Your interpretation of a Chinese song, even lyrics that are hard to understand like this one, is so impressive. You’re helping me (a native speaker) better understand the messaging this song is trying to deliver. Great work Joe!
As their fan, I really appreciate that Joe spent a lot of time to understand the lyrics, the social metaphor and anlysis of the music help me understand the song better!
I loved this song since it was firstly posted eight years ago. But I have to admit that Joe has a better and deeper understanding of this song than me. Learnt a lot! I didn't know the name of this song is from a traditional game. And I love your interpretation that our adult society is another game of Simon Says. Thanks you Joe!
Love this song, and love your interpretation too! I used to only focused on the lyrics, thanks for sharing the knowledge of those grooving and instruments .
Glad that Joe finally release another video of some real music, this one’s almost my favorite of 草東. Try 親愛的無情孫小美 by EggPlantEgg, their guitar tone is amazing!
Would really appreciate if Joe could interpret with a bit longer video regarding the whole album! Would credit this is one of the favoriate albums for me in the recent ten years
please review their song "床" the bed. absolute forensic level of analysis that you had for this "simon says", bravo! i love their band too, R.I.P. for their female drummer. cheers from Malaysia.
I love it! Definitely a quality song from a great band, with a distinctive and individual sound! I love "light and shade", "soft and hard" contrasts in a song. It builds emotion and power. And when you know the song well, there is great tension and suspense, waiting for the heavy section to start. Love your review details, with reflections on the interpretation of the lyrics and how the music builds the picture. ❤
if you're still looking for recommendations for this band, i suggest checking out 在 (Am For You) by No Party for Cao Dong! it doesn't have an MV, unfortunately, but it's one of my favorites. it's very moody, a bit grungy and a bit bluesy, and they do some really cool things with the vocals and there's an amazing solo at the end 👌
I love the song "空" and"等" that also from no party for cao dong their are my favorite song forever, I think you should have a try. but they aren't have mv.
Please do《床 Lie》,《我們 Us》, 《還願 Devotion》, 《在》 by No Party For Cao Dong Would also like to recommend you another Taiwanese band: 傻子與白痴 Fool and Idiot , please do their 《流離的時間與流離的妳 Drifting in Time》
I like this band too, but sadly they were forced to shut down when they almost reached their apex because of COVID-19 After that, their former drummer 凡凡 committed suicide, so they kept being hiatus until last summer pretty unfortunately
Just think of the lockdowns of cities in the COVID-19 pandemic, or just think of the powerful USA's two old presidents, and you'll understand more about this song.
Guys if you're just watching this video, thank you so much for 100K Subscribers, love you all!!! 🥰🥰
谢谢大家观看我的视频！我们有了十万粉丝！太好了 谢谢谢谢！！！！！！😍😍
老師可以看看蔡依林 她不管是MV或是Live演出 絕對會讓你從驚豔到愛上她
草东早期有很多未收录的歌曲 也不错的
我刚才在这边喝点酒听曹东的歌然后偶然碰到你的TH-cam号。 我是美国的，好久在中国大陆听他们的歌。 真的很开心找到一个西方人喜欢听中文歌。 我读大学的时候有几个中国好兄弟给我推了这个乐队。已经关注你的TH-cam号。草动永远地神💥 you're from the UK right?
能理解到這個程度很驚人了，Simon says的翻譯確實好。紙蓮花對外國人來說比較難一點，同時有著榨取最後剩餘的價值&憑弔死亡的涵義，我超級喜歡紙蓮花那幾幕的
珂拉琪 Collage／萬千花蕊慈母悲哀 & MALIYANG
這首還要了解台灣白色恐怖時期的故事，感覺更難用英文表達
推
這首我同事介紹我聽我很驚艷
推 但外國人理解可能有些不易
不過好聽就好😂
@@雞皮_GP我記得他們沒有說是以那時期為主題做的吧 感覺很像大家單純的臆測再套上一個故事
《還願 Devotion》 by No party for CaoDong
這首一聽都會淚流不止
“Devotion”is a great game too….
And the theme song “Devotion”
will pull the tears out of eyes after finish the game.
推上去
推起來推起來🔥🔥
推上去
Your interpretation of a Chinese song, even lyrics that are hard to understand like this one, is so impressive. You’re helping me (a native speaker) better understand the messaging this song is trying to deliver. Great work Joe!
Thank you! 😃
這首歌詞也含有霸凌的意象，像是買了玩具去學校炫耀，但獲得的卻是嘲笑：「哎呀呀～你看你手上拿的是什麼啊？那東西我們早就不屑啦！～哈哈哈 哈」，而大風吹那個遊戲輸的人也就是被排擠的那個人。
然後又回到了前段的「哭啊～喊啊～」懇求媽媽帶去買玩具，然後希望能交點朋友，但又是重新的一個循環。
所以歌詞才會一開始就說：每個人都想當鬼（當決定一切的掌權者，或是霸凌者）因此才有下一句，「都一樣的下賤」
這歌也很隱含了社會化的意思，從小在學園裡的霸凌轉到進入社會爬升到上位決定下屬去留的生殺大權，或是物質的攀比都像是一樣的狀況。
我第一次聽也是有霸凌的感覺
其实我觉得最后是步入社会后对以前自己的不屑，最后的那几声哈哈哈就是对自己以前幼稚的嘲笑。
感觉被霸凌，这是台湾人普遍的群体心理。但是他们一遍说自己被欺负，一遍毫无底线地用谎言造谣和辱骂大陆，以至于原来曾经对台湾有同情心的大陆人，现在也巴不得解放军早点武统台湾。弱小不是你造谣别人的理由，可怜之人必有可恨之处！
我很推他們最近的“缸”以及“床”這兩首！也非常的有感覺
As their fan, I really appreciate that Joe spent a lot of time to understand the lyrics, the social metaphor and anlysis of the music help me understand the song better!
I loved this song since it was firstly posted eight years ago. But I have to admit that Joe has a better and deeper understanding of this song than me. Learnt a lot! I didn't know the name of this song is from a traditional game. And I love your interpretation that our adult society is another game of Simon Says. Thanks you Joe!
Hi Joe !I recommend 我還年輕 by 老王樂隊（your women sleep with others).
They use the cello in the song. I believe it will surprise you.
大港開唱才聽完草東沒有派對現場 這是我個人聽現場已經3-4次還是一樣的起雞皮疙瘩
Love this song, and love your interpretation too! I used to only focused on the lyrics, thanks for sharing the knowledge of those grooving and instruments .
Joe, fantastic breakdown of the lyrics! And also the music transition. It is social commentary. Great job!
Greetings from Singapore, Joe 👋 Really enjoy your videos! 😃 Thank you for your effort in creating them!
還願 Devotion by No party for CaoDong
As a Taiwanese and the song writer I feel that you’re comments very well!! I have almost the same feeling!
Glad that Joe finally release another video of some real music, this one’s almost my favorite of 草東.
Try 親愛的無情孫小美 by EggPlantEgg, their guitar tone is amazing!
RIP to the original drummer "凡凡（蔡憶凡）" of the band who passed away a year ago
台灣近幾年的樂團真的很強
告五人 老王 草東 滅火器
但很少讓人留下印象深刻的單人歌手
希望看到點評我還年輕我還年輕
告五人真的還好😂
@@蘆洲老二人 對 真的還好
觀看也才3 5千萬
其他三個加起來就能贏告五人了😂
@@莫名其妙-u2z 你用這種算法根本在污辱人流量可能對你來說是一切啦難道您覺得李宗盛大哥的歌會比他爛嗎？🤣不要笑了那種水歌真的不要當頂欸
滅火器跟告五人先不要好嗎
@@zaomi5553 排除滅火器該不會是綠黨的原因吧？但當初島嶼天光是救贖欸但政黨敗壞跟他們無關吧信念是很重要的
Try their other song, they are really poets!!
床
情歌 (Live ver )
滔滔(Live ver )
無常 (最常聽)
About 無常, there was an online event about steaming.
是如常吧？
《如常》+1，可惜沒看到英文翻譯
就我來說，如常很像另一個角度去描述的大風吹。但其中的旋律與含意又是另一種不捨… …
謝謝joe在這個時候放了這支影片讓我複習，正好要去大港開唱聽草東唱現場啦！！草東真的好久沒參加臺灣的音樂祭了🎉
如常沒錯
但無常和如常都是我對這首歌的結論
我們一直都沒差
就像他們一直都沒差
@@lee445588 说得好，一切无常，尽是如常
Would really appreciate if Joe could interpret with a bit longer video regarding the whole album! Would credit this is one of the favoriate albums for me in the recent ten years
please review their song "床" the bed.
absolute forensic level of analysis that you had for this "simon says", bravo!
i love their band too, R.I.P. for their female drummer.
cheers from Malaysia.
推薦他們的另一首歌-【床】
草東沒有派對 No Party For Cao Dong - 床 Lie【Official Lyric Video】
th-cam.com/video/yq5KovCxq8o/w-d-xo.html
《床 Lie》by No Party for Cao Dong
th-cam.com/video/U60_PkV47b0/w-d-xo.htmlsi=wzwvo1wN1G7SVT_A
I love it! Definitely a quality song from a great band, with a distinctive and individual sound!
I love "light and shade", "soft and hard" contrasts in a song. It builds emotion and power.
And when you know the song well, there is great tension and suspense, waiting for the heavy section to start.
Love your review details, with reflections on the interpretation of the lyrics and how the music builds the picture. ❤
與心理學上「療癒童年的自己」不同，這首歌就像是在告訴童年的自己，「別傻了，你以後會很慘。」
讲解的太棒了！我一个母语人都没有理解的那么透彻😮
I wanna recommend VH(vast & hazy), vocal is amazing.
我太喜欢joe感受到歌曲中迸发的情绪并且共鸣的时候了
if you're still looking for recommendations for this band, i suggest checking out 在 (Am For You) by No Party for Cao Dong! it doesn't have an MV, unfortunately, but it's one of my favorites. it's very moody, a bit grungy and a bit bluesy, and they do some really cool things with the vocals and there's an amazing solo at the end 👌
Respect man,how a great understanding.
I love the song "空" and"等" that also from no party for cao dong their are my favorite song forever, I think you should have a try. but they aren't have mv.
你是我聽過對「大風吹」最好的評論了
Hi,Joe.很喜欢看你的音乐视频。我有一个小小的建议，能不能每次分享你在你的视频中观看的原视频链接，这样既可以让原创者多一点关注度，也算是尊重的引用的原视频作者。
推上去
資訊點開下面就有了呀
@@ouo1276 并没有
@@李某-p5e 有音樂標註
其實有啦只是不是連結他是直接youtubemusic
Hi Joe, I just want you to know, this band is from Taiwan, they represent the colors of Taiwanese music, not Chinese music. Thanks you.
Taiwan is part of China
歌词是中文，不是华语是什么语？
台湾不是中国的？
别被政治游戏给整魔怔了，先管好你们自己国家的事。台湾就是中国的一部分
@@jingshenggeng1897 世界各地都有講華語的人，但是文化背景不一樣造就不同的音樂
歐美人士能理解這首歌到這程度真的很用心欸……推。
我自己的看法，這首歌在講校園霸凌
我個人到覺得沒那麼淺，或許第一段是校園，但二三段應該不是，不然什麼東西"一樣"？
聽了草東，怎麼可以沒聽非人物種呢?
想當初金曲獎就是他們兩團排隊領獎
擺渡人也有這種風雨前的寧靜的音樂感
床
鬼
我認為是草東最棒的兩首 希望你能做REACTION🙏
Thank you for sharing , love from taiwan ❤
好奇这首歌创作背景是什么样的，为什么我听了就忍不住哭了
My mom is over 70 and she enjoys most of CaoDong’s songs too, head nodding to their songs
Do one for the song 鬼 or 如常those are one of my favorite songs from them pleaseeeee
03/30 大港開唱，草東也會到。只是，很多人都不在了…期待這次草東會帶給大家什麼感覺。
沒搶到票，我難過
一個字 神
hi Joe, in your opinion, what is keeping Chinese music from being more welcomed in the Western world besides the language barrier?
Hi Joe, this reaction video is way better than you did mostly before. Do you feel the same?
我也超喜歡大風吹～
I would recommend you to listen 缸 (Pool) which is also one of my favorite songs from Cao Dong!
Fantastic 🫡🫡🫡🫡🫡
love this 🥺
Hi Joe, appreciate if you can a review on Queen- Bohemian Rhapsody
If u love Taiwanese Rock , should never miss father of Taiwan's Modern Rock 伍佰 (Wu Bai) . Suggesting 【挪威的森林 Norwegian forest】
What brand is your headphone
很喜歡草東的創作，你也評論的很專業，知音遇知音
草东的歌真的很动听也很深刻，这是他们在大陆也能受到追捧的原因
Please do《床 Lie》,《我們 Us》, 《還願 Devotion》, 《在》 by No Party For Cao Dong
Would also like to recommend you another Taiwanese band: 傻子與白痴 Fool and Idiot , please do their 《流離的時間與流離的妳 Drifting in Time》
草东还有一首可以推荐一下，叫《人洞山》
6:00
Ayaya is the sound chinese people make when we are gloating about someone's misery.
或許該來個老王樂隊了?
老王樂隊｜我還年輕 我還年輕 (Teens Edge)
雖然很久了，還是想推茄子蛋《親愛的無情孫小美》
講得很好，我有共鳴！XD
草東要再推一首的話，我選〈床〉( Lie )。
- -
Sorry but not China. +1
推薦"床"
Hope you can react more their song
I recommend the specter 鬼and am for you 在
草東臺灣之光❤
推薦「爛泥」
Damn…. u have better understanding than me even u don’t really understand Chinese .
joe，推荐你一首歌叫做《万千花蕊慈母悲哀》，期待你可以点评一下
這首要外國人精準點評真的太難啦....
這首連台灣自己一些民俗專家都要解半天你叫一個外國人聽😂😂😂
那得先讀一些台灣歷史才能懂😂
珂拉琪的歌，尤其這首必須要懂台灣的歷史背景，單獨歌詞翻譯無法真的理解意涵
草東大推幾首:老張，情歌，八，但。
新專輯真的很推!
看得出你真的很喜欢！草东的歌真的很震撼
I like this band too, but sadly they were forced to shut down when they almost reached their apex because of COVID-19
After that, their former drummer 凡凡 committed suicide, so they kept being hiatus until last summer
pretty unfortunately
Sunset Rollercoaster - Candlelight feat. OHHYUK
講解的真好
解读的太到位了。
Hello Joe, I highly recommend "鮮花" by "回春丹" and I really want to watch your reaction.
Please do this song review!
海浪-Deca Joins
大风‘s English name is Simmons . 吹 is 吹牛 means swank.
Simon says是老師說吧
Just think of the lockdowns of cities in the COVID-19 pandemic, or just think of the powerful USA's two old presidents, and you'll understand more about this song.
这几年才发现草东想等他们开演唱会，但是现在机会渺茫～
草東沒有派對 No Party For Cao Dong - 床 Lie
im really not party for caodong fan.and u fan joe
空，很炸
床，也蠻不錯的
《床 Lie》by No Party for Cao Dong 👍
R.I.P 凡凡
草東沒有派對真的很好聽欸
床🙌🙌🙌
島嶼都市浪漫譚【台北心碎鵲橋】Official Music Video
想聽草東沒有派對的《還願》(恐怖遊戲《還願》的主題曲)
th-cam.com/video/sSQKl7rBTWQ/w-d-xo.html
台灣nirvana ，這首有lithium 感覺😂
哥们儿！喜欢你🎉加油
可以聽他們的床嗎? 我非常愛的一首
老破麻 放空
That is really great
deca joins
草東主打一個意識流 每個人聽到的東西都不一樣
you shoud wach the live.
我個人沒聽過草東，今天聽了一下大風吹，感覺很有民謠搖滾風的感覺。
這點在現今台灣樂團好像比較少了!
感覺好像中國比較多這類型的團體或歌手，像 朴樹、宋捷...
草東不錯，加油!
❤
It is funny how you ignore every comment about them being a taiwanese band
Bro, I recommend you 鮮花 by 回春丹, it is really good!
so sad…the drummer passed 26 years old