The strategy behind Russia's abduction of tens of thousands of Ukrainian children | DW News
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 2 มิ.ย. 2024
- The Russian President has ordered the abduction tens of thousands of Ukrainian children. Some have been adopted by Russian families; some are held in camps scattered all over Russia. The idea is to make them Russian - or use them as leverage against their home country. A few mothers have managed to take their kids back from Putin, but most are unlikely to return anytime soon.
Chapters:
00:00 Intro
02:09 The Accusations
11:04 The Logistics
15:14 Responsibility
20:32 Getting the children back
26:53 What happens next?
Subscribe: th-cam.com/users/deutsche...
For more news go to: www.dw.com/en/
Follow DW on social media:
►Facebook: / deutschewellenews
►Twitter: / dwnews
►Instagram: / dwnews
►Twitch: / dwnews_hangout
Für Videos in deutscher Sprache besuchen Sie: / dwdeutsch
#UkraineChildren #Russia #ChildAbduction
I can think of nothing more painful for a father and mother than to be separated from their children.
Россия эвакуировала детей сирот. Вывезла их из под обстрелов.
Take it from someone who's had it happen. Your life matters very less afterward.
@@ryanreedgibson Look on the brightside, Ukraine will form it's own version of Mossad and will try everything to get these kids back.
Oh yes there is if you let your mind wander into darker waters.
Edit: (Loosing your children as a father is almost a normal thing in todays world, so I think you ment something darker when you added your comment now when thinking about it a bit more)
Think also of the pain of the children torn from their parents and given to strangers.
How barbaric!!!
All Russians
Gestapo
This is just so evil, I don’t know where to begin. We support Ukraine 🇺🇦
😂
@@dennispus9358 What goes around come around God Stronger then PUTLER Z RAZZIA ZOMBIE Terrorist state
How horrifying! Children should be with their parents and guardians! Give those kids back, they need their families!
Russians are like "sure just give us the parents too."
@@1112viggo Reminds us of the SS/Gestapo
@@m42037 Sure, only the Russians are vastly less competent and stylish.
They will russify them, those children are already lost. Even if they return them, they will be an asset of the kremlin to wage new war. If they are kept in russification camps they will serve as meat in the next war in 20 years
@m42037 exactly, they were also abducting children who looked aryan from the occupied territories and sending them to Germany giving them false identity
Russia shouldn't be taking children away from their families, it's absolutely immoral.
Canada and Denmark did it to the natives of Canada and Greenland for decades.
I see where Russia learned it from.
@@Exxperiment626 first clue to being a Russian Bot, quotes a Whataboutism.......
@@jayjayn007 So now, pointing out historical facts, makes one a Russian bot?
I guess I am a Russian bot then (sarcasm) 😂
@@jayjayn007 whataboutism is what every Russian argument boils down to. "In the distant past some country (probably the US) did something bad, so this excuses Russia's current genocide." It's completely brainless.
The SS /Gestapo did this 79 years ago
I can't remember another video giving me such a deep feeling of disgust
There's been a few. Like the kids birthday who blows out the candles seconds before the apartment is obliterated. That 1 killed me a little on the inside.
@@priapulida propagandized ir brainwashed by Skabaeva? Russian ship Moskva ПНХ
@@priapulida It means they have a soul, unlike you, comrade.
@@Blodhelm So, you rather see these kids in a war zone than being adopted until they're of age? 😢
@@First-Last_name That is why the Russians are rescuing these children, unlike Ukraine simply leaving them to die.
Thanks for covering this extensively. This deserves more attention in international community.
Yes 🙌🏻 agreed 👍
Sooner or later, Putin will be judged for his crimes.
While this happens, Ukraine needs all support we can give.
From now on is the greatest insult in human history to be called a "Russian"!
They are like the Gestapo was 78 year's ago
That’s why this war is not just the war beteen Russia vs UKRAINE THIS IS A WAR BETWEEN GOOD VS EVIL.
Its too bad Russia doesn't save children in the west from the rainbow abusers. You're right, it is good vs evil.
If only the other part of the nations would see that. There's something to be 'against' to west, but it's a whole other thing to not condemn Russia for what they do to Ukraine for more than a decade already.
@@blehz The GOP wants to suspend assistance to Ukraine says Kein McCarthy.
@@crankychris2 he agreed to for his position. He can't. Make it happen though.
Even if some of these abducted children will manage to escape Russia, I imagine that many will be deeply traumatized. So much harm is being inflicted on Putin's victims right now. When this is all over, an international tribunal needs to look into things like accountability, reparations, and reconstruction, perhaps similar to the Nuremberg Trials or the post-Apartheid Truth & Reconciliation Committee.
Burn Moscow to the ground, salt the earth, leave no two stones touching.When Russia is defeated so utterly that they will know for a hundred generations that they were fools to think they could get away with such crimes against humanity when their forces were so weak, it will make every dictator that follows think twice.
If they ever escape the russification camps, they will already be too damaged. They are being indocrinated and russified. They are taught to worship Z and Putin, to handle Kalashnikovs and to hate on their dead parents killed by russian bombs or executions.
They are indoctrinated to become Russian. You cannot reverse indoctrination without using indoctrination.
Why most people in Europe loath russian goverment? Its not rusophobia. It is reaction to all things russian goverment did in last two decades and last two years especially.
Brain washing starts at a young age.
Overwhelming anger and disgust at Putin & those involved. Hope for the children's safe return to their grieving family.
I find it funny how Europeans dnt have anger and disgust at things like state-sponsored child abduction by gov. from their families in countries like Norway.
If they are kept in russification camps, they will be grown into meat for the next war in 20 yesrs. If not, they will be returned to their families, but only when they are russified, so then the federation can claim that russia ends where russian is not heard.
Perhaps there are honorable and brave people inside Russia who will organize an underground network (Kindertransport) to secretly rescue some of the kids so they can be reunited with their relatives. Or at least track these kids and document their whereabouts and their new names and identities.
Doing what Stalin did .Putin wants the Soviet union to operate again but forgot that the zombies are going to wake up once again when they start dieing of hunger
Or when the world wakes up and removes Russia from the board, permanently.
Ghosts of the SS during the war. Many of these children are dead or in trafficking
How evil Putin !! 😢
I am sure that in long term Russia will pay for this because messing around with children is one of the worst crime world wide....
Russia needs to give those children back. And while they're at it stop attacking Ukraine too.
I’m getting angrier and angrier with each second. We need to give Ukraine everything they need.
Angry? LOL. You're just a coward.
The Ukraina going to gett the everything they need,Becuse the Russia frozing many, the West have going to bilding op Ukraina 💪
@@priapulidaand you are not? Talk of ruzzian bots! You might as well return the kids you abducted! You have already committed so much atrocities.
We need to give Russia what it deserves.
@@priapulida ruzzia is the invader, Einstein. So that oink belongs to you.
*Russia🇷🇺 still occupied oblast Luhansk, Donetsk, Zaporizhia, Kherson, Crimea.*
Russia must end occupation & keep peace.
Ruzzia must not exist.
Well the thing is power corrupts. You have a sick guy in power, if no one stops him, he starts trying sicker and sicker stuff. To show to himself how powerful he is. He enjoys it.
He's shown himself more powerful than children.
Putler needs to end
Get the orcs!
Slava Ukraina 🇺🇦💪👊🤜
What can we expect from orcs
This is the sickest thing I’ve ever seen!!
Did this happen in Chechnya and northern Georgia too?
😮
No, because russians don't think of those peoples as "pure Slavs". For some reason they believe that Ukrainians are the same people as them and their goal is to "improve the demographics".
It's scary similar to 1939 Germany
I don’t think so because those are not Slaves so Putin just needs Slavic children
Wouldn't doubt it.
SS
It's happened for centuries. That's why russia is how big it is: genocide.
Despicable from Putin, send Ukraine more tanks
Please for the love of God call it what it is. It it kidnapping!
It's actually worse than that, this is part of their genocide.
@@arceusthomas2447 “Hypocrisy is not only our birth right but our first amendment
@@arceusthomas2447Sheer, shameless and undiluted whataboutery. What Americans might or might not have done is nothing to do with what Russians are doing.
On this scale, it is a crime against humanity.
@Internet Guidance they aren’t amendments, it was written correctly the first time.
Russia has a massive population problem. Demographics and endless actual wars has devastating effects in a young male population. Those children translate into future "GDP"
The SS/Gestapo did this 80 year's ago, same thing, and terminated many of them. Some of these children are now deceased, you know Russia is like the SS during the world war
The Geneva convention only applies when you loose a war. Germany did the exact same thing in Poland.
There are no words for this...
I am not surprised in the least
me either
Just like the SS
Thats disturbing wtf...
@@arceusthomas2447 no what's disturbing is that they steal children and trolls like you are teary-eyed laughing emojing at this. moving anyone against their will to trashy russia is the opposite of saving.
@@arceusthomas2447 watch the video?
@@arceusthomas2447 This is not about what America did this is about what Russia is doing today. Also not sure about Vietnam but that defiantly did not happen in Afghanistan. Not sure where you are getting your facts.
@@arceusthomas2447 I don't remember the US ever trying to erase Vietnamese identity and tell them their nation doesn't exist. Which is what russia is doing.
The scenenario is also completely different from the fall of saigon or Afghanistan.
@@jimflagg4009 when saigon fell people thought to be pro USA or South were lined up in the streets and executed. Many people ran to the docks and helicopter pads. There's footage of quite a few families who gave their kids to US troops begging them to save their kids from the slaughter.
The kids however were returned to parents that survived, allowed to learn their country's history and language. Unlike what russia is doing 🙄
I wonder if AI facial recognition will play a big part in finding these children who would become older with new names.
Both countries have very low birth rates and high death rates, which means that the population is shrinking rapidly. Therefore, children are considered a very important resource for both countries
Yes, young children can be easily 'reeducated' to hate their country and become willing Russian soldiers.
Wow. This is horrible
STOP RUSSIAN AGGRESSION NOW !
How low can you possibly get?
his name is PUTLER
I wonder what Putin was planning on doing with Ukraine children that didn't deserve to have to be taken from their family.
Putler use them to go against their birthplace soon. I guess psychopathy is a very strong trait among putin's ruzzians.
There are mass graves everywhere Ukraine liberates a city Russia occupied. We can guess.
Its time to rethink this. We as the west should stop saying "How not to provoce Putin?" and start saying "Lets dare him to provoce US as the west!" ... Poland alone could be in Moscow within a few months - add frence and the rest of the EU ... its weeks. Add the rest of NATO - days.
The problem is nukes🤷♂️ can't March to Moscow, though we probably should send Moscow a few conventional presents. Especially to their artillery shell and missle factories.
@@First-Last_name Nukes are expensive and technically difficult to maintain, Russia is notorious for pocketing government funds for even vital things and being terrible at maintenance. They probably never had a tenth of what they claimed, the ones they do have probably never worked, and those that remain are no doubt as rusty as their tanks and ships with initiating charges that have degraded to uselessness because they were never replaced. We have missile interception systems, they don't. We have weapons that actually work and our stealth aircraft could fly right into Moscow without them ever knowing it until it is too late.
We can march to what's left of Moscow after we level their cities and destroy all their bases so they can never threaten anyone again.
@@Blodhelm Still Don think rolling in is the right answer. Though we should give Ukraine better missles, more missles, planes, and more shells.
@@First-Last_name True, but we could just send everything to ukraine - start a small war eco and be done with this at the end of this year.
@@julonkrutor4649 ya, I think what ukraine really needs is enough material to make a series of sustained offensives. russia can't take kyiv, but they can flounder around for years. Ukraine needs enough to make some major pushes and the whole russian front will collapse.
Makes my blood boil
You are using the Russian words for it as opposed to what it is
Hope All children b reunited with their parents r guardians in Ukraine
Thx 4 ur npt, n u hv a gd day 🤣
@@m42037 Russian troll farms are looking into the past to make their 100 comment per day at the troll farm I see.
@@beebscalicor The op needs to learn to spell 🙄
Ukraine needs to deny leverage. Train the kids in sabotage.
John Major got a really hard time for refusing to evacuate children from Sarajevo.
This is extremely cruel!
What a terrible thing to do to Ukrainian parents! May the Infant of Prague help with the return of ALL Ukrainian children. May Putin and his offsider be taken to the Hague.
Why can't the mothers also be evacuated with their children ? Being
separated from my kids almost killed me. No mother or father wants
war. A mother's place is with her children. The Lord was with that girl.
This is wrong on so many levels.
Orcs
They gotta restock their military some kinda way
This must end.
Chinese Peace Efforts now!
For the Children.
This is a stunning story. Ty
Yes, it is. But I'm sitting here crying. Those poor children and their parents. 😢
💙💛🇺🇦
This will never go away, until every child is returned to Ukrane the scandal will continue to tarnish the reputation of the Russn state.
This can not be condoned nor justified!
Un mismo Pais todos juntos unidos vamosss
Of all of the russian crimes, this one feels like the absolute worst. I literally feel sick every time I see something about it.
Madeleine Albright went onto '60 Minutes ' and when questioned about the estimated half a million Iraqi children dead because of sanctions, she said it was worth it... That was in 1996... How many more Iraqi children died in the decades since due to Western military interventionism
Such superficial morality
What the officials in Moscow are doing is a sad and they need to be accountable for it 😒
What goes around comes around.😂😂😅 And I am sure that is the comes around bit😅😂
Have Ukrainians attack Russians by any chance? Did they stole Russian children, by any chance? What are you laughing about? To be so blatant in your expression of hate, makes you almost sweet. To squash.
😢😢😢😢😢
If stealing kids does not spell “obvious evil” to you need to go read up on your fairy tales …
I hope families are reunited
"a perfidious and elaborate scheme"
They should not be talking about children unless the parents are horrible people and abuse there kids.
They even bragged about it
Action needs to taken to highest level against such perpetrator not mere words.
Remember, No Russian
Great article. I enjoyed it very much. However, I listen to these videos while driving. Much the same as a podcast. I can not read the translations. An audio dub of the foreign language into English, instead of text translations, makes it available on the road. I don't know any advantage not having audio dubs of foreign languages. Thank you for listening.
Where's the Russian Orthodox on this?
Telling lies in the name of the Lord. Kirill is after all rumoured to have been Putin's boss when he was a young KGB officer.
They're going to brainwash these children for future wars against Ukraine, since Russia has already depleted their own dying population.
Putin just offers them some Kinder chocolate when they come to his car
George Orwell would have been shocked!!
Finally found Ukrainians they could defeat I guess… baby’s truly worthy foes.
omg... Max Zander reappears. i love this guy! best reporter/journalist name ever :)
While Russia chooses to abduct, the Chinese are doing the exact opposite! Flooding new born and chinese children from mainland china to schools in Hong Kong, slowly posions the way of life in Hong Kong from 1st world city state, to a 3rd world city under a 3rd world developing country. What a joke.
If you think red china will help, nah, xi won't, and xi is happy to teach a trick or two to his bff putin.
Watching this show is a painful experience for the parents for Ukrainian, but also for Hong Kongers as well.
That's not the opposite, but part of the same etno-nationalist policy, expanding the empire by replacing/erasing other peoples.
It's a practise for both China and Russia that goes back centuries.
Millions of Russians were moved into Crimea, the Baltics, Königsberg. It's just phase 2 of their genocidal program.
😂what a joke.
Homo homini lupus est ( Plautus).
It turns out that humans can be crueler than wolves.
You should have never trusted Russia
I remember the US did the same thing in Vietnam by evacuating vietnam babies in a plane. Wasn't that against international law? Or maybe if US does it international law changes 😂😂
Where is the outrage from the Global South?
Not just Putin, all Russians need to pay for eternity for that.
And by "pay" it means the Russian people will experience the same legacy Germany has. Germanys' mistake became their legacy. And for Russia what they've done to Ukraine will be their legacy. All people in Russia will always be reminded of this gcide of Ukraine.
Could someone explain to a Ukrainian citizen why the evacuation of children became the only reason to announce Putin guilty???!!!)))))
Why nothing similar happened regarding same crimes during wars in Iraq, Yugoslavia, Libya, Afghanistan, Syria with western leaders?!(((
Choose love
Putin, he must pay for what he did.
Thank you NGO SAVE UKRAINE! -for all your hard work, for reuniting families.
I pray for all the children to be reunited with their loved ones ASAP!
My prayers go out to the parents/loved ones-stay strong, keep the faith as a mother myself this story leaves me in tears-children are sacred.
I mean, it is war... so...
There's no more death sentence in Europe (mostly for a good reason) so I guess the post war tribunal against Putin and the closest cronies must be held elsewhere where there's such an option. Why not in Russia itself...
After the names has been changed out by the lawyers and judges and attorneys and sealed there identitys its hard to find a missing kids that has had electric shocks reprogramming therapy that can not remember and does not know and is having problems waking up all there lives and some will never wake up or remember there true identities and when you say something you are a lier and sent to be locked up by mental health and have a mental illness
I still was Putins head though.
Empire of Evil.
俄罗斯的小姐姐都去中国赚快钱了
Human mine
Surprised how few heartbroken parents you were able to find, whose children will never return. Of course, border logistics will be a mess with suspicions on all sides - I fully support Ukraine🇺🇦 but every time I research this story it seems like a propagandized set of assertions. (And, of course, various Russians in charge will influence the children with "You're part of Russia now" tales)
Precisely.
Save little Ukrainians girls!
Yo mama went to Russia
Did in 1959 did when king Faisals orphanages was closing and king Faisal went to Richard Nixion to find homes for the orphans of Saudi Arabias orphanages and of the Russian missing kids that Donald Trump found and was investigating for Vladimir Putin about what happened to Vladimir Putins childhood wife that king Faisal wanted me to wait for him to return but he would be assassinated and would not come back to get me or us
snakeoil
*What is done against a child is done against God.* - Victor Hugo, The Man Who Laughs
💙💛 🇺🇦🇺🇸✌
So u agree that usa is a totalitarian regime .😂😂😂😂😂
There is no country named west . So u lost
Communist liars ? Ok prove it . Lets see how truthful u are .
If xi does not care about any rules then prove it . Waiting
Winston Churchill ? The guy who took food from indians and over 3 million died of starvation ?
Wow u lost already. U defended a war monger ..
WE WON'T DECOUPLE SINCE THERE IS NO COUNTRY NAMED WEST . OTHERWISE ENTIRE ASIA AFRICA LATIN AMERICA WILL DECOUPLE FROM U . U WON'T EVEN SURVIVE 3 DAYS