I like to imagine that the Wild Cards aren't surprised that the Velvet Room residents didn't tell them about the whole "you're all from different times" thing because they know that the Velvet Room never explains anything
I'd like to imagine the Wild Cards just have a really good memory of their first time in the Velvet Room, where it is explained that it exists between dream and reality, mind and matter. Anywhere with them is a weird place
An in-game (missable) TV broadcast in P5 mentions that Rise is 21. As we all know, Rise is 16 during P4, which takes place in 2011-12. Due to that hint, and the in-game calendar matching the irl calendar, it's easy to deduce that P5 takes place in 2016-17, with Strikers taking place about 4 months after the ending.
@@aqua6887 I doubt they're from another alternate universe like the Femc's circumstances or p1 and p2, there’s also multiple evidences that they’re from the same timeline, like the references about the P3 (I think Yukari was mentioned) and P4 cast (Rise is in a poster, Yukiko and Adachi appear on tv), and most importantly the supporting character Tanaka who appeared from 3 to 4 and 5 as a shady businessman.
I kind of like idea of two sets of Persona users going through their adventures at the same time, never meeting each other, fighting two separate gods that are vaguely connected to each other. And each time one of them hits a milestone, it affects the other team.
Trails into Reverie is a very similar premise to that, but with 3 teams. You can select whichever you want to play as at any given time and they all have stories happening in parallel that affect each other, and sometimes even directly unlock something in the other route, and then they all converge at the end. Unfortunately I can't really recommend it, not because it's bad, it's great, but because it's the culmination of a long-running series with 9 games prior to that one. It'd be like playing PQ2 as your first Persona game.
@@joshuagabrielcatindig7607 They have the disclaimer at the start of the game that says any and all references to events in the real world are coincidental so I don't think adding the exact year would change anything
Too many delays make the game "dont" have a official year, but is easy to know is 2016 (the original release year) comparing the game calendar and the 2016 calendar.
@@BlueTwins even though Makoto is 17 as her birthday in the spring and Haru is 16 due to her birthday being in December and the official birth year for them is 1998 which would make it that 2015 as most third years in Highschool especially around the Tokyo area are usually around 17.
@@chuguvsme no I’m not if you look at her birthday and judge that with her time in the game during Shido’s palace yes she’s 17 and in strikers she’s going to be 18 but when you meet her around September-October she’s still 16 due to Joker, Anne, Ryuji, and Yusake all being 16
@@soundwavegamer2321 I am wondering if you can see my link because it lists her official age. It also good to note that she is the second oldest student and that 18 years old is usually when Persona characters graduate highschool.
Very minor spoil: It was a running joke that Junpei didn't realize Naoto was a girl until basically the end of the second dungeon. Naturally, Junpei being himself, layered on the cheese by calling her that to make up for all of the lost time.
Oh, my God. It never occurred to me that Yuki and Yosuke have the same VA. I never heard the. Together up until this point. Yuri really is a talented VA to be able to do two completely different characters in the same scene.
This might seem unrelated, but whenever I hear Yosuke, I see Pharos and Ryoji instead. Also Persona is apparently very big on reuse since 3 and 4 share a pattern of protagonist and antagonist sharing VAs (not counting Portable's Femc, and Japanese VAs of P4 I think).
@@navycalvin9337 Persona 5 takes place in 2016-2017, I believe. The official calendar follows the timeline in-game. Same goes with Royal's third semester, following up with Scramble later on.
Just image if the Persona 1 characters were in this (I’d say persona 2 as well but I didn’t look up when it took place) Naoto: Is the year 2011? Yusuke: I can assure that it is not 2011 Minako: It’s 2009! *everyone just being confused Naoya:... it’s 1996...
@@theamazingwman9349 That wasn't Konoe's doing. EMMA made it seem like it, however, EMMA is fully responsible for capitalizing on what she learned from Konoe's introduction to cognitive psience and from that, became the false god formed by the desires of the masses. Igor also isn't an antagonist. It was the god of control / demiurge "Yaldabaoth" who simply took the form of Igor
Persona Q2: “It’s hard to believe we are from different time periods... but we shouldn’t mention too much from where we came from, as we don’t know what effects that can have on the past/future.” And Elizabeth being like: ohhh so that’s what happened Persona Q: “Chihiro is a third year and student council president in the future. Remember when Rise’s event and the P3 cultural event got cancelled?” Easily accepting that they’re from different times, especially when Elizabeth + Margaret were like: yeah we already knew we were all from different time periods, glad that you finally realized it lol I easily prefer the Q version of the realization, it was pretty funny lol
@@TUCell-ps5mi I don’t think he remembers since their memories of PQ (and Q2) get erased at the end, but it is some nice angst material to write about :D
@@sotoro2154 it is. There’s a reference in P5 that confirms the Rise is 21 at the time of the game. Since she’s 16 in P4 which happens in 2011, it means P5 happens in 2016-2017.
I don’t know that I agree if it’s clever.. I think it’s clever in Catherine, to make Catherine feel timeless and a little mysterious. But it annoys me for a persons game. Part of the charm of Persona 3 and 4 is that I can look back on the years those games took place: I know where I was when SEES went to the beach or when the Investigation Team rented mopeds. I know what I was doing when Makoto Yuki sacrificed himself to stop Nyx and when Yu Narukami fought Izanami. And knowing how much time has passed makes it more meaningful when we see them again in media that takes place after their game, like Persona 4 Arena Ultimax and Persona 4 Dancing. Giving the games a canon year helped me relate a lot to the characters and feel like they were real friends to me. Aaaaand… P5 doesn’t do it. So Imo it only detracts from the game that it’s never outright said in dialogue. More so that the only way to find out the year is reverse Engineering the age of a character from a persons game that knew you should just tell the player the year.
Persona Q is seriously underrated AF. the story is so heartbreaking and yet beautiful that I kept remembering about it every now and then. Hoping for a remake/remaster :3
Well, it's good that no one told each other what happens in the future, like Yukari becoming a famous fashion model and actress that Ann looks up to and Futaba is a fan of on Phoenix Ranger Featherman. Although technically, if Ken was 10-11, he would be the same age as Makoto and Haru, if the year that P5 takes place in is 2016.
That being said, if Ryuji reacts to and recognizes Rise, I don’t understand why Ann or Futaba wouldn’t react at all to Yukari. Futaba especially since she doesn’t have as much of a filter
@Daddly Lou Gerera I’m all for a Q sequel involving a modern cast and a classic cast. I have tossed around an idea for the next one to involve P1 and P5R.
Everyone has a Nurse kink. Joker let his nurse kink manifest and it turned into a Doctor Kink. Now he’s into doctors, or shall I say the doctor is into him.
Oh I cannot wait for when they do this again for persona 6.... I wonder how they’ll all react to hearing about a certain pandemic that will take place in a few short years
@Joshua Gabriel Catindig honestly Atlus has no balls at all. We fuckin waited over 10 years for Persona 3 FUCKING PORTABLE and we'll probably never get FES
What's funnier is [SPOILERS] Shinjiro is the one of the two being who saw through him ( the other is Koromaru, he knows something about Akechi who is sus )
Wooow so in PQ 1 Yuri voice both Yosuke and Makoto Yuki (in the P4 route) man feels good. Also as a good green android said once, "multiverse theory is a bitch".
Because that timeline has been erased and none of P3, P4 and P5 characters are aware that they are living in an altered timeline aka Eternal Punishment.
I pretty much sure that when attendants created, they weaveved in reality retroactively. Like, Margaret was created sometime in 2011 for Narukami, but then reality rearranged so she became oldest sister and actually existed before and interracted with p3 cast in tartarus. Same happened with Theo, when Minako appeared. Attendants are created FOR Wildcards, not other way around, but then reality rewriten - and bam, they always were here, even before. Of course, that's just an excuse - why don't we see any of late attendants in games before, if they are quite old... cause they were not created by atlus before. But it's a meta-excuse, and i tried to create in-universe excuse. But actully, even if attendants think of themselves as wholesome and independent persons(pun intended) they are created and heavily connected to their Wildcards, they literraly hold links between WC and Sea of Souls - Compendium and act like Anima/Animus for MC.
Margaret mentions that Elizabeth left her job as an attendant because she wants to save the p3 protag. I think all of the attendants exist from the very beginning, they just join the velvet room whenever someone needs them on their journey. Margaret also appears in persona 3 portable, but I don't know if that involves time travel or not.
I'm watching this while the video was muted, and I am playing a game with myself and this video, by reading each character's lines with me reading them in what I remember their English voice acting sounds like. And those who I don't know their voice actor/actress sounds like when they voice act these characters (mainly most of the characters from Persona 4, as it's the only mainline Persona game I haven't played that isn't Persona 1 or 2, where back then, Persona didn't exactly have it's own identity that it got starting with 3), those who's voices I don't know, I substitute made-up voices I imagine, to fill those gaps
I'd laugh if they said that Persona 5 cast is from year 20*censored* and they would constatly using this phrase. Or even better use YHVH sound from SMT4A to censor it.
Well, to clarify things I will briefly explain Persona's timeline (NOT SMT OR MEGATEN.) P1 and P2 EP major events occours in a different timeline from P2 IS and the other Personas games, this is because Persona 2 IS exists but completely towed P2 EP due to the game's final events. P2 IS: 2001-2002 ( maybe ) P3: 2009-2010 P4: 2011-2012 P5: 2016-2017
I'd love it if these games had a Yukkuri voice filter on the characters, Chibis, Yukkuris, annoying ass and cute, stupid and absurd over a sort of serious plot which leads to it becoming hilarious. Perfect.
It's really not. It's just Atlus being reluctant to put an official time setting for Persona 5. But we know it's: Persona 3: 2009-2010 Persona 4: 2011-2012 Persona 5: 2016
P3 - P5 are also still on the same timeline as P1 - P2 the blue butterfly that appears to P3MC, the save points in P4 as well as the one that appears in Q2, are the character Philemon from the older games his creations, Igor and the Velvet Room appear in every numbered game too during the Yakushima trip in P3, Mitsuru's father mentions that the Kirijo Group is an offshoot of the Nanjo Group, who were also mentioned in P1 and the current heir being one of that game's main characters (Kei Nanjo) They also most likely got the idea of developing artifical Persona users after Kei seized research documents about it in Persona 2 Eternal Punishment if you want to go even further, the Persona timeline is also the same timeline as Devil Summoner and Soul Hackers - Soul Hackers 2, and it all started from Shin Megami Tensei: if..., which itself is an alternate outcome from when ICBM hitting Tokyo from Shin Megami Tensei 1 never happened
I dunno, i like how Risette is known by Sees and the phantom thieves. Its a small thing, but great detail. But its kinda lame that we arent told witch year p5 takes place
Because certain characters are based on real-life events, legal reasons, they don't bring up the year, it's clear it's 2016 and no one should waste chewing their heads off about it.
Hehehe, i gotta say, i find it interesting how while we did get definitive Years for when P3 (2009) and P4 (2011) takes place, the P5 Cast didn’t give us anything that could’ve potentially told us just how far into the Future P5 could’ve taken place from P4, I guess they didn’t really want to think about that, huh?
Ok as someone who played the previous games after playing Persona 5, I admit Yuu's humour is the best out of all ther persona protags after all who can forget the iconic group date scene
I'm just gonna say something, and you can hate me for it just like I hate myself for saying so...... MAKOTO ISN'T ALIVE IN 2011 OR IN 2016! I'm going to cry in the fucking corner now
Unrelated but one of the best interactions in this game is to me Is Shinji and Akechi Like the game takes around November for the p5 team. Before the end of Saes Palace. And at some point Shinji pulls Akechi aside and says basicaly: i dont know you whole deal is. But you're vibes are horrendous. Call off whatever your scheming. And Ken is hiding somewhere just watching. And the Cherry ontop being that everyons games still happen passed the point they get sent home. So like a few weeks after that conversation Akechi will be shooting Joker
...this is the first Persona Q video I've seen with English audio. I was convinced that those games just didn't have the English cast. EDIT: Only Q1? Curious....
The PQ games aren’t dreams, they do happen but everyone forgets about it at the end. And I heard that Q2 happens like... the next day after PQ apparently
@@Jarock316 how!? Yu literally says Rei which is the name of the character in Persona Q! I don’t know of any other persona game with the voice actor for yu narukami saying the name Rei. This was definitely dubbed over by the original cast .
Persona 3: 2009 Persona 4: 2011 (Rise is still a High School student and a first year, there are 3 years for School age so if Rise is an adult by Persona 5 and is an Idol again) Persona 5 year: in game Calendar reads as 20XX right ? If Rise isn't in School anymore at least a few years have passed. (For 2017 to be the Canon year of Persona 5 that means it's been 6 years since the Inaba Killings)
So Persona 4 characters are 2 years after Persona 3 characters? And then (from Persona 5 in game clues specifically Rise) Persona 5 characters are 4 years after Persona 4 characters?
@@andys2801 we don’t know. Persona 3 took place in 2009 even though it came out in 2006. And since Persona 4 takes place 2 years after P3, it’s during 2011 even though the game came out in 2008
@@andys2801 with the modern games, it seems to be more or less a “20 minutes into the future” approach. Though with P5 trailing behind, with Strikers taking place in 2017, who knows when they’ll place P6.
@@Dresfvae but you also gotta take into account Persona 4: Dancing All Night and Persona 4: Arena Ultimax for the P4 timeline and Persona 5: Strikers in the timeline of P5 as well
I like to imagine that the Wild Cards aren't surprised that the Velvet Room residents didn't tell them about the whole "you're all from different times" thing because they know that the Velvet Room never explains anything
Meanwhile, the Persona 3 MC is just asking "Who cares?"
@@NicoTheCinderace that's a spot on impression of Makoto Yuki you sure you aren't related
I'd like to imagine the Wild Cards just have a really good memory of their first time in the Velvet Room, where it is explained that it exists between dream and reality, mind and matter. Anywhere with them is a weird place
@@Aigis31 considering that Yu has a monologue in arena about not forgetting the original scene in velvet room I think you are right
and also despite the fact even the residents and the p3 and p4 cast didnt know that the twins were once one person named lavenza
Yu saying "senpai" is one of those reasons why i like him so much
big Chad energy
Chad Narukami strikes again
RESPECT IS A QUALITY A TRUE CHAD HAVE
He sounds so sad that Junpei told him not to call him that
@@Graknorke 3:16 wha…!?
An in-game (missable) TV broadcast in P5 mentions that Rise is 21. As we all know, Rise is 16 during P4, which takes place in 2011-12. Due to that hint, and the in-game calendar matching the irl calendar, it's easy to deduce that P5 takes place in 2016-17, with Strikers taking place about 4 months after the ending.
So,yu is 22,yosuke 22,teddy??,kanji 21,rise 21,naoto 21,chie22 and yukiko is 22
but persona 5 only 20xx and never use original real years, that mean is other dimension, different with timeline persona 3 and 4
@@aqua6887 I doubt they're from another alternate universe like the Femc's circumstances or p1 and p2, there’s also multiple evidences that they’re from the same timeline, like the references about the P3 (I think Yukari was mentioned) and P4 cast (Rise is in a poster, Yukiko and Adachi appear on tv), and most importantly the supporting character Tanaka who appeared from 3 to 4 and 5 as a shady businessman.
After noticing that, I actually looked at the days and they seem to mimic 2016's days.
@@one-wingedangel5107 Why P1 and P2 are another timeline? In P3 are some P2 and P1 references
As someone who hasn't played PQ2 seeing Theo randomly in a popcorn outfit made me laugh much more than it should have.
They really couldn't just have the P5 cast say 2016 😔
They either forgot that they reveal the ages and birth years of both Makoto and Haru or they thought nobody would notice.
Nah. Its more of an in-game reference to how Persona 5 takes place in the year 20XX, even though uts clearly 2016 when you match up the dates
With delay after delay, this is pretty much Atlus’s way of apologizing about the delays and not giving P5 a specific date.
I kind of like idea of two sets of Persona users going through their adventures at the same time, never meeting each other, fighting two separate gods that are vaguely connected to each other. And each time one of them hits a milestone, it affects the other team.
Xenoblade 1 & 2, kind of.
Trails into Reverie is a very similar premise to that, but with 3 teams. You can select whichever you want to play as at any given time and they all have stories happening in parallel that affect each other, and sometimes even directly unlock something in the other route, and then they all converge at the end.
Unfortunately I can't really recommend it, not because it's bad, it's great, but because it's the culmination of a long-running series with 9 games prior to that one. It'd be like playing PQ2 as your first Persona game.
I might be wrong but, didn’t P1 have this going on?
Even the p5 crew don't know what canon year they take place in. Lmao.
It’s 2016.
I feel like games that try to hide these things don't really try. Like it matches up so why bother hiding it?
It's ridiculous. LOL
@@lightningpenguin8937 I heard it's to avoid lawsuits ala-Shido because some Palace stories are too close for comfort with their...source material.
@@joshuagabrielcatindig7607 They have the disclaimer at the start of the game that says any and all references to events in the real world are coincidental so I don't think adding the exact year would change anything
Fuuka's got pretty good impressions of Elizabeth and Margaret
Rise’s vocal range is also great
Atlus really doesn’t wanna staple a year on Persona 5, do they?
Too many delays make the game "dont" have a official year, but is easy to know is 2016 (the original release year) comparing the game calendar and the 2016 calendar.
@@BlueTwins even though Makoto is 17 as her birthday in the spring and Haru is 16 due to her birthday being in December and the official birth year for them is 1998 which would make it that 2015 as most third years in Highschool especially around the Tokyo area are usually around 17.
@@chuguvsme no I’m not if you look at her birthday and judge that with her time in the game during Shido’s palace yes she’s 17 and in strikers she’s going to be 18 but when you meet her around September-October she’s still 16 due to Joker, Anne, Ryuji, and Yusake all being 16
@@soundwavegamer2321 I am wondering if you can see my link because it lists her official age.
It also good to note that she is the second oldest student and that 18 years old is usually when Persona characters graduate highschool.
Well if we use the roman numeral rule for P5's date of "20XX", it should be "2020".
Did Junpei just call Naoto "Nao-cakes?"
Apparently he does that a lot.
Very minor spoil:
It was a running joke that Junpei didn't realize Naoto was a girl until basically the end of the second dungeon. Naturally, Junpei being himself, layered on the cheese by calling her that to make up for all of the lost time.
@@cpMetis more evidence to showcase Junpei is best girl
Oh, am I mistaken? I thought I overheard something about delicious -NaoCakes-
He called her that back in the first Persona Q game when he learned Naoto was female.
i'm imagining that akechi saw naoto and had to keep himself from yelling "IT'S THE DETECTIVE PRINCE!" akechi is absolutely naoto's #1 fanboy
Clearly a Persona Q3 will have to include both Sofia from Strikers and Kasumi from Royal, and whoever is introduced in the P5 Racing game.
I want my black mask dammit
the WHAT
Black Mask Akechi replacing Prince Akechi and adding Robin Hood to the DLC Personas is a better way to look at this
Don’t forget Zenkichi and Metis
Don't forget the Gacha game (Probably)
Oh, my God. It never occurred to me that Yuki and Yosuke have the same VA. I never heard the. Together up until this point. Yuri really is a talented VA to be able to do two completely different characters in the same scene.
Tara Plat does it quite often as she voices Mitsuru and Elizabeth
This might seem unrelated, but whenever I hear Yosuke, I see Pharos and Ryoji instead. Also Persona is apparently very big on reuse since 3 and 4 share a pattern of protagonist and antagonist sharing VAs (not counting Portable's Femc, and Japanese VAs of P4 I think).
Atlus and, to an extension, Sega seem to have a group of prefered VAs. It's not only in Persona, but it also happens in SMT
Lyzder keep in mind Atlus is pretty small all things considered. It could be it costs less to reuse VAs
Yuri is indeed amazing. My favorite role is when he voiced Gig from Soul Nomad. It's definitely one of his best act.
P3= 2009-2010
P4= 2011- 2012
P5 = 20XX
Correct
In Persona 5 they did say Rise already hit her 20's that would mean it is at least 4y after P4
@@navycalvin9337 yea ur right but i want exact timeline of p5. Dam u atlus!
@@navycalvin9337 Persona 5 takes place in 2016-2017, I believe. The official calendar follows the timeline in-game. Same goes with Royal's third semester, following up with Scramble later on.
P1= 1996
P2= 1999-2000
10:28 Joker's still right in a way, an example literally comes up right after when Teddy doesn't recognize Liz
Just image if the Persona 1 characters were in this (I’d say persona 2 as well but I didn’t look up when it took place)
Naoto: Is the year 2011?
Yusuke: I can assure that it is not 2011
Minako: It’s 2009!
*everyone just being confused
Naoya:... it’s 1996...
If you add Tatauya he’d probably be like: dude how old are you? It’s 1999
@@loliezz8461
Maya: Don’t worry, we’ll figure this out. Let’s think positive! ᴬⁿᵈ ᵗʰᵉ ʸᵉᵃʳ ᶦˢ ²⁰⁰⁰.
Persona 6 protag: wait these guys are like 30
Some random youtube video: Wake up bro it's 2006!
Becomes even funnier when you consider that in 1996, the P5 cast weren't even born
"Could it be we would be victorious?"
You will but with a hard price.
DOOOOOOOOOOOR
*cries*
@@princessdawn718 DOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOR
Mitsuru: “Ive seen a Ray of hope. A future as bright as they are.”
Makoto: “🚪”
Minato: Bruh, I'm dead! **Vine boom effect**
Makoto Yuki and Kotone Shiomi co-existing in PQ2 kinda screams alternate timelines is a thing in this series
Bro they confirmed it when Q2 released
And alternate universes are a thing since Persona 2
I'm glad someone finally addresses her as Kotone lol. I love that name
@@kirakira_san Well, never one for fanmade names and that's like her only official name
@@WoomyBoomyGG It’s all Hitler’s fault.
Strict Mitsuru is love.
Scaredy Mitsuru is live.
salutations fellow gentleman/lady of culture, have a like
So happy Mitsuru is Laugh?
a future as bright as they are....adachi/ Igor / konoe haha go brrrrrrrrr
Is konoe kokonoe from blazblue
Which is related to persona 4 and 3 cast
@@ultra9349 no im talking about P5S basically he mimicked mementos and created an app similar to the meta nave to "save" ppl from them self
@@theamazingwman9349 That wasn't Konoe's doing. EMMA made it seem like it, however, EMMA is fully responsible for capitalizing on what she learned from Konoe's introduction to cognitive psience and from that, became the false god formed by the desires of the masses.
Igor also isn't an antagonist. It was the god of control / demiurge "Yaldabaoth" who simply took the form of Igor
@@ultra9349 Konoe is the real name of Nine though
Persona Q2: “It’s hard to believe we are from different time periods... but we shouldn’t mention too much from where we came from, as we don’t know what effects that can have on the past/future.” And Elizabeth being like: ohhh so that’s what happened
Persona Q: “Chihiro is a third year and student council president in the future. Remember when Rise’s event and the P3 cultural event got cancelled?” Easily accepting that they’re from different times, especially when Elizabeth + Margaret were like: yeah we already knew we were all from different time periods, glad that you finally realized it lol
I easily prefer the Q version of the realization, it was pretty funny lol
P3MC couldn't even go and say, "i knew she'd do it" without giving a clue that Chihiro was one of the girls from his harem
I like how Chihiro of all people was important in PQ tbh
Makes it even weirder when you realise Door-kun probably remembers Persona Q, but doesn’t say anything because...
@@TUCell-ps5mi I don’t think he remembers since their memories of PQ (and Q2) get erased at the end, but it is some nice angst material to write about :D
@@princessdawn718 only Joker remembers
Persona characters wondering why they went from speaking English to speaking Japanese again.
Atlus is sort of clever for not letting the P5 characters reveal the actual year they're in.
But it still pisses me off.
They’re from 2016
@@plushytv5295 As much as I want to think that, there isn't an official date.
@@sotoro2154 it is. There’s a reference in P5 that confirms the Rise is 21 at the time of the game. Since she’s 16 in P4 which happens in 2011, it means P5 happens in 2016-2017.
I feel like the timeline is too well thought out. They can't even hide it if they wanted too.
I don’t know that I agree if it’s clever.. I think it’s clever in Catherine, to make Catherine feel timeless and a little mysterious. But it annoys me for a persons game.
Part of the charm of Persona 3 and 4 is that I can look back on the years those games took place: I know where I was when SEES went to the beach or when the Investigation Team rented mopeds. I know what I was doing when Makoto Yuki sacrificed himself to stop Nyx and when Yu Narukami fought Izanami. And knowing how much time has passed makes it more meaningful when we see them again in media that takes place after their game, like Persona 4 Arena Ultimax and Persona 4 Dancing.
Giving the games a canon year helped me relate a lot to the characters and feel like they were real friends to me. Aaaaand… P5 doesn’t do it. So Imo it only detracts from the game that it’s never outright said in dialogue. More so that the only way to find out the year is reverse Engineering the age of a character from a persons game that knew you should just tell the player the year.
Persona Q is seriously underrated AF. the story is so heartbreaking and yet beautiful that I kept remembering about it every now and then.
Hoping for a remake/remaster :3
I'm just disappointed they skipped on the english VA's for the localization.
4:14 its pretty wild to hear yuki and yosuke speak right after each other since they share the same VA
3:09 Naoto just DESTROYED Junpei.
And Yu went for the jugular.
Tatsuya:honestly I just stopped thinking about timelines a looooong time ago...
Well, it's good that no one told each other what happens in the future, like Yukari becoming a famous fashion model and actress that Ann looks up to and Futaba is a fan of on Phoenix Ranger Featherman. Although technically, if Ken was 10-11, he would be the same age as Makoto and Haru, if the year that P5 takes place in is 2016.
11 in 2009 means 18 in 2016, making him Makoto's age, due to her having an April Birthday
That being said, if Ryuji reacts to and recognizes Rise, I don’t understand why Ann or Futaba wouldn’t react at all to Yukari. Futaba especially since she doesn’t have as much of a filter
An interesting thing to note is that Akechi is the same age as Ken, almost to the day, and they're both associated with the Justice arcana
12:53-
Tatsuya: yeah, about that....
@Daddly Lou Gerera honestly, I prefer the games without social links.
@Daddly Lou Gerera I’m all for a Q sequel involving a modern cast and a classic cast. I have tossed around an idea for the next one to involve P1 and P5R.
Tatsuya appearing like: oops wrong timeline 😐
@@thorhit pfft!
@@thorhit Tatsuya like "shit not again"
It is so funny that two highschool detectives are talking to each other. I love this kind of game. I never played Q2 but I played Q1
Ann: What year is this?
Yusuke: Certainly not 2011.
Coomer: *2020*
3:15
Yu: trying to be gay with P3's BFF
P3's BFF: no homo
no one can seduce Junpei, not even femc can do it
Yosuke turned him down and he found out Junpei was the prequel to Yosuke. Narukami didn’t waste the opportunity
fuuka's elizabeth and margaret impressions are great
I'm glad yosuke's nurse kink is consistent
Everyone has a Nurse kink. Joker let his nurse kink manifest and it turned into a Doctor Kink. Now he’s into doctors, or shall I say the doctor is into him.
@@andys2801 I thought Joker had a maid kink?
@@Jarock316 both. both is good
@@andys2801joker is inside the doctor
Yusuke: I can assure you it’s not 2011…
Minako: Right, it’s 2009!
Chie: What!? It’s 2011..!
Junpei: Dude, it’s 2009.
Keaneau Reeves: IN 2077,
WHAT MAKES YOU A CRIMINAL?
@@waterized_bottle GETTING CAUG-
G E T T I N G C O C K
@@waterized_bottle getting co-
1:41 you’re ALL wrong, it’s 2021!!
r/woooosh
@@pyroflare7774
Joke
Your head
@@saucehunter9705 sex is hot, you are not
No it's 2024
Yukiko: Sorry Junpei, you are 2009 you not 2011 you or 2099 you. You are my age nothing more
3:49
Funni to see the Kirijo meme is even accepted by the devs
Oh I cannot wait for when they do this again for persona 6.... I wonder how they’ll all react to hearing about a certain pandemic that will take place in a few short years
I don't think they'll use that one. Because a certain red country may react to that and demand for it to be taken.
@@joshuagabrielcatindig7607 Well boo freaking hoo to them.
@@Jarock316 Atlus may not have as big balls as Cover...
@Joshua Gabriel Catindig honestly Atlus has no balls at all. We fuckin waited over 10 years for Persona 3 FUCKING PORTABLE and we'll probably never get FES
Fuuka does a pretty good Elizabeth and Margaret impression!
3:16 yuu sounds so conflicted from being denied junpei plz
Persona 5 spoilers:
The thing i love about persona q2 is the fact that akechi had to fake his personality for an entire game XD
What's funnier is [SPOILERS]
Shinjiro is the one of the two being who saw through him ( the other is Koromaru, he knows something about Akechi who is sus )
@@zapperilanyways joker and morgana (and futaba) already knew about akechi bc the eavesdropping he did
When you forget that Ryuji is voiced by a MADO SCIENTIST in Japanese. Ryuji, you're a real bro.
I AM MADO SCIENTIST. IS SO COOOLLL! ˢᵘⁿᵒᵛᵃᵇᶦᶜʰ
El psy congroo
For real!?
And then you have best cat girl Hanekawa in Chie
Makoto kun : sorry I died young and becoming seal
Yu kun : how did you know!?
Makoto kun : having Dija Vu
I was really expecting the P5 cast to show their Smartphones to P3 and P4 cast since they use freakin flip phones at their time.
never change Elizabeth.. never Change
3:16 Yu canonically chooses the troll options
Wooow so in PQ 1 Yuri voice both Yosuke and Makoto Yuki (in the P4 route) man feels good.
Also as a good green android said once, "multiverse theory is a bitch".
Nobody tell them about the timeline where Xibalba rises and the Earth is destroyed.
Because that timeline has been erased and none of P3, P4 and P5 characters are aware that they are living in an altered timeline aka Eternal Punishment.
I really wanted to have this spinoff game its one of the games where the Persona users from different game meet
And Rise’s show at Club Escapade was mentioned in Reload
Theodore is younger than Margaret ? I thought it went Elizabeth, Theodore, Margaret, Lavenza, but I guess I was wrong
Margaret is the oldest.
Next is Elizabeth.
Then Theodore.
And the youngest is Lavenza.
I pretty much sure that when attendants created, they weaveved in reality retroactively. Like, Margaret was created sometime in 2011 for Narukami, but then reality rearranged so she became oldest sister and actually existed before and interracted with p3 cast in tartarus. Same happened with Theo, when Minako appeared. Attendants are created FOR Wildcards, not other way around, but then reality rewriten - and bam, they always were here, even before.
Of course, that's just an excuse - why don't we see any of late attendants in games before, if they are quite old... cause they were not created by atlus before. But it's a meta-excuse, and i tried to create in-universe excuse. But actully, even if attendants think of themselves as wholesome and independent persons(pun intended) they are created and heavily connected to their Wildcards, they literraly hold links between WC and Sea of Souls - Compendium and act like Anima/Animus for MC.
Margaret mentions that Elizabeth left her job as an attendant because she wants to save the p3 protag. I think all of the attendants exist from the very beginning, they just join the velvet room whenever someone needs them on their journey.
Margaret also appears in persona 3 portable, but I don't know if that involves time travel or not.
Hey, share your profile picture please ...
In 3 dancing Elizabeth calls theodore a "naive pup worthy of teasing" and says "his height is his most mature trait"
I'm watching this while the video was muted, and I am playing a game with myself and this video, by reading each character's lines with me reading them in what I remember their English voice acting sounds like. And those who I don't know their voice actor/actress sounds like when they voice act these characters (mainly most of the characters from Persona 4, as it's the only mainline Persona game I haven't played that isn't Persona 1 or 2, where back then, Persona didn't exactly have it's own identity that it got starting with 3), those who's voices I don't know, I substitute made-up voices I imagine, to fill those gaps
I'd laugh if they said that Persona 5 cast is from year 20*censored* and they would constatly using this phrase. Or even better use YHVH sound from SMT4A to censor it.
Well, to clarify things I will briefly explain Persona's timeline (NOT SMT OR MEGATEN.) P1 and P2 EP major events occours in a different timeline from P2 IS and the other Personas games, this is because Persona 2 IS exists but completely towed P2 EP due to the game's final events.
P2 IS: 2001-2002 ( maybe )
P3: 2009-2010
P4: 2011-2012
P5: 2016-2017
12:30 Subtitles: "Thai pair of dachshunds?"
Words: "Thai Kick a dog?"
I'd love it if these games had a Yukkuri voice filter on the characters, Chibis, Yukkuris, annoying ass and cute, stupid and absurd over a sort of serious plot which leads to it becoming hilarious. Perfect.
I really liked they tackled the fact that combining heros of different eras should be noticed. Better than Your Name
These timelines are realy freaking confusing as hell
Um yeah, that's the point🤣
Not as messed up as Zelda’s official timeline.
Persona 3 2009 2010 games ending Persona 4 2011 2012 Ending Persona 5 2016 2017 games ending.
It's really not. It's just Atlus being reluctant to put an official time setting for Persona 5. But we know it's:
Persona 3: 2009-2010
Persona 4: 2011-2012
Persona 5: 2016
Yu calling Junpei Senpai is so sweet, it also reminds me of his moments with Yosuke in the Persona 4 anime
Wait, how am I just realizing Fuuka’s impressions of Elizabeth and Margaret?
Yu manages to be both a chad and a troll
this would be better if they dub pq2 too i hope atlus west will working on that cant wait to hear jb as yu narukami again
Too bad, they confirmed no english VA's for Q2.
The fact that all the 3-5 persona games are connected gives me a lot of questions.
P3 - P5 are also still on the same timeline as P1 - P2
the blue butterfly that appears to P3MC, the save points in P4 as well as the one that appears in Q2, are the character Philemon from the older games
his creations, Igor and the Velvet Room appear in every numbered game too
during the Yakushima trip in P3, Mitsuru's father mentions that the Kirijo Group is an offshoot of the Nanjo Group, who were also mentioned in P1 and the current heir being one of that game's main characters (Kei Nanjo)
They also most likely got the idea of developing artifical Persona users after Kei seized research documents about it in Persona 2 Eternal Punishment
if you want to go even further, the Persona timeline is also the same timeline as Devil Summoner and Soul Hackers - Soul Hackers 2, and it all started from Shin Megami Tensei: if..., which itself is an alternate outcome from when ICBM hitting Tokyo from Shin Megami Tensei 1 never happened
I dunno, i like how Risette is known by Sees and the phantom thieves. Its a small thing, but great detail. But its kinda lame that we arent told witch year p5 takes place
why do they not admit that p5 takes place in 2016 already?
Because certain characters are based on real-life events, legal reasons, they don't bring up the year, it's clear it's 2016 and no one should waste chewing their heads off about it.
Also it was election year in Japan if I remember right
@@raisingwings2913 oh... yea that would have been a problem
OathkeeperRoxas99 which characters? P5 is the only game that has the statement it's not based on any real world events or persons
@@OathKeeperRiku07 "This story is a work of fiction. Similarities to persons living or dead in your world are purely coincidental."
Hehehe, i gotta say, i find it interesting how while we did get definitive Years for when P3 (2009) and P4 (2011) takes place, the P5 Cast didn’t give us anything that could’ve potentially told us just how far into the Future P5 could’ve taken place from P4,
I guess they didn’t really want to think about that, huh?
I never realized how crunchy Rise’s voice was
Dang I wish q2 was English dubbed
7:34 zen a daw is a digital audio workspace duh
Ok as someone who played the previous games after playing Persona 5, I admit Yuu's humour is the best out of all ther persona protags after all who can forget the iconic group date scene
They would be more surprized if the persona 5 crew told everyone that they come from 2016
Rise has the gamer mic
It just sounds like the navigators are talking way to close to their mics
We can summon Persona by shooting ourselves, destroying cards, and ripping off masks, but time travel is out of the question.
I'm just gonna say something, and you can hate me for it just like I hate myself for saying so......
MAKOTO ISN'T ALIVE IN 2011 OR IN 2016!
I'm going to cry in the fucking corner now
Unrelated but one of the best interactions in this game is to me
Is Shinji and Akechi
Like the game takes around November for the p5 team. Before the end of Saes Palace.
And at some point Shinji pulls Akechi aside and says basicaly: i dont know you whole deal is. But you're vibes are horrendous. Call off whatever your scheming.
And Ken is hiding somewhere just watching.
And the Cherry ontop being that everyons games still happen passed the point they get sent home. So like a few weeks after that conversation Akechi will be shooting Joker
Persona Q + Q2 for the Switch (and PS4) please!
Yasssssss
With English dub for Q2!
I can see Switch but why PS4? What is PS4 going to do? Make it look HD? PSP is dead so they can’t release there. Only option IS the Switch
@@andys2801 Hmm, you're probably right. I'm just throwing the PS4 idea because of the updated graphics and the Trophies
I'm a sucker for PS4 Trophies 😋
3:21 Bro is flabbergasted
fuuka literally voiced eliz better than herself
Zen sounds like Flynn
Same VA, but yeah I totally hear it lol
...this is the first Persona Q video I've seen with English audio. I was convinced that those games just didn't have the English cast.
EDIT: Only Q1? Curious....
Q2 was released so late into the 3DS's lifecycle that they didn't bother with english audio.
Persona Q2 is expensive af for a physical game
The final 3DS game with a limited run and budget, it sold so poorly
Occasionally, it goes on sale on the eShop. That's how I picked it up.
@@brendanbeta487 Damn but I really want it and it’s like 80 😭
I’m gonna pass the tf out-
I haven’t played PQ, but is that Keith Silverstein as Zen?
Edit: holy fucking shit
Additionally, Theodore’s Japanese voice is _immaculate_ .
Wait so now what's the timeline between pq and pq2?
Are these dreams to the p3,4,5 crews like in the dancing games?
Yes
The PQ games aren’t dreams, they do happen but everyone forgets about it at the end. And I heard that Q2 happens like... the next day after PQ apparently
Persona 4 Dancing is canon and not a dream
PQ2 probably took place before Q, as weird as it is.
@@davidlarkin1040 huh? How so?
Poor Narukami XD
Persona, the game where the right answer will be said so might as well say the most ridiculous thing presented.
basically persona 3-5 takes place in the same universe and the p3p hero is from a parallel universe where her mom pushed extra hard and had a girl🤷🏻
3:57 why did she freeze
I didn’t know they dubbed this!?
Just Persona Q
They didn't. This is the original Japanese sub.
@@Jarock316 they’re speaking English literally in the beginning.
@@never_ending2220 Ripped from other games.
@@Jarock316 how!? Yu literally says Rei which is the name of the character in Persona Q! I don’t know of any other persona game with the voice actor for yu narukami saying the name Rei. This was definitely dubbed over by the original cast .
"am I a ladies man in the future"
You don't exist.
Holy shit Makoto and Yosuke are the same voice
kinda makes me sad that they didn’t make q2 in english
Persona 3: 2009
Persona 4: 2011 (Rise is still a High School student and a first year, there are 3 years for School age so if Rise is an adult by Persona 5 and is an Idol again)
Persona 5 year: in game Calendar reads as 20XX right ? If Rise isn't in School anymore at least a few years have passed. (For 2017 to be the Canon year of Persona 5 that means it's been 6 years since the Inaba Killings)
“What was Atlus smoking when we were being developed…”
“…Huh? Who? Developed?!”
Yu got rejected by Junpei-senpai :(
Real time Fun fact
I was going into my second year of high school when p3 came out.
I was finishing high school when p4 came out.
Goddangit they didnt say what year p5 was in
so miss fortune and Elizabeth share the same voice actor?
So Persona 4 characters are 2 years after Persona 3 characters? And then (from Persona 5 in game clues specifically Rise) Persona 5 characters are 4 years after Persona 4 characters?
Yes. Here’s how the game follows
P3: 2009-2010
P4: 2011-2012
P5: 2016-2017
@@Dresfvae And I wanna assume Persona 6 is going to be
2020-2021 or
2021-2022
@@andys2801 we don’t know. Persona 3 took place in 2009 even though it came out in 2006. And since Persona 4 takes place 2 years after P3, it’s during 2011 even though the game came out in 2008
@@andys2801 with the modern games, it seems to be more or less a “20 minutes into the future” approach. Though with P5 trailing behind, with Strikers taking place in 2017, who knows when they’ll place P6.
@@Dresfvae but you also gotta take into account Persona 4: Dancing All Night and Persona 4: Arena Ultimax for the P4 timeline and Persona 5: Strikers in the timeline of P5 as well