Hi Rabbi can you please look in your email to find the comment I left asking about Nadab and Abihu? I wanted to go look back how I worded it to make sure no one misinterprets it but I cant find my comments I left you. When the thought came to me and I asked the question, in my mind it was like in a tone of, "I know there is a difference Im missing and you'll probably want to give me a slap for this question, lol, but at least without knowing the full reasons why it wouldn't be, right now to me it seems like good parallel and I still wonder about it." Basically I had a funny feeling about my own thought, plus maybe projecting how a learned Rabbi would react to my question of seeing a similarity in two situations that you would probably know are completely different, but I didnt, so Ill ask anyway. I intended kind of a sheepish tone because of how, of all things, the connection to that Talmud teaching about "my children have defeated me" had come into my mind in juxtaposition to the Nadab and Abihu story. But now Im wondering how I typed it and how you interpreted it, because it seems like you dont like me or something, since you wouldn't answer my questions, so I started to think what if you thought I didn't take the lesson seriously, and if that's why you wouldn't answer about Joseph and Esau's soul levels. Is that what you thought? If so, now that I cleared up what I actually meant, can you please reconsider answering about that? Can you please maybe make a video answering about Joseph and Esau's soul levels now? It still doesn't make sense to me. I wont comment again since you said you didnt want me to anymore, but I wanted to clear this up and ask one more time for that answer. Thank you.
Hello! I'm not rabbi Salmaniah, the speaker of this video. Remember that I am only a "repeater station" for the voice of rabbis who speak what I know with confidence it's the Truth. This is the first comment in months I received from you, i was not notified of any other messages specially about "nadab". Are you sure you left a comment here and not anywhere else? I am not familiar with other matters that are not specifically Mashiach and Moshiach. About the souls of Esau and Yoseph, I am stuck there, I have not advanced much since then and what I have is only apocrypha and gnostic sources, basically Esau is a another name for satan, and for Shemesh wich is a sungod for the romans, shemesh is samech, in kabbalah zohar is an celestial body associated with sama-e-l if i am not mistaken. But Yoseph is also a "sun of righteousness", so it seems Yoseph and Esau are one and the same, just it depends how righteous or evil a person is, he will be consumed by the heat and light of this sun or healed by it. Just theorizing based on different sources I've been researching.
@@yisraeleliyahu7495 It was Sulam Ya'aqov. Thats notyou? I left the comment there too. He/you? didnt respond, but hopefully saw it. I hoped he/you? would answer my question finally but it's OK. Thanks for your videos and everything, and sorry for asking too many questions.
@@punchforpound2808 Hello bro, that channel you mentioned is owned by Rav Yehezkel Italqi. I also tried to have some question answered but I received no answer. No problem, I let you with another link that I found in the last months;
Hello i have been watching your videos for some time and its very interesting i just want to ask about one thing yesterday i was watching some documentaries and many are saying that western european people are the 10 lost tribes of israel is this true i am asking because i am from france and i got confused about this is this theory has many are saying true or its just nonsense with no reality to it ?
Hello! Thank you very much for your comments. First we must depart from what we have as factual, for granted. And in this way, the Pashtoon from Afghanistan are without a doubt a "sample" of not only the ten tribes, and one tribe of Judah, making up almost the entire kingdom of Israel; the tribe of Binyamin which was part of the Southern Kingdom of Judah. Secondly, one thing is also granted that Western Europe is EDOM, they are at the minimum, descendants of the Romans which in turn descend from Idumeans (semitic peoples mixed with Yavan, son of Japhet). We must ask ourselves why what was the purpose of the ten tribes to be exiled and dispersed? To be a light to the nations of Edom, this is a prophecy in Isaiah 49:6 (biblehub.com/jps/isaiah/49.htm). Just these past weeks I realized (we are every day or every weak discovering something new) that the common understanding that the Jews from Yehuda is not very accurate, if we refer to great commentators such as Malbim we see that the chapters prior and including 53 of Isaiah which is very known and talked in the western christian world, is not referring as the Jews or the people of the House of Yehuda as the servant. Isaiah is referring to the ten tribes where a prophet will lead them back to Eretz Yisrael, and both the ten tribes and Yehuda will be under a unified 12 tribe kingdom again. So, 2000 years have passed already when the land was left inhabited (at least from the spiritual aspect, the Divine Presence was exiled also). By this present day 2023, we assume that Esau has been elevated enough to return to Israel holding the hand of Ephraim (also known as kingdom of Samaria, Yoseph, ten tribes, etc). A source for this is here: th-cam.com/video/M-xy0iE25pI/w-d-xo.html -Rabbi Yitzchak Ginsburgh In order to be concluding this answer and not to make it very large, western europeans, as descendants of the germanic tribes (goths), what we have is that Portugal, Spain and France have descendants of the tribe of Gad. A source for this is here: blogs.timesofisrael.com/the-lost-tribe-of-gad-found/ Speculations says that all the tribes are in western europe, but what we have on that statement are mostly speculations, one of it is "British Israelism". So, Western Europe for sure is Edom. The countries I mentioned have found strong evidence of being the tribe of Gad. The tribe of Ephraim, the chief tribe I mean, has proven to have been found in Germany, why? Almost this entire channel emerged from it (promo video): th-cam.com/video/ABNEVNJwLRw/w-d-xo.html
@@yisraeleliyahu7495 according to rabbi yair and others the goths, franks, celts and anglosaxons are part of the 10 tribes and these people i have mentioned form the vast majority of western europe so how could western europe be edom, edom in my opinion are central europe (italy, slovenia, czech republic, hungary etc...) besides this does ephraimites required to observe 613 mizsvot and sabbah and the rest of the holidays, i think the problem here is that the lefty govermments are bringing a lot of amalek from ukraine and thousands of ishmaelites from the Middle east and africans.
@@yisraeleliyahu7495 one interesting fact is that the goths and the others i mentioned they did not used to marry outside their people while for the other people in europe was normal thing to do wich reminds me of the practice of the jews for marrying outside their own people
@@yisraeleliyahu7495 about the pashtuns i doubt they are israelites because they dont fit the descriptions of the blessings given to israel they were always poor and they never had power outside their borders and they never shaped or influenced the world in any way shape or form wich is one of the characterisitcs of israel you look at the western europe and they fit those blessings and characterisitcs 100% they had the power to do whatever they want and all the money, military power and all the innovations that changed the world and still have alongside the usa, it just takes minor decisions from western europe or usa to make changes in the world and sometimes even influences the stock market wich you dont see these type of influences anywhere else in the world even big powers like china or india dont have such influence they might have on regional level but not anywhere close when it comes to international level like usa, australia and western europe has.
@@pierre22423 The theory of our estimated rav Yair Davidiy was proposed already two centuries ago by white supremacists from the protestant church and has been already debunked. That doesn't mean Anglosaxons are not related to Israel, on the contrary yes, they are, based on factual science they are related to the tribe of Gad, and probably other tribes too, but it is not that exclusively the Anglo-Saxons are the ten tribes. Edom is a synonym of Esau, Esau is a synonym of Edom which in turn is a synonym of the Roman Empire. The goths, although mysterious origins according to what I was researching in Academia, if we help us with the Torah, including hermeneutics, we know that the Goths are the ancestors of the Germans. But the goths are also ancestors of all the Germanic peoples who are Western Europe. When goths defeated Romans, they became Rome (th-cam.com/video/XTMrXfS64bk/w-d-xo.html -may need a VPN due to regional restrictions), and that reign lasted until the Third Reich when officially Rome opened a new HQ in Washington D.C. The Roman Empire split into two and the eastern part became later the "Third Rome" which is today Russia. Third Rome served as a place of concentration for the amalekites. In kabbalah, we have quite some clues that the body of Esau which is not redeemable is his grandson Amalek. The aryan nations are the amalekites; Russia, Belarus, Poland, Czechs, the Baltics, etc, or basically where the pogroms happened. It must be clarified though, that many Greeks settled in Eastern Europe but I'm sure the Divine Providence will rescue them because they are Edom, if not descendants of Israel also, here we see some passage about the kenites, related to Yitro, father-in-law of Moses, as parallelism; " 6And Saul said unto the Kenites: ‘Go, depart, get you down from among the Amalekites, lest I destroy you with them; for ye showed kindness to all the children of Israel, when they came up out of Egypt.’ So the Kenites departed from among the Amalekites. "- 1 Samuel 15 (www.biblehub.com/jps/1_samuel/15.htm) Finally, of course anyone hearing the call of the Shofar must start keeping the Torah immediately, converting to Judaism also doesn't harm, because in a conversion what the Beit Din must do is make sure the person's soul was at mount Sinai, going to the mikveh and checking circumcision (if it was not yet done, must done with authorized mohel) won't harm anybody.
Hi Rabbi can you please look in your email to find the comment I left asking about Nadab and Abihu? I wanted to go look back how I worded it to make sure no one misinterprets it but I cant find my comments I left you. When the thought came to me and I asked the question, in my mind it was like in a tone of, "I know there is a difference Im missing and you'll probably want to give me a slap for this question, lol, but at least without knowing the full reasons why it wouldn't be, right now to me it seems like good parallel and I still wonder about it." Basically I had a funny feeling about my own thought, plus maybe projecting how a learned Rabbi would react to my question of seeing a similarity in two situations that you would probably know are completely different, but I didnt, so Ill ask anyway. I intended kind of a sheepish tone because of how, of all things, the connection to that Talmud teaching about "my children have defeated me" had come into my mind in juxtaposition to the Nadab and Abihu story. But now Im wondering how I typed it and how you interpreted it, because it seems like you dont like me or something, since you wouldn't answer my questions, so I started to think what if you thought I didn't take the lesson seriously, and if that's why you wouldn't answer about Joseph and Esau's soul levels.
Is that what you thought? If so, now that I cleared up what I actually meant, can you please reconsider answering about that? Can you please maybe make a video answering about Joseph and Esau's soul levels now? It still doesn't make sense to me.
I wont comment again since you said you didnt want me to anymore, but I wanted to clear this up and ask one more time for that answer. Thank you.
Hello! I'm not rabbi Salmaniah, the speaker of this video. Remember that I am only a "repeater station" for the voice of rabbis who speak what I know with confidence it's the Truth. This is the first comment in months I received from you, i was not notified of any other messages specially about "nadab". Are you sure you left a comment here and not anywhere else? I am not familiar with other matters that are not specifically Mashiach and Moshiach.
About the souls of Esau and Yoseph, I am stuck there, I have not advanced much since then and what I have is only apocrypha and gnostic sources, basically Esau is a another name for satan, and for Shemesh wich is a sungod for the romans, shemesh is samech, in kabbalah zohar is an celestial body associated with sama-e-l if i am not mistaken. But Yoseph is also a "sun of righteousness", so it seems Yoseph and Esau are one and the same, just it depends how righteous or evil a person is, he will be consumed by the heat and light of this sun or healed by it. Just theorizing based on different sources I've been researching.
@@yisraeleliyahu7495 It was Sulam Ya'aqov. Thats notyou? I left the comment there too. He/you? didnt respond, but hopefully saw it. I hoped he/you? would answer my question finally but it's OK. Thanks for your videos and everything, and sorry for asking too many questions.
@@punchforpound2808 Hello bro, that channel you mentioned is owned by Rav Yehezkel Italqi. I also tried to have some question answered but I received no answer. No problem, I let you with another link that I found in the last months;
Hello i have been watching your videos for some time and its very interesting i just want to ask about one thing yesterday i was watching some documentaries and many are saying that western european people are the 10 lost tribes of israel is this true i am asking because i am from france and i got confused about this is this theory has many are saying true or its just nonsense with no reality to it ?
Hello! Thank you very much for your comments. First we must depart from what we have as factual, for granted. And in this way, the Pashtoon from Afghanistan are without a doubt a "sample" of not only the ten tribes, and one tribe of Judah, making up almost the entire kingdom of Israel; the tribe of Binyamin which was part of the Southern Kingdom of Judah.
Secondly, one thing is also granted that Western Europe is EDOM, they are at the minimum, descendants of the Romans which in turn descend from Idumeans (semitic peoples mixed with Yavan, son of Japhet).
We must ask ourselves why what was the purpose of the ten tribes to be exiled and dispersed? To be a light to the nations of Edom, this is a prophecy in Isaiah 49:6 (biblehub.com/jps/isaiah/49.htm). Just these past weeks I realized (we are every day or every weak discovering something new) that the common understanding that the Jews from Yehuda is not very accurate, if we refer to great commentators such as Malbim we see that the chapters prior and including 53 of Isaiah which is very known and talked in the western christian world, is not referring as the Jews or the people of the House of Yehuda as the servant.
Isaiah is referring to the ten tribes where a prophet will lead them back to Eretz Yisrael, and both the ten tribes and Yehuda will be under a unified 12 tribe kingdom again.
So, 2000 years have passed already when the land was left inhabited (at least from the spiritual aspect, the Divine Presence was exiled also). By this present day 2023, we assume that Esau has been elevated enough to return to Israel holding the hand of Ephraim (also known as kingdom of Samaria, Yoseph, ten tribes, etc). A source for this is here: th-cam.com/video/M-xy0iE25pI/w-d-xo.html -Rabbi Yitzchak Ginsburgh
In order to be concluding this answer and not to make it very large, western europeans, as descendants of the germanic tribes (goths), what we have is that Portugal, Spain and France have descendants of the tribe of Gad. A source for this is here: blogs.timesofisrael.com/the-lost-tribe-of-gad-found/
Speculations says that all the tribes are in western europe, but what we have on that statement are mostly speculations, one of it is "British Israelism". So, Western Europe for sure is Edom. The countries I mentioned have found strong evidence of being the tribe of Gad. The tribe of Ephraim, the chief tribe I mean, has proven to have been found in Germany, why? Almost this entire channel emerged from it (promo video): th-cam.com/video/ABNEVNJwLRw/w-d-xo.html
@@yisraeleliyahu7495 according to rabbi yair and others the goths, franks, celts and anglosaxons are part of the 10 tribes and these people i have mentioned form the vast majority of western europe so how could western europe be edom, edom in my opinion are central europe (italy, slovenia, czech republic, hungary etc...) besides this does ephraimites required to observe 613 mizsvot and sabbah and the rest of the holidays, i think the problem here is that the lefty govermments are bringing a lot of amalek from ukraine and thousands of ishmaelites from the Middle east and africans.
@@yisraeleliyahu7495 one interesting fact is that the goths and the others i mentioned they did not used to marry outside their people while for the other people in europe was normal thing to do wich reminds me of the practice of the jews for marrying outside their own people
@@yisraeleliyahu7495 about the pashtuns i doubt they are israelites because they dont fit the descriptions of the blessings given to israel they were always poor and they never had power outside their borders and they never shaped or influenced the world in any way shape or form wich is one of the characterisitcs of israel you look at the western europe and they fit those blessings and characterisitcs 100% they had the power to do whatever they want and all the money, military power and all the innovations that changed the world and still have alongside the usa, it just takes minor decisions from western europe or usa to make changes in the world and sometimes even influences the stock market wich you dont see these type of influences anywhere else in the world even big powers like china or india dont have such influence they might have on regional level but not anywhere close when it comes to international level like usa, australia and western europe has.
@@pierre22423 The theory of our estimated rav Yair Davidiy was proposed already two centuries ago by white supremacists from the protestant church and has been already debunked. That doesn't mean Anglosaxons are not related to Israel, on the contrary yes, they are, based on factual science they are related to the tribe of Gad, and probably other tribes too, but it is not that exclusively the Anglo-Saxons are the ten tribes.
Edom is a synonym of Esau, Esau is a synonym of Edom which in turn is a synonym of the Roman Empire. The goths, although mysterious origins according to what I was researching in Academia, if we help us with the Torah, including hermeneutics, we know that the Goths are the ancestors of the Germans. But the goths are also ancestors of all the Germanic peoples who are Western Europe.
When goths defeated Romans, they became Rome (th-cam.com/video/XTMrXfS64bk/w-d-xo.html -may need a VPN due to regional restrictions), and that reign lasted until the Third Reich when officially Rome opened a new HQ in Washington D.C. The Roman Empire split into two and the eastern part became later the "Third Rome" which is today Russia. Third Rome served as a place of concentration for the amalekites.
In kabbalah, we have quite some clues that the body of Esau which is not redeemable is his grandson Amalek. The aryan nations are the amalekites; Russia, Belarus, Poland, Czechs, the Baltics, etc, or basically where the pogroms happened.
It must be clarified though, that many Greeks settled in Eastern Europe but I'm sure the Divine Providence will rescue them because they are Edom, if not descendants of Israel also, here we see some passage about the kenites, related to Yitro, father-in-law of Moses, as parallelism;
" 6And Saul said unto the Kenites: ‘Go, depart, get you down from among the Amalekites, lest I destroy you with them; for ye showed kindness to all the children of Israel, when they came up out of Egypt.’ So the Kenites departed from among the Amalekites. "- 1 Samuel 15 (www.biblehub.com/jps/1_samuel/15.htm)
Finally, of course anyone hearing the call of the Shofar must start keeping the Torah immediately, converting to Judaism also doesn't harm, because in a conversion what the Beit Din must do is make sure the person's soul was at mount Sinai, going to the mikveh and checking circumcision (if it was not yet done, must done with authorized mohel) won't harm anybody.