❤ Je t'adore ❤ Well, ... I am really intrigued by the "spoken" dialects of German. Schwabish and Bairisch in particular. They are still spoken in Southern Germany and Austria and maybe in Switzerland and Northern Italy. These languages are spoken, usually at home, as a mother tongue. They are predecessors of Standard German languages. The Standard Languages probably were constructed from various dialects of German. I listen to German dialect songs by Melissa Naschenweng. Such beautiful songs from Southern Germany and Austria. Such wonderful music ❤
my native language is mandarin Chinese, and I learned English later on, my son and grand son, however, since they are living in west Netherlands, both speak fluent English, Dutch and German.
Protogermanic also existed on the eastern and western north coasts of today's germany. That is a crucial mistake leading others to think all begann only in scandinavia :(
One theory is that it was not originally an Indo-European language as it has a foreign sub-stratum. It borrowed from other Indo-European languages probably from the Slavs/Celts/Latins.
A widely discredited theory, btw. Also, the evidence for a non-IE substrate is rapidly diminishing, as many Germanic words previously believed to be "foreign" are now accounted for.
Let me know here what language branch or family we should talk about next 😉 Italic? Celtic? Or maybe Balto-Slavic?
О славянской письменности и культуре очень бы хотелось что-то узнать новое. На твоём канале всегда то, о чëм я раньше и не догадывалась😮
Perhaps some dead languages? Tocharian maybe? Anatolian languages are also interesting.
East Germanic, Gothic.
This video is disgustingly underrated; I think more people should see this
Great video 😊
Great video thanks 🙏 DANKE 😁
Don't forget low german, a endangered language spoken in north Germany and east Netherlands
❤ Je t'adore ❤ Well, ... I am really intrigued by the "spoken" dialects of German. Schwabish and Bairisch in particular. They are still spoken in Southern Germany and Austria and maybe in Switzerland and Northern Italy.
These languages are spoken, usually at home, as a mother tongue. They are predecessors of Standard German languages. The Standard Languages probably were constructed from various dialects of German.
I listen to German dialect songs by Melissa Naschenweng. Such beautiful songs from Southern Germany and Austria. Such wonderful music ❤
Very much informative
my native language is mandarin Chinese, and I learned English later on, my son and grand son, however, since they are living in west Netherlands, both speak fluent English, Dutch and German.
Юлечка, как всегда всё очень познавательно и интересно. Смотрю всегда твой канал для саморазвития😊. Спасибо❤
😊💝💝 спасибо большое
Protogermanic also existed on the eastern and western north coasts of today's germany. That is a crucial mistake leading others to think all begann only in scandinavia :(
what about the foreign input in the german language
I guess such topics deserve separate whole videos! On the list
Helgoland Frisian is a language in itself too.. Afrikaans was also influenced by Malay.. You forgot Low-German.
One theory is that it was not originally an Indo-European language as it has a foreign sub-stratum. It borrowed from other Indo-European languages probably from the Slavs/Celts/Latins.
I feel like kinda unlikely though
@@joanxsky2971ye there’s just too many similarities for it to be a sub strata
@@seandemhairr4572 Yea fr, and a lot of basic Germanic vocab shows similarities to other IE langs so it would be weird if it wasn’t an IE lang
A widely discredited theory, btw.
Also, the evidence for a non-IE substrate is rapidly diminishing, as many Germanic words previously believed to be "foreign" are now accounted for.
The prime example of a Germanic language is not even German but Swedish or Norwegian 🤪
I think you did yourself a disservice here, as you took away or just touched upon the interesting parts, and leaft just the very superficial ones.
Thanks for your observation. But I guess if I was to go deeper into the topic, the video would last 10 hours
@@LanguageEasy Between 15 minutes, and 10 hours, lots of other possibilities exits.
I think the video length is perfect for beginners like me
What about Manx... Alemmanic and Luxembourgish!? Varagians and Gepids!? It lacked a lot of things... 😂
Manx? It’s Celtic…
Elfdalian, Gutnish, Scots, Yola, Hunsrik, Pennsylvanian Dutch/German, Mennonite Low German, Transylvanian Saxon, Anglish, Folkspraak…………
Manx is Keltic.
I feel like the only influence English should have is Celtic Influence.
Looking good!