This channel puts out so much great, concise and intelligent, neutral information...yet still fools talk smack and criticize? Stay the course SIR! I am gonna buy one or two of your wonderful charts and look forward to continue seeing your informative and fun to learn vids! ^~^ PE@CE THESE "holy" day seasons.
@@screwthenet I wish I could buy a couple of charts. That's a lie, I wish I could buy them all. Alas, I live with my parents and everything I am interested in that they are not is "childish" (e.i. Video Games that are literally rated R for a reason..., or history charts, or anything political)
No one, mind you no one, has ever done a more professional, humble, and calm approach to critics as this extremely rational, pragmatic and qualified legend here.
I completely agree. I think so many of us are used to seeing very emotional responses to criticism, whereas this is purely an intellectual response. It's very refreshing and I learned a lot watching this.
People in the "european historical arms & armour" cathegory on TH-cam are also really good on answering criticism and changing their views if they are found to be wrong. Some good examples are Shadiversity, scolagladiatora, Tod's Workshop and Metatron.
I'm 8 minutes in and I need to stop and comment. From the bottom of my B.A. in General History and my M.A. in the Study of Religion, can I just offer a massive standing ovation for presenting the process of source analysis so beautifully, calmly, and rationally?
4 ปีที่แล้ว +1037
That was the most polite mic drop I have heard in a while.
I agree. This video was excellent in both its acceptance of other cultures and beliefs, but also shows how some people just can't reasonably argue and debate while at the same time use evidence and truth. I love this channel
Catholic here: I LOVE your work, and you have contributed greatly to my own research in making a very detailed “inspiration chronology” Bible-reading plan. Thanks so much for your hard work!
@@djordjejaric3214 Im as well an Serbian orthodox christian but i'm more of agnostic i'm only culturally christian because Serbian national identity is deeply tied with orthodox christianity.
Orthodox Christianity is a very respectable and deep tradition, I think. Free from literalism and full of interesting symbols, philosophy and stories. (I'm an atheist but interested in church art.)
As a devout Christian, I have to say that this has been one of the most interesting and informative series on religion I have ever seen. It's nice to see an unbiased take on the subject for once.
Indeed. As a OLD (not by birth age) fashioned Christian I like to see the level approach. Scripture is 🔆SACRED🔆 Historical records📜(not accurate per se but must be rigidly accepted when concerning spiritual matters of it)
@@jstrick85 it really is though. It sees both sides and concludes one is very lacking in comperison of the other, which is a very fair conclusion to make
@@NPC-bs3pm ..excuse me, but if you are going to use a Latin phrase please don't apply 'per say, but ''per se' which is Latin for “in itself”, “as itself”. I must add that I'm bemused that a person will recognise inaccuracy, but still abide 'rigidly' by the tenets of a religion. Where is the full understanding between you and God with this sort of thinking?
Wonderfully clear explanations! Side note: I've started to think that those who call others "atheist" often don't seem to know what that word means. I suspect that for many, it just means something like "bad person" or "you don't believe in MY god, so you're an atheist."
Sadly, there are just as many on the atheist side who will describe literalist or ludicrous theology, in order to mock how absurd it would be for anyone to believe such rubbish. It's not a helpful way to debate anything. We need to learn to listen and to respect, even where we think we are in complete disagreement.
I think they mean as another way to say "you must be ANTI-religion", as atheists are always depicted as hateful bigots who hate religion and anything and anyone associated with it, which is of course not accurate.
Matt, let me just say that I have my personal beliefs, and your videos have not compromised this. You are personable, professional and a delight to follow!
I've "disagreed" with some biblical theories or comments you've made but I've always respected your learned presentation. People should learn to gut up and deal. If i see or hear something i question or disagree with, i research it, ask questions or i ignore it. Folks, that's called adulting. That said, I didn't know you were a Jewish convert. I will say i always assumed you were agnostic. I just never cared because, as even you say, this is a history channel, not a religion one.
Yeah I’ve rarely heard of many people converting to Judaism, from what I understand it’s a long hard process. It sounds like he did it to join the same religion as his wife, but I wonder if it’s just a cultural thing or if he actually believes in the Judaic god as his form of “theism”
@@LordJagd you do realize that the Jewish God is the same as the Christian God and also Allah of the Muslims, right? All three are Abrahamic religions and all three consider Abraham as the patriarch of their faith and that all of them are descendants of said Abraham.
@@RachaelMarieNewport They're claimed to be the same god by the religions themselves, but to be honest there's a lot of huge differences between those three gods, especially between Islam and the others - god in Islam asks for things and says things that the god of Christianity wouldn't. Also, in Christianity most people think that Christ was also god, so that's a fundamental difference between the Christian and Judaic gods.
@@LordJagd I didn't say there were no differences between the 3, in fact there are massive differences in each branch, especially in Christianity. All three have an extremely fundamentalist and uber conservative sect or sects in them, all 3 have more moderate and liberal sects as well. The church where I was baptized was originally part of the Church of Christ, but split with them in the 1800s over wanting to include the organ and other musical instruments in their services and became known as Disciples of Christ to differentiate them from Church of Christ. Which is not the same as Church of God which is very popular in the Southern US. Also radically different from the church I belonged to and the interdisciplinary college group I was a member of after I graduated from high school. Both were fundamentalist and conservative. The church was an Assembly of God church which is Pentecostal. The group was led by a young couple who pushed the Evangelical message and believed in the literal truth of the Bible. My mom was raised as Christian Scientist and then converted to Episcopalian church (US version of the Anglican church). I have relatives who are Catholic as we all as many other Cristian sects. I have family members who are agnostic or atheist. Some like me turned to non Abrahamic religions. I became Pagan myself. Yes converting to Judaism is a lengthy and difficult process because they unlike Christianity and Islam do not proselytize and make it clear you have to seriously want to join them. Learning Hebrew is only part of the process. And if you are in a country that doesn't practice infant circumcision as a matter of course like the US until the mid 80s, you have to undergo adult circumcision at least traditionally since it was part of the covenant. In fact one of the controversial issues in the early Christian church was over whether Gentiles had to be circumcised and follow a kosher diet. Much of what Paul did to increase numbers in his travels was to say Gentiles did not have to do those things. Later many Westrrn counties adopted circumcision as a public health issue and it was pretty routine in them until recently. My son who was born in the US in 1987, and we were asked and his dad said to go ahead. I am not sure if I would make the same decision today. Muslims also practice infant circumcision.
I'm an Episcopal priest and got my early seminary education in the 1950s. How I wish I had had your charts available then. As one who takes the Bible seriously, It is refreshing to hear of your work to make Holy Scripture meaningful by putting religious writing in its historical setting without presenting it as literal reportage. Bravo!
If you really want something to blow your mind, you could learn about the rest of the ancient Near East which surrounded and interacted with the ancient Jewish writers of the biblical scrolls. Once you really understand ancient Egypt, the Phonecians, Ugarit, Sumeria, Akkad, Babylon, Assyria and the Hittites - the religions, history and literature - the Bible looks incredibly different. Just beware of the pseudohistory and pseudo-archeology. Sadly, many of them come from Protestant backgrounds (though usually FAR more evangelical and fundamentalist than Anglicans like yourself.) I forget his name but there was even one guy who claimed to have found Noah's ark on Mount Ararat, but when you look at his "evidence" he's essentially looking at rock in the same way children fantasize seeing images in clouds. Lol. Just a suggestion. I have to imagine someone from your denomination with a serious seminary degree would find all kinds of interesting things in the ancient history of the Near East to be interested in.
This video was very well-presented and well-executed. It might sound a bit strange, but this is probably one of my favorite videos on your channel just because of the personal connections you made to your own life and research; this really helped strengthen your claim. Excellent job!
As a muslim I personally enjoy these videos as they shed alot of light on the subject of interpreting holy texts like the bible, torah or the quran. Please do not get discouraged by these fundamentalists.
@@aldamon Progressive Muslims maybe? I don't fully understand it either, but maybe that's the future for Islam to make it more palatable to the modern western world.
@@hullie7529 not now, not ever my man, what wasn't part of the religion when it first came will never be a part of it and is not a part of it today, there have been many innovators in the past and they all failed and ended up in the dust bin of history, thanks to our scholars shouting from the mountain tops and warning against them. ;)
I came from a background that taught that the Bible is 100% the “Word Of God” and is more literal than Legend. I did my own research and have changed my mind about Biblical Literature but, it has increased my belief, not caused me to disregard the Bible. Thanks you Matt for your dedication because it’s people like you that calms the choppy waters of religion…. Jim from Napa, California
I wouldn't discount Ron Wyatts discoveries as a hoax and selling snake oil. The word of god has been passed to us and is literal, as well as some metaphorical - like you would normally describe something or compare things. The bible is itself the Word of God.. the same Word that lives in us all... Don't disregard that.. it is one of the most sacred parts of the bible and the belief in the living creator. Check out Ron Wyatt yourself - dig deep like he has - I would put him above this guy who ultimate seeks proof and confirmation from peer reviews.. and worst still , THE MEDIA???? 😭
So how do you get around bristlecone pines being older than the flood by 1,000 years since the fake genealogies of Jesus were printed on trees, after the same people put Jesus to death on them... Can I compost you or are an abomination in a box waiting for your forever box and eternal separation from the ground your God cursed you to care for in this life... Since a living sacrifice to the voice in the garden and the tree of wife might require you put borrowed shit back respectfully where you borrowed it from disrespectfully. 🌋 🌲 🍄 🐿️💥!
How did your belief increase after learning that the "historical" events of the Old Testament are just myths and legends? As an example, a video in this channel deems the book of Exodus and the character of Moses as simply mythology. However, if a Christian believes in Jesus, Moses is "historically" real because Jesus speaks about being with him. Therefore, in what area did your belief increase?
@@iamafan7492 Usefulcharts answers your question in video : some stories are better, more useful, more inspiring, and more profound when they are symbolic rather than historical
Matt, I want to be you when I grow up (No seriously, I’m currently finishing my BA in history and anthropology with a focus in religious social reformation, and I’m hoping to go on to my MA and PhD. Thank you for inspiring me for all these years)
I am a devout Christian, and I enjoy this series. I appreciate the format in which you present your information. It is nice, too, to hear your personal connection to the subject matter.
Love your channel. You truly offer a fresh voice. My only criticism isn't even your fault. But since watching your videos TH-cam has been recommending me a bunch of worship resource videos and Christian apologist videos. It's okay, you're worth it!
The best thing you said here was probably “those aren’t the only two choices”. That’s true for so many situations, I wish more ppl would understand that.
Even if the religious texts have a kernel of truth when it comes to human nature and society, the central premise of a deity with transcendent attributes falls flat on its face. When looking at the texts from an objective perspective using reason and science proving it’s falsity, the grand claims in it in my opinion dismisses the entirety of it
Yes religious videos particularly Judaism, Christianity and Islam is very difficult to do because of opposition by literalists. But I do recommend your courageous yet calm approach
@@UsefulCharts this was the moment you (metaphorically) took our your Oxford annotated NRSV, your three diplomas and your entire childhood memoirs and dropped them along with the mic. (politely) 🙇🎤⛪📚 🎤 💣💥
This was at best, the most kind but very impactful read I have ever witnessed! This just reminded me, that when facts are involved there’s no need to reciprocate the given energy! I love your work by the way ✨
Unfortunately, the vast majority of those that agree with the comment have never actually read the bible. Polls asking Christians if they have read the entire bible vary between 10 and 20 percent responding, yes.
@@jedgar63 They may fear they would become atheist. It happened to me actually. I was raised as a Christian, devoutly believed, then started to think, read the bible, got out.
@@jedgar63 strictly speaking you don't have to read the Bible to be a follower of Jesus Christ. Plus majority of ppl throughout human history were illiterate
@@kalyptro123 I have been an atheist for most of my adult life, because religion seemed to be an oversimplification of an extremely complex reality. Five years ago I decided to read the entire bible. If I hadn't been an atheist before I read the bible, I would have been one afterwards. But I also found it extremely interesting, and the bible, combined with a general interest of ancient history, has been the main subject that I personally study. It includes the bible, the history of the bible, and the history and mythology of Christianity, of Israel and Judaism, and the history and mythologies of the Romans. Greeks, Mesopotamians, Egyptians, etc. Just because I, and others, do not have a degree, does not mean we are not highly knowledgeable on the subjects. But then, I don't claim to be an expert, or misrepresent myself as one. I am learning for my own sake, not to satisfy others.
@Carlos Adrián Aguirre some people says human at least if not being full blown cynical must at least having faith on something, doesn't matter it's God, religion, love partner, family, friends etc with out that a person can be depressed.
I am an atheist. And I don't care if you are a theist or not. You do a great job. And you are extremely fair and accurate in your approach. I like using people like you as an example to militant atheists (those that think anything to do with religion is wrong) as an example that you can believe in a god and still do great history. Thank you.
Church of Satan atheists (atheists who think anyone who believes in a deity is insane) are some of the worst to encounter as a more liberal atheist. They will literally blow up over someone commenting "God bless you" or "Amen", and will say you're not a "true atheist" for defending people just minding their own business. They're the hyper literalist evangelicals of the atheist world. Thanks for coming to my TEDTalk
@@colinpierre3441 For me, it's a long story. Deconverting isn't just one Eureka! moment that completely destroys our faith. It's a slow burn that eventually bursts into a rejection of faith. I eventually saw scientific explanations as being more logical than superstitious ones, so I stopped believing.
@@colinpierre3441 Hi, sorry it took so long to reply. I was raised nonreligious. I learned about Greek, Roman and Norse gods before I ever heard of the Christian god. Religion just never came up much growing up. However, when I was older I gave it more thought. Many of my friends believed in a god. So I studied religion. The weird thing is that, while I never believe in a god. I was superstitious. I believed in psychic's etc. That is because I had no tools to tell the difference. One day I picked up a Skeptical Inquirer magazine. It gave me the tools to discern the difference between science and pseudoscience. And I used those tools to look at religion. Plus, I have a background in history and mythology. Sorry for the length. If you would like more information, let me know. This is the short version. Good luck and keep up the good work.
@@humbaba55 It's no problem, I myself am very busy at times so I don't mind waiting a day or 2 to receive a response... this topic deals with our very purpose of existence, so it is something worth waiting to hear. I have done quite some research on atheism myself even though I am a Christian, because we always need to keep searching for truth and considering new information as time progresses. It's interesting that you believed in psychic's, although I do admit that there are some strange things that humans are able to pull off at times that I can't find a good explanation of how it was possible. In any event, I stay clear of most religions because they are riddled with corruption and hypocrisy. However, I do believe in the Bible and how it harmonizes with historical findings and accounts. So the question I would like to ask you is have you ever read the Bible and do you think it is a morally beneficial book?
This man is tranquility incarnated. He literally sat down for (at least) half an hour and told everyone in the most polite way possible why they are wrong to dismiss his video and kept his cool even though clearly the amount of work needed make these vids is clearly too monumental for some dude online to go BULLSHIT. This channel was such a great find!
I usually comment on music. This presentation was very informative whether you are very tradional or liberal in your beliefs. It is good and correct to be open to other concepts of anything in life if you respect your brain's ability to function. Bruce Meredith.
Funny you should say that he’s tranquility incarnate- I use his videos to help me fall asleep- not because they’re boring! Far from it! he just has a soothing voice and cadence 😊
I can’t believe that you had to explain all of this. I studied some of the Old Testament 20+ years ago at uni, and your analysis of the verbal traditions was what we learnt then. Love your work!
@@translarrybutz I heard that in Canada people non-whites don't refer to themselves as Irish-Canadians/Black-Canadians/Fillipino-Canadians etc. They also refer to themselves as *Canadians.*Pretty sure he is reffering to that just as you said now that I re-read it. I originally thought he was indicating he was half-theist and half-atheist which is...you know.
I’m Christian and a physician and I am such a fan of your work! I think those who are religious need to treat historical analysis as a science- it can be used in many ways, sometimes “helpful” and other times surprisingly in relation to your beliefs. Thank you for all your work!
When people care more about the credentials than the quality of the work produced it becomes problematic. The reverse is also problematic. Useful charts is a great example of quality work by someone qualified to do so and sources to back up his claims
My daughter and I are impressed with your responses. We have been thoroughly enjoying watching these series you present and your other videos, and we look forward to continuing to see your work. Thank you very much.
Speaking as an Orthodox Jew here: while I believe in the Hebrew Bible, in terms of knowledge, you’re using the terms “myth,” “legend,” and “history” correctly. I do not know whether the Bible is real, and in terms of the scientific method, the standard you’re using is perfectly correct. Don’t listen to the haters.
@@stephanieho6162 My reaction too lol. But I was mostly surprised that there is a field of "Psychology of Religion". Makes perfect sense when you think about it, but it was unfamiliar to me.
@@PeterP_ the psychology of religion. The research field that dare not speak its name (within proximity of a church.) I've had students flinch when I mentioned its existence. And I'm not even exaggerating.
@@mustafaali3333-q1m I say, "Flex away." It's fun to school people who make assumptions from time to time. I enjoy flexing mine when trolls like to school me on public policy and politics.
love this channel. I also sometimes watch another channel who doesn't have a degree, but he has read all the religious texts, and also the Nag Hamadi, Targums of Palestine, Emerald Tablet of Thoth, Gospel of the Holy Twelve, Essene Gospel of Peace and more, as well as historical documents from the time. I know I'll never be able to read all of these and study with anyone, so it's interesting to be sure.
It's a credit to him that he has been so objective on this subject that people thought he was an atheist. Typically when a abrahamic theist speaks on this subjects it's quite clear that their believes are affecting their argumentation.
To many people, including ministers, the bible is not literal history. It is about the messages in the bible, and the theology; a combination of parable, allegory, moral teachings, and history.
I attended a Bible literalist Christian school for 14 years from age 4 to 18. I didn’t know half of the stories in the Bible let alone which ones had a touch of history and which were pure fiction until I started watching this channel. I officially denounced my faith two years ago and from then on I’ve been learning more about the faith I left then I ever knew while I was still practicing. This channel has instilled in me a sort of respect for the Bible not as an unquestionable moral guide but rather for what it is, an excellent look at the evolution of ideas and values from a group of peoples that still exists today. Thank you for helping me develop a healthy respect for the Bible and for religion as a whole instead of the blind hatred many others succumb to.
so sorry to hear that maddie - it’s a shame that people teaching the bible with poor biblical literacy has pushed you away from the faith. i urge you to look up Michael Heiser either on youtube or listen to his Naked Bible podcast on spotify/apple. Heiser is a very knowledgeable Old Testament scholar who both regularly interacts with modern biblical criticism / scholarship yet also has a pragmatic view of the faith. He is a very smart christian man who doesn’t just blindly believe. It’s a shame that there are many christians who cannot answer the concerns of doubters, who then eventually get pushed away. God bless you sister.
Other options on youtube are Testify and InspiringPhilosophy. Each show their sources throughout all their claims, so it's easy to go fact checking them. And they're clear on what claims are archeological vs reason/logical (not sure the term).
Great that you are now learning more about the christian faith. Now I would challenge you to pick up the Bible itself and go through it Genesis to Revelations. You'll learn plenty more than on this channel!
It's quite a fascinating document, from a historical, political, and cultural standpoint. Unfortunately, religions generally discourage people from looking at the actual historical, political, and cultural standpoints.
I was raised atheist and hold very deep atheist beliefs, but I've recently started interacting more with various theist friends and I'm trying to better understand how they approach the world -- why certain things that seem blatantly obvious from an atheist point of view may look much different to someone who was raised differently. This channel has been immensely helpful, because it clearly separates scientific/historical facts from myth, legend, and faith.
I’m seeing a lot of “as a Christian...” and “as a Muslim...” comments, so my turn : as a secular humanist and atheist (yes, the a-word 😱) I was very impressed by your scholarly approach and unbiased presentation of the varying biblical myths and legends. As a nonbeliever, you made me feel included in a discussion a lot of people think atheists shouldn’t be involved in, even though we are *very* much affected by religion and its influence on, well... everything. So thank you very much, and keep up the amazing work.
As a practicing Catholic, I thought that your series was a very well done. In the end, the important aspects of the Bible are the messages it teaches (Loving God, loving thy neighbor, etc).
That is correct but the problem lies with those who believe in 100% literal Bible interpretation. It is impossible to change their minds, and if presented with evidence that disproves their theories (i.e, the age of earth or dinosaur fossils) they simply discount the scientific qnd archeological evidence because for them "faith" trumps all.
I think many difficulties come from how far back the events of the Old Testament go. But As a Pentecostal, I believe that the New Testament has concrete historical evidence to back up the events described. But each to their own, every individual is free to believe in the things they want too.
@@senpainoticeme9675 God claims to be the truth so if young earth is false the only thing that tells me is the story wasn't literal I don't know why so many people have a problem with that.
Your work is inspiring. Please don't stop. Also in this video, your calmness and intelligence and how clearly articulate, is what I and my kids aspire to be.
You crushed this. Watching your videos has really provided me stable ground through my questions about my faith. This might be my favorite video on the channel so far.
The fact people have the audacity to literally say “You are uneducated in this matter” is baffling to me, who are you to decide that?? You cannot take everything you read or write as literal, at the end of the day all religions are correct in some way and the only way to dispel any would be if you literally lived during that time or in the after life. Anyways thank you for the video!
Because that’s the favorite catchword here on the internet. ‘Uneducated”. If you don’t agree with somebody, or have a different opinion, you’re “uneducated”. They LOVE that word. And considering some the grammar/spelling they use, I find it amusing.
Having watched both your Bible series and this one, I gotta say that it is REFRESHING to find someone who discusses the Bible and it's stories in an academic fashion. I grew up in the southern United States, which is HEAVILY Christian. The sort of Christian where the Bible is the world of God, and everything in it is the literal truth. I love religious studies, but couldn't actually take courses in it in college because of those Christians. It would have been like going to church, which is the last thing I wanted to deal with. I left Christianity long ago because American Christians want me dead. So I greatly appreciate the historical look at the stories of the Bible and the people it talks about. Thank you for all the work you do.
Fellow Jew, and I agree. I ended up buying the biblical chart from his site for Torah study to keep lineages straight. Lol. I love his channel and how he has presented this
You are clear, concise, have removed what might considered getting too far into the weeds ... and, above all, are comprehensible in historical and literary matters, that would otherwise remain arcane and boring the average viewer. Even your relaxed approach and somewhat matter-of-fact style lend themselves your appeal and your impressive number of subscribers. You are a superb teacher, in every sense of the words, and the perfect example of how relaying information in an educational way on You Tube can help so many comprehend subject matter they might otherwise neglect to take notice. And your practical visual aids add so much to your spoken words, and our understanding. Thank you for your dedication, hard work and passion for teaching. Most appreciated.
Thanks, Matt! As a theist who follows Jesus with both his intellect and faith fully engaged, I appreciate the thoughtful, well reasoned analysis and interpretation you offer here. As someone who shares in some of the same religious and cultural history as you, I’m really proud of all the work you do!👊🏼
i had a conversation with my mom a couple of months ago where i said something about not understanding the bible entirely literally and she started getting a little snippy about it until i was like.. well do you believe the earth is 5000 years old or do you believe it's billions of years old? she said billions of years and i was like well see you don't believe everything in the bible is literal either. i kind of think it blew her mind. she'd just never even considered it.
each day of the lords is a 1000 years.when you multiply 6,868 of the Jewish calendar you get a far more reasonable numbet,the book I read said it adds up to 4.5 billion years, sorry I read the book 20 years ago some details r fuzzy think its psalm 92
Having been brought up as a Christian, I was also brought up to believe that the Bible was a mix of myth, legend, and history. Learned that in Sunday school as a kid.
@@alankent perhaps they’ve just been more successfully infiltrated. And infiltration doesn’t happen with things that aren’t important enough to someone else who knows the truth, and wants to make sure no one else does.
Personally I am agnostic to, But I’ve recently been getting into some religious and spiritual stuff because I think that even though they are myths and legends they can still hold value as long as you look at them from an unbiased perspective
You need to identify the differences between these books, for once the Quran is much less narrative and less detailed than the bible when it comes to history.
Yes I respect the artistic, cultural, linguistic, historical, scientific and institutional achievements religions have brought to the world even today. However, I am against fundamentalism and when religion gets weaponized.
Having been educated in Argentina as a Catholic, I must say that the metaphorical character of Genesis has been widely accepted for years. And I'm amazed at the resistance I find in the comments.
i’m chilean but same, i honestly thought everyone took the old testament as metaphorical, and that people who took it literally were small minorities. it wasn’t until i started spending more time on the internet that i realised how massive they actually are.
@@v4lentinaaaaa De hecho, tengo la Vta edición de Ediciones Paulinas de la Biblia, traducida en equipo por el Dr. Evaristo Martín Nieto, y en el estudio preliminar aclara que el valor es teológico y no científico (que sí es histórico, pero como la historia de una caída y su redención). Tiene notas al pie esclarecedoras: por ejemplo, sobre Caín y Abel, que según el Genesis eran uno pastor y otro agricultor, dice en la nota que al hagiógrafo no le interesa explicar cómo vivían los primitivos cazadores y recolectores; sino que usa esas profesiones que eran las que el común de la gente podía entender.
I think the anglosphere is pretty toxic as far as properly understanding the world for what it is. This is coming as someone who grew up in rural Canada and still lives there. There is a level of arrogance built into the logic of the culture. This is to say it is essential to the rationalization of our society. It makes it really hard to properly see outside. I'm not trying to excuse it, it is of our own creation so we have only ourselves to blame. But it kind of has to be carried around with you when you are trying to understand the disconnect between the anglosphere and the rest of the world. It's really messed up it feels a bit equivalent to the citizens of Rome in the Italian peninsula as things started to get Shakey in the third century. When it's all you've known and the logic of society says that what you have created is the greatest there ever was conceiving of anything different is almost impossible.
Honestly it’s videos like the ones you make that make me wanna go into theology and mythology, you’re very good at presenting your Information that I wanna keep learning more!
Thanks for this. I'm an atheist, from an evangelical Christian background, and I think your materials are perfectly pitched. If sensible voices like yours weren't out-shouted by the extremists the world would be a much better place. Best wishes ;0)
If you don’t mind my asking…What was it that caused you to turn away from an evangelical Christian background to becoming an atheist? Of course I realize that just because one has a “background” in something, it does not automatically identify him/her as whatever that something is. But, since you’ve identified yourself as an atheist I’m just curious as to how you ended up going in the complete opposite direction?
@@sadiea4381 A long and complicated story - probably too long for TH-cam. Let's see... My decision to allow Jesus into my heart was sincere, but very emotionally based. At the time I was taking drugs. I wanted to believe, but thought Christianity was intellectually bankrupt. Came across some Campus Christians who were using the apoplogetics of Francis Schaeffer, etc., so that "gave me permission" to allow my emotions to dictate. So, foundations were strong but brittle? (Initial evangalism - hey guys Jesus is really cool . Pass joint.) I converted, full of the Holy Spirit and joy, etc. Then got into discipleship, attended an interdenominational Bible School, worked with Youth With A Mission for a year. Always believed all Christians should love each other. Fought against doubt, against my (hetero)sexuality. (Timothy said we should treat women as mothers and sisters.) Noted that a lot of churches spent a lot of time arguing against other churches rather than for the lord. Heard too much false teaching - especially grating to hear "Hebrew" or "Greek" being used to argue against the plain meaning of scripture. Prophecy on the basis of the OT, rather than the New. Anti-intellectualism, anti-science. Biblical hostility to a gay friend that I really just wanted to hug. Left that church for another, and a year later it came out that the pastor of the church I left was using "unorthodox counselling techniques" with female members of the congregation. Managed to hold it together for another three years. Went off to a foreign country to learn the language to prepare to be a missionary. Away from the support of my brothers and sisters, I ... had the time and space to ... think what I really thought, ... feel what I really felt... I started to see how emotionally messed up I was. I had no idea what human beings even were. Over a period of six months, all the god stuff started falling away. Unfortunately, because I was "raised" with Schaefferian absolutes, heading towards a more liberal Christianity didn't seem to be an option. It was all or nothing. So, with knowledge of the fires of hell awaiting me if I chose wrong, I eventually made the decision to utterly renounce god. Hardest thing I've ever done in my life. Over the next few years I read and read and read - anthropology, sociology, psychology, philosophy, neuroscience, counselling. And I made non-Christian friends, and even acquired non-Christian lovers. As a general rule, my life, thirty five plus years on, is now emotionally rich and rewarding, and comfortable. But revisiting the trauma (as here, or in encounters with volubly religious people) is difficult. I am ever so happy to have gotten free, to be able to live my life in kindness to all of good will. Best wishes for your journey.
@@mikeharrison1868 You must be a great wonderful young man, but there is something I want you to know if you have not be able to know it before. Jesus Christ make it clear to everyone who believes in Him, He said Love your God with everything in you and the next is your neighbor. The biggest problem is: how can you love God you don't see but claimed to love others? This lead us to what Jesus Christ said in summary that, once you love others you love God. Been atheist or not doesn't change the facts, the fact is LOVE. But Mr. Mike Harrison, you don't have to run away from Christianity to proof yourself right or wrong, the reason is, in as much Human Beings exist, always expect good or bad. Have a wonderful day. God bless you in Jesus Name, Amen and Amen.
@@davidafolayan5707 Hey dude, I was a Christian from 75 to 86. Young man is totally inappropriate and patronising. I've heard all the arguments. I've thought carefully about them. Not interested in brainwashing myself again.
Historically Doctor meant Teacher (which may explain Luke as a Doctor, rather than a Physician - difficult to follow actually). anyway, one question one of my friends worked on, and I dont know if he succeeded was trying to match the genology timelines of Jesus/David and the Kings of Israel/Judah and the rulers of the immediate eastern civilisations'.
Wow. Incredibly ironic on that one as Saints Ambrose, Augustine, Jerome, Gregory the Great, Thomas Aquinas, etc., etc., even lacked the PhDs (though Aquinas had a Master's), and none had MD's and yet they're all considered Doctors of the Church within Roman Catholic tradition. Face palming and eye rolling, indeed!
This was a great presentation. You are a very good educator. Please keep doing what you do, you respect knowledge and facts, and this is the foundation of any thought, religious or otherwise.
Jew here (yemenite and Ashkenazi) and I love your work, methods, and perspectives. Also very interesting to hear your background as I'm currently stuvk in India waiting for immigration services to resume so my wife and I can return to the promised land (NYC lol)
I greatly applaud the coolheadedness, academic critical thinking, and charisma with which you've presented your bible series, and it's very inspiring to small creators like me. Thank you for making this series as it's a fascinating topic that has gone unexplored in this medium
I applaud your clear statement of your credentials and viewpoint. I've found this series very educational and your professional use of graphics makes much easier to follow. Congratulations and thanks for all your great work.
I appreciate the clarity you bring to really complex and contentious subjects. Your thought processes are as riveting to view as the actual history you describe. Bravo.
As a fellow Jewish convert, I gotta say I love this channel and your videos. You have helped me with understanding history so much better. Thank you. Seeing things generally it has really helped me put things in the right perspective. I ordered three charts and will likely get more soon. Thank you. Bible one will really help me with Torah study
@@jmstouter6572 Oh, my apologies, I see where you are going lol..."Claims" , I made no claims lol, I simply said, He did what Jesus would do. I'm not up with arguing. Have a nice day.
This video legit is the first video I’ve wanted to be able to talk to the presenter and discuss rather than just watch. Very well done, I felt like you were literally talking to me in the same room. Bravo.
I haven't read the other comments, but from one professional historian to another, well said! Just ran into your videos today & have watched a sampling. You're pretty brave to address the Christian Bible to the masses in the first place! I grew up a fanatical Roman Catholic but realized by my teen years that I felt something different - later found the term for it was Humanist. Anyway, when I was a grad assistant at a large US university teaching discussion section in Western Civ I, one of my students asked me one day, "who wrote the Bible?" I didn't know the answer off-hand so I told them I'd get back to them, then asked one of our Medievalists, who told me, "we don't know." So I pass this info along to my class (a little more detailed than that). At the end of the semester, they do their supposedly anonymous instructor evaluations (but by then, you know everyone's handwriting, so it's not *that* anonymous), and I get great evals from every student but one. The guy who asked who wrote the Bible wrote, "doesn't know anything about what she's teaching." To this day, more than 15 years later, idk if he was pissed that I had to consult with a specialist (I'm an Americanist & specialize in Social & Cultural history), or that he didn't like the answer. In any event, I'd like to smack some sense into him. People don't understand what we do, that we study methodology constantly, that we constantly revisit our understanding of the past as our thinking in the present evolves. When our work doesn't fit *their* biases, they call us biased. Anyway, great video, don't know what lot of good it does but if it helps you, cool.
I'm sorry to hear what that student wrote about you in his evaluation... rather distasteful on his part. However, are you still interested in knowing who wrote the Bible?
I don’t often react to videos, but I have to say Matt, the amount of respect you handle and approach all the different opinions : Theïst, Atheïst, scientists, etc. People this is a great example of respect and instead of butchering other opinions, we can als do it the “Matt way”. Thnx for this great example 👍👍👍👍👍
I love this, and I love your channel. I'll be honest, my faith plays a big part in how I interpret the Bible, but I have always been open to all points of view and I value education deeply. Your perspective just strengthens my beliefs. Thank you for being honest, unbiased and scientific about all the topics you cover.
I just found your chanel yesterday, and find it to be extremely informative. I am Roman catholic, hence a Christian and I agree that the Bible is part myth, legend and history. Thank you and blessings.
I'm more than a year late, BUT, I need to say; don't worry about such comments, akin to the ones you've mentioned/read in this video mate. Toxicity is everywhere :/ ;) You're doing a heck of a good job with your trees and videos both, -and as a fellow ...hmm.. family tree maker (by hobby) I can say your job with the trees, is not as easy as some might think. I personally had a bit of headache during my research of the Iberian & Scandinavian monarchs :D (my charts are inspired by yours btw. since I've found this style to be very esthetically apealing)
My favorite comment is the one that “can only assume that you are an atheist....” because Jesus claimed it was historical and that the Jews and Muslims agree. It reminds me of an exchange I had with a coworker a few years back when I worked in a costume shop. We were working on some pieces for a local production of the story of John the Baptist. After a production meeting in which we discussed the story of the play and its characters i.e. John the Baptist, King Herod and Salome etc., one of the stitchers who had been eavesdropping with great interest interjected with the question, “does the Bible tell us what happened to King Herod after that?” To which I replied, “the Bible doesn’t tell us what happened to Herod in the end, but the Roman Histories do”. She looked at me for a while and came back with the follow up question, “but if it doesn’t say so in the Bible, how can we know that it’s true?”. I found this exchange very informative about the world view of bible literalists. They don’t recognize any other written source on the topic of Bible characters and events as legitimate. They also can’t see why anyone would find that suspicious. Like the viewer who made the above mentioned comment who thinks the concept of a belief in God and theology is exclusive to Abrahamic religious tradition, my coworker thinks historic accuracy is a concept exclusive to the Bible. It’s called being brainwashed.
20:53 That's called circular reasoning. "It says so in the bible that it's true, so it must be true!" Astounding that people cannot think things like this through.
While you could say it is a misinterpretation, it is not circular. The New Testament is different set of documents than the Old Testament. The Bible is a collection of numerous books and using one to check another is not necessarily circular as long as the proof for the initial document is not entirely grounded in the other. If one were to prove the reliability of the Gospels and came to believe that Jesus was God, then they may take his words to mean that the Old Testament is literal. Proving the deity of Christ makes this interpretation and option.
You are so wonderfully articulate, thorough and sincere. I enjoy all of your content fully and hearing you speak frankly and as factually precise as possible is such a treat. Thanks for all the great work and grace 😊
Even if their was a chariot wheel found at the bottom of the red sea, how would that prove that a million people walked across the sea bed of water that was literally cut in half?
@@kingdom1872 At the end of the movie Miley convinces this entire town that found out she was Hannah Montana to never mention it again and everyone goes on their merry way
it actually can make sense - according to the story it was very humiliating to eygpt and the pheroh , and according to the story he was very strong headed pheroh- so it makes sense he can order to not write it in the first place
Just got to this one since I've been busy with work, and the segment from roughly 13:00 resonates strongly with what I've been doing. I've been translating a Monica L. Smith's _Cities: The First 6000 Years_ into Chinese, and she goes into great detail in describing what can be inferred from an archaeological dig, and how the process happens. True, archaeology won't hold all the answers, but a large amount of knowledge can be obtained from not just the artifacts recovered, but also from simple observation of the digging environment and how it relates to other sites around the region. Simply from this fact, it is quite clear that biblical descriptions and archaeological evidence don't match, and concrete evidence must call into question any literary accounts or writings that date from much later in history. Thank you for tackling this topic so clearly, directly and honestly.
![กี่หมื่นฟ้า | Your Sky Series EP.1 [2/4]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/qJbQs_nhjD4/mqdefault.jpg)
If you haven't watched the series on the Bible that I'm referring to, it starts here: th-cam.com/video/aLtRR9RgFMg/w-d-xo.html
In the beginning, Usefulcharts created the bible series
This channel puts out so much great, concise and intelligent, neutral information...yet still fools talk smack and criticize? Stay the course SIR! I am gonna buy one or two of your wonderful charts and look forward to continue seeing your informative and fun to learn vids! ^~^ PE@CE THESE "holy" day seasons.
btw...though not a fan of modern "education" systems, I am impressed by your credentials. Well played sirrah.
@@screwthenet I wish I could buy a couple of charts. That's a lie, I wish I could buy them all. Alas, I live with my parents and everything I am interested in that they are not is "childish" (e.i. Video Games that are literally rated R for a reason..., or history charts, or anything political)
I think it'd be really cool if you started another channel that looked into religious studies stuff by the way
No one, mind you no one, has ever done a more professional, humble, and calm approach to critics as this extremely rational, pragmatic and qualified legend here.
I completely agree. I think so many of us are used to seeing very emotional responses to criticism, whereas this is purely an intellectual response. It's very refreshing and I learned a lot watching this.
People in the "european historical arms & armour" cathegory on TH-cam are also really good on answering criticism and changing their views if they are found to be wrong. Some good examples are Shadiversity, scolagladiatora, Tod's Workshop and Metatron.
@the kaiser If you disagree with something please first of all say what it is you're disagreeing with and secondly state your counter arguments.
I mean I'd call him a rational, pragmatic and qualified myth, but whatever
Also him being a theologian made this really great lmao
This is the most polite and kind, “I know wtf I’m talking about, check the credentials.” I’ve ever heard. I do love this channel for exactly that.
He doesn't know what he is talking about.
@@historian252 let me guess, you do?
@@historian252 multiple degrees, careers and experience in the field would say otherwise.
@@bethaniw7640 Yes.
@@bethaniw7640 Those degrees mean nothing.
I'm 8 minutes in and I need to stop and comment.
From the bottom of my B.A. in General History and my M.A. in the Study of Religion, can I just offer a massive standing ovation for presenting the process of source analysis so beautifully, calmly, and rationally?
That was the most polite mic drop I have heard in a while.
Exactly!!! I couldn’t help but chuckle at the polite slap to the cheek. 🤣
His reply is a work of art! So much respect and admiration for this man. ❤️
Those who have the most knowledge never need to turn up the volume.
I agree. This video was excellent in both its acceptance of other cultures and beliefs, but also shows how some people just can't reasonably argue and debate while at the same time use evidence and truth. I love this channel
What a flex 🙏🤣🤣🤣
Good Job, I believe that you did a professional job in touching these issues.
ikr, some people are so easily riled up
Agree
I cannot agree enough with this.
I read this as Good Job, of the Book of Job 😅
@@davidstenow5055 Same lol
Catholic here: I LOVE your work, and you have contributed greatly to my own research in making a very detailed “inspiration chronology” Bible-reading plan. Thanks so much for your hard work!
Well there's a whole bunch of them and you can even print your own if you want to be a real catholic
@@adaptercrash What do you mean by that?
@@adaptercrash You need to take into account that the catolich church has changed a lot since the 17th century
@@Lucas-yf1es yeah we use to go to church, I shouldn't have to I'm not severe catholic only limited by its very own downfalls
I'm an orthodox christian, and I agree with almost everything you said in the series so far and even if I did not It’s still a great series
I like this series but I prefer septuagint numbers than Masoretic personally
that’s cool! what kind of orthodox church are you? i am greek orthodox
@@iamnotachickennugget7655 I'm serbian orthodox
@@djordjejaric3214 Im as well an Serbian orthodox christian but i'm more of agnostic i'm only culturally christian because Serbian national identity is deeply tied with orthodox christianity.
Orthodox Christianity is a very respectable and deep tradition, I think. Free from literalism and full of interesting symbols, philosophy and stories. (I'm an atheist but interested in church art.)
As a devout Christian, I have to say that this has been one of the most interesting and informative series on religion I have ever seen. It's nice to see an unbiased take on the subject for once.
It’s not unbiased though
Indeed. As a OLD (not by birth age) fashioned Christian I like to see the level approach. Scripture is 🔆SACRED🔆 Historical records📜(not accurate per se but must be rigidly accepted when concerning spiritual matters of it)
@@jstrick85 it really is though. It sees both sides and concludes one is very lacking in comperison of the other, which is a very fair conclusion to make
@@kfiraltberger552 No, his bias is a part of everything he says, the difference is that he tells you what his bias is for you to take into account.
@@NPC-bs3pm ..excuse me, but if you are going to use a Latin phrase please don't apply 'per say, but ''per se' which is Latin for “in itself”, “as itself”. I must add that I'm bemused that a person will recognise inaccuracy, but still abide 'rigidly' by the tenets of a religion. Where is the full understanding between you and God with this sort of thinking?
Wonderfully clear explanations! Side note: I've started to think that those who call others "atheist" often don't seem to know what that word means. I suspect that for many, it just means something like "bad person" or "you don't believe in MY god, so you're an atheist."
Precisely, they assume atheists are contrarians by nature and refuse to acknowledge all the valid reasons such an ideological position could exist.
Sadly, there are just as many on the atheist side who will describe literalist or ludicrous theology, in order to mock how absurd it would be for anyone to believe such rubbish. It's not a helpful way to debate anything. We need to learn to listen and to respect, even where we think we are in complete disagreement.
interestingly, the same did the roman pagan wen the early christian didnt believe in theirs.
I think they mean as another way to say "you must be ANTI-religion", as atheists are always depicted as hateful bigots who hate religion and anything and anyone associated with it, which is of course not accurate.
Matt, let me just say that I have my personal beliefs, and your videos have not compromised this. You are personable, professional and a delight to follow!
I've "disagreed" with some biblical theories or comments you've made but I've always respected your learned presentation. People should learn to gut up and deal. If i see or hear something i question or disagree with, i research it, ask questions or i ignore it. Folks, that's called adulting. That said, I didn't know you were a Jewish convert. I will say i always assumed you were agnostic. I just never cared because, as even you say, this is a history channel, not a religion one.
I second this comment. Well said.
Yeah I’ve rarely heard of many people converting to Judaism, from what I understand it’s a long hard process. It sounds like he did it to join the same religion as his wife, but I wonder if it’s just a cultural thing or if he actually believes in the Judaic god as his form of “theism”
@@LordJagd you do realize that the Jewish God is the same as the Christian God and also Allah of the Muslims, right? All three are Abrahamic religions and all three consider Abraham as the patriarch of their faith and that all of them are descendants of said Abraham.
@@RachaelMarieNewport They're claimed to be the same god by the religions themselves, but to be honest there's a lot of huge differences between those three gods, especially between Islam and the others - god in Islam asks for things and says things that the god of Christianity wouldn't. Also, in Christianity most people think that Christ was also god, so that's a fundamental difference between the Christian and Judaic gods.
@@LordJagd I didn't say there were no differences between the 3, in fact there are massive differences in each branch, especially in Christianity. All three have an extremely fundamentalist and uber conservative sect or sects in them, all 3 have more moderate and liberal sects as well. The church where I was baptized was originally part of the Church of Christ, but split with them in the 1800s over wanting to include the organ and other musical instruments in their services and became known as Disciples of Christ to differentiate them from Church of Christ. Which is not the same as Church of God which is very popular in the Southern US. Also radically different from the church I belonged to and the interdisciplinary college group I was a member of after I graduated from high school. Both were fundamentalist and conservative. The church was an Assembly of God church which is Pentecostal. The group was led by a young couple who pushed the Evangelical message and believed in the literal truth of the Bible.
My mom was raised as Christian Scientist and then converted to Episcopalian church (US version of the Anglican church). I have relatives who are Catholic as we all as many other Cristian sects. I have family members who are agnostic or atheist. Some like me turned to non Abrahamic religions. I became Pagan myself.
Yes converting to Judaism is a lengthy and difficult process because they unlike Christianity and Islam do not proselytize and make it clear you have to seriously want to join them. Learning Hebrew is only part of the process. And if you are in a country that doesn't practice infant circumcision as a matter of course like the US until the mid 80s, you have to undergo adult circumcision at least traditionally since it was part of the covenant.
In fact one of the controversial issues in the early Christian church was over whether Gentiles had to be circumcised and follow a kosher diet. Much of what Paul did to increase numbers in his travels was to say Gentiles did not have to do those things. Later many Westrrn counties adopted circumcision as a public health issue and it was pretty routine in them until recently. My son who was born in the US in 1987, and we were asked and his dad said to go ahead. I am not sure if I would make the same decision today. Muslims also practice infant circumcision.
I'm an Episcopal priest and got my early seminary education in the 1950s. How I wish I had had your charts available then. As one who takes the Bible seriously, It is refreshing to hear of your work to make Holy Scripture meaningful by putting religious writing in its historical setting without presenting it as literal reportage. Bravo!
If you really want something to blow your mind, you could learn about the rest of the ancient Near East which surrounded and interacted with the ancient Jewish writers of the biblical scrolls.
Once you really understand ancient Egypt, the Phonecians, Ugarit, Sumeria, Akkad, Babylon, Assyria and the Hittites - the religions, history and literature - the Bible looks incredibly different.
Just beware of the pseudohistory and pseudo-archeology. Sadly, many of them come from Protestant backgrounds (though usually FAR more evangelical and fundamentalist than Anglicans like yourself.) I forget his name but there was even one guy who claimed to have found Noah's ark on Mount Ararat, but when you look at his "evidence" he's essentially looking at rock in the same way children fantasize seeing images in clouds. Lol.
Just a suggestion. I have to imagine someone from your denomination with a serious seminary degree would find all kinds of interesting things in the ancient history of the Near East to be interested in.
This video was very well-presented and well-executed. It might sound a bit strange, but this is probably one of my favorite videos on your channel just because of the personal connections you made to your own life and research; this really helped strengthen your claim. Excellent job!
Thanks. I know you've been watching for a long time so that means a lot 🙂
One of my new favourites too!
Agree. And I would definitely read or listen to Matt’s autobiography. What an interesting life and thanks for sharing it with us.
As a muslim I personally enjoy these videos as they shed alot of light on the subject of interpreting holy texts like the bible, torah or the quran. Please do not get discouraged by these fundamentalists.
I found your comment inspiring, as I haven't heard such comments from muslims before.
@@rogerwilco2 you could have but they weren’t addressing their religion
Fundamentalists? The Quran Is the word of Allah, how could any Muslim not believe in it 100%?
@@aldamon Progressive Muslims maybe? I don't fully understand it either, but maybe that's the future for Islam to make it more palatable to the modern western world.
@@hullie7529 not now, not ever my man, what wasn't part of the religion when it first came will never be a part of it and is not a part of it today, there have been many innovators in the past and they all failed and ended up in the dust bin of history, thanks to our scholars shouting from the mountain tops and warning against them. ;)
I came from a background that taught that the Bible is 100% the “Word Of God” and is more literal than Legend. I did my own research and have changed my mind about Biblical Literature but, it has increased my belief, not caused me to disregard the Bible. Thanks you Matt for your dedication because it’s people like you that calms the choppy waters of religion…. Jim from Napa, California
I wouldn't discount Ron Wyatts discoveries as a hoax and selling snake oil. The word of god has been passed to us and is literal, as well as some metaphorical - like you would normally describe something or compare things. The bible is itself the Word of God.. the same Word that lives in us all... Don't disregard that.. it is one of the most sacred parts of the bible and the belief in the living creator. Check out Ron Wyatt yourself - dig deep like he has - I would put him above this guy who ultimate seeks proof and confirmation from peer reviews.. and worst still , THE MEDIA???? 😭
So how do you get around bristlecone pines being older than the flood by 1,000 years since the fake genealogies of Jesus were printed on trees, after the same people put Jesus to death on them...
Can I compost you or are an abomination in a box waiting for your forever box and eternal separation from the ground your God cursed you to care for in this life... Since a living sacrifice to the voice in the garden and the tree of wife might require you put borrowed shit back respectfully where you borrowed it from disrespectfully.
🌋 🌲 🍄 🐿️💥!
How did your belief increase after learning that the "historical" events of the Old Testament are just myths and legends? As an example, a video in this channel deems the book of Exodus and the character of Moses as simply mythology. However, if a Christian believes in Jesus, Moses is "historically" real because Jesus speaks about being with him. Therefore, in what area did your belief increase?
@@iamafan7492just because a story isn't true doesn't mean it's not worth hearing.
@@iamafan7492 Usefulcharts answers your question in video : some stories are better, more useful, more inspiring, and more profound when they are symbolic rather than historical
Matt, I want to be you when I grow up
(No seriously, I’m currently finishing my BA in history and anthropology with a focus in religious social reformation, and I’m hoping to go on to my MA and PhD. Thank you for inspiring me for all these years)
Awww, thank you!
I am a devout Christian, and I enjoy this series. I appreciate the format in which you present your information. It is nice, too, to hear your personal connection to the subject matter.
Love your channel. You truly offer a fresh voice.
My only criticism isn't even your fault. But since watching your videos TH-cam has been recommending me a bunch of worship resource videos and Christian apologist videos.
It's okay, you're worth it!
Haha. Sorry about that!
@@UsefulCharts No problem. That Bible Unearthed is a great book btw.
Love from Tasmania!
The best thing you said here was probably “those aren’t the only two choices”. That’s true for so many situations, I wish more ppl would understand that.
Even if the religious texts have a kernel of truth when it comes to human nature and society, the central premise of a deity with transcendent attributes falls flat on its face. When looking at the texts from an objective perspective using reason and science proving it’s falsity, the grand claims in it in my opinion dismisses the entirety of it
Especially in politics
Yes religious videos particularly Judaism, Christianity and Islam is very difficult to do because of opposition by literalists. But I do recommend your courageous yet calm approach
@@TJCampbell78 Yep. From what I've heard, the political spectrum used to be well, a spectrum.
This is such a useful teaching phrase. Seriously.
4:20 lol it's like you've spent your entire life preparing to crush this comment and many similar to this. Quite impressive!
Haha.
Hahahahah.
@@UsefulCharts this was the moment you (metaphorically) took our your Oxford annotated NRSV, your three diplomas and your entire childhood memoirs and dropped them along with the mic. (politely)
🙇🎤⛪📚 🎤 💣💥
This was at best, the most kind but very impactful read I have ever witnessed! This just reminded me, that when facts are involved there’s no need to reciprocate the given energy! I love your work by the way ✨
“That’s DR. UsefulCharts to you”
Tell that to Joseph Epstein at the _Wall Street Journal_ .
LMAO
"You dont know anything about Religion"
*Drops 2 degrees, a career, and 30+ years of experience worth of religious papers on the haters*
Unfortunately, the vast majority of those that agree with the comment have never actually read the bible. Polls asking Christians if they have read the entire bible vary between 10 and 20 percent responding, yes.
@@jedgar63 They may fear they would become atheist. It happened to me actually. I was raised as a Christian, devoutly believed, then started to think, read the bible, got out.
@@jedgar63 strictly speaking you don't have to read the Bible to be a follower of Jesus Christ. Plus majority of ppl throughout human history were illiterate
@@kalyptro123 I have been an atheist for most of my adult life, because religion seemed to be an oversimplification of an extremely complex reality. Five years ago I decided to read the entire bible. If I hadn't been an atheist before I read the bible, I would have been one afterwards. But I also found it extremely interesting, and the bible, combined with a general interest of ancient history, has been the main subject that I personally study. It includes the bible, the history of the bible, and the history and mythology of Christianity, of Israel and Judaism, and the history and mythologies of the Romans. Greeks, Mesopotamians, Egyptians, etc. Just because I, and others, do not have a degree, does not mean we are not highly knowledgeable on the subjects. But then, I don't claim to be an expert, or misrepresent myself as one. I am learning for my own sake, not to satisfy others.
@Carlos Adrián Aguirre some people says human at least if not being full blown cynical must at least having faith on something, doesn't matter it's God, religion, love partner, family, friends etc with out that a person can be depressed.
I am an atheist. And I don't care if you are a theist or not. You do a great job. And you are extremely fair and accurate in your approach.
I like using people like you as an example to militant atheists (those that think anything to do with religion is wrong) as an example that you can believe in a god and still do great history.
Thank you.
Church of Satan atheists (atheists who think anyone who believes in a deity is insane) are some of the worst to encounter as a more liberal atheist. They will literally blow up over someone commenting "God bless you" or "Amen", and will say you're not a "true atheist" for defending people just minding their own business. They're the hyper literalist evangelicals of the atheist world. Thanks for coming to my TEDTalk
Can I ask what moved you to become an atheist? Or what turned you away from religion?
@@colinpierre3441 For me, it's a long story. Deconverting isn't just one Eureka! moment that completely destroys our faith. It's a slow burn that eventually bursts into a rejection of faith. I eventually saw scientific explanations as being more logical than superstitious ones, so I stopped believing.
@@colinpierre3441 Hi, sorry it took so long to reply. I was raised nonreligious. I learned about Greek, Roman and Norse gods before I ever heard of the Christian god. Religion just never came up much growing up.
However, when I was older I gave it more thought. Many of my friends believed in a god. So I studied religion.
The weird thing is that, while I never believe in a god. I was superstitious. I believed in psychic's etc. That is because I had no tools to tell the difference. One day I picked up a Skeptical Inquirer magazine. It gave me the tools to discern the difference between science and pseudoscience. And I used those tools to look at religion. Plus, I have a background in history and mythology.
Sorry for the length. If you would like more information, let me know. This is the short version.
Good luck and keep up the good work.
@@humbaba55 It's no problem, I myself am very busy at times so I don't mind waiting a day or 2 to receive a response... this topic deals with our very purpose of existence, so it is something worth waiting to hear. I have done quite some research on atheism myself even though I am a Christian, because we always need to keep searching for truth and considering new information as time progresses.
It's interesting that you believed in psychic's, although I do admit that there are some strange things that humans are able to pull off at times that I can't find a good explanation of how it was possible. In any event, I stay clear of most religions because they are riddled with corruption and hypocrisy. However, I do believe in the Bible and how it harmonizes with historical findings and accounts. So the question I would like to ask you is have you ever read the Bible and do you think it is a morally beneficial book?
This is the most polite smack down I have ever seen.
This man is tranquility incarnated. He literally sat down for (at least) half an hour and told everyone in the most polite way possible why they are wrong to dismiss his video and kept his cool even though clearly the amount of work needed make these vids is clearly too monumental for some dude online to go BULLSHIT.
This channel was such a great find!
I usually comment on music. This presentation was very informative whether you are very tradional or liberal in your beliefs. It is good and correct to be open to other concepts of anything in life if you respect your brain's ability to function. Bruce Meredith.
Funny you should say that he’s tranquility incarnate- I use his videos to help me fall asleep- not because they’re boring! Far from it! he just has a soothing voice and cadence 😊
I can’t believe that you had to explain all of this. I studied some of the Old Testament 20+ years ago at uni, and your analysis of the verbal traditions was what we learnt then. Love your work!
I’m delighted that you’ve chosen to share your years of education and immersion with us. Thank you for allowing us to benefit from your expertise!
Most polite rebuttal of TH-cam comments ever, you must be Canadian. As a half-Canadian theist, I loved it!
🇨🇦🇨🇦🇨🇦
@@UsefulCharts oh shit you are? Cool
".....half-canadian theist...."????????????
@@lobstered_blue-lobster im guessing that means that one of their parents immirgrated from Canada and the other did not
@@translarrybutz I heard that in Canada people non-whites don't refer to themselves as Irish-Canadians/Black-Canadians/Fillipino-Canadians etc. They also refer to themselves as *Canadians.*Pretty sure he is reffering to that just as you said now that I re-read it. I originally thought he was indicating he was half-theist and half-atheist which is...you know.
I’m Christian and a physician and I am such a fan of your work! I think those who are religious need to treat historical analysis as a science- it can be used in many ways, sometimes “helpful” and other times surprisingly in relation to your beliefs. Thank you for all your work!
the way intelligent people make their cases is just so refreshing to watch. great job, no wonder you have a phd!
Best part is point long out the idiocy of saying you're not ”qualified”. Never judge someone’s qualifications, you’re usually wrong.
r/dontyouknowwhoiam/
IKR? It’s like, “Boom”!
That person, if he/she watched this, maybe surprised because he/she just found out about Matt's profession.
they just got owned, i would've been so embarrassed.
When people care more about the credentials than the quality of the work produced it becomes problematic. The reverse is also problematic. Useful charts is a great example of quality work by someone qualified to do so and sources to back up his claims
My daughter and I are impressed with your responses. We have been thoroughly enjoying watching these series you present and your other videos, and we look forward to continuing to see your work. Thank you very much.
Speaking as an Orthodox Jew here: while I believe in the Hebrew Bible, in terms of knowledge, you’re using the terms “myth,” “legend,” and “history” correctly.
I do not know whether the Bible is real, and in terms of the scientific method, the standard you’re using is perfectly correct. Don’t listen to the haters.
I'm not sure if science is the method here. It's certainly empirically sound, but I think experimentation is required.
Ooo Matt over here flexing on everyone with his degrees and his way around the world/religious-non religious beliefs. Great job
I literally clapped when he brought up his PhD. XD
@@stephanieho6162 exactly
@@stephanieho6162 My reaction too lol. But I was mostly surprised that there is a field of "Psychology of Religion". Makes perfect sense when you think about it, but it was unfamiliar to me.
Useful Charts brought RECEIPTS!
@@PeterP_ the psychology of religion. The research field that dare not speak its name (within proximity of a church.)
I've had students flinch when I mentioned its existence. And I'm not even exaggerating.
You are absolutely my go-to source for comparing time along with events and persons. Nothing short of a fantastic job. Thank you, young man.
I love it when you can whip out the "Actually.... I am an expert. Here's my PhD." Keep up the great work!
@@mustafaali3333-q1m I say, "Flex away." It's fun to school people who make assumptions from time to time. I enjoy flexing mine when trolls like to school me on public policy and politics.
love this channel. I also sometimes watch another channel who doesn't have a degree, but he has read all the religious texts, and also the Nag Hamadi, Targums of Palestine, Emerald Tablet of Thoth, Gospel of the Holy Twelve, Essene Gospel of Peace and more, as well as historical documents from the time. I know I'll never be able to read all of these and study with anyone, so it's interesting to be sure.
It's a credit to him that he has been so objective on this subject that people thought he was an atheist. Typically when a abrahamic theist speaks on this subjects it's quite clear that their believes are affecting their argumentation.
I'm a minister.. your channel is great..
@Ousmaila Bouba I'm a Supreme Minister
@@bl00dhoney okay so basically, I’m monkey.
@@AaTagPag congratulations
To many people, including ministers, the bible is not literal history. It is about the messages in the bible, and the theology; a combination of parable, allegory, moral teachings, and history.
I’m palpatine. Do it!
I attended a Bible literalist Christian school for 14 years from age 4 to 18. I didn’t know half of the stories in the Bible let alone which ones had a touch of history and which were pure fiction until I started watching this channel. I officially denounced my faith two years ago and from then on I’ve been learning more about the faith I left then I ever knew while I was still practicing. This channel has instilled in me a sort of respect for the Bible not as an unquestionable moral guide but rather for what it is, an excellent look at the evolution of ideas and values from a group of peoples that still exists today. Thank you for helping me develop a healthy respect for the Bible and for religion as a whole instead of the blind hatred many others succumb to.
so sorry to hear that maddie - it’s a shame that people teaching the bible with poor biblical literacy has pushed you away from the faith. i urge you to look up Michael Heiser either on youtube or listen to his Naked Bible podcast on spotify/apple. Heiser is a very knowledgeable Old Testament scholar who both regularly interacts with modern biblical criticism / scholarship yet also has a pragmatic view of the faith. He is a very smart christian man who doesn’t just blindly believe. It’s a shame that there are many christians who cannot answer the concerns of doubters, who then eventually get pushed away. God bless you sister.
Other options on youtube are Testify and InspiringPhilosophy. Each show their sources throughout all their claims, so it's easy to go fact checking them. And they're clear on what claims are archeological vs reason/logical (not sure the term).
Great that you are now learning more about the christian faith. Now I would challenge you to pick up the Bible itself and go through it Genesis to Revelations.
You'll learn plenty more than on this channel!
It's quite a fascinating document, from a historical, political, and cultural standpoint. Unfortunately, religions generally discourage people from looking at the actual historical, political, and cultural standpoints.
I was raised atheist and hold very deep atheist beliefs, but I've recently started interacting more with various theist friends and I'm trying to better understand how they approach the world -- why certain things that seem blatantly obvious from an atheist point of view may look much different to someone who was raised differently. This channel has been immensely helpful, because it clearly separates scientific/historical facts from myth, legend, and faith.
I’m seeing a lot of “as a Christian...” and “as a Muslim...” comments, so my turn : as a secular humanist and atheist (yes, the a-word 😱) I was very impressed by your scholarly approach and unbiased presentation of the varying biblical myths and legends. As a nonbeliever, you made me feel included in a discussion a lot of people think atheists shouldn’t be involved in, even though we are *very* much affected by religion and its influence on, well... everything. So thank you very much, and keep up the amazing work.
I am also a humanist and atheist. What you said was what i was thinking, just more eloquent.
Ironically, the word “atheist” appears on a lot of UsefulCharts’ comment sections more than “Christian” or “Muslim”
Marxism also affects me and it does not work anyway but people still shill it.
Why did you say the A-word bro. I am disgusted, dishonoured and trembling with anger. How dare you.
myth legend and historical
As a practicing Catholic, I thought that your series was a very well done.
In the end, the important aspects of the Bible are the messages it teaches (Loving God, loving thy neighbor, etc).
That is correct but the problem lies with those who believe in 100% literal Bible interpretation. It is impossible to change their minds, and if presented with evidence that disproves their theories (i.e, the age of earth or dinosaur fossils) they simply discount the scientific qnd archeological evidence because for them "faith" trumps all.
To me the Bible is meant to serve as a guide to being good, through stories, and legends, that kinda snuggly fit into history, which is sweet.
I think many difficulties come from how far back the events of the Old Testament go.
But As a Pentecostal, I believe that the New Testament has concrete historical evidence to back up the events described. But each to their own, every individual is free to believe in the things they want too.
@@senpainoticeme9675 God claims to be the truth so if young earth is false the only thing that tells me is the story wasn't literal I don't know why so many people have a problem with that.
Your work is inspiring. Please don't stop. Also in this video, your calmness and intelligence and how clearly articulate, is what I and my kids aspire to be.
You crushed this. Watching your videos has really provided me stable ground through my questions about my faith. This might be my favorite video on the channel so far.
The fact people have the audacity to literally say “You are uneducated in this matter” is baffling to me, who are you to decide that?? You cannot take everything you read or write as literal, at the end of the day all religions are correct in some way and the only way to dispel any would be if you literally lived during that time or in the after life. Anyways thank you for the video!
Because that’s the favorite catchword here on the internet. ‘Uneducated”. If you don’t agree with somebody, or have a different opinion, you’re “uneducated”. They LOVE that word. And considering some the grammar/spelling they use, I find it amusing.
It is what religion does to you.
Having watched both your Bible series and this one, I gotta say that it is REFRESHING to find someone who discusses the Bible and it's stories in an academic fashion. I grew up in the southern United States, which is HEAVILY Christian. The sort of Christian where the Bible is the world of God, and everything in it is the literal truth. I love religious studies, but couldn't actually take courses in it in college because of those Christians. It would have been like going to church, which is the last thing I wanted to deal with. I left Christianity long ago because American Christians want me dead. So I greatly appreciate the historical look at the stories of the Bible and the people it talks about. Thank you for all the work you do.
I did not expect you to look like Jack Black.
I dont think Jack Black expected to look like Jack Black either.
He’s shown his face before
Sounds like him, too!
A surprise, to be sure, but a welcome one.
Reminder that all these people were Jack Black
I’m a Jew, and I agree. You did a great job presenting this information.
Fellow Jew, and I agree. I ended up buying the biblical chart from his site for Torah study to keep lineages straight. Lol. I love his channel and how he has presented this
You are clear, concise, have removed what might considered getting too far into the weeds ... and, above all, are comprehensible in historical and literary matters, that would otherwise remain arcane and boring the average viewer. Even your relaxed approach and somewhat matter-of-fact style lend themselves your appeal and your impressive number of subscribers. You are a superb teacher, in every sense of the words, and the perfect example of how relaying information in an educational way on You Tube can help so many comprehend subject matter they might otherwise neglect to take notice. And your practical visual aids add so much to your spoken words, and our understanding. Thank you for your dedication, hard work and passion for teaching. Most appreciated.
Thanks, Matt! As a theist who follows Jesus with both his intellect and faith fully engaged, I appreciate the thoughtful, well reasoned analysis and interpretation you offer here. As someone who shares in some of the same religious and cultural history as you, I’m really proud of all the work you do!👊🏼
i had a conversation with my mom a couple of months ago where i said something about not understanding the bible entirely literally and she started getting a little snippy about it until i was like.. well do you believe the earth is 5000 years old or do you believe it's billions of years old? she said billions of years and i was like well see you don't believe everything in the bible is literal either. i kind of think it blew her mind. she'd just never even considered it.
YES and as I learned with my dad who is a devout Christian IN seminary, you’re correct in that many just doNOT consider these things! :)
@Stratis Georgilis what punctuation is there to be added...? Also Eminem has punctuation just not in the correct positions.
each day of the lords is a 1000 years.when you multiply 6,868 of the Jewish calendar you get a far more reasonable numbet,the book I read said it adds up to 4.5 billion years, sorry I read the book 20 years ago some details r fuzzy think its psalm 92
@@dffndjdjd Well that's intense
at least your mother believes the earth is billions of years old
Having been brought up as a Christian, I was also brought up to believe that the Bible was a mix of myth, legend, and history. Learned that in Sunday school as a kid.
What church did you go to? Lucky...
@@glasscardproductions4736 I grew up in the Episcopal church and I'm still a member.
@@markballard9942, ah. Makes more sense.
I was raised a Presbyterian. I was also taught that the bible was a mix. I was taught that logic supercedes literalism as the proper hermeneutics.
@@alankent perhaps they’ve just been more successfully infiltrated. And infiltration doesn’t happen with things that aren’t important enough to someone else who knows the truth, and wants to make sure no one else does.
As an agnostic I actually wanna thank you for making be reconsider the value the Bible and Quran and provided to human history.
Personally I am agnostic to, But I’ve recently been getting into some religious and spiritual stuff because I think that even though they are myths and legends they can still hold value as long as you look at them from an unbiased perspective
You need to identify the differences between these books, for once the Quran is much less narrative and less detailed than the bible when it comes to history.
Yes I respect the artistic, cultural, linguistic, historical, scientific and institutional achievements religions have brought to the world even today. However, I am against fundamentalism and when religion gets weaponized.
Having been educated in Argentina as a Catholic, I must say that the metaphorical character of Genesis has been widely accepted for years. And I'm amazed at the resistance I find in the comments.
i’m chilean but same, i honestly thought everyone took the old testament as metaphorical, and that people who took it literally were small minorities. it wasn’t until i started spending more time on the internet that i realised how massive they actually are.
@@v4lentinaaaaa De hecho, tengo la Vta edición de Ediciones Paulinas de la Biblia, traducida en equipo por el Dr. Evaristo Martín Nieto, y en el estudio preliminar aclara que el valor es teológico y no científico (que sí es histórico, pero como la historia de una caída y su redención). Tiene notas al pie esclarecedoras: por ejemplo, sobre Caín y Abel, que según el Genesis eran uno pastor y otro agricultor, dice en la nota que al hagiógrafo no le interesa explicar cómo vivían los primitivos cazadores y recolectores; sino que usa esas profesiones que eran las que el común de la gente podía entender.
Those commenters are mostly american protestants mostly evangelicals fundamentalists, Seeing the bible as literary.
I think the anglosphere is pretty toxic as far as properly understanding the world for what it is. This is coming as someone who grew up in rural Canada and still lives there. There is a level of arrogance built into the logic of the culture. This is to say it is essential to the rationalization of our society. It makes it really hard to properly see outside.
I'm not trying to excuse it, it is of our own creation so we have only ourselves to blame. But it kind of has to be carried around with you when you are trying to understand the disconnect between the anglosphere and the rest of the world. It's really messed up it feels a bit equivalent to the citizens of Rome in the Italian peninsula as things started to get Shakey in the third century. When it's all you've known and the logic of society says that what you have created is the greatest there ever was conceiving of anything different is almost impossible.
@@kmills2554 It's not even the Anglosphere, it really is--with exceptions like Ken Ham--Americans and only Americans.
Honestly it’s videos like the ones you make that make me wanna go into theology and mythology, you’re very good at presenting your Information that I wanna keep learning more!
That was the most eloquent and patient way to say ✨deal with it 😎✨ bravo. I've binged watched so many of your videos.
Dang, that "you are not qualified" remark really backfired!
You are exactly the type of religious person I wish we had more of. Bless you and keep up the good work!
As an agnostic and a lover of anthropology and history, I truly appreciate your channel. Keep up the very good work you do!
Thanks for this. I'm an atheist, from an evangelical Christian background, and I think your materials are perfectly pitched. If sensible voices like yours weren't out-shouted by the extremists the world would be a much better place. Best wishes ;0)
I couldn't agree more!
If you don’t mind my asking…What was it that caused you to turn away from an evangelical Christian background to becoming an atheist?
Of course I realize that just because one has a “background” in something, it does not automatically identify him/her as whatever that something is.
But, since you’ve identified yourself as an atheist I’m just curious as to how you ended up going in the complete opposite direction?
@@sadiea4381 A long and complicated story - probably too long for TH-cam. Let's see...
My decision to allow Jesus into my heart was sincere, but very emotionally based. At the time I was taking drugs. I wanted to believe, but thought Christianity was intellectually bankrupt. Came across some Campus Christians who were using the apoplogetics of Francis Schaeffer, etc., so that "gave me permission" to allow my emotions to dictate. So, foundations were strong but brittle? (Initial evangalism - hey guys Jesus is really cool . Pass joint.)
I converted, full of the Holy Spirit and joy, etc. Then got into discipleship, attended an interdenominational Bible School, worked with Youth With A Mission for a year. Always believed all Christians should love each other.
Fought against doubt, against my (hetero)sexuality. (Timothy said we should treat women as mothers and sisters.) Noted that a lot of churches spent a lot of time arguing against other churches rather than for the lord. Heard too much false teaching - especially grating to hear "Hebrew" or "Greek" being used to argue against the plain meaning of scripture. Prophecy on the basis of the OT, rather than the New. Anti-intellectualism, anti-science. Biblical hostility to a gay friend that I really just wanted to hug. Left that church for another, and a year later it came out that the pastor of the church I left was using "unorthodox counselling techniques" with female members of the congregation. Managed to hold it together for another three years. Went off to a foreign country to learn the language to prepare to be a missionary. Away from the support of my brothers and sisters, I ... had the time and space to ... think what I really thought, ... feel what I really felt...
I started to see how emotionally messed up I was. I had no idea what human beings even were. Over a period of six months, all the god stuff started falling away. Unfortunately, because I was "raised" with Schaefferian absolutes, heading towards a more liberal Christianity didn't seem to be an option. It was all or nothing. So, with knowledge of the fires of hell awaiting me if I chose wrong, I eventually made the decision to utterly renounce god. Hardest thing I've ever done in my life.
Over the next few years I read and read and read - anthropology, sociology, psychology, philosophy, neuroscience, counselling. And I made non-Christian friends, and even acquired non-Christian lovers.
As a general rule, my life, thirty five plus years on, is now emotionally rich and rewarding, and comfortable. But revisiting the trauma (as here, or in encounters with volubly religious people) is difficult. I am ever so happy to have gotten free, to be able to live my life in kindness to all of good will.
Best wishes for your journey.
@@mikeharrison1868 You must be a great wonderful young man, but there is something I want you to know if you have not be able to know it before. Jesus Christ make it clear to everyone who believes in Him, He said Love your God with everything in you and the next is your neighbor. The biggest problem is: how can you love God you don't see but claimed to love others? This lead us to what Jesus Christ said in summary that, once you love others you love God. Been atheist or not doesn't change the facts, the fact is LOVE. But Mr. Mike Harrison, you don't have to run away from Christianity to proof yourself right or wrong, the reason is, in as much Human Beings exist, always expect good or bad. Have a wonderful day. God bless you in Jesus Name, Amen and Amen.
@@davidafolayan5707 Hey dude, I was a Christian from 75 to 86. Young man is totally inappropriate and patronising. I've heard all the arguments. I've thought carefully about them. Not interested in brainwashing myself again.
You are so patient and generous with your time...an example to all of us...I would never be able to do it!
Then there is my friend who said "Just because they have a PhD doesn't make them a real doctor". Face palming, eye rolling true story.
Historically Doctor meant Teacher (which may explain Luke as a Doctor, rather than a Physician - difficult to follow actually). anyway, one question one of my friends worked on, and I dont know if he succeeded was trying to match the genology timelines of Jesus/David and the Kings of Israel/Judah and the rulers of the immediate eastern civilisations'.
Wow. Incredibly ironic on that one as Saints Ambrose, Augustine, Jerome, Gregory the Great, Thomas Aquinas, etc., etc., even lacked the PhDs (though Aquinas had a Master's), and none had MD's and yet they're all considered Doctors of the Church within Roman Catholic tradition. Face palming and eye rolling, indeed!
This has got to be the most beautifully executed mic-drop to anyone questioning your credentials and credibility I have ever seen.
Well done! Keep up the good work. This will truly help many who are looking for answers and enjoy what historic and anthropological facts can tell us.
This was a great presentation. You are a very good educator. Please keep doing what you do, you respect knowledge and facts, and this is the foundation of any thought, religious or otherwise.
Jew here (yemenite and Ashkenazi) and I love your work, methods, and perspectives. Also very interesting to hear your background as I'm currently stuvk in India waiting for immigration services to resume so my wife and I can return to the promised land (NYC lol)
Well said sir !, and right on the mark. Your actually a breath of fresh air to anyone with an open mind for just the facts.
I greatly applaud the coolheadedness, academic critical thinking, and charisma with which you've presented your bible series, and it's very inspiring to small creators like me. Thank you for making this series as it's a fascinating topic that has gone unexplored in this medium
Wasn’t expecting to see you here
Awesome job man. Your doing a great service to the world tbh.
I applaud your clear statement of your credentials and viewpoint. I've found this series very educational and your professional use of graphics makes much easier to follow. Congratulations and thanks for all your great work.
I appreciate the clarity you bring to really complex and contentious subjects. Your thought processes are as riveting to view as the actual history you describe. Bravo.
As a fellow Jewish convert, I gotta say I love this channel and your videos. You have helped me with understanding history so much better. Thank you. Seeing things generally it has really helped me put things in the right perspective.
I ordered three charts and will likely get more soon. Thank you. Bible one will really help me with Torah study
Thank you for being so professional about it. I find it discrediting when people treat disrespectful comments with equal or more disrespect.
as a christian, i'm loving the series, keep it up :)
Same! I love learning about history :)
Your crushing of the ignorant whilst being totally kind and understanding of them is glorious.
that's how Jesus would have handled it.
@@pastcolours citing a Person you don’t believe in?
@@jmstouter6572 Who doesn't believe in who ?
@@pastcolours are you claiming to have a literal belief in Jesus Christ?
@@jmstouter6572 Oh, my apologies, I see where you are going lol..."Claims" , I made no claims lol, I simply said, He did what Jesus would do. I'm not up with arguing. Have a nice day.
I find your channel thoughtful and I think it adds to my personal bible study and understanding
of other denominations.
This video legit is the first video I’ve wanted to be able to talk to the presenter and discuss rather than just watch. Very well done, I felt like you were literally talking to me in the same room. Bravo.
I haven't read the other comments, but from one professional historian to another, well said! Just ran into your videos today & have watched a sampling. You're pretty brave to address the Christian Bible to the masses in the first place! I grew up a fanatical Roman Catholic but realized by my teen years that I felt something different - later found the term for it was Humanist. Anyway, when I was a grad assistant at a large US university teaching discussion section in Western Civ I, one of my students asked me one day, "who wrote the Bible?" I didn't know the answer off-hand so I told them I'd get back to them, then asked one of our Medievalists, who told me, "we don't know." So I pass this info along to my class (a little more detailed than that). At the end of the semester, they do their supposedly anonymous instructor evaluations (but by then, you know everyone's handwriting, so it's not *that* anonymous), and I get great evals from every student but one. The guy who asked who wrote the Bible wrote, "doesn't know anything about what she's teaching." To this day, more than 15 years later, idk if he was pissed that I had to consult with a specialist (I'm an Americanist & specialize in Social & Cultural history), or that he didn't like the answer. In any event, I'd like to smack some sense into him. People don't understand what we do, that we study methodology constantly, that we constantly revisit our understanding of the past as our thinking in the present evolves. When our work doesn't fit *their* biases, they call us biased. Anyway, great video, don't know what lot of good it does but if it helps you, cool.
I'm sorry to hear what that student wrote about you in his evaluation... rather distasteful on his part. However, are you still interested in knowing who wrote the Bible?
You are the truth definition of kind, empathetic and considerate. Thank You for being different
One of the best videos you’ve ever made imo, absolutely captivating to hear you speak about your area of expertise so eloquently!
I'm a Methodist Christian and I find your video absolutely amazing. Not only the content, but you have a Gift of communication. Congratulations 👏
I don’t often react to videos, but I have to say Matt, the amount of respect you handle and approach all the different opinions : Theïst, Atheïst, scientists, etc. People this is a great example of respect and instead of butchering other opinions, we can als do it the “Matt way”.
Thnx for this great example 👍👍👍👍👍
It’s alway so mind-boggling to see TH-camrs that otherwise you just hear
Really like your channel btw
I love this, and I love your channel.
I'll be honest, my faith plays a big part in how I interpret the Bible, but I have always been open to all points of view and I value education deeply. Your perspective just strengthens my beliefs. Thank you for being honest, unbiased and scientific about all the topics you cover.
Thank you for creating this channel. I'm excited to have found a reliable source of infomation on various topics.
I think you have done a great job on this series and I applaud the manner in which you have presented it.
I really enjoy your educated and well-prepared presentations.
I just found your chanel yesterday, and find it to be extremely informative. I am Roman catholic, hence a Christian and I agree that the Bible is part myth, legend and history. Thank you and blessings.
I'm more than a year late, BUT, I need to say; don't worry about such comments, akin to the ones you've mentioned/read in this video mate. Toxicity is everywhere :/ ;)
You're doing a heck of a good job with your trees and videos both,
-and as a fellow ...hmm.. family tree maker (by hobby) I can say your job with the trees, is not as easy as some might think.
I personally had a bit of headache during my research of the Iberian & Scandinavian monarchs :D
(my charts are inspired by yours btw. since I've found this style to be very esthetically apealing)
I’m so happy that you made this video. I also agree on your view of myth, legend and history.
I think you have one of the most grounded interpretations of History that anyone could hope to have.
My favorite comment is the one that “can only assume that you are an atheist....” because Jesus claimed it was historical and that the Jews and Muslims agree.
It reminds me of an exchange I had with a coworker a few years back when I worked in a costume shop. We were working on some pieces for a local production of the story of John the Baptist. After a production meeting in which we discussed the story of the play and its characters i.e. John the Baptist, King Herod and Salome etc., one of the stitchers who had been eavesdropping with great interest interjected with the question, “does the Bible tell
us what happened to King Herod after that?” To which I replied, “the Bible doesn’t tell us what happened to Herod in the end, but the Roman Histories do”. She looked at me for a while and came back with the follow up question, “but if it doesn’t say so in the Bible, how can we know that it’s true?”.
I found this exchange very informative about the world view of bible literalists. They don’t recognize any other written source on the topic of Bible characters and events as legitimate. They also can’t see why anyone would find that suspicious. Like the viewer who made the above mentioned comment who thinks the concept of a belief in God and theology is exclusive to Abrahamic religious tradition, my coworker thinks historic accuracy is a concept exclusive to the Bible.
It’s called being brainwashed.
20:53
That's called circular reasoning. "It says so in the bible that it's true, so it must be true!"
Astounding that people cannot think things like this through.
While you could say it is a misinterpretation, it is not circular. The New Testament is different set of documents than the Old Testament. The Bible is a collection of numerous books and using one to check another is not necessarily circular as long as the proof for the initial document is not entirely grounded in the other. If one were to prove the reliability of the Gospels and came to believe that Jesus was God, then they may take his words to mean that the Old Testament is literal. Proving the deity of Christ makes this interpretation and option.
Its not circular reasoning actually, I am a muslim, and if you accept Bible comes from God, and God is truthful, all he says is true.
You are so wonderfully articulate, thorough and sincere. I enjoy all of your content fully and hearing you speak frankly and as factually precise as possible is such a treat. Thanks for all the great work and grace 😊
Even if their was a chariot wheel found at the bottom of the red sea, how would that prove that a million people walked across the sea bed of water that was literally cut in half?
They really thought that ancient Egypt pulled a Hannah Montana movie and just collectively decided to never mention the Exodus
Omg Hannah Montana 😭😂 I love this comment so much
What was missing in Hanna Montana movie?
@@kingdom1872 At the end of the movie Miley convinces this entire town that found out she was Hannah Montana to never mention it again and everyone goes on their merry way
it actually can make sense - according to the story it was very humiliating to eygpt and the pheroh , and according to the story he was very strong headed pheroh- so it makes sense he can order to not write it in the first place
@@polpol2739 yes but literally everyone else could still write about. It’s not like other people aren’t going to run into 2 million travelers.
You handled these questions with incredible poise. I’m not sure I could have done that without my emotions becoming involved. Good job.
Just got to this one since I've been busy with work, and the segment from roughly 13:00 resonates strongly with what I've been doing. I've been translating a Monica L. Smith's _Cities: The First 6000 Years_ into Chinese, and she goes into great detail in describing what can be inferred from an archaeological dig, and how the process happens. True, archaeology won't hold all the answers, but a large amount of knowledge can be obtained from not just the artifacts recovered, but also from simple observation of the digging environment and how it relates to other sites around the region. Simply from this fact, it is quite clear that biblical descriptions and archaeological evidence don't match, and concrete evidence must call into question any literary accounts or writings that date from much later in history. Thank you for tackling this topic so clearly, directly and honestly.
This really made me reconsider how i view bible and my own bias within, so thank you i find your content very useful
No explanation needed. But, geez it was interesting to hear your story. Thanks for posting.