan's 12th are very good :) Jonathan actually voices the War Doctor these days for the official Doctor Who Audio Dramas at Big Finish! Pleased to see him go on to bigger things :)
Awesome. Great story - and well written! Wonderful voice acting all around and loved the interaction between 12 and 9. Their characters ~and their voices- were very true to form. Loved it. And the sound effects and music really just tied everything together. Cheers and well done! Would love to see more (and will go looking for more!)
Thanks very much! What a lovely comment :) If you're looking for more Doctor Who Audio Dramas, have you tried Big Finish? They produce the official stuff! A number of their stories are available to listen to for free on Spotify at the moment. If you're a fan of the 8th Doctor, I highly recommend 'The Chimes of Midnight'!
Just read some of your other comments and just want to add my agreement. Production values on this are amazing, this could have come straight out of the BBC. Excellent stuff!
@@lukeoliver2785 Thanks! I've heard of Big finish before, but never listened to anything from them. I guess your audio drama is my gateway into official doctor who audio dramas. (But to be honest, I imagine this as Canon anyway, it's so good and in character)
I accept this as cannon.
Well I accept it as canon
We all accept it as cannon! I think I might review it, myself! :)
me to
Me too!
me too
_“Me, playing old MR SMITH, travelling through TIME and SPACE in a little BOX”_
_“Oh, I was just PASSING THROUGH”_
I love how desperately 12 was trying to signal to 9 that he was also the Doctor 😂
12: . Yes of course it's....its you.
9: Yes, I'm me hello. Now who the hell are you?
12: I'm exhausted.
9: How'd ya get here Exhausted?
Too brilliant XD
9 right?
No matter who he is he always be cracking those dad jokes. 😂
I always wondered how long he traveled in between, " You could come with me," and " It travels in time."
the theory as I understand it is all the 9th doctor comics and audio dramas take place in between as they never actually separate during the 1st season
And in Rose, he hadn't seen what he looks like yet, but was documented in all those photos by that other guy, I forget his name. All of 9's stuff that doesn't include Rose, takes place there.
Soro Hanosh couldn’t some of them also take place before Rose? Considering we don’t know how long he’s been the Doctor for?
Wibbly wobbly timey wimey
Hunter Winter yea me to
Imagine being Peter Capaldi and getting to listen to a brand new adventure starring yourself not knowing what will happen to you
I'd love this to happen! :)
You deserve a lot more attention for this
CinemaSinsSins Ah, thanks! Do please share it with your friends :)
Hey
Ayy it's you
Oh hey it's daddy.
“Oh, I was grouchy, wasn’t I?” so funny. One of my favorite lines.
In a world where Christopher Eccleston will likely never reprise his role as the Ninth Doctor; The Ninth Doctor lives on, in this audio drama! The Ninth AND the Twelfth, together. This was, frankly, amazing. The acting, superb. The writing, brilliant. All told, just fantastic! I'm so glad that it popped up in my recommended feed. 👌👍👍
I'm so glad it popped up on your feed too! What lovely comments - they really mean a lot, thanks!
The Private Archive Indeed. :)
Thank you, it means a lot.
I bet you're feeling pretty happy right now. 😉
Hes back!!!
Officially head canon now. Very happy.
I love the small touch of the War Doctor's "No More.." after the Ninth Doctor says "My future..."
why can't we have this on the screen with Capaldi and Eccleston, sob! It's so glorious.
Ah great, glad you enjoyed it :)
Blame the BBC
The sad part is, that it wouldn't be that difficult to actually make it happen. Both actors are still alive and well and one of them I'm sure it's eager to return any episode now. There would be a bit of difficulty getting Christopher Eccleston to agree, but then again it would be the same with the BBC.
I could see Christopher maybe coming back for a charity minisode or something someday but I doubt he'll ever do a full episode again.
@@carealoo744 the bbc black listed eccleston over disagreements with Russel t davies that's why eccleston went to do films in the us
As a fan of 9th and 12th Doctors, this fan derived story of two-parts was delivered beyond my expectations.
The story kept engaged me to listen and wonder what would happen next.
And how you have made a cliff-hanging ending from the first part was excellently executed, which it felt as if I was watching a real episode of Doctor Who.
The voice actors has done a *fantastic* job as well. I could not have asked more from this audio drama.
I also enjoyed how you tried to made this story fit in with the canon story-line of the Drama series of Doctor Who, and surprisingly it appears to fit in very well.
I look forward to your future audio dramas.
Ah, thanks! Very glad you enjoyed it :)
My favorite Doctor, Nine, along with my son's favorite Doctor, 12??!!
You have made a 10 year old very happy. Thank you SO much!
Ah! That's lovely to hear - glad you both enjoyed it :)
i still love Eccleston's Doctor - so glad someone else out there does, too :}
12: I'm Exhausted
9: How you got here, Exhausted?
Best part.
Big Finish are gods at Doctor Who stories. But they're not the only ones. The fact this is fanmade with proper impressionists and an engaging plot and everything... This is glorious sir. Glorious. This, to me, is the official 10th anniversary of the revival. Be proud of it.
And I must say I love the cheeky idea that John Smith may be common because of the Doctor, meaning when Jamie first sees it in The Wheel in Space it might be the Doctor's influence that name is used there...
Thanks for leaving such lovely comments! Always nice to hear what Doctor Who fans think of this little project :)
@@lukeoliver2785 You're very welcome. This fandom can be a vile place but it can also birth some glorious talent. Doctor Who fans can create the most wonderful pieces of entertainment if they put their minds to it and you end with things like this. Just great to listen to. Honestly.
This is the single greatest fan made thing I have ever had the opportunity to partake in.
Great! Glad you enjoyed it :)
I love this combo.
I love this idea.
I love this.
I always thought there needed to be an actual 10th anniversary nod for the show... and IMO, this is it. Thank you so much for this!
Ah, thanks! Glad you enjoyed it :)
I love this. It captured the individual personalities of both Doctors just as well as the voice acting. I could totally see this as canon. Matter of fact, I don't care what anyone says. I'm counting it as canon.
when elderly enceladus said “john smith” THEN THE MUSIC STARTS . I LITERALLY HAD GOOSEBUMPS
“Insulation... Wait haven’t we seen that somewhere before?” Oh you little-
When I heard Krakatoa I thought, "I wonder if this is gonna tie back into the last few minutes of "Rose" and it did! The voices were incredibly well done and Carley as Capaldi was spot on. Nice touches with "A Good Man?" theme at points in the story. A really good story, too! And whoever did Clara's voice sounded just like Jenna Coleman. We know where this takes place for 9 so where do you have this adventure happening for 12? I was thinking between "Sleep No More" and "Face The Raven".
Ah, thanks! Glad you enjoyed it :) I'm afraid Clara's lines were lifted from TV episodes. For me, this story sits somewhere between 'The Husbands of River Song' and 'The Return of Doctor Mysterio'. I imagine he made the tape whilst he was with Clara, but the kept it in his pocket until it was required. But to be fair there are a number of places this could fit in 12s timestream!
Wow. The twists and payoffs in this drama are among the best I’ve seen in a Doctor Who story, and that’s counting the show.
You're very kind :) Glad you enjoyed it!
This is the most fantastic audio drama I've heard!! Amazing, realistic interaction between the Doctors and with such impressive imitations of the actual actors. The story was really well written as well! I'm TOTALLY accepting this storyline as canon!! 😍😍😍😍😍😍
Ah, that's great! Really glad you enjoyed it. Was a fun project to put together :)
This was completely awesome - or should I say fantastic? Cause it was. Can't believe these weren't actually the voices of Christopher Eccleston or Peter Capaldi. Sounded just like them.
Both audios were great to listen to but this second part had the best lines 😊
Thanks very much! Glad you enjoyed it :)
Wow, I could swear that this was just another Big Finish Audio. They need to hire the guy playing 9, he's FANTASTIC!
big finish obviously dont like new young ideas mr briggs need to listen to this
This was absolutely fantastic! Legitimately one of the best DW audio dramas I’ve heard. The story was compelling and very well written with great pacing. I’m very impressed by the storytelling, as well as the overall production. The guy who plays 12 isn’t bad, but the guy who plays 9 actually sounds MORE like the 9th Doctor than Eccleston does in his recent official audio dramas. I’m blown away. You’re a very talented writer, good sir. Better than the writers working on the DW show right now, in my opinion. Even if you only release it as fan fiction, you should write a lot more, though I think you could make a career out of it, assuming you aren’t already a professional writer.
Thanks for leaving such a lovely comment! Yes, Pete's 9 is very impressive. Jonathon (who voices 12 in this, and War in the prequel) is actually now doing official Doctor Who stories for Big Finish as the War Doctor...!
Well, there's another project currently in the works, but that won't be finished till next year. In the meantime, have you listened to my Doctor Who poem? Ode to a Timelord. That features impressions of all the Doctors...!
This is headcanon now. I love Doctor Who and Big Finish, and this is just too good not to accept as the real deal. The audio quality is fantastic, the voice acting and impressions are very believable, and the story... oh, the story is just brilliant. I hope to see more from you in the future. Thank you for this amazing adventure.
Thanks a lot, really appreciate your kind words - very glad you enjoyed it :)
Thank you for coming on this amazing adventure with us x
A story like this is fantastic, it's so hard to write time travel stories, but one where they're sending people back in time to be their own fossil fuels, so clever
As someone who adores Doctor Who and Big Finish, I think this is truly outstanding! Brilliant plot, dialogue, pratically spot on manerisms and great voice acting; a real shame it has yet to get attention it deserves but has made me very much interested in whatever this channel makes next, I would love some more Doctor Who stories by this creative team!
Ah, thanks very much! Glad you enjoyed it :)
That was fantastic! Felt like 9 and 12 were certainly there together and the characteristics of each were right on in the story. Would certainly listen to more!
Ah, thanks a lot! Glad you enjoyed it :) Check out Big Finish (if you haven't already) for the official audio adventures of Doctor Who...!
@@lukeoliver2785 Luke, this IS official :)
Love the ending and where it ties into the 9th Doctor Timeline
This audio drama was absolutely amazing, I love nearly everything about it. The fact that at first, it seems like the 9th and 12th doctors are in completely different stories only for it to be revealed they're connected down to the temporary companion their both traveling with, the characterization of both doctors as well as the interactions between the two and the plot itself, everything. The only small thing I disliked was I wished 9 and 12 had gotten to interact a bit more, but I understand why they needed to be split up again. Finally, I absolutely love the ending. I've always thought it was such an interesting idea that the 9th doctor actually left after Rose said no and traveled alone for a pretty long time, but this audio drama made it even better since the doctor didn't just remember that he forgot to tell Rose that the Tardis could travel in time, and instead he was actually encouraged by his future self to go back and talk to Rose again, I just absolutely love it.
Amazing! Glad you enjoyed it :) Haha, yeah, I understand, but it's tricky putting the two Doctors together - there's only so much you can do with them before the plot unravels...! I was also keen for a tight story, so tried to avoid too much fan-service, and just keep to the plot as much as possible!
I love it. Doctor roasts himself, then the Doctor parents himself, then they do the time paradox thing that's very on-brand with Doctor Who, especially Twelve. It's going EVERYWHERE! And I love every second of it. This is getting saved for later.
Ah, thanks ever so much for your comments! Glad you enjoyed it :)
And the Doctor-to-Doctor angst!
And that ending; very on-brand. The words, the way they were executed... It felt right.
That was great! I loved the 12th doctor voice!
I loved the story! The refrences! I loved it all!
The world need more multiple doctor stories!
It was fantastic, abolutely fantastic!!!
That's great! Glad you enjoyed it :)
two grumpy doctors being grumpy to each other
I've heard it all in a breath. Part 1 and 2. I loved it. The ending was so perfect that I just rewatched the end of 1x01 with Rose and Nine. Fantastic. Epic. Thank you for this.
Thanks! Your comment means a lot to me - very kind words :)
Woah! So the nice doctor went through the entire adventure of a Rose, then went through this, and then came back for the ending of that episode? That's awesome!
HOW DOES THIS ONLY HAVE 28 LIKES ITS FANTASTIC I RAISE MY BAG OF JELLY BABIES TO YOU GOOD SIR
Thanks! glad you enjoyed it :)
I thought this was an official episode! The writing is great, the acting is nearly perfect and the sound design is super immersive! As the 9th Doctor would say, it’s absolutely fantastic! Great work!
What a lovely comment! Thanks so much - glad to hear you enjoyed it :)
Dont care what anyone says...this is cannon. Absolutely fantastic job I love it.
That's lovely to hear - glad you enjoyed it :)
I love the EDM remix of the Doctor Who intro sequence.
Actually gave me goosebumps when the pods returned to sender! Absolutely fantastic!
Ah, brilliant! Thanks for commenting :)
That ending though! Amazing! So typical of Twelve! The very last lines had me beaming from ear to ear. Great work, well done!
That's lovely to hear - glad you liked it!
Big Finish should totally hire you guys. This is one of the best audio adventures I've heard. (Aside from most of the EDA), great story, nice twists and even with the impression of Twelve (Really good, but just a tad off in places) and 9 (INCREDIBLE) it feels like I am listening to something canon. Are there plans for any more? PLEASE tell me there are more on the way!
Ah, thanks! Glad you enjoyed it :) It took a lot of time and effort to put together, so I'm afraid there won't be anything new for a while...!
@@lukeoliver2785 any news on more of the 9th and 12th together
Luke Oliver omg this is so good I legit thought it was Big finish
@@lukeoliver2785 Just go and apply with Big Finish! This here should be enough of a reference!
How have I just found this now?! This is amazing! The VA for Nine is on point, and Twelve has his mannerisms on point. Would love to see a Thirteen one if you find a VA for her(though because of this she’d have to be really close to how Nine’s is)
Thank you! Glad you enjoyed it :)
I take my hat off to you guys. Perfect voice-acting, spot-on characterisation, and the twist at the end - using one of the few continuity gaps in the 9th Doctor's series to set a story in. Fantastic!
Cheers! Glad you enjoyed it :)
My mind can’t comprehend that this isn’t audio from an actual tv episode. These episodes were so incredible.
So lovely to read this :) Glad you enjoyed the story!
@@lukeoliver2785 I’ve listened to tons of Dr Who audio dramas in the past month and this is probably still the best one I’ve ever heard.
@@base-mint Wonderful :) I think my all time favourite audio is 'The Red Lady' with the 8th Doctor. If you haven't heard it, I highly recommend!
Acting 10/10, Impersonations 10/10, Story 10/10. As good a Doctor Who story as I have heard.
Thank you, Bob! That's so lovely :) Really glad you enjoyed it!
@@lukeoliver2785 id love to hear 9th doctor stories before he met rose the ones clive mentions in ep 1.
@@darkhall8227 Our Ninth Doctor, Pete Walsh, also worked on somebody else's Doctor Who fanfiction audio drama (set before Rose) - It's called 'Cold Open' and you can listen to it here... th-cam.com/video/Z6EH95tXZg8/w-d-xo.html
Even years later, this stands up as one of the best audio productions I've heard.. Up there with some of my favorite BF stories, this is much more than just a fan made production. The story is awesome, the Doctors are so well written and acted, plus the sound design is brilliant.. Great job to everyone involved, and thank you :)
Ah, thanks ever so much for coming back for another listen! Those are some very kind comments :) I've got another story on the way, but it'll probably be another year before it's all finished...!
Sassy Nine! This was absolutely fantastic! You deserve so much more attention for this. Head canon accepted!
Ah, thanks a lot! Glad you enjoyed it :)
This was a really nicely done script. Among the things it does very well, I love that it acknowledges that Nine had an entire run as the Doctor at the end of the first episode, Rose, and traveled alone before he gave her a second chance to say yes.
Thanks very much :) In retrospect I think my characters are a little two-dimensional, but I'm still happy with the overall concept. Took a lot of careful planning in the script stage to ensure there weren't any major plot holes...!
God the larger story manifesting into a personal arc for the Doctor was great and something a lot of writers don't pick up on. It's that final touch that makes this so satisfying.
i'm sorry I'll behave. I love how twelve is older and yet he still apologizes to old Mr. serious. love it.
It's a weird one, isn't it? The younger Doctor always acts the more senior. Like the War Doctor in Day of the Doctor, or the 1st Doctor in the Three Doctors :)
More fun than I had expected. Better script than a lot of the official product IMHO.
Man, I loved this story. The cast did a phenomenal job, it nearly sounded like the real 9 and 12 were part of this! That ending was great as well!
YOU HAVE GOT TO BRING THIS STORY TO NICK BRIGGS AT BIG FINISH!!!!. IT WAS "Fantastic"
Hah the ghost busters reference was bloody amazing and voice acting is a 10/10
2D Cheers! Yeah, managed to persuade some very talented impressionists to take part in this :)
What an amazing story. The voice acting is ridiculously good too. I would pay good money for a live action version of this. Top work
14:58 “so insulation- hold up. Haven’t we seen something like this before?”
“Quite probably it is a finite universe”
Me: OOH OOH OOH! This was how they tackled the VERY VERY first Dalek story in the Hartnell years. Cheeky.
The bickering between the two is spot on! This entire production is spot on.
This is brilliant. The voices are so close. The woman who accompanies the 9th Doctor sounds like Linda from Bad Wolf. The storyline felt very RTD imo and i really enjoyed it. Thank you for going into such effort.
You're very kind :) Glad you enjoyed it!
All I have to say for this is "FANTASTIC!"
I took to listen to this at the gym, and the whole thing kept me engrossed! A good Doctor Who mystery, as it should be. I found myself trying to piece together everything that was going on. What is the dead world? Who are the Council? Every moment you're with the Doctor and trying to figure it out with him. Brilliant writing from true fans.
Now for SPOILERS
- I LOVED how Selly got a happy ending. I first put her down as being one to be killed off - but no - she gets to live a happy life (albeit aged up considerably) but at least she can live in content now that she knows the truth.
- I LOVED how you handled 9 and 12 interacting. I didn't realise until now, that 12 is more "chirpier" than 9 - and the latter practically ready to beat him up thinking he doesn't care about what happened to Gallifrey, and the way 12 handled it was wonderful. He can't tell 9 the truth unfortunately, but what he says about the hurt getting better - it really reads true for 12. He knows Gallifrey is safe now, but the pain he went through as 9 was still real, and that can't ever go away.
All in all - Brilliant writing - brilliant story
Wow, what a detailed review! I'm so glad you enjoyed it - thanks for leaving such a lovely comment :)
OMG! The Ending!!! That's so brilliant!!! Best audio story ever!!!
Haha, thanks man! Glad you enjoyed it :)
Luke Oliver Hope to see more like this!
Azizul Adnan Haha, maybe one day...!
Luke Oliver Looking forward to it :).
I just share this to my member in a facebook group, hope they like it too
Thanks man - appreciate that :)
In a world where the BBC and Chibnall are destroying Doctor Who, it's good to see the fans still care enough to pour their souls and talent over amazing work like this.
On my giddy aunt! Found this by accident, it's BRILLIANT!! The writing, acting, everything is FABULOUS!!!
You did a Fantastic Job, I mean really well done man, Doctor Who could use writers like yourself, keep up the great work
Haha, that's great! Thanks a lot for your comment - means a lot :)
The fact this is fan made and feels totally canon is amazing, and especially now that i've heard Eccleston actually play the Ninth Doctor for big finish, it actually only proves more how perfect the impression done here is.
Lovely words, thanks :) And yes - Pete's 9th is fantastic!
when I found out the 9th Doctor already knew Rose, I thought he only knew her up to when he blew that building up, and I thought the cassette was going to be the holographic recording the 9th Doctor gave to Rose in Parting of the Ways to remind him to go back to Rose. But this ending was good too, and a lot less complicated.
To quote the Ninth Doctor, “Fantastic!” I imagine a lot of work went into this serial, but I’d love to hear more!
THE ENDING!!!!
THIS IS CANON.
Legitimately more entertaining than the current TV series, amazing job!
Brilliant! The twists got me chilled, the resolution is truly satisfactory and the voices are wonderful which is perfect for practice listening. Thank you for making this!
AD ASTRA PER ASPERA Ah, that's great! Glad you enjoyed it, thanks for listening :)
Love how the guy playing 9 got the impression bang on, but rather than sounding Scottish, 12's VA sounds like a Cardi, straight out of Ceredigion. Love it
My two favourite doctors, and an outstanding story. BF hire this man!
I was looking forward to seeing at what point this would take place in Ninth’s timeline... that ending had me actually smiling, you guys nailed it
Better than all of series 11 and 12 combined. I honestly didn't have any clue this was "simply" fan-made until reading some of the comments here.
This was absolutely awesome work. As soon as I heard the first 5 mins I totally called it as Soylent Green (Energy instead of food of course) with a Timey-wimey edge. Pete Walsh as Ecclestone's doctor was amazing, you could genuinely fool yourself it was Ecclestone, Jonathon Carley was good as Capaldi but there was a few areas the voice didn't match but otherwise was excellent. Excellent work by the other voice actors playing the other parts as well.
Well done for figuring it out! From the Whoniverse it's also got certain similarities to Revelation of the Daleks. Glad to hear you enjoyed it :)
Truely fantastic! An excellent performance by Pete Walsh and Jonathon Carley. This really captured the essence of both doctors, I hope that there are more of these to follow. Well done to all involved, this is truely first class and a testament to the creative talents of fans out there. like others I would love to see audio plays by the likes of big finish based on these. Certainly better than the 'official' 9th doctor series.
On behalf of all involved, thanks! Glad you enjoyed it :)
Cant believe how well written this is, and how well Eccelston & Capaldi's Doctors are played by other actors. Excellent sound design, excellent acting and excellent writing. Better written than some of the Big Finish work, (and definately better than the BBC). The dialogue around 12:30 makes me laugh so much ! This drama goes to show how good something can be when it's made by fans, instead of the lollipops in the BBC, many of who it is painfully obvious have never watched a single episode. Keep up the good work !
This is so fucking brilliant!! You should write the script for a few episodes mate, I'm glad you included the 12th doctor in this , he hardly ever gets a good story🔥
Kavan Puranik Haha, cheers man! Glad you enjoyed it. Was a lot of fun to put together :)
@@lukeoliver2785 Can't wait for the next one!!
@@kavanpuranik98 There might not be another. It's unfair to pester.
This is fuc*ing awesome. My favourite two Doctors together, I adore it
Ok. That w,as, to borrow a word, fantastic. A well crafted, well-written story that captures both Doctors perfectly. And they play off of each other so well. There were only a few moments where the impressions didn't sound just like Capaldi and especially Eccleston. And it leaves me wanting more of both. And that ending... It worked so well and fits so well.
I only wish I'd have heard about this sooner. Brilliantly done.
Thanks a lot, glad you liked it :)
Oh my, I have to pause and say that the meeting of these two doctors is brilliant! I would fully expect the two to get on that way!
veggiet2009 Cheers! Their interaction was mostly down to my fab script editor, Leno. He's a clever chap...!
I love this for a very specific reason. There are two doctors in the same place, but not because there’s a fracture in time or something, but because of a coincidence. There is literally no reason for these two to be here besides pure chance
I got a multi doctor with the 11th and 9th doctor. I call it secrets of artron. (But no fan made audio story.)
Loved the way it was tied into the pilot episode in the end. Wow!
Brilliant, brilliant, brilliant. You have captured the WHO spirit perfectly! Bravo.
Ah, thanks :) Glad you liked it!
Holy wow! I just discovered this and its amazing. No, its Fantastic! How is this only fanmade and not actually canon?!
It's fascinating how in the first few minutes of the first ep, i couldn't stop thinking about the differences between capaldi/eccleston and these VAs-and how by the end of this episode, there was no difference at all. A truly good characterization, a story that draws you in, the sort of humor that absolutely defined 9 and 12-Well, this is canon now. That simple!
What a really lovely comment :) Thank you so much for this! So pleased people are still stumbling across my little Doctor Who story!
@lukeoliver2785 Can I just mention-the bit about the Doctor choosing John Smith as an anonymous name, wondering if he's the reason it's an anonymous name-I LOVED that. That was infuriatingly clever and lives in my head rent free.
@@denizdenizer7813 I wish I could take credit for that - but I'm fairly sure I saw it in a meme originally...!
That was one of the best episodes to Doctor who I have ever listened or heard.
That's a lovely thing to hear! Really glad you enjoyed it :)
This is truly one of the best pieces of doctor who related media official or fan made, the ending was very satisfying and the concepts explored were truly unique and exciting. And of course thank you very much for bringing more ninth doctor related media into existence. Definite 10/10.
Oh, thanks very much :) Very kind words - glad you enjoyed it!!!
This has definitely been said before but that was absolutely fantastic.
All sound and audio effects were superb, sounded completely professional. The voice acting was also very well done. Most importantly the story was very well written, very clever plot and that ending was quite clever. Well done
Thank you, Joseph - glad you enjoyed it :)
That was a bloody brilliant listen. Great editing, clever plot, and you worked it into the first episode.
Forster Church Cheers! Glad you enjoyed it :)
Considering this is never going to happen on-screen, this is the best thing I could have wished for. My two favorite Nu-Who doctors in one story together.
Well done on the impressions.
Well done on the writing for each doctor, and the concept in general.
Just bravo.
Thanks very much! Yes, Pete's 9th and Jonathan's 12th are very good :) Jonathan actually voices the War Doctor these days for the official Doctor Who Audio Dramas at Big Finish! Pleased to see him go on to bigger things :)
Awesome. Great story - and well written! Wonderful voice acting all around and loved the interaction between 12 and 9. Their characters ~and their voices- were very true to form. Loved it. And the sound effects and music really just tied everything together. Cheers and well done! Would love to see more (and will go looking for more!)
Thanks very much! What a lovely comment :) If you're looking for more Doctor Who Audio Dramas, have you tried Big Finish? They produce the official stuff! A number of their stories are available to listen to for free on Spotify at the moment. If you're a fan of the 8th Doctor, I highly recommend 'The Chimes of Midnight'!
@@lukeoliver2785 Big Finish is great! I will definitely be looking up the Crimes of Midnight. Thanks for the recommendation! :D
This was easily a match for anything I've heard from Big Finish! Really really excellent work!
Thanks! Glad you enjoyed it :)
Just read some of your other comments and just want to add my agreement. Production values on this are amazing, this could have come straight out of the BBC. Excellent stuff!
So very kind of you :) It was a lot of hard work, but definitely worth it!
This was fantastic! Hope to hear more of these from you! Brilliant voice actors, great script and sound. Bravo! Please do more 12th Doctor adventures!
Thanks, Brenda! Glad you enjoyed it :) I'm sure Big Finish will bring in Peter Capaldi for some new 12th Doctor adventures before too long...!
This was the first ever audio drama I listened to, and I loved it! This was amazing.
Kcaj Animates That's great! Glad you liked it :) If you're looking for more, check out Big Finish for some official Doctor Who audio dramas!
@@lukeoliver2785 Thanks! I've heard of Big finish before, but never listened to anything from them. I guess your audio drama is my gateway into official doctor who audio dramas. (But to be honest, I imagine this as Canon anyway, it's so good and in character)