@@AstronomicalASMR I meant to say that I agree and that I too like the idea he doesn't know that which in that case yes It does make charlie a brave individual
1:47 Edward really loves Bella you can feel the anger in his voice when he is about to kill Jacob for kissing Bella. That is definitely true love right there.
Sometimes I wonder if a millionaire like Mormon Stephenie Meyer could finally realized that a woman can make her own way in the world without a man if the man admires her for it and good for him but he still has his own choice just like a woman should have her own choice I think the Native American tribe should sue Stephanie for thinking she can just use a tribe in the area she grew up in without any real consequences
I am pretty sure imprinting is just something Stephanie made up for the poor Native American QUILEUTE Tribes just thinking that she could do that for her own profit
Did you know, in the eclipse book, bella just takes the kiss, her body goes on lock down and she just stands there, once he’s finsihed he pecked her three to four times, then Bella says “Are you done?” Then jAcob replies yes, and then he gets punched lol
And that was after she tried fighting him off for a minute or so too. He assaulted her and then everyone took his side. Except Edward. That's when I changed teams from Jake to Edward
I realize something like couple months ago and now its my favorite thing he says "If you ever touch her against her will again" that just shows his love
Sooo are we ignoring the fact that Charlie could clearly seen Edward eyes practically glowing golden? Like oh yeah that’s a normal eye color. He’s averagely pale nothing weird about him at all. Like tf? No.
I love how everyone is siding with Jacob even tho he literally assaults her in the books and is forcing a kiss on her in this scene, like yall are just outting yourselves as r@p1st enablers and apoligists.
A kiss is not an assault. Not even close to the trauma of how violating sexual touch/penetration really is. An assault gives you PTSD for years. It’s very insensitive to compare the two. AND he stopped kissing her when she jerked away. This comment is just for likes/attention.
@@TheBoneVampireit's incredible how wrong this is. He kissed her, without her consent and he doesn't jerk away, he keeps kissing her until he's done. It's even worse in the books, she tried to push him off her and he still won't stop.
@@TheBoneVampireby law and definition it is sexual assault. There are different levels to everything. How insensitive of you to downplay that. “any sexual activity performed without permission constitutes sexual assault. This can include kissing, exhibitionism…etc”
@@cianne1488 kissing someone without asking first is assault? No officer would arrest someone for that. Lol yeah ok. Maybe if he kept going after she pushed him away you could come close to your argument being legit. But he didn’t. And again, it’s not even close to penetration or touching in certain areas. Ask me how I know. And move on.
People wondering if they would choose Jacob or Edward, I would choose to live with my mom in Jacksonville lol and probably would make up something to protect my dad
if you are in a committed relationship, even if there is someone else you may have some attraction to, would you be comfortable with that person forcing a kiss on you? because I mean it's all fiction and playing on fantasies and what not for story's sake, but on the other hand, not sure if the messaging sent to the target audience wasn't thought out properly, normalizing this, but then again Bella reacted accordingly ......... but i digress, the acting is funny as hell
I love Edward more in this scene when he knows that bella is a lill bit confused about jacob he respects her decision and respects what she choose he said "wait for her to say the words" that means he knew she's also attracted to jacob and he didn't get mad about this..❤️
he literally assaults her and it’s downplayed by the characters. In the book i hate charlies reaction even more. Like who’s father laughs at their daughter getting assaulted?
I mean he's certainly the warmest option, but I'm not sure if he's the best option. He's kinda narcissistic imo. Maybe a bit imature. Good friend material but not serious relationship material. But then in the last two movies he seemed far more level headed and mature
@@oxo1Oh please, Bella was always playing with his feelings. It was far more evident in the book that she was in love with Jacob, and pictured a life with him. She described him as her “sun”. He brought happiness to her in a way Edward just couldn’t. They had a pure love that’s natural, her and Edward were intense, painful, and all consuming.
@@firstthings_first9828 That's cute, but it still doesn't give him the right to kiss her without her consent. In fact, all three of them suck. Bella doesn't need a hundred dudes to fight over her, she needs therapy. They all do
I never knew how Jacob is like in the books but as much as I love him, I can agree that what he didn't isn't exactly right because she does like Edward and he should take the hint. But then again idk why but I keep liking Jacob 😭I've been team Jacob day 1. Imagine if the story was reversed and it was written where it was Bella and Jacob and not Edward and Bella, imagine how big that would be
In the books he literally holds her against him and when she tries to push him away and fight him off, he holds her tighter. She then goes slack and just doesn't respond. After she punches him, he laughs at her and says "it's not my fault you broke your hand. You should have known better." And then Charlie takes Jake's side. That's the moment I became team Edward from Team Jacob.
I am always gonna love Twilight series, but the most stupid part of the story in my opinion was how Jacob was all about Bella and he shifted it to her daughter in last movie..i mean this was ridiculous..i wish Meyer wrote it differently.
dontcha hate it when you think you love a girl, but it turns out you're just in love with her unborn baby. but i guess now you can share! you get the baby and the 100 year old murderer gets the teenager! yay happy endings!
I feel so much for Jacob, although yes his behaviour and trying to impose his belief on Bella is plain toxic. It's hard to accept even out of love that the one you love chose something else than you. It's hard when you believe that they are just not admitting their feelings for you just so they could commit to their decision to choose something else. With a lot of suffering and self-control, (at 24yo) I managed to live with that, to force myself to be respectful to the one I love, so I would understand and forgive Jacob (at 17yo) for being unable to do it.
He literally assaulted her in the books and clearly he forces a kiss on her in the movies, im kinda shocked that people still love Jacob even with knowing about this scene. Yall need some psychological help for this way of thinking. Whether the story is fictional or not, your mindsets and how you go about it is NOT
Are people defending Jacob pkay? I mean okay, he kissed her out of desperation but should've stopped the second he felt her pulling away. Also, he manipulated her into kissing him later on saying he would get himseld unalived bc she got engaged😭 like yes he is cute. I see he is very attractive now which I didnt 13 years ago when I was 11 but he is so immature and the worst option. Edward was always respectful and no you can't compare him watching Bella sleep with jacob forcing a kiss lol.
She led him on for years…. Don’t know why she acts all innocent. No he shouldn’t of kissed her then but at the same time she should have made things clear from the get go. She practically uses Jacob and it really pisses me off. Edward is a classic case of an extremely abusive partner. He controls her, gaslights and manipulates her and tries to kill himself and puts bella in danger. Jacob can be irritating but at least it seems he actually did care for her whereas bella seemed more like a consolation prize for edward.
Jacob was just as bad LMAO. 😂 He manipulates Bella, using her feelings of guilt to make her feel sorry for him, even gaslighting her into kissing him, and is trying to force himself on Bella in the scene above.
@@Rosesnthorns13 i did, and she only caught feelings for jacob in New Moon, and she got back with edward at the end. It was pretty clear she and edward were solid at that point
I thought Jacob was better I take it back he's just as bad as Edward in the abusive category but I like Bella and Angela no shipping justbthe characters so whatevs
I don't think edward is abusive. He didn't get angry that jacob kissed bella. He got angry because he kissed bella without her consent. "I'll kill you if you ever touch her against her will". I dont think that was toxic or abusive
Very powerful scene, Jacob making a pure statement by telling the truth and proving that a life with him doesn’t have to be a life of cover ups etc to protect Charlie
Take notes, all you vampire boyfriends out there, if your girlfriend punches a wolf boy for kissing her, that needs to be enough grounds for you to back the heck away because she got this, she’s not the fragile human the vampire that wanted to kill her thought she was, granted, she’s also not the girl boss I’m probably unwittingly making her out to be, but still.
I love Charlie in this bit. Even though he doesn’t know it, he legit stopped a vampire and a werewolf from fighting to the death, with no fear at all.
But he doesn't know that lol which makes him more brave
@@jaxban4858 Literally what the dude said in the comment but ok
@@AstronomicalASMR I meant to say that I agree and that I too like the idea he doesn't know that which in that case yes It does make charlie a brave individual
He’s despicable and uncharacteristic in the books. He didn’t acknowledge that bella broke her hand and congratulated Jacob on kissing her??
In the books he picks Jacob's side even though he had literally assaulted his daughter.
“The. She broke her hand….. punch my face” that line always makes me laugh
True 😂
😂😂😂
1:55 "Wait for her to say the words" YES EDWARD YES
My favorite thing is edward doesnt say "if you ever touch her again" he says "if you ever touch her AGAINST HER WILL again"
Man! Edward has raised the bar so high 🥺
Thats exactly why I keep thinking about this scene xD
Edward has already raised the Standards!!
Edward was always very mature and understanding. Even being in midst of this complex triangle and knowing that Bella has some feelings for Jake
That's how true love really works.He's worried about her feelings over his own.Twilight's a masterpiece ♥️
No one is talking about the way she punched him and almost broke her hand but he just stood there like no pain at all.
Also team Jacob for life
Yeah cuz he's a werewolf lol
Well to be fair compared to what happened to her in the end of the first movie a broken hand isn't that horrible
@@leannegibbs1064 what when she gets a big smooch from Jacob and doesn’t break her hand 😝 jk I know what you mean and can agree😔
@@Asianlover012 I'm innnnnnn
1:47 Edward really loves Bella you can feel the anger in his voice when he is about to kill Jacob for kissing Bella. That is definitely true love right there.
Cap
@@lilbubiesetread the books. Jacob is 20x worse and immature.
I like how after she punched him and broke her hand, she literally stood there like there was no pain 😂
Thats because jacob is shapeshifter durable
@@allunjajerrynkanavaWhat?
I meant shapeshifters are more durable than humans in terms of durability
I like this scene a lot better in the movie than the book. 😭😂
samee why was edward so calm in the book? 😭
Who’s here from the bad lip reading on IG
Lmaoo me
🤚
Me too lol
HUH??
Bro so weird! Yes. We all are! XD
What I find amazing is Edward isn’t mad Bella and Jacob kissed. He’s mad that he kissed her against her will. Best bf ever 🥹
Fr I love how protective he is of Bella
2:16 Charlie's face is so hilarious when Jacob told him that he kissed Bella looks like it's saying wow you finally kissed my daughter.😂😂😂
Jacob: “I don’t buy it!”
Bella: “what don’t you buy?!”
Me: I don’t buy shirts, and I don’t believe in them, so stop asking!
😂what don't you buy ?
😂😂😂
Ah, Twilight. The cautionary tale of abusive and manipulative relationships.
Jacob ends up with a literal newborn baby.
Ah, women. Loved them a few years ago now have negative IQ pRoNounS in the bio and call everything you liked as a kid "aBusiVe and "tOxiC" 🤡
Cautionary tale? Twilight made abusive relationships look highly appealing.
Sometimes I wonder if a millionaire like Mormon Stephenie Meyer could finally realized that a woman can make her own way in the world without a man if the man admires her for it and good for him but he still has his own choice just like a woman should have her own choice I think the Native American tribe should sue Stephanie for thinking she can just use a tribe in the area she grew up in without any real consequences
I am pretty sure imprinting is just something Stephanie made up for the poor Native American QUILEUTE Tribes just thinking that she could do that for her own profit
Edward first official supporter of No means No😂
Everyone looked their best in this movie out of all of them
Him: she broke her hand. “….” Punching my face..
Jacob is like: I'm not a corpse, Bella, I'm clearly a better option.
Did you know, in the eclipse book, bella just takes the kiss, her body goes on lock down and she just stands there, once he’s finsihed he pecked her three to four times, then Bella says “Are you done?” Then jAcob replies yes, and then he gets punched lol
And that was after she tried fighting him off for a minute or so too. He assaulted her and then everyone took his side. Except Edward. That's when I changed teams from Jake to Edward
I know right, I am team Edward but, Jacob is kinda fine, ngl
@@EveyWells If it weren't for the kiss, I would be team Jacob
“I kissed Bella & she broke her hand punching my face” 😂😂
“Total misunderstanding”😭
"Next time use a crowbar or baseball bat" close enough to the book quote
@Vee fenty I sle-pt with your man
This was the best line that stood out in the book for me as it was so funny, seeing it in the movies makes it 1000x funnier XD
I realize something like couple months ago and now its my favorite thing he says "If you ever touch her against her will again" that just shows his love
Imagine two handsome guys fighting over you
nah it’s gross machismo bs would rather they didn’t
Ikr 😂😭
@@kimberlym1183 Don't worry, you'd never experience it anyway
I'd cringe
@@Daniel-ro8tq lol
Is anyone gonna talk about how he pushes her to say something she doesn’t want to and kisses her without consent 😭😭😭
Thats kinda hot, ngl.
@@hahahaaha7208 ew
@@hahahaaha7208 you have severe problems
@@hahahaaha7208 ?
@@hahahaaha7208 yikes lmao
This is giving “pick me, choose me, love me.” 😭
Twilight movies always take me back to another time 🌧️🥹😊😊🌧️☕
yeah it's called me giving my 3 ft. long new moon jacob poster a quick kiss before school every day 🐺❤
That "thump" was the funniest thing in this scene.
I love this scene not cause of Edward, Jacob... Not even Bella. It's cause of Charlie thinking he could handle that
Bro I swear Jacob is literally lying to Bella.
He isn’t made of blood and flesh, he is made of stone and steel 🗿
😂yes 😂
Sooo are we ignoring the fact that Charlie could clearly seen Edward eyes practically glowing golden? Like oh yeah that’s a normal eye color. He’s averagely pale nothing weird about him at all. Like tf? No.
A lot of people are pale. Maybe he didn't directly look into his eyes.
I love how everyone is siding with Jacob even tho he literally assaults her in the books and is forcing a kiss on her in this scene, like yall are just outting yourselves as r@p1st enablers and apoligists.
please as if edward is at all better than
@@erikita2095Bella would have been better off leaving both of them to go to college in Jacksonville and find someone else after getting therapy lol.
@@erikita2095edward is sm better than jacob in so many ways
YES
I always find it funny how Bella ends up hurting herself by punching Jaccob. Just my wicked sense of humour 😂😂😂
"Dont misunderstandç
Me:...how can we not misunderstand WHEN YOU SAY IT LIKE THAT
"Fine, and she will."
Got shivers from that
This isn’t an “unrequited love” scene it’s an assault scene and should be represented as such.
A kiss is not an assault. Not even close to the trauma of how violating sexual touch/penetration really is. An assault gives you PTSD for years. It’s very insensitive to compare the two.
AND he stopped kissing her when she jerked away. This comment is just for likes/attention.
@@TheBoneVampireit's incredible how wrong this is. He kissed her, without her consent and he doesn't jerk away, he keeps kissing her until he's done. It's even worse in the books, she tried to push him off her and he still won't stop.
@@TheBoneVampireby law and definition it is sexual assault. There are different levels to everything. How insensitive of you to downplay that. “any sexual activity performed without permission constitutes sexual assault. This can include kissing, exhibitionism…etc”
@@cianne1488 kissing someone without asking first is assault? No officer would arrest someone for that. Lol yeah ok. Maybe if he kept going after she pushed him away you could come close to your argument being legit. But he didn’t. And again, it’s not even close to penetration or touching in certain areas. Ask me how I know. And move on.
@@TheBoneVampire Are you completely daft?????
People wondering if they would choose Jacob or Edward, I would choose to live with my mom in Jacksonville lol and probably would make up something to protect my dad
Bro☠️
Facts lmao i would skip both of them since they’re both manipulative as hell
I love the wolf men ❤️
2:10 Charlie's face😂❤
Dude is a freaking wolf. How badass is that... and yet he's all mushy and wimpy when he talks to her. Makes me sick!
“Simple misunderstanding Mr. Swan but you may need to get her an ice pack & Ibuprofen” lolol
if you are in a committed relationship, even if there is someone else you may have some attraction to, would you be comfortable with that person forcing a kiss on you? because I mean it's all fiction and playing on fantasies and what not for story's sake, but on the other hand, not sure if the messaging sent to the target audience wasn't thought out properly, normalizing this, but then again Bella reacted accordingly ......... but i digress, the acting is funny as hell
I love Edward more in this scene when he knows that bella is a lill bit confused about jacob he respects her decision and respects what she choose he said "wait for her to say the words" that means he knew she's also attracted to jacob and he didn't get mad about this..❤️
he literally assaults her and it’s downplayed by the characters. In the book i hate charlies reaction even more. Like who’s father laughs at their daughter getting assaulted?
I’m a lesbian and I would have chosen Jacob. He’s such a better option.
Dude is literally the alpha... Like c'mon.
I mean he's certainly the warmest option, but I'm not sure if he's the best option. He's kinda narcissistic imo. Maybe a bit imature. Good friend material but not serious relationship material. But then in the last two movies he seemed far more level headed and mature
It's funny how you commented this in a scene where Jacob literally assaults Bella.
@@oxo1Oh please, Bella was always playing with his feelings. It was far more evident in the book that she was in love with Jacob, and pictured a life with him. She described him as her “sun”. He brought happiness to her in a way Edward just couldn’t. They had a pure love that’s natural, her and Edward were intense, painful, and all consuming.
@@firstthings_first9828 That's cute, but it still doesn't give him the right to kiss her without her consent. In fact, all three of them suck. Bella doesn't need a hundred dudes to fight over her, she needs therapy. They all do
I never knew how Jacob is like in the books but as much as I love him, I can agree that what he didn't isn't exactly right because she does like Edward and he should take the hint. But then again idk why but I keep liking Jacob 😭I've been team Jacob day 1. Imagine if the story was reversed and it was written where it was Bella and Jacob and not Edward and Bella, imagine how big that would be
In the books he literally holds her against him and when she tries to push him away and fight him off, he holds her tighter. She then goes slack and just doesn't respond. After she punches him, he laughs at her and says "it's not my fault you broke your hand. You should have known better." And then Charlie takes Jake's side. That's the moment I became team Edward from Team Jacob.
@@gillibean.1075 Team Edward all the way bruh
@@andreasandreas2728Team Jacob
Team Jacob
Damn imagine you the dad and you just see 2 dudes fighting over your daughter 😂
Literally 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
THE JUMPING-❤️
Bella's dad so Brave Like Mulan & Mushu
Both Jake and Edward care about her so damn much they broke it up immediately for Charlie out of pure respect for family.
Honorable to say the least.
I am always gonna love Twilight series, but the most stupid part of the story in my opinion was how Jacob was all about Bella and he shifted it to her daughter in last movie..i mean this was ridiculous..i wish Meyer wrote it differently.
This is so bad, why do I love this ❤
Where is the huh part supposed to be?
1:05
Her said a bad thing to me😂
HUH?!
U feel something else for me you won't admit ittt 🙃
dontcha hate it when you think you love a girl, but it turns out you're just in love with her unborn baby.
but i guess now you can share! you get the baby and the 100 year old murderer gets the teenager!
yay happy endings!
Team Edward forever
Same!
Huh?
I feel so much for Jacob, although yes his behaviour and trying to impose his belief on Bella is plain toxic. It's hard to accept even out of love that the one you love chose something else than you. It's hard when you believe that they are just not admitting their feelings for you just so they could commit to their decision to choose something else. With a lot of suffering and self-control, (at 24yo) I managed to live with that, to force myself to be respectful to the one I love, so I would understand and forgive Jacob (at 17yo) for being unable to do it.
He literally assaulted her in the books and clearly he forces a kiss on her in the movies, im kinda shocked that people still love Jacob even with knowing about this scene. Yall need some psychological help for this way of thinking. Whether the story is fictional or not, your mindsets and how you go about it is NOT
There is no way that the movie was this bad
It is.
Are people defending Jacob pkay? I mean okay, he kissed her out of desperation but should've stopped the second he felt her pulling away. Also, he manipulated her into kissing him later on saying he would get himseld unalived bc she got engaged😭 like yes he is cute. I see he is very attractive now which I didnt 13 years ago when I was 11 but he is so immature and the worst option. Edward was always respectful and no you can't compare him watching Bella sleep with jacob forcing a kiss lol.
She led him on for years…. Don’t know why she acts all innocent. No he shouldn’t of kissed her then but at the same time she should have made things clear from the get go. She practically uses Jacob and it really pisses me off. Edward is a classic case of an extremely abusive partner. He controls her, gaslights and manipulates her and tries to kill himself and puts bella in danger. Jacob can be irritating but at least it seems he actually did care for her whereas bella seemed more like a consolation prize for edward.
Jacob was just as bad LMAO. 😂 He manipulates Bella, using her feelings of guilt to make her feel sorry for him, even gaslighting her into kissing him, and is trying to force himself on Bella in the scene above.
She didn't lead him on for that long lol as she made it clear to jacob multiple times she's with Edward and loves him.
@@kaveenasingsandcosplays3441 no she did not have y a read the books
@@Rosesnthorns13 i did, and she only caught feelings for jacob in New Moon, and she got back with edward at the end. It was pretty clear she and edward were solid at that point
Team edward
I remember watching this back in high school Jacob has a huge crush on her
I thought Jacob was better I take it back he's just as bad as Edward in the abusive category but I like Bella and Angela no shipping justbthe characters so whatevs
I don't think edward is abusive. He didn't get angry that jacob kissed bella. He got angry because he kissed bella without her consent. "I'll kill you if you ever touch her against her will". I dont think that was toxic or abusive
That's honesty! 💕🤷♀️ *Charly's face looks like "I don't understand anything but I'm really worried about you, guys.* 🥰🍀🧿 📿⚖️🎋🕯🙏
“Huhhh” - tiktok 😂
𝔼 𝕥𝕦✨𝕛😍𝕦✨𝕛𝕥𝕖𝕦𝕪𝕣𝕣𝕜𝕖𝕦✨𝕚𝕪𝕖𝕓𝕟𝕨𝕙𝕙𝕣𝕪✨𝕪✨𝕪 ℝ𝕋 𝕪✨𝕨𝕖 𝕙𝕖𝕥✨𝕦✨𝕚𝕦❤❤❤❤❤❤❤😂😂😂😢😢😢😢😮😮😮😅😅😅😅😅
TEAM JACOB FOR EVER
Very powerful scene, Jacob making a pure statement by telling the truth and proving that a life with him doesn’t have to be a life of cover ups etc to protect Charlie
1:32 punch 🤜
which movie is this is this eclipse?
🐀 🐀 🐀 came here after Jens post to hear the sound again ✨
I love this
tOtAl MiSuNdErStAnDiNg
Came here from a Facebook video
"Huh?"
1:23
What Charlie was thinking when he broke them apart:
Why is this one soo cold and the other soo hot ???
jacob: i kissed bella...
charlie: just wait a minit hrere... I have to find my shotgun...
"Wait for her to say the words" 🔥
The crickets in the background 💀
Gosh she could have asked her if she was okay instead of just following her
Charlie,seth,carlisle, wolf pack boys are some of the more sensible 1s in this franchide..
Hangi film
After renesmee was born I never see jacob and bella's friendship anymore🫤
Esme Cullen is very Beautiful 😍😍😈❤️❤️
I love
Sharkboy would never.
i think it is sweet
I’m good at lip reading
You have to solve something yes you are
“Total misunderstanding” 💀
“How come everybody whispers in these movies?”
-Butt-Head
But that's very sad to see how bella is agreed to kisd jacob even edward is with him and he loves him a lot 😓
Is this SA?
🤣🤣🤣🤣 damn kiss her she broke her hand
😂😂😂
When she hurt her hand
Take notes, all you vampire boyfriends out there, if your girlfriend punches a wolf boy for kissing her, that needs to be enough grounds for you to back the heck away because she got this, she’s not the fragile human the vampire that wanted to kill her thought she was, granted, she’s also not the girl boss I’m probably unwittingly making her out to be, but still.
Huh?? 😭
HUHHH
1:45-1:46 1:48
"Haa?! Haaa?! HAAAAAAA?!"
1:32 😂💀
Oops LOL!!!!