Thank you for an interesting review Rabia just want to tell that the story is set in the backdrop of 60s and all the questions that you asked like why Batool's character was shown as a negative character, why Tajwar lost her sanity and what Mahnoor did afterwards will all be answered in the sequel "Sikkay" which will come this year In sha ALLAH.
I just finished reading this book, and every word you said resonates with my thoughts. I understood that the story was set in the old era, but still I was disappointed knowing it's Umera Ahmed.
Koi to Amar bail ki bat kray ham Omar ko khona nahi chahtay is ka second part please we requested to you please umera Ahmad please buhat mushkil hai ab is ka part second ana chaiye we requested to you ❤❤
Just finished listening to the novel & literally your review is echoing my thoughts. The writing, setting, charachters are all so very captivating but the story, at least in this part, is such a classic & familiar one.
Very honest review ❤ Maine b Novel end tk bs is liye padhi k ye Umera Ahmed ne likhi h AGR kisi Aur writer ne likhi hoti to shayad bich me hi chhodh deti.
I so agree with not reading and seeinh toxic friendship and yeah stories impact.that thought process is same. I also agree with dana paani and jannat kay pattay seems more like the old typical schematic storyline evil vs good . So yeah i think we have seen so good but now we have progressive life
Assalamualaikum Rabia....Maine bhi is novel ko padha hai...aj raat hi khatam kiya hai...main har novel padhne k bad apka review dekhti hoon... I'm totally agreed with your points....but mujhe lagta hai iske age kuch bht acha hoga...is novel k sequel novel me Inshallah.... Mujhe sabse afsos hua "Gamu" ki mout ka padh kar... uske mout ke ek ek harf par dil bechain hone laga tha...wo pura phase disappointing tha mere liye..."mera andaza hai,sequel novel m,batool ki beti or murad ka beta ek doosre s mohabbat karege,or mahnoor us mohabbat ko mukammal nhi hone degi,as like tajwar",tb shayad batool.ko.tarp hogiii.....
AA Rabia, I am fond of your book reviews and enjoy learning about Urdu literature. Is it possible for you to run a book club would Love to be a part of it. Stay blessed💕💕
The story is good aswell.... Its not that the story was not 'intelligent and progressive""' but it shows the versatality of Umera Ahmed. Yes, there were a few drawbacks, especially BATUL and death of Murad
Hey Rabia, have you tried Mitch Albom's books they are literally so well written and different. I recently read The Stranger in the lifeboat and Tuesdays with Morrie. After a very long time you posted I review, I really love your videos regarding books. ♥
Why these channels not promote anything related to Deena and tons of work on Islam. They only focus on Fahaasi Showbiz industry as Kaptaan always called it.
Shyd ap sb disagree karen but UA ki heroines strong hoti hein but remarkable nhi, mtlb koi extraordinary strength nhi hoti jesi ho skti hey, For ex, salar sikender k dono beton ka high IQ hota hey, dono apny professions mein boht successful hotey hein but dusry side anaya ka character bs Abdullah k character ko support krny k liye tha, anaya bhi tou apny bhaion ki tarah professionally strong aur successful ho sakti thi, Mere shadeed khuwahish hy UA aesa koi character likhey
After reading Amarbail, I totally agree with you. How stupid and immature Alizeh was. Her character was very poorly written. Imama also started acting immature and weird in Aab e hayat, like how can someone be like this after taking such big decisions of life. And and Motiya, she had nothing special except beauty. Her whole personality was written as she was drop dead gorgeous, stunning, pale white etc etc. Also she was studying medicine due to Murad's father. Nothing special at all
Oh i went too far into the review rabia.. thorey spoilers bhi sun liye😂 anyways will definitely read since desperately need something to read. No episode of maala yet either. Please koi aur kitab bhi hai tu share kerein.
That arif bhaii mujy 10 mint de dein srf😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 but overall it was a good review and i am not gonna read it because i want to read some intelligent stories something far from the typical love stories something sensible and meaningful. I am expecting more from Umera Ahmed♥️.
One thing which I found common in urdu novels is they try to portrait that girls who wear abaya nd practice all the different islamic norms are the only one who are real muslims , this is my opinion after reading umera Ahmed novel (English translation) and Nimra Ahmed novel(audio book) but anyways I like to always hear ur thoughts bcs u seem to look so genuine
@@iamrabiamughniI was actually trying to tell that most urdu novels are based on spirituality nd yes I didn't mean abt all the novel characters, I said only abt the novels which I read nd the ones which I heard through audiobooks bcs in those books it's precisely always said how a true muslim shd behave especially peer e kamil I was so excited to read that book but I was not very much satisfied with it bcs the book was more abt how to become a true Muslim nd how practising religion makes a person a perfect man nd those who don't practise religion are imperfect Sry if I have offended u
@@viya2234yes nimrah ahmed, umera ahmed, sumera hameed they have given a new genre of novels in urdu which is very different from what classic wtites like manto and asmat chughtai etc wrote. So u have to accept that writers if this genere will talk about islam and hiw to be a good muslim etc. Huge nu.ber of readership reads their novels for same reason.
Honestly speaking ....being as nimrah ahmed's fan. Ab ye love stories itniiiii kr bongi lgti hain mje. Or ye novel m bht kuch meri smj sy bahar tha. Like motiya doctor bn ri thi to us ki parhai ka kya wo itniiii itniiiii lambi chutiya kesy guzarti thi gao aak. Or chand m shakal nzr ana...etc etc. Aisa pyar real life m nai hota. Nimrah reality based stories btati h. Jo k besttttt h
I swear aisi mohabbatein hazam nahi hoti hain yaar😂 Matlab, sirf ek do baar milne par kisi se itni shadeed qism ki mohabbat. Aur mujhe aisi heroine zehar lagti hain novels mein jinke paas beauty without brains hoti hai. Aur Murad ka character bhi kuch khaas nahi tha waise. Novel ho toh Namal jaisi, aisi story agar ispar movie banjaaye toh super duper hit ho jaaye. Waise main Umera Ahmed ki bhot badi fan hun and Peer e Kamil was my favourite novel lekin yeh novel ummedon par khari nahi utri.....🙁
Its my own opinion and it may be wrong. But i think umera ahmad ki writing before becoming playwright was more mature and spiritual. . after that you can see a transition in her writing . . .a lil shallow i guess. .
Nice review. Story achi thi lakin js trha umera ahmed itnaaaa acha likhti hyn. Lakin jb dana pani prha to lg hi ni ra tha k umera g ny likha wsa interesting ni lga jasy bki novel hoty. But she knows better k ks character ko kis trha ly k chlna.
Assalomu alaykum Rabia bajje ap ki Harr vlog say mujay aor mahriee younger sister fareen jo muj say 2 years younger ha bohot kuch suknee ko milta ha you are doing great keep it up lots of❤ love and respect from 🇵🇰 Murree❤ Allah Pak bless you always and your family❤ Ameen ❤️
You are right this is not an intelligent writing ....so disappointing ... can't believe this is umaira Ahmed's novel.... don't read it it's just a waste of time
Oh oh oh an other novel that i never read like amarbail i intensly love this type of characters but ending also matter bcz i not want to cry i feel cry just at rewiew🥹
Thank you for an interesting review Rabia just want to tell that the story is set in the backdrop of 60s and all the questions that you asked like why Batool's character was shown as a negative character, why Tajwar lost her sanity and what Mahnoor did afterwards will all be answered in the sequel "Sikkay" which will come this year In sha ALLAH.
Waiting.... ❤
Can't wait to read it ❤
Waiting for the next part ❤
Oh great. Waiting anxiously
Waiting...... Anxiously ❤
I just finished reading this book, and every word you said resonates with my thoughts.
I understood that the story was set in the old era, but still I was disappointed knowing it's Umera Ahmed.
Koi to Amar bail ki bat kray ham Omar ko khona nahi chahtay is ka second part please we requested to you please umera Ahmad please buhat mushkil hai ab is ka part second ana chaiye we requested to you ❤❤
Just finished listening to the novel & literally your review is echoing my thoughts.
The writing, setting, charachters are all so very captivating but the story, at least in this part, is such a classic & familiar one.
ایک اور شاہکار عمیرہ احمد کے ہاتھوں سے لکھا ہوا😍❤❤❤
Main ne aj hi dana pani parha h aur mujhey ab season 2 ka intizar nhi kar sakti buhat mushkl h intizaar karna
Very honest review ❤ Maine b Novel end tk bs is liye padhi k ye Umera Ahmed ne likhi h AGR kisi Aur writer ne likhi hoti to shayad bich me hi chhodh deti.
Very nice review Rabia , thanks for choosing this book for review …… it was a beautiful book to read ….. I’m waiting for the 2nd part to come …..
I so agree with not reading and seeinh toxic friendship and yeah stories impact.that thought process is same. I also agree with dana paani and jannat kay pattay seems more like the old typical schematic storyline evil vs good . So yeah i think we have seen so good but now we have progressive life
I'm still in a novelll...... atleast ending shouldn't be like this I'm out of words !!!! Just umera's writting 😭❤️
Ap ny bilkl thk kha, Jab novel Nemrah aur Umera likhti tw bht mza ata
Yaar jo aap ne bola na kay woh scene boht typical tha jb woh train pe milty but still woh prh k jo khushi milti hai na🤣relatable tha ye🤣🤣
Assalamualaikum Rabia....Maine bhi is novel ko padha hai...aj raat hi khatam kiya hai...main har novel padhne k bad apka review dekhti hoon... I'm totally agreed with your points....but mujhe lagta hai iske age kuch bht acha hoga...is novel k sequel novel me Inshallah.... Mujhe sabse afsos hua "Gamu" ki mout ka padh kar... uske mout ke ek ek harf par dil bechain hone laga tha...wo pura phase disappointing tha mere liye..."mera andaza hai,sequel novel m,batool ki beti or murad ka beta ek doosre s mohabbat karege,or mahnoor us mohabbat ko mukammal nhi hone degi,as like tajwar",tb shayad batool.ko.tarp hogiii.....
Umera Ahmed ne Indian serial dekha tha ise likhte waqt , can't expect from Umera Ahmed.
Nemrah Ahmed is only favourite ❤
AA Rabia,
I am fond of your book reviews and enjoy learning about Urdu literature.
Is it possible for you to run a book club would Love to be a part of it.
Stay blessed💕💕
Yes good idea
UMERA AAPA ne likha iss liye prh rhi hun.thanks for 30 subscribers.
The story is good aswell....
Its not that the story was not 'intelligent and progressive""' but it shows the versatality of Umera Ahmed.
Yes, there were a few drawbacks, especially BATUL and death of Murad
I dont know why this novel is underrated ,
This is another masterpiece from umera ahmed ❤❤❤
Story well written but end is very disappointing.
Randomly ye review dekh liya n Nobel b parh liya....uffff.... like be it...I cried alot... recommended to friends also
The way of your talking about anything is just fantastic🎉
Behtreen. loved the way of explanation. Simple and easy to comprehend.
Hey Rabia, have you tried Mitch Albom's books they are literally so well written and different. I recently read The Stranger in the lifeboat and Tuesdays with Morrie.
After a very long time you posted I review, I really love your videos regarding books. ♥
No I have not read Mitch Albom books. Yes trying to go back to books :)
Yes same here
Why these channels not promote anything related to Deena and tons of work on Islam. They only focus on Fahaasi Showbiz industry as Kaptaan always called it.
Assalamualaikum Rabia.....! Please review a novel by Sadia Rajpoot "ishq e aatish".
Yes I want same
Please do review of umera ahmed novel amarbail
Shyd ap sb disagree karen but UA ki heroines strong hoti hein but remarkable nhi, mtlb koi extraordinary strength nhi hoti jesi ho skti hey,
For ex, salar sikender k dono beton ka high IQ hota hey, dono apny professions mein boht successful hotey hein but dusry side anaya ka character bs Abdullah k character ko support krny k liye tha, anaya bhi tou apny bhaion ki tarah professionally strong aur successful ho sakti thi,
Mere shadeed khuwahish hy UA aesa koi character likhey
Sing e Aahan is also written by Umera Ahmed and in that all women are remarkable.
After reading Amarbail, I totally agree with you. How stupid and immature Alizeh was. Her character was very poorly written. Imama also started acting immature and weird in Aab e hayat, like how can someone be like this after taking such big decisions of life. And and Motiya, she had nothing special except beauty. Her whole personality was written as she was drop dead gorgeous, stunning, pale white etc etc. Also she was studying medicine due to Murad's father. Nothing special at all
I felt this story was very similar to drama humsafar
Anjaam or sazish esi hi thii
RABIA JI. daana pani m jo shyriii padi gayi h mujhe vo bata skty. h khhh se li gayi h
Boht acha review diya hai Rabia mere dil me bhi yahi sab aya novel read krne k bad 😞 Ab umeed hai k sequel me kuch acha ho motiya k sath ❤
Oh i went too far into the review rabia.. thorey spoilers bhi sun liye😂 anyways will definitely read since desperately need something to read. No episode of maala yet either. Please koi aur kitab bhi hai tu share kerein.
Ya noval play store py to Nahi ha ,ap ko kahan sy Mila? Mujhy bhe parhna ha JB tak Maalaa Ka episode 14 Nahi ata ufff intazar karty karty thak gaye hn
@@imraavlogger3178yes too much wait for mala
That arif bhaii mujy 10 mint de dein srf😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 but overall it was a good review and i am not gonna read it because i want to read some intelligent stories something far from the typical love stories something sensible and meaningful. I am expecting more from Umera Ahmed♥️.
Assalamualaikum
Please make a review of novel or umera Ahamd "AKS"❣️
It's a best novel. I enjoyed...
Ya noval kahan available ha without book play store my to Nahi ha
Rabia I agree with your points , Umair Ahmad ak achi musnaf Hain but there is to much weak points In side the novel overall 👎
I agree
Bas mam bas ab mein chla read karne
Yhi to chaiye kam se kam read hi kar ke feel lelu😂
One thing which I found common in urdu novels is they try to portrait that girls who wear abaya nd practice all the different islamic norms are the only one who are real muslims , this is my opinion after reading umera Ahmed novel (English translation) and Nimra Ahmed novel(audio book) but anyways I like to always hear ur thoughts bcs u seem to look so genuine
Yeah so true, I think they should also share the side of Muslim girls without Abaya.
I think all Nemrah Ahmed heroines do not wear abaya. Zumar didn't, Taliya Murad didn't. Even Umera Ahmed has many heroines who don't wear abayas.
U are doing great work
@@iamrabiamughniI was actually trying to tell that most urdu novels are based on spirituality nd yes I didn't mean abt all the novel characters, I said only abt the novels which I read nd the ones which I heard through audiobooks bcs in those books it's precisely always said how a true muslim shd behave especially peer e kamil I was so excited to read that book but I was not very much satisfied with it bcs the book was more abt how to become a true Muslim nd how practising religion makes a person a perfect man nd those who don't practise religion are imperfect
Sry if I have offended u
@@viya2234yes nimrah ahmed, umera ahmed, sumera hameed they have given a new genre of novels in urdu which is very different from what classic wtites like manto and asmat chughtai etc wrote. So u have to accept that writers if this genere will talk about islam and hiw to be a good muslim etc. Huge nu.ber of readership reads their novels for same reason.
Honestly speaking ....being as nimrah ahmed's fan. Ab ye love stories itniiiii kr bongi lgti hain mje. Or ye novel m bht kuch meri smj sy bahar tha. Like motiya doctor bn ri thi to us ki parhai ka kya wo itniiii itniiiii lambi chutiya kesy guzarti thi gao aak. Or chand m shakal nzr ana...etc etc. Aisa pyar real life m nai hota. Nimrah reality based stories btati h. Jo k besttttt h
I swear aisi mohabbatein hazam nahi hoti hain yaar😂
Matlab, sirf ek do baar milne par kisi se itni shadeed qism ki mohabbat. Aur mujhe aisi heroine zehar lagti hain novels mein jinke paas beauty without brains hoti hai. Aur Murad ka character bhi kuch khaas nahi tha waise. Novel ho toh Namal jaisi, aisi story agar ispar movie banjaaye toh super duper hit ho jaaye. Waise main Umera Ahmed ki bhot badi fan hun and Peer e Kamil was my favourite novel lekin yeh novel ummedon par khari nahi utri.....🙁
Kindly do a review of amarbail by umera ahmad
I agree with you 💯
Sad ending bht mushkil hti ha brdasht krna phly Amar bail ki b sad thi ab iski b 😢😢
Rabia api.. kindly amarbail per review bhi kren jaldii
Dana pani novel ka dusra hisa kb publish ho ga aur uska name kia ha.? somebody guide me plz
Best novel forever
Mahnoor kai liye bura lga , usse acche se sidha zameen par utar diya i disappointed....
But ye matter of facts b to tha
K hum sab janein k aesa aesa b hua hai duniya mein. Isse b bura bura ho raha hai. Log kya kya kr rae hai.
Thank u rabiya for the detailed review
Wa Alaikum assalam
Api please give the review of Novel "Usri Yusra" by Husna Hussain
Its my own opinion and it may be wrong. But i think umera ahmad ki writing before becoming playwright was more mature and spiritual. . after that you can see a transition in her writing . . .a lil shallow i guess. .
Iska 2nd part Aya ke NAHI?
Bhot khobsurt khani ❤
Nice review. Story achi thi lakin js trha umera ahmed itnaaaa acha likhti hyn. Lakin jb dana pani prha to lg hi ni ra tha k umera g ny likha wsa interesting ni lga jasy bki novel hoty. But she knows better k ks character ko kis trha ly k chlna.
Hi Rabia... Kindly read Mitch Albom's novels
plz rabia ask umerahahmed k sequel kb aiyay ga? bcz they said about january or feb of this it’s already 5 months passsed
Dana Pani novel ka part 2 hona hai aap maloom kry hai bhi nahi it's request from you
Ya noval pdf my majood ha Kia? Koe bata sakta ha? Play store my to main ha ya noval
It's in kitab ghar
Best urdu novels ke naam suggest karen?
I think you should read namal,haalim,jannat kay pattay ,peer e kamil,aab e hayat,and mala is also nice which is an ongoing novel by nemrah ahmed
Is k session 2 nhi aya kya abhe tk plz bata da
Can u tell us when we can read the 3rd part of mala novel by namra ahmad
Hey rabia! Can you please add the reviews of aks and mani salwa novels by umera Ahmed please
TH-cam py novel prhny Ki permission kesy lety hn?
Assalomu alaykum Rabia bajje ap ki Harr vlog say mujay aor mahriee younger sister fareen jo muj say 2 years younger ha bohot kuch suknee ko milta ha you are doing great keep it up lots of❤ love and respect from 🇵🇰 Murree❤ Allah Pak bless you always and your family❤ Ameen ❤️
thanks so much. you made my day :)
@@iamrabiamughni ☺️🎈❤️❣️
@rabiamughani why can’t you say Salaam in the beginning.
Bht achi h ye book
Such a lovely novel
Hey rabia, Always loved your reviews. ❣️
Best novel.:)
Please review jane Austen ( all 4 novels)
Is ka part 2 kb ay ga???
Kitna time ho gya is novel ko?
Sherzaad novel ka review karona
Need summary
You are right this is not an intelligent writing ....so disappointing
... can't believe this is umaira Ahmed's novel.... don't read it it's just a waste of time
Aapko kya lgta h mahnoor Kai saath ?? Kaisa hua !?? I means when she heard about his husband second marriage
Oh oh oh an other novel that i never read like amarbail i intensly love this type of characters but ending also matter bcz i not want to cry i feel cry just at rewiew🥹
Part 2 aya Ya nhin 😢
Good review mam ❤
Ye book hindi mein ya english mein milti hai
Haa
Plss give a review on amarbail
👌👌👌
Happy ending?
No😢..
Wow I'm the first one to comment ?
اس سے اچھا تھا مراد اکیلے شادی کرلیتا
Worst novel that I have read so far
🫣🫣
Typical story writing such a.....🤐