@@sobhanshams7016 They used to fight too much and after a bit they could not do it anymore, also both wanted to pursue solo careers this happened in 2011, so sad :'( hope this helped
@@sobhanshams7016 Yulia, wanting a relationship, her boyfriend left her as soon as she fell pregnant. It ruined Lena. When Yulia tried coming back to Lena, she had got herself a man in her absence. It was a very vicious love cycle. The duo couldn't last. Their feelings for each other were far too strong. They ended up going solo.
@@sobhanshams7016 also Yulia had cancer and so she can't sing anymore the way she did but in spring 2022 they will meet up and perform for all their fans!!!
I know that they always say they never dated, and that they were just really close friends, but if you ask me, this song shows that there was something going on there.
i cried hearing this video. :'( It's bad to know that its imposible to make they sign together again. Julia's voice and face is not the same. tATu can start with other singers that's the only way but it will never be the same.
It was their producer who made them act like a couple for publicity, but, they weren't allowed to date. They did, however, end up falling in love with each other. Yulia, wanting a relationship, went off with a boyfriend who left her as soon as she fell pregnant. It ruined Lena. When Yulia tried coming back to Lena, she had got herself a man in her absence. It was a very vicious love cycle. The duo couldn't last. Their feelings for each other were far too strong. They ended up going solo.
Not true, they both said in a recent interview that it was more of a close friendship and they weren't seriously lovers. Julia is more interested in kissing Russian government's ass now (the same government that passed laws that would make Tatu illegal in today's Russia) while Lena continues to make beautiful music.
Леночка, Красота! Выкинь эту гадость (сигарету) и никогда даже в руки не бери! Береги здоровье и красоту!!! Остальное - супер! Счастья и творческих успехов!!!
I am sure there was something, there is so much footage on stage and off where they were very close. More then just your average friends. I thinking it is interesting both of them dated/married unattractive men, yet the two of them are so attractive it is astounding.
WHY DO PEOPLE SAY SUCH BAD THINGS ABOUT JULIA! they both were the reason tatu succeeded! they are both very beautiful and very talented. sure julia hade plasic sugury or watever you people call it but that does not make her un-talented! tatu was a great band i wish they hadnt had broken up too. but just because of that dosent mean you have to like one over the other. i personally like them both and i wish them a lot of luck but please do not say bad things about julia. it upsets me and others FU
heyy eres una verdadera artista una gran artista de verdad te admiro por tus talento y por la forma de amar que tienes tan bonita me gusta demasiado esta canción espero julia sepa valorar eso mucha suerte :=
Last time I checked, Lena had confirmed that they were NOT getting back together. She and Yulia/Julia wanted to focus on their solo careers, but they ARE reuniting for a show at a Russian VIP club.
This is the real story of Tatu, like Abba's "Winner", the same situation, but here it is about the love between 2 girls. And this is how Tatu died... Would love them to reunite, same for Abba (but Abba is physically impossible, it's 30 years since they broke up), Vanilla Ninja and Tarja back in Nightwish. Sad that Julia doesn't feel in the same way... 2 girls loving each other, happy of that, but unfortunately, beautiful things can't be forever what they are, which's a pity.
Think it would be better if it was 'I'll always respect you BUT life goes on' and 'Our moments together I'LL ALWAYS TREASURE' still an awesome song...just my inner song writer unable to contain herself lol xx
If I remember correctly, Yulia's husband or boyfriend or whatever he was got between them and Yulia wasn't really in it anymore. That's what I've read.
That would be Parviz Yasinov who is the father of her son. Parvis would sit with Lena and Yulia in interviews. I also gather he was mentally abusive to Yulia, he threatened to leave her if she got fat during the pregnancy of their son, so she exercised a lot. He also was cheating on her and this was the time she started to get plastic surgery. Rather sad.
Career-wise, because they wanted to do solo careers. Which I'm all for this anyways, I never really liked Yulia. I always thought she was holding Lena back. Relationship-wise, they were never "together" so they can't "break up". The whole lesbian thing was made up by the man who created t.A.T.u. and after they broke off from him they came clean about the whole thing.
PLAGIATE with all caps!!! Clever & sneaky remake of "In the Shadows" from The Rasmus. Shame on you, Lena! Nicola Tesla used to say: "I don't care that they steal my ideas. I care that they don't have their own."
are you fucking stupid? she smokes! Have you seen videos and stuff of tatus life? because in those the smoked ALOT, dont act like you know something when you clearly dont, naive person
Amy Christopher I don't condone smoking but it sounds like you need one or two cigarettes and you're right it's what I THINK it's MY OPINION that people who smoke don't look attractive oh and people who swear a lot must be stupid other wise you would have something else to say ok poopy head
This is a world level single. Very beautiful. Lena, I wish you more songs like this one. Molodets. Spasibo.
listened to this right after reading their story, which makes it the saddest and truest song ever. hope they come back together again
Why were they seprated
@@sobhanshams7016 They used to fight too much and after a bit they could not do it anymore, also both wanted to pursue solo careers this happened in 2011, so sad :'( hope this helped
@@sobhanshams7016 Yulia, wanting a relationship, her boyfriend left her as soon as she fell pregnant. It ruined Lena. When Yulia tried coming back to Lena, she had got herself a man in her absence. It was a very vicious love cycle. The duo couldn't last. Their feelings for each other were far too strong. They ended up going solo.
@@sobhanshams7016 also Yulia had cancer and so she can't sing anymore the way she did but in spring 2022 they will meet up and perform for all their fans!!!
I know that they always say they never dated, and that they were just really close friends, but if you ask me, this song shows that there was something going on there.
Just have to watch the clip, Lena strokes and kisses Yulia's photograph tenderly like a lover.
I still can't believe they broke up :(. We have lost a one of the true last talented duo the
record's label has ever seen.
they were never..😢
i cried hearing this video. :'( It's bad to know that its imposible to make they sign together again. Julia's voice and face is not the same. tATu can start with other singers that's the only way but it will never be the same.
saddest part 1:53 - 1:57 :( so sad
It was their producer who made them act like a couple for publicity, but, they weren't allowed to date. They did, however, end up falling in love with each other. Yulia, wanting a relationship, went off with a boyfriend who left her as soon as she fell pregnant. It ruined Lena. When Yulia tried coming back to Lena, she had got herself a man in her absence. It was a very vicious love cycle. The duo couldn't last. Their feelings for each other were far too strong. They ended up going solo.
Rose Pryor how do you know this stuff???
Real talk though, Shopavalov is a fucking creep.
Not true, they both said in a recent interview that it was more of a close friendship and they weren't seriously lovers. Julia is more interested in kissing Russian government's ass now (the same government that passed laws that would make Tatu illegal in today's Russia) while Lena continues to make beautiful music.
Awesome. Love this song!
Леночка, Красота! Выкинь эту гадость (сигарету) и никогда даже в руки не бери! Береги здоровье и красоту!!! Остальное - супер! Счастья и творческих успехов!!!
For my ex, who I loved more than life at one point. You were just too toxic. I'll never forget you :/
Am I the only one who thinks Lena and Yulia wasn't fake and that they still love each other, maybe not as before, but still?
I am sure there was something, there is so much footage on stage and off where they were very close. More then just your average friends. I thinking it is interesting both of them dated/married unattractive men, yet the two of them are so attractive it is astounding.
I dnt y i also feel that
Yes.
WHY DO PEOPLE SAY SUCH BAD THINGS ABOUT JULIA! they both were the reason tatu succeeded! they are both very beautiful and very talented. sure julia hade plasic sugury or watever you people call it but that does not make her un-talented! tatu was a great band i wish they hadnt had broken up too. but just because of that dosent mean you have to like one over the other. i personally like them both and i wish them a lot of luck but please do not say bad things about julia. it upsets me and others FU
Why they were seprated the reson?
I know this by my heart!!! Love u Lena. Tatu FOREVER!!!!!!
this song is actually for Julia .:(
Thank you very much for an amazing video and lyrics.
its so sad that they broke up hopfully one day they will get back together its just a wish :(
Just because they are both girls and not boy and girl - it's a big test from God and they will be paid for that - they are unique together, I cried
heyy eres una verdadera artista una gran artista de verdad te admiro por tus talento y por la forma de amar que tienes tan bonita me gusta demasiado esta canción espero julia sepa valorar eso mucha suerte :=
I'LL NEVER FORGET t.A.T.u NEVER NEVER AND NEVER!! :((( it's make me cry i miss old times : ) not gonna get you..good job lena
1:00 love that picture of her
Dx I'll never forget t.A.T.u!
True love never die
💖💖💖💖💖💖💖
I will NEVER FORGET tatu.
this deserve more viewer...
Damn i miss these girls , oh well , at least 1 of them is still making music
I like how lena sings she rocks i mean i also like yulia but i've always liked lena alot better i am her #1 fan in the world
Amazing
Last time I checked, Lena had confirmed that they were NOT getting back together. She and Yulia/Julia wanted to focus on their solo careers, but they ARE reuniting for a show at a Russian VIP club.
Why is it impossible to getting back togheter for them? Why were the seprated
I miss them sm
Juan oh hi!! Nice to see you here aswell :D
Haha! girl you just made my day! (Y)
what a song... omg...
daniel buen trabajo
This is the real story of Tatu, like Abba's "Winner", the same situation, but here it is about the love between 2 girls. And this is how Tatu died... Would love them to reunite, same for Abba (but Abba is physically impossible, it's 30 years since they broke up), Vanilla Ninja and Tarja back in Nightwish. Sad that Julia doesn't feel in the same way... 2 girls loving each other, happy of that, but unfortunately, beautiful things can't be forever what they are, which's a pity.
Tatu we miss you
sent it to my ex best friend during a fight before she moved countries...
Lena simplemente hermosa...
love them
No, they are officially back together now. :)
Thumbs up if you'll NEVER FORGET t.A.T.u.!! :"( ♥♥♥
They are back together now! :D
1:55 omg thats sad but cool vid
I love them
did they really break up ? :/
and thnx for ur hard work
I don't understand... If they miss each other, why broke up?? ; /
Yeih 2017😍
respect lena katina♡
Great job on the video!
Lena
Will never be allowed to forget, more like.
@MioMikio Thanks =D
i agree with i like both girls theyre talented and cute,i also wish they never broke up. . .but. . . no need to get soo mad of it :O
I know right even though Yulia got plastic surgery and they split up it doesent mean you half to choose one or another.
Villő♥
I can hear a back voice in the chorus. Is that Julia?
Lena Katina
Think it would be better if it was 'I'll always respect you BUT life goes on' and 'Our moments together I'LL ALWAYS TREASURE' still an awesome song...just my inner song writer unable to contain herself lol xx
mantap...
Holy crap it does sound like Julia!! I dunno, maybe I was wrong ;)
If I remember correctly, Yulia's husband or boyfriend or whatever he was got between them and Yulia wasn't really in it anymore. That's what I've read.
That would be Parviz Yasinov who is the father of her son. Parvis would sit with Lena and Yulia in interviews. I also gather he was mentally abusive to Yulia, he threatened to leave her if she got fat during the pregnancy of their son, so she exercised a lot. He also was cheating on her and this was the time she started to get plastic surgery. Rather sad.
What was the reson this to was seprated
This is a theme song of mine to an ex friend.
zajebiste ;)
i know!!!! YAYYYY!!!!!!
We said that we were meant to be that we each other's destiny and now we faded away maybe it's too late now it's time for us to get straight
Career-wise, because they wanted to do solo careers. Which I'm all for this anyways, I never really liked Yulia. I always thought she was holding Lena back.
Relationship-wise, they were never "together" so they can't "break up". The whole lesbian thing was made up by the man who created t.A.T.u. and after they broke off from him they came clean about the whole thing.
que lindo =(
I like the song, maybe they will get back together in 10 years or so,,,,
@MIDDR3AM3R yes
there are many of us who don't understand it...
me too
Its so sad that they broke up.
WHY DID THEY HAVE TO BREAK UP?!?!?! ITS SO UPSETTING THEY NEED TO GET BACK TOGETHER!!!
so sad
Why did they break up???
ya
D: NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO D,: Poor Yulia v_v
poor lena :(
who told you that she is not smoker, I saw in there interview she,was smoke
(Doctor Who fans) Makes me feel like this should be a song used for a David Tennant tribute.
; ( sad
Does the virus come in purple? c:
lena hace mejores canciones que yulia u,u :( me hace llorar lena de emocion u,u
yulia de tristeza :( y eso qe a yulia la amo mas qe a lena :(
Poor Lena
always gay but having happy mom and dad , BUT LOVING AND KISSING GIRLY
never for get
i think julia sounds better with lena and lena sounds good on her own but they both sound better in tatu
le truc c’est qu’elles ont été faîte pour un peu choquer au départ
leur amour est comme s’il avait pas été le plus sincère
Soit
cause of their manager and yulia was being mean and yulia's plastic sugery so sad
:(((((((
:((
Lena is awesome on her own but Julia...Just watched Didn't wanna do it and loved the melody,hated the lyrics and the video.
PLAGIATE with all caps!!! Clever & sneaky remake of "In the Shadows" from The Rasmus. Shame on you, Lena!
Nicola Tesla used to say: "I don't care that they steal my ideas. I care that they don't have their own."
That's not true..
Lies
Not.
At 1:00 she is less attractive now holding that cigarette
+Travisowski She has always smoked. Both Lena and Yulia smoked during t.A.T.u.
are you fucking stupid? she smokes! Have you seen videos and stuff of tatus life? because in those the smoked ALOT, dont act like you know something when you clearly dont, naive person
Why the fuck does it matter if she smokes? She's a grown ass woman. She can do what she wants, regardless of what you think.
Amy Christopher I don't condone smoking but it sounds like you need one or two cigarettes and you're right it's what I THINK it's MY OPINION that people who smoke don't look attractive oh and people who swear a lot must be stupid other wise you would have something else to say ok poopy head
she looks more attractive to me
yh but theyre Bisexual owo
The music is good but the lyrics doesn`t really fit in.
liar!