He wasn't right about everything. He wanted to protect the group, but he also would abadon a little girl in the woods. While Rick made hard decisions Shane made the easy ones thinking he would keep the group safe.
@@Dead.Vibrations bro its not abandoning if the girls has been missing for a week. A typical police search, if someone goes missing, you’ve got 72 hours and after that you’re looking for a body. But in a world full of billions of things trying to eat you and you’re a completely inexperienced 10 year old girl….. you’re done Also, was he or was he not right about Sophia being dead? She looked pretty dead to me
@@trips347 so what if Sophia actually did go missing. Never to be found. Would they have spent years on that farm looking for her? Absolutely not! Because at a certain point, you have to realize that it is entirely possible for her to be dead. She isn’t worth risking EVERYONE else’s lives
The Governor is easily the most shocking and real villain of all the seasons, a psychopathic, manipulative man whose desire for power left him insanity, being responsible for two towns/civilizations fell for seeking the "Governor's" personal goals of revenge.
most villains are broken, Gareth was tortured along with his family and friends when they were trying to help people, the Governor lost his wife before the zombies, then his daughter, then his daughter again, and then his whole community....twice.
@@letmetakeyoufaraway7035for real, both times the Governor lost his community it was his own doing. Martinez’s camp because he led them into a suicide mission for no good reason, and Woodbury he literally genocided the whole town himself
So much so he tried to sexually assault her at the end of Season 1. Yeah everyone can brush it off as a "drunken mistake" but what happened happened, and I don't even like Lori, but it doesn't make it right though.
@@rickydickydoohdahgrimes well like I said, this is the point where he was going mad,and I guess he did it for revenge that he shot Carl too.All in all,Rick impacted his actions a lot.
@@rickydickydoohdahgrimesit was either Shane dies or he dies survival Shane offered to be left behind but Otis was taking to long to make a decision so Shane just made his own choice
@@alliii835 The Governor is a better villain. He became a villain and died a villain. Negan was more of a smart ass antagonist that soon became a anti-hero. The Governor couldn't be redeemed, end of story.
@@cypressbbq no he isnt, he may be more evil and psychotic, but he had far less of an impact on our characters than negan did, negan is more powerful, charismatic, and complex, making him the best antagonist of the walking dead
@@alliii835 The Governor is far more charismatic and has more class. He met Rick face to face and alone in a barn with whiskey while Negan had to ride with his men for protection. Negan is a child compared to The Governor. You really wanna talk about impact? The Governor changed EVERYTHING. He killed Hershel which established an end of an era and forced the group to become the beasts which they were in season 5, having to survive Terminus. If not for The Governor, Rick and his group could've lived a relatively peaceful life in the prison. Even in gun fights, The Governor stands in the open and not behind cover like Negan. The only advantage that Negan had was his numbers. The Governor was a one man army and crushed walkers with his bare hands like nothing. Not to mention that Negan's arc was fucking boring and the saviour war even more boring. The Governor had better character writing and didn;t overstay his welcome.
@@cypressbbq the governer is not charismatic, charisma is a trait that makes you like someone, which negan had mastered, the governer was extremely easy to hate and his motives were substandard, he is just a really awful and psychotic person, but thats not the only criteria for a good villain, the governer met rick face to face? So did negan, 3 times, and the governer had his men there too, lets not pretend that the show has horrible writing to send the governer alone as if he is bulletproof, negan created the most tense episodes in the history of the show , and possibly tv, the only thing that came close to that was when the governer had hershel and michonne on their knees, and even then the reason that wasnt as suspenseful as 7x1 is because the governer is fightable, negan at that time was thought to be the most powerful man in the continent and maybe even the planet, and the way he demoralized our characters and made rick his bitch was something the governer could never do, if the criteria for a good villain was being psychotic and a “one man army” then beta and carver would be at the top of that list too, but no, there are so many factors and negan has them all ticked, not to mention the fact that negans arc being boring had nothing to do with negan himself but the horrible writing the show had during those seasons, even then, negan was such a good villain he still had some of the most tense and memorable scenes we’d seen, everytime he came to alexandria, his fights with rick during the war, as well as the finale of season 8, were all memorable moments of the show, bottom line is negan is definitely the best villain of the show, he had a much larger impact on the characters to the point where they kept him alive even though he committed monstrous acts, hes more complex and was much more scary, making him the best antagonist in the walking dead.
In a way i can see why shane lost his shit man got mixed mesages from lorri one min she was all loved up with him the next "oh sorry my husbands still alive cant see you no more" cant blame a guy for catching feels after how many months
Not quite Merle at first only care for daryl And he wanted rick and his group to suffer Then it had his redemption Shane only opposed rick That makes him an antagonist but merle was a villain because he wanted to hurt more people than only the protagonist
The absolute level of delusion of Shane simps to try and pin this on Lori. Shane told Lori that Rick was dead. She was in her right to start a relationship and in her right to end it when she found out he lied. Shane being a violent simp for a girl with no interest in him is entirely on Shane.
@@sernoddicusthegallant6986well she tried to manipulate both of them to kill each other it wasn’t just shame who was in a relationship with Lori, Lori accepted it, criticized Rick when killing Shane even though he was a loose end to the group. So yes it was Loris fault for manipulating both to kill each other.
@@sernoddicusthegallant6986and she had interest in him just stopped when Rick got there and decided to cause even more problems. I get Shane was obsessed with Lori but she was the one who went straight back to Rick not telling him she was pregnant And that she had a thing with Shane, if they explained it sooner Shane wouldn’t have been obsessed as much, Rick wouldn’t have had To kill him so her not telling him all that was the main reason Shane had to die making Lori the villain not Shane he was manipulated into trying to kill Rick by Lori. Stop defending her she was a nuisance from the get go.
Sorry to break it to you but Negan is better than Shane by so much shane was only good for season 2 and governor was only good in season 4 Negan carried almost half of the show. And I have 80% of twd fans to back me up on that
Joe is probably one of the most underrated characters in the whole show. Him and The Claimers felt like what would be real if awful people joined together in the apocalypse which would absolutely happen. Him and Shane were probably the most realistic villains in the entire show. They aren't the best but they are damn near close to it. I mean, the Governor and Negan are just a blast to watch and definitely my favorites but Joe had that sense of realism, same with Shane who would probably be 2nd or 3rd best. This list id good but Id put Joe and Gareth a bit higher. Also thank you for putting some respect in Beta and Shane's name.
Literally every single person had their reasons for doing what they did except Pope. 😂 He just simply wanted to kill them lol and his people attacked first.
@@Dutch329 exactly, Gareth was great and so was Owen, but to me Joe is the most underrated. Not the most compelling antagonist but his code of conduct and the fact that he’s the most realistic in this list makes him scary. Plus I feel like he’s basically a dark mirror for Daryl. He shows up right when Beth is taken, and Daryl could’ve became just like him had he not been reunited with his family
Shane is literally just a minor villain to Rick. What him the hardest villain to defeat was because he was Rick’s partner and best friend. It’s sad that it turned out that way.
![บุษบา - เมนทอล [Official MV]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/IGnWPokSEis/mqdefault.jpg)
Nice seeing people actually respect shane.
Ikr
Except he’s not a villain.
@@trips347 Exactly
@@trips347 he was a villain in rick's eyes
@@Homophobic_racist_sexist Then how do you explain Rick’s hallucination with Shane in season 9?
Shane and governador 🗿🍷
Not shane💀💀💀
@@swedishboy5649Bro what Shane was a good villain but people’s opinions are people’s opinions
@@FishyCola hes so overrated bruh
@@swedishboy5649 overrated, his char dev is one of the best in twd
True lol
S1 Villain: Walkers
S2 Villain: Shane Walsh (Atlanta Camp)
S3 Villain: The Governor (Woodbury)
S4 Villain: The Governor (Woodbury)
S5 Villain: Dawn Lerner (Hospital)/ Gareth (Terminus)
S6 Villain: Owen (Wolves)/Negan Smith (Saviors)
S7 Villain: Negan Smith (Saviors)/ Jadis (Trash People)
S8 Villain: Negan Smith (Saviors)
S9 Villain: Beta and Alpha (Whisperers)
S10 Villain: Beta and Alpha (Whisperers) and Pope (Reapers)
S11 Villain: Lance Hornsby (Commonwealth)
u forgot simon
And Joe
What? Reapers don’t appear until season 11
@@darkmatter8712yea part a of season 11 is reapers
@@sq33p87 but they don’t appear at all on season 10, season 10 is just whisperers
its so nice seeing simon getting appreciated every so often
By the way
Shane his strength is overrated
People say that is stronger than daryl and merle in a 2v1
@@Among.us85literally 1 guy said that
@@Among.us85 Its not, He literally carried a probably 6'3 giant Ed to beat him up.
Negan And governor are Best
No
Governador yes
Governor is definitely the best Villian and Shane is the best Antagonist
Negan>vali
@@honoredtoast382governador💀
I’m so glad they put Shane at number 1, amazing character and my all-time favourite.
Negan should be number one. He literally broke Rick's spirit and made him his bitch
Blud how Shane ur fav. And how tf he at number 1 over Negan…
@@BloonMaster36 yeah negan is the best he is the only one to truly defeat Rick. He begs and cries when he tried to make him chop his sons arm off
NGL Shane was just ahead of the group
Shane ain't no villain, he was right about everything but the group was just too pussy to admit it. Season 5 Rick is the same as season 2 Shane
Rick in season 5 was even more unpredictable and brutal than shane. Problem is Shane adapted way faster than Rick and rest of the Group.
He wasn't right about everything. He wanted to protect the group, but he also would abadon a little girl in the woods.
While Rick made hard decisions Shane made the easy ones thinking he would keep the group safe.
@@Dead.Vibrations bro its not abandoning if the girls has been missing for a week.
A typical police search, if someone goes missing, you’ve got 72 hours and after that you’re looking for a body. But in a world full of billions of things trying to eat you and you’re a completely inexperienced 10 year old girl….. you’re done
Also, was he or was he not right about Sophia being dead? She looked pretty dead to me
@@yourdailydoseofnegativity8964 Bruh it doesn’t matter. You can never know 100% that she’s dead.
They needed to know.
@@trips347 so what if Sophia actually did go missing. Never to be found. Would they have spent years on that farm looking for her? Absolutely not! Because at a certain point, you have to realize that it is entirely possible for her to be dead. She isn’t worth risking EVERYONE else’s lives
Shane is a really big influence especially when he died
My top 5
1: the governor
2: Negan Smith
3.Beta
4. Shane Walsh
5: Alpha
ili fix it 1 simon 2 simon 3 simon 4 simon 5 simon the goat = simon
@@aa_th_ees2808Simon fanboy? Wsg my G
For me, Shane isn't a villain. He's advance when it comes to surviving. If Dale only let the kid to be killed, he and Shane could still be alive.
I agree, Shane’s downfall was his obsession for Lori
@@RADU-Edits23bro shut up people do things for love but yea it wasn’t ok
@@shade2785wdym shut up, he tried murduring his best friend just cuz he was a simp for lori, and a bunch of other things that werent ok lmao
@@shade2785Get out of your fantasy world
Shane defenders conveniently forgetting his creepy obsession with lori to say hes just like rick
The Governor is easily the most shocking and real villain of all the seasons, a psychopathic, manipulative man whose desire for power left him insanity, being responsible for two towns/civilizations fell for seeking the "Governor's" personal goals of revenge.
Shane : let me tell you something 😂
Who is that? Huh whoo is thatt (starts running) 💀
@@Leo.Messi.3010STOP I CAN HEAR HIM SAYING THAT 😭😭😭
Owen was not a villian, he was just broken, but then he snapped back and sacrificed himself for Olivia
most villains are broken, Gareth was tortured along with his family and friends when they were trying to help people, the Governor lost his wife before the zombies, then his daughter, then his daughter again, and then his whole community....twice.
It was Denise not Olivia
oh yeah@@unknown_user4463
@@hylianmango8272 I'd agree one Gareth but not the Governor man. His level of insanity was too much even for what he had been through
@@letmetakeyoufaraway7035for real, both times the Governor lost his community it was his own doing. Martinez’s camp because he led them into a suicide mission for no good reason, and Woodbury he literally genocided the whole town himself
All is goat
But my favorite is THE GOVERNOR
Finally Shane gets respect. Imagine if he survived until the end and we saw a much better epic end between he and rick. The possibilities
Shane is more like an Anti Hero
Carver is the strongest charecter in whole twd but he is wasted too soon
Governor is the best villain, the episodes 6,7 and 8 of season 4 made this very clear to me
I disagree. Alpha is the only one in this whole show that represents true evil. She was evil even before the outbreak.
Yes yessss Shane best
Shane it a fucking bitch he try to kill Rick just to steal Lori for him he deserves to die what he did to Otis and Rick and Lori fuck Shane 🤬
Yes man
Just imagine how badass Shane would have been if he killed rick and not rick him
He wouldn’t be badass he’d just be an angry psycho who would eventually get the whole group killed by the Governor
Shane was never truely evil, he was just broken inside.
Shane best!
Noo negan
Shane and negan are the best
Don’t forget Alpha, I’d rank her as the second or third best villain in the only series.
@@DrystHawkyour right she is a very good villain
@@Barkitybarkbark out of all of the villains in the walking dead she’s the only one who was truly evil. She was evil even before the outbreak.
@@DrystHawk true
Negan becomes soft later and eventually changes. Governor was evil through and through and he was also a psycho
Shane isn't a villian,he was misunderstood and went crazy because of Lori.
So much so he tried to sexually assault her at the end of Season 1. Yeah everyone can brush it off as a "drunken mistake" but what happened happened, and I don't even like Lori, but it doesn't make it right though.
Yeah, betraying Otis wasn't evil? sure
@@cavaliothorson7755 he just acted recklessly because Rick "took her away" from him.
@@rickydickydoohdahgrimes well like I said, this is the point where he was going mad,and I guess he did it for revenge that he shot Carl too.All in all,Rick impacted his actions a lot.
@@rickydickydoohdahgrimesit was either Shane dies or he dies survival Shane offered to be left behind but Otis was taking to long to make a decision so Shane just made his own choice
I love how half these people died so soon 💀
Finally someone who doesn’t put Negan over the true villain, Governor
Governer is just not as good man
@@alliii835 The Governor is a better villain. He became a villain and died a villain. Negan was more of a smart ass antagonist that soon became a anti-hero. The Governor couldn't be redeemed, end of story.
@@cypressbbq no he isnt, he may be more evil and psychotic, but he had far less of an impact on our characters than negan did, negan is more powerful, charismatic, and complex, making him the best antagonist of the walking dead
@@alliii835 The Governor is far more charismatic and has more class. He met Rick face to face and alone in a barn with whiskey while Negan had to ride with his men for protection. Negan is a child compared to The Governor. You really wanna talk about impact? The Governor changed EVERYTHING. He killed Hershel which established an end of an era and forced the group to become the beasts which they were in season 5, having to survive Terminus. If not for The Governor, Rick and his group could've lived a relatively peaceful life in the prison. Even in gun fights, The Governor stands in the open and not behind cover like Negan. The only advantage that Negan had was his numbers. The Governor was a one man army and crushed walkers with his bare hands like nothing. Not to mention that Negan's arc was fucking boring and the saviour war even more boring. The Governor had better character writing and didn;t overstay his welcome.
@@cypressbbq the governer is not charismatic, charisma is a trait that makes you like someone, which negan had mastered, the governer was extremely easy to hate and his motives were substandard, he is just a really awful and psychotic person, but thats not the only criteria for a good villain, the governer met rick face to face? So did negan, 3 times, and the governer had his men there too, lets not pretend that the show has horrible writing to send the governer alone as if he is bulletproof, negan created the most tense episodes in the history of the show , and possibly tv, the only thing that came close to that was when the governer had hershel and michonne on their knees, and even then the reason that wasnt as suspenseful as 7x1 is because the governer is fightable, negan at that time was thought to be the most powerful man in the continent and maybe even the planet, and the way he demoralized our characters and made rick his bitch was something the governer could never do, if the criteria for a good villain was being psychotic and a “one man army” then beta and carver would be at the top of that list too, but no, there are so many factors and negan has them all ticked, not to mention the fact that negans arc being boring had nothing to do with negan himself but the horrible writing the show had during those seasons, even then, negan was such a good villain he still had some of the most tense and memorable scenes we’d seen, everytime he came to alexandria, his fights with rick during the war, as well as the finale of season 8, were all memorable moments of the show, bottom line is negan is definitely the best villain of the show, he had a much larger impact on the characters to the point where they kept him alive even though he committed monstrous acts, hes more complex and was much more scary, making him the best antagonist in the walking dead.
That top 3 will always be top 3
Major W having Shane and the governer at 1 and 2
A man of culture I see
Nah Negan is hands down the best one the amount of fear he put in people by simply just showing up is insane.
Top 15 Villains Of The Walking Dead
15 Dawn Lerner (Season 5)
14 Joe (Season 4)
13 Owen (Season 6)
12 Gareth (Season 5)
11 Jadis (Season 7 - Season 8)
10 Pope (Season 11)
9 Lance Hornsby (Season 11)
8 Leah Shaw (Season 11)
7 Brandon Carver (Season 11)
6 Alpha (Season 9 - Season 10)
5 Simon (Season 6 - Season 8)
4 Beta (Season 9 - Season 10)
3 Negan Smith (Season 6 - Season 8)
2 The Governer (Season 3 - Season 4)
1 Shane Walsh (Season 2)
0 Walker (Season 1 - Season 11)
9) bro called saul at an inconvenient time
Lmao
That’s Clay Jensen’s dad.
Shane is my favourite character overall. Rick wouldn’t become the ruthless badass he became without Shane’s influence
In a way i can see why shane lost his shit man got mixed mesages from lorri one min she was all loved up with him the next "oh sorry my husbands still alive cant see you no more" cant blame a guy for catching feels after how many months
If shane counts as a villain then merle would count too
Not quite
Merle at first only care for daryl
And he wanted rick and his group to suffer
Then it had his redemption
Shane only opposed rick
That makes him an antagonist but merle was a villain because he wanted to hurt more people than only the protagonist
Yeah he does
Negan is actually just like Rick just looking after us people if u really think about it
Negan and his saviors were terrorists and ruled people through fear
Nah Shane wasn't even a villain he was just 5 seasons ahead of everyone and a bit too obsessed with Lori but that's it
the fact negan and beta carry twd
Ty bro
Governor 😂
@@Reenuldhe looks like a pirate 😂
@@King_midas74 and beta looks like a middle aged man in his mother's basement, and negan looks like a barber who didn't make it 💀
Shane respected and loved by me ❤
Why..?
Shane my fav
I mean, he’s a cool character but he definitely ain’t a good person
Governor easily
Fax
Based
Shane may be a villain In your eyes but I see him as one of my favourt characters ever
Negan litteraly on the top 1
I still refuse to believe shane was villain, he was the best member of the group
Governor was awesome!
He was boring
@@Rickyyy_374L opinion
@@Rickyyy_374LOL 😂
Bro when he just gunned down his own people I was like, this man is next level savage
Nice list! 🔥 Shane is the goat on both the good and bad sides! 🔥
Shane was never a villain, he's more of an antagonist In fact, the best villain in the series is definitely Rick Grimes
The true villian was not Shane, it was Lori, who was the reason of the conflict.
The absolute level of delusion of Shane simps to try and pin this on Lori. Shane told Lori that Rick was dead. She was in her right to start a relationship and in her right to end it when she found out he lied. Shane being a violent simp for a girl with no interest in him is entirely on Shane.
@@sernoddicusthegallant6986well she tried to manipulate both of them to kill each other it wasn’t just shame who was in a relationship with Lori, Lori accepted it, criticized Rick when killing Shane even though he was a loose end to the group. So yes it was Loris fault for manipulating both to kill each other.
@@sernoddicusthegallant6986and she had interest in him just stopped when Rick got there and decided to cause even more problems. I get Shane was obsessed with Lori but she was the one who went straight back to Rick not telling him she was pregnant
And that she had a thing with Shane, if they explained it sooner Shane wouldn’t have been obsessed as much, Rick wouldn’t have had
To kill him so her not telling him all that was the main reason Shane had to die making Lori the villain not Shane he was manipulated into trying to kill Rick by Lori. Stop defending her she was a nuisance from the get go.
he’s against the protagonist which makes him a villain
Also he tried to get handsy with Lori at the CDC, against her protest, which is pretty gross
The governor is for me the best psycho 😈☠️
Jadis is not bad so at first she wanted to kill Rick but she loved Gabriel. Gabriel showed who Jadis really is.
The Go-vo-na is the best, he and gareth are literally representetions of villians
👇who's love Daryl
Shane is not a villain per say, rather an antagonist. There is a slim line between those two.
just like obito kinda
Shane be like trying to kill rick: 👿👿👿👿👿👿👿👿👿😈😈😈🧟🧟🧌🗿
shane was way ahead of his time in how to handle the zombie apocalypse.
Shane>>>>>>>> fax 😜😜😜😜🗿🍷
The governor is 1 stop it
yeah but like, Shane just felt real
@@manOnAboatand governor didnt?
1: Governor
2: Shane
3: Negan
4: Beta
5: Lance
6: Leah
7: Carver
8: Alpha
9: Simon
10: Gareth
My top 5
1. Governor
2. Shane
3. Beta
4. Simon
5. Walkers
Walking dead legend Governor 😈🔥
Negan is Negan, period.
Negan will always be No. 1 for me
Even though he's actually top 3, I respect you for putting Shane at 1.
Shane is not a vilian lori is
Hornsby should be ATLEAST Top 3.
Shane was no villain he was just broken
Shane will always be the goat
Number one:The Governer
Shane>
Hell no lol@@brackus9235
Shane aint even came close to governors crimes
Sorry to break it to you but Negan is better than Shane by so much shane was only good for season 2 and governor was only good in season 4 Negan carried almost half of the show. And I have 80% of twd fans to back me up on that
Guess I'm 20% 😂
Where they at 😂
Yes Negan carried the show, but that says more about the quality of the later seasons than it does about Negan.
You only hate negan cause he killed glenn@@ayemikey4178
Shane is not evil just broken😢
Shane is amazing
Yanliz aralarındaki en güçlü carver
Beta
Governor is best villain
Shane was right about everything rick was weak in season 1-2
Negan, governor and Beta, are the best for me.
Beta straight nr1
such a bad rating bro
Joe is probably one of the most underrated characters in the whole show. Him and The Claimers felt like what would be real if awful people joined together in the apocalypse which would absolutely happen. Him and Shane were probably the most realistic villains in the entire show. They aren't the best but they are damn near close to it. I mean, the Governor and Negan are just a blast to watch and definitely my favorites but Joe had that sense of realism, same with Shane who would probably be 2nd or 3rd best. This list id good but Id put Joe and Gareth a bit higher. Also thank you for putting some respect in Beta and Shane's name.
I don't consider Shane a villain, he did the best for the group, but he was considered selfish
are u still doing shane walsh vs andrew tate?
Shane beats Tate lmao, if it were to happen
@@footedthread9315 shane negs tates dumbass
@@hectorbarbossa4403 Yeah
only until rick's enter.
Yes this channel is definitely not bias or anything
Bro must be high to put shane on the list
Finally, an intelligent individual
Negan the first forever 👌
Literally every single person had their reasons for doing what they did except Pope. 😂 He just simply wanted to kill them lol and his people attacked first.
The Pope was such a stupid villain, doesn’t deserve a spot anywhere this list. He makes Dawn look like a Governor-level villain 😂
@@ndhickson3599 That is so true, literally every person that was ranked below him was better than him lol Dawn was better written than him by miles
@@Dutch329 exactly, Gareth was great and so was Owen, but to me Joe is the most underrated. Not the most compelling antagonist but his code of conduct and the fact that he’s the most realistic in this list makes him scary. Plus I feel like he’s basically a dark mirror for Daryl. He shows up right when Beth is taken, and Daryl could’ve became just like him had he not been reunited with his family
Ótimo vídeo! Meu preferido é o Governador
You should put Ed in number 1 😅
I’m a nice guy
Yea
1. Governor
2. Shane
3. Negan
Am i the only 1 that when i saw joe that i tought *JOE MAMA*
gareth and joel 1
Who's The guy on no.14?? Who's joe ?
Leader of archer's group. Rick kill him in 5 season
The ones who live Jadis🗿☠️
Worst TWD villians: >Dawn(boring) >Leah(Annoying) >Jadis(garbage person)
Finally people respect Shane
Shane is literally just a minor villain to Rick. What him the hardest villain to defeat was because he was Rick’s partner and best friend. It’s sad that it turned out that way.
Honestly, the governor is number one
Bro how is jadis a villain like sure at first she was but she literally saved Rick's life
For real, though the governor was so underrated