Dr Taimur Rahman sir......I have no words to appreciate you..Aap ne ye ek chhota sa ILM Ka Diya jalaya hai jiski Roshni se Yaha India tak Hum Jaise log Faiziyab ho rhe ...
Accumulation of wealth on one pole is at same time accumulation of misery, agony of toil, slavery, ignorance brutality, mental degradation on opposite pole- karl marx
Wish you good health & long life.Hope you are having team members learning from you. Working so hard on so many fronts may cause fatigue or burn out. Though an atheist but for you pray to almighty to give you strength. Ameen. Prof. (Dr.) Prem khosla
تیمور بھائی آپ نے بہت اچھے طریقے سے اپنا پوائنٹ ثابت کیا۔ روس کا جس طرح تجزیہ کیا جاتا ہے وہ درست نہیں تھا۔ خاص طور پر سرمایہ دار سامراجی ممالک کا جو تجزیہ آپ نے دیا وہ بلکل درست لگتا ہے۔ مگر پھر ساتھ ہی جو تجزیہ آپ نے روس کا پیش کیا وہ مجھے کچھ ایسا مناسب نہیں لگا جسے میں سائنسی طور پر درست مان سکوں۔ جب ایک ملک سوشلزم سے سرمایہ داری کے نظام میں داخل ہوتا ہے تو اس کی یہ تبدیلی اتنی آسانی سے نہیں ہوپاتی۔ کسی ملک تو چھوڑیں کسی چھوٹے سے ادارے میں بھی اتنی بڑی تبدیلی اسے بہت پیچھے دھکیل دیتی ہے۔ جو شماریات آپ نے دیکھائیں وہ درست ہونگی مگر ان پر تجزیہ کچھ سمجھ نہیں آیا۔ کوئی بھی نظام نافذ ہوتے ہیں اپنے ثمرات دینا شروع نہیں کردیتا۔ اسے اس کےلئے مناسب وقت دینا پڑتا ہے۔ اصل بات یہ ہے کہ سوشلزم کو ۱۹۲۲ سے ۱۹۹۱ تک کافی وقت ملا تھا مگر پھر ایسا کیا ہوا کہ سوشلزم کو ترق کرنا پڑا۔ کیوں سوشلزم وہاں لوگوں کی توقعات پر پورا نہ اترا کیوں ملک تباہی کا شکار ہوا؟ دنیا میں ۱۹۵ ملک ہیں ان میں سے کتنے ملک ہیں جہاں سرمایہ داری اس بری طرح ناکام ہو کے کسی دوسرے نظام میں تبدیل ہوئی ہو؟ بلکہ اب تو سرمایہ داری نے اپنے آپ کو سائنسی بنیادوں پر ڈھال لیا ہے اور ںورڈیک ممالک میں سوشل جمہوریت کی صورت میں مثالی نظام کے طور پر ابھر رہی ہے۔ کیا سوشلزم اپنے آپ کو بدلتے ہوئے حالات کے تحت تبدیل کرنے کی وجہ سے ناکام نہیں ہوا؟
Sorry Sir, with due respect, I strongly disagree due to following reasons: 1. What do you think was the reason of Germany's GDP (Capitalist) growth before and after second WW(Germany had no colonies)? 2. What do you think was the reason of Japan's GDP (Capitalist) growth before and after second WW (Japan had no colonies in a real sense)? 3. What do you think was the reason of Scandinavian countries's GDP (Capitalist) growth before and after second WW (they had no colonies)? 4. You did not compare West Germany's economy (Capitalist) vs East Germany (Communist)? 5. You did not compare South Korea's economy (Capitalist) vs North Korea (Communist)? 6. You did not compare India's economy before 1990 (Socialist, closed economy) vs India's economy after 1990 (Open Market, Capitalist)?
@@bravosix8171 how can you compare Russia with 50 states of US? And their looting in Middle east and Afghanistan.. how can you even do that.. what they did with red indians?
Dr Taimur, I highly appreciate your work. I have a small suggestions. I think this analysis of around 3 decades which is short duration to comment which political system is better
Sir, are there any studies/books comparing the economies of socialist and the capitalist countries, which have taken into consideration the economies of the colonies as you have mentioned in this video? Thanks!
Why is the title in English but the person speaks in another language. Is it him or youtube? Because if it's him then why would he do that with no subtitles? I can't understand what he's saying but I can read.
Sir did you overlook the impact of Balkan Wars and Chechen Wars? And what was the point of comparing individual FSU countries? (I'm not a student of politics, I didn't understand)
Dear Taimur, Please do an English version of these Soviet Union presentations for the ignorant Western viewer: There are too many histrionic exaggerations about the 'evil Soviet Union in the West, as you well know.
AOA, Sir. Kindly make a separate detailed video on Marxist/Socialism thoughts/ideas on religion. Why did Marx criticize religion? And what was the status of religious people in the USSR? Were they forced to not practice their religion or total liberty were given to them to practice their religion? Sir, Kindly do make a video on it, I really want to listen to your view on this.
Sab se Badi bat ye hai ke itna authentic information share krne ke bad ap professional nhi huye Apne Kabhi nhi Kaha he ke mere channel ko Subscribe kro.share kro take apko Koi monitory gain mile ya apki popularity bhadhe ye Apka Bada pan hai ek Ideal teacher ko aisa hi Hona Chahiye....... Warna TH-cam pr har Koi Subscribe, like,shre Ka Nara lagata he ..... thanks
Its duty of Govt to facilotate n uplift the poor sections of the society n making one faced standard syllabus where from all ones could study equally n avail the provided opportunities by mental hard work
But it is not that simple, for example, why France was able to extract slaves from Africa, because France was already. more wealthy and powerful before going for slaves.
IF GOVT CONTROLLS THE RESOURCES N DOES NOT MAKE EQUALITY BASED EDUCATION WHERE FROM EVERY ONE COULD GET STANDARD EDUCATION THERE SHOULD BE NO FARMERS N LABOURERS THEY COULD AVAIL IT FROM OTHER COUNTRIES WHICH ARE POOR ONES. WE SHOULD MAKE LAWS OF EDUCATION COMPULSARY ON EVERY CITIZEN UPTILL UNI
Ap ko communism ko kamiyab banane ky lihe "Islamic touch" bi dyty rehna chahihe Sir,As you know Pakistan is a Islamic conservative society,Ye communism kay phalsaphy ka jin atni asani sy hamarhe koond zahinoo me nai bethne wala jb tak ky is me Emotions ka flavor na mily.Salam to all from Balochistan.
But communism deprives a person from sense of competition. If people are treated the same, provided the same how can one go on the top. It is in human nature to traverse forward and take life as competition. How can everyone stand financially at an equal level?
Human nature is always evolving !! It's never stay same from the beginning!!! Human nature & society always based on economy systems of a country !! People thoughts & character are made depending on economy & production system of a country.. & How can one go to the top this is thought of a men of capitalist society .. because while capitalism based around on individuals wealth individuals status in a society while in socialism every individual work for society & contribute the labour into the economy of a country Bt please note that i don't mean people losses their individualty & extreme equality which is totally wrong I just mean in socailsam individualistic thoughts of people extinct in a socialistic way with cultural revolution in a order.. I hope you get what i want to say exactly..
You have missed the most important aspect that communism failed due to inevitable weakness that developed as most people were not interested to work hard resulting in drop in agricultural productivity industrial productivity and lack of interest to pursue higher studies research in various regions of USSR other than core Russian ethnic leading to shortages and disparities.I have been going to USSR and have seen miserable conditions of normal people queuing for bread and other essentials well before 1991 ..in fact when I had gone to western Siberian region and made a purchase of watch from a govt. Shop the sales lady was annoyed that I had purchased the item depriving her an opportunity to buy which she was planning by accumulating her savings every month..but was far below the mark..(having learnt about it ..I gifted her on my way back just to see her happy)..so please don't make theoretical superficial analysis..fact remains communism gets far more easily amenable to get under the control of local dictatorial regime..what happened in west bengal under communist rule as against progressive western southern and northern states is itself a proof. Similarly the state of east and west Germany who are basically of same ethnic block is another proof of inadequacies of real communism compared to theoretical expectations of bookish communism
what is the model of socialism? will any system in this universe survive with out incentives? What an irrational system is socialism. I wonder how you show only one side of the coin and that too incorrect.
@@Taimur_Laal definitely from a better university than yours'. Lol. On the other hand, you have studied politics for your PhD not economics hence what you talk about lacks even simple understanding of economics. The west has thrown socialism out of window but people in our part of the world are still preaching it. What an irony! Plz don't tell me that Scandinavian countries are socialist because you might go for it since you must not be aware from economics data. If you have doubt, I can show you data that substantially supports that Scandinavian countries are even more capitalist in nature than the US when it comes to wealth creation. We can have debate over it some day if you like.
ECONOMICS WITH DR. SHERAZ MUSTAFA I’m just wondering which university you studied at. Because anyone with any understanding of socialist economics would know that socialism is not a system without incentives.
@@Taimur_Laal does it believe in transfer of ownership/property rights? Does it believe in transfer of inheritance from. Older generation to the following one? Does it believe in letting the market forces operate and determine prices? If yes, the. You Re talking about capitalism not socialism. There are many such questions that can easily be floated. What kind of incentives does socialism offer? Plz don't tell me it offers intrinsic ones. I will only laugh at that. Why do you guys keep on quoting Marx only? Don't you have recent research supporting you? Plz quote only 2 economists from top 10 contemporary economists who support socialism. Plz don't tell they criticize capitalism so it is tantamount to supporting socialism.
Dr Taimur Rahman sir......I have no words to appreciate you..Aap ne ye ek chhota sa ILM Ka Diya jalaya hai jiski Roshni se Yaha India tak Hum Jaise log Faiziyab ho rhe ...
Accumulation of wealth on one pole is at same time accumulation of misery, agony of toil, slavery, ignorance brutality, mental degradation on opposite pole-
karl marx
Wish you good health & long life.Hope you are having team members learning from you. Working so hard on so many fronts may cause fatigue or burn out. Though an atheist but for you pray to almighty to give you strength. Ameen.
Prof. (Dr.) Prem khosla
Love and solidarity from Mexico comrades!
Plus there is great resistance in socialism way like sanctions etc where captialism is absolutely free from any resistance in it's way
Thank you so much for this Taimur. Great as always!
Clearly shows Soviets looked after their people more than FSU! Alarming and surprising!
Dr sahb you are doing good work.i have learn alot of from ur all lectures...God bless you and your family..
Sir I studied international relations,And i saw stastical graph in growth rate of USSR decling (1923-1991) as compare to USA
تیمور بھائی آپ نے بہت اچھے طریقے سے اپنا پوائنٹ ثابت کیا۔ روس کا جس طرح تجزیہ کیا جاتا ہے وہ درست نہیں تھا۔ خاص طور پر سرمایہ دار سامراجی ممالک کا جو تجزیہ آپ نے دیا وہ بلکل درست لگتا ہے۔ مگر پھر ساتھ ہی جو تجزیہ آپ نے روس کا پیش کیا وہ مجھے کچھ ایسا مناسب نہیں لگا جسے میں سائنسی طور پر درست مان سکوں۔ جب ایک ملک سوشلزم سے سرمایہ داری کے نظام میں داخل ہوتا ہے تو اس کی یہ تبدیلی اتنی آسانی سے نہیں ہوپاتی۔ کسی ملک تو چھوڑیں کسی چھوٹے سے ادارے میں بھی اتنی بڑی تبدیلی اسے بہت پیچھے دھکیل دیتی ہے۔ جو شماریات آپ نے دیکھائیں وہ درست ہونگی مگر ان پر تجزیہ کچھ سمجھ نہیں آیا۔ کوئی بھی نظام نافذ ہوتے ہیں اپنے ثمرات دینا شروع نہیں کردیتا۔ اسے اس کےلئے مناسب وقت دینا پڑتا ہے۔ اصل بات یہ ہے کہ سوشلزم کو ۱۹۲۲ سے ۱۹۹۱ تک کافی وقت ملا تھا مگر پھر ایسا کیا ہوا کہ سوشلزم کو ترق کرنا پڑا۔ کیوں سوشلزم وہاں لوگوں کی توقعات پر پورا نہ اترا کیوں ملک تباہی کا شکار ہوا؟
دنیا میں ۱۹۵ ملک ہیں ان میں سے کتنے ملک ہیں جہاں سرمایہ داری اس بری طرح ناکام ہو کے کسی دوسرے نظام میں تبدیل ہوئی ہو؟ بلکہ اب تو سرمایہ داری نے اپنے آپ کو سائنسی بنیادوں پر ڈھال لیا ہے اور ںورڈیک ممالک میں سوشل جمہوریت کی صورت میں مثالی نظام کے طور پر ابھر رہی ہے۔ کیا سوشلزم اپنے آپ کو بدلتے ہوئے حالات کے تحت تبدیل کرنے کی وجہ سے ناکام نہیں ہوا؟
Sorry Sir, with due respect, I strongly disagree due to following reasons:
1. What do you think was the reason of Germany's GDP (Capitalist) growth before and after second WW(Germany had no colonies)?
2. What do you think was the reason of Japan's GDP (Capitalist) growth before and after second WW (Japan had no colonies in a real sense)?
3. What do you think was the reason of Scandinavian countries's GDP (Capitalist) growth before and after second WW (they had no colonies)?
4. You did not compare West Germany's economy (Capitalist) vs East Germany (Communist)?
5. You did not compare South Korea's economy (Capitalist) vs North Korea (Communist)?
6. You did not compare India's economy before 1990 (Socialist, closed economy) vs India's economy after 1990 (Open Market, Capitalist)?
You are right.
US itself does not have colonies but its gdp/capita is greater than that of Russia......
Bhai I'm sorry lekin aap masly ki rooh hi nahi samjhy. Warna ap ye sawal na karty. I request you to listen to him once more.
@@malikfahdaliawan178 ap na samjhay
@@bravosix8171 how can you compare Russia with 50 states of US? And their looting in Middle east and Afghanistan.. how can you even do that.. what they did with red indians?
@@malikfahdaliawan178 the questions raised in first comment must be answered. Don't run awat
Love from India.
Dr Taimur, I highly appreciate your work. I have a small suggestions. I think this analysis of around 3 decades which is short duration to comment which political system is better
very valid point.
comparison must be made between the two economies
Sir, are there any studies/books comparing the economies of socialist and the capitalist countries, which have taken into consideration the economies of the colonies as you have mentioned in this video? Thanks!
Ek farmaish. 1929 ke depression me sare world ko ek taraf aur USSR ko doosri or karke ek study dikhayen.
Sir, Kamal lecture Allah Sehat dy mn first listner...!
سر مہربانی کر کے یہ بتائے کہ سویت اکنامک ڈیکلا ئن کی وجوہات کیا تھیں
Why is the title in English but the person speaks in another language. Is it him or youtube? Because if it's him then why would he do that with no subtitles? I can't understand what he's saying but I can read.
Sir did you overlook the impact of Balkan Wars and Chechen Wars?
And what was the point of comparing individual FSU countries? (I'm not a student of politics, I didn't understand)
sir i really appriciate what youre doing. i love ur lectures. wish u good health. peace.
Dear Taimur, Please do an English version of these Soviet Union presentations for the ignorant Western viewer: There are too many histrionic exaggerations about the 'evil Soviet Union in the West, as you well know.
AOA, Sir. Kindly make a separate detailed video on Marxist/Socialism thoughts/ideas on religion. Why did Marx criticize religion? And what was the status of religious people in the USSR? Were they forced to not practice their religion or total liberty were given to them to practice their religion? Sir, Kindly do make a video on it, I really want to listen to your view on this.
Watch this th-cam.com/video/X9CwaE0joLc/w-d-xo.html
CHANGE COULD COME BY THIS WAY
Sab se Badi bat ye hai ke itna authentic information share krne ke bad ap professional nhi huye Apne Kabhi nhi Kaha he ke mere channel ko Subscribe kro.share kro take apko Koi monitory gain mile ya apki popularity bhadhe ye Apka Bada pan hai ek Ideal teacher ko aisa hi Hona Chahiye....... Warna TH-cam pr har Koi Subscribe, like,shre Ka Nara lagata he
..... thanks
Really wonderful. Keep the good work up.
Please 🙏 answer
What you say about north Korea and south Korean economy which is extream example
Sir please also create a video on individual rights in socialism.
Its duty of Govt to facilotate n uplift the poor sections of the society n making one faced standard syllabus where from all ones could study equally n avail the provided opportunities by mental hard work
Dear professor sab asalam o aliakum please answer me how and what a poor man can help another poor man
Sir what is comunizam and socialazam please make the vedio briefley.
Sir, what about the economies of those regions where west didn't make colonies like some part of middle East?
Sir what about the polish economic situation under socialism and capitalism?
Revolution in india ? . Thanks for good knowledge about communism.
Sir, what are your views on German economic growth after 1840. Was that anywhere related to slave trade?
2008 me duniya depression nahi to kamse kam recession me tha. India me us waqt itna asar nahi pada. Kya communiston ka role usme tha?
SIR Turkey ki history par aik lecture upload karay Thanks
Thank you so much.
May Allah give you reward😊
Why didn't you compare East and West Germany- Today, south korea with North Korea
You know which system won
But it is not that simple, for example, why France was able to extract slaves from Africa, because France was already. more wealthy and powerful before going for slaves.
Dr. Mehbool ul haq in his book "poverty curtain " writes round 400 billion pounds, s material exploitation on the part of u. k from Hindustan
bahut sahi sir ji
Socialism or capitalism's dno buree nazam hain ...
Great Comrade!
Thank you sir.
Long live doctor sab
Bahot khub janab 🌹
Loved it as usual.
Or Rahi bat Britishers ki to unko modern world me survive karna bakhubi ATA tha, or indian sub continent me mordenisation Britishers hi lekar aye the
Yar ye bat to hume kisi ne nhn batyae
Great sir
Appreciated
Sirf man power se development Ni hota, man power Ko sahi direction me use karne se country develop Karti h
Please talk about East and West Germany
Back in 2005 one of my international relations lecturer said ' Russia has tremendous wealth n she will rise once again .'
Sir u r brilliant
IF GOVT CONTROLLS THE RESOURCES N DOES NOT MAKE EQUALITY BASED EDUCATION WHERE FROM EVERY ONE COULD GET STANDARD EDUCATION THERE SHOULD BE NO FARMERS N LABOURERS THEY COULD AVAIL IT FROM OTHER COUNTRIES WHICH ARE POOR ONES. WE SHOULD MAKE LAWS OF EDUCATION COMPULSARY ON EVERY CITIZEN UPTILL UNI
thank you sir
Thank u!
ایک دفعہ ہلیری کلنٹن نے جل بھن کر کہا تھا. Russia is nothing more than a gas station
East & West Germany is best example.
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
What you say north Korea and south Korea and East jermany and west Germany examples
good
Ap ko communism ko kamiyab banane ky lihe "Islamic touch" bi dyty rehna chahihe Sir,As you know Pakistan is a Islamic conservative society,Ye communism kay phalsaphy ka jin atni asani sy hamarhe koond zahinoo me nai bethne wala jb tak ky is me Emotions ka flavor na mily.Salam to all from Balochistan.
Sir your email please
You didn't include those poor 30 million people (farmers) who had been killed by a chronic thief Stalin ...
Kuch b kuch b Bata Rahe h ye
Wsalam
But communism deprives a person from sense of competition. If people are treated the same, provided the same how can one go on the top. It is in human nature to traverse forward and take life as competition. How can everyone stand financially at an equal level?
Human nature is always evolving !! It's never stay same from the beginning!!! Human nature & society always based on economy systems of a country !! People thoughts & character are made depending on economy & production system of a country..
& How can one go to the top this is thought of a men of capitalist society .. because while capitalism based around on individuals wealth individuals status in a society while in socialism every individual work for society & contribute the labour into the economy of a country
Bt please note that i don't mean people losses their individualty & extreme equality which is totally wrong
I just mean in socailsam individualistic thoughts of people extinct in a socialistic way with cultural revolution in a order..
I hope you get what i want to say exactly..
You have missed the most important aspect that communism failed due to inevitable weakness that developed as most people were not interested to work hard resulting in drop in agricultural productivity industrial productivity and lack of interest to pursue higher studies research in various regions of USSR other than core Russian ethnic leading to shortages and disparities.I have been going to USSR and have seen miserable conditions of normal people queuing for bread and other essentials well before 1991 ..in fact when I had gone to western Siberian region and made a purchase of watch from a govt. Shop the sales lady was annoyed that I had purchased the item depriving her an opportunity to buy which she was planning by accumulating her savings every month..but was far below the mark..(having learnt about it ..I gifted her on my way back just to see her happy)..so please don't make theoretical superficial analysis..fact remains communism gets far more easily amenable to get under the control of local dictatorial regime..what happened in west bengal under communist rule as against progressive western southern and northern states is itself a proof.
Similarly the state of east and west Germany who are basically of same ethnic block is another proof of inadequacies of real communism compared to theoretical expectations of bookish communism
Sorry but I think capitalism is pure form of democracy in economy..
You are stupid then.
Apse milne ka mutmanni hu
what is the model of socialism? will any system in this universe survive with out incentives? What an irrational system is socialism. I wonder how you show only one side of the coin and that too incorrect.
Where did you study economics Dr. Sheraz Mustafa?
@@Taimur_Laal definitely from a better university than yours'. Lol. On the other hand, you have studied politics for your PhD not economics hence what you talk about lacks even simple understanding of economics. The west has thrown socialism out of window but people in our part of the world are still preaching it. What an irony! Plz don't tell me that Scandinavian countries are socialist because you might go for it since you must not be aware from economics data. If you have doubt, I can show you data that substantially supports that Scandinavian countries are even more capitalist in nature than the US when it comes to wealth creation. We can have debate over it some day if you like.
ECONOMICS WITH DR. SHERAZ MUSTAFA I’m just wondering which university you studied at. Because anyone with any understanding of socialist economics would know that socialism is not a system without incentives.
@@Taimur_Laal does it believe in transfer of ownership/property rights? Does it believe in transfer of inheritance from. Older generation to the following one? Does it believe in letting the market forces operate and determine prices? If yes, the. You Re talking about capitalism not socialism. There are many such questions that can easily be floated. What kind of incentives does socialism offer? Plz don't tell me it offers intrinsic ones. I will only laugh at that. Why do you guys keep on quoting Marx only? Don't you have recent research supporting you? Plz quote only 2 economists from top 10 contemporary economists who support socialism. Plz don't tell they criticize capitalism so it is tantamount to supporting socialism.
We all will love to see a healthy program on such topic between you both!!!
❤