Budget Light Showdown: Colbor CL60 vs Amaran 60x S vs Zhiyun Molus G60
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 6 ก.ค. 2024
- * BEST PRICES I KNOW ABOUT *
COLBOR CL60 - geni.us/pCxnUJ or howl.me/ckzFcZsCOEN
AMARAN 60x S - geni.us/Bp9AoUK or howl.me/ckzFcZl2PW0
ZHIYUN G60 - geni.us/xFjA or howl.me/ckzFcZ9Btfz
CHEAP, BUT GOOD, REFLECTOR - geni.us/zJZK7RM or howl.me/ckzFcZTbUfF
GEAR I USED TO MAKE THIS VIDEO
[VIDEO GEAR]
A Camera - geni.us/fCo6 or howl.me/ckVm0lD1bLa
A Lens - geni.us/w3Oak or howl.me/ckVmU6LbhHv
B Camera (Table Top) - geni.us/3deXcAQ or howl.me/ckVm4MAPaVI
B Lens - geni.us/z0GG3y
C Camera (Wide View) - geni.us/FOSOn
C Lens - geni.us/nF6Hxa
On Camera monitor - geni.us/ZJVKX
My off camera monitor - geni.us/AHOu
The LUTS I used for this video - bit.ly/42Q58uQ
[AUDIO GEAR]
Microphone - geni.us/SAQ4uk7
Cheaper alternative to studio mic (sounds just as good) - geni.us/0rN8FO
XLR Audio Recorder - geni.us/yDUf
USB Audio Interface - geni.us/ZdN1a
Wireless Microphone (out of studio) - geni.us/XFnz
Podcast/Voice Over Mic - geni.us/SAQ4uk7
Podcast Boom Arm - geni.us/J7Fp
Editing Headphones - geni.us/WmwFC
Editing Speakers (super cheap but awesome) - geni.us/wfLkz
Stand for Boom Mic and Overhead Camera - geni.us/8O8UtdY
[LIGHTING]
Main Light (Key Light) - geni.us/nQQ10
Main Softbox - geni.us/GysBN
Light Stand (for Key/Main light) - geni.us/y4HuK4R
Hair Light - geni.us/waB7lTp
Background Light - geni.us/xFjA
Hair Light - geni.us/waB7lTp
Light Tubes (behind my monitor) - Small - geni.us/5Lvl Large - geni.us/4QPjp
[COMPUTER AND EDITING]
Monitor - geni.us/AG7b6u
Computer - geni.us/rOHA
Dock (one plug for power, audio, monitor, and 6 hard drives) - geni.us/lwJDmz
Keyboard - geni.us/bA16W
Touchpad - geni.us/PLaLMh
Editing Software I Use - www.apple.com/au/final-cut-pro/
Awesome Free Editing Software (Pros use it!) - www.blackmagicdesign.com/prod...
* Some links are affiliate links, you do not pay any extra, but I may get a small commissions. Using these links allows me to make more videos like this one.
00:00 - They Are NOT All the Same
00:24 - Disclosure
00:49 - How Bright Are They?
02:21 - The Problem With Reflectors
04:11 - How Bight Do YOU Need the Light?
04:53 - Build Quality
06:23 - Portability/Travel/Power
09:38 - Bowens Mount/ZY Mount (IMPORTANT)
11:50 - Pricing
13:35 - Fan Noise
14:18 - Interface/Ease of Use
17:20 - Nato Rails and Light Stand Mount
19:05 Color Accuracy and Skin Tones
20:30 - Which One Should YOU Get? - แนวปฏิบัติและการใช้ชีวิต
* BEST PRICES I KNOW ABOUT *
COLBOR CL60 - geni.us/pCxnUJ or howl.me/ckzFcZsCOEN
AMARAN 60x S - geni.us/Bp9AoUK or howl.me/ckzFcZl2PW0
ZHIYUN G60 - geni.us/xFjA or howl.me/ckzFcZ9Btfz
CHEAP, BUT GOOD, REFLECTOR - geni.us/zJZK7RM or howl.me/ckzFcZTbUfF
That was such a useful, in-depth comparison, thank you
I used both Amaran and Colbor. I really like Colbor's form factor, mount and rails. Amaran has advantage of the eco system, so I'm switching to them. If it were just about these two, I would go with Colbor.
Amaran's advantage of ecosystem will even increase, quite drastically. Aputure recenty acquired Prolycht, a company with their own lights, but more importantly, they have really thought up and advanced color science. Prolycht also provided Dedolight with their color engine and cooperation will continue, most likely there will be direct cooperation between Dedolight and Aputure.
Bought the COLBOR CL100X instead of the 60W and its just slightly bigger but BRIGHTER. 100% recommend.
The brightness is a factor for me because I use the light as a bounce light off a ceiling where the white ceiling is the diffuser.
Works great in hotel rooms with the ladies...
the most useful comparison yet, thank you very much!
Thank you for testing brightness properly and also discussing how much brightness you really need for a scene!!!
What is the most amount of sunlight you'd be able to use these lights with? Or how would you think about using one of these lights if you also have daylight in the scene?
Great review! Thank you!
I was thinking about buying the Colbor Cl60r, but now I might choose the Amaran 60xs because of the mounting bracket. I want to mount the light on a ball head :/
Someone did it.
Cheers so much for all your hard work very nicely done 😊
I'll wait until I get my camera and might end up either getting or skipping these ❤
Yea, it was a lot of work. Thanks for the comment.
as always i think you are one of the best reviewers in youtube, i always watch your reviews before buy something cause you feel super reliable, thanks so saving me money many times!!
I will say this is the best comparison on TH-cam for these portable cobs!
not only you compare the light without reflector, you also add a proper bowen softbox for the measurement
AND you even compare the size with their stand and bowen adapter! Thank you so much!
also have you try Nanlite FS-60B?
not a small light but still compact, plus it's cheaper than Godox sl60s and can be controlled by bluetooth app, kinda underrated
So kind of you to say. The thing about lighting videos, on TH-cam, is that they are hard to do well, and even when you do, the views are not great. So they rarely repay the time the take to make. All these lights have app control now, I should have mentioned it. The Nanlite stuff is great, but does tend to cost more. The FS-60 is very highly regarded.
@@markwiemels agree I think TH-cam algo put the lighting stuff behind other gear idk why... anyway I guess since all these light have common strength the colbor with pd powerbank/npf plate is the sweet spot!
Thank you for the review! I already have Colbor CL60M and pretty happy with it!
Please, consider making a review of Colbor CL100X
You are most welcome. Thanks for the suggestion.
Great comparison. One thing I noticed you didn’t mention was the swivel stand/mount on the zhiyun. Could that be used to mount to a light stand? Also how do these compare to the Godox ML60bi. I currently use them to light weddings and they are mostly good but one has stopped working after a year so I’m looking at a replacement.
Watt is actually a great way to compare the brightness, just look at the bare bulb test vs wattage
great review!
Might want to look at the Sutefoto 100 watt RGB and CCT light.
What would be good light stands for these lights? I’m considering mainly the Amaran or Colbor, but I can’t find any info on what stands are recommendable.
Can you mount an umbrella to the colbor light stand?
Hi, Just a question. Currently owned a colbor cl60 and update the firmware using colbor edgemax but stuck in 0%
Just in time was thinking of Colbor 60 for my YT setup. Can you also add Ulanzi 40w in comparison next time as these 60 watts are overkill for small studio especially when you want 2, to illuminate both sides equally.
Thanks for the comparison.
These aren't really over kill though. They should probably go through modifiers and get negative fill to prevent spill.
I wish seen this video before... I bought the amaran, but, today, I would bought the colbor, because I want to buy the cl220 and cl330 and do a Colbor Light Ecosystem, that is way cheaper than a Amaran Light Ecosystem... Just for that
Yah, that makes sense. The Colbor stuff is hard to beat at the prices. I was actually very surprised, I expected the build quality, or light quality, to be poor, given the price, but I can’t fault it.
I think you're in the right system. It's so much more robust and will continue to be innovative in the future.
Subscribed!
Interesting review on color and brightness accuracy. I appreciate the other points being made. Being more objective and using a light meter would provide more useful info. Just bought the Colbor CL60 this afternoon and have been testing it to see what I bought. At 6,500 k setting, the measured CCT is 5,810 k, with Lumu light meter, and a meter away. Lux. is @ 1,833 lx, less than 2,082 lx advertised on their site. To make it close to the daylight 6,500 k, one needs to crank the green all the way to +10, max., in the settings. But, if you don't have a light meter, you are clueless on what you are seeing.
At 2,700 k setting, the measured CCT is 2,630 k, with 1,419 lx. CCT is much closer at this setting. If you are a foot way from the LED, the CCT is better, but still falls short at 6,110 k, when set for 6,500 k. Lux. is at 21,220 lx in this situation. I was reading on their site that the CRI is at 97+. I just don't see that happening in this situation. Guess this thing will be going back to Best Buy.
You really need a spectrometer to know this with any real accuracy. They cost $2000, and I don’t have one, if you’re testing with the in-camera custom white balance, the accuracy tends to be highly variable and something you can’t really trust. Best best is to find a review that tested with a spectrometer.
True. Others use such equipment in video and photo editing rooms, where light is important, as well. Some might not have a camera, or even a light meter. I do know that my light meter out in bright daylight it reads almost spot on, with +/-100 k, so I trust what it measured in this case. Was really looking forward to using the light, but will have to go back. @@markwiemels
I saw a review of the Amaran 60x showing a horrible (half) battery life compared to similar 60w models (Godox, Nanlite).
Did you test anything about battery life maybe?
I didn’t test that. It’s a good question to ask.
The G60 is great, but after owning it for a while, the bowens mount absolutely sucks. Plastic, and broke already. Not great.
Gonna buy the 60x now.
Funny, my Sirui C60B cob light seems to have just fell under the radar of everybody although it actually very recent budget light, why is that?
I think they just haven’t done a great job of promoting the light, that’s all.
Thank you. Well done video. But, I disagree about color. I think it's a much bigger deal than you're making it here.
That’s the purpose of the sample footage, so everyone can see the results. I can’t pick them apart, and even the manufacturers rating of the lights are so close that I wouldn’t expect there to be any obvious difference.
The thing ist the Lightquality below 20% Output. Most budget light tend to be horrible at low outputlevels. The Molus G60 ist one of them. There is no point using it a very low power setting.
The Interface of the Molus is better than statef here. It also got Quick Settings if you just press the knobs down. And a fiddly Studio Mode, so the light turns on and off, if you cut Power.
You should really be aware about color accuracy on low Power settings, because might dont want to use them, with a 20Watt powerbank anymore 🎉
Colbor es bueno y cuesta menos
this video was made in 2023..still use laptop charger? for high wattage power supply? come on.. there are so many mini 65w GaN charger. for anything under 65w is so small and slim. you can carry 6of 65w charger for the size of G60 light itself. no one carries stupid bulky laptop charger anymore…it’s mean quite while….do some research on type c power supply or charger. I have 275w type c 8port charger and it out puts 65w for multi port. and it 1/3 size of zhiyun G60. it can power up 4 G60 lights at the same time.