@@mikeoz4803 That's right - expecting them to embrace the AUSTRALIAN culture, _not a sub group of paper Australians,_ with no real loyalties or understanding of the existing culture *which actually built the infrastructure, has been trampled on.*
Try moving from the sunshine coast to Melbourne....culture shock, more like an earth quake. Boy, did I feel like a fish out of water, did not recognise anything about the place...especially the language... wasn't English!
I understand that lady. I went to school in the 70's and 80's. Most of the students were Anglos. It's human nature to be more comfortable with your own kind
I am also in that boat, as at least a 5th gen Australian, *its not about feelings... Its about Culture.* And the deliberate destruction of what made Australia - Australian! _(So we could be part of the new world order! They made economic trade their God, and gave up who we are.)_
A thing! A character of our nation! What the..I remember when speaking the english language was beaten down as a requirement to enter this country..big mistake...sometimes I feel like I am the foreigner, people speaking in front of me in a language I dont understand...my grandfather did not loose both of his feet in the trenches for this "multiculture" he fought for Australia...screw multiculture its disrespectful....
But we have the Islamic culture dictating and in no way submitting to the culture already established and working to beneficially to any belief or culture
I am Sri Lankan and have always embraced multiculturalism and I also embrace the English race and what they have contributed to Australia. I share their values and freedom. All migrants to this blessed country should be grateful for the comfort and support afforded to them and should not try to undermine the culture and values that should be embraced. May God bless this country and all who dwell in it.
Whilst allowing cultures into Australia who assimilate and add to our culture is a good thing. Multiculturalism has gone way to far when we see thousands of Pro- Palestinian protesters on the streets week after week after an atrocity in another country Its gone way to far when a Muslim kid stabs a Syrian Christian Preacher and our Police who did the right thing and arrested the assailant are attacked by hundreds of Syrian protesters with many Police injured and Police cars damaged! I congratulate her for being brave enough to speak up on the woke lefty ABC
And now the Weather: A chance of rain across Our "Boundless plains to share" in 35 languages. Not one of them Indigenous Australian! Shame on you! Ref: 2nd verse Adv Aust Fair.
As a once great supporter of Australia, there is nothing "fair" about Australia *anymore* - Now we are controlled by laws derived from outside our borders.
From the personal perspective of how Ive been treated in Australia, with racist slurs and physical abuse in my teen years for my English /Irish culture. The irony is those using the slurs and abuse have roots from the same origin.
It is a perverted mind set being taught by the government - at the schools - _In reality the result of what they get is always the opposite to the name they put on it._ From a 60yo with five children, all of us life time Australians.
Multiculturalism only works under a dominant or foundational culture. One of the reasons why Anglo-Celtic tradition survived and thrived in the past was its inclusive nature. However, I’m afraid that that kind of inclusiveness has turned into self-destruction. When plenty others have been trying to suppress other cultures, it’s the Anglo-Celtics absorbing all of them. The positive impact is tremendous, let us appreciate it again.
I disagree with that questioner, though not with her right to question. I haven't watched Q&A since Stan Grant/the producers threw an audience member out for daring to ask an uncomfortable question. Never forget.
The funny thing is it is the British who classified everyone, and came up with this multiculture, selecting people carefully and making sure their culture is the mainstream while allowing only very few little ingredients from other cultures. 😂
@@TheRastacabbage Some are "better" (More egalitarian, fair, just) and some are more tyrannical (authoritarian, controlling, domineering, restrictive, intolerant). People prefering the latter fall into Com... Marx... Fash... isums. _And should be rejected._
Kudos to the ABC for allowing dissenting views and having commentators from both left and right wing. How about Sky News try this for once instead of just giving one sided bias right wing views?
Very true. Although the same cannot be said of principles, these vary significantly. If you regard slavery as a moral evil, it would be a mistake to assume all other humans likewise consider it an evil.
He didn't say it wasn't. He just explained that some cultures don't see slavery as bad and plenty of countries still engage in the practice. Just because you find a moral issue with it doesn't mean everyone has the same morals as you. This is why multicultural countries always fall into chaos because of the vastly different morals.
Give that woman a BIG pat on her back,she has said what many people think.GOOD on you ,and Australian 🇦🇺 hero
,
Actually no one was ever asked if they wanted multiculturalism.
Well said that lady.
Ali never addressed the womans concerns. Typical.
It's never ever worked anywhere in the world .
John Howard said it right..multi ethnic under 1 culture...but that's not happening so let's put the brakes on it
Howard brought in the Sudanese & muslims!!
@@mikeoz4803 That's right - expecting them to embrace the AUSTRALIAN culture, _not a sub group of paper Australians,_ with no real loyalties or understanding of the existing culture *which actually built the infrastructure, has been trampled on.*
She’s right.
When will they defund the ABC.
Multiculturalism is racism dressed in a nicer sounding word, this is how i've always experienced
Where are you? (edit, not interested in what these idiots or Q+A Panel think)
Maybe you're own beliefs are influencing your experiences.
Exactly. And who could come up with this if not the most racist people in the world? The British 😂
Try moving from the sunshine coast to Melbourne....culture shock, more like an earth quake. Boy, did I feel like a fish out of water, did not recognise anything about the place...especially the language... wasn't English!
@@JustNanJustSoap So nobody in Melbourne speaks English? What other whoppers you got?
I understand that lady. I went to school in the 70's and 80's. Most of the students were Anglos. It's human nature to be more comfortable with your own kind
I am also in that boat, as at least a 5th gen Australian, *its not about feelings... Its about Culture.* And the deliberate destruction of what made Australia - Australian! _(So we could be part of the new world order! They made economic trade their God, and gave up who we are.)_
@@martinrayner6466 Benzos & ECT:STAT!
Good on her for expressing an opinion, to which she's entitled to. Last i looked, this is a free and democratic country 😂
well, you haven't looked for a while.
@@christophermay4540 this country is a free country even if there's a noisy minority😂😂
I agree with her Good on her .
I NEVER watch the Australian Bullshit Corporation!
A thing! A character of our nation! What the..I remember when speaking the english language was beaten down as a requirement to enter this country..big mistake...sometimes I feel like I am the foreigner, people speaking in front of me in a language I dont understand...my grandfather did not loose both of his feet in the trenches for this "multiculture" he fought for Australia...screw multiculture its disrespectful....
Where can you leave comments re anything ABC because on TH-cam the comments are always closed
So is Channel 7, 9, 10 and SBS
_In law it's called the _*_lie of omission._* It appears all the sighted media outlets fall into that category.
But we have the Islamic culture dictating and in no way submitting to the culture already established and working to beneficially to any belief or culture
Didn't think there were Elephant Scrubbers in the First Fleet
I am Sri Lankan and have always embraced multiculturalism and I also embrace the English race and what they have contributed to Australia. I share their values and freedom. All migrants to this blessed country should be grateful for the comfort and support afforded to them and should not try to undermine the culture and values that should be embraced. May God bless this country and all who dwell in it.
Whilst allowing cultures into Australia who assimilate and add to our culture is a good thing.
Multiculturalism has gone way to far when we see thousands of Pro- Palestinian protesters on the streets week after week after an atrocity in another country
Its gone way to far when a Muslim kid stabs a Syrian Christian Preacher and our Police who did the right thing and arrested the assailant are attacked by hundreds of Syrian protesters with many Police injured and Police cars damaged!
I congratulate her for being brave enough to speak up on the woke lefty ABC
Why is it "a good thing"?
@@JohnSmith-ux3tt "Assimilate and Add" are the key words there! And by the way environmentally were full.
And now the Weather: A chance of rain across Our "Boundless plains to share" in 35 languages. Not one of them Indigenous Australian! Shame on you! Ref: 2nd verse Adv Aust Fair.
As a once great supporter of Australia, there is nothing "fair" about Australia *anymore* - Now we are controlled by laws derived from outside our borders.
Onward Christian Soldier!
Amen.
From the personal perspective of how Ive been treated in Australia, with racist slurs and physical abuse in my teen years for my English /Irish culture. The irony is those using the slurs and abuse have roots from the same origin.
It is a perverted mind set being taught by the government - at the schools - _In reality the result of what they get is always the opposite to the name they put on it._ From a 60yo with five children, all of us life time Australians.
"Its who we are"
Sounds like a cult.
Multiculturalism only works under a dominant or foundational culture. One of the reasons why Anglo-Celtic tradition survived and thrived in the past was its inclusive nature. However, I’m afraid that that kind of inclusiveness has turned into self-destruction. When plenty others have been trying to suppress other cultures, it’s the Anglo-Celtics absorbing all of them. The positive impact is tremendous, let us appreciate it again.
I disagree with that questioner, though not with her right to question. I haven't watched Q&A since Stan Grant/the producers threw an audience member out for daring to ask an uncomfortable question. Never forget.
The funny thing is it is the British who classified everyone, and came up with this multiculture, selecting people carefully and making sure their culture is the mainstream while allowing only very few little ingredients from other cultures. 😂
You mean they looked and saw that certain cultures are better than others
@@TheRastacabbage Some are "better" (More egalitarian, fair, just) and some are more tyrannical (authoritarian, controlling, domineering, restrictive, intolerant). People prefering the latter fall into Com... Marx... Fash... isums. _And should be rejected._
@@TheRastacabbage name the cultures that are better than ours.
@@stoptheworldIwanttogetoff ours?
What all 3 of their viewers?
Multiracial YES; Multicultural, NO.
Kudos to the ABC for allowing dissenting views and having commentators from both left and right wing. How about Sky News try this for once instead of just giving one sided bias right wing views?
Amd do t you have your own crap to deal with instead dealing with America...
We all sleep, eat, love and hate..., we are all human. Unless your a alien from another planet, i doubt they are much different.
Very true. Although the same cannot be said of principles, these vary significantly. If you regard slavery as a moral evil, it would be a mistake to assume all other humans likewise consider it an evil.
@@patrickhenry7721 hurting people for your own pleasure, is evil.
He didn't say it wasn't. He just explained that some cultures don't see slavery as bad and plenty of countries still engage in the practice. Just because you find a moral issue with it doesn't mean everyone has the same morals as you. This is why multicultural countries always fall into chaos because of the vastly different morals.
@@istoleurteacup yes
Just look at reality - people can be very different.
She should be ashamed of herself. Education system has failed her.
_How dare she speak her mind, from a life times experience, and not theoretical experiments with culture._ *More power to her.*
@@martinrayner6466 less power to her from god as she can’t embrace multiculturalism. Shows her age. Totally out of touch from this world
Real Australia has had enough of this crap, and the ABC. If the 7 viewers of that taxpayer funded mess Q&A want to scream, who gives a stuff.
I stopped watching ABC several years ago, too much woke and queer stuff