I wish that they would have kept Lupin and Tonks alive. After everything they'd been through together, and Lupin getting over his fears of being a parent, their deaths just felt so anticlimactic. Still, perhaps that was Rowling's underlying point, that almost anyone could die in a war.
@@juliamatthews4595 and also because she couldn't part with Arthur as she believed that he was the only really good father/ father figure in the whole series.
What irks me about Remus being killed by Dolohov is the fact that Harry’s defeated Dolohov several times over and could have killed him at any of those times. However Bellatrix beating Tonks is 100% believable. That witch’s skill is insane.
I've said it before, and I'll say it again: the disappointing deaths of Lupin and Tonks always struck me as being the fault of bad writing choices, more than any character's actions. Essentially, it was the opposite of plot armor. From the beginning, I always sense a confrontation looming beetween Lupin and Fenrir Greyback, and we never got it. In fact, not only did Lupin die needlessly, but so did his wife, and Greyback never really got what was coming to him.
I can easily see Bellatrix besting just about anyone because that witch is crazy and has the skill to back it up, but Dolohov killing Lupin with no assistance just seems unacceptable. I would have bet on either Tonks or Remus winning going one on one with Dolohov. He just seems like a lower-tier death eater.
To be fair Dolohov was a legitimate threat to most people. He may have seemed like a low tier soldier, but he was stronger than majority of Voldermort’s supporters. Underestimating your opponent is the number one way you die. While I do believe Lupin was strong enough to go against him and win, him dying is definitely not an improbability either. They were more evenly matched. Bellatrix was definitely insane and strong, and would have beat either one of them.
I actually cried mid-way while watching this. Remus too was my favorite character - my most favorite, in fact. He just lost so much in life and was seen as a monster by many who knew nothing, yet he remained humble and continued to help others in any way he can. He reminds me so much of Kenshin Himura from the anime Rurouni Kenshin, except the fact that Lupin didn't get to livr with the woman he so waited for in his life. It's just really heartbreaking comsidering how Lupin and Tonks were originally gonna survive. I mean, sure - on the bright side, Remus was reunited with his friends whom he considered as family, Sirius, James and Lily, but there could have been much more. He lost the first set of people who accepted him for who he is, and when someone finally did once again after a long time, both he and that person died. Remus lived an unfair life and he didn't live long enough to see the fruits of his labor. If he lived, he could have been the permanent DADA teacher and maybe the prejudice against wizards with lycanthrophy would decrease. There's just so much wasted potential. Remus Lupin was actually one of the characters that made me love Harry Potter more; he deserved so much better. Greyback didn't even got what should have been the punishment for the things he had done.
You have to keep in mind before Teddy was born Remus was malnourished from living amount the werewolves for Dumbledore. That left him exhausted and weak. Then they found out Bellatrix was actively hunting them because Voldemort thought it horrible for a witch to marry a werewolf. The two of them further exhausted themselves putting up protective charms o hidden and protect Teddy and Tonks, not to mention their work for the order. They went into the battle exhausted and weak. I think they both knew they wouldn’t survive that battle, yet they went.
If they stayed home then there would've been more casualties since despite being rusty, they can still hold their own. Every person in the battle matters. Take one or two legs of a chair away, and the whole thing falls. If it was a fragile thing instead (ex. a glass statue), then it'll shatter. Like I said, they've been rusty but still strong. Edward Remus "Teddy" Lupin is Harry's godson so he can tell more about his parents and Teddy is old enough and ready. For now as a small child, Harry and his grandmother Andromeda will tell him some small things.
I honestly think Remus could be a good doctor, in other words a PhD or PSYD. I honestly think that he could also work with students with special education needs. Let’s put it this way, if you were the coordinator of the Blindness And Low Vision program at Missouri State University in Springfield Missouri, yes I would take his classes, and all of them. He’s a great teacher, he’s a great man, and I just love him. The actor is great too. He seems like a father figure for Harry, which is good. I hate that he died, but would’ve loved if he would’ve lived.
The wand would only give a boost to magic he is using. It could potentially if you cast the right spell, but so could a normal wand. It was touched on in the books enough to make sure its understood
Lupin was killed by Dolohov, a character that Harry could've killed numerous times. Had Harry killed Dolohov instead of constantly disabling him, Lupin at least mightve lived and had he lived, he might have been able to save Tonks. The death of Lupin at the very least is 100% Harry's fault.
Bro, this is extremly stupid. Are u tryin to tell me that it is Harrys fault that Lupin is dead bc he didn't killed him months ago?? Ok, Lupin d be probably alive when Harry had killed him instead of obliviate him, but this doesn't mean that it's his fault. You could also say it's lupin's fault bc he lost the duel, but this d be stupid too. Would u say it's Sirius fault that the Potters are dead bc he said them to choose Pettigrew as secretkeeper instead of him?
@@Karol-ei1fc If you have a rabid dog in front of you and the ability to end it's life but refuse and it escapes to maul someone else, are you not at fault? Of course you are. You allowed someone else to come to harm. Harry had every reason to end Dolohov. He knew he would be back and that he would threaten him again. He knew Dolohov was a threat to his friends and family. Yet he let him live and in doing so blames most of the blame for their deaths.
@@TheLastKentuckyIrregular9524 most of the blame is not the same thing like 100% but Ok. But if this is your opinion you must also blame Sirius for James and Lily's death. And in my view its very hard to blame Harry for his death bc it sounds like Harry wouldn't care about Lupin. And in the situation where Harry choose to obliviate Dolohov he couldn't know that Dolohov was going to kill Lupin.
@@Karol-ei1fc He didnt know that Dolohov would kill Lupin. I agree. But he knew from having faced Dolohov before that Dolohov was a threat not only to himself but his friends. Dolohov had already hurt Neville, Luna, Hermione, and nearly just killed Ron. Harry knew he might come back and hurt someone he cared about. He chose not to kill him, and in so doing basically accepted that someone he cared about was likely to be harmed.
@@Karol-ei1fc There is a big difference between what Sirius did and what Harry did. Sirius thought Pettigrew was an ally and recommended James and Lily to ask him for help. Did this contribute to their death? Yes. Was it a stupid decision based on what Sirius knew? I don't think so, although you could argue that he should have known Peter better, but the same could be said about James. Harry knew Dolohov was an enemy and had injured several of his friends and allies in the past including Mad-Eye and Hermione and would continue fighting for Voldemort. Did this contribute to Lupin's death? Yes. Was it a stupid decision based on what Harry knew? Yes, particularly considering the last death eater whose life Harry had spared had played a vital role in Voldemort's return. And why would blaming Harry for Lupin's death mean Harry didn't care about him? Harry clearly cared about Sirius and yet he blames himself for Sirius death, because he allowed Voldemort to lure him to the department of mysteries.
Well done as usual Dean. Their (Lupin and Tonks) were the deaths along side Fred, I truly cried over. They three in my opinion need not have died. Always theorizing as to what would have happened if... Once again thank you and GOD BLESS
I just love your videos. Try to make a video abot what if Remus Lupin was the secretkeeper instead of Peter Pettigrew and Harry would grow up in a time of the first world wizarding war.
It would be very interesting to see what would've happened if some other wizards or witches helped saved Remus and Tonks during the Battle of Hogwarts.
It’s war. hello. It’s not fair, people die. Fred’s death especially. He was blown up while laughing the most awful thing Harry could see right then. It was completely unfair. SO IMPORTANT to the story.
The chief reason at least in my opinion is the Prime Minister of magic Cornelius Fudge. Why you ask. It’s very simple because instead of taking the Actions that Dumbledore recommended I Tom Riddle a.k.a. Voldemort would’ve never been able to get as powerful as he did and a second chance to destroy the entire Wizarding world but instead he just completely blew everybody off including Harry and Dumbledore he ignored all the warning signs he cared more about holding onto his job then doing his job and overall That’s why he’ll forever be known as the man who stepped aside and did nothing in a time in that time of crisis when they needed him to be a leader. If he had then So many lives including Remus and Tonks as well as Albus Dumbledore Fred Weasley Sirius Black Cedric Digory Dobey and so many others could’ve been spared.
I think it is sad that Tonks was killed by her own aunt. It shows that even family members can be mortal enemies when they just happen to be on different sides.
The dilemma you have given is the dilemma facing soldiers in war - should I be at home with my family, or fight for the future of my people? This decision may or may not be driven by delusion. In my opinion, the single biggest weakness in the Harry Potter series is that Harry, Ron and Hermione do not make the decision to use the killing curse. At the Battle of Hogwarts, it is ridiculous the defenders do not use the killing curse, they are now soldiers in a war fighting for the future against great evil. This decision could have been a pivotal point in the storyline and introduced moral complexities and dilemmas. Does it damage the soul to kill in war? If it does should a moral person accept the damage to their soul for the greater good? Understanding they have been wounded by the experience and cannot be made innocent again.
So true!! It was rather idealistic, unrealistic, and immature to have them NOT use the killing curse in the war. Had the Hogwarts army killed a few death Esther’s instead of simply stunning them, less people would have died.
So is Andromeda raising Teddy then? I haven't seen anything about that. I very well may have missed something. Thank you for all your hard work on these videos.
Remus Lupin is definately my favorite HP character ever. I always had a big crush on him. Curiously, I can relate A LOT to Tonks.❤ They had so little screen time 😢 And they shouldn't have died at all. Hope the series correct the screen time part.
You do know that if Harry had stopped Bellatrix at the Battle at the Ministry and the Auroras took her to Azkaban, Voldemort would have just broken her out again or she would have been released once the Death Eaters took over the Ministry? Of course they could have just gave her the Dementor's Kiss.
In my opinion, the only logical reason that Bellatrix was able to kill Tonks is that Tonks was still quite weak from giving birth. If she had fully recovered from birth, it probably would’ve been the other way around. Tonks would have finished Bellatrix. I don’t understand how Dolohov managed to kill Lupin though, maybe he saw Tonks dead before that, and he was not concentrated because of grief, but I’m not sure.
Parents should not leave their children. My dad died in 1986 and I still miss him. And when I don't have Mum anymore, I'll be so upset I'll want my memory as affected as Lockhart's, so I can relive my childhood over and over. I don't regret my attitude, either. Being an adult is not all it's cracked up to be. God's will makes me angry, so I have been an atheist for a long time(I only go to church on special occasions, for the pomp and circumstance, not because I believe). I'm not sorry about my atheism. I'm proud of it. But the point is, losing a parent is hell! And I will be grieving and tearful for the rest of my life.
Honestly, Lupin is one of my least favorite characters. I have no idea why he was in Gryffindor. He was a coward. He didn't prevent the extreme bullying of his friends, and he even continued on with them after Sirius used him as a murder weapon. He tries to abandon his pregnant wife because of his lycanthropy, and he goes to fight because of, again, his lycanthropy believing his wife and son are away from the danger. I also think he was stupid to pull that boggart prank on Snape whom he depended on for his wolfsbane potion. No, I can't stand Lupin.
Harry and Teddy both lost their parents. Harry and Teddy both have great relationships with their god fathers. Both of their god fathers are good/best friends with their fathers. And the Weasleys treat both Harry and Teddy as family. Gotta love the symmetry.
Interesting concept. At the same time do you think an author should rewrite something that has come forth because it's not fair or right? Wouldn't books be so mundane if they did?. We would read nothing but froufrou books. Just my thoughts.
I disagree with implications and notion they dies due being rusty or unprepared. To anyone who has ever been in a proper fight or any sporting competition, knows alot of factors can influence the outcome. We don't know much about the fight or the condition. We do know that it was chaos, spells flying everywhere and people getting injured or killed all around. With all that it takes only take a brief second for the tied to turn. Something could have fallen near by, forcing them to get out of the way but as result lost sight of their opponent for a brief sec. Which was all they need to strike. In corse of the fight the footing could gave way again providing a split second for the opponents to strike. And then their the face we don't know if in corse of their duel they see the other get hurt or even possibly hurt which would most likely get them to loose focus with fear or anger- thereby setting themselves up for a strike from a their opponents. My point is the out come of a duel/ fight is often a impacted by several factors. - all this being said good video and points raised.
Another thing that tonks could’ve survived of is that if Bellatrix was destroyed a couple of hours or minutes earlier she wouldn’t have been able to kill Tonks but at the same time she would’ve been able to do all someone else and might die we don’t know
i would have left to fight too. what's the point in living in a world where you don't really live, you hide? not me i will fight and die to not have to hide
Uh.... "Remus meets the woman of his dreams and falls in love, with Dora?!!" Based on what from the books does he love her, prior to their son being born? Seriously! WHAT?! He never shows any desire for her, he is always arguing against it, or acting depressed about the situation. He never wanted to marry her, or anyone really... But he never showed any desire for her. Dora whined to Molly, and Molly pressured Remus once she knew that Dora was not going to go for Bill. Remus was very much of the opinion that Dora was too young for him, in addition to his being dangerous. Remus even tried to run away from the marriage (and at Bill and Fleur's wedding, Remus showed that he was not happy about being with Dora; he put on a happy front, but then turned away and his face sank), until Harry called him a coward....Harry convinced Remus that he had to take responsibility for his choices, even if he was not happy with his choices...that's the only reason Remus went back to Dora. Once Remus saw his son, he fell in love with Teddy and then chose to love Dora. I'm glad Remus and Dora's "Til death do us part" came quickly, it was a marriage that never should have been. Though I love both characters, I just don't like that Remus was forced into marrying someone he felt was a kid.
I have a question. Did a greater understanding of parenting spark this video? I know when I had my kids, all children became my kids. Sort of. Children's welfare became so much more important to me.
It was rather idealistic, unrealistic, and immature to have the Golden Trio NOT use the killing curse in the war. Had the Hogwarts army killed a few death Esther’s instead of simply stunning them, less people would have died.
I have always been of the school of thought that one should have definitely died and one stay alive. In my view it made sense that Tonks died as she's an Auror. It's literally her chosen path to put her life on the line to capture and/or kill wanted dark witches and wizards. So her death is not at all shocking to me. I jus' hate the fact she died at the hands of Bellatrix. That's the second good blood related Black that she's killed and that jus' hurts me to my core. But Tonks death in general didn't sadden me as much as Remuses. He should have lived if for no other reason than that he coulda been the link between were-kind and wizardkind. He could have shown the wizarding world what it looks like to show someone in his situation compassion & kindness. He could have come back as the DADA teacher now that the "curse" had been lifted with the death of voldermort and been the greatest DADA ever. Then of course he could have been there for Teddy and to a smaller degree her mom Andromeda. This coulda been the beginning of something great but instead he was whacked.
I don't think you need to justify their deaths tbh. It was not in their character to stay out of the fight. Plus, Bellatrix and Dolohiv are probaly the 2 most powerful death eaters there are
If Lupin choice too remain with the Order and still was a combative fighter I don't think it would have change anything. Anton Dolohov I think was just that great of a fighter
To be fair Lastrange and Dolohov were some of the most skilled deatheaters, Voldemort even trained Bellatrix himself and she was very motivated to kill Tonks bc of her sister marrying Ted, and Dolohov even won against Molly’s brothers and Moody, and he had created his own spell.
![[Live] ศึกมหึมันส์มวยไทยสังเวียนเดือด เวทีมวยชั่วคราวสวนสยาม | จันทร์ 30 กันยายน 2567](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/pM1k6f7JXUc/mqdefault.jpg)
I can safely say that Lupin was definitely more of an uncle to Harry than Vernon would ever be.
Anyone would literally be as vernon sucks
I wish that they would have kept Lupin and Tonks alive. After everything they'd been through together, and Lupin getting over his fears of being a parent, their deaths just felt so anticlimactic. Still, perhaps that was Rowling's underlying point, that almost anyone could die in a war.
The point was their death would be painful to readers. Or at least people who cared about them as characters.
No shit lol
The series starts with an orphaned child and ends with an orphaned child, kinda fits
Lupin died because JK was thinking of either killing Arthur (When he was attacked by the snake) or Lupin and since Arthur survived Lupin and to go
@@juliamatthews4595 and also because she couldn't part with Arthur as she believed that he was the only really good father/ father figure in the whole series.
What irks me about Remus being killed by Dolohov is the fact that Harry’s defeated Dolohov several times over and could have killed him at any of those times. However Bellatrix beating Tonks is 100% believable. That witch’s skill is insane.
I've said it before, and I'll say it again: the disappointing deaths of Lupin and Tonks always struck me as being the fault of bad writing choices, more than any character's actions. Essentially, it was the opposite of plot armor.
From the beginning, I always sense a confrontation looming beetween Lupin and Fenrir Greyback, and we never got it. In fact, not only did Lupin die needlessly, but so did his wife, and Greyback never really got what was coming to him.
It's a war. People die needlessly in wars. It would bad writing if everyone survived or those who died all had big heroic deaths
@@mrdr0161 That’s a separate issue, and so your reply is not relevant to the point I was making.
Their death was so sad. The last of the Marauders. It would have been nice if he could have been there for Teddy and Harry.
I can easily see Bellatrix besting just about anyone because that witch is crazy and has the skill to back it up, but Dolohov killing Lupin with no assistance just seems unacceptable. I would have bet on either Tonks or Remus winning going one on one with Dolohov. He just seems like a lower-tier death eater.
To be fair Dolohov was a legitimate threat to most people. He may have seemed like a low tier soldier, but he was stronger than majority of Voldermort’s supporters. Underestimating your opponent is the number one way you die.
While I do believe Lupin was strong enough to go against him and win, him dying is definitely not an improbability either. They were more evenly matched. Bellatrix was definitely insane and strong, and would have beat either one of them.
Dolohov was considered one of the strongest Death Eaters
Just a quick note, I like that Fred died in a random explosion. It shows the true unpredictability and chaos of war. Not every gets a heroic death
i saw the title and pretty much had no choice but to click- i also love remus as a character
I actually cried mid-way while watching this. Remus too was my favorite character - my most favorite, in fact. He just lost so much in life and was seen as a monster by many who knew nothing, yet he remained humble and continued to help others in any way he can. He reminds me so much of Kenshin Himura from the anime Rurouni Kenshin, except the fact that Lupin didn't get to livr with the woman he so waited for in his life. It's just really heartbreaking comsidering how Lupin and Tonks were originally gonna survive. I mean, sure - on the bright side, Remus was reunited with his friends whom he considered as family, Sirius, James and Lily, but there could have been much more. He lost the first set of people who accepted him for who he is, and when someone finally did once again after a long time, both he and that person died. Remus lived an unfair life and he didn't live long enough to see the fruits of his labor. If he lived, he could have been the permanent DADA teacher and maybe the prejudice against wizards with lycanthrophy would decrease. There's just so much wasted potential. Remus Lupin was actually one of the characters that made me love Harry Potter more; he deserved so much better. Greyback didn't even got what should have been the punishment for the things he had done.
You have to keep in mind before Teddy was born Remus was malnourished from living amount the werewolves for Dumbledore. That left him exhausted and weak. Then they found out Bellatrix was actively hunting them because Voldemort thought it horrible for a witch to marry a werewolf. The two of them further exhausted themselves putting up protective charms o hidden and protect Teddy and Tonks, not to mention their work for the order. They went into the battle exhausted and weak. I think they both knew they wouldn’t survive that battle, yet they went.
If they stayed home then there would've been more casualties since despite being rusty, they can still hold their own. Every person in the battle matters. Take one or two legs of a chair away, and the whole thing falls. If it was a fragile thing instead (ex. a glass statue), then it'll shatter. Like I said, they've been rusty but still strong. Edward Remus "Teddy" Lupin is Harry's godson so he can tell more about his parents and Teddy is old enough and ready. For now as a small child, Harry and his grandmother Andromeda will tell him some small things.
I honestly think Remus could be a good doctor, in other words a PhD or PSYD. I honestly think that he could also work with students with special education needs. Let’s put it this way, if you were the coordinator of the Blindness And Low Vision program at Missouri State University in Springfield Missouri, yes I would take his classes, and all of them. He’s a great teacher, he’s a great man, and I just love him. The actor is great too. He seems like a father figure for Harry, which is good. I hate that he died, but would’ve loved if he would’ve lived.
Potential video topic- could Harry have killed Naghini with the Elder Wand? Or destroyed any horcrux with it for that matter...
You can't take Naginis death away from Longbottom, it's his great redeeming moment.
@@kellysouter4381 Didn't say I wanted to. Just that I wanted to know if the Elder Wand was CAPABLE of it.
I think Dumbledore would have used the wand instead of the sword if it were possible.
The wand would only give a boost to magic he is using. It could potentially if you cast the right spell, but so could a normal wand. It was touched on in the books enough to make sure its understood
Lupin was killed by Dolohov, a character that Harry could've killed numerous times. Had Harry killed Dolohov instead of constantly disabling him, Lupin at least mightve lived and had he lived, he might have been able to save Tonks. The death of Lupin at the very least is 100% Harry's fault.
Bro, this is extremly stupid. Are u tryin to tell me that it is Harrys fault that Lupin is dead bc he didn't killed him months ago?? Ok, Lupin d be probably alive when Harry had killed him instead of obliviate him, but this doesn't mean that it's his fault. You could also say it's lupin's fault bc he lost the duel, but this d be stupid too.
Would u say it's Sirius fault that the Potters are dead bc he said them to choose Pettigrew as secretkeeper instead of him?
@@Karol-ei1fc If you have a rabid dog in front of you and the ability to end it's life but refuse and it escapes to maul someone else, are you not at fault? Of course you are. You allowed someone else to come to harm. Harry had every reason to end Dolohov. He knew he would be back and that he would threaten him again. He knew Dolohov was a threat to his friends and family. Yet he let him live and in doing so blames most of the blame for their deaths.
@@TheLastKentuckyIrregular9524 most of the blame is not the same thing like 100% but Ok. But if this is your opinion you must also blame Sirius for James and Lily's death.
And in my view its very hard to blame Harry for his death bc it sounds like Harry wouldn't care about Lupin. And in the situation where Harry choose to obliviate Dolohov he couldn't know that Dolohov was going to kill Lupin.
@@Karol-ei1fc He didnt know that Dolohov would kill Lupin. I agree. But he knew from having faced Dolohov before that Dolohov was a threat not only to himself but his friends. Dolohov had already hurt Neville, Luna, Hermione, and nearly just killed Ron. Harry knew he might come back and hurt someone he cared about. He chose not to kill him, and in so doing basically accepted that someone he cared about was likely to be harmed.
@@Karol-ei1fc There is a big difference between what Sirius did and what Harry did.
Sirius thought Pettigrew was an ally and recommended James and Lily to ask him for help. Did this contribute to their death? Yes. Was it a stupid decision based on what Sirius knew? I don't think so, although you could argue that he should have known Peter better, but the same could be said about James.
Harry knew Dolohov was an enemy and had injured several of his friends and allies in the past including Mad-Eye and Hermione and would continue fighting for Voldemort. Did this contribute to Lupin's death? Yes. Was it a stupid decision based on what Harry knew? Yes, particularly considering the last death eater whose life Harry had spared had played a vital role in Voldemort's return.
And why would blaming Harry for Lupin's death mean Harry didn't care about him? Harry clearly cared about Sirius and yet he blames himself for Sirius death, because he allowed Voldemort to lure him to the department of mysteries.
Title: If they hadn't DIED, they would still be alive
Harry’s godfather was in prison for a dozen years and was able to kick a** using his wand with no problem.
Well done as usual Dean. Their (Lupin and Tonks) were the deaths along side Fred, I truly cried over. They three in my opinion need not have died. Always theorizing as to what would have happened if...
Once again thank you and GOD BLESS
I just love your videos.
Try to make a video abot what if Remus Lupin was the secretkeeper instead of Peter Pettigrew and Harry would grow up in a time of the first world wizarding war.
It would be very interesting to see what would've happened if some other wizards or witches helped saved Remus and Tonks during the Battle of Hogwarts.
So what you're saying is that Harry and Ron's choice to be merciful resulted in the death of good people.
It’s war. hello. It’s not fair, people die. Fred’s death especially. He was blown up while laughing the most awful thing Harry could see right then. It was completely unfair. SO IMPORTANT to the story.
I think Lupin and Tonks might have been better off staying home with baby Teddy and not being part of the Battle Of Hogwarts.
The chief reason at least in my opinion is the Prime Minister of magic Cornelius Fudge.
Why you ask.
It’s very simple because instead of taking the Actions that Dumbledore recommended I Tom Riddle a.k.a. Voldemort would’ve never been able to get as powerful as he did and a second chance to destroy the entire Wizarding world but instead he just completely blew everybody off including Harry and Dumbledore he ignored all the warning signs he cared more about holding onto his job then doing his job and overall That’s why he’ll forever be known as the man who stepped aside and did nothing in a time in that time of crisis when they needed him to be a leader. If he had then So many lives including Remus and Tonks as well as Albus Dumbledore Fred Weasley Sirius Black Cedric Digory Dobey and so many others could’ve been spared.
I can't help but say this, but your right. The boy named Sue definitely hated his name.
Can you please make a video, about what if halfbloods weren't allowed in Slytherin? Then Snape and Voldemort were in other houses.
I think it is sad that Tonks was killed by her own aunt. It shows that even family members can be mortal enemies when they just happen to be on different sides.
Bellatrix killed Sirius too. He was her cousin.
they are the most suave couple. i could see them in modernity with chic style i dunno why.
The dilemma you have given is the dilemma facing soldiers in war - should I be at home with my family, or fight for the future of my people? This decision may or may not be driven by delusion.
In my opinion, the single biggest weakness in the Harry Potter series is that Harry, Ron and Hermione do not make the decision to use the killing curse. At the Battle of Hogwarts, it is ridiculous the defenders do not use the killing curse, they are now soldiers in a war fighting for the future against great evil. This decision could have been a pivotal point in the storyline and introduced moral complexities and dilemmas. Does it damage the soul to kill in war? If it does should a moral person accept the damage to their soul for the greater good? Understanding they have been wounded by the experience and cannot be made innocent again.
So true!! It was rather idealistic, unrealistic, and immature to have them NOT use the killing curse in the war. Had the Hogwarts army killed a few death Esther’s instead of simply stunning them, less people would have died.
So is Andromeda raising Teddy then? I haven't seen anything about that. I very well may have missed something. Thank you for all your hard work on these videos.
Moral is Finish off your enemies or they will pursue you and the people you care about until they succeed
Please make a video of what if potters return
at least remus is reunited with his best friends :,)
Remus Lupin is definately my favorite HP character ever. I always had a big crush on him. Curiously, I can relate A LOT to Tonks.❤
They had so little screen time 😢
And they shouldn't have died at all.
Hope the series correct the screen time part.
You do know that if Harry had stopped Bellatrix at the Battle at the Ministry and the Auroras took her to Azkaban, Voldemort would have just broken her out again or she would have been released once the Death Eaters took over the Ministry? Of course they could have just gave her the Dementor's Kiss.
They would've given her the dementors kiss like they did with Barty. She was in azkaban for the same crime he was
Lupin is really the best HP character, by far. He and Tonks should have had a happy ending. Plus, they were almost left out from movies. Why? 😢
In my opinion, the only logical reason that Bellatrix was able to kill Tonks is that Tonks was still quite weak from giving birth. If she had fully recovered from birth, it probably would’ve been the other way around. Tonks would have finished Bellatrix. I don’t understand how Dolohov managed to kill Lupin though, maybe he saw Tonks dead before that, and he was not concentrated because of grief, but I’m not sure.
It's clearly Harry's fault, if he hadn't talken some sense into Remus, maybe he would have run away 😂 just kiddin', I love Remus
Parents should not leave their children. My dad died in 1986 and I still miss him. And when I don't have Mum anymore, I'll be so upset I'll want my memory as affected as Lockhart's, so I can relive my childhood over and over. I don't regret my attitude, either. Being an adult is not all it's cracked up to be. God's will makes me angry, so I have been an atheist for a long time(I only go to church on special occasions, for the pomp and circumstance, not because I believe). I'm not sorry about my atheism. I'm proud of it. But the point is, losing a parent is hell! And I will be grieving and tearful for the rest of my life.
Honestly, Lupin is one of my least favorite characters. I have no idea why he was in Gryffindor. He was a coward. He didn't prevent the extreme bullying of his friends, and he even continued on with them after Sirius used him as a murder weapon. He tries to abandon his pregnant wife because of his lycanthropy, and he goes to fight because of, again, his lycanthropy believing his wife and son are away from the danger. I also think he was stupid to pull that boggart prank on Snape whom he depended on for his wolfsbane potion. No, I can't stand Lupin.
Can't like this video. TH-cam won't let me. Sorry
Harry and Teddy both lost their parents. Harry and Teddy both have great relationships with their god fathers. Both of their god fathers are good/best friends with their fathers. And the Weasleys treat both Harry and Teddy as family. Gotta love the symmetry.
Interesting concept. At the same time do you think an author should rewrite something that has come forth because it's not fair or right? Wouldn't books be so mundane if they did?. We would read nothing but froufrou books. Just my thoughts.
I disagree with implications and notion they dies due being rusty or unprepared. To anyone who has ever been in a proper fight or any sporting competition, knows alot of factors can influence the outcome. We don't know much about the fight or the condition. We do know that it was chaos, spells flying everywhere and people getting injured or killed all around. With all that it takes only take a brief second for the tied to turn. Something could have fallen near by, forcing them to get out of the way but as result lost sight of their opponent for a brief sec. Which was all they need to strike. In corse of the fight the footing could gave way again providing a split second for the opponents to strike. And then their the face we don't know if in corse of their duel they see the other get hurt or even possibly hurt which would most likely get them to loose focus with fear or anger- thereby setting themselves up for a strike from a their opponents. My point is the out come of a duel/ fight is often a impacted by several factors. - all this being said good video and points raised.
Another thing that tonks could’ve survived of is that if Bellatrix was destroyed a couple of hours or minutes earlier she wouldn’t have been able to kill Tonks but at the same time she would’ve been able to do all someone else and might die we don’t know
You should give your opinion on do u think Dumbledore always knew Sirius was innocent
What if harry was harriet book 1 to 7. "You look so much like your mother.. except your eyes, you have your fathers eyes"
I love this channal
i would have left to fight too. what's the point in living in a world where you don't really live, you hide? not me i will fight and die to not have to hide
But...wasn't Teddy just a few months old infant at this point? No one gets rusty that fast after years and years of action?
I think this deaths are the must nonsensical of the book, actually they felt poor written and cheap.
I think you should do a Voldemort vs. Bellatrix
Fabulous! Reds going to Paris and then one of your videos covering a subject that always saddened me. Great insight.
You should do what if harry was a twin so lily jumped in front of them both and they both have to kill Voldemort
The moment I see the title, I clicked
I read too many fics where they are still alive to cope...
Uh.... "Remus meets the woman of his dreams and falls in love, with Dora?!!" Based on what from the books does he love her, prior to their son being born? Seriously! WHAT?! He never shows any desire for her, he is always arguing against it, or acting depressed about the situation. He never wanted to marry her, or anyone really... But he never showed any desire for her.
Dora whined to Molly, and Molly pressured Remus once she knew that Dora was not going to go for Bill.
Remus was very much of the opinion that Dora was too young for him, in addition to his being dangerous.
Remus even tried to run away from the marriage (and at Bill and Fleur's wedding, Remus showed that he was not happy about being with Dora; he put on a happy front, but then turned away and his face sank), until Harry called him a coward....Harry convinced Remus that he had to take responsibility for his choices, even if he was not happy with his choices...that's the only reason Remus went back to Dora.
Once Remus saw his son, he fell in love with Teddy and then chose to love Dora.
I'm glad Remus and Dora's "Til death do us part" came quickly, it was a marriage that never should have been.
Though I love both characters, I just don't like that Remus was forced into marrying someone he felt was a kid.
Here before comments are disabled
Maybe if the order of the phonex destroyed the horcruxs every one would be alive idk🤷♂️🤔
The Order did not know Voldy had made horcruxes. That information was only known by a few people, like Dumbledore and the Trio
Is there any news on the Riddle Animated Series??
How could Albus Dumbledore of lived
Hate that they were taken from us:(
I like this video thank you
Well, they were part of the Order & had to fight for what was right.
Don’t call me nifadora 😂
Lol
Lmao
do a video with noman Osborn and tanks
Respect ✊
Ouch 😣
Thanks for the video Dean!!
👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👌👌👌👌👌😎😎😎
I have a question. Did a greater understanding of parenting spark this video? I know when I had my kids, all children became my kids. Sort of. Children's welfare became so much more important to me.
It was rather idealistic, unrealistic, and immature to have the Golden Trio NOT use the killing curse in the war. Had the Hogwarts army killed a few death Esther’s instead of simply stunning them, less people would have died.
I mean dueled
I have always been of the school of thought that one should have definitely died and one stay alive. In my view it made sense that Tonks died as she's an Auror. It's literally her chosen path to put her life on the line to capture and/or kill wanted dark witches and wizards. So her death is not at all shocking to me. I jus' hate the fact she died at the hands of Bellatrix. That's the second good blood related Black that she's killed and that jus' hurts me to my core. But Tonks death in general didn't sadden me as much as Remuses. He should have lived if for no other reason than that he coulda been the link between were-kind and wizardkind. He could have shown the wizarding world what it looks like to show someone in his situation compassion & kindness. He could have come back as the DADA teacher now that the "curse" had been lifted with the death of voldermort and been the greatest DADA ever. Then of course he could have been there for Teddy and to a smaller degree her mom Andromeda. This coulda been the beginning of something great but instead he was whacked.
Equally, I’m kind of happy Remus died because he was reunited with his two best friends James and Sirius
Lupin will always be my favourite character in harry potter. 🥰
Good video
Lovely!! As always (I love Shockwave too!! Your new stuff is awesome!)
" Others will tell him what his mother and father died for one day he'll understand!!!!!"
What if Harry Potter fought Voldemort in the first war?
You mean Time Travel?
why did i imagine tiny baby harry waving a wand at the dark lord 😭😭
@@Panther-Strife4724 yes
@@mauraaa2988 that sounds adorable
By time Turner do you mean? I think they can be dangerous.
I don't think you need to justify their deaths tbh. It was not in their character to stay out of the fight. Plus, Bellatrix and Dolohiv are probaly the 2 most powerful death eaters there are
No shame in losing to them. Bellatrix went after Tonks specifically if I remember correctly
Quality over quantity brah
Love ur videos!
First
If Lupin choice too remain with the Order and still was a combative fighter I don't think it would have change anything.
Anton Dolohov I think was just that great of a fighter
Wolfstar
To be fair Lastrange and Dolohov were some of the most skilled deatheaters, Voldemort even trained Bellatrix himself and she was very motivated to kill Tonks bc of her sister marrying Ted, and Dolohov even won against Molly’s brothers and Moody, and he had created his own spell.
Could you do a video on what if Harry grabbed the Triwizard cup alone without Cedric
What if Cedric became a vampire in Harry Potter I mean the actor that played him was a vampire in another movie