iCon M+ vs P1-M - Which DAW Controller Is Better?
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 7 ก.พ. 2025
- The iCon P1-M is iCon's Newest Device they have put out, full of revolutionary features that changes the game completely on DAW Controllers period! But... How does it compete with a traditional DAW Controller Style, like it's Legacy device, the iCon Platform M+ ?
P1-M on Amazon: amzn.to/3VHZYzM
Platform M+ on Amazon: amzn.to/3RuEMuL
Like, Subscribe, & HIT THE BELL!! 🔔
♪♫♪ To Learn EVERYTHING On Making Music: JustinOmoi.com
► Spotify: open.spotify.c...
I just found your channel and videos today and all I can say is I know a troll when I see one! This guy is a comedic genius
:D
So glad to see you back on that regular posting
Thanks! I'm trying my best though, I still have some side-projects to deal with before I'll be able to get a lot more done here
Cool review! Personally, I’m happy with my Platform M+ and see no need to upgrade. It just works and these new features seem to be not that significant. And I would hate the placement of those play/stop buttons. Def keeping the old one
Ayee! I am glad that this video was able to reach a fellow Platform M+ user :D
I totally feel you on that! Sometimes, having too much can be.... too much!
It's a give and take though. I appreciate you commenting ^_^
@@OmoiSenpai exactly! The metering would be nice though. Personally I’m using a streamdeck as well to use shortcuts. So the touchpad feels a little useless
I guess the only positive part would be that the touchpad is on the device, whereas, the Steamdeck is a further reach, and to me, pressing those buttons are a bit awkward compared. My Brother owns one, and idky but I have to cup my hand around it to press on it.
I definitely want to grab one, but after using the P1-M, it's definitely lower on my priority list of things to grab for now.
@@OmoiSenpai haha yes I do the same thing to press it. And yeah, if you have the P1-M, no need to get one now haha
Thanks for the comparison! Are the detachable displays interchangeable between the models? 🤔
You're welcome! The Display Accessories have a different port between the Platform M and the P1-M.
The P1-M uses a Type C port whereas; the Platform M+ uses an older port that Honestly I am not sure what it's called. Looks like an old Thunderbolt port? I am not sure at all
@@OmoiSenpai Thanks for the reply! 👍 Thunderbolt, in any of its iterations, would seem like an overkill for the purpose; maybe it's a proprietary connector.
Go Upstate!
Thanks for this. I'm thinking about getting a DAW controller of some kind at some point.
Hehe :D Glad the video gave you some insight! Either way you go, just know that having your hands on motorized faders will feel so much better than a mouse and doing it one at a time!
Can either controller manage third-party plugins, such as an EQ, within FL Studio?
The P1-M Does have an option to give you control banks, where you can link the controller knobs with the 3rd Party Plugins. When you use the Override Generic Link function in FL Studio, they will stay there, even when you close FL and open a new project!
With The M+, I believe it is possible, but there are a bit more hoops to jump through to get that Banking function, which honestly wouldn't be worth the effort to do.
I get your point on the clicking part when it comes to like changing the channel insert but think of automation wouldn't you want it to be smooth
But But... Clicky :D lol true that though!
can u expand the p1-m in fl ? and use them both as a main unit and its expansion ?
You can use the P1-M and it's Extender (The P1-X) in FL Studio. Maybe it can be done with the Platform M+ with the P1-M too. I'll see. I'll make a video about it for tomorrow!
Faderport 8 and softube console fader mk 3
I have the Platform M+ and love it. full size motorised faders and all the useful controls right there on each channel. Agree with your points on the master fader, seems unnecessary, especially as it's incompatible with ProTools master fader. I have upgraded my Mac and this control surface is no longer compatible with either the M4 processor or Sequoia :(
Something to be aware of.
Mac's latest Processors since their integration back in 2020-ish? idr but ever since They switched out Intel, they steadily have issues with compatibility with programs. =/
reached out to Icon support and they totally hooked me up. All up and working. Customer service winning!! +100, would buy again.
Great stuff !
Thanks Ian ^_^ I am glad you liked it!
that was helpful
Do it automatically sync to FL mixer and playlist or do you have to set it up?
I have the V1-M and love a lot of its new features :) There are still one or two bugs that irritate and the fact that it does not have the colour going through from cubase is annoying and that the 2nd strip does not work in cubase also.:( Maybe in the future... And as for the Job Wheel :( Just way to sensitive at the moment
Hey! Aww nice. I saw the V1-M through iCon's TH-cam Channel, but it looks too big for my setup. But man that Jogwheel looks like it's comfortable!! ^_^
As for the Color Scribble Strips, for FL Studio, it is not there as well under the legacy Mackie controller script, BUT it is possible to create a script that shows it. I've tested an unfinished script from a developer, and the scribble strips does show up!
That is one thing that these Midi Developers lack on the most, the scripting section to have their devices compatible with every DAW as best as they could be. It's simply too much for their focus, which sadly diminishes their first appearances for the core audience.
Hello. Thanks for the video. Can you transpose scenes as to manipulate more channels (eg. 16/24/32 channels)?
Hello. If you mean to move the fader banks, so like from faders 1-8 to 9-16 then 17-24 etc then yes! They both have the ability to move the faders over either 1 bank, or 8 banks forward or backwards.
@@OmoiSenpai thanks for the info man!
No problem :D
❤
Kool BTW We dont say YOU ORK We say New YORK "R is silent Hommie 😁
Shieed it's been a minute since I been back over that side! I be buggin! ^_^
Do it automatically syncs to FL mixer and playlist or do you have to set it up manually?
Automatically! When you set up the controller type to the Mackie Control Universal, it will automatically do it's thing ^_^