I love Paul’s current voice so much. It’s not even “conceding” anything or “being nice”, I just love old people’s singing voices a lot. They sound so sweet and warm, in ways that young voices very often are not. Really love the lyrics sung with him, as recently as he did, with THIS voice.
Can you tell me what this means? I’m a big Beatles fan. Love McCartney. But how music works just eludes me. when you say his chords are recognizable what does that mean? If you ever see this question, I’d love to know.
2 ปีที่แล้ว +1
@@tomandrews2887Paul's playing is reckognisable particularly for his rhythm, all over his discography. The way he mutes and hits the strings, hits the piano, etc. Specially noticeable when he's playing drums or acoustic guitar, there's a McCartney feel. You could say that about lots of musicians as well but I prefer the McCartney sound. Albums like Chaos and Creation and Flaming Pie where he plays almost every instrument, have the McCartney groove all over them !
When Paul played Lollapalooza Chicago he did a little bit of "FourFiveSeconds" and then he went imediattly into "We Can Work It Out". I saw him playing the full song in Belo Horizonte last year, but I would love to see that little medley.
A worthy addition to the McCartney catalog of hits and beyond. He picked up a force of nature known as Rihanna and an evangelist named Kanye along the way.
The Indie Diary Yeah, he's not a "musician". But that's being pendantic. And Paul has worked with Kanye three different times and said he's quirky but he likes him and would again. But I'm glad Paul has more forward opinions on music than some of his listeners do. Rihanna is close to beating a couple Beatles billboard records and is highly acclaimed but some people comment on her like she's nothing. Lots of folks with limited horizons and probably racism in their musical opinions.
Paul McCartney and Kanye should do a whole project together. At the very least, an EP's worth of bangers. Both of them are absolute geniuses, and have distinct styles, and the amalgamation of those 2 distinctive styles put together is just musical bliss. Please, oh please, get the two of them back in the studio together. It would be one of the biggest projects ever conceived! Do it, 'Ye and Sir Paul! Yall have great chemistry together, and I hope you both recognize that! Legends and Icons!
Paul McCartney is geniune legend. He was in the greatest band ever. He was in a songwriting partnership, Lennon and McCartney that was the greatest ever. Whether they wrote together or alone while in The Beatles, they were just awesome. Progressive, imaginative, powerful and beautiful. I would say the only artist who could compete with them for a time was Bob Dylan. As a solo artist he's never been able to reach those peaks again consistently. Nobody could. They wrote some of pop/rock musics greatest tracks, consistently, we will ever hear. He has written some real gems as a solo/wings artist. Some of his album's are now considered great work by a solo Beatle. McCartney, Ram is one of his best in my opinion, Band on the run has always been highly recieved. It's a perfect McCartney album. There's not a bad moment on it and it holds in it some great songs, the title track, jet, let me roll it, nineteen hundred and eighty five is one of my favourite solo McCartney tracks. Flaming pie and chaos and creation in the backyard are both brilliant later day McCartney album's. There's venus and mars, tug of war, flowers in the dirt. All good album's, but not what I would call classic. People will disagree with me, as everyone has their own opinions on what they consider to be his greatest work. That's what music is about. As an artist, I don't feel McCartney is the great songwriter who wrote Eleanor Rigby, Hey Jude, Listen to what the man said etch. His music no longer appeals to me. But I have the Beatles album's, when he was at the height of his powers. I also have 7 of his solo and wings album's that I consider to be Paul working his magic. I hope he keeps making music for his many fans, as long as he can. He is a living legend. In my opinion he is among the 3 greatest songwriter's ever. Lennon, McCartney and Dylan.☮️
I LOVE ❤️ this SO MUCH MORE than the original . When the original first came out and I saw his name, I remember immediately clicking so fast... and I was waiting for Paul to sing 🥺 only to find out it was just Kanye and Rihanna but all I did was smile every-time they showed Paul playing his guitar . 😭😭😭 Paul is all I live for in music 🥰
Listen, I'm a Beatles obsessive and lifelong McCartney fan but this is absolutely not better than the original. Rihanna makes the original. It's cringe hearing Paul struggling to sing this.
@@mauritius_pe absolutely. He can't sing it. It's like watching your grandad butchering some karaoke. It's such a modern song too and the style of vocals just doesn't suit him.
I love The Beatles, they are the band that got me seriously into music...so interestingly Paul (a man in his late 70s) using 'like' like a member of today's youth is something I both simultaneously hate and love!!!
People disrespect Kanye so much because of his mental health. It's actually really sad. Here you have Paul, one of the greatest singer/songwriters talking about the genius of Kanye... This guy who, in 2 days, creates a song that reaches the top of the charts... 2 days folks...
I want an AI version of this song with young Paul McCartney voice, John Lennon singing back up and guitar, Ringo style drums, and George Harrison solo, please and thank you.
People really need to give serious credit to Kanye. He loves taking pauls melodies and writing lyrics on top of them. Remember Kanye wrote and produced this entire song... Rihanna just came to be the lead vocalist cos her voice is just unreal, but this is real Paul n Ye featuring rihanna
It would’ve been good to hear a young Paul sing this
I agree, but on the other hand his old-man voice is full of soul, I just happen to love it.
Technically Paul wrote that song. Not rhiana. So Paul deserves most of the credit
Helter skelter paul would've killed this
@@laurencefishburnt8866 that'd be mind blowing
@@louis.gabriel no
It’s really funny hearing Paul McCartney saying things like wildin’
HAHA “i heard you was talkin’ trash”
sounds like someone has never heard The Fireman
The real James Paul McCartney died in 1966.
It's Billy Shepherd (William) singing something Paul would never have done.
I love Paul’s current voice so much. It’s not even “conceding” anything or “being nice”, I just love old people’s singing voices a lot. They sound so sweet and warm, in ways that young voices very often are not. Really love the lyrics sung with him, as recently as he did, with THIS voice.
McCartney's chords are always recognisable and his hallmark. Not needed singing. Incredible.
Can you tell me what this means? I’m a big Beatles fan. Love McCartney. But how music works just eludes me. when you say his chords are recognizable what does that mean? If you ever see this question, I’d love to know.
@@tomandrews2887Paul's playing is reckognisable particularly for his rhythm, all over his discography. The way he mutes and hits the strings, hits the piano, etc. Specially noticeable when he's playing drums or acoustic guitar, there's a McCartney feel. You could say that about lots of musicians as well but I prefer the McCartney sound. Albums like Chaos and Creation and Flaming Pie where he plays almost every instrument, have the McCartney groove all over them !
@@tomandrews2887Listen to Penny Lane. His chords are genius. Key changes and such. It’s hearing something that sounds abnormal but correct
I love the way he says "wildin"
I am almost 34 & grew up listening to my guy. My mom went to JL’s memorial service.
did not expect that... but I like this version more than the origanal...
Corenlius Sulla yeah Paul got to sing on this version
The classic paul mccartney is the best
Corenlius Sulla did you just say origANAL 😂
Considering he wrote EVERYTHING this is the original lol
Wow...hearing it like this, FourFiveSeconds is a Wings song. Its totally got that McCartney trademark sound.
It's Paul❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
When Paul played Lollapalooza Chicago he did a little bit of "FourFiveSeconds" and then he went imediattly into "We Can Work It Out". I saw him playing the full song in Belo Horizonte last year, but I would love to see that little medley.
I prefer this version.
@Malachi Lui no
The most versatile musician ever?
A worthy addition to the McCartney catalog of hits and beyond. He picked up a force of nature known as Rihanna and an evangelist named Kanye along the way.
I love you Paul❤
Unbeliebeable
This song is just soo amazing! Been listening since it came out....thats exactly how music should be like, just simple but impactful 😁😁.
Thank you Paul! #egyptstation
How can you still be this cool
This crowd was not impressed by Paul's mention of Kanye.
Hard to overlook the Trump thing with him.
Christopher A. How? Who cares about his political beliefs he’s still a pretty good musician.
The Burning Candles TBCX I agree. But it's a NYC crowd. I live there. He's not exactly in peoples' good grace at the moment. I'm just explaining.
Kanye and musician, are not 2 words i'd ever put close together.
The Indie Diary Yeah, he's not a "musician". But that's being pendantic. And Paul has worked with Kanye three different times and said he's quirky but he likes him and would again.
But I'm glad Paul has more forward opinions on music than some of his listeners do. Rihanna is close to beating a couple Beatles billboard records and is highly acclaimed but some people comment on her like she's nothing. Lots of folks with limited horizons and probably racism in their musical opinions.
Paul is a legend
On a trip to my hometown right now and repeating on this song. Definitely, a terrific one! Thanks Paul, West and Rihanna.
I feel like, if Paul wants to work with you, and talks pretty glowingly of you, you’re doing something right
Paul McCartney and Kanye should do a whole project together. At the very least, an EP's worth of bangers. Both of them are absolute geniuses, and have distinct styles, and the amalgamation of those 2 distinctive styles put together is just musical bliss. Please, oh please, get the two of them back in the studio together. It would be one of the biggest projects ever conceived! Do it, 'Ye and Sir Paul! Yall have great chemistry together, and I hope you both recognize that! Legends and Icons!
Sir Paul, i'm so excited to see you in Rio this year. I've dreamed about it since I was a little girl. Love you ❤
God bless you paul ,im still loving you 🙏
he's amazing
my favorite singer of all time 😍😍💖🎵🎵👍🏼👍🏼💖
Y love you Lord..... you are thé BEST..
Aha! This explains the mysterious squeeks behind the song. Cheers Sir, big fan of this one, good to hear this properly 😊
This is the version that should have existed forever.
What a great song
You are so sweet paul ❤
Paul McCartney is geniune legend. He was in the greatest band ever. He was in a songwriting partnership, Lennon and McCartney that was the greatest ever. Whether they wrote together or alone while in The Beatles, they were just awesome. Progressive, imaginative, powerful and beautiful. I would say the only artist who could compete with them for a time was Bob Dylan. As a solo artist he's never been able to reach those peaks again consistently. Nobody could. They wrote some of pop/rock musics greatest tracks, consistently, we will ever hear. He has written some real gems as a solo/wings artist. Some of his album's are now considered great work by a solo Beatle. McCartney, Ram is one of his best in my opinion, Band on the run has always been highly recieved. It's a perfect McCartney album. There's not a bad moment on it and it holds in it some great songs, the title track, jet, let me roll it, nineteen hundred and eighty five is one of my favourite solo McCartney tracks. Flaming pie and chaos and creation in the backyard are both brilliant later day McCartney album's. There's venus and mars, tug of war, flowers in the dirt. All good album's, but not what I would call classic. People will disagree with me, as everyone has their own opinions on what they consider to be his greatest work. That's what music is about. As an artist, I don't feel McCartney is the great songwriter who wrote Eleanor Rigby, Hey Jude, Listen to what the man said etch. His music no longer appeals to me. But I have the Beatles album's, when he was at the height of his powers. I also have 7 of his solo and wings album's that I consider to be Paul working his magic. I hope he keeps making music for his many fans, as long as he can. He is a living legend. In my opinion he is among the 3 greatest songwriter's ever. Lennon, McCartney and Dylan.☮️
please please please record this version! Way better than the released one. PLEASE PAUL :D
I LOVE ❤️ this SO MUCH MORE than the original . When the original first came out and I saw his name, I remember immediately clicking so fast... and I was waiting for Paul to sing 🥺 only to find out it was just Kanye and Rihanna but all I did was smile every-time they showed Paul playing his guitar . 😭😭😭 Paul is all I live for in music 🥰
This is by far my favorite version
Like this a lot
AH!!!!!!!! No words. Amazing. Legend. And, here for everyone as Alive as can be!
amazing!!
Snatched back! Love it!
😍😍in love
This song technically did well. But I felt like it was so underrated. Kanye and rihanna really added a lot of good to this song though.
Well Kanye wrote most of it, for a start
@@bw2937 it was Paul
This version is wayy better than the original, in my opinion. Why?
Because Paul
Listen, I'm a Beatles obsessive and lifelong McCartney fan but this is absolutely not better than the original. Rihanna makes the original. It's cringe hearing Paul struggling to sing this.
@@HoudiniJam but mccartney is 78 and does not use autotune here.
@@boazmusic9992 Rihanna didn't use autotune at all, only Kanye did. She's an amazing singer
@@HoudiniJam cringe????
@@mauritius_pe absolutely. He can't sing it. It's like watching your grandad butchering some karaoke. It's such a modern song too and the style of vocals just doesn't suit him.
How he says “had enough” and “woke up an optimist”… he owns this song, Ye worked it for the masses, Rihanna made it eternal.
I. Have. To.see.this.man.live.
King of charisma..
This is beautiful
I love The Beatles, they are the band that got me seriously into music...so interestingly Paul (a man in his late 70s) using 'like' like a member of today's youth is something I both simultaneously hate and love!!!
I think that's a Liverpool thing. It seems like he's done that forever.
Honestly I was so confused when I first saw the video. What was a former Beatles member doing with Rihanna and Kanye 😂
Amazing
WHOA. WHAT KEY IS THIS?!? I LOVE IT SO MUCH MORE.
Iblove this so muuch 💖💖💖😭
I do miss John so much.
This versions hella better feels more electric
Bro this actually slaps as a rock song. I prefer it performed this way
Fire
omg this video was better than i thought it would be! actually i don't think i've ever seen paul mccartney play, so this was great for me :D
Catch back up on his 70s live performances with Wings. He was and still is a powerhouse, especially on bass.
It's greater than the original version!!!
jose antonio ortiz sanchez prieto this is actually the “original version”!
It isn't tho
cap
Hardly
Eu amo essa fera ....sabe o que cantar 🙌🏻🙌🏻🙌🏻🙌🏻🙌🏻😍😘❤
Legend 🙌
People disrespect Kanye so much because of his mental health. It's actually really sad. Here you have Paul, one of the greatest singer/songwriters talking about the genius of Kanye... This guy who, in 2 days, creates a song that reaches the top of the charts... 2 days folks...
Even if kanye makes garbage music you can't Diss him for it
Didn't make it in two days, he and Paul recorded for two days then Kanye took a few weeks to finish it.
Pls God...dont take McCartney from us...
2:24 is the best. Once it picks up..
I want an AI version of this song with young Paul McCartney voice, John Lennon singing back up and guitar, Ringo style drums, and George Harrison solo, please and thank you.
That was sooooo good. Better than the original. In mho.
Yeah they do take My kindness. For weakness Too
eu amo esse veio
what ❤️
Honestly just Paul and Rihanna singing this would make me love this song more
2 geniuses made a great song and rihanna killed it also.
1 of those 2 "geniuses" is actually a genius, and the other one is Kanye West.
Archil Zhvania hating on Kanye is getting old. You try to do what Kanye has done musically, I don't think you could.
Not hating Kanye. He's far from being genius, though.
Archil Zhvania he most definitely is a genius and I hope you relaide
@@UTuberz04 What prominent did he make musically? Show me a song.
fabulous
Missed the bridge! Great to hear Paul do this ... and they missed the best part. Great song tho!
Il est phénoménal. Est-ce encore bien utile de vous dire qu'on vous aime Sir Paul? Salutations
Come in Lollapalooza and rock in brazil the best of world!
ari presento esta cancion con su team en the voice estoy tan feliz
i prefer this version
Why am I not subscribed and Paul McCartney? Like what’s wrong with me?
LOVE YOU
LIKE I KNOW YOU
ALL MY LIFES
Bien😮😮🙃🙃💚🙋
Awesome!
People really need to give serious credit to Kanye. He loves taking pauls melodies and writing lyrics on top of them. Remember Kanye wrote and produced this entire song... Rihanna just came to be the lead vocalist cos her voice is just unreal, but this is real Paul n Ye featuring rihanna
La voz de Paul se escucha cansada su espíritu sigue ferviente nació para ser grande.
Paul take me on I’m the young Jesus
Studio version pls
Is Duff McKagen playing bass?
💓
😭💜
Hey This Paul Mccartney guy is going to make it big one day since he did a song with kanye and rhianna!
esto se pblico el dia d emi cumpleaños
Клёво!!
De quién es el tema original? De Rihanna?
I wish there would be a collaboration between Paul McCartney and Roger Waters 😊
Mejor que la versión original!!
THIS DESERVES SO MUCH MORE ATTENTION LIKE WHAT?!😭 the 59 people who gave a thumbs down are tone deaf 👁👄👁
yeah - expected to come here and say ‘love this version way more’ but no - Rihanna OWNS this song and her vocals
I prefer this version over the recording.
Love U, love your music, live you're vegan. #GoVegan for your health, for animals, for the planet. For the future. 🙏☮️💚
Like his somewhat rough/scratchy voice in that song..
Wow Paul is still pulling beautiful women to his shows lol what a god
for me Paul>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Rihanna, Kanye
2'39 Paul Hahn, Daft Punk's manager? ;)