LA Galaxy’s Martín Cáceres Earns Silly Red Card After Entering Referee Review Area
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 1 ต.ค. 2024
- Andrew Wiebe and former FIFA referee Christina Unkel breakdown the latest controversial plays of the weekend.
#mls #referee #instantreplay
Subscribe to our channel for more soccer content: www.youtube.com...
Follow us on Twitter: / mls
Like us on Facebook: / mls
Follow us on Instagram: / mls
For more information about MLS, go to the league's official website: www.MLSsoccer.com
Not sure if I’m the only one but I love this series. I get excited when I see it on my feed.
I blame the coaching staff for this LA Galaxy squad. Players are undisciplined. Easily rattled by pressure. A well disciplined team will not get distracted. Win or lose, its a long season, many strong teams in this league. What next?
Blame the FO. They haven't done anything relevant since Donovan.
@@AthenaTheWolf58 What?
@@AthenaTheWolf58 They play in a small time college stadium an hour south of LA proper. And the coach blame everyone but himself.
Carson Milkyway. Must be all the mold and dust from their 5 championship trophies going to their heads.
@@AthenaTheWolf58 What did the FO do to get Donovan? The league manipulated their own system to get Donovan on the LAG as Donovan wanted to live in LA and the league saw it best for the league if he was in it.
The nerves of some St Louis fans to say the refs favoured the Sounders.. 😂😂
When you’re on a yellow, you should know better than to enter the referee’s review area and most certainly not touch the ref! Easy 2nd yellow!
Ref should warn in the first place
That was too much for red card
you should know better than to attempt communication with the higher life forms, especially as they contemplate the mysteries of the game. Get off it. He laid a hand on his shoulder to talk to him. The ref’s ego took over.
@@jacobcriss5624 Entering the review area alone is a cautionable offense with or without him touching the referee! So he really pushed his luck!
I’m not saying it’s not technically a rule (in the sense that any dissent is cautionable), but the referee has to use his judgment. “He entered the review area” is a charmin-soft reason for a second yellow. I really don’t care for the Galaxy, but this sort of call, compensating for lack of perceived authority (due to, frankly, inability to properly officiate) with ego calls, is all too common nowadays.
Im betting Cáceres and the other red card from the Galaxy was to avoid playing in El Tráfico
When was the protocol created/enacted for dealing with abuse that the referees don't hear? I know I had to deal with that a couple times back in my referee days; and although me and my crews handled it much as you described it, actually having a protocol would have make it a lot easier to work with the coaches and players - whenever something like that happens emotions go through the roof, but it might have helped, even a small amount. I'll put my old man stick away now.
As a referee, and one who started at 13 years, I've seen a lot of abuse in my days. There's a good NYT article about how many young referees along with vets are leaving the job in droves, and it shows. Assignors are always begging, and if you say yes, you're going to be doing games all day. This past recertification there was a large emphasis on referee and player abuse, so I hope this issue starts to get treated more seriously.
If you watched MLS Wrap Up on Apple TV you would’ve seen them describe their protocol on that situation. They spent a good 5 minutes or more talking about it
I've done hundreds of games. Unfortunately, I enforce the laws of the game.
My assessor gave me high grades. The assignors said I wouldn't go far calling all this stuff. Let them play.
Amazingly, my games were controlled and the temperature of the game held.
I see other games of loose rules and the games go bonkers. The refs are the ones they promoted that let them play. Lack of control, behavior, heat, etc.
A lot of young refs quit. I would AR for them and in the end, they just give up with parents and coaches. I tossed enough of the problem children. Leagues don't want it.
Retired now.
No mention of the uncalled foul on Guzan that will have him out 10-12 weeks? Cool cool cool...
9:00 unkel says you can be too close to play, very true. It seems strange but actually being farther from play 10-12 yards gives you a better view of most things
As a referee one of the most important things I've learned is: Angle matters more than proximity.
Now do the no-call on clearing out Guzan, the yellow on Giakoumakis for pulling out of a tackle and making minimal contact, the no-review on Etienne being brought down by the last man, the scissor tackle by Chanot that went unpunished, and the inexplicable 10 minutes of extra time in the second half after only 3 minutes in the first despite longer stoppages. Pineda was right about Fisher on the night.
I totally agree, entienne should’ve had a goal too, everyone thinks he offside but they paused the freeze frame after the ball was kicked, that’s why, he was completely onside i stg
I was at the game behind goal. It was brutal to watch up close. Red Bull also rammed into guzan last weekend. No yellows. Nothing.
You have to remember, Wiebe and team are employed by MLS/Apple so there is no way they are going to be 100% objective about the horrible state of refereeing we all see every week. Mark Geiger is GM of PRO, that should tell us all we need to know about how things are going to go.
@@brandonduncan6216 clear offside. I have absolutely no idea what u r talking about
@@oliveroren5627 you’re blind, he is within the line of last defender and on the replay they freeze frame it way after the ball was kicked
That Seattle one definitely should of been a red, could of broken roldans ankle or leg
Wasn't the only hard challenge on him that went unpunished in the game too
That was Alex Roldan, not Christian.
So we just breeze over and don't review Colorados 3 fouls in the box in the last 15 minutes of the game none of which were called? I assume because both teams are non factors at the moment.
SKC fan here. I was very surprised that none of those were called or sent for review and none were shown on this video.
Clint Dempsey got a red card for Evander’s elbow
Dude literally uses his arm to smash the dude in the face, she's like "not a weapon". WTF?
Are you a referee? Did you become a Fifa referee? Didn't think so
@@josiasroach5601 but you see, we all have eyeballs and can see him raise his arm and lead with it in his challenge in an abnormally high way, that smashed his face. So no I'm not an MLS ref. I did coach Select. I have a brain. Sorry yours was castrated.
Yes, only those who have been crowned Referees can see when an appendage is being used as a weapon. Good call.
Leading with the arm? Yellow!
Leading with the elbow? Straight Red!
Elbow isn’t cocked and he’s within his rights to try to defend the ball! Yellow!
@@noahtalley4351 yah, I'm not arguing yellow or red. More just her comment was ridiculous. He led the attack/challenge high at the guys face with his arm, strong. Whether he tried or not for the face, that's only known by the guy that did it. ✌️
Refs just don’t give any Roldan respect, not even a Var review? Come on
Of course they won’t mention any of the actual tough calls cause they don’t want to highlight just how bad the PRO organization has been with their choice of refs. Guzan is out for twelve weeks for another injury this time caused by a uncalled foul from Drew Fischer. What a joke
wow, Wiebe actually isn't biased against Seattle again
what is this world?
Maybe it's just that he calls them as he sees them (which is in line with most non-Seattle fans) and that there's something else going on....
Seattle should have won the red, the fact that I was able to see it from my desk but somehow VAR wasn't is annoying. I am also shocked of how bad LA Galaxy have gotten, they need to cool their heads or they are really going to be up a creek.
That missed Red in Seattle shocked me. I saw the replay and was stunned that there wasn't even a review
I hate Seattle and agree that a 100% red card. No idea how they don’t review that
Costa learning from Ronaldo lmao
The arm on Gressel was intentional, should have been a red card
Galaxy is a disaster,Klein,Beckerman,Vamney,AEG,Costa,Caceres,Hernandez,Coulobaly,etc. All of them need to move their circus act to another city sooner the better.
Studs hit Dylan Nealis in the chest. The San Jose player was coming in studs first to a ball over his hip and raised his leg high to get it.
"Pulling back" doesn't mean enough here. Studs first with a leg over the waist should matter more.
The match ends after seven yellow cards seven playing teamates can not defend four starters on the field ten players of the rival side. 11-8 men game is the situation. 0-3 the home team forfeits. The refs are dropping red and right for fun.
3.50 In this case you need to be sure if the player is in a off side position. For me the defender on the far side of de Assitant referee is putting him in a onside position. This cases can be really difficult to make a decision.
The team of officials in the match here are authority of the MLS and whistle as trained profesionals.
MIA vs DAL has to be an offside rather than a foul. The offside is clear.
Only the head referee is allowed to look at the VAR monitor.
Terrible weekend by Pro. Warrants an apology knowing all the terrible calls and handling of the games
Collectively the refs had a terrible weekend. So many bad calls throughout the league.
0:12 lol😂😂😂😂😂
Good checking and use of var on the first clip
being a soccer referee, this series really helps!
i never forget this guy best player for me when i played pes 2013
7:24 if not for the foul, it was also offside.
Imma be honest he sounds so depressed
Love your show :)
If you do that in English Premier League, you get Red Card plus banned for 5-7 matches
He touched nicely tho
@@sakuraisp6974 its forbidden for player came to referree when he check VAR
Do what? There are a dozen plus plays in this segment.
LA galaxy really thriving to be the worst team in MLS
I wish jimmy conrad was still doing this
VAN goal should have stood. He falls cuz his foot slips, not because he was pushed. You can easily see his foot loose traction and him going down specifically because of it
While it wasn't as much of a push as it looks like, it does look like there is a push by the attacker's right hand. That push contributes to the defender's foot slipping and him going down. This has to be called.
Stl should have a red card
Wiebe is actually brainless. Sands touched the ball with his plant foot and swung through as well. It’s a yellow at best.
Holy crap, you're right. Somehow it seems like everyone missed this point. Now that I'm seeing it, neither player had control of the ball and they both effectively swung into each other. It just so happened that Ibarra's foot was at a slightly further point in its trajectory. Not sure what the right call should have been but I think punitiveness towards one player/team and not the other doesn't seem correct.
As a DC United fan, it's obviously frustrating to have two controversial calls go against them, but your rationale in both cases is reasonable. I was sort of surprised that nothing was made of the Columbus keeper going for a punch, completely missing and absolutely clattering into a United player. Is this just a special privilege for keepers? I always thought the standard was the keeper needed to make contact with the ball before they can legally go through a player.
I'm a Columbus fan and agree about that foul from our keeper. When I was watching, I figured he would have been called over to take a look at that. He took your player completely out and didn't get the ball. But the other two goals I believe were correct. Matan did dive, but the contact before was a foul. If he wouldn't have went down as he did, VAR probably wouldn't have noticed the foul. A foul is a foul, even if you don't go down.
Keepers get way too much leniency. They're also some of the biggest babies out there when they get brushed.
Headline is not correct. He received a yellow for entering VAR booth area. It was his 2nd yellow.
Just a clarification: A second yellow IS a red. That's why the headline says that a red card was 'earned' and not "received". He received a 2nd yellow, which earns him a red card infraction.
A penalty for New England Revolution is a right call.
Fraude
Wow. That first one was silly!
I was at the dc United game in the supporter section we couldn’t believe the first call and I’m shocked to see the replay of the 2nd goal. Really took the wind out of the crowd and now we’re in 13th place …
Both calls were correct in the end anyways. Matan did dive but the contact before is still a foul. You don't have to go down for a foul to occur. But if he didn't dive as he did, VAR probably wouldn't have taken a second look to see the actual foul. Also the second goal, he doesn't look to be offside. He looked level or in front of the defender to me. They probably should have taken a second look but I believe the call on the field would have stood.
Kkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkk que cara maluco
Struber needs to go
why?
so many calls i disagree with lol. i feel like this commentator has never played at a competitive level and just doesnt really understand what actually happens on the field
So once again, y’all gonna be silent on a takedown of ATL keeper by NYC?!?!? Come on, do better!
I'm probably rushing things bit , but this will definitely be included in top season's bloopers later 😂
You have got to be kidding me, Wiebe. Matan took two steps then obviously pulls up the landing gear.
How is that not simulation with the Dallas Miami game😂
I assume your laughing emoji is because you think your question is so ridiculous. (?) I can't see how else to take it.
MLS doing everything to try and improve the league's reputation except for FIXING THE REFS. How can an entire ref organization be this godawful?
The massive number of thumbs up you (didn't) get for that says a lot.
Don't drink it your yunk is gonna fall off
a racial slur? Dismantle the team!
That handball was definitely a PK. The fact that VAR tried to overturn the womans call seems a little sexist. Good on her for not caving to them
I dont think thats the first time this has happened. Be better Pro
I don't know if there was sexism involved (which has zero place in the game), but I'd prefer to look at it in light of a somewhat similar call last week. In that call, the handball was initially waved off, but VAR showed the referee (coincidentally? also T. Penso) an angle that looked like arm extension and the PK was given. PRO later came out and said that was the wrong call, as the arm was extended behind the player within their frame. You could be right, but I'd like to think this was a case of referees and VARs trying to calibrate their handball decisions before I jump to patronizing. Penso is an excellent referee in a challenging position.
I wouldnt call it sexism, the arm from a certain angle does look like it isnt in a natural position. Im thinking VAR just suggested to the ref to look over and confirm the decision.
I was there in the front row. It was pretty obvious that Tori made the right call (she called a really good game to be honest). No clue why the VAR official called her over to look at it but she was right on the pitch and she was right after reviewing it. They kept showing the play on the huge screen while she was reviewing it which surprised me but they showed a couple angles and it was so clear and obvious that she made the right call that to flag it was a joke. However, I seriously doubt sexism has anything to do with it. This isn't her first game, or even her first season.
Why can you not say (racial) slurs? Literally almost everyone uses them, and many foreigners have typical words that some Americans might not be accustomed to
I'm not sure what your group of friends is like, but 'literally almost everyone' is certainly not valid in my life. 40 years ago it was more common when joking with friends, but even then you'd never cross the line with certain words and certainly not with people you weren't tight with. Your comment just shows how far we haven't come.
Couple of those decions where absolutely laughable yet a tackle that could have ended someone's career doesn't even get picked up by VAR. Makes perfect sense
How on earth did Vazquez miss a serious foul on the stomp to Alex roldan almost reminds me of Ishmael’s missed red card on melia for body slamming Cristian roldan