Nier Automata Game vs Anime Comparison
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 16 ม.ค. 2023
- A collection of scenes from the Nier Automata Game and episode one of new Nier Automata anime. Some scenes are almost a shot for shot recreation from the game. Which do you think does it better? The game or the anime? And what do you think the rest of the episodes has in store? Let us know!
#nier #nierautomata #anime
SUBSCRIBE to us for more game and pop culture videos!
---------------------------------------
📲 Check out our website & follow us on social media!
✦ emmengaming.com/
✦ / emmengaming
✦ / emmengamingmv
✦ / emmengaming
✦ / emmengaming - เกม
Why is not one talking ab how perfect that loop was?
I know right
Damn you're right!
What loop?
That was my first truly perfect loop after seeing a lot of false ones. I didn't even notice it
finally someone talking about it 😅
"Copy the game, but don't make it too obvious."
The Last Of Us: xd
@@dragonov5969 Well I haven't seen it so idk.
Well, you would want it to copy a majesty of a game
when anime changes stuff from games - *MALD*
when anime keeps almost everything same as the game - *MALD*
@@KryoNautwtf is Mald
Kinda funny that this is one of the few instances they followed the game 1 to 1. The story does a lot of "what ifs" to the storyline, like what if Emil was the one who turned Pascal into a pacifist, or what if Eve died instead of Adam, or what if Anemone died instead of Lily and she became the Resistance leader instead. Seeing references to supplementary material outside of the game was neat too. Also the references to Nier Replicant and Drakengard were great.
Well Nier replicant is a indirect prequel so yeah the ref does make sense
@@Echoes-dz2ur nier replicant is a direct prequel, drakengard is the indirect
Episode 4 looked even better than the original game. It was great.
Eh
@@Koel_Hellionhe
No
Episode 4 was with the Opera singer right? Then I dissagree.
Where can I watch this show
The game at bottom look like the anime.
Hmm... wait
Yeah it's anime
Both great
Idk if anyone else noticed but the first few lines 2b says at the very beginning of ep1 was basically the weapon story for virtuous contract
this is genuinely one of the first Open World (still pretty linear but it's good) games to get an Anime adaptation that's going very well
Nier is definitely not an open world game.
@@MaxIronsThird It is partly open world
edge runners: you didn't have to cut me off
@@MaxIronsThirdI mean there’s an open map with a bunch of locations where you can wander around and do side quests. It’s not like Fallout or Skyrim, but it’s definitely open world to an extent.
@@ottovonbearsmark8876it's just a corridor
game 2B still the hottest
True. I forgot how hot she is until I see this short
YoRHa really did make the sexiest assassin android ever
Her eyes in the anime version was beautiful
is that just cause her tits are bigger in the game or cause its more realistic looking.
Less sexier lips
The only character look hot without eyes
That cameraman is working overtime in both, for sure. She looks so cool.
When animators give their 110%
This is actually way less effort, since they just draw over the cinematics.
Waiting for the next episode
It was canceled
@@Jizozss why
@@volt1360 idk
@@JizozssIt's not canceled. Episode 4 is only postponed indefinitely due to Covid-19
It's back on the 18th
Proof that if the shot was great in the original, don't change it. Just make a 1:1 recreation. Too often when something is remade or adapted the new creative team will try to put their own spin on something.
Gj team
The anime looks like they've only replaced game models with Lineart
I wonder that what endings they choose for anime version? 🧐
Ammetto che c'è una scelta
You know the one
We need a remastered for the ps5
I didn't even notice the loop bro
They nailed it!
The boss fight is straight out of nier: automata.
perfect loop
Sooo.. no one's gonna talk about the perfect video loop?
The animation in both of these is so fucking good
I was about to say I knew I saw this same animation from the game and low and behold
Omg, I'm so happy I saw this 😆 I'm playing this game and just learned its an anime show too! Totally going to binge this show!
About halfway through when the cranes connect the hooks and get lifted a bit, was I the only one who heard the transformers transformation sound? 😂😂
Imaginate pensar que la animación solo puede ser usada para algo infantil. Esto es sublime
I'm down
i like that everything was identical except that one 2 second clip being flipped across the y axis 😭
The anime is just extended cutscenes
really?
@@flayy.h1 pretty much
Yep and honestly I am all for it.
All i noticed was that there isn't constant fog around engels which mutes the colors for no reason. They really did the game justice with the visuals and i like it.
You gotta love the loop.
Love the game! Love the anime
That's why this is THE BEST game adaptation to any other media EVER!
I was hyped for this but couldn’t make it through the first episode, played through the game a handful of times and idk just knew what to expect at that point, it’s amazing though but idk
Looks like they just take the game animations and filtered them as an anime..., wait!
Starts off that way, with subtle differences, but each subtle shift creates a butterfly effect until a MASSIVE shift in Episode 9 causes things go crazy in episode 11.
the only thing I don't like in the first episode is the the soundtrack don't timed well when the Goliath jumped unlike the game where it timed properly
Since when was Devastator from Revenge of the Fallen in an anime?
After they failed with another 2017 JRPG critically praised with countless crossovers and is remembered to this day, A1 is doing a great job!
so here is the question, did they draw over game cutscenes or they just added some filters to “create” the anime
I forgot she weared lipstick
いや、NieRの本家アメリカだったんかい
cool.
This is how you make an adaptation😊, I wish game that turns to anime are more on the like this
The most gorgeous 2D animation you’ve ever seen combined with somehow-downgraded in-game models
The loop was PERFECT.
"I was dangerous man"
The animators really know how to get the job done
Bruh, the *"9-ass"* makes me laugh so hard that almost makes me meet my grandpa in the lobby 😂😂😂
If not for all the small differences, I'd think it was rotoscoped, god damn.
tbh anyone that expected an anime to be 100% 3d like the game i have no clue what you were expecting its an anime most anime dont look good 3d or have short ass run times
I prefer the game over the anime in my opinion the game cut scene run so smooth unlike the anime laggy a lot of missing frames, in game also slow motion works a much better than the anime.
El gameplay de arriba es de la versión de Switch 😱
The anime is beautiful
Now I know why I thought the CGI looked awkward in the anime, the smoke and fog in the game really added to it.
Perfect loop+ both of them are magnificent.
What I don't like about the anime, is that their mimics are way to human. You see way more emotion in their faces.
I was hoping for the eng VA to change a bit by redoing the lines but I guess I will only rewatch it for 9s after all
They did, there are some interesting changes in inflection and phrasing (such as 2B saying Emotions are STRICTLY prohibited, or saying that It's completely unnecessary for him to be so formal). the audio for the video is using the game's English dub, the Anime didn't have an English dub when this video was posted on youtube. Also what's interesting is that Pod 042 sounds different in the anime's English dub (same actor, just using a deeper voice/effect) sounding closer to the Japanese version.
Later episodes add a lot of stuff so it wouldn't work to just reuse the lines from the game.
@@moffxanatos6376 I see... Guess gonna give it a chance again then, as 2B -game sounds too... Forcing or different to what the character does...
Cleanest Loop I’ve ever scene
와우............. 구현이 거의 완벽에 가깝게 됬군요. 놀랍습니다.
I love how 9S looks adorable no matter in 3D or 2D lmao
Anime wins in close looks, but the looks from far away in the game are one of the most beautiful looks you'll find in any videogame
When she said 9s, i thought she said 9-A** and i was very confused for a second.
wow just wow the anime is so good
There is only 1 thing i don't like about the anime, and it is that the robots don't have the tear stains anymore
I really wish everyone would play NieR:automata
The skirt is short in anime
The original acting was superb. Mocap team did an awesome job. Have to say the game is better in both graphics and animation.
I mean its based on game so to chancge it up would be bad imo, as the game is already really good
Both are bangable
Game feels smooth cause thats 60fps
And anime is 23 fps
Spoiler:
9S gets to be upgraded to 9s Pro Max.
Absolute perfection and the definition of satisfying 🥹😍❤️🔥
Episode 1 is really eyesgasm for us cultured gamers
They did great job i mean for game it's fantastic and for anime it's also fantastic they are godly in their own categories i liked the anime character design
Normally, i don't like when an anime is different to its game (except when is a totally different history)
But now, i watched the anime and i didn't like that the anime is that similar to the game
It sits in the middle of what you said wdym
La calidad es mejor en el juego, pero la animación le da un toque distinto y más lleno de vida
It took me like three episodes later to realize this art style is AMAZING!!! compared to other animes ✨✨😍 Her Stiletto Boot Are Shiny And Her Lips Are Luscious She Got Them DSLs 😍
That good continuity.
When did they make an anime?
This is the most powerful masterpiece that has ever graced my ears.
wait which was which?
they both are too good I can't tell em' apart!
RTX On vs RTX Off 😂
It amazes me that being a Netflix series, they have respected the content... or at least that's what it seems like.
I found gojo family
This is the excellent result of when people stick to the source material
凄いな😅アニメとゲームをここまで再現するって、神業か？
I'll wait for the dlc director easter egg in anime lol
I can't imagine the amount of money they spent to animate that
9S sounds like Sykkuno to me
Actually my dream anime comes true 🗿🥂 I always thought about that
That loop was khhhlllleeeeeaaaannnnnn
Is this game getting a resurgence?
and yes, you can change the dub into japanese in game setting
Visual do Anime era lindo, pena que quase ninguém gostou da história 😂
[inclusive eu sou um dos que dropou esse anime]
I already watched the whole season in 2018. Wait...
There’s an anime?…grrr….-WhAT?! I’ll shall have me revenge on everyone who didn’t tEll mE!
This...cannot continue? 😅
What do you guys recommend? Should I watch the anime first or should I play the game first instead?
Game
Hey to everyone who finished the game after you beat the circus robot or whatever it is I can’t remember I didn’t play in a bit where do you go I can’t find the way point because buildings cover it up
Same Energy
I heard.. "nine ass"