Per his letter to Pospelova “..the thought of not being able to get closer to the music is killing me. It will flicker and then disappear like the elusive bluebird...” In this last recital recorded 6 days before his death (he knew that his days were numbered per his documentary), it seems that he was beyond being close to the music; he had become music… it is truly unforgettable performance - so intoxicating!
This is the best interpretation of Chopin´s ballades. Invincible performance and the emotions are incredible. Thank you maestro for this recordning. Rest in peace
Султанова послушайте. И тогда поймёте, что заявление о том, что современные исполнители не могут исполнять так же глубоко Шопена выглядит неубедительно. Да, эмоции здесь переполняют, но и грязи достаточно, извините. Султанов безупречен в этом отношении.
@@user-yq3on8vx3c Utálom a steril interpretációt. Hallottam Fischer Annie-t élőben, amikor gyerek voltam - és többször melléütött. Ettől még az egyik legnagyobb Beethoven játékos volt a világon.
Straordinarie interpretazioni, piene di gusto e di originalità...straordinaria la prima Ballata,poi, piena di passione raggiante, come dovrebbe essere, mentre oggi la eseguono come un pezzo di marmo. Grande scuola quella dei Neuhaus.
Mi associo, dott. Pelizzoli, straordinario davvero. Mi riempie di tristezza il pensare che fine ha fatto pochi giorni dopo questo fantastico concerto...ma perchè??? ci sono persone che non dovrebbero morire mai. Grazie a Dio resta la loro musica.
Великолепно. Восторг. В этом видео я открыл для себя нового пианиста, необычайно красиво, с филигранной выразительностью исполняющего музыкальные шедевры.
Imagine, if he had had more years......but it would have had to be bearable for him. This is six days before his departure - and the concert was very difficult for him, but we, his loving audience, cannot detect that.
His performance catches my ears. This is one of my favorite Chopin Ballades interpertation, very musical just like Arthur Rubinstein. I knew him from his video of playing Scribian Etude op42 no5 in 1966. It was also an astonishing performance.
The Ballad No. 2 is so gorgeous! An evening romance: Breathtaking!.... as viewed through the windows of my childhood home in the country - with an accessible grand in the livingroom!😍 It leaves me longing!💔
처음 이 연주를 접하고서 2년은 된 것 같지만 여전히 그 매력을 설명하기 힘든 것 같습니다. 어쩌면 아직 제대로 체감하지 못 한 걸지도 모릅니다. 아마도 그의 생애 마지막 리사이틀이라는 연주 외적인 이유 때문에 이 연주의 내적인 것 들에 집중 못 한 것 같습니다. 본래라면 세심하고 그리워하는, 애절하고 서글픈 쇼팽의 곡을 그는 이토록 거칠고 격분되게, 억울하고 비참해 분노섞인 슬픔을 목이 터져라 소리지르며 토로해내는 듯 합니다. 한 개인의 사상에 반하는 세상에 반론하고 싶어하지만 그러지 못 하는 현실과 현재에 절망하는 그런 감정이 느껴져옵니다. 이는 아쉬케나지, 폴리니, 치메르만, 조성진 혹은 라플란테와 같은 연주자와 사뭇 다른 모습입니다. 작품의 아비인 작자를 극진히 배려해주는 그들과 다르게 마치 호로비츠처럼, 자신의 음악을 타인의 말을 빌려 세상에 현현시킵니다. 해석의 과정에서 그는 자신의 세계로 작품을 납치해 데려갑니다. 저의 견해로써는, 이 연주가 본래의 의도를 품고 있다고는 말 못하겠습니다만, 그것 이상으로 개인의 정체성을 강하고 명확하게 주장하는 그 모습이 너무나도 경이롭습니다. 사랑스럽습니다. 신경을 자극시켜줍니다. 같은 경지에 다다르도록 삶의 의욕을 불어넣어줍니다. 비록 그의 억울한 목소리에 동의하지 못 한다 해도 존중해주길 바라는 마음입니다.
I'm sure these are my very favourite ballades. I've listened to many other recordings: richter, kissin, wang, argerich, busoni, deyanova, horowitz and many others! I just can just finally feel them on myself. Not just hear music or hear chopin. I think this is how liszt played. I don't mind mistakes. It is better to hear them with this recording, than without hearing anything! (Hamelin's are my fav too!)
Bien que je sois personnellement heureux d’entendre les 4 ballades de Chopin jouées ainsi, je comprends le commentaire de Jean-Louis. C’est pourquoi il est heureux qu’il existe de nombreuses versions de ces œuvres. Neuhaus plaira à certains et pas à d’autres. J’aime son engagement total (comme celui d’Alfred Cortot), qu’importe les fausses notes qui sont le pendant de cet engagement.
OMG the coda of the F minor ballade is astounding... I almost fell of my chair listening to it!!!!!! I love how he dramatically prolongs the fermata long before the coda...thank you for this treasure
Гениально прекрасно! Нет слов,9 чтобы выразить восхищение перед таким шопеновским духом исполнения! Первая Баллада--как целая жизнь, прожитая на сцене! 🌹🌹🌹
What has happened to his son? It seems a sad story through the generations who ended up in a world no longer receptive of their legacy. Substance is no longer recognized or in demand these days. Passionate and vulnerable playing has been replaced with a facade.
I believe his son Stanislav Bunin was involved in an accident in 2013 after which he stopped performing. He may return to performing this fall 2023 according to Japanese media.
Bunin's father ‼ ‼ ✴⤴Buninの解釈のセンスはお父様譲りだと思います。(因みにお祖父様は似ていないと思います)お二人がBig name 過ぎて最盛期の短かったBuninは色々言われますが、Chopinに関しては唯一無二の解釈者だと思います。Buninは最近、『死』について考えるようになったと言っていましたが、恐らくお父様の亡くなられた年齢を越えてそのように感じるのだろうな…と思っています。Bunin には生きついる限りpianistでいて欲しいです✨🎶
5:34 ...... o God ..... all what Neuhaus is giving here ...... singing , singing ...... howling ...... despair of a ruined life .... all guts ...... this is a fantastic moment ........ (and Horowitz seeming suddenly so childish ...)
Ruined life? He was very succesful - a brilliant musician - loved by his lovable dad - but what ailed him? Why was he in hospital for ten days? Why was he unsure, if he would still be alive on the day of this concert? He certainly doesn´t sound weakened, but the circumstances are told to have been very difficult... but what circumstances? It´s extremely difficult to find details about what really went on.
.... oh my dawg .... wind in the skies.... howling, howling .... like a wounded animal ..... is it a satanic owl? ...... a hellhound? ...... a Donald taking a desperate Dump? ...... no, it's Fritzle...... der mit 'ner Meise .... being sooooo melodramatic yet again ........ singing, singing ...... whining, whining .... howling like the devil's wind in the skies ........ all guts splattering out .... Dude, take a breath. Relax. Make complete sentences. Give the world a break.
@@Pogouldangeliwitz Is it my fault if this music is dramatic, and you do not perceive it ? And for your information, Neuhaus committed suicide a short time after this recital. So, I DO NOT HAVE THE SLIGHTEST INTENTION TO "relax". And not "taking a breath". And don't tell me how to write or not to write. Short sentences are efficient, like this one : Moron.
Финал (с заглавной буквы)в первой балладе сЫграна (с «ы» и СЛИТНО) так ЗАПЯТАЯ как надо ТИРЕ без всяких горовИцЕвских (ЕСЛИ УЖ) соплей. П.С. Ты где, Жека, у Горовица сопли видел, безграмотный ты м...к!
@@minister_of_films2635agree. For example more details of his biography? (How the hell did he die, i want to know. There are multiple rumours around. I NEED TRUTH)
Знаете, однажды Лист погасил свет , стал играть музыку Шопена. Многие не догадались, что это Лист...Не все, конечно.) Лист сказал :"Я могу сыграть, как Шопен. А сможет ли Шопен сыграть , как Лист?" Музыка Шопена гениальна, а Лист был не только композитором, но и гениальным исполнителем . Мог сыграть практически любую музыку очень хорошо.
Когда слышишь ТАКОЕ, как-то чрезвычайно мелко говорить о каких-то там "фальшивых нотах". "Экзистенц-минимум" более чем соблюдён. А какие-то непопадания... да чёрт с ними. Так и Корто можно обвинить в "плохой технике". Между тем быть большим пианистом, не будучи виртуозом, невозможно. Просто не всех техника стабильная. Да, возможно, не завоевал бы С. Нейгауз "место на конкурсе", по крайней мере - высокое. Ну и что???
@@user-eu3bt4ji4k Ему, по счастью, операцию удачно сделали, и рука полностью восстановила работоспособность. Не знаю, что это было, вроде не травма. У его папы был полиневрит и два пальца перестали слушаться, но он на операцию не решился. Что-то фамильная какая-то у них с правой рукой проблема.
Artistic timing....incredible......spirit
Spirit agree..
Van Cliburn guy?
@@epicaunleashed8764 yes
윤찬림 고마워!! 좋은 음악소개, 인생을 살아가는 태도를 알개해줘서 .. 내평생에 직접 만나서 얘기 할수 없지만..전하고 싶었어. 영.혼,육이 건강하길 기도해.
I agree with you!
31:56 this is so desperate. Quite impossible to hear and to bear. Beautiful. Morbid. Earth life.
Per his letter to Pospelova “..the thought of not being able to get closer to the music is killing me. It will flicker and then disappear like the elusive bluebird...” In this last recital recorded 6 days before his death (he knew that his days were numbered per his documentary), it seems that he was beyond being close to the music; he had become music… it is truly unforgettable performance - so intoxicating!
What poetic words!
Какое высокое, одухотворенное исполнение. Пронзило.
А нельзя ли ссылку на этот документальный фильм?И может быть ещё его выступления.
He puts all his feelings in this. So passionate...
This is the best interpretation of Chopin´s ballades. Invincible performance and the emotions are incredible. Thank you maestro for this recordning. Rest in peace
peace***
so skilled I wonder why he is not as famous as the other pianists at his time.
😀
No.1 in G minor- 0:00
No.2 in F Major- 8:41
No.3 in Ab Major- 16:07
No.4 in F minor- 23:31
Jaw-dropping,. Just on another level; nothing like I hear from today's big record label pianists or competition winners.
of course not
After this you'll no longer need to listen to today's pianists ( and even think of them).
Султанова послушайте. И тогда поймёте, что заявление о том, что современные исполнители не могут исполнять так же глубоко Шопена выглядит неубедительно. Да, эмоции здесь переполняют, но и грязи достаточно, извините. Султанов безупречен в этом отношении.
@@user-yq3on8vx3c Utálom a steril interpretációt. Hallottam Fischer Annie-t élőben, amikor gyerek voltam - és többször melléütött. Ettől még az egyik legnagyobb Beethoven játékos volt a világon.
Straordinarie interpretazioni, piene di gusto e di originalità...straordinaria la prima Ballata,poi, piena di passione raggiante, come dovrebbe essere, mentre oggi la eseguono come un pezzo di marmo.
Grande scuola quella dei Neuhaus.
Mi associo, dott. Pelizzoli, straordinario davvero. Mi riempie di tristezza il pensare che fine ha fatto pochi giorni dopo questo fantastico concerto...ma perchè??? ci sono persone che non dovrebbero morire mai. Grazie a Dio resta la loro musica.
@@robertobeltrami6466 how did he die?
Великолепно. Восторг. В этом видео я открыл для себя нового пианиста, необычайно красиво, с филигранной выразительностью исполняющего музыкальные шедевры.
Imagine, if he had had more years......but it would have had to be bearable for him. This is six days before his departure - and the concert was very difficult for him, but we, his loving audience, cannot detect that.
His performance catches my ears. This is one of my favorite Chopin Ballades interpertation, very musical just like Arthur Rubinstein. I knew him from his video of playing Scribian Etude op42 no5 in 1966. It was also an astonishing performance.
Who do you think has the best recording of Scriabin 42/5
The Ballad No. 2 is so gorgeous! An evening romance: Breathtaking!.... as viewed through the windows of my childhood home in the country - with an accessible grand in the livingroom!😍 It leaves me longing!💔
yessß
처음 이 연주를 접하고서 2년은 된 것 같지만 여전히 그 매력을 설명하기 힘든 것 같습니다. 어쩌면 아직 제대로 체감하지 못 한 걸지도 모릅니다.
아마도 그의 생애 마지막 리사이틀이라는 연주 외적인 이유 때문에 이 연주의 내적인 것 들에 집중 못 한 것 같습니다.
본래라면 세심하고 그리워하는, 애절하고 서글픈 쇼팽의 곡을 그는 이토록 거칠고 격분되게, 억울하고 비참해 분노섞인 슬픔을 목이 터져라 소리지르며 토로해내는 듯 합니다.
한 개인의 사상에 반하는 세상에 반론하고 싶어하지만 그러지 못 하는 현실과 현재에 절망하는 그런 감정이 느껴져옵니다. 이는 아쉬케나지, 폴리니, 치메르만, 조성진 혹은 라플란테와 같은 연주자와 사뭇 다른 모습입니다. 작품의 아비인 작자를 극진히 배려해주는 그들과 다르게 마치 호로비츠처럼, 자신의 음악을 타인의 말을 빌려 세상에 현현시킵니다. 해석의 과정에서 그는 자신의 세계로 작품을 납치해 데려갑니다.
저의 견해로써는, 이 연주가 본래의 의도를 품고 있다고는 말 못하겠습니다만, 그것 이상으로 개인의 정체성을 강하고 명확하게 주장하는 그 모습이 너무나도 경이롭습니다. 사랑스럽습니다. 신경을 자극시켜줍니다. 같은 경지에 다다르도록 삶의 의욕을 불어넣어줍니다.
비록 그의 억울한 목소리에 동의하지 못 한다 해도 존중해주길 바라는 마음입니다.
I'm sure these are my very favourite ballades. I've listened to many other recordings: richter, kissin, wang, argerich, busoni, deyanova, horowitz and many others!
I just can just finally feel them on myself. Not just hear music or hear chopin. I think this is how liszt played. I don't mind mistakes. It is better to hear them with this recording, than without hearing anything! (Hamelin's are my fav too!)
I like so much how Neuhaus play this ballades. My favourite version is by Bela Siki th-cam.com/video/dRfQyzWx1Jk/w-d-xo.html
His performance is off the charts
Bien que je sois personnellement heureux d’entendre les 4 ballades de Chopin jouées ainsi, je comprends le commentaire de Jean-Louis. C’est pourquoi il est heureux qu’il existe de nombreuses versions de ces œuvres. Neuhaus plaira à certains et pas à d’autres.
J’aime son engagement total (comme celui d’Alfred Cortot), qu’importe les fausses notes qui sont le pendant de cet engagement.
Лучшее исполнение Баллад! Гениальное!
Спасибо Станислав Генрихович! ❤❤❤❤❤
Сколько страсти!
Не страсти, а благородных утонченных возвышенных чувств, которые не соизмекримы с грубой страстью.
So beautiful
00:00
08:40
16:06
23:31
OMG the coda of the F minor ballade is astounding... I almost fell of my chair listening to it!!!!!! I love how he dramatically prolongs the fermata long before the coda...thank you for this treasure
Lol i read it as "I almost felt my chair listening to it!!"
Самое любимое исполнение Баллад Шопена..
Я Тоже
Гениально прекрасно! Нет слов,9 чтобы выразить восхищение перед таким шопеновским духом исполнения! Первая Баллада--как целая жизнь, прожитая на сцене! 🌹🌹🌹
Grazie per queste UNICHE Interpretazioni che ci hai lasciato Stanislav❤
Vorrei anch'io suonare come emozionalmente.
숨을안쉬고 크라이맥스로가는 연주!!! 와...듣는것만으로도 ♡뭐랄까 같이 호흡하며 듣게되니까..유산소운동한 느낌인가♡~~!
Beyond words!
Прекрасное исполнение. Гениальная музыка.
He perfectly plays built-up moments. I love him this
예상치도 못하셨을텐데 이 연주가 마지막 연주가 되었네요.아름답고도 애절하네요.좋은 연주 남겨주셔서 고맙고 올려주신 분께도 고마움 전합니다.
he died 6 days after this recital. RIP
Just discovered a cool pianist. What a marvelous performance
One of the last romantics
So beautiful! Thank´s for sharing! 🌹🌹🌹🌹
Very exciting music making !
awesome...
WOW.. BRAVA.....
Such mastery.
I suddenly hear a loving, singing voice in his playing of the melody in right hand.
🎶Magnificence!!🥰
Ever heard about insanity and beauty? Go to 7:00 and you can listen.
Фантастическое исполнение!
31:38 seconds of beauty in levitation
❤❤❤
Que Hombre tan intenso.
What has happened to his son? It seems a sad story through the generations who ended up in a world no longer receptive of their legacy. Substance is no longer recognized or in demand these days. Passionate and vulnerable playing has been replaced with a facade.
What a peceptive comment - thankyou.
I believe his son Stanislav Bunin was involved in an accident in 2013 after which he stopped performing. He may return to performing this fall 2023 according to Japanese media.
@@ocean_0602did he perform in this year?
@@dwacheopus Yes, he did. from Japan 🇯🇵
Bunin's father ‼ ‼ ✴⤴Buninの解釈のセンスはお父様譲りだと思います。(因みにお祖父様は似ていないと思います)お二人がBig name 過ぎて最盛期の短かったBuninは色々言われますが、Chopinに関しては唯一無二の解釈者だと思います。Buninは最近、『死』について考えるようになったと言っていましたが、恐らくお父様の亡くなられた年齢を越えてそのように感じるのだろうな…と思っています。Bunin には生きついる限りpianistでいて欲しいです✨🎶
5:34 ...... o God ..... all what Neuhaus is giving here ...... singing , singing ...... howling ...... despair of a ruined life .... all guts ...... this is a fantastic moment ........
(and Horowitz seeming suddenly so childish ...)
Ruined life? He was very succesful - a brilliant musician - loved by his lovable dad - but what ailed him? Why was he in hospital for ten days? Why was he unsure, if he would still be alive on the day of this concert? He certainly doesn´t sound weakened, but the circumstances are told to have been very difficult... but what circumstances? It´s extremely difficult to find details about what really went on.
.... oh my dawg .... wind in the skies.... howling, howling .... like a wounded animal ..... is it a satanic owl? ...... a hellhound? ...... a Donald taking a desperate Dump? ...... no, it's Fritzle...... der mit 'ner Meise .... being sooooo melodramatic yet again ........ singing, singing ...... whining, whining .... howling like the devil's wind in the skies ........ all guts splattering out ....
Dude, take a breath. Relax. Make complete sentences. Give the world a break.
@@Pogouldangeliwitz
Is it my fault if this music is dramatic, and you do not perceive it ?
And for your information, Neuhaus committed suicide a short time after this recital.
So, I DO NOT HAVE THE SLIGHTEST INTENTION TO "relax". And not "taking a breath".
And don't tell me how to write or not to write.
Short sentences are efficient, like this one :
Moron.
@@Fritz_Maisenbacher Growling, growling... 😝
@@Pogouldangeliwitz
Do not reverse the roles.
You were the "growling" man against my enthusiasm.
I didn't ask you anything.
crazy very crazy
crazy but wonderful....
Прекрасно!
Averne di questi pazzi
конфермация отлично.
кофермация в кульминации))
8:37 стоп. первая баллада закончилась ((...
Senti lui tutti gli altri scompaiono.
wat a very personal playing
финал в первой балладе с игран так как надо. Без всяких горовецовских соплей.
Финал (с заглавной буквы)в первой балладе сЫграна (с «ы» и СЛИТНО) так ЗАПЯТАЯ как надо ТИРЕ без всяких горовИцЕвских (ЕСЛИ УЖ) соплей. П.С. Ты где, Жека, у Горовица сопли видел, безграмотный ты м...к!
@@markdenemark7298Ха-ха. Вы разорвали его в клочья!
@@dwacheopus Кого? Нейгауза?
великий был пианист......
Аристократ во всём своём существе.
he died 4 days after this concert
Really ? From what ?
31:04 completely crazy ..... but when the day come I shall face my own death , I 'll understand , I think ....
@@Fritz_Maisenbacher killed himself because of depressions
@@BeethovenHD Really... Is that true?
@@asdfasdf-gm5uk yes
@@asdfasdf-gm5uk no
lUI E' il padre di Bunin che si chiamava Stanislv Neuhaus
!!!!!!
My teacher's teacher.
That's so cool, does your teacher have any stories about him?
@@minister_of_films2635agree. For example more details of his biography? (How the hell did he die, i want to know. There are multiple rumours around. I NEED TRUTH)
Hi Evgeny! have a nice day
That's where I came from too
What? I didn't get it
@@dwacheopus I think it was mentioned in an interview that this exact recording was his favorite
@@TheDirtyLuke thanks for that fast reply. I usually have to wait for several months...
@@dwacheopus haha, no worries :)
31:35
Oh…….
Такое впечатление, что 1-ю Балладу Шопена играет Лист ://
Знаете, однажды Лист погасил свет , стал играть музыку Шопена. Многие не догадались, что это Лист...Не все, конечно.) Лист сказал :"Я могу сыграть, как Шопен. А сможет ли Шопен сыграть , как Лист?" Музыка Шопена гениальна, а Лист был не только композитором, но и гениальным исполнителем . Мог сыграть практически любую музыку очень хорошо.
Very original, sensitive, music making. A bit erratic, but so what......
The errors add a lot to the dementia, despair and passion. I love them!
I agree, so what.... so genuine, so desolate, my heart aches every time i listen to it.
Erotic
#1 and #4 are otherwordly.....#3 felt rushed in too many spots
0:00
8:40
16:07
23:31
4:57 7:58 11:01 12:58 18:52 26:57
Когда слышишь ТАКОЕ, как-то чрезвычайно мелко говорить о каких-то там "фальшивых нотах".
"Экзистенц-минимум" более чем соблюдён. А какие-то непопадания... да чёрт с ними.
Так и Корто можно обвинить в "плохой технике". Между тем быть большим пианистом, не будучи виртуозом, невозможно.
Просто не всех техника стабильная. Да, возможно, не завоевал бы С. Нейгауз "место на конкурсе", по крайней мере - высокое. Ну и что???
Я где-то читала, если не ошибаюсь, что у него болела рука, была какая-то травма, но он все преодолел...
@Queeen q А что такое "экзистенц-минимум"?
@@user-eu3bt4ji4k Ему, по счастью, операцию удачно сделали, и рука полностью восстановила работоспособность. Не знаю, что это было, вроде не травма. У его папы был полиневрит и два пальца перестали слушаться, но он на операцию не решился. Что-то фамильная какая-то у них с правой рукой проблема.
@@nataliea.s.6173 видимо не решился потому, что боялся оказаться там же, где и Фрунзе. В те времена людям часто помогали уходить во время операций.
@@nataliea.s.6173 Минимум, ниже которого профессионалу опускаться уже нельзя.
Sadly at a point in his career when he hadn´t the technique and powers to do those works justice.However,wondeful details.
not bad for a music school...
Do you even realize how good this is.
Mon Dieu quel massacre dans la première ballade !!! N importe quoi ! du bruit. Ecoutez Cortot aucune fausses notes ici c en est truffé.
...Se si vuole essere originali,bisognerebbe almeno fare le note giuste....!!
He plays the notes righter than any pianist... Let your heart speak, not your mouth.
Ну такое себе конечно
Грязь есть, но страсти больше!
@@dwacheopus По моему ваши оценки ближе к Вам, а не Нейгаузу
НЕЙГАУЗ=ПОСРЕДСТВЕННОСТЬ
Провокация не удалась
@@user-vv4jk9kw2x Талантливый алкоголик, как и папа.