ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 18 ก.ย. 2024
- Liz Garbus’ two-part documentary, Who Killed Garrett Phillips?, outlines the series of events that led to a murder, a wrongful arrest and the police cover-up that almost took a man’s life. In the studio is his lawyer, Mani Tafari.
#112BK #Justice #Documentary
We want to hear from you! Send tips, comments, compliments, and/or complaints to 112BKcomments@bricartsmedia.org.
Hosted by MacKenzie Fegan.
--
This video is from BRIC TV- the first 24/7 television channel created by, for, and about Brooklyn. It is the borough's source for local news, Brooklyn culture, civic affairs, music, arts, sports, and technology. BRIC TV features programming produced and curated by BRIC, an arts and media nonprofit located in Downtown Brooklyn, NYC.
Watch more Brooklyn-centric content from BRIC TV:
112BK: bit.ly/2FE17yY
BHeard: bit.ly/2Hw9Gws
Going In With Brian Vines: bit.ly/2CVnM7K
B-Side: bit.ly/2Iqzzz6
Check out more from BRIC:
/ bricartsmedia
Connect with us:
/ brictv
/ brictv
/ brictv
BRICartsmedia.o...
Waiting 35 minutes for the landlord to arrive is what killed that boy ...
When every second counted in saving that boys life there was a police officer DOING NOTHING right on the other side of that door.
For the cost of a replacement door that officer allowed that boy to die.
The cops and D.A in that town are retarded
Yes exactly this is my son's cousin we are devastated we just want who did it behind bars. This broke our hearts! This was a horrible way to die. He didn't deserve this, people heard him scream and no one helped him! I honestly think the cop killed him and they took forever too get too Garrett! Garrett we have your signs posted all over. We miss you.
Yes they let him die! I wonder what what through his mind knowing he was dying. Ugh he would be 18 now! Justice for Garrett it's sad enough his daddy died when he was little from a anersym! Justice for Garrett! I'm sorry tandy shouldn't of had him living with her he and Garrett didn't get along
@@trailer_trash_Barbie Is it true that JJ threaten to kill her and the boys?
Maybe the officer already knew who was behind the door.
Nick picked up on the fact that that interview was going to become a problem when Gary Snell read him his Miranda Rights then they got mad when he stopped talking to them. I will never, ever, forget this documentary. Good job Brother Mani
I doubt this big black man got into that apartment unseen.
Exactly while people was outside. The sad thing is the people outside head Garrett screaming for his life
Nick did it.
You mean like how Nick showed up in the apartment in the middle of the night even though he didn’t have a key? Who saw him then?
@@emilyjones5830 Keyword,NIGHT.
@@emilyjones5830 so you’re telling me that without a shadow of a doubt that the cops wasn’t tryna set him up.
This is so sad bc this prosecutor said they were not going to pursue anyone else. She is basicly letting the real killer go free!!
@@sweetpea6814 yup
It's crazy how the supposed "Protectors" are the biggest violators of the law...
Definitely john Jones did it,or got someone else to do it.
Possibly got someone else to do it. I was convinced it was him until, the evidence came out to the contrary. He was seen on at least 4 cameras walking his dog and was only off camera for 1 min. Which... is a little suspicious in itself. It’s almost like over compensation, like “look at me I’m on camera I couldn’t have done it! See?!”
I’m not entirely convinced Hilary didn’t do it but if I had to bet I would probably say, Jones getting someone to do it.
Nick did it.
@@emilyjones5830 will you be a one woman jury your verdict?? Please!!
@@6ixStringStudio how are you not convinced Hillary didn't do it?
@@SombraLocs do you believe in coincidences during a timeline of a murder ? The daughter texting Nick what’s for dinner .. after nicks story clearly says he was eating with his daughter .. pulling left toward the direction of Garrett skateboarding .. instead of his normal route going right … the ankle injury … I mean come on
Watching that documentary I believe John jones did it he gives me the chills. Dude is legit so creepy the more it goes on.
I agree.
Both Nick Hillary and John Jones had motives and were physically in the same location that the homicide occurred...also both Nick and John had leg injuries but looks like they never investigated Jones even though surveillance footage shows him pulling into his driveway the same time as Garrett is skating home...meaning Jones saw Garrett when pulling into the driveway
Was he the one sitting in a car waiting for him to follow him from that school the day of the murder? Nope
Actually, he was sitting in his car waiting for the child to go by his house... last time Garrett was seen alive, Sheriff was in the video frame. Nice try though.
Look at the ex boyfriend the cop.
Nick did it.
th-cam.com/video/8P31StnKKNE/w-d-xo.html
Im form LatinAmerica, i saw the documental in HBO and is obviously it was the sheriff
THE END
EL FINAL
I think the same that you
Go home
I rarely go this deep into a case but the intelligent, clear cut presentation drew me in. How was that DNA on the window not HUGE enough to send the cops looking for another suspect? How could they disregard the smoking gun? As a white woman who dated the only black man in a small town, I am grateful Mr. Hillary was acquired and wish him well!
Well you clearly haven’t looked into the case as much as you said… you only have watched bias videos like the one above…. Maybe keep an open mind no matter what color their skin is….
As a black man DON'T GO LIVE IN A SMALL TOWN AND DATE A HIGH PROFIL WHITE WOMAN.A BANK MANAGER.STAY AWAY FROM THEM.
HE IS LUCKY HE DIDN'T LIFE OR 25 IN PRISON.FROM THE GET GO YOU CAN SEE A BOTCHED INVESTIGATION
@@garykrum6134 Do you do that?..I doubt it.
Why is it that Nick was deemed the crazy jealous ex who couldn’t get over Tandy and not Jones. Jones was placed at the scene of the crime, but DA Rain forgot to turn over that evidence. FOH! Tandy filed complaints against Jones’s harassing her and she was in fear for her life and those of her children. Prior to the murder, Tandy was still texting Nick, inviting him to join her at a club. Jones was a little salty bish who murdered Garett. Think of the night of the murder and how he called his girlfriend to let her know that he would be SPENDING THE NIGHT WITH TANDY to comfort her. Next morning he turns up holding hands with her as she talks to investigators. Are you joking 🙃??? 100% scandalous altogether. The best thing Hilary ever did was opt for a bench trial and skip the jury , whom by the way were comprised at least 2 people who were close friends to The Phillips & DA Rain.
th-cam.com/video/8P31StnKKNE/w-d-xo.html
People are coddling a child killer. He was obsessed with garret’s mom and felt garret was in the way
To be truthful I go back and forth about the who killed Garett. There is a possibility that Nick is innocent as the police had tunnel vision and the first interview with him was so bad and inexcusable. I didnt understand why people still focused on Nick till I read through the evidence and the deposition where he gave statements. Nick does lie and some facts do not makes sense about his movements that day. He turned left instead of right out of the parking lot. His ankle was sprained and he had a abrasion on it. The DNA evidence wasnt used in court but in first DNA test, 6 out 15 markers match and 2nd DNA test match 9 out of 15 markers, which doesnt meet the requirement. The third test only can tell the probability of the dna evidence and its 1 to 30 million. The dna evidence is so small that they probably are unable to have another test. Problem is when you look at the case, they dont have any physical evidence that prove beyond a doubt about his involvement. Its correct that he should be pursuing a lawsuit against the police and the court acquitted Nick of the murder charge. I am still unsure whether he killed Garett.
I think with the above problem its difficult to reinvestigate Garett case.
Here's a theory. The downstairs neighbours who are Dexter fans killed Garrett.
Motive: the kid was a little sh!t, liked to play pranks, could have easily annoyed neighbors.
Means: As Dexter fans, they could probably come up with a way to do it without leaving a trace.
They also controlled the narrative when he was discovered. They rang the police, they said they heard the door lock, when they could have pulled it shut before the police arrived.
While the police were there, they were directly downstairs and could have had tapping the roof with a broom to mimic someone moving around up stairs.
Their alibi wasn't checked. Did they actually watch Dexter. Was it on tv that night?
It was so weird that woman mentioned they were Dexter fans when making reference to a murder case. Really cringeworthy.
Lmao! That was the first thing my aunt said! And I told her she was crazy. She was like “I bet it was those Dexter freaks” 😂 now I’m not so sure she’s crazy. Seeing as how others (you) have brought this up. 🤔
No. Dexter aired the night before. They must have taped it but why? That episode aired on a Sunday night and the boy was killed on Monday night. They didnt have time to watch on a Sunday night? Weird.
Anyway, I thing JJ did it.
@@bakerman1971 if they were big dexter fans they would watch it when it aired right?
I’m late, but the door was dead bolted. So if they were both in there they were both going out that window.
Mary Rain said she knew 1 of the jurors....I couldn't believe she actually said that on camera! She clearly was not thinking.
I originally believed Nick was innocent. The more I’ dug, I am convinced Nick is guilty. You leave an out a lot of facts which clearly show your agenda . Nick made a left turn from the high school parking lot right after Garrett made a left turn. Nick’s house was a right turn. Why was Nick following Garrett home?
I learned so so much from watching the HBO Documentary Parts 1 and 2, and think that the documentary is an excellent teaching tool for African Americans.
There are lots of issues inside this story. And you know how they say... Keep your friends close but your enemies closer! When you have lots of money and power you will do anything to use it. Totally capable of hiring someone to do the job. It's sad knowing we still have people of authority not working for the needs we have today! Specially to protect our children!
Lots is money and power ? Huh
It's because alot of witnesses have ended up as the suspect and confirmed as the killer.
framing a HOOKUP and removing KIDS is a great way to get a slore back. My opinion
Hare Krishna.
That female prosecuter said she knows for a fact 100% that it was Nick BUT. reporter didn't ask her how she knew to be a fact just other than he turned left on that street? How could she be sure of it unless she was psychic????
Shameful behavior of those who are supposed to uphold the law insisting on his guilt without any evidence.
1. Nick and Garrett are at odds, so much so, that Garrett's mom tells Nick she must end the relationship for this reason.
2. Police ask family who had an issue with Garrett, only one name comes up, Nick.
3. Nick goes to the highschool to watch a soccer game but does not park where he can see the field.
4. Nick claims to be waiting for the rain to break before going to the soccer field, yet only waits 6 minutes before leaving.
5. Nick just happens to leave exactly after Garrett passes him in the parking lot.
6. Nick claims to have gone home yet does not go right towards his house, but left following Garrett, towards the murder scene.
7. Nick and his lawyer contradict each other as to his reason for turning left.
8. Nick claims to be at home with his daughter discussing what they will have for dinner while the murder is taking place. However over an hour later his daughter texts him, "what's for dinner?"
9. The killer is perceived to be injured from the 20 foot jumped escape from Garret's house. The police believe Nick has a limp to his right leg. Nick is asked to reveal his right ankle and low and behold the police accurately predict an injury to his right ankle. A scrape and swelling.
10. Nick claims the injury is do to knocking his ankle on a piece of furniture, yet he can not name the piece of furniture.
11. Nick refuses to cooperate early in the police interview when the police are asking him basic questions that could have cleared him if he were innocent.
12. Nick smokes cigarettes at the police station and then puts the butts down a sink, presumably to deny the police DNA to test.
13. Nick claims the only reason he is targeted is due to his race. No other factors at play.
14. Nick buddies up with a Hollywood producer, and the next thing you know HBO supplies a propaganda piece that tells half the story.
Rocky P
And a JUDGE at a trial declares him not guilty because there is NO EVIDENCE linking him to this murder.
Rocky P what on earth! Go back with an unbiased mind and look at the evidence.
@@LightRainzWhat am I biased by??? the overwhelming evidence maybe?
You should ask Nick if he ever remembered what piece of furniture injured his foot. lol
Have fun in fantasyland
@@patriciaR004 I asked you if Nick ever figured out what piece of furniture he injured in ankle on!!! One of the numerous lies from Day 1 with him.
Also, if you looked at the crime scene pics, you might have noticed the 2nd floor window was directly over a small protruding landing (most likely storage or basement entrance) which was approx 6ft jump from the window, then another 6ft to the ground.
And most of the area around the protruding landing was mostly grass.
In either case, wasn't Nick lauded for this athleticism?
You NEED to look at the evidence.
Leave these toxic women with all of their toxic baggage alone.
Yah's peach I don’t think the toxic woman is who we should be pointing fingers here when there is a man stalking her after the breakup. Sad that you write the narrative in such a way.
Anna K you’re missing the whole point. He called her a toxic woman like it’s her fault he stalked her. Victim blaming. You’ve clearly never been manipulated or maybe you have but are too perfect to admit it.
I just think the uncle did it. Because of something he said while speaking for TV...
Yea you'll be a great detective 😂
No not the uncle this is my son's cousin from his dad side
@@trailer_trash_Barbie first let me say I'm sorry for your lost, as a father of five may I say he was a beautiful kid. If I may can I respectfully ask a question? Do you think there's a chance that drug addicts could've broken in to find money or drugs something for quick to sell. I ask this because in my area that's who does most of the break-ins and from the HBO video there appears to be pills on the floor ?
@@derricktaylor1905 no i dont think a drug addict killes him at all nor his uncle! I wont say who i think. But karmas a mofo? And garrett is with hia daddy in heaven with his other cousin that died at 8 years old. Justice for Garrett!
What did he say?
I'll never forget what Norman Siegel said to Nick after the verdict. He told Nick to "be careful cause it ain't over it will never be over"
Cops shouldn't have waited for the landlord...well, and Tandy should not have taken up with a child killer like Nick either.
detaining for 6hrs = 100% 4th Amendment violation
But he flushed the cigarettes down the sink to avoid DNA extraction
Derek Armstrong
will you be a 1 man jury your verdict?? Please!!
Her son was dead wasnt it important for her to know d real killer...sick n sad to frame an innocent man
th-cam.com/video/8P31StnKKNE/w-d-xo.html
He did it......she never even talk bout him jus d black guy she dated....hmmmm how sad i say no more
Catena saw through the okey doke. you saw the way Catena looked at the DA's when the discovery of Gmoney was brought out in court......
jon jones did it
What about his ankle injury that he denied until they got a search warrant to photograph his person...
He denied that he had a leg injury I wouldn't call a scab on an ankle an injury either.
A soccer coach with an ankle scab? Oh how shocking 🙄
Dude, how many futbol players do you know without a scab on their ankles. To be truthful, any person that runs in shoes without socks or low ankle socks will have these types of scabs on their ankles.
This is way crazy, right here! I'm 71 yo arthritic grandma and I've got an ankle scab of unknown origin. Athletic people move around lots more than I do! Crazy assumption!
Then why hide it , why wouldn't he just say yea I got it playing or coaching soccer, then his explanation was he received it moving furniture, just very odd altogether.
There are 3 possible scenarios With 4 different suspects involved besides nick
My list consists of
John ( directly or indirectly)
The boyfriend of the girl who called
A burglar caught off guard.
Or a teen junkee
Nick did it.
@@emilyjones5830 ,Sounds like YOU were there.
@@emilyjones5830 ,The ex sheriff did it,he had a key.
@@emilyjones5830 You were an accomplice but it wasn't Nick Hillary.
@@sharijohnson6121
I agree and he was always beside her ...holding her hand at the police station. Also, the mother filed a complaint saying she feared for her and her childrens life !
The general consensus with Tafaris rant here is that "da wite peeplez be bad and racist!", yet he's married to a white woman. That's gotta be a weird dynamic for his wife, strange way for her to live. Way to keeps it real, black men.🙉
One brilliant attorney Mani
LOL , Nick Hilary filed a complaint against him saying he was not representing him in the correct manor , thats why all those high price attorneys where called in to help NH ... look it up ...
Oh I'm gonna research that complaint!
>>Oral "The Chimp " Willams Killed poor Garret ....
Wow .. I'm inspired.
Nick was seen around the time Garrett was coming back from school Nick lied he said he went straight home but he turned left in the same direction as Garrett heading home according to Garrett’s mom nick blamed Garrett for their relationship ending Nick knew the apartment n that area in general very well so you guys go figure
Heartbroken? Walk away...get support and improve yourself.
as it relates to staying silent while talking to the police. I was checking the DNA CIA question that Gary Snell was asking Nick Hillary attempting to show that Nick was lying. I was like what??? the cops will twist you up with a simple and seemingly matter of fact question.
Please be honest !!
Nick Hillary's police interaction was flawed ... he should have never agreed to go down to the police station to answer questions in the first place.
Please do not say he is a blueprint since he made the grave error of cooperating IN ANY WAY WHATSOEVER.
Police officer talking to a rich white man, "I'd like you to come down to the station and answer some questions."
Rich white man replies, "Officer I would love to assist you in any way I can. I will give you the name of my attorney and you can present any questions you have TO them and you will receive all my answers THROUGH them."
Talking to a police officer about the law is like talking to an 11 year old about sex ... they have both learned everything they know on the school playground!!!
Hillary mentions the 6th amendment and both police officers don't even know the constitution to understand what he is referring to!
an innocent NEVER expects cops to try to FRAME them BLACK or WHITE
The innocents who end up free do tho.
Oh shut up
Bull , one should also listen to the podcast and find out a lot of interesting facts that are distorted on here
Stop playing the victim!
this guy is a horrible lawyer...he let Nick be questioned for hours during the civil suit they brought against the authorities...the prosecutors were able to arrest and prosecute him based on that civil testimony...
yep , NH actually filed a claim against the courts saying he had bad attorney representation befor his criminal trial began ...
Is that Y a WHITE JUDGE acquitted him and prosecutor had her law license suspended ?
this guy is full of it ... all of their civil lawsuits have been tossed !
"Now wey awl da wite wimenz be at?!?!"... Nick Hillary🙉
Hillary killed that boy and it was not a race thing. The mother said that there were issues between Holley and Garrett and was going to put her boys first. Good for her. So she broke it off with Hillary. She said if her kids weren’t happy she had to drop Hillary. Hillary saw Garrett as the reason Tandy dropped him and was mad at Garrett. Hillary was obsessed with Tandy and couldn’t take no for an answer. Tandy kept telling him her boys came first. So no, it was not a race thing it was a revenge thing.
Where’s the evidence that he was “obsessed”
Yeah where's the evidence?! You're just another white supremacist like all the rest of the Potsdam, NY white citizens!! Black people get falsely accused all the time!! There was a black man in 2020 that was falsely accused of stealing a lottery ticket in a town near Buffalo, NY!! That man was arrested based on hearsay!!! Then he was released a week later!!!
@@davidgurrola760 the evidence is: 'trust me, bro'. From the text messages they shared, he didn't seem obsessed at all.
BS. Race was definitely a major factor in this case. The only black man she ever dealt with killed her son, not likely. Garrett deserves justice, but not at Hillary's expense. This man is clearly innocent, and the evidence just doesn't add up to a Hillary conviction.
@@leroymiddletoniii9892 🐂💩 🐂💩 🐂💩 oh stop playing the victim. You are not only blind, you are deaf and brain dead. Hillary was obsseed with Tandy. It said so in the video. So because Hillary was black she should have put him before her kids so your feelings wouldn’t be hurt? Grow up dude and listen to the entire report, not just what you want to hear