The problem is you can't class it as self defense because the deceased did not come with a weapon nor did he physically attack him that would be classed as life threatening. But yes in an ideal world he should have been granted a lesser sentence
Asika he already had the knife. He had the intention to use it. If he had reached out for a knife during the fight then it would have been a different story. Also, he stated that he was standing by the kitchen door with a plan to fight there, advancing from there. He had the intention to fight.
Tilder how can someone get in touch with you. I would like to help this man because he is in jail because he only crime he done was defend his life from people who would have murdered him instead
Handizivivo kuti kune mamwe mamwe maprovinces zvrikovo hre zvemiganhu .Masvingo its too much umm .Baba vangu vakasangan nazvo tichri van vadiki tikakura ichingonetsa tikat baba mugumo rufu siyai zvakadaro .VaMaranda dai vakangozvisiya grudge reminda hariperi .
Nt quite..it wud be self defense if the neighbour also had a deadly weapon..knife/gun. So issue is our guy here used deadly force where the threat to him wasnt deadly in the immediate moment. Law aint fair..feel sorry for him though
@@tchitambira6465 The law was an ass here. THERE is no doubt whosoever what the deceased intentions were. HE brought a gang with the sole purpose of luring him out of his own house to be attacked and most definitely have been killed. They were intruders meant to cause him harm this was a clear case of self defence.
@T Chitambira The law was an ass here. THERE is no doubt whosoever what the deceased intentions were. HE brought a gang with the sole purpose of luring him out of his own house to be attacked and most definitely have been killed. They were intruders meant to cause him harm this was a clear case of self defence.
This guy is a sober sense. Many events of his story to me he was very correct though it's unfortunate enough that it ended up claiming the life. His mistake was to argue with the wife of the deceased whilst the wife was stopping the husband. Up to an extent of pushing her twice. These are very common disputes in the rural homes and I think sometimes these circumstances needs relocation.
Murume uyu ari kutara ega kuti akadzingirira munhu akabata banga nyaya inobva yashanduka kuita murder. It's no longer self defense. I think ma judge vari correct.
Does it really mean that Zim law courts and lawyers do not know what murder is. My understanding is that there are two crucial principles that constitute murder and these are; mens rea which is the mental element of a person committing a crime and actus rues which is the physical element of committing a crime. It therefore follows that if a person knowingly and intentionally plans to kill another person and successfully does so, then that is undoubtedly referred to as murder. On the other hand, if someone has not planned to kill another person but accidentally does so whilst trying to defend himself/herself, that is not murder but manslaughter. I am therefore flabbergasted to hear that someone who was defending himself from being killed by a group of seven thugs is the one who is serving a 15 year prison term. This is utterly ridiculous and unprecedented and clearly proves that there's something wrong with the Zim judicial system hence it's obvious that a bigger number of people that are behind bars are innocent while the real criminals are freely enjoying life out of prison and I absolutely think that something definitely needs to be done in order to rectify this crucial problem.
God is the judge in tis issue & he will send an interceder Tshaka Maranda, he will be released before his time, for he has learnt that (kibo kagwala akula sililo) i pray that he gets a donor so he can finish his degree. Keep on praying man, our God is a faithful & just God
hsaisi nyaya ye Temba or kushaya temba , unoita temba yei ivo vanhu vauya kuzokuuraya , he didnt have an option, dai vasina kubaya ndivo vangadai vakabayiwa.
Shame baba ava vakangoita munyama the deceased alive nemusoro wakaoma abd vakaita munyama wekuvengwa munharaunda Dai vakaziva vakangotama vakanogara Kure nevanhu ava
Ndinofarira chido chenyu kana pane vanokwanisa kuchinjirawo baba ava hupenyu please help vaenderere mberi ne chikoro, yaiva self defense zvayo asi murder I murder.
Oh shame..People keep grudges foe years and they dont forgive silly things like football stuff. I witnessed this in rural areas..kumamisha uku iproblem chaiyo
Shem Mwari vakuchengete Mwana waMkoma vangu ,,,Satan ndiro basa rake iroro rekuparadza thank you so much Tete Tilda nekushanyirawo Hama yangu yeropaa Mwari akuitirei zvidhafuu ,,,zvakakora zveGuta ngazvive zvenyu 💕💕💕💕
The tongue is a double edged sword. Silence is golden. A piece of land has destroyed two families and the land still stands. Anger is a curse.
Mmmm a truth well articulated
Well stated!!
You cant help but love these villages stories.
Behing bars with Tilder has to be the best local content we have in zim 🙌🙌
This was self defense this man should have never been put in prison for saving his life on his property.
The problem is you can't class it as self defense because the deceased did not come with a weapon nor did he physically attack him that would be classed as life threatening. But yes in an ideal world he should have been granted a lesser sentence
This was self defense, vakatadza kutonga nyaya iyii
@@catherinesiziba6729 exactly! He needed to have a lawyer.
Asika he already had the knife. He had the intention to use it. If he had reached out for a knife during the fight then it would have been a different story. Also, he stated that he was standing by the kitchen door with a plan to fight there, advancing from there. He had the intention to fight.
Pakuzomupindira pa yard vakaresva. Chinoda kufa chinovingira
Baba ava zvinhu zvakazongoitikao zvazvo bt he is 100% innocent
Yaaa law is very stuborn
Touching narration
Tinamate Jehovha vatiwanire nyasha, nyaya ya mr Tshaka Maranda inoratidza kuti kunyangwe tisingashuviri kuita zvakaipa nebwoni asi satan anotitsvaga nenzira dzose kuti aparadze shuviro dzakanaka paupenyu hwedu, tikumbire uchenjeri hunobva kuna Jehovha musiki kana tasvika pakumanikidzwa
Chokwadi tinamate tichiti Mwari musatirege tichipinda pakuedzwa asi mutinunure mune zvakaipa
Tete Tildah...u inspire me so much..am planning on starting something like this in my beautiful country and will definitely look for u
The word of God says “come unto me those who are heavily burdened and I will give you rest.”
Amen!!
Tilder how can someone get in touch with you. I would like to help this man because he is in jail because he only crime he done was defend his life from people who would have murdered him instead
Contact the number given at the end of the video
@@andypanashemajuru2920 yeah got it thank you👍🏿
May God bless you abundantly
@@mufasasdaughter4831 did you manage to get in touch with Tilder and this man?
Makazovabatsira here
He's a good narrator
True seems like he is at Loggerheads with everyone
Lets hope the show will save the innocent
This is sad and it's self defense uzophuma
zita ravo Tshaka rine mhepo dzehumhondi
Yemasabhuku iyi iiiii 🙌🙌🙌
Self defense iyi,self defense. These people would have killed him.Mupurisa should have been a witness to this.
Exactly
Ko itai kari ka movie tete Tilda. Nyaya inospaka hayo iyi
Be strong ✊✊✊ zvinowanika ... GOD BLESS KING
You are a hero mi brother
Ndiri wezhira sewe wamai.... be blessed
Handizivivo kuti kune mamwe mamwe maprovinces zvrikovo hre zvemiganhu .Masvingo its too much umm .Baba vangu vakasangan nazvo tichri van vadiki tikakura ichingonetsa tikat baba mugumo rufu siyai zvakadaro .VaMaranda dai vakangozvisiya grudge reminda hariperi .
Iriko kwese dear kwedu kuHurungwe taigara tichiona vanasekuru vangu vaigara vachinetsana nemuvakidzani wavo kusvika pakuda kutemana nematemo
@@shallatkz4434 So poitwa sei ?Gvt ichion kudeuka kweropa no action
Nothing dear hazvigadzirisiki coz panotowanikwa ari selfish
Bt that was self defense
Nt quite..it wud be self defense if the neighbour also had a deadly weapon..knife/gun. So issue is our guy here used deadly force where the threat to him wasnt deadly in the immediate moment. Law aint fair..feel sorry for him though
@@tchitambira6465 ... actually the victim touched him first. So anything after that is self defense.
@@tchitambira6465 The law was an ass here. THERE is no doubt whosoever what the deceased intentions were. HE brought a gang with the sole purpose of luring him out of his own house to be attacked and most definitely have been killed. They were intruders meant to cause him harm this was a clear case of self defence.
@T Chitambira The law was an ass here. THERE is no doubt whosoever what the deceased intentions were. HE brought a gang with the sole purpose of luring him out of his own house to be attacked and most definitely have been killed. They were intruders meant to cause him harm this was a clear case of self defence.
In UK and US if you are killed whilst attempting to attack someone in their own home it's case dismissed. This man shouldn't be in jail.
Mmmmmmm zvokwadi kuMasvingo kwedu uku miganu inonetsa .... So sorry to the man and condelences to the berieved family
Very sorry my dear Baba ,makakandirwa mhepo nasabhuku vanowe iwo babamukuru vako .dai makagara zvenyu kuSouth Africà zvaiwe nani
God protect this man's children 🙏
Don't worry my brother God will help you ok
Ndakanga ndajaira Kwedu kwaMaranda 🎉
Tete Tilder your patience amazes me 👏👏👏
What from 2006 to 2016 he was a free man after auraya munhu wow 😮
This guy is a sober sense. Many events of his story to me he was very correct though it's unfortunate enough that it ended up claiming the life.
His mistake was to argue with the wife of the deceased whilst the wife was stopping the husband. Up to an extent of pushing her twice.
These are very common disputes in the rural homes and I think sometimes these circumstances needs relocation.
I hope someone can help him
Damn, staying in SA was the best....coz mmmm pakaipa.
Apo unototiza SA tichiti hakusi safe nekuda kwemhondi woenda kumusha wosangana nemiyedzo
Pakaipa Mkomana, series of unfortunate events
Tete Tilda how far akazoitigwa appeal here munhu uyu.update pliz
Tshaka😅🤣🤣 hanzi ndakati anenge anorwara
Ku testa aids nema ziso😂
that issue was self defense in his own yard, this guy had no option, nyaya haina kutongwa mushe iyo
True. Who trains these judges?? He was going to be attacked in his own backyard. He had to defend himself.
Yanga iri self defense kaiyi nhai tete tilder baba vekufa ava vakatouya kuzodenha vega kava ..
It was premeditater murder. He went to the scene with the wife.
Yaaa that was self defence indeed my brother let's just wish kty mubatsirike
Yeminda ahipere mushe iyi panotofiwa tozviona kazhinji mumamisha umu
Very painful
Nhai veduwe ndarwadziwa!!
Wanga ussina mhosva mdara self defence haina control inga saver oponent
Murume uyu ari kutara ega kuti akadzingirira munhu akabata banga nyaya inobva yashanduka kuita murder. It's no longer self defense. I think ma judge vari correct.
Does it really mean that Zim law courts and lawyers do not know what murder is. My understanding is that there are two crucial principles that constitute murder and these are; mens rea which is the mental element of a person committing a crime and actus rues which is the physical element of committing a crime. It therefore follows that if a person knowingly and intentionally plans to kill another person and successfully does so, then that is undoubtedly referred to as murder. On the other hand, if someone has not planned to kill another person but accidentally does so whilst trying to defend himself/herself, that is not murder but manslaughter. I am therefore flabbergasted to hear that someone who was defending himself from being killed by a group of seven thugs is the one who is serving a 15 year prison term. This is utterly ridiculous and unprecedented and clearly proves that there's something wrong with the Zim judicial system hence it's obvious that a bigger number of people that are behind bars are innocent while the real criminals are freely enjoying life out of prison and I absolutely think that something definitely needs to be done in order to rectify this crucial problem.
God is the judge in tis issue & he will send an interceder Tshaka Maranda, he will be released before his time, for he has learnt that (kibo kagwala akula sililo) i pray that he gets a donor so he can finish his degree. Keep on praying man, our God is a faithful & just God
Well said. That should have been involuntary manslaughter. But this is Zim, nothing makes sense
Sei usingawirirane nevanhu vese iwewe 😂😂😂😂 uri nhundiramutsime
Marondedzerero ababa Ava vanoratidza kutaura chokwadi because zvavarikutaura zvinhu zvirikusangana nevanhu chaizvo chaizvo kumamisha.problem ndeyekuti vakazotadza Ku controller tamper yavo chete vakazoguma vabaya munhu..
hsaisi nyaya ye Temba or kushaya temba , unoita temba yei ivo vanhu vauya kuzokuuraya , he didnt have an option, dai vasina kubaya ndivo vangadai vakabayiwa.
@@givemorechiguvare2010taura hako
Pakaoma baba shame...
Shame baba ava vakangoita munyama the deceased alive nemusoro wakaoma abd vakaita munyama wekuvengwa munharaunda Dai vakaziva vakangotama vakanogara Kure nevanhu ava
Soriyii zvenyu....zvenyika zvonetsa
Shem zvemiganhu kuMasvingo ma1
Nyaya iyi yaitoda headmen Chigodora
hayiiiiii sekuru vangu pakaipa
Ngatiregei kutanga tataura kuti yange iti self defense tisati tanzwa rimwe divi. Ndinoona sekunge vatongi havana kutadza nekuti pakauya vanhu pamusha pane vakange vasina zvombo. Ko akadii kutiza kuyenda ku police. Uyezve anotaura ega kuti akabuda mumba achidzingirira munhu nebanga. Mutemo wakaoma. Mbavha ikapinda mumba mako, ukaidzingirira panze ukaiuraya, hazvireve kuti hauna mhosva. Vanoongorara kuti wamuuraya sei. Ndoona sekunge vakatonga zvakarurama.
Uuuuumm Mwari akuwanirei nyasha
Soo sorry va Maranda
The whole story irikukonzegwa nemamai
He refused mukadzi waaida kupihwa aigwara
Akaroora muramu wasabhuku
Uyo aitora munda nokuda kuoneregwa nemukadzi
It’s the handiti iri innocent for me 😢
Kurimirana pamuganhu...
Dai asina kubaya uyo iye ndiye aizourayiwa,vanhu vavakamutsoma ava ende ukaona waita muvengi weropa rako pakaipa anopa mukana wevamwe vekunze
a case that got on pending for 10 years, after that given a term of 15 years........
Mwana wamai spereki pamachena apa zveubhinya bhinya ndozvake tomuziva uyo
Ndinofarira chido chenyu kana pane vanokwanisa kuchinjirawo baba ava hupenyu please help vaenderere mberi ne chikoro, yaiva self defense zvayo asi murder I murder.
Nyaya yemuganhu inourayisa ameno kuti chii
Shame why people do this thing when they go back home from South Africa
Yowe nyaya iyi ine magrudges emakore zvakaoma.
Baba ava vanotaurisa zvakaitika zvakaitika hazvo but ivowo ummm ndashora munhurume hazvidi kutaurisa kudaro
ii mwana wekumusha kwangu'hauna mhosvà ' vakakuvinga pamba' vaidei pamba pako ' vakahwa butter
He was 40+ in 2006
So he is now 60+ in 2021.
Is it so
Ndoona kunge mutemo urikutora one side of story yemunhu anenge amhqngara ndiye anoteererwa ..let the court equalise both
Haaa nyaya yeminda iyii yakashata shame
it is well
i pray for his freedom
Nguva yaSmith kupinda mumusha memunhu uchimurwisa wowurawa nyaya yacho yairaswa.
Kiikiii sadza vanorifarira
Dai mwari vapindira imepo yakagezerwa pana baba ava.
U kno a lot
Shame zvorwadza wairwisawo asi satani akafamba
Zvakaoma vedu
Unkulunkulu ubhekile Ngwenya okusalayo uzaphuma sitshela
Dai akatora baby zvisina kuzodai
Tilda uri dofo
This man does not deserve to be in jail
Kupindira munhu paden pake shuwa. Self defence iyi mxm
Too many stories, difficult to keep track. Is this a diverting tactic?
You just don't listen very well, the story was well narrated
Oh shame..People keep grudges foe years and they dont forgive silly things like football stuff. I witnessed this in rural areas..kumamisha uku iproblem chaiyo
Tshaka anga akamakwa nevanhu vese😂😂😂,,
🤣😂😂😂
Ndoona kuti aivengerwa kumbogara kuJoni nekusimudza simbi kkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkl
@@yvonnepakura954 😂😂😂
Ini baba vangu vakatozvifira zvemunda
This was self defense....he could have run away during these 10 years he knew he did not commit any crime
Vanogona kurondedzera ava
Nyaya dzacho dzawandisa
I know.
It's self defence why the court give him many years like that
Sandy ndichanoGura kikikiki
Mwari batsiraio babaava
Haaaaa nyaya yeminda ine makuva pasi
This man is innocent
Nyaya yeminda haina kutanga nemi mukoma yakatanga navamugabe karesa ramba wakashinga zanu
Self defence if this man is telling the truth
pakaipa pakaipa
Zvakaoma
Handiti
Shame ...iself deffense Lord have mercy
Vanhanzvadzi kuInterviewer henyu munonyatsokugona