Join The Wire's TH-cam Membership and get exclusive content, member-only emojis, live interaction with The Wire's founders, editors and reporters and much more. Memberships to The Wire Crew start at Rs 89/month. th-cam.com/channels/hWtJey46brNr7qHQpN6KLQ.htmljoin
India's Modi-led BJP Government's Foreign Policy Paralysis in Afghanistan - kindly watch this video till the very end in order to get your perspective right. th-cam.com/video/PyQQPqwIryo/w-d-xo.html
My dear it is called "Baajwa Doctrine" that is why we have extended his job in Pakistan. However India has also extended the services of "Bipin Rawat" although in different form but what have been achieved? As regard Iran & Taliban relations both are now under control of China the new superpower therefore India will not be able to gain anything with this issue. Finally India is totally out from Iran as well as Afghanistan.
Brother many time as he mentioned our diplomat are very intelligent they already planned something else., that is very important which is actually pointing the recent situation., the question is why indian denying to meeting talaban even American asking them for that and American leaving mysteriously more over afghan surrender without any clashing., I feel some thing strange going on in near future., as japan suffered in-past may Allah safe our beloved country and Afghanistan by evils
For now it's happy time for you and Pakistan. It's a blunder by USA. Next 10 years will decide pakistan fate. You are powering China. One day pakistan will be kicked by them. Are Iran and Afghanistan (Taliban) said we don't work with India. Assuring you world never spare you.
I'm not sure you heard the interview right through. Katju is concerned about Pakistan influencing the Taliban to launch jehad against India via LeT and Jaish (or their modern variants).
They didnt discuss most important topic of salma dam, where India has spent $3 billion even when the economy was struggling. Now taliban might take it over amd destrioy.
@Amjad Hussain Did we tell you what ideology to follow ? Did we object you to follow Islamic ideology ? Hope you are wise enough to get my hint. India and Indian population including Indian Muslims know what is best for them.
@@independentnationalist1740 tera baap hosakta hai Modi... Don't talk on behalf of everyone.. If he was such a great leader the relationship with Bangladesh,srilanka,nepal,China and afghanistan is in jeopardy... Considering pakistan perennial enemy...
@Vilas Tamhane My hero is not Rahul/Pappu and no one can stop Islam. For your information Islam is the fastest growing religion in the world,please read the basic of Islam on your own it will help your knowledge.
India's Modi-led BJP Government's Foreign Policy Paralysis in Afghanistan - kindly watch this video till the very end in order to get your perspective right. th-cam.com/video/PyQQPqwIryo/w-d-xo.html
Yes..complex thing like donating your own land to China saying nothing grows there...Aur padhao bhai diplomacy ke baar main...we are very much interested..
Since last 7 years our foreign policy has been influenced by anti Muslim agenda in the mindset of the government. We cozied up with china with the perception that xi jingping is anti Muslim, we failed, because that was not the case, then we cozied up with trump assuming that he was anti Muslim, failed again, then in the Armenia / Azerbaijan we were supporting Armenia again failed, we r over zealous with Israel, because of the same mind set, not realising that it will fail again, we r angering Iran, who has been our ally, we get cheap oil there, we cozied up with Saudi/ UAE, not realising that they don’t matter due to the economical benefit to Ambani probably, then we r on and off relation with Iran, not realising that Saudi/ UAE has issues with Iran. We r not handling turkey well, not realising after 2023 they might become a major player, then we will fall into the same situation as we r in with taliban. The government has to realise that foreign affairs is not about anti Muslim agenda, it’s totally what is benefit for us. Let’s see how many more corners we force ourselves into. Foreign policy is no close friends with anyone, enemy of non, maintaining middle part. We r being used by the 3 in the quad to fight against china, for them. We should fight our own battle.
@Amjad Hussain No we aren’t isolated.But Pakistan is isolated. India is 3 trillion economy with 1.3 billion people.And no country has ability to ignore us. You are living in fool paradise.
@@thewitcher8658 It isn’t hunger it is called "upbash" in Sanskrit and fasting in english. We are committing fasting for empowered our government and military. You can see country like Switzerland,Netherland,Norway and canda whose people aren’t hungry but no country take seriously them.Even China whose average people are poor but terming "trudeau" as d0g.😂😂 So, it is sacrifice of our people for country.
I think the stand taken by the government for building Hindu Rashtra is standing as a hurdle to talk directly to the Taliban because their stand in home land is against the Muslims and their rhetoric has been against the Taliban . I think talking directly to Taliban may erode their vote bank too. Foreseeing, American leaving Afghanistan, the language of RSS chief also changed and his statement on Muslims was a surprise to many hardcore Hindus.
Diplomacy is the art of dealing with people in a sensitive and tactful way. It appears from the interview that we have not kept diplomatic channels open with Talibans and have been pushed in a situation where we have very little say in dealing with present Afgan situation.
@@we_the_people_of_kashmir3534 India is India and we do not meddle into others affairs. If some one tries to do in our affairs , we are capable to teach the lessons .
Come on guys be brave and admit that it was the close minded-ness of the BJP regime which has been able to use the Hindu card through the systemic biased propaganda against the Muslims and given itself the position to lead your nation. Talking to the Taliban would mean that trash their anti Muslim card.
@@trunner5220 was expecting some modibhakt, servant could only think of being servant. Seriously pray that modi becomes prime Minister atleast 2 more time then amit shah for 2 times and ajit deal or sorry Doval you maasi ka beeta should remain as advisor for all these term you will see more tiger zinda hai, Lomri zinda hai and till chipkali zinda hai ... enjoy just took care of you next generation as well trunner if you like I can vomit on you but then there is not point why would you vomit on shit
The Ambassador is bang on target that India is a flyweight bystander in his assessment of Indian Afghan policy. Indian foreign policy is formulated by a bunch of amateurs who have no capacity for a serious policy strategy that is not coloured by innate and entrenched bias. Is it any wonder that is is now being boxed out on every front.
I think bottom line of the discussion is it's no more time of oppression so resolve Kashmir conflict through dialogue. 2. Arrogance makes you dumb not letting you see and think real life so India has closed itself in a box with there own great values while the same are not even practiced in India. 3. When tide changes friends become foes and foes become friends so chosing the right boat takes one to your destination. India again made bad decision by going with US when Asian century is starting hence again will face loss. I think ambassador explained it better in quotes and you competing the sentence
@@Manish_Kumar_Singh sometimes you share a part and are given right on whole. India has been missing the point since independence, read through the historical facts about how Germany wanted to become a power in Europe WWI and than WWII not succeeded than the politics cal way creating EU now today all Europe is behind Germany. same is the case of USSR trying to reach hot waters through force failed now is being offered to reach the same port of Gawadar.
Insha Allah Next project for Talibaan is Indian Occupied Kashmir. We kashmiris fully support them. Insha Allah it will be a big loss for india here in kashmir.
@@FunnyandDelightful HOW RISHIS WERE CREATED? According to the Hindu Holy books, God Brahma arranged the marriage of god Shiva to goddess Parvathi. When they went around the fire as per Hindu religious ritual, god Shiva looked at the thighs of goddess Parvathi and ejaculated his semen into the Fire and they became Rishis (priests). According to the Hindu Puranas this "god" can do such a filthy act!
Hats off to Mr. Vivek Katju jee, for being so truthful about the real situation and India's negligent stance, When World was busy on the negotiating table, India was busy sabotage these negotiations
My dear Indian friends these types of things happens when you have a narrow minded person siting in govt. When his top priority is to manage his local politics using any mean like Hindu Muslim then how he could think that much broader, which you are expecting from him. if he would've talked to Taliban then what would happens to his 56 inch ki chati narrative. And one more thing this was surprise no 1 by Modi ji. Now surprise number 2 is on the way from Kashmir due to his historic blunder. We Pakistan's thanks Mr Modi from our deepest heart ❤️.
Kashmir🤣🤣🤣. Tum bikhari marte dum tak kashmir chilate rehna. 4 war bhi lad liye . Aur har gaye kuch na le paye. Kashmir karte karte Bangladesh kho diya aisa na balochistan kho do.
And I think it was Pakistan who lost their more than 40,000 soldiers fighting taliban. So America used you . The joke is on you 🤣🤣🤣 . Plus it was a twin group of taliban who attacked APS school in peshawar and killed 140 children. If you keep snakes in your backyard one day it will bite you
Why india want to talk to taliban when taliban said we will not allow anyone to use afghan soil against pakistan. Indian investment on Baloch and TTP terrorists is going in vain. Recents terrorist attacks india used Dubai for handling. India has nothing in afghanistan , when india cant do terrorism . Modi is right in approach
Its not that Indian diplomacy failed to establish contact with taliban but taliban delibrately ignored Indian advancements to keep them out of loop and stratigically disadvantaged. Who knows who prompted Taliban to play it that way China or Pak or both time will tell.
Thank u Karan for conducting this interview with Vivek a very able diplomat , incidentally it gave me a great pleasure to see my old classmate from Allahabad,saint josephs'collegiate. Look forward to ur interviews in the offing.
@Amjad Hussain India never even sent their army to afghanistan. We were their to help people. You were the one who were sending terrorists in afghanistan supporting taliban
" I have great respect for our team in charge of the Afghanistan-Pakistan policy" Sir, do you have respect for the Ajeet Dowal and akin, Mr. ambassador, as well? And were you not a member of that policy, that you are dissociating from that now?
Why India is hoping be involved in Afghanistan at all? You borders don't meet and your cultures as well. Is it only to counter Pak & China? Also if you are thinking to deal with the devil (Taliban) then why not have good relations with Pakistan (lesser evil in India's perception)
The Prime Minister has not made any Press Conference from his first day till now. It shows how efficient and clear he is not to face press and reply the questions. Why is he doing it? Why is he not facing the Press?
चुनावी भाषणबाजी, अक्षय कुमार छाप स्क्रिप्टेड ईन्टरव्यु शूट या 'मन की बकवास' करवा लो इनसे..! लाईव प्रेस कॉन्फरंस में जवाब देने के लिए पहले कुछ काम करना भी तो जरुरी है..!!😀😁
India - We don't talk with terrorists ( Afghan Taliban ) , We support Asraf ghani govt. India - We can talk with Afghan Taliban, everything is possible in geopolitics . Conclusion - India is terrified about Pakistan, Afghanistan & China nexus (Most importantly about JIHAD)
India wants the world to see it as a global power. However, it was not even invited to discuss the Afghanistan issues. That shows that India is not even regarded as a regional power in its own region. Afghanistan is a saarc country and a south Asia country.
Nobody seems to be answering the elephant in the room, that by not astutely dealing with the Taliban and with the Afghanistan government, we have sealed the last nail in the coffin of what may become the global hotspot for breeding international terror. And with the abrogation of article 370, the hate mongering in these camps may just have reached it's highest decibel.
@@SS-kg8qw The impeding force to the last nail of the coffin could have been evaded by tactical wisdom. It's the futile belief that wisdom is vested only in the PMO's office and not with groomed bureaucrats that is a cause of concern.
@@danielraju4458 When the wise men of Nagpur has decided that the enemy is within and not outside the border, that nailed the coffin. Don't give much credit to the buffoon in Delhi, he's just a scare crow, the real power is vested with Nagpur fundamentalists
@@SS-kg8qw How are they going to understand global foreign policy? I greatly fear for the future of our country, with adversaries surrounding us from the west to the east and the north.
@sameer rush Stop this cancer of polarization based on religion. This is an age of Science, just because my folks gave me a Christian name doesn't mean I'm not a patriot. I'm Indian and I care deeply for the future of our nation, in fact, like Vivekananda put it, I care for the destiny of this nation. When you have a barbaric tribe surrounding you on all three frontiers, and you have no neighboring allies(the Russians won't come), then what would India do? War cries won't help, the gods won't come down, Mahabharata won't ne replayed. It will be catastrophe, since the enemy too have sophisticated weapons, the best logistical supply chain and lethal men who don't mind dying in the name of religion. Be rational, be scientific, then be a nationalist because if you loose your brain to Deshbhakti and sing your bhajans to your heroes, then one day, the enemy will attack and snatch even your basic livelihood.
There is no relevance of India in Afghanistan. I don't know why they are discussing what india should do in Afghanistan. Totally non sense efforts to do something in a country which strongly fought against almost all great powers of the world like russia, America, nato, Australia, Poland, canada, England and many more. Then what india can do something which will benefit India in Afghanistan. India better to call back its citizens to India as all western nations calling their citizen back. I don't know who india is trying to fool - Afghan government which will be non existent in near future, Taliban whom no one can defeat, indian citizen who constantly fed lies or government itself.
@Vilas Tamhane After America's shameful and humiliating defeat at the hands of taliban despite being super power is enough to reject your claim that America will not allow Taliban to succeed. but the contrary is more truer that it is Taliban that not only would not allow America but can defeat America again if again America make the mistake of reentering Afghanistan. Remember popular line that Afghanistan is grave yard of empires. Another truth is more badder to hear that Taliban not only defeat America (the super power) but Taliban defeat all major powers of the whole world like nato, England, Poland, Australia, Germany, france who all were station in Afghanistan but all ran like a coward rat. Now you just reason out that if major power failed to defeat Taliban then what India has which will make India to keep its feet on the land of Afghanistan. Just think. I don't need to elaborate.
Pakistan lost 40,000 soldiers and 102billion dollar fighting taliban on direction of America. The joke is on you. India built dam and roads and infrastructure to help them. India not send madrsachapp jihadis to fight in other countries
What to do?! There are no good options for India. But the interlocutors are right. Modi is utterly clueless about India's national interests concerning the unfolding Afghanistan situation. Worse, in this context, the removing of Art. 370 in Kashmir looks to be a disastrous move.
Modi is NOT utterly clueless. The Govt knows more than you what should or should not be done. AND Kashmir is NOT a disastrous move unless you are a coward.
Absolutely someone who is a staunch nationalist from jammu. I want to say that removal of art 370 is single largest anti india act done by parliament of india.
@@littlebral9899 Thanks bro 🤜for understanding the disastrous implications of abrogating Art. 370. Modi has turned India 🇮🇳into a magnet 🧲for Jihad (already Jihadis are ranting and foaming about Ghazwa-i-Hind). Worse, India doesn't have any real friends in the West and possible Russia also might abandon Modi-India (think of the inoperable Indian military hardware of Russian origin, if that happens).
Article 370 was disastrous. A million people displaced.. around 3lakhs family. We were already at Loss with Article 370, no gains in reducing Terrorism. Also there was no equal human rights.
@@manidwivedi5880 Since Modi is so dependent on Russian 🇷🇺military hardware, then how is he different from Nehru and the Gandhi-Congess continuity of India's foreign policy?!? In the 7 years (since 2014) since Modi became PM I expected a massive order of 250-300 American 🇺🇸 F-16s so that today the IAF 🇮🇳 could provide sustained and comprehensive air-support to insert 2-3 lacs Indian Army and ground forces in Afghanistan, to take over from the Americans/NATO/ISAF forces there. This would have aligned India's interests with America completely and ensured a permanent seat 💺in the UN Security Council as a reward. Also India would be in a strong position to recover PoK. All this is not far fetched, because Modi has displayed tremendous resolution in abrogating Art. 370 on Kashmir with alacrity. But instead, Modi has managed to procure a paltry 24 Rafales (out of a meagre 36) in last 7 years. With the Manmohan government India would have had 126 Rafales by now (the original deal). Besides, the Congress govt. saw through the delivery of 272 Su-30 MKIs, the backbone of the IAF today.
Of course no logic to our (Modi)policy , only whims and fancies of Hindu extremism policy come in way of having diplomatic relations with Taliban. Other major reason could be American Ghulam-Modi-Shah India
Tell me a name of country with which present government has improved relationship with in their tenure. All modi's foreign visits went down the drain They spoiled relationships with their own citizens as well as other countries
Perhaps more fundamental than anything Mr. Katju said is that does any Indian understand how did Taliban defeat NATO. They bombed Afghanistan to stone age but the Afghans defeated them with stones.
Look at the map and you will realize how PHYSICALLY boxed in India is. Their own "Belt and Road" working with Ashraf Ghani is going to be dead. And now, it is sending its navy to the South China Sea inviting danger from the north. Amazing.
Recently, the Taliban spokesman said that they are grateful to India for investing in the development of Afghanistan. But the narrow-minded Hindutva ideology did not permit us to build relationships with the Taliban like we did the blunder of saying " apke bar trump sarkar ".
Our policy was 'there can be no good taliban and bad taliban meaning all talibsns are bad taliban' so for this haughtiness on the part of indian govt we will have to pay heavy price becas in afghanistan now majir players are pakistan china russia and iran all have become anti indian.
Ambassador Katju a recent report by Brown University in US has disclosed that the number of American casualties is 30177 soldiers and the amount of money wasted between five and six trillion dollars.
When your whole foreign policy is based on attacking your tiny neighbour you will always be left to pick up crumbs. Plus theres no need for cheap labour in afghanistan so not much for you guys to worry.
India's Afghan policy is based on a single aim and that is to box in Pakistan. Which is not possible when Taliban are in power so India is just not interested in talking to them. India isn't trying to help the Afghan people nor to make their lives better. And the Afghan officials have milked India to their content by capitalizing on India's Pakistan centric policy.
These two dont know anything 56D chess is being played by our world best spy NSA and best foreign minister of all planet,,with the blessing of supreme leader
there are revelations abt him going on btw he is one of the biggest useless spy lol faltu ka james bond he is... dude spies dont showed up themselves in public and claim it... who knows putin himself is an agent you never know... yes they do exist pr aese faltu me claim nhi krte h...
India with its Hu=indutva ideology has become like Pakistan. A state portraying one particular religion. How can with citizenship act offering to hindus and sikhs of afghanistan, can India seriously talk to 180 d opposite extremist muslim mindset. Another point is they r still trying to pop up the Ghani regime
Because partition was based on hindu Muslim, it was supposed all Muslims will go to pakistan, and all hindu to India, but this could not happen, because how can you leave India at peace, when mindset is ghazwa e hind, no Muslim country besides India is reproducing so fast, mentality of outnumber hindu, I am ex Muslim, I know deep
India: Sorry You lost the War. Your investment gone in waste . Don't act more foolishly and Stop brutality in Kashmir otherwise will face embarrassment in Kashmir as well.
India, s foreign policy was caught napping at Afghanistan not because it was left in the dust.. In the fast moving Doha Diplomacy.. And in not anticipating the Taliban Violence.. The failure of not gauging a China outsmarting India was never expected at Afghanistan.. We lost our invested capital..
India's Modi-led BJP Government's Foreign Policy Paralysis in Afghanistan - kindly watch this video till the very end in order to get your perspective right. th-cam.com/video/PyQQPqwIryo/w-d-xo.html
@iqbal Not semi-literate but complete illiterate and only working to become a man of history, a hero of india who in reality did nothing for india, other than making few gujratis more richer and maing all people poor who are from middle class to extreme poor who in future will do nothing but suicide.
Why, modi is not harming me. If I will not support him then there will be a collision government in india which is not good for my mother land. Ask your beloved congress to throw out Gandhi family bring back leaders like jyotiraditya sidhya. I will vote for them My legions is with my country I don't believe in politics and all this crap. I replied this moron because they hate bjp not because of any policy only religion. I can challenge that thi MC doesn't know A of foreign policy and India's challanges in Afghanistan but he commented on because of Hate.
11:18 "I don't like the word mistakes in diplomacy because you make judgememnts on the basis of......" Basically translates to : "I was a diplomat & hence we don't make mistakes. Also I'm not courageous enough to criticize the current regime." 🤡🤡
what an intellectual meaningful conversation .Very impressive insights more people like this should be in Indian politics .. Educated , intellectual and balanced
We were seeing this coming. We have a great stake. We cannot be in peace when our neighbours are in trouble. We had played a major role earlier. We cannot take sides. And also we cannot be a by stander too. Opening up talks with Taliban will have impact in local politics so we are muted and boxed. Keep your self Flexible is the best policy as Katju Sir says. But today the speed at which Taliban is emerging, it is a Present and Clear Danger for us.
@@chaqeb7681 When there is disturbances in the neighbourhood it is going to affect us as neighbours. These disturbances may be used by groups, which will impact us.
@@parthibank2736 you are right, india will suffer if Afghanistan fall under Taliban even everyone, every country in the world will suffer ,but reality is they are a major power in afghanistan .With out talking them how can india save interest there?
@@parthibank2736 your current government has only one ideology that no talks to opposition, Kashmiri huriyat calls for talks your govt put them in jail now even non huriyat leaders asking for dialogue with pakistan but your government has it's own ideology ,but keep remember if you have your own strict ideology then others also has ,why you can't control militants in kashmir because they have jihad concept ,no ideology in world is wrong but balance is best thing ,if you take action and don't expect reaction then what we can do?If you don't talk taliban and bound to your own ideology and also condemned them and use harsh language against them ,try to sanction them UNSC but still you expect they will not retaliate, they will give answer to modi ,sooner or later.
this time Talibans may danger or not it is in our govt hands but Bjp is spoiled diplomatic relations with surrounding Countries and deviding people in cast line n religious line for their servival then how cum country progress
A delightful interview. Two civilized gentlemen discussing a foreign policy and security issue of great international significance dispassionately and wisely. If only men and women of such foresight were responsible for deciding affairs of countries and the world. America's exit from Afghanistan and India (suddenly) looking irrelevant in the Afghan situation shows that neither application of huge military power nor infusion of vast economic resources are sufficient to decide issues of national sovereignty or international relationships. India has made tremendous, by and large successful, efforts to become a world class military power. But that has not made her an advanced modern country. If utilized sensibly, it's very large population, very rich culture, great agricultural and industrial potential and other factors of history, geography etc. can make it a great country, a country which is not feared but respected and loved by its neighbours and the world at large. But that will require men and women of calibre and perception of Mr. Thapar and Mr. Katju to be in positions of decision making.
@@zakirali8721 pakistan, a failed state. A terriorists sponser country. Next time, pakistan will be put in the Black list of FATF. Are not you people proud for this?
An valuable discussion that from now on will be discussed more and more. It’s mind boggling why India has preferred to place all its eggs in the USA basket and even more egged in the Ghani basket that was never strong. This is shocking..
India will have to pay great costs for the civilan and economic damage it caused to Pakistan via terrorism and funding of NDS and Criminal proxies via Afghanistan. "IT KNOWS ITS FATE VERY WELL WHAT WILL BE THE OUTCOME AND COST OF STAYING AND ENGAGING FURTHER IN AFGHANISTAN..HENCE THE SILENCE"
Good to hear the Word Mujahideen from His Excellency mouth while referring events of 1980s…..why the same lot being termed by Indian Media as terrorists…..
What a great experience to enhance from such great intelligent gentlemen. Exposing the wisdom of our present so called wise men handling the future of India.
Very good discussion and impressive thoughts of Mr Kaatju! However, the real India has to first dealt with its very visible Hindutva policy which is restricting to progress with good diplomacy with Taalibaan and even with Pakistan.
The cost you pay for 'trying' to keep LOC is huge. 300+ Indian troops have left the planet in your last bollywood adventure. When you can talk to Izrael the biggest of all why not talk to balsy villagers.
@@shsaeed6818 not left the planet they are martyrs, say directly you want Kashmir to pakistan By the way who the hell are you, when army men happily doing their duty
@@shsaeed6818 then Pakistan army must leave pok, it's the first step of UN resolution, 1st step is to taken from pakistan. Recently on election there dissidence appeared, 2 kashmiri was shot dead during clash with Pakistan army, even 1 mla Ismail gujjar go to extent to seek help from India, this is not godi media propoganda, you can go through bbc
I think the answer to Katju's puzzled "for some odd reason," "somehow," we didn't make contact with Taliban is quite obvious. It's because in the Indian mind the Taliban are too overly conflated with Pakistan, so India either considered it futile to talk to a Pakistani "proxy" and/or thought it would dangerously expose it to Pakistani manipulation and derision while also alienating its Kabul govt allies.
India is obsessed with Pakistan more than their intention of peace in Afghanistan. Even Taliban dont truly accept stance of Pakistan, otherwise there wont have been US on the ground as they would have accepted to give up on Al Qaeda.
What I don’t I understand is that there are major riots going on against Rohinga Muslims, why they are also , who need help as they are India immediate neighbor and can absorb this much population easily, or can put pressure on Mia mar to behave in better republic way , if India wants to do humanitarian activities
@Lion Warrior khushal shay zema sher khana rora ,pe yo paragraph ke dey da semay toll hall um bayan kere o che se rah rawan di hagai na dey hum khabara Krum . Os bes khushala shum, che dase Safah nazer rurna larum. Da dey na pes khuday dey Khasmir hum Azad Kari ,Ameen ze ba weum che da khudai sengai pe mung dasi merabhanashu. 🌹🍀🔥
Our country has stood for two things democracy and women rights. It was Indias key role that military junta of Myanmar came under global pressure. Our ranking in women rights as 145 out of 155 countries is in itself a psychological pressure on Taliban. These two forces make the taliban scare of India
Afghan taliban has said they wish India not even think about entering Afghanistan military as consequences will be fatal but also they are coming to liberate the Kashmiris
Didn't admit any mistake in the entire 36-minute chat The entire 36-minute interview was revolving between 3 or4 questions Only and only time has been sung for 36 minutes
My question is that if according to this former ambassador it's in the strategic interest of india to talk with Taliban the why not talk to leaders of Indian Occupied Kashmir?? You consider them Indians so why don't you talk to them? 2nd question is wth is Indias interest in Afghanistan other then sabotaging Pakistan and supporting terrorism in Pakistan?
India/modi is in the usa pocket, USA regards Taliban as untouchable. This paralyzes India, who may see the. Insanity of not dealing with Taliban as the master of Afghanistan. When India/modi chose to be USA spear-carrier against prc, this is a foreseeable consequence. You must live with it.
Dear Mr. Thapar please consider changing the sound track that precedes your program and played during the breaks. It is very loud and not pleasant to hear.
Only one concerned and preoccupied with Afghanistan is Wire itself. India can never be friend with Taliban. Kowtowing to Taliban for friendship will actually send wrong signal to the world. India is not a major player in Afghanistan. The only spectacle Wire wants to see is Modi beseeching Taliban for friendship and then mock Modi.
Oh we get it, that is why message should be sent to Taliban and their puppet master that any trouble in India or holding Indian citizens hostage will invite a disproportionate response across the LOC and IB.
@@taimurmughal78 Oh am sure the genocidal TSPA is straining at the leash to push even more terrorists across the LOC & IB because a leopard cannot change its spots. I hope our Govt has given a message to GHQ about disproportionate response. The clue was in PM Modi's Independence day speech :).
@@Mork2001 yes keep on crying no one cares. We are focus on establishment of regional peace and trade routes via CPEC. We know how to deal with Fascist Modi and his hateful agenda. Remember Feb 19..Tea was fantastic!! 😂
@@taimurmughal78 How are the Chinese workers in Gwadar doing? You had to return him within 48 hours while 93000 genocidal TSPA troops were POW in India for more than a year. Surrender was by a Niazi in 1971 and now another Niazi is the puppet PM of the genocidal TSPA.
Mr Karan Ambassador Katju is very diplomatic in his statement about the failure of Indian Afghan policy. Ambassador Katju will never acknowledge the mistake because he was trained to be cautious in usage of words. I humbly submit that in my opinion the Indian Afghan Policy was not left to the external affairs department. It was hijacked by the National Security department.
India's Modi-led BJP Government's Foreign Policy Paralysis in Afghanistan - kindly watch this video till the very end in order to get your perspective right. th-cam.com/video/PyQQPqwIryo/w-d-xo.html
Join The Wire's TH-cam Membership and get exclusive content, member-only emojis, live interaction with The Wire's founders, editors and reporters and much more. Memberships to The Wire Crew start at Rs 89/month. th-cam.com/channels/hWtJey46brNr7qHQpN6KLQ.htmljoin
²
Now RSS Backed BJP buerocracy Discuss and creat relationship with ISI Backed ISLAMIC AMIRAT OF AFGANISTAN 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
India's Modi-led BJP Government's Foreign Policy Paralysis in Afghanistan - kindly watch this video till the very end in order to get your perspective right.
th-cam.com/video/PyQQPqwIryo/w-d-xo.html
@@_ku_fu th-cam.com/video/fTx3Wm0fFUw/w-d-xo.html
@@digamberkalgutkar9794 aaaaa me
My dear it is called "Baajwa Doctrine" that is why we have extended his job in Pakistan. However India has also extended the services of "Bipin Rawat" although in different form but what have been achieved? As regard Iran & Taliban relations both are now under control of China the new superpower therefore India will not be able to gain anything with this issue. Finally India is totally out from Iran as well as Afghanistan.
👍
Intellectusl in india and their views
All are below vote takingfor....
Brother many time as he mentioned our diplomat are very intelligent they already planned something else., that is very important which is actually pointing the recent situation., the question is why indian denying to meeting talaban even American asking them for that and American leaving mysteriously more over afghan surrender without any clashing.,
I feel some thing strange going on in near future., as japan suffered in-past may Allah safe our beloved country and Afghanistan by evils
For now it's happy time for you and Pakistan. It's a blunder by USA. Next 10 years will decide pakistan fate. You are powering China. One day pakistan will be kicked by them. Are Iran and Afghanistan (Taliban) said we don't work with India. Assuring you world never spare you.
@@Ashokathegreat8699 lol - anything else? 🤣
Bottom line of this video ...
India's Afghan honeymoon is over.
How did u come up with this example?
Yup....you nailed it right on the head
@Ali Mujhtaba it'll happen only after Taliban destroys Pakistan, like Afghanistan.
Now let's see what happens to Pakistan in next 2 years
@Amjad Hussain Taliban supporter wants to make India bride, how refreshing. BTW watching commies is haram in saria law. They gonna stone you to death.
It's time for bjp to send its rss members to show their bravery in Afghanistan
Haha nice one 😂
No need of others.
Only modi is enough.
Just make him PM of Afghanistan
Yeah let's make RSS great again. 😁
Rss are cowards like rats outside of their domain.
Are you really required to go there ?
How refreshing, two intelligent Indian gentlemen discussing regional issues without vilifying either China or Pakistan.
Thanks karan to have an interview with Mr. V Katju.
I'm not sure you heard the interview right through. Katju is concerned about Pakistan influencing the Taliban to launch jehad against India via LeT and Jaish (or their modern variants).
@@anshuecon Thanks, I did not finish
They didnt discuss most important topic of salma dam, where India has spent $3 billion even when the economy was struggling. Now taliban might take it over amd destrioy.
@@PankajDoharey Well, how do you ensure that unless you talk to them and say it should not be destroyed?
This govt is a prisoner to its domestic policies
Tell me a single govt world over , which is not? It is interesting to know.
@Amjad Hussain Did we tell you what ideology to follow ? Did we object you to follow Islamic ideology ? Hope you are wise enough to get my hint. India and Indian population including Indian Muslims know what is best for them.
@Amjad Hussain Your perception . Modi Saabka Baap hein.
@Amjad Hussain You understand all . Take care fo Pakistan .
@@independentnationalist1740 tera baap hosakta hai Modi... Don't talk on behalf of everyone..
If he was such a great leader the relationship with Bangladesh,srilanka,nepal,China and afghanistan is in jeopardy...
Considering pakistan perennial enemy...
Ambassador katju is right in saying that we hv cornered ourselves in 🇦🇫
One who DIGGS WELL FOR OTHERS FALLS HIMSELF INTO IT
@Vilas Tamhane dear they're not idiots by they have given the real picture,be realistic hv courage to accept the truth
@Vilas Tamhane bhakt jan undermining Indian diplomat......shows your I.q status
@Vilas Tamhane He the journalist who made Modi drink water in his interview. That why our PM is scared to face Media.
@Vilas Tamhane My hero is not Rahul/Pappu and no one can stop Islam. For your information Islam is the fastest growing religion in the world,please read the basic of Islam on your own it will help your knowledge.
Maybe this is what happens when ONE man wants to run the entire country, every ministry, and every department? Where's the bandwidth?!
That's Chai-wala, who have destroyed India inland and abroad.
@@monty1156 Chai wallahs are lovely, why spoil their name... let's call a spade a spade, and the PM the PM :)
Bandwidth is floating in the clouds.
The only problem is, he wants to care about winning election domestically.
India's Modi-led BJP Government's Foreign Policy Paralysis in Afghanistan - kindly watch this video till the very end in order to get your perspective right.
th-cam.com/video/PyQQPqwIryo/w-d-xo.html
how can we expect a goverment as narrow-minded and capricious as the current one to engage in the subtle and complex thing called "diplomacy"
Now we realised that the bubble & burst of so called deep reach of strategic policy of Afghanistan by govt of India, kicked out by feet of Taliban 😂
th-cam.com/video/fTx3Wm0fFUw/w-d-xo.html
Yes..complex thing like donating your own land to China saying nothing grows there...Aur padhao bhai diplomacy ke baar main...we are very much interested..
How do we approach the Taliban when our entire foreign policy is Hindutva and domestic politics centric 😒
Well judge
But all reservations are given to Muslims , all free bee for Muslims only
@@sany199 nice 😂
@@sany199 Nothing is given for free ,if Muslims had given reservation than you could have find most of them working in govt sectors.
Ola hu uber
Since last 7 years our foreign policy has been influenced by anti Muslim agenda in the mindset of the government. We cozied up with china with the perception that xi jingping is anti Muslim, we failed, because that was not the case, then we cozied up with trump assuming that he was anti Muslim, failed again, then in the Armenia / Azerbaijan we were supporting Armenia again failed, we r over zealous with Israel, because of the same mind set, not realising that it will fail again, we r angering Iran, who has been our ally, we get cheap oil there, we cozied up with Saudi/ UAE, not realising that they don’t matter due to the economical benefit to Ambani probably, then we r on and off relation with Iran, not realising that Saudi/ UAE has issues with Iran. We r not handling turkey well, not realising after 2023 they might become a major player, then we will fall into the same situation as we r in with taliban. The government has to realise that foreign affairs is not about anti Muslim agenda, it’s totally what is benefit for us. Let’s see how many more corners we force ourselves into. Foreign policy is no close friends with anyone, enemy of non, maintaining middle part. We r being used by the 3 in the quad to fight against china, for them. We should fight our own battle.
Very well explained.
Every good step for India is anti muslim for you.
We your true intention.😂😂
@Amjad Hussain No we aren’t isolated.But Pakistan is isolated.
India is 3 trillion economy with 1.3 billion people.And no country has ability to ignore us.
You are living in fool paradise.
@@robertbackham7660 lol. 3 trillion with hunger index ranking of 102 out of 117 countries. So, shut up.
@@thewitcher8658 It isn’t hunger it is called "upbash" in Sanskrit and fasting in english.
We are committing fasting for empowered our government and military.
You can see country like Switzerland,Netherland,Norway and canda whose people aren’t hungry but no country take seriously them.Even China whose average people are poor but terming "trudeau" as d0g.😂😂
So, it is sacrifice of our people for country.
I think the stand taken by the government for building Hindu Rashtra is standing as a hurdle to talk directly to the Taliban because their stand in home land is against the Muslims and their rhetoric has been against the Taliban . I think talking directly to Taliban may erode their vote bank too. Foreseeing, American leaving Afghanistan, the language of RSS chief also changed and his statement on Muslims was a surprise to many hardcore Hindus.
@Vilas Tamhane 😁😆😅😂🤣
Fact!!!
@Vilas Tamhane we might need an explanation
Truely explained 👍👍👍
@Vilas Tamhane 😭😭🙏🏾🙏🏾 Daydream 😭
Afghanistan is only one example. The foreign policy has been a total disaster. Period.
Yeah you are right, American foreign minister just visited India, and imran khan is yet waiting for call from biden
Pata kuch hai nahi gyan ch*do duniya bhar ka.
Absolutely right, Modi has become a laughing stock and ruined India internally & externally.
Let’s accept it, you ha been cornered by the masters (Pak army) not only in Afghanistan but in South Asia.. salute to ISI from Kashmir
Diplomacy is the art of dealing with people in a sensitive and tactful way. It appears from the interview that we have not kept diplomatic channels open with Talibans and have been pushed in a situation where we have very little say in dealing with present Afgan situation.
Abbey gadhe…taliban is extended arm of isi…what do u wanna talk with them?
Appearance only. India is careful and strong enough to do what it plans to do . No body will come to know even .
@@Annu.26 when USA had to talk with them who the heck you think India is?
@@we_the_people_of_kashmir3534 India is India and we do not meddle into others affairs. If some one tries to do in our affairs , we are capable to teach the lessons .
@@independentnationalist1740 haha come out of your dream what were you doing in Afghanistan, what raw is doing in Pakistan.
Come on guys be brave and admit that it was the close minded-ness of the BJP regime which has been able to use the Hindu card through the systemic biased propaganda against the Muslims and given itself the position to lead your nation. Talking to the Taliban would mean that trash their anti Muslim card.
@Vilas Tamhane Even home grown shld be checked for a hormonious future.
7:13 i have an answer AJIT DOVAL, he should be a director in dharma production or under Kabir Khan not the National advisor
😂
YOU SHOULD BE SERVANT AT DHARMA PRODUCTION NOT VOMITING SHIT ON SOCIAL MEDIA
@@trunner5220 was expecting some modibhakt, servant could only think of being servant. Seriously pray that modi becomes prime Minister atleast 2 more time then amit shah for 2 times and ajit deal or sorry Doval you maasi ka beeta should remain as advisor for all these term you will see more tiger zinda hai, Lomri zinda hai and till chipkali zinda hai ... enjoy just took care of you next generation as well trunner if you like I can vomit on you but then there is not point why would you vomit on shit
The Ambassador is bang on target that India is a flyweight bystander in his assessment of Indian Afghan policy. Indian foreign policy is formulated by a bunch of amateurs who have no capacity for a serious policy strategy that is not coloured by innate and entrenched bias. Is it any wonder that is is now being boxed out on every front.
Or India itself is a flyweight? Or you think that you have influence which you don’t actually have.
I think bottom line of the discussion is it's no more time of oppression so resolve Kashmir conflict through dialogue.
2. Arrogance makes you dumb not letting you see and think real life so India has closed itself in a box with there own great values while the same are not even practiced in India.
3. When tide changes friends become foes and foes become friends so chosing the right boat takes one to your destination. India again made bad decision by going with US when Asian century is starting hence again will face loss.
I think ambassador explained it better in quotes and you competing the sentence
We can keep Kashmir physically, we dint needs to talk with anyone on that issues
@@Manish_Kumar_Singh sometimes you share a part and are given right on whole. India has been missing the point since independence, read through the historical facts about how Germany wanted to become a power in Europe WWI and than WWII not succeeded than the politics cal way creating EU now today all Europe is behind Germany. same is the case of USSR trying to reach hot waters through force failed now is being offered to reach the same port of Gawadar.
Insha Allah Next project for Talibaan is Indian Occupied Kashmir. We kashmiris fully support them. Insha Allah it will be a big loss for india here in kashmir.
Finaly the truth has prevailed. Alhmadulillah
Saap palega tu dasega tujehi
@@rupertmurdoch469 Fr now jo snakes tm ne palay the vo bhag gae han....
It cost you Hindus 20 00 000 carores rupees or thereabouts
Nevermind lot of infanrs going hungry in India and they Havnt invented toilets yet
Afghanistan will soon join CPEC opening up huge trade opportunities from Central Asia to Gwadar seaport. China has won without firing a single shot !!
Pakistan ki abhi maa chud ne wali hai wait and watch.
@@FunnyandDelightful gay mata 😆
@@FunnyandDelightful HOW RISHIS WERE CREATED?
According to the Hindu Holy books, God Brahma arranged the marriage of
god Shiva to goddess Parvathi. When they went around the fire
as per Hindu religious ritual, god Shiva looked at the thighs of goddess
Parvathi and ejaculated his semen into the Fire and they became
Rishis (priests). According to the Hindu Puranas this "god" can do such
a filthy act!
Indian Afgan policy a major failure.
Imran's tricky policy going to win.
Yes, literally Pakistan gave Independence Day gift to India.
Otherwise, Taliban would have taken Kabul lpng before.....
Hats off to Mr. Vivek Katju jee, for being so truthful about the real situation and India's negligent stance, When World was busy on the negotiating table, India was busy sabotage these negotiations
My dear Indian friends these types of things happens when you have a narrow minded person siting in govt. When his top priority is to manage his local politics using any mean like Hindu Muslim then how he could think that much broader, which you are expecting from him. if he would've talked to Taliban then what would happens to his 56 inch ki chati narrative.
And one more thing this was surprise no 1 by Modi ji. Now surprise number 2 is on the way from Kashmir due to his historic blunder. We Pakistan's thanks Mr Modi from our deepest heart ❤️.
True
But most of indian think that Pakistani are afraid from strong man Modi 😂😂😂😂. Bollywood is good for us. It stop rational thinking of our enemy.😂😂
Kashmir🤣🤣🤣. Tum bikhari marte dum tak kashmir chilate rehna. 4 war bhi lad liye . Aur har gaye kuch na le paye. Kashmir karte karte Bangladesh kho diya aisa na balochistan kho do.
And I think it was Pakistan who lost their more than 40,000 soldiers fighting taliban. So America used you . The joke is on you 🤣🤣🤣 . Plus it was a twin group of taliban who attacked APS school in peshawar and killed 140 children. If you keep snakes in your backyard one day it will bite you
You mean 'small man' in big office 😂
In short what he means by "Wise men" presently our policy makers are Foolish people.
Why india want to talk to taliban when taliban said we will not allow anyone to use afghan soil against pakistan. Indian investment on Baloch and TTP terrorists is going in vain. Recents terrorist attacks india used Dubai for handling. India has nothing in afghanistan , when india cant do terrorism . Modi is right in approach
Just wait India’s turn is about to come….
Its not that Indian diplomacy failed to establish contact with taliban but taliban delibrately ignored Indian advancements to keep them out of loop and stratigically disadvantaged. Who knows who prompted Taliban to play it that way China or Pak or both time will tell.
Thank u Karan for conducting this interview with Vivek a very able diplomat , incidentally it gave me a great pleasure to see my old classmate from Allahabad,saint josephs'collegiate. Look forward to ur interviews in the offing.
India showed its true colors to the Afghan government who India claimed that Afghanistan is a strategic ally.
Strategic only in talking..
@Amjad Hussain India never even sent their army to afghanistan. We were their to help people. You were the one who were sending terrorists in afghanistan supporting taliban
" I have great respect for our team in charge of the Afghanistan-Pakistan policy" Sir, do you have respect for the Ajeet Dowal and akin, Mr. ambassador, as well? And were you not a member of that policy, that you are dissociating from that now?
Taliban are monsters
Why India is hoping be involved in Afghanistan at all? You borders don't meet and your cultures as well.
Is it only to counter Pak & China? Also if you are thinking to deal with the devil (Taliban) then why not have good relations with Pakistan (lesser evil in India's perception)
The Prime Minister has not made any Press Conference from his first day till now. It shows how efficient and clear he is not to face press and reply the questions. Why is he doing it? Why is he not facing the Press?
चुनावी भाषणबाजी, अक्षय कुमार छाप स्क्रिप्टेड ईन्टरव्यु शूट या 'मन की बकवास' करवा लो इनसे..! लाईव प्रेस कॉन्फरंस में जवाब देने के लिए पहले कुछ काम करना भी तो जरुरी है..!!😀😁
You should see Pakistan PM while speaking in front of any forum in the world.
Doval has been a disaster, he should be sacked immediately
@taladuga picpwaspwat we don't want to live in india. We are happy in our homeland. Thank you very much
@@come2success104 Thank God!
@taladuga picpwaspwat o bhai humne unki female MP ko to Delhi airport se wapia bhej diya rehne dou
India - We don't talk with terrorists ( Afghan Taliban ) , We support Asraf ghani govt.
India - We can talk with Afghan Taliban, everything is possible in geopolitics .
Conclusion - India is terrified about Pakistan, Afghanistan & China nexus (Most importantly about JIHAD)
India wants the world to see it as a global power. However, it was not even invited to discuss the Afghanistan issues. That shows that India is not even regarded as a regional power in its own region. Afghanistan is a saarc country and a south Asia country.
Nobody seems to be answering the elephant in the room, that by not astutely dealing with the Taliban and with the Afghanistan government, we have sealed the last nail in the coffin of what may become the global hotspot for breeding international terror. And with the abrogation of article 370, the hate mongering in these camps may just have reached it's highest decibel.
But the reality is that "we" neither have the nail nor the coffin. "we" really don't have an idea what to do.
@@SS-kg8qw The impeding force to the last nail of the coffin could have been evaded by tactical wisdom. It's the futile belief that wisdom is vested only in the PMO's office and not with groomed bureaucrats that is a cause of concern.
@@danielraju4458 When the wise men of Nagpur has decided that the enemy is within and not outside the border, that nailed the coffin. Don't give much credit to the buffoon in Delhi, he's just a scare crow, the real power is vested with Nagpur fundamentalists
@@SS-kg8qw How are they going to understand global foreign policy? I greatly fear for the future of our country, with adversaries surrounding us from the west to the east and the north.
@sameer rush Stop this cancer of polarization based on religion. This is an age of Science, just because my folks gave me a Christian name doesn't mean I'm not a patriot. I'm Indian and I care deeply for the future of our nation, in fact, like Vivekananda put it, I care for the destiny of this nation.
When you have a barbaric tribe surrounding you on all three frontiers, and you have no neighboring allies(the Russians won't come), then what would India do? War cries won't help, the gods won't come down, Mahabharata won't ne replayed. It will be catastrophe, since the enemy too have sophisticated weapons, the best logistical supply chain and lethal men who don't mind dying in the name of religion.
Be rational, be scientific, then be a nationalist because if you loose your brain to Deshbhakti and sing your bhajans to your heroes, then one day, the enemy will attack and snatch even your basic livelihood.
There is no relevance of India in Afghanistan. I don't know why they are discussing what india should do in Afghanistan. Totally non sense efforts to do something in a country which strongly fought against almost all great powers of the world like russia, America, nato, Australia, Poland, canada, England and many more. Then what india can do something which will benefit India in Afghanistan. India better to call back its citizens to India as all western nations calling their citizen back.
I don't know who india is trying to fool - Afghan government which will be non existent in near future, Taliban whom no one can defeat, indian citizen who constantly fed lies or government itself.
@Vilas Tamhane
After America's shameful and humiliating defeat at the hands of taliban despite being super power is enough to reject your claim that America will not allow Taliban to succeed. but the contrary is more truer that it is Taliban that not only would not allow America but can defeat America again if again America make the mistake of reentering Afghanistan. Remember popular line that Afghanistan is grave yard of empires.
Another truth is more badder to hear that Taliban not only defeat America (the super power) but Taliban defeat all major powers of the whole world like nato, England, Poland, Australia, Germany, france who all were station in Afghanistan but all ran like a coward rat.
Now you just reason out that if major power failed to defeat Taliban then what India has which will make India to keep its feet on the land of Afghanistan. Just think. I don't need to elaborate.
$3 billion down the drain
Can you imagine how many TOILETS Could’ve been built with this money
More Toilets that even Pakistan could be flushed in them
Pakistan lost 40,000 soldiers and 102billion dollar fighting taliban on direction of America. The joke is on you. India built dam and roads and infrastructure to help them. India not send madrsachapp jihadis to fight in other countries
@@piyushgarggarg9131 Do you remember Sri lanka ? Caused SL 30 years economic progress !
What to do?! There are no good options for India. But the interlocutors are right. Modi is utterly clueless about India's national interests concerning the unfolding Afghanistan situation.
Worse, in this context, the removing of Art. 370 in Kashmir looks to be a disastrous move.
Modi is NOT utterly clueless. The Govt knows more than you what should or should not be done. AND Kashmir is NOT a disastrous move unless you are a coward.
Absolutely someone who is a staunch nationalist from jammu. I want to say that removal of art 370 is single largest anti india act done by parliament of india.
@@littlebral9899 Thanks bro 🤜for understanding the disastrous implications of abrogating Art. 370.
Modi has turned India 🇮🇳into a magnet 🧲for Jihad (already Jihadis are ranting and foaming about Ghazwa-i-Hind).
Worse, India doesn't have any real friends in the West and possible Russia also might abandon Modi-India (think of the inoperable Indian military hardware of Russian origin, if that happens).
Article 370 was disastrous. A million people displaced.. around 3lakhs family. We were already at Loss with Article 370, no gains in reducing Terrorism. Also there was no equal human rights.
@@manidwivedi5880 Since Modi is so dependent on Russian 🇷🇺military hardware, then how is he different from Nehru and the Gandhi-Congess continuity of India's foreign policy?!?
In the 7 years (since 2014) since Modi became PM I expected a massive order of 250-300 American 🇺🇸 F-16s so that today the IAF 🇮🇳 could provide sustained and comprehensive air-support to insert 2-3 lacs Indian Army and ground forces in Afghanistan, to take over from the Americans/NATO/ISAF forces there.
This would have aligned India's interests with America completely and ensured a permanent seat 💺in the UN Security Council as a reward. Also India would be in a strong position to recover PoK.
All this is not far fetched, because Modi has displayed tremendous resolution in abrogating Art. 370 on Kashmir with alacrity.
But instead, Modi has managed to procure a paltry 24 Rafales (out of a meagre 36) in last 7 years. With the Manmohan government India would have had 126 Rafales by now (the original deal). Besides, the Congress govt. saw through the delivery of 272 Su-30 MKIs, the backbone of the IAF today.
....kudos :
VIVEK KAATJU SIR... 🙂🙂
& :
...shame-shame-FEKUNOMICS...!!!
Of course no logic to our (Modi)policy , only whims and fancies of Hindu extremism policy come in way of having diplomatic relations with Taliban. Other major reason could be American Ghulam-Modi-Shah India
Tell me a name of country with which present government has improved relationship with in their tenure.
All modi's foreign visits went down the drain
They spoiled relationships with their own citizens as well as other countries
Antarctica
North Pole.😂😂
Perhaps more fundamental than anything Mr. Katju said is that does any Indian understand how did Taliban defeat NATO. They bombed Afghanistan to stone age but the Afghans defeated them with stones.
Indians prematurely greeted Ashraf Ghani for his re-election likewise Modi chanted in USA that Abb ki bar Trump sarkar 😄😄
Look at the map and you will realize how PHYSICALLY boxed in India is. Their own "Belt and Road" working with Ashraf Ghani is going to be dead. And now, it is sending its navy to the South China Sea inviting danger from the north. Amazing.
His saying 'wise man handling our policy' seems more of sarcasm 😀
Recently, the Taliban spokesman said that they are grateful to India for investing in the development of Afghanistan. But the narrow-minded Hindutva ideology did not permit us to build relationships with the Taliban like we did the blunder of saying " apke bar trump sarkar ".
Our policy was 'there can be no good taliban and bad taliban meaning all talibsns are bad taliban' so for this haughtiness on the part of indian govt we will have to pay heavy price becas in afghanistan now majir players are pakistan china russia and iran all have become anti indian.
Russia and India are pretty solid allies though.
@@84y87 Russian can see how India becoming friend of USA. Don't think that they are dumb.
@@mudassaram1410 please think rationally .
Vivek Katju is a matured diplomat and his stand was very right.
Well, it is not just Afghanistan, Modi government doesn’t seem to have no logic to all of it’s policies. India has lost out big time in Afghanistan.
Ambassador Katju a recent report by Brown University in US has disclosed that the number of American casualties is 30177 soldiers and the amount of money wasted between five and six trillion dollars.
have the link?
India has no clue what realpolitik means.
Do pak have?
When your whole foreign policy is based on attacking your tiny neighbour you will always be left to pick up crumbs. Plus theres no need for cheap labour in afghanistan so not much for you guys to worry.
This man is scared of opening his mouth!
India's Afghan policy is based on a single aim and that is to box in Pakistan. Which is not possible when Taliban are in power so India is just not interested in talking to them. India isn't trying to help the Afghan people nor to make their lives better. And the Afghan officials have milked India to their content by capitalizing on India's Pakistan centric policy.
I think, we have missed the boat because the of total myopia...
How?
India , never had logical based foreign policy , always been HINDU / MUSLIM Centric policy !!!
These two dont know anything 56D chess is being played by our world best spy NSA and best foreign minister of all planet,,with the blessing of supreme leader
there are revelations abt him going on btw he is one of the biggest useless spy lol faltu ka james bond he is... dude spies dont showed up themselves in public and claim it...
who knows putin himself is an agent you never know... yes they do exist pr aese faltu me claim nhi krte h...
@@damn738 SARCASM SAMJH RE BABA
India is about to make china a colony and strike 500 trillion $ GDP. Gobar exports have skyrocketed.
India with its Hu=indutva ideology has become like Pakistan. A state portraying one particular religion. How can with citizenship act offering to hindus and sikhs of afghanistan, can India seriously talk to 180 d opposite extremist muslim mindset. Another point is they r still trying to pop up the Ghani regime
Because partition was based on hindu Muslim, it was supposed all Muslims will go to pakistan, and all hindu to India, but this could not happen, because how can you leave India at peace, when mindset is ghazwa e hind, no Muslim country besides India is reproducing so fast, mentality of outnumber hindu, I am ex Muslim, I know deep
India: Sorry You lost the War. Your investment gone in waste . Don't act more foolishly and Stop brutality in Kashmir otherwise will face embarrassment in Kashmir as well.
Mr Vivek is very diplomatic in not offending his political bosses but what he actually meant was quite evident.
India, s foreign policy was caught napping at Afghanistan not because it was left in the dust.. In the fast moving Doha Diplomacy.. And in not anticipating the Taliban Violence.. The failure of not gauging a China outsmarting India was never expected at Afghanistan.. We lost our invested capital..
Things can be rendered even after the loss if matters are handled pragmatically and sagaciously.
Mind Begs the Question:
USA Govt armed Afghans against Russia
Terrorists - Evil
To arm Terrorists - Bigger Evil
No?
India's Modi-led BJP Government's Foreign Policy Paralysis in Afghanistan - kindly watch this video till the very end in order to get your perspective right.
th-cam.com/video/PyQQPqwIryo/w-d-xo.html
When are our Indian prime minister so weak how can we fight with taliban. He only speak in against Indian
National interest is paramount and not that of any political party's interest.
Sure, Sir. God Almighty will show India its real value and worth. This all is due to your tea-maker semi-literate prejudiced P.M.
Semi literate Nahi illiterate
Still better than madarsa chaap
@@MyAvi1991 wake up man
@iqbal
Not semi-literate but complete illiterate and only working to become a man of history, a hero of india who in reality did nothing for india, other than making few gujratis more richer and maing all people poor who are from middle class to extreme poor who in future will do nothing but suicide.
Why, modi is not harming me.
If I will not support him then there will be a collision government in india which is not good for my mother land.
Ask your beloved congress to throw out Gandhi family bring back leaders like jyotiraditya sidhya. I will vote for them
My legions is with my country I don't believe in politics and all this crap.
I replied this moron because they hate bjp not because of any policy only religion.
I can challenge that thi MC doesn't know A of foreign policy and India's challanges in Afghanistan but he commented on because of Hate.
No wrong Ambassador, India put all its eggs in US' basket! Call the spade, spade!
11:18 "I don't like the word mistakes in diplomacy because you make judgememnts on the basis of......"
Basically translates to : "I was a diplomat & hence we don't make mistakes. Also I'm not courageous enough to criticize the current regime." 🤡🤡
what an intellectual meaningful conversation .Very impressive insights more people like this should be in Indian politics .. Educated , intellectual and balanced
Yeah because the agree with you .good to be balanced but these guys r just as bided as anyone else
@@arunsalwan8558 is peace not a good message ✌️
We were seeing this coming.
We have a great stake.
We cannot be in peace when our neighbours are in trouble.
We had played a major role earlier. We cannot take sides. And also we cannot be a by stander too.
Opening up talks with Taliban will have impact in local politics so we are muted and boxed.
Keep your self Flexible is the best policy as Katju Sir says.
But today the speed at which Taliban is emerging, it is a Present and Clear Danger for us.
How Talibans are danger for you??The biggest danger for india is BJP not Taliban.
@@chaqeb7681
When there is disturbances in the neighbourhood it is going to affect us as neighbours.
These disturbances may be used by groups, which will impact us.
@@parthibank2736 you are right, india will suffer if Afghanistan fall under Taliban even everyone, every country in the world will suffer ,but reality is they are a major power in afghanistan .With out talking them how can india save interest there?
@@parthibank2736 your current government has only one ideology that no talks to opposition, Kashmiri huriyat calls for talks your govt put them in jail now even non huriyat leaders asking for dialogue with pakistan but your government has it's own ideology ,but keep remember if you have your own strict ideology then others also has ,why you can't control militants in kashmir because they have jihad concept ,no ideology in world is wrong but balance is best thing ,if you take action and don't expect reaction then what we can do?If you don't talk taliban and bound to your own ideology and also condemned them and use harsh language against them ,try to sanction them UNSC but still you expect they will not retaliate, they will give answer to modi ,sooner or later.
this time Talibans may danger or not it is in our govt hands but Bjp is spoiled diplomatic relations with surrounding Countries and deviding people in cast line n religious line for their servival then how cum country progress
A delightful interview. Two civilized gentlemen discussing a foreign policy and security issue of great international significance dispassionately and wisely. If only men and women of such foresight were responsible for deciding affairs of countries and the world. America's exit from Afghanistan and India (suddenly) looking irrelevant in the Afghan situation shows that neither application of huge military power nor infusion of vast economic resources are sufficient to decide issues of national sovereignty or international relationships. India has made tremendous, by and large successful, efforts to become a world class military power. But that has not made her an advanced modern country. If utilized sensibly, it's very large population, very rich culture, great agricultural and industrial potential and other factors of history, geography etc. can make it a great country, a country which is not feared but respected and loved by its neighbours and the world at large. But that will require men and women of calibre and perception of Mr. Thapar and Mr. Katju to be in positions of decision making.
Karan you are awesome as always - brilliant mind.
Solve the Kashmir issue and stop target the Muslim in India,talk to Pakistan is key ....
Absolutely not! Kashmir is an Indian province. Lol
A day will come... when India will leave kashmir just like Ghani flee kabul.
@@zakirali8721 A day came when India revoked article 370, created Bangladesh.
@@zakirali8721 pakistan, a failed state. A terriorists sponser country. Next time, pakistan will be put in the Black list of FATF. Are not you people proud for this?
@@samarjeetmohanty8981 What will they be proud of? New Zealand cricket gave a tight slap yesterday.
An valuable discussion that from now on will be discussed more and more. It’s mind boggling why India has preferred to place all its eggs in the USA basket and even more egged in the Ghani basket that was never strong. This is shocking..
Because you can not trust Taliban
India will have to pay great costs for the civilan and economic damage it caused to Pakistan via terrorism and funding of NDS and Criminal proxies via Afghanistan.
"IT KNOWS ITS FATE VERY WELL WHAT WILL BE THE OUTCOME AND COST OF STAYING AND ENGAGING FURTHER IN AFGHANISTAN..HENCE THE SILENCE"
جی بالکل بجا فرمایا آپ نے۔
ہم بھی انتظار کر رہے ہیں اسلام کے ان عظیم سپاہیوں کا ❤️
بھارتی مقبوضہ کشمیر سے آپکا برادر این فیتھ
Good to hear the Word Mujahideen from His Excellency mouth while referring events of 1980s…..why the same lot being termed by Indian Media as terrorists…..
Head chopping is terrorism and not mujahidin
What a great experience to enhance from such great intelligent gentlemen. Exposing the wisdom of our present so called wise men handling the future of India.
Very good discussion and impressive thoughts of Mr Kaatju!
However, the real India has to first dealt with its very visible Hindutva policy which is restricting to progress with good diplomacy with Taalibaan and even with Pakistan.
Why would India progress with rogue regimes like Pakistan and Afghanistan! Doesn't matter to us much!
Talking to terrorist? What nonsense. Lets develope some spine and support Afghan militarily and keep LOC hot to keep Pakistan in check
The cost you pay for 'trying' to keep LOC is huge. 300+ Indian troops have left the planet in your last bollywood adventure. When you can talk to Izrael the biggest of all why not talk to balsy villagers.
@@shsaeed6818 not left the planet they are martyrs, say directly you want Kashmir to pakistan
By the way who the hell are you, when army men happily doing their duty
@@harshsysnet
Pakistan gives "free will and choice" to Kashmiris.
@@shsaeed6818 then Pakistan army must leave pok, it's the first step of UN resolution, 1st step is to taken from pakistan.
Recently on election there dissidence appeared, 2 kashmiri was shot dead during clash with Pakistan army, even 1 mla Ismail gujjar go to extent to seek help from India, this is not godi media propoganda, you can go through bbc
I think the answer to Katju's puzzled "for some odd reason," "somehow," we didn't make contact with Taliban is quite obvious. It's because in the Indian mind the Taliban are too overly conflated with Pakistan, so India either considered it futile to talk to a Pakistani "proxy" and/or thought it would dangerously expose it to Pakistani manipulation and derision while also alienating its Kabul govt allies.
Pakistan and india should get together and talk to Taliban . We should make it clear that we will not tolerate Terrorism
@@kamranshaukat6024 That's a tall order !!
India and Taliban are in touch.
@@kamranshaukat6024 where are you from If I may ask?
India is obsessed with Pakistan more than their intention of peace in Afghanistan. Even Taliban dont truly accept stance of Pakistan, otherwise there wont have been US on the ground as they would have accepted to give up on Al Qaeda.
India should have built toilets for 600m people. And 1 for modi
Loved this interview. Every second.
Well, India has definitely failed in buying the Afghan people loyalty. A couple of billions couldn't do a small dent where trillions couldn't.
What I don’t I understand is that there are major riots going on against Rohinga Muslims, why they are also , who need help as they are India immediate neighbor and can absorb this much population easily, or can put pressure on Mia mar to behave in better republic way , if India wants to do humanitarian activities
@Lion Warrior khushal shay zema sher khana rora ,pe yo paragraph ke dey da semay toll hall um bayan kere o che se rah rawan di hagai na dey hum khabara Krum . Os bes khushala shum, che dase Safah nazer rurna larum. Da dey na pes khuday dey Khasmir hum Azad Kari ,Ameen ze ba weum che da khudai sengai pe mung dasi merabhanashu. 🌹🍀🔥
I am sure many Muslim nations who have much less population and more money can absorb these people
Our country has stood for two things democracy and women rights. It was Indias key role that military junta of Myanmar came under global pressure. Our ranking in women rights as 145 out of 155 countries is in itself a psychological pressure on Taliban. These two forces make the taliban scare of India
PM Modi has adopted the right policy in Afghanistan. Taliban are terrorists and no talk with terrorists.
Then why talk to the junta in Myanmar? Why talk to the Saudi regime? The Iranian regime? Diplomacy doesn't work on morality. It never has.
Ok then don't talk with Israel, China , Syria, US , Saudi Arabia , Russia
They all are killing innocents by their proxies or by themselves
@@deenmohammad1886 iran is worst including myanmar
Afghan taliban has said they wish India not even think about entering Afghanistan military as consequences will be fatal but also they are coming to liberate the Kashmiris
British PM said that he will not recognise Taliban government, and Taliban said, “do we care”. LoL
Didn't admit any mistake in the entire 36-minute chat
The entire 36-minute interview was revolving between 3 or4 questions
Only and only time has been sung for 36 minutes
My question is that if according to this former ambassador it's in the strategic interest of india to talk with Taliban the why not talk to leaders of Indian Occupied Kashmir?? You consider them Indians so why don't you talk to them?
2nd question is wth is Indias interest in Afghanistan other then sabotaging Pakistan and supporting terrorism in Pakistan?
There will be a serious consequences if we have not helped Afghanistan at this crucial time
India/modi is in the usa pocket, USA regards Taliban as untouchable. This paralyzes India, who may see the. Insanity of not dealing with Taliban as the master of Afghanistan.
When India/modi chose to be USA spear-carrier against prc, this is a foreseeable consequence. You must live with it.
Dear Mr. Thapar please consider changing the sound track that precedes your program and played during the breaks. It is very loud and not pleasant to hear.
Only one concerned and preoccupied with Afghanistan is Wire itself. India can never be friend with Taliban. Kowtowing to Taliban for friendship will actually send wrong signal to the world. India is not a major player in Afghanistan. The only spectacle Wire wants to see is Modi beseeching Taliban for friendship and then mock Modi.
Modi is gutter and he has lost
@@aali8316 That's your observation. Live happily with it.
You could start by not calling them "terrorists."
Yea driving around cities with ak47s are terrorists for any normal person par tum log kaunse normal ho
@@travelinwards5747 That makes them a military, which now has its state back. Don't bother traveling inwards...you won't find anything of worth there.
@@travelinwards5747 and it looks like you want to burn the last boat you have left...go ahead.
The road to Kabul goest through Islamabad. You guys simply don’t get it!!
Oh we get it, that is why message should be sent to Taliban and their puppet master that any trouble in India or holding Indian citizens hostage will invite a disproportionate response across the LOC and IB.
@@Mork2001 no one really cares about you guys. You are the ones who are making all the noise trying to get attention.
@@taimurmughal78 Oh am sure the genocidal TSPA is straining at the leash to push even more terrorists across the LOC & IB because a leopard cannot change its spots. I hope our Govt has given a message to GHQ about disproportionate response. The clue was in PM Modi's Independence day speech :).
@@Mork2001 yes keep on crying no one cares. We are focus on establishment of regional peace and trade routes via CPEC. We know how to deal with Fascist Modi and his hateful agenda. Remember Feb 19..Tea was fantastic!! 😂
@@taimurmughal78 How are the Chinese workers in Gwadar doing? You had to return him within 48 hours while 93000 genocidal TSPA troops were POW in India for more than a year. Surrender was by a Niazi in 1971 and now another Niazi is the puppet PM of the genocidal TSPA.
A very one dimensional interview. Why is Karan Thapar so keen to provide legitimacy to Taliban?
Open your mind and ears, he is trying tp draw out responses from the person.
Mr Karan Ambassador Katju is very diplomatic in his statement about the failure of Indian Afghan policy.
Ambassador Katju will never acknowledge the mistake because he was trained to be cautious in usage of words. I humbly submit that in my opinion the Indian Afghan Policy was not left to the external affairs department. It was hijacked by the National Security department.
TALIBAN never asked india to talk to them, stop flattering urself...
The question is what is there for us in Afghanistan ? Why should we meddle in Afghanistan ? We share no boundaries with them.
Excellent conversation. Hope peace ☮️ will prevail for everyone's benefit.
India's Modi-led BJP Government's Foreign Policy Paralysis in Afghanistan - kindly watch this video till the very end in order to get your perspective right.
th-cam.com/video/PyQQPqwIryo/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/fTx3Wm0fFUw/w-d-xo.html