Factually and historically there is only ONE club in birmingham Aston is a recent addition to birmingham ...1911 Aston is about as much part of birmingham as west bromwich
The reason Blue's carry the city's name goes back a long way when the two clubs were forming. Villa were from Aston and Blue's were from Small Heath. Both clubs had to register their name's with the Football League and agreed to keep the names of the district they were from and neither would take the name of the city. Villa registered as Aston Villa but Blue's went back on the agreement and registered the name Birmingham. The Villa directors were furious and broke off communications with their rivals for years referring to Blues as backstabbers. So began the hostility that remains to this day.
A lot of rivalries are built from power struggles and the fight for dominance and influence. This rivalry (for me anyway) is more to do so with identity. The guy at 4:10 alluded to it. We were the first club founded in Birmingham, a club founded by Brummies, for Brummies. Villa can't claim to be established as a Birmingham club, they were 36 years old (their most successful period) before Birmingham expanded and incorporated Aston and throughout their existence, they have scoffed at any opportunity to represent the city. I see villa as conflicted, "anti-Brummie" and an imposter/fake club, a true Brummie proudly supports the team that represents their home town, moreso over status, stadium and trophies etc. I imagine this is the main reason why they also resent us and call us "Small Heath" because they don't like the fact that we are the sole team that represents Birmingham, but if they don't like it why haven't their fans ever presssured the club to change? is it elitism? Shame of being from Birmingham? we already call them "Identity Crisis FC", what's a name change for them? They'll happily sing anti-Birmingham songs but don't like the fact WE have our city's name. I honestly don't think I'd hate them anywhere near as much if they embraced the identity of the city all those years ago but here we are. TL:DR - Birmingham ❤>>>Aston💩💩
Well thats a load of bollocks for a start & you're clearly deluded & trying hard to fit in your non factual nonsense to suit your agenda in defence of your small irrelevant piss poor excuse of a football club. The fact is it was your club that changed its name,starting out as Small Heath fc,which is quite fitting really & changing it to Birmingham City to big yourselves up & give some dog shit delusion that you represent the city overall,absolute shite in everyway, shape & form. If your club is really meant to represent Birmingham overall,what a piss poor job they've made of it,it's fuck all to be proud of pal & Villa are making a far better picture of it locally, nationwide & worldwide. Enjoy division 1 next season pal....up the fuck'in Villa!!! 😂
@@BrianHillier-di2vn the fear and insecurity of villa fans is showing. How are you letting "small heath" rattle you so much that you're all over the vid of a Blues youtuber? I thought we were irrelevant. 🤣 None of you were so emboldened to pipe up this much when bordering on bankruptcy in the championship. 👍
Small heath alliance changed the name to birmingham before aston was brought in to be a part of birmingham as a whole. Now the villa fans will claim this is false, but they fail to do the research to check. KRO
That small you bothered to comment on my comment lool. Must be the fact its been over 10,000 days since you seen the glimmer of a trophy hahaha a team in league one has won one more recently than you. Bottle it when it comes to winning something😂
Actually the first club to be called Birmingham used to play at our ground - en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Birmingham_Football_Club_(Aston_Lower_Grounds). Also Aston was part of Brum in 1838 but Blose fail to do the research lol, you're not even the first to be called Birmingham haha
I honestly can't wait for next season Villa fans think they are a big club ... but they will be playing the real elite of Europe, and I can't wait for the moaning 28 years snd won f..k all , will soon be 29 yrs and won f..k all . Meanwhile some great days out for us 💙💙💙💙
Hi @eddyvlogsfootball; thanks for an interesting video. From an historical standpoint Birmingham City were first called Small Heath Alliance (SMA naturally being located in the district of Small Heath). Now legend has it that they had a gentleman’s agreement with the team located in the district of Aston (called Aston Villa) not to take the name of the city (which is Birmingham). SMA broke the agreement. Now the two are bitter rivals ever since.
@@ilianbh that Birmingham had any agreement with villa about not adopting the city's name. There's no proof of this, just copium from villa fans. Birmingham City adopted its name well before Aston was ever part of Birmingham
@@TCPH Ah yes, Aston became part of the expansion of Birmingham in 1911. Small Heath Alliance adopted the name of Birmingham 6 years earlier in 1905. 👍🏾
@@thinksmart5247 I couldn't name another team from Slovenia apart from Maribor, nobody cares about you bro 👍 name me one street in Aston without using Google. 😭
@@TCPH small heath played Maribor few years ago, that is why you remember it... i don't care about you or your little club either. Only Bruce can save you, hahaha. Stuck forever in the shadows of the Villa.
Villan here. Nice video n I'm glad you have love for the City of Birmingham and your club, that's nice 👍 I find on the whole the Villa Blues thing is always about banter and friendly rivalry because we all have friends and sometimes family from the other side and throughout the year we always give each other stick but on the whole we all know each other. The major difference is a derby day match. When it's actually a game between Villa n Blues the day itself is intense, the tension is electric and nobody wants to lose. Villa got 4th and qualified for champions league this season while Blues got relegated to league one and of course we at Villa celebrated that and had a laff about it but in reality most Villa fans would rather see Blues do better because we miss those match days. Those couple of seasons we shared in the Championship were wild and great days playing Blues and West Brom.
So let me get this right… you moved to Birmingham and chose Birmingham city 🤣🤣🤣 I feel for you so much 😢 UTV SOTC but don’t ever forget….. THE CITY IS OURS 💜💙 MIND THE GAP 😂
Muppet! It’s amazing how all the villa fans come out the woodwork when they win a few games and do well. Vile park was empty in the championship, whereas Birmingham City has a top fan base. We know we are shit …. But we are on our way back.
Our average attendance for the 3 years in the pathetic championship was 32,000 while your average attendance just for this season alone is… wait for it🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 16,758 🤣🤣🤣🤣 Next?
@@secretpolice6322 lol case rested. The ground it what 43k capacity! So out your 32k average attendance, 5k would have been away fans, so 27k villa fans! Where’s the rest of them? Lol 😂. Anyway lads enjoy your big days out getting battered by a Greek pub team, you will be an embarrassment to English football in the champions league! But you can keep our spot until we are there in 2 seasons. 😂 SOTV.
Small Heath fc,the blues original name are full of hate for Aston Villa cos they've always played 2nd fiddle to Villa & they can't handle that fact,so the hate is returned by Villa. Aston Villa is one of the biggest/most successful clubs in English football & former champions of Europe, we've won 7 English champions titles,7 FA Cups,5 League Cups,1 European Cup,1 European Super Cup,2 intertoto European Cups,1 Charity shield & 2 division 2 titles,1 division 3 title. The blues have won 2 league Cups in 149 years of their history & the only pathetic boast the blue noses have is their 2nd league Cup was won more recently than Villa's last trophy, well just about as Villa's last 2 trophies were 2001/2008 intertoto European trophies & Villa's last domestic trophies were league Cups in 1994/96,so Villa won 2 league Cups in 3 years,it took the blues 149 years to win the same 2 trophies, sad,eh? Villa are far ahead of Small Heath in every possible metric & there is no comparison in the stature of these Birmingham based clubs,maybe an elephant in Villa to a mouse in blues,but deluded blue noses will never admit that fact in which causes them pain & spiteful hatred towards their far bigger neighbours in Aston. While Villa will be mixing it up next season with Europe's finest, the blues will be getting batterd in division 1,England's 3rd tier football league. Enjoy your lovely trips to Stockport,Exeter etc,so exotic!!! Hate will eat you up & hasn't brought anything positive to your small club,acceptance might be less painful long-term....up the fuck'in Villa!!! 💜💙💪😀✌️
All you care about is trophies won. If villa were historically shit, no-one would support them. That's why your fans are fickle cuz when youre not getting success, you have no reason to cheer for a team representing an area you're not from. None of you are from Aston or give 2 shits about Aston. Frustrated gloryhunters
Loving ur vids mate I’m from paisley Scotland myself and Celtic supporter but Aston Villa are my second team since John Gregory was manger in 1998 still not gonna make me not like ur vids though 😂😂
you know when you pick teams in the school playground and theres always a couple of fat kids to choose at the end ? well those fat kids went on to form Birmingham City. True story
Hahaha mate any villa fan that is 28years or younger have never seen there team lift a trophy, fucking tragic for such a succesful club you claim to have😂.
The only way Birmingham city be better than villa is they do a man city Chelsea or Newcastle and even if they win more trophies than villa witch is highly unlikely I go to a scum Birmingham city fan and say congratulations you brought the trophies 😂
im a huge fan of aston villa i grew up in bordsley green as a villa fan while around the corner st andrews was there i went to many villa vs blues and my first game was when dion dublin headbutted robbie savage that was crazy any way blues are shit there in league one while is villans sit in 4th place and we got champions league SHIT ON THE CITY UP THE VILLA (@Eddy Vlogs Football you chose the wrong side)
Nice but sorry for you but like you said you like football but you made wrong decision to follow blues. You should’ve went to Villa Park instead, like your channel surprise to the blues for everyone says good Derby when we played together, hopefully soon we will
Birmingham are not Villa's rivals, they're our neighbours. Big difference. It's a shame they don't spend more time supporting their own club rather than obsessing about Villa. It's a point not lost on some of their more educated fans. Until that massive cultural shift happens they'll always be at best a yo-yo club, at worst, irrelevant. Villa fans may say they hate Birmingham but in reality it's more amusement which is why the derby is still important to Villa, who would want to lose to such a little club? It would be embarrassing.
Battle of Birmingham 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 there is no Battle, Villa conquered the midlands LOOOOOOONG ago. the blouse should concentrate on Walsall, closer to there level
Factually and historically there is only ONE club in birmingham
Aston is a recent addition to birmingham ...1911
Aston is about as much part of birmingham as west bromwich
The reason Blue's carry the city's name goes back a long way when the two clubs were forming. Villa were from Aston and Blue's were from Small Heath. Both clubs had to register their name's with the Football League and agreed to keep the names of the district they were from and neither would take the name of the city. Villa registered as Aston Villa but Blue's went back on the agreement and registered the name Birmingham. The Villa directors were furious and broke off communications with their rivals for years referring to Blues as backstabbers. So began the hostility that remains to this day.
Loveddd the video eddy! KRO as alwaysss
Liking the underlying message in this vlog Eddy ... good stuff ... 👍
SMALL heath by name
SMALL team by nature
Literally haven't been Small Heath for 119 years but it's comical you think this is an insult even though we embrace and celebrate our roots. 🤦♂️
Eddy I have a video idea!! I’d love to see you do a reaction to our carling cup journey and victory :)
A lot of rivalries are built from power struggles and the fight for dominance and influence. This rivalry (for me anyway) is more to do so with identity. The guy at 4:10 alluded to it. We were the first club founded in Birmingham, a club founded by Brummies, for Brummies. Villa can't claim to be established as a Birmingham club, they were 36 years old (their most successful period) before Birmingham expanded and incorporated Aston and throughout their existence, they have scoffed at any opportunity to represent the city. I see villa as conflicted, "anti-Brummie" and an imposter/fake club, a true Brummie proudly supports the team that represents their home town, moreso over status, stadium and trophies etc. I imagine this is the main reason why they also resent us and call us "Small Heath" because they don't like the fact that we are the sole team that represents Birmingham, but if they don't like it why haven't their fans ever presssured the club to change? is it elitism? Shame of being from Birmingham? we already call them "Identity Crisis FC", what's a name change for them? They'll happily sing anti-Birmingham songs but don't like the fact WE have our city's name. I honestly don't think I'd hate them anywhere near as much if they embraced the identity of the city all those years ago but here we are. TL:DR - Birmingham ❤>>>Aston💩💩
You should write fantasy for a living, rather than posting it in you tube comments.
Well thats a load of bollocks for a start & you're clearly deluded & trying hard to fit in your non factual nonsense to suit your agenda in defence of your small irrelevant piss poor excuse of a football club. The fact is it was your club that changed its name,starting out as Small Heath fc,which is quite fitting really & changing it to Birmingham City to big yourselves up & give some dog shit delusion that you represent the city overall,absolute shite in everyway, shape & form. If your club is really meant to represent Birmingham overall,what a piss poor job they've made of it,it's fuck all to be proud of pal & Villa are making a far better picture of it locally, nationwide & worldwide. Enjoy division 1 next season pal....up the fuck'in Villa!!! 😂
@@tonymcfeisty2478 you should stay off Blues youtube you obsessed muppet 👍
We simply call you "crisis".
@@BrianHillier-di2vn the fear and insecurity of villa fans is showing. How are you letting "small heath" rattle you so much that you're all over the vid of a Blues youtuber? I thought we were irrelevant. 🤣 None of you were so emboldened to pipe up this much when bordering on bankruptcy in the championship. 👍
Small heath alliance changed the name to birmingham before aston was brought in to be a part of birmingham as a whole. Now the villa fans will claim this is false, but they fail to do the research to check. KRO
Boring mate,small club!!! 😂
That small you bothered to comment on my comment lool. Must be the fact its been over 10,000 days since you seen the glimmer of a trophy hahaha a team in league one has won one more recently than you. Bottle it when it comes to winning something😂
They can't handle that we are the only true Birmingham club 😂 They don't want the name themselves but don't want anyone else to have it 🤦♂️
Actually the first club to be called Birmingham used to play at our ground - en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Birmingham_Football_Club_(Aston_Lower_Grounds). Also Aston was part of Brum in 1838 but Blose fail to do the research lol, you're not even the first to be called Birmingham haha
@@patrickbateman7122 what are you waffling on about, Aston was incorporated in 1910.
💙 Birmingham forever kro 💙
Eddy great videos as per KRO
KRO… towards league one 🤣
One massive team in champions league,one small sad little club in 3rd division,not much of a battle .Blues v Walsall is a derby .
Where you from, Telford? Shrewsbury? 😂
@@classic-shirt-obsession9843 Kingstanding.what part of Redditch are you from .
@@classic-shirt-obsession9843 nothing to say B44
So massive you closed an entire stand in the championship. O'Leary was right about you lot 🖕
Massive team ??...
SMALL HEATH FOREVER IN OUR SHADOW. WATCHING VILLA ON A TUESDAY NIGHT BLUES AT SHEWSBURY CAUSE THEYRE FU***** SHITE WHAT A FEELING WHAT A NIGHT 😂😂😂 UTV
“Barcelona on a Wednesday night, blues at Wrexham cuz there fucking shite”
I honestly can't wait for next season
Villa fans think they are a big club ... but they will be playing the real elite of Europe, and I can't wait for the moaning
28 years snd won f..k all , will soon be 29 yrs and won f..k all .
Meanwhile some great days out for us
💙💙💙💙
@@andyniblett8986great days out? Hilarious. And we are deluded? 😂
Hi @eddyvlogsfootball; thanks for an interesting video. From an historical standpoint Birmingham City were first called Small Heath Alliance (SMA naturally being located in the district of Small Heath). Now legend has it that they had a gentleman’s agreement with the team located in the district of Aston (called Aston Villa) not to take the name of the city (which is Birmingham). SMA broke the agreement. Now the two are bitter rivals ever since.
This is pure villa propaganda, it's false. 👍
@@TCPH which part of it is propaganda and which part is false?
@@ilianbh that Birmingham had any agreement with villa about not adopting the city's name. There's no proof of this, just copium from villa fans. Birmingham City adopted its name well before Aston was ever part of Birmingham
@@TCPH Ah yes, Aston became part of the expansion of Birmingham in 1911. Small Heath Alliance adopted the name of Birmingham 6 years earlier in 1905. 👍🏾
look at the history mate, VTID
Villa is massive, UTV from Slovenia!
What's a Slovenia?
@@TCPH not in League 1, haha
@@thinksmart5247 I couldn't name another team from Slovenia apart from Maribor, nobody cares about you bro 👍 name me one street in Aston without using Google. 😭
@@TCPH small heath played Maribor few years ago, that is why you remember it... i don't care about you or your little club either. Only Bruce can save you, hahaha. Stuck forever in the shadows of the Villa.
How are you able to stay in the rotunda and those nice tower blocks.we lived ladywood winson green and could never live there.how expensive is that
Villan here.
Nice video n I'm glad you have love for the City of Birmingham and your club, that's nice 👍
I find on the whole the Villa Blues thing is always about banter and friendly rivalry because we all have friends and sometimes family from the other side and throughout the year we always give each other stick but on the whole we all know each other.
The major difference is a derby day match.
When it's actually a game between Villa n Blues the day itself is intense, the tension is electric and nobody wants to lose.
Villa got 4th and qualified for champions league this season while Blues got relegated to league one and of course we at Villa celebrated that and had a laff about it but in reality most Villa fans would rather see Blues do better because we miss those match days.
Those couple of seasons we shared in the Championship were wild and great days playing Blues and West Brom.
So let me get this right… you moved to Birmingham and chose Birmingham city 🤣🤣🤣 I feel for you so much 😢 UTV SOTC but don’t ever forget….. THE CITY IS OURS 💜💙 MIND THE GAP 😂
Muppet! It’s amazing how all the villa fans come out the woodwork when they win a few games and do well. Vile park was empty in the championship, whereas Birmingham City has a top fan base. We know we are shit …. But we are on our way back.
Our average attendance for the 3 years in the pathetic championship was 32,000 while your average attendance just for this season alone is… wait for it🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 16,758 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Next?
And on your way back 😂 Back to where? League One 1️⃣ THE THIRD TIER 😙 💜💙
Jog on…back to Staffordshire
@@secretpolice6322 lol case rested. The ground it what 43k capacity! So out your 32k average attendance, 5k would have been away fans, so 27k villa fans! Where’s the rest of them? Lol 😂. Anyway lads enjoy your big days out getting battered by a Greek pub team, you will be an embarrassment to English football in the champions league! But you can keep our spot until we are there in 2 seasons. 😂 SOTV.
Small Heath fc,the blues original name are full of hate for Aston Villa cos they've always played 2nd fiddle to Villa & they can't handle that fact,so the hate is returned by Villa. Aston Villa is one of the biggest/most successful clubs in English football & former champions of Europe, we've won 7 English champions titles,7 FA Cups,5 League Cups,1 European Cup,1 European Super Cup,2 intertoto European Cups,1 Charity shield & 2 division 2 titles,1 division 3 title. The blues have won 2 league Cups in 149 years of their history & the only pathetic boast the blue noses have is their 2nd league Cup was won more recently than Villa's last trophy, well just about as Villa's last 2 trophies were 2001/2008 intertoto European trophies & Villa's last domestic trophies were league Cups in 1994/96,so Villa won 2 league Cups in 3 years,it took the blues 149 years to win the same 2 trophies, sad,eh? Villa are far ahead of Small Heath in every possible metric & there is no comparison in the stature of these Birmingham based clubs,maybe an elephant in Villa to a mouse in blues,but deluded blue noses will never admit that fact in which causes them pain & spiteful hatred towards their far bigger neighbours in Aston. While Villa will be mixing it up next season with Europe's finest, the blues will be getting batterd in division 1,England's 3rd tier football league. Enjoy your lovely trips to Stockport,Exeter etc,so exotic!!! Hate will eat you up & hasn't brought anything positive to your small club,acceptance might be less painful long-term....up the fuck'in Villa!!! 💜💙💪😀✌️
Spot on well said 👍
All you care about is trophies won. If villa were historically shit, no-one would support them. That's why your fans are fickle cuz when youre not getting success, you have no reason to cheer for a team representing an area you're not from. None of you are from Aston or give 2 shits about Aston. Frustrated gloryhunters
Still living in the past then 😴😴😴😴😴😴
Loving ur vids mate I’m from paisley Scotland myself and Celtic supporter but Aston Villa are my second team since John Gregory was manger in 1998 still not gonna make me not like ur vids though 😂😂
Villa are the Irish club in Brum ☘️
@@clario2178 didn’t know that thanks 👌👍
Small Heath fc are the small irrelevant shit club in brum. 😂
@@clario2178 wtf no they're not 🤣 Blues is on the doorstep of Digbeth, a historically Irish area
Villa claim to be the irish club but yet celebrwte and let the royals in with open arms lol bit backwards lads
Aston wasn’t part of Birmingham until til around 1911, that is why!
Champions league for Aston Villa 🤯
Copa90 really did the derby no justice in this video
UTV
Is that a Birmingham city scarf on the wall or is it toilet paper 😂
The thing is , we work with each other the following day and have to live with that 😂
Nah B-lose fans don't work !!!
you know when you pick teams in the school playground and theres always a couple of fat kids to choose at the end ? well those fat kids went on to form Birmingham City. True story
If villa folded tomorrow blues could go on for a thousand years and not achieve what we have. UTV💜💙
Yet you're still concerned 😉
Hahaha mate any villa fan that is 28years or younger have never seen there team lift a trophy, fucking tragic for such a succesful club you claim to have😂.
Are you broken? Did you read what I put, hardly concerned about a league 1 team😂😂
Eventually Blues and the villa will be the true teams from Birmingham to be beating all the other city's that represent there backgrounds regardless
Manchester?
Small club, small mentality, Small Heath UTV
Atleast ya not a glory hunter 😂 KRO 🔵⚪️
Is that your trophy board behind you utv,utv,utv,utv,utv
The only way Birmingham city be better than villa is they do a man city Chelsea or Newcastle and even if they win more trophies than villa witch is highly unlikely I go to a scum Birmingham city fan and say congratulations you brought the trophies 😂
You spent 400mill and still have no trophy, vile can't even buy a fucking trophy lool tragic
Small heath...small club. UTV.
Blues fans are bitter twisted and jealous. Its funny.
😂😂😂😂😂😂
Small heaf alliance so obsessed 😂😂😂 well be playing Madrid, barca, Milan next season while you lot will be playing Lincoln away 😂😂😂
im a huge fan of aston villa i grew up in bordsley green as a villa fan while around the corner st andrews was there i went to many villa vs blues and my first game was when dion dublin headbutted robbie savage that was crazy any way blues are shit there in league one while is villans sit in 4th place and we got champions league SHIT ON THE CITY UP THE VILLA (@Eddy Vlogs Football you chose the wrong side)
I will be right
Great video bro. Great message. Keep racism out of football. As always Up The Fucking Villaaaaa
Nice but sorry for you but like you said you like football but you made wrong decision to follow blues. You should’ve went to Villa Park instead, like your channel surprise to the blues for everyone says good Derby when we played together, hopefully soon we will
You chose poorly.
Enjoy league 1 my guy 😂😂😂
Grealish does what he's told and it's affective
Birmingham are not Villa's rivals, they're our neighbours. Big difference. It's a shame they don't spend more time supporting their own club rather than obsessing about Villa. It's a point not lost on some of their more educated fans. Until that massive cultural shift happens they'll always be at best a yo-yo club, at worst, irrelevant. Villa fans may say they hate Birmingham but in reality it's more amusement which is why the derby is still important to Villa, who would want to lose to such a little club? It would be embarrassing.
The amusement is with us ,I assure you 💙
Up the villa champions league baby the City is ours
Aston isn't a city as far as I'm aware
Don't fool yourself
Eddie keep with the royal blue rather than that shite in b6 down the road kro
Battle of Birmingham 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 there is no Battle, Villa conquered the midlands LOOOOOOONG ago. the blouse should concentrate on Walsall, closer to there level
Its not a battle of birmingham ...only one team in birmingham , factually
Blues best non league team ever...
Great video Eddy. UTB SOTV KRO
💙🤍💙🤍💙🤍💙🤍