There is no way to know what prompted the thumbs down. Perhaps he didn't like the A-flat rather than A-natural or something (else) too subtle for you to hear. The young musicians might know exactly what he objected to; and, they were hoping no one would notice it. On the other hand, maybe he's just stupid.
@@claytonpoon7764 It's not as much that as it is going to a video about jazz, hearing it done really well, and disliking without giving a reason. If you don't want to hear a version of Donna Lee, then don't open the video.This is such a great community and it baffles me that we still have toxic people in it.
Man that is just amazing God that alto player is phenomenal so is the trumpeter and tenor man! Dona lee is one of my favorites but i still can't seem to play it on my alto but I can I play it on my guitar lol
Dayum!! this is killer! I came from Gabe Evans website and randomly clicked "Donna Lee". You guys smoke it, and the interlude and Gabe's little touches are so cool. Rhythm section, so tight too. Solos, mind-blowing. Great stuff guys!
I like how the Alto tried to keep his laughter or smile in in the beginning. I can't blame him, if I had that much sauce, it would be hard not to smile too
It's such a nice new, soothing jazz. You can feel the new elegance after the time of two decades of free jazz. The present has reconciled so many free elements that once took some getting used to, that it is a pleasure to listen to these young musicians. Love the contribution of the piano player. (Sorry for my maybe strange english). Greetings from Germany.
Really great version of the tune! Everybody in this combo are great musicians. I really like the the piano quotes. And alto sax is monstruous! Greetings from Argentina
So cool seeing you young cats absolutely killin' it in straight-ahead jazz! Keep up the great work, and I look forward to hearing more about all of you in your future musical endeavors!
Carlos Schvartzman In that article it states that Miles Davis wrote "Donna Lee". Will gladly change the description if you can send me something that proves otherwise!
Hi Stuart! I know I wouldn't have to ask a question like this if my ears were better, but the modal break you guys are adding between choruses is 8 bars of Ab Mixolydian, 8 of E Mixolydian and 8 of Eb Mixolydian (ish) right?
Jacobo Vega-Albela hi Jacobo, you're really close! What's written on the page (in concert pitch) is Ab7sus, E7sus, Eb7sus. However, we took a lot of liberty of the changes and weren't necessarily always playing those chord qualities.
Greatissimo performance by each member of the group. Alex smokes and burns relentlessly. What an alto saxophonic display of excellence! The tenorman, not unlike the trap drummer, is a polite inferno that can be extinguish with only maximum difficulties. The trumpeter, bassist and pianist are gentle giants who will certainly create brilliance in the not-too-distance future. Great Band.
when bird said “in the next 25 maybe even 50 years maybe some youngster will come along and take this and do something with it” he was talking about alex hahn.
+Stuart Mack D@mn you guys are killin' it! Sax and drum player here. :) Big THUMBS UP! Well I know that it's been years ago now, but can you PLEASE ask JOHN STURINO what right hand RIDE CYMBAL he is playing here??? I want to steal that pie right off his kit, haha! Thanks! - B.B.
Is there any way you could help me get a piano part for this. Possibly a drum part as well? I'm trying to play this as a trio at school and I'm unable to find an arrangement for both piano and drums. Thanks!
I love the bass player's expressions.
Colonel_Chu He walked that bass from LA to New York and back
+Jousting Dildos
Me too!!
Is that Dmitri Shostakovich with... Princess Leias hair?
Stuart Mack was
Wow! As a jazz musician myself, it's always to see the great and emerging talented "younger generation" carry on the jazz tradition. Kudos to you!
Thanks so much Jeremiah!!!!
Yes, it warms my heart to see and especially hear!
The person that disliked should be placed in a pit of poisonous snakes. Why hate on kids making art. Get a life. Great job Stu
There is no way to know what prompted the thumbs down. Perhaps he didn't like the A-flat rather than A-natural or something (else) too subtle for you to hear. The young musicians might know exactly what he objected to; and, they were hoping no one would notice it. On the other hand, maybe he's just stupid.
or he missed the like button
People are allowed to have different opinions from you?
@@claytonpoon7764 It's not as much that as it is going to a video about jazz, hearing it done really well, and disliking without giving a reason. If you don't want to hear a version of Donna Lee, then don't open the video.This is such a great community and it baffles me that we still have toxic people in it.
Poor stupid,idiot and above all jealous!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Man that is just amazing God that alto player is phenomenal so is the trumpeter and tenor man! Dona lee is one of my favorites but i still can't seem to play it on my alto but I can I play it on my guitar lol
jacob bowen I play guitar bass sax clarinet and keys
I think its easiest on sax since it was oringinaly written for that
Nice, another alto/guitar player
I love this alto player.
Dayum!! this is killer! I came from Gabe Evans website and randomly clicked "Donna Lee". You guys smoke it, and the interlude and Gabe's little touches are so cool. Rhythm section, so tight too. Solos, mind-blowing. Great stuff guys!
I like how the Alto tried to keep his laughter or smile in in the beginning. I can't blame him, if I had that much sauce, it would be hard not to smile too
the real musicians of youtube ^^. Wish skill like this was still respected like it used to be.
Excellent
I listen to this as often as I can
Liam Lord awesome :)
Takes Donna Lee up a level.. i need this run in a Spotify playlist
Instant like after that saxophone-solo-intro. Awesome!
unbelievable!!
!!DE PELÍCULA!!..........
Alv!!! Super insane,powerfull AND cool!!
Great playing by all.
I really love it❤❤❤
I love this
It's such a nice new, soothing jazz. You can feel the new elegance after the time of two decades of free jazz. The present has reconciled so many free elements that once took some getting used to, that it is a pleasure to listen to these young musicians. Love the contribution of the piano player. (Sorry for my maybe strange english). Greetings from Germany.
These cats are simply in beast mode!
Really great version of the tune! Everybody in this combo are great musicians. I really like the the piano quotes. And alto sax is monstruous! Greetings from Argentina
Didn’t know Rick Astley played the alto
He's never gonna give it up
fax lmaoooo
Amazing job fellas
Very nice version
amazing... please do dizzy's salt peanuts.
jagermeister5 yeah!!!!
This is burnin. Nice work, guys.
So cool seeing you young cats absolutely killin' it in straight-ahead jazz! Keep up the great work, and I look forward to hearing more about all of you in your future musical endeavors!
Great sentiment but straight ahead jazz this definitely isn't
Great ideas, really nice rendition. awesome tones. over all outstanding
Thank you!
Very very very nice!👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
Killin Stuart!!! I love your playing and how fluid your ideas are. Great. Work man!!!
Thanks so much man!
fantastic.
Did they take it faster than the tempo Donna lee was originally in? Cuz it sounds like it
This is around 300; Parker's is at 230
Playing it GRP big band style😎
Yup. This about the same tempo as the Wynton Marsalis cut.
In the real book its 200 but the 2nd arangement is at 250 but idk what this is in
@@rezqyagung7782 4 years later 🥲 thank you
I'm an alto player, and you, as a trumpet player, stood out to me. Smooth and melodic ideas.
Wow! Thank you so much for your kind words!
Great Playing!!!
Fuck this was the most pleasing thing to my ears all month.. it’s gold jerry it’s gold!!
Amazing
Keep going ! greetings from Mexico,
Dat style! what's it's going on! you nailed it guys!
Awesome !
Great work Lads!!!!!!!!!!!
Thanks!!
maravilhoso, inspirador... parabéns!!!!!
Stunning. Everyone just stellar!! Thank you so much
Loved it!!!
thank you!
Thank you for making jazz
these guys are good!
+Joshua Han
Thanks!
Real Nice Guys!
I actually love it! Great great recording
+spaz life
Thank you!
Awesome dudes, you guys nailed it!
Cheers from Brasil!
Dammmmmm! That's burn'in!!!
Y'all make me so excited to be going to UNT in the fall. The hang will be so great with guys like you
Sensacional parabens...
Beautiful, out of the box, version - heard a little Steely Dan Aja in there.
Nice job, guys!
Killin' it!
+Marty Metcalf
Thank you!
superb man.
+nockle
Thank you!!
This is dope!
+Antonio baez
Thank you!
Hey everyone! Thanks for watching my videos. :) Anyways, for those of you who might be interested, here's my new website!
www.stuartmackjazz.com
Thanks so much!
Thank you!
www.jazzstandards.com/compositions-1/donnalee.htm
Carlos Schvartzman In that article it states that Miles Davis wrote "Donna Lee". Will gladly change the description if you can send me something that proves otherwise!
Hi Stuart! I know I wouldn't have to ask a question like this if my ears were better, but the modal break you guys are adding between choruses is 8 bars of Ab Mixolydian, 8 of E Mixolydian and 8 of Eb Mixolydian (ish) right?
Jacobo Vega-Albela hi Jacobo, you're really close! What's written on the page (in concert pitch) is Ab7sus, E7sus, Eb7sus. However, we took a lot of liberty of the changes and weren't necessarily always playing those chord qualities.
Amazing!!!! I love it! ♥
Perfeito
brilliant guys! off to transcribing I am now!
YEAAAA
video : *starts*
me : *checking the playback speed*
super bom em delirios!!!
Greatissimo performance by each member of the group.
Alex smokes and burns relentlessly.
What an alto saxophonic display of excellence!
The tenorman, not unlike the trap drummer, is a polite inferno that can be extinguish with only maximum difficulties.
The trumpeter, bassist and pianist are gentle giants who will certainly create brilliance in the not-too-distance future.
Great Band.
Genius players.
Muito bom!!!
i need to know how to comp like the pianist. i hear a lot of mccoy tyner in there
Are your fingers alive after that ? You kill the game ! 👌🏼
wow!
I'm glad you liked it!
Great job guys, sounds awesome!! exciting performance well done.
+geoffmobile
Thank you!
Oh my God, very nice :D
Amazing!!! :D
Damn Alex!
when bird said “in the next 25 maybe even 50 years maybe some youngster will come along and take this and do something with it” he was talking about alex hahn.
Listen to this at twice the speed. It’s intense
+Stuart Mack
D@mn you guys are killin' it! Sax and drum player here. :) Big THUMBS UP!
Well I know that it's been years ago now, but can you PLEASE ask JOHN STURINO what right hand RIDE CYMBAL he is playing here??? I want to steal that pie right off his kit, haha!
Thanks!
- B.B.
What are the changues in the harmony? Congrats!
That bass tho!
Daaaaaaang.
cool
Sell this on itunes
Ooowee!
Emily Xander lol! Thanks 😊
1:00 the saxophonist sounds exactly like baptiste herbin!
Holy shit
Dude, this is really really awesome! How can i find u guys on spotify????????
what's the name of the second tune
fuck i wish I never quit music.
Fucking insane!!!!!! These boys would’ve scared the shit of out em back in the day
At 1:45. the bass player must be thinking his fingers are going to fall off and saying to himself "hands don't cramp up now!!".
whats the altos whole setup? sounds sweet!
Sasha king crimson !!!
nice modern take on a classic tune...
I think the 1960s ended a long time ago?
0:50
Is there any way you could help me get a piano part for this. Possibly a drum part as well? I'm trying to play this as a trio at school and I'm unable to find an arrangement for both piano and drums. Thanks!
What's your email?
o compositor é o miles Davis? Pensei que era o Parker.
+thisaxlevy I thought Parker as well, but Wikipedia says Miles Davis.
It is not an easy question, read here (read also the comments): peterspitzer.blogspot.com.br/2011/05/tunes-miles-may-not-have-written.html
fino..
👍
Say what you want but that bassist was popping off
How do u practice getting faster at jazz articulation ?
if you know bebop articulation you tongue the off beats and slur going into the beat! Just work on tonguing exercises