Rest in Peace to Roberto Clemente (1934-1972). I would’ve had him as the best 70s player. Sad to see his career and life cut short by a plane crash. He will forever be remembered in the MLB Hall of Fame
For 2000's, it has to be Barry Bonds. You could've gone to MLB The Show 17 for him. They don't have a card with his actual name because he did not allow them to. However, they made him Reggie Stocker
In 2003, Bonds withdrew from the MLB Players Association licensing agreement because he felt independent marketing deals would be more lucrative for him. Because of this withdrawal, his name and likeness are not usable in any merchandise licensed by the MLBPA so they would have to deal with him to have his name in. For this reason, he does not appear in some baseball video games, forcing game-makers to create generic athletes as replacements.
Just like Pete Rose holds the record for career hits but because of his bets they won't acknowledge him in games as career hits leader due to him being banned from the MLBPA.
For 80’s you could’ve done Don Mattingly, In 84 he won the batting title, in 85 he won AL MVP, 9 gold gloves, 3 silver slugger awards. A great player and my dads favorite player of all time.
Unpopular opinion but Miguel Cabrera is one the most underrated hitters to step in the box. He won a Triple Crown and nearly a 2nd ring in 2012.. he has a career batting average above .300 3000+ hits 1600 + RBIS 508 homers.. People have him way back in the list. To me he’s one of the greatest all round hitters ever, as he could hit bombs both ways without juice or Peds, Simply injuries kept him back from his prime.
day 2 of asking to do Playing until I lose, But every game the deficit gets bigger in the Show 23 (idea from Yoboypizzas Madden 23 Playing until I lose, But every game the deficit gets bigger)
To the Babe Ruth comment, the Old Yankee Stadium was the house Babe Ruth built, so yeah he played there, same with Lou Gehrig, and Mickey Mantle...the new one didn't exisit till 09
@@TheBaseballGauntlet Not particularly. They played at the Polo Grounds when the giants were in New York. before then, Hiltop park, which probably wouldn't be in any game. They got kicked out. But that had a 290 pols and 500 foot center field
@@TheBaseballGauntlet Yankee Stadium I built in 1923, before it was heavily renovated in the 1970s and became Yankee Stadium II (1976-2008). The original dimensions were much different. 490 feet to deep center, also very deep to left-center where the bleachers were, and it was shorter down the lines.
It’s obv shohei otahni no question. If judge replicated his 2022 season in 2021 and 2020 then maybe but otahni has been dominant the last 3 years both hitting and pitching
Babe Ruth hit a homerun in the stadium that his yankee teams played in lol hence why they call it the house that Ruth built before that they played for a little bit in the polo grounds
Rest in Peace to Roberto Clemente (1934-1972). I would’ve had him as the best 70s player. Sad to see his career and life cut short by a plane crash. He will forever be remembered in the MLB Hall of Fame
100%
Mike Schmidt is CRIMINALLY underrated by most fans.
For 2000's, it has to be Barry Bonds. You could've gone to MLB The Show 17 for him. They don't have a card with his actual name because he did not allow them to. However, they made him Reggie Stocker
Yeah I wasn’t thinking about stocker. Bonds didn’t play much second half of 2000 tho
@@MKPC_Official Bro are you kidding me?
@@Imperiallegate1507 yeah he did
@@Imperiallegate1507 DUDE HE DID THEM WHAT DO YOU MEAN
@@Imperiallegate1507 bruh lol he did them
im happy he went back to get the "no doubt" animation from Ken Griffey Jr. so beautiful
surprised you didnt do ichiro at 2000s, but albert was real good too. good video!
let’s go mike you were a very good player for the phillys
i can't tell you my anger when you sail pullhos instead of pujols when you were going the 2000's
I can’t pronounce his last name right
Lowkey annoyed the fuck out of me lol
I was scrolling through the comments waiting for someone to say something about that
@@TheBaseballGauntletPOO-holes.
This might be an unpopular opinion but, Barry Bonds should’ve been in it, but I’m not even sure he’s in mlb the show.
Yeah if he was in the show he’d have an argument
Reggie stocker
In 2003, Bonds withdrew from the MLB Players Association licensing agreement because he felt independent marketing deals would be more lucrative for him. Because of this withdrawal, his name and likeness are not usable in any merchandise licensed by the MLBPA so they would have to deal with him to have his name in. For this reason, he does not appear in some baseball video games, forcing game-makers to create generic athletes as replacements.
Just like Pete Rose holds the record for career hits but because of his bets they won't acknowledge him in games as career hits leader due to him being banned from the MLBPA.
@Quadtiger556 from what I found it said he was outright banned from any mlb video game because of his cheating scandal
"You guys think Schmidt is Underrated?" As he blasts an absolute swamp donkey into low earth orbit.
You should make a team with all these players that are available in the show 23
Noted
The Willie Mays disrespect is crazy
Mickey mantle is better tho
@@Sgtalex-iv6eo Cap.
For 80’s you could’ve done Don Mattingly, In 84 he won the batting title, in 85 he won AL MVP, 9 gold gloves, 3 silver slugger awards. A great player and my dads favorite player of all time.
mike shmidt is majorly under rated nobody ever talks about him and he was one of the best third base men
We need hitting a home run with the best player from every year from 2010 to 2023
Unpopular opinion but Miguel Cabrera is one the most underrated hitters to step in the box. He won a Triple Crown and nearly a 2nd ring in 2012.. he has a career batting average above .300 3000+ hits 1600 + RBIS 508 homers.. People have him way back in the list. To me he’s one of the greatest all round hitters ever, as he could hit bombs both ways without juice or Peds, Simply injuries kept him back from his prime.
You hit a home run with Mickey Mantle as Honus Wagner though 😬
no way you just called him albert pullhose
The fact ty cobb was only in 2 mlb the show games is a crime
day 2 of asking to do Playing until I lose, But every game the deficit gets bigger in the Show 23 (idea from Yoboypizzas Madden 23 Playing until I lose, But every game the deficit gets bigger)
Yoboypizza goes hard I really like him
We will see!
Did he say pulhos? 😂😂😂
Fr
Yeah I always pronounce it wrong
Eddie Murray: “Am I a joke to you..”
Great vid
Great comment
This video led off with Honus Wagner. I'm very disappointed the next two weren't Cap Anson and Mordecai "Three Finger" Brown.
Mike = underrated
Great video
Thanks!
@@TheBaseballGauntlet No problem
I think Mike Schmidt is underated
Valid
1940s has to be Jackie robinson
You forgot the 1800’s blud
Nice vid
Nice comment
Joe morgan was the best player of the 1970s imo. but his teammate bench was great to.
You should make a team of all the home run derby champions plus you have to win a home run derby to unlock 99 babe Ruth in the show 23
Doing a home run derby video Tuesday!
Imagine choosing Mike Trout and Albert Pujols over the last person to win a triple crown.
Tomorrow can you please do hitting a home run with Joc Pederson in every MLB the show that he had been in
what teeam is mcg?
For me 2020s is Aaron Judge, but anyway good video 😊
Thank you but I’ll go ohtani
He had 1 good year
Both equally good but judge got that homerun record over ohtani
@@jeffritchie213show his pitching stats
albert pole hose LOL
Yannkes nations own this list
How did you get honus wagner?
Is he just in the Groundbreaker?
I was going to ask why you didn't use Crosley Field when hitting with Bench until I remembered Bench was too young to have played at Crosley.
Ronald acuna .jr
We need ichiro as a 99 overall legend as well as pete rose
honestly, for the 1960's, shouldve had Aaron hitting in Milwaukee. ha
MLB The Show 23 had the Angels in the wrong dugout.
Mike Schmidt kind of looks like a Dr.Disrespect
I think you could have gotten chipper jones in that 90s or 2000s era but I don’t hate the pick
I agree Ohtani ngl
W
So no Rickey Henderson?
They should add all time teams for each team with all their best players
Agreed
Houso the goat wager
I’m surprised there was no Bryce Harper in this video
Trout owned the 2010s
@@TheBaseballGauntlet yeah
Trout is better, Bryce young is at least 2nd or 3rd best in the 2010s
@@Sgtalex-iv6eo yeah I agree trout in those years were insane
nice videos
Glad you like them!
Wait no arod or Ricky Henderson or Derek jeter
something about looking at ty cobb makes me feel weird. I don't know what it is.
Where is the say hey kid
Where was chipper jones?
The goat babe Ruth
Fun fact: babe Ruth first played for my Red Sox before joining the yanks
To the Babe Ruth comment, the Old Yankee Stadium was the house Babe Ruth built, so yeah he played there, same with Lou Gehrig, and Mickey Mantle...the new one didn't exisit till 09
I’m wondering if there was like an older old Yankee stadium lol
@@TheBaseballGauntlet Not particularly. They played at the Polo Grounds when the giants were in New York. before then, Hiltop park, which probably wouldn't be in any game. They got kicked out. But that had a 290 pols and 500 foot center field
@@TheBaseballGauntlet Yankee Stadium I built in 1923, before it was heavily renovated in the 1970s and became Yankee Stadium II (1976-2008). The original dimensions were much different. 490 feet to deep center, also very deep to left-center where the bleachers were, and it was shorter down the lines.
For the 2020, I would put judge. I personally think he’s better. Pls don’t get mad at me, I’m just stating my opinion
Mike Schmidt is underrated
Bluds on beginner 💀
Thats not the point of the video lol. I haven't lost an online game this year so send the challenge
For 70s you should have used a created player Pete rose in the vault
Unpopular opinion, buh the fact that Tony Gwynn didn’t sneak in here is crazy
Tony Gwynn one of the GOATS
Tony Gwynn a great but not that much power
In my opinion I'm probably biased as a braves fan but I'm going to go with Ronald acuna jr as my best of the 2020's extremely underated
I respect it
I would say he’s up there but Ohtani will always be number one he’s argued to be the greatest of all time right now
I guested ken Griffey jr first home run distance (403)FT
Where the hell is miggy
I’m playing MLB the show 22 right now two
90s could've been Tony Gwynn tbh
Honus Wagner was playing in the 1890s
I saw 1905
That 1890 honus
I feel like around 2028 it will go from ohtani to de la cruz
It could!
I was thinking Aaron Judge for 2020’s but its your opinion
It’s obv shohei otahni no question. If judge replicated his 2022 season in 2021 and 2020 then maybe but otahni has been dominant the last 3 years both hitting and pitching
Valid my friend
Aaron Judge best player active even I’m a Mets fan
Nahhh and I am a yanks fan
shohei is definitely better
ichiro
WHERE IS HE
He’s not in mlb the show and even so puljols is better
Where is judge
Ohtani better
Why does Ty Cobb hold a bat like that?
Not sure lol
Ty Cobb used a split grip because it gave him more barrel control but killed his power but it didn’t matter because he was a contact hitter
No Mays and Bonds, my Giants getting ignored even here
Bonds not in game
This is the best chnol
Where’s Jackie Robinson
Me and me dad❤❤❤ty Cobb the best ever
Where’s derek jeter and Aaron judge
where is Jackie Robinson
he was really good and a revolutionary player, but he wasn’t greatest of all time good
The article I used didn’t have him #1 of a decade
Babe Ruth hit a homerun in the stadium that his yankee teams played in lol hence why they call it the house that Ruth built before that they played for a little bit in the polo grounds
where is willie mays
Definitely should have been here if I made my own list
You forgot David Ortiz and Derek jeter
for the 80s im putting rickey henderson
Personally I would have too but I stuck to the list mostly
@@TheBaseballGauntlet oh
I’d go with Ronald acuna Jr for 2020s
gotta go ohtani
Um I would put Willie Star gel for 1970s
Wheres jeter!?
altuve for 2020
best player of every decade ay?
Indeed
And Miguel Cabrera?
I went Albert over Miggy
2020 i going we ronald acuña jr
Fair I think ohtani
I’d go Harper over otani for the 2020s
No bonds!?!?
Not in game or he would be
I think Elly de la Cruz
Honus Wagner started his career in the 1800s not 1905
Puljos🤓
Schmidt’s best years were split between the 70’s and 80’s and so he wasn’t the best player of the 80’s. George Brett was
Valid
Babe ruth played at polo grounds
Really short in left and right but crazy long in center