TIER LIST: Ranking The BEST PL Transfers 23/24
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 31 ม.ค. 2024
- Join Pitch Sides’s official Super 6 mini-league now using the code PTCH23: super6.skysports.com/league/c...
Full season competition T&CS:
super6.skysports.com/landing/...
New episodes available to watch & listen EVERY DAY.
Click HERE: linktr.ee/pitchsidepodcast
If you'd like to work with us, email the studio on
pitchside@fellasstudios.com
Produced by The Fellas Studios: fellasstudios.com/podcasts
Theo:
/ himalfoy
/ theobakervlogs
Ollie:
/ reev
/ olliefletcher
Tom Garratt:
/ @tomgarratt10 - กีฬา
Never thought I’d see the day Lewis made all the sense 😭
He’s normally right you know but the others just gaslight him into thinking he’s wrong or that he said something outrageous. Some of the takes on this channel by Theo especially are absolutely criminal.
Reev is actually a lot more biased than people think, he turns into a bit of a bonehead when it comes to Arsenal
Theo saying Rice has gone up a level since moving to Arsenal - Dec has been playing at this level for 2-3 years at West Ham lmao
errrr no
Most overrated player ever
He hasn’t mate . Last season he was like 4th best cdm now he is like 1 or 2 so he has gone up a level
@@abyeadchowdhury2529spoken like someone who watches football through highlights
@@abyeadchowdhury2529let me guess partey and casemiro were better than him last season
Thinking rice exceeded expectations is delusional. He's done exactly what people thought nothing more and for the price tag it's Bellingham level who actually has exceeded and is levels above rice and doing it for by far the biggest club in the world.
Hard agree and Jude was 50% the price. So he is an A and Rice is a C (by the way Rice has been great, but he is good value not great or unreal and not poor or dog sh*t)
Bellingham was 88 mil and rice was 105
@@stephenrowe458850%??? He is like 10-15 million less that’s it
Thinking van Dijk exceeded expectations is delusional. He’s done exactly what people thought nothing more for being the most expensive defender ever when he was sold to Liverpool for £75,000,000 (which with inflation would be well over £100m now)
My bad not over 100m but just £97m which would still be a world record fee for a defender transfer value shouldn’t be subtracted from quality👍
@@maxm7365 who mentioned VVD lmao guessing Liverpool just live rent free in your head. Why you bringing players up who aren't even in this debate. Triggered over nothing my guy. 😂😂😂
Szoboszlai in C is a joke. Just because he's not hitting the same heights as earlier on in the season doesn't mean he's been bad. He's still playing at a B tier standard
How tf are they saying him and Nkunku are both C. Nkunku has played like 2 games ffs and Szoboszlai was one of Liverpool's best players for a good while
@@dillonmurphy7502 as a Liverpool fan he hasn’t been that good at all c is more than fair. He was not our best player for up there for any point of the season
@@youngmetrojokeman6172 When you start watching the games I'll starting giving your opinion value until then keep it shut.
@@youngmetrojokeman6172 As a Liverpool he was our best midfielder for most of the early part of the season and a solid 7 out of 10 for the season so far.
as a liverpool fan myself, you can be quiet, and start talking when you understand football @@youngmetrojokeman6172
You guys clearly don't watch Liverpool much. You said their midfield 3 was Endo - Jones - Macallister when they literally haven't started a single league game with that midfield.
Szoboszlai has started 20 games out of 22 for Liverpool in the league. Having him only 1 tier above Havertz and Mount is insane.
Clueless
The fact that they put Szobo at C is criminal, he’s been so good when playing but has been injured, as soon as he came back he has scored haha
What's really criminal is nobody is mentioning Mac Allister
@@MGJK97what I’m saying. Szobo, Mac and Endo have all been amazing. And Gravenberch will get there.
As usual Theo answering everything with his arsenal goggles on. Price has to be factored in which is why he is a B. No one is saying he isn’t playing well but for 100 million he should be anyway
You can't say he "supposed" to be playing like a 100m player because it's legit rare for someone to live up consistently to those standards when they have went for 100m. SO Price shouldn't be the indicator to change rice from A to B because it should be based off the player and the expectations they live. That's why he's A for me.
Reev said the same thing
@@itshurtt395 Well let me put it to you like this Dom Szobo has 3 more goal contributions while playing 600 less minutes and costing 45m Pound less. So tell me why Rice is A and he is C?
It's not arsenal goggles. It's just retarded goggles
@@paulk4204I’m a Liverpool fan and that’s not a good comparison, rice is a defensive midfielder whereas szoboslai is more attacking
Already know Theo’s about to drop the most insane ball knowledge!
Szoboszlai can't be a C if Rice is an A
yea exactly
Szoboszlai is closer to havertz than rice according to them.
And Nkunku being a C too playing like 5 games all season
Yes he can 😂 hes fucking average, you kopites think hes good because hes good looking
Reev you can avoid higher grades for expensive players. You’re not ranking the player, you’re ranking the transfer. The transfer is based on performances compared to the price tag. If a 30 million signing is putting up an 8/10 every week and a 100 million signing is putting an 8/10 every week, the 30 million signing is a better signing cos he’s putting up that level of performance but being 70 million cheaper
No way in hell is Szoboszlai a C when rice is an A deluded.
And to have Nkunku at C aswell when he’s missed most of the season
I’m gonna take a wild guess and say you’re a Liverpool fan …
@@jt8944 Hey I may be a Liverpool fan but I ain’t saying Szoboszlai is an A or anything like that I’m just saying that if Nkunku who has missed a lot of the season is a C he has to be rated higher
@@aidenmilburn6727tbf that fair because they didn’t sign him knowing he’s going to be injured
@@ashleyndlovu8636 yeah like Nkunku was fantastic in pre season but he’s like Maddison he’s injured and missed a lot of the season you can’t rate him high if they’ve missed a lot of games
Why is nobody talking about Mac Allister??? Only cost 35M and has been amazing for Liverpool who sit at the top of the table and are still active in all comps?! He’s literally one of the best signings of the season
Did you just not watch the video? They did mention him you sausage
My thoughts exactly
I think they were just doing some of them not all of them because if they did them all in 1 vid it would be a long vid
"he's been amazing" mans had a couple good games after an injury and speaking like he's prime Busquets, know your role jabroni and shout your mouth
I believe they said they were doing the most expensive signings. Endo has been immense too, but wasn't that expensive.
Why isnt Vicario mentioned The sighning of the season clear as day
Rice is a B reason is, Arsenal are on the same level as they were last year, 0 trophies, and falling short of the league again. Technically not improved the squad.
Literally 1 minute in when Reev says you can’t judge a transfer based on the transfer fee!!!
These clips are actually unlistenable sometimes 😂
And yet they tried to rank transfer but without including transfer fee factor hahahah 😂
Szoboszlai at c is criminal, B minimum
szoboszlai has been poor for the most of the season, he just started really well
@@archielilley3882 calm down lad, rice is an A and Szoboszlai is a B
And Mac Allister has been better than them all 😂
@@archielilley3882poor in what way?
@@archielilley3882 9 goals & 5 assists for club & country this season
Liverpools midfield is jones endo and Macallister literally cause szoboslai has been injured for like a month what am I hearing 🤣
Rice-A: Has been great even considering his price.
Havertz-D: Only not an E because of his crucial goals.
Szoboszlai-B: Was one of the best players in the league but has fallen off since his injury.
Mount-D: Barely played so hard to judge.
Tonali-E: In a tier by himself.
Nkunku-C: Very sharp considering he's been injured most of the season.
Diaby-B: Played a key part of Villa's brilliant season.
Onana-D: Close to E but hasn't been as useless as Tonali.
Cunha-B: Class signing worth the money.
Maddison-A: Best player in the league before his injury.
Agree with everything except Rice as a B
Fallen off since injury? He made his first start back against Chelsea, scored and put in a great performance hahaha
If Onana had the same ban as tonali, United would still be in the champions league. I’m a United fan and I put Onana as an F
Lewis Hamilton to Ferrari is the best transfer this season lmao
Fax
“Goal keeping glove isn’t given out for how good the goalies been “ Reeve take a bow for the worst comment I’ve ever heard 😭😭😭
Personally, I see A as "exceeded expectations/price", so players like Madison, Palmer, Vicario, Bellingham. Declan Rice is a B in that, he has played very well, probably 2nd best DM in the league, but wouldn't say he's exceeded his price tag. Whereas Madison was touted as signing of the season, best player in the league (before his injury). Vicario in his first PL season, is at the very least a top 3 goalkeeper in the league, and there's a debate if he should be top. And even Jude was bought for a similar price, but he's basically getting nominations for the Ballon D'or already.
Rice is a great signing but the only way he's in A is if there's an S tier.
really cant understand how you have diaby and cunha at b and szobo at c? Hahahaha its actually mad. Saying szobo is no longer in starting midfield yea cause hes been injured. And then saying diaby is a b and not an a cause he doesnt play every game. Doesnt really make sense
They don't really know what's going on, I remember last week they were saying mount can't get in the united team when he's been injured for months 😂
Reeve talking about diaby not getting in over bailey, its called rotation and thats why they perform all the time, arsenal's manager could take a leaf out of emerys book and rotate saka. Might get more out of him then instead of running him into the ground
Arsenal fans are literally the ONLY people that big rice up like this, he’s been a good midfielder that’s it, no better than Maddison, or warde prowse, or even Douglas luiz, and he cost £100m no chance is A tier signing😂
No ball knowledge
Rice has been this level for years ffs just cos u only watch arsenal doesn’t mean he’s gone up a notch
errrr no u wrong
A - Maddison, Rice
B - Szoboszlai, Cunha
C - Diaby, Nkunku
D - Havertz (just so someone is in D but I’d really put him in E)
E - Tonali, Mount
F -
G -
H -
I -
J -
K -
L - Onana
Mac Allister has been better than Szobo and Szobo deserves to be B
Nkunku has played like 2 games haha
Jao Pedro - A
Putting Szoboszlai in the same tier as Cunha is nasty stuff. Also how on earth is Diaby below Szoboszlai?
@@MGJK97Mac Allister hasn't been better, he's been good while Szobo was injured. Szobo took the league by storm in first 3 months
Love hearing non-biased ball knowledge from the Arsenal Muppets
Rice put in a 4-5/10 against West Ham in the league lmao
The fact you can only bring up one game out of the 30+ he's played is hilarious.
@@lemz.stackz3775 well Fulham, few other losses etc. Rice is unreal, played at the same level for years at West Ham, hence why he went for so much and city were after him. To fetch that much when his contract is running down shows everything. Just listening to reev and stuff say he’s not played under an 8 is just wrong. It’s a straight lie
@@lemz.stackz3775well reev did say he's hasn't gone below 8/10 for every game this season which is a stupid thing to say. He was just giving an example of when he's had a shocker.
@@lemz.stackz3775he’s had more games below an 8/10 than above it.
Theo and Reev when someone doesn’t agree with their opinion “ 😢😢😢😡😡🤬🤬😡🤬😡😢😢😢😢😢”
14:01 Theo reading my comment from the other vid where everyone said madders didn’t play enough but kudus did…😂
them: He shouldn't be high because he didn't play much games
also them: James maddison is up high because he was great when he played
Why do every arsenal fan say rice hasn't dropped a game less than an 8.. at least 3 games he's had probably a 4 😂
Szoboszlai hasn’t been playing because he’s injured, these guys have no clue about football sometimes 😭😭
How has Lewis made the most sense this vid.
Wataru Endo is a better signing that Declan Rice for the simple fact that he cost £16m and has been solid having no problem getting up to speed with the premier league after battling relegation with Stuttgart. Liverpool also has a higher win percentage and ppg with Endo in the starting 11.
Declan Rice has had more bad games than Szoboszlai this season, he had 2/3 bad games at the end of December, he's been out recently through injury and Liverpool's best midfield is Mac Allister, Jones and Szoboszlai.
you are WAFFLINGGGG
@@fweela1508 it's the truth, West ham and Fulham he dropped stinkers. The only one that comes to mind for Szoboszlai is Man United.
Absolute 0 ball knowledge this Liverpool fans😂
If you guys were less bias this channel would get more views , but everytime i watch its justs u lot being bias. Making dom szobo- C is actually ridiculous.
To be fair I think their biased opinions get them more views. There biggest engagement is on the most outrageous takes
7:46 no it isn't. When all are fit Szoboszlai was in it. It was Endo-Szoboszlai-Jones OR Endo-Szoboszlai-Mac Allister OR Mac Allister-Szoboszlai-Jones. They all include Szoboszlai who has been solid all of this season. He's a B.
Theo and Reev have completely shown their bias in this video. Not only did they not accept any other opinion than “Declan rice is amazing” they also showed the delusion of every arsenal fan. They all slagged havertz off in every minute of every game whilst he was at chelsea, he’s doing the exact same at arsenal for the exact same amount of money and now they love him and protect him. Accept he’s shit and move on ffs
Lmao at theo saying Lewis has an agenda!! If that ain't the definition of the pot calling the kettle black then I don't know what is. Telling someone they have an agenda as you defend Kai havertz is crazy hahaha
The price paid for rice shouldn’t matter then puts the price comparison for nearly every other player
Declan rice is definitely in B Lewis actually spat facts
REEV and Theo cant look beyond the arsenal bias
Theo has the worst ball knowledge of all of them. Catching so many Ls
I love rice and I'm a hammer. He's not changed at all so It's a B. A is that he's changed (got better). Not changed
Rice hasn’t dropped less than an 8/10 is ridiculous he was a 6/10 against west ham
6/10 is being generous, he was awful
Arsenal fans are so insecure it's insane. They put Rice in B and they're acting as if they said he's shit. One moment they say "he's exceeded expectation", the next moment it's "he's playing to his price tag". Which one is it then?
Your job is to watch football lads, that assessment of Szoboszlai is embarrassing
Rice: B
Havertz: D
Szoboszlai: C
Mount: E
Tonali: E
Nkunku: C
Diaby: B
Onana: D
Cunha: B
Maddison: B because he’s been injured for ages
Declan Rice hasn’t exceeded expectations. Not sure how people rate him as one of the best in the league let alone in the world. Very overrated imo. Outstanding defensively but for the price tag he should be the needle mover for Arsenal.
In contrast Szoboszlai who’s elevated the Liverpool midfield from last season gets rated a C.
You’ve defo not watched Rice enough when he was at West Ham or even for England, bet you support utd or Chelsea or something
Havertz actually won us the game against Man City, played very well against Liverpool which we won, won us the game against Luton, scored champions league goals
Listening to Arsenal fans pretending the price you pay for a player doesnt matter after their team spent a month trying to haggle West Ham down fron 100 million is exhausting.
Of course Havertz is gonna play, they payed too much for him not to play
How are Nkunku and Szoboslai the same level!! one of them has played like 2 games
Both signed from the same club
Quick quiz Broski guess who is who
Player 1 costed 70 mil had one good season and now plays as a 10 in the 8 at his club
Player 2 costed 60 mil was in his last 2 season player of the season and in the other one top scorer
Carried his teams to their first ever two trophies scoring in both cup finals and scored between that hat tricks for Leipzig against Manchester City
It’s not just how they performed it’s also the price and the business behind it
Tonali was acc really good before the ban
"you're entitled for your opinion" and proceed to say "you're also wrong" hahahaha
the topic is worst transfers, tonali wasn't a bad transfer in terms of footballing ability i agree with tom
but still is a bad transfer overall cause u spent how ever much on a player who aint gonna play for u until next season
One of the worst takes of the video, Haven't seen enough of Mount to judge him more harshly? He's played the same amount of minutes as Tonali who is being compared to Havertz when everyone who's not an Arsenal fan knows he's one of the biggest wastes of money in the window, he has regressed them as a team
Szobozlai has been injured 😴
Shocking to put szoboszlai C and mount D just one below him. Szoboszlai and macallister transformed liverpool midfield completely to a point where they dominate basically against anyone but city, and szoboszlai its not like hes playing bad, its just that he was so good at the start that he set the standard for himself to be like the best CM in the league
THe way Theo keeps bringing up Rice shows his agenda
Onana deserves a C in my opinion. He was horrendous in the champions league but he has been solid enough in the prem and is on top of the goals prevented stats in the league
Surprised no mention of Vicario and Micky Van De Ven. And the fact they put Nkunku in B and Szoboszlai in C is ridiculous
I think u have to judge an injured or unavailable player as a d or e cuz they might end up being good but at the moment it’s literally a waste of money and therefore bad.
Rice “hasn’t dropped anything less than an 8/10” did they watch him against West Ham?
I'm an Arsenal fan. Has been for more than 20 years. Declan Rice as a B is very reasonable.
Reev and Theo NEVER take price into account when ranking transfers. They often argue that price doesn't matter as well. It's as if they think they are rating the player and not the transfer. When ranking transfers. The price of the transfer weighs 50/50 with perfomance.
it would be better if you had a S tier for players that exceeded expectations, because I agree Rice is fair A, but he just lived up to the expectations, so I understand (this time) where is Lewis coming from
Correct neutral PL fan(Real Madrid fan) list (A-F):
Rice (B)
Havertz (D)
Szoboszlai (C)
Mount (E/na)
Tonali (E/na) (When he played, he was a solid C, close to B)
Nkunku (D)
Diaby (B)
Onana (D)
Cunha (B)
Maddison (A)
Szobo has been great, macca has been crazy, endo has been great as well. We haven’t had lower than a B transfer
Lewis is really dumb most of the time but he was spot on with rice. A should be for players who blew expectations out of the water
How is Rice playing like his price tag? I want goals and assists for a 100m midfielder
If i buy Rice for 100mil and he's a consistent 8/10. Or i buy a player for half that and they are a consistent 8/10 they CANNOT be equal, one is better because they were cheaper. Rice is a B, if he were an A Arsenal wouldnt be slumping every now and then
What about James ward-prowse
Reev gets away with being a bone head with his opinions a lot. He’s so bias towards arsenal and gets so aggressive towards Lewis when he questions arsenal. Roids have him stressed even his hairs thinning aswell
This pitchside or AFTV?
The thing with Havertz is that if Arsenal never bought him, they’d probably have been able to buy a striker in January. He may have won a couple of points, but I honestly think we’d be talking about Arsenal winning the league with a striker. Absolutely stinky transfer
Only at 1:52 and i can't watch further due to the relentless bias. How has Rice exceeded expectations for a £100m player? Arsenal fans must have very low expectations. Pepe and Havertz giving them trust issues.
Rice deserves an A; if not that then we’re just saying for that price tag it’s impossible for him to have gotten an A. He is currently the CDM with two attacking midfielders ahead of him. He’s not going to bomb forward and score like Bellingham. It’s just not his position; saying that though he has already single handedly won Arsenal 5 points through scoring. With the two winners coming in 90+ minute of the game.
They are ranking players not transfers, and yet the title of the video is ranking transfers
The inconsistency in their arguments really grinds my gears!!
For Rice and Havertz they say you can't take the transfer fee into account, but then for every other transfer they keep mentioning the fees😂😂 cmon Lads!!
Value for money:
1.Vicario
2.Endo
3.Mac Allister
The Rice hype is a joke - He is a good holding midfielder. He is not lighting the league up, he hasn't had say the Kante impact. He is performing at the level you would expect of his fee.
I always find it confusing when people say he is up there for POTY. I watch Arsenal and there hasn’t been a game where Rice dictates play or influences the game like a POTY.
just incredible arsenal PR
So boring on the eye as well paddle feet side to side
@@mckennageno7053 him being english helps create a lot of hype
Szoboszlai C is actually so dumb. Was out for a bit with an injury and "dropped off ", these guys barley watch football its a joke.
Theo looking around for validation when debating with Lewis is so annoying and childish
Rice A is a joke, if you compare to Caicedo yeah, but look at Alexi Mac, a third of the price , top of the league, plays everygame he's fit, if you make Rice an A you need a new alphabet to discuss actual good transfer business
A can't be the only person that thinks Declan Rice is a little bit overrated. Very good player but he's not really made Arsenal any better. He's a solid player who will give a 7 out of 10 every game but he's nowhere near the level that some Arsenal and England fans put him at
Reev so entitled don’t like the guy, Szobo is a starter for Liverpool not macalister cause Mac plays as a 6 or LCM. Just because havertz starts doesn’t mean he’s good they are pushing bad the bad form hoping he finds his feet and the price was daylight robbery, and lastly Onana being a ucl finalist GK doesn’t instantly make him good Karius?? Mendy who like Onana was good now shit
D for Mount because he hasn’t been and can’t play
E for Tonali….because he hasn’t been and can’t play
English bias towards their own players is wild
Arsenal have got worse since Rice signed?
Maddison an A when he’s missed a substantial amount of the season?? Wtf are these ratings
Think Moussa Diaby is way too high
0:44 West Ham ?👀
Mount D is a shocking rating he’s E and that’s generous
Diaby is definitely not B. Had a good start at villa but dropped off massivelt after first 6/7 games. Has ability and can recapiture that form, but as of right now I’d go C
For me Sometimes Reev picks on Lewis when he disagrees just because it’s Lewis, Tom said B for Rice but he just went for Lewis, not that deep but something I’ve noticed over the months of watching them
Vicario is arguably signing of the season, these man actually are clueless
saying Rice hasn't dropped less then an 8/10 is complete rubbish he's had a couple stinkers
I don’t understand why Lewis’ opinions get questioned every time. They’re only opinions.
Saying Liverpool midfield is jones endo and mac is silly it’s only because szobo was injured for 4-5 games
Diaby is a C 100% dropped off a lot recently