the members who contributed as the main vocals on this setlist; Tyler Hyde (Bass) - Up Song / I Won't Always Love You / Laughing Song / Dancers / Up Song (reprise) ; Tyler also has a wonderful solo side project "Tyler Cryde" which i highly recommend, its a much more instrumentally stripped back style than BCNR with mainly acoustic guitar and piano, her voice is absolutely heavenly fr May Kershaw - (piano/accordion) The Boy & Turbines, her voice is v mesmerizing and she has spoken about being heavily inspired by Joanna Newsom Lewis Evans (Sax/Flute/Occasional Aerophone player) - Across The Pond Friend / Wrong Trousers, i think ppl are sometimes kinda hard reharding his vocals, he had a solo side project as well called "Good with Parents" which he only pursued for a year only but a pretty cozy & chill bedroom popish style which is rlly solid, people tend to be more overly critical of Lewis' vocals but out of 1/3 of the members who did vocald on this set he was the only one who had never perfomed live/did vocals outside of the 2 srudio releases of his solo projects but he has legitimately imporved so much both vocally and perfomance wise, looking back on their first gig post Isaac's official derparture announced from around May, 2022; u can clearly tell his vocals wrre much more coarse and he nervous/stiff perfomance wise like constantly looking down; with a rlly stit posture and hande behind his back and he hae improved so much both on terms kt vocals comfortable on stage, i think his songs are definitely "growers" type songs, but overall rlly excited to what will come nect from BCNR as inthink they'll definitely stick with this rotating and not with an exclusive vocalist,i reallt hope we get songs eith Georgia doing vocals because her voice is so uniquely beautiful and i absolutely fell in love with her voice when listening to "I Love u Jennifer B from her project Jockstrap, which was one of my fav records off it 2022, alsoi highly recommended checking "Never Again Pt. 2" which is a compilation of 4 covers they recorded last year and checking their cover of "I Think I need a New Heart" by The Magnetic Fields which Luke Mark (Guitarist) does the main vocals and their cover of "Happier than Ever" by Billie Eilish where the last half has Charlie Wayne (drums) doing the main vocals and the parts wherte he does screaimg bocald legitn gives me chills (which is why it became my perosnal favourite of that reease), its insane how incredibly talentef they all are and think there are still a lot of great things coming BCNR's way
I was really skeptical, and feared that they will lose too much of what makes them amazing with the loss of Isaac. But I gotta say, they still got it. Sure, Isaac is irreplaceable, and has one of the most unique voices and way of words. But those new songs are still really good, and I gotta say I'm impressed that pretty much all of them can sing, especially girl on piano, who kinda sounds like Regina Spektor. That being said, I still hope Isaac might return one day. Who knows.
@@The_RedVIII The little "ah!" punctuations are so Spektor, made me think of Apres Moi immediately (they show up in a lot of her stuff but thats what I think of)
I personally lewis' voice its very costello esque, it's got a softness and nervousness which the other band members don't really have, I love that he has such a confident personality but such a quiet and unsure singing voice. He's my 2nd favourite vocalist besides charlie on drums who didn't preform at bush hall
I dont remember where I read it but Im pretty sure they stated because she tours with jockstrap often enough that she didn't want to be a main vocalist for the new tracks so they can perform all the songs live when they have a stand in
Turbines is an amazing song. Girl on Piano also has the best voice, she should be their main singer IMO. I do think Louis voice is good enough, though. Obviously not as good as some of the others, but I did not find it distracting.
I actually really don't mind Lewis' voice. I think objectively his voice is kind of bad and sounds a bit strange, but I think it works for some reason. Its like how Jeff Mangum from neutral milk hotel definitely has some off key and messy vocals on Aeroplane, but the imperfections are actually what make it so powerful and beautiful. In the same way, I don't think the songs would have been as enjoyable if Lewis had great tone and a voice that sounded like any other dude. I can't say I understand why, but sometimes it works better for a song if the singer can't sing very well or sounds a bit odd
i feel like anything other than lewis's soft, inexperienced and almost unsure singing voice (i dont mean any of that in a bad way obv) wouldnt have worked nearly as well with the song and the lyrics. it suits the song perfectly imo!
@endgravity honestly idek, I've just seen reviewers say that before and I'm trusting them enough to repeat what they said. To my understanding, he's not super off key or anything, hes just a bit loose on the melody and they didn't use autotune
Awesome to see you've covered the BCNR bases. You still need to jam midi's Schlagenheim, but I feel like I haven't seen too many people mention the third band in what I call the holy trinity of 2020s era post-punk, Squid. They've got a track called The Cleaner you should check out, and their debut album Bright Green Fields was incredible. Sadly, I think it got a little overlooked. Narrator is one of the best tracks I've heard in a long long time, up there with some of the BCNR - Ants stuff.
I agree, Lewis had a nice tone but lacks technique. We all miss Isaac, but we wouldn’t have songs like “turbines” “dancers” or “laughing song” so this makes them even more interesting. This band is already music history period.
I feel a bit bad, but I agree on Lewis' voice. It's a shame because I really love those tracks, but I'd be interested in hearing if they could be made to work either May or Tyler's voices?
@@mocapcow2933 I’m not saying she isn’t I just think Isaac is better. I was also kinda more thinking of Tyler’s and Lewis’s writing tbf, I think may is definitely the best out of the 3
@@ash.953 yea I agree lol I think it’s probably cos they need her to play violin tho and bc if she already sings for jockstrap she might not want to for her other group
@@largeshaftzac8027Laughing Song is great. About someone who is ending a relationship because they dont see it going anywhere. This is causing they anxiety however because the person genuinely makes them happy and makes them laugh.
I disagree. I think we're at the same level, but just moving in a different direction. There are clearly elements from before that are gone, but they've been replaced with some new elements that give the band a whole new flavor.
Turbines gives me chills from head to toe the whole time. Absolutely euphoric song
the members who contributed as the main vocals on this setlist;
Tyler Hyde (Bass) - Up Song / I Won't Always Love You / Laughing Song / Dancers / Up Song (reprise) ; Tyler also has a wonderful solo side project "Tyler Cryde" which i highly recommend, its a much more instrumentally stripped back style than BCNR with mainly acoustic guitar and piano, her voice is absolutely heavenly fr
May Kershaw - (piano/accordion) The Boy & Turbines, her voice is v mesmerizing and she has spoken about being heavily inspired by Joanna Newsom
Lewis Evans (Sax/Flute/Occasional Aerophone player) - Across The Pond Friend / Wrong Trousers, i think ppl are sometimes kinda hard reharding his vocals, he had a solo side project as well called "Good with Parents" which he only pursued for a year only but a pretty cozy & chill bedroom popish style which is rlly solid, people tend to be more overly critical of Lewis' vocals but out of 1/3 of the members who did vocald on this set he was the only one who had never perfomed live/did vocals outside of the 2 srudio releases of his solo projects but he has legitimately imporved so much both vocally and perfomance wise, looking back on their first gig post Isaac's official derparture announced from around May, 2022; u can clearly tell his vocals wrre much more coarse and he nervous/stiff perfomance wise like constantly looking down; with a rlly stit posture and hande behind his back and he hae improved so much both on terms kt vocals comfortable on stage, i think his songs are definitely "growers" type songs, but overall rlly excited to what will come nect from BCNR as inthink they'll definitely stick with this rotating and not with an exclusive vocalist,i reallt hope we get songs eith Georgia doing vocals because her voice is so uniquely beautiful and i absolutely fell in love with her voice when listening to "I Love u Jennifer B from her project Jockstrap, which was one of my fav records off it 2022, alsoi highly recommended checking "Never Again Pt. 2" which is a compilation of 4 covers they recorded last year and checking their cover of "I Think I need a New Heart" by The Magnetic Fields which Luke Mark (Guitarist) does the main vocals and their cover of "Happier than Ever" by Billie Eilish where the last half has Charlie Wayne (drums) doing the main vocals and the parts wherte he does screaimg bocald legitn gives me chills (which is why it became my perosnal favourite of that reease), its insane how incredibly talentef they all are and think there are still a lot of great things coming BCNR's way
I was really skeptical, and feared that they will lose too much of what makes them amazing with the loss of Isaac. But I gotta say, they still got it. Sure, Isaac is irreplaceable, and has one of the most unique voices and way of words. But those new songs are still really good, and I gotta say I'm impressed that pretty much all of them can sing, especially girl on piano, who kinda sounds like Regina Spektor. That being said, I still hope Isaac might return one day. Who knows.
So on point with the Spektor comparison
@@lukeg1940 Right? Sound great though, love Regina Spektor personally.
@@The_RedVIII my first thoughts when i heard her sing
Yeah I hear Regina too. The Boy reminds me of Regina Spector singing a Joanna newsom song about forest creatures.
@@The_RedVIII The little "ah!" punctuations are so Spektor, made me think of Apres Moi immediately (they show up in a lot of her stuff but thats what I think of)
I personally lewis' voice its very costello esque, it's got a softness and nervousness which the other band members don't really have, I love that he has such a confident personality but such a quiet and unsure singing voice. He's my 2nd favourite vocalist besides charlie on drums who didn't preform at bush hall
I’m not seeing nearly enough love for The Boy holy shit
I've been thinking the same! It's brilliant!
YES, LET MAY DO THE WHOLE OF LP3 PLEASE
nah that shit is mid
@@ejc9118you're mid
Lewis gave my favorite singing performance of the video on across the pond friend, it feels so real in a way that Isaac did.
I’d actually like to hear Georgia on some tracks, her voice in Jockstrap is unreal
I dont remember where I read it but Im pretty sure they stated because she tours with jockstrap often enough that she didn't want to be a main vocalist for the new tracks so they can perform all the songs live when they have a stand in
she has started playing a song called 'horses' on their uk tour. its brilliant. theres a few videso of it on youtube.
Turbines is an amazing song. Girl on Piano also has the best voice, she should be their main singer IMO. I do think Louis voice is good enough, though. Obviously not as good as some of the others, but I did not find it distracting.
I feel like Lewis' voice you're expecting gravitas when his songs are more based around vulnerability
I actually really don't mind Lewis' voice. I think objectively his voice is kind of bad and sounds a bit strange, but I think it works for some reason. Its like how Jeff Mangum from neutral milk hotel definitely has some off key and messy vocals on Aeroplane, but the imperfections are actually what make it so powerful and beautiful. In the same way, I don't think the songs would have been as enjoyable if Lewis had great tone and a voice that sounded like any other dude. I can't say I understand why, but sometimes it works better for a song if the singer can't sing very well or sounds a bit odd
i feel like anything other than lewis's soft, inexperienced and almost unsure singing voice (i dont mean any of that in a bad way obv) wouldnt have worked nearly as well with the song and the lyrics. it suits the song perfectly imo!
when is Jeff Mangum off key on Aeroplane? i can't think of a single time
@endgravity honestly idek, I've just seen reviewers say that before and I'm trusting them enough to repeat what they said. To my understanding, he's not super off key or anything, hes just a bit loose on the melody and they didn't use autotune
@@Purplepentapus_ I think he's pretty tight on the vocals but the standards of reviewers are different than mine so that is understandable lol
I love Lewis' voice, it's improved so much from February to December so I'm sure it'll be amazing by the time the next release comes along
A year later with their new tracklist out, looks like he gave up entirely😢
@@londonwontstopcalling they have new music?
It really is the best sound quality I’ve ever heard from a live performance.
I actually love Lewis’ voice it has a ton of potential. I think with more practice and power he could be incredible
Hey just needs to work on his tone. He sings to nasally and forward right now. He probably doesn’t have much singing experience.
Honestly might be worth reacting to their cover of happier then ever cause it's fucking amazing
Awesome to see you've covered the BCNR bases. You still need to jam midi's Schlagenheim, but I feel like I haven't seen too many people mention the third band in what I call the holy trinity of 2020s era post-punk, Squid. They've got a track called The Cleaner you should check out, and their debut album Bright Green Fields was incredible. Sadly, I think it got a little overlooked. Narrator is one of the best tracks I've heard in a long long time, up there with some of the BCNR - Ants stuff.
yooo lets go. glad to see uploads on this channel again
Glad to see a new video on the channel I thought it was dead honestly haha. Looking forward to more videos. Keep up the great work!
May's songs are both incredible
Tyler is the singing bass player. Daughter of yer man from Underworld.
May is the singing piano player.
I would end it all if i missed that concert dawg
My man came back to YT just to react to BCNR. That's what I'm talking about
Dancers is f*ing amazing
BC,NR FRIENDS FOREVER
my prayers have been answered!!
I would really love to see the so far released songs of sleep tokens “Take me back to Eden”
I’d love more king gizzard reactions.
yesss
bcnr friends forever!!!
I commented in ur other bcnr videos to react this I didn't know u had another channel lol oops
Disagree on the voice - it feels very endearing and authentic
Authentic in the way a bad karaoke singer is
Tanks for the Video:)
Why dont you upload this on your Main Chanel?:)
I agree, Lewis had a nice tone but lacks technique. We all miss Isaac, but we wouldn’t have songs like “turbines” “dancers” or “laughing song” so this makes them even more interesting. This band is already music history period.
I feel a bit bad, but I agree on Lewis' voice. It's a shame because I really love those tracks, but I'd be interested in hearing if they could be made to work either May or Tyler's voices?
Laughing song, dancers and turbines are top tier. I prefer them to a lot of their old stuff
YOOOOOOO
lewis's voice isnt bad at all and hes not trying to be isaac so why are you comparing them
I think the band misses isaacs song writing more than his vocals tbh
Idk, May kinda a great writer
@@mocapcow2933 I’m not saying she isn’t I just think Isaac is better. I was also kinda more thinking of Tyler’s and Lewis’s writing tbf, I think may is definitely the best out of the 3
@@largeshaftzac8027 Georgia's an S-Tier lyricist and vocalist in Jockstrap and she's just hiding in plain sight here lol
@@ash.953 yea I agree lol I think it’s probably cos they need her to play violin tho and bc if she already sings for jockstrap she might not want to for her other group
@@largeshaftzac8027Laughing Song is great. About someone who is ending a relationship because they dont see it going anywhere. This is causing they anxiety however because the person genuinely makes them happy and makes them laugh.
its just a level lower without isaac, he was more than just a vocalist
I disagree. I think we're at the same level, but just moving in a different direction. There are clearly elements from before that are gone, but they've been replaced with some new elements that give the band a whole new flavor.