SIGMA STRIKES BACK! - Sigma 35mm F1.4 DG DN Art Lens for Sony Review
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 27 ก.ค. 2024
- Review of the new Sigma 35mm f/1.4 DG DN Art lens for Sony E-mount with comparisons to the Sony 35mm G Master and the Sony 35mm f/1.8.
👍 Thanks for watching! Please like, comment, & subscribe.
🛒 Sigma 35mm f/1.4 Art: geni.us/mYZlZ3g
🛒 Sony 35mm f/1.4 GM: geni.us/fGKNl4i
🛒 Sony 35mm f/1.8: geni.us/LB7iE
🛒 Gear I Use to Make Videos: bit.ly/3RlRmgx
🟣 Gerald Undone Merch: bit.ly/2ViBkcV
=============================
Relevant Links:
=============================
📼 Gordon's Video: • Sigma 35mm f1.4 Art RE...
📝 Cameralabs Review: www.cameralabs.com/sigma-35mm...
📼 Sony 35mm G Master Review: • Sony 35mm f/1.4 GM Rev...
=============================
Table of Contents:
=============================
0:00 - Intro & Disclosure
1:05 - Build & Focusing
2:30 - Close Focusing Issues
4:47 - Sharpness & Image Quality
8:05 - Chromatic Aberration
9:52 - Transmittance
10:43 - Bokeh
11:24 - Stopping Down Improvements
12:14 - Comparison to Sony 35mm f/1.8
13:23 - Sunstars & Flare
13:43 - Final Thoughts
15:27 - Second Opinion
=============================
Gear Used to Make This Video:
=============================
Camera: geni.us/KVz6Au
Lens: geni.us/LB7iE
Microphone: geni.us/I40Dn
Recorder: geni.us/ZLyb
Key Light: geni.us/AQto9
Complete Gear List: kit.co/GeraldUndone/youtube-v...
=============================
Best Deals for Camera Gear
=============================
Gear Focus Marketplace: geni.us/gearfocusGU
Amazon Top Deals: amzn.to/3d9tdT4
B&H Deal Zone: bhpho.to/2SCDrnj
=============================
Music:
=============================
I use Artlist for my background music needs. Use this link to get two extra months when signing up: bit.ly/2TV5sYT
=============================
Follow Me:
=============================
Twitter: / geraldundone
Instagram: / geraldundone
Discord: / discord
=============================
Patreon & PayPal:
=============================
If you wish to support the channel monetarily, you can use my Patreon page here: / geraldundone
Or directly via PayPal here: www.paypal.me/geraldundone
This is appreciated, but unnecessary, and no content will ever be behind a paywall.
=============================
Affiliate Links:
=============================
Some of the links in my video descriptions are affiliate links, which means at no extra cost to you, I will make a small commission if you click them and make a qualifying purchase. If you have a different purchase in mind, you can also use these storewide links below.
🛒 Amazon: geni.us/1m1G32
🛒 B&H Photo: bhpho.to/2MYRKBE
=============================
Recommended Channel Tools:
=============================
💬 Closed captioning provided by ONEXTRA: onextra.ca
🚩 If you're a fellow TH-camr, I highly recommend you try TubeBuddy. It's helped my channel immensely: www.tubebuddy.com/pricing?a=U...
=============================
#sigma #sonyalpha #35mm - วิทยาศาสตร์และเทคโนโลยี
![[LIVE] : ONE ลุมพินี 72 วันนี้!! คู่เอก "ก้องศึก vs โจอาคิม"](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/hT1EOSsRPac/mqdefault.jpg)
Thanks for having me on your channel Gerald!
The pleasure was mine! You're very good at this. 🤓
@@lenhister I always try to channel Nicki Minaj in my work. I'm wearing my monster-do under that beanie...
Great collaboration more please 😀
I love that you did a colab together!
Excellent job
I am Gerald Undone and, contrary to the Sony GM, I don't breathe.
I really like how you talk so fast and clean that makes every video like a high quality lecture.
Man i don't own any sigma lenses, sony lenses, or full frame cameras but I still end up watching your videos and learning so much from them because the basic principals and problems when it comes to lenses and cameras in photography and cinematography carry over across brands and models. I appreciate your in-depth reviews.
Your reviews are as good as Sony’s latest G Master lenses. I appreciate the different viewpoints from the colabs. For me, compact size (and light weight) is everything for street photography and travel, so yet another reason the two Sony 35’s win out for my personal style and use. Thank you for these excellent series of reviews!
Thanks for another thorough and technical review Gerald! Considering here in Europe the Sony 1.4 GM retails for €1700, the Sony 1.8 for €700 and the Sigma will be priced at €849 and also considering I will be using the lens mainly for photography and not be close-focusing too often, the Sigma may still be the best option for me.
Hey, I'm Gerald Undone and I put a ND1000 Filter on my Camera and set the ISO to 64000.
You're evil
I'm Gerald Undone and I put the bottle back in the genie.
And the genie said, "Harder daddy"
Loving the reviews and the guests. Good job guys
Best in-depth review! On my copy of the lens I also did notice a bit of aberrations especially in the catchlight of the model eyes, when using strobe! I’ve been using A7R4, and it was quite sharp, but it was detailed enough to see that aberrations! Cheers from Japan!
Oh I'm your subscriber 😎having you here is mechya uresiii 🐸🐸
Wow I paniced when i saw all the reviews popping up after purchasing the GM version 3 weeks prior. Glad with my purchase though and reassuring with your review. :)
my theory with the sigma 35 f 1.4 is that they designed it to be a competitor to the zeiss 35 f1.4. its nearly the exact same size and form with drastically better images. i dont think sigma counted on sony releasing a gmaster just weeks before they released their own. i expect this lens to have a version 2 in the near future.
Near future...
That's interesting how different of results we have all seen. I just looked over my head to head results on the a1 between the Sigma and the GM and found that Sigma was equally sharp (a hair better, actually), with the GM having the edge in the outer third of the image circle. I did see the CA you mention in a few shots, but not persistently like you encountered. Did your copy seem properly centered? I've had lenses damaged in transit that underperformed.
Say, Dustin, I like your reviews and on this lens your perspective presents regarding “character” of the lens where as sharpness or close focus ability is key for me. Itsa matter of communication style as I see it.
You are my #1 go to when I really wanna know. You are thorough, objective and detailed.
I got sigma lens yesterday and greatly dissapointed. The close focus shots at 1.4 are not sharp at all with lots of colour fringing. Also distant shots at 1.4 are tad softer. I went ahead and returned it today and ordered the sony GM which is currently back ordered
Awesome video as usual. Love the second opinion sections you have been doing lately.
Love the close-up wide open tests. I shoot like this as well. Have found that the Sony 35mm 1.8 makes most lenses look very soft in comparison when used this way. It's the first lens I ever used on mirrorless and never realized how spoiled I was until I tried lots of others and found that they can't even compare when used this way. Every Fuji lens I've tried is soft close and wide open; I assume they don't optimize for it.
How is it that you only have 285k subscribers? just getting into photography and you are my go-to creator as your videos are super in depth. I have bought any lenses because they are expensive but hoping eventually to afford one
I was thinking about getting this lens. Thanks so much for the review, Gerald. It helps me a lot to make my final decision.
What was your final decision?
Hahaha I was JUST binge watching your sigma 35’s, g master 35 AND your sigma 40 and suddenly this pops up!
Fantastic review Sir
Love it 💯
It's hard to describe, how much I appreciate your work, no bs just straight to the point! Thank you Gerald!
Lol! Love the ending :) Great video👍
A lot of these issues with this lens would be more prominent to photographers and not filmmakers, in my opinion. Watching a movie, I'm not going to "punch in" to look for chromatic aberration or focus bands. I guess that's one of the nicer aspects of filmmaking. Of course, the focus breathing would be an issue. And from what I've seen from this video, the bokeh is pretty clean...except when you "punch in". Thanks for another thorough Undone review. I don't know too many people that cover products with such detail, other than Philip Bloom and Jared Polin. I'm a grateful subscriber to be sure. 😀
It's a great day when you upload ❤
I enjoy the cross-over videos, very fun!
Great review! Thank you.
Many thanks for the review.
I watched this to the end too... . Not sure why, really, as my camera is a Z6ii. But, the chromatic aberration demos were interesting. I use DXO and they claim their lens correction modules help a lot. I wonder if they help the Sigma to any significant amount. Assuming there is a module a available... . Well done, again, Undone!
Always breaking it down as always. Love your videos 📹 man
I'd love to see you get your hands on industry standard cine lenses and compare them against the best offerings from photography companies to see the differences and benefits of each. Just an idea!
@@antoniog8276 I work full time in video with higher end cine lenses, so I already know the differences. I'd just love to see it on Gerald Undone's channel, as he tends to focus on video, and his breakdowns of focus breathing, flare control, CA, and distortion are some of the best. I think it would be extremely helpful to keep things in perspective for still lenses shooters, as it might really highlight the shortcuts that lens manufacturers take to keep the prices down. From my experiences, amateur videographers simply don't know the differences and having a side by side comparison might be helpful to them.
Thank you so much! Getting up close to wildflowers is super important for me and you saved me from an expensive mistake!
Great crossover!
Your best lens review to date.
Killer review, in more ways than one. Gotta love Gordon ^^
Good to see the A1 made its way off the shelf!
Superb work.
I'll very very happily stick with my 1.8 Sony. Booyah xxx
10,000 views in 4 hours....you've come a long way baby! Ok now I'll watch the video and get undone.
Sony f1.8 is still the winner in my book. Had the lens since release and don’t see the need to upgrade 🤙
the "all right, I'm done" had my mind completely undone.
That was an inception moment...
Great review Gerald! I can understand your frustration with sigma's productions lately.... The fact is they are doing good yet but the recent sony products are acting like a "game changer" leading the quality in the whole industry! Now comparing this good sigma lens with the Sony GM we can confidently say the GM is the best ever made autofocus 35mm f1.4 in any brands! Yes it's not perfect but is the perfect possible option available!
Very perceptive review, thanks for all the details! I do think though that the Sigma is a slam dunk choice over the Sony f/1.8, because it does everything the Sony does plus it offers the option of f/1.4. The f/1.4 is flawed in some situations but in others it shines. Certainly worth the slight increment in price over the Sony f/1.8 unless size and weight are very critical or strong preference.
thanks for the review Gerald. I''ll stay with the Sony 1.8
Very nice review with useful insights - thanks! a pity you didn't compare the lens to Zeiss or Samyang 35/1.4 though...
I got my 35mm GM last week and it rocks!
You are amazing, I was just about to buy this lens, I hope their 50mm for Sony E mount is better. Manny loves this lens, the 35mm that you are reviewing, but it was how he was using it.
The Dream Team for lens review. It was entertaining, did not have to press on the play back speed.
Thanks for a very comprehensive and clear review!
Seeing this trend with more and more lenses these days .. close focussing compromised to get closer to GM infinity performance (and size/weight) at a lower price point. I guess it makes sense looking at typical usage, but I really like to shoot 24 & 35 focal lengths up quite close. Other case being the new Samyang 24/1.8 close focus compared to GM24 .. However that one did less worse compared the GM at an even lower size & price. Not sure what went wrong with the Sigma. Oh well .. luxury of choice is a good thing.
Edit: Kinda loving the slightly outlined bokeh from the Sigma. Very nice aesthetic!
Thanks Gerald for such detailed comparison review, i am comparing Sony 35gm and Sony 35 1.8 If I am a video maker and don’t really mind focus breathing issue. Wondering the video images quality gonna make any noticeable difference on FX3 ‘s 4K 10bit ? Consider the resolution is very low on 4K. My key consideration is image quality on video.
Hi Gerald. Great as always, thanks! I own the older 35mm f1.4 Sigma art e-mount. I use it on the fx6 and fx9, so video work it is mostly used for. I guess the upgrade isn´tHow'sadvance, cheers, Matthias
Love that you don't put brand preference ahead of objectivity. That specular blooming and lack of contrast is a bit reminiscent of some of the super fast manual primes on the market, my M43 & E-Mount Mitakon's show this quite distinctly at f/0.95, my Voigtlander less so (still not what you'd call a sharp lens. 35mm is one of my favourite focal lengths too, though for Sony FE my favourite overall to date is the Samyang Tiny Prime. I recently lost mine for a few days as I had inadvertently put it away on my M43 lens shelf. It is just that small. Sigma are one of my favourite lens manufacturers too, so a bit of a shame they didn't completely nail this. I recently picked up the new Sony FE version of their 85mm f/1.4 and that thing is ridiculously good.
Hey Gerald, love your lens reviews, but could you please start testing vignetting? I imagine Sigma's larger lenses may have quite a bit less vignetting than Sony's, especially wide open, which is quite important for low light shots where we're already cranking ISOs for the center.
Great review, Gerald. Loved the final Gordon kick😉.
Anyway, I am Gerald Undone and I put the Pi before Sigma.😜👍
Actually Rho comes before Sigma, but Pi is before that... Or pie. I’ll put pie before any lens manufacturer 😋
Wow those details at 12:28!! Insane!
Interesting! Nice video. ✌️
I recently bought the Sigma 50mm f/1.4 'Art' and I was confused b/w the 50mm, 85m, and 35mm. When comparing them with Zeiss Batis and Sony Lenses, the price makes a huge impact because of that 1.4 aperture. Also! It's built like a tank as compared to cheaper Samyang/Rokinon offerings. I tried my hands on both G-Master and Zeiss, if the price wasn't an issue, Zeiss Batis all the way. While as far as G-Master goes, both 35mm and 50mm but not the 85mm, I would rather take either the 1.8 version or the Sigma.
Hey Gerald! what kind of camera was Jarod using... also an a7sIII or ??
Great sound quality on this video
I'm glad to hear all of this about the sigma. I just got my G Master, and WOW worth every penny. Great video Gerald!
nice one as always.....but is there any upcoming videos one that little a1 ?
Terrific content here. High level.
Hi Gerald
Do you recommend to upgrade from the older sigma 1.4 version to this brand new?
Thank Gerald ! 35mm is perfect for full-frame, but I used APSC might be get some else lens, could you advise best lens for eos 90d for my youtube works.
That's interesting. That hazy look is exactly like a problem I have with an older A-mount Sigma 70-200 2.8 I ended up getting rid of. Never been able to figure out what the problem was exactly.
Your tests are the best !
I'm Gerald Undone and I have to test my taste
Ugh, I really want a 35mm for L mount and I was hoping this would be the ticket. I don't want the sigma contemporary and the 1.2 Art is massive and expensive. I wish Panasonic would release the rest of their 1.8 primes so I could see if the 35mm was sufficient for my needs.
Anyway, fantastic review and definitely helped me save some money lol.
Howdy Gerald great vid, you gonna review the BMPCC 6K Pro? I know it's the same sensor but I need your blessing before I buy a new camera.
Thanks for this video. I had the sigma 35 on order and cancelled it to go with the GM instead!
can you do a review of the virtrox 85 1.8? love the vid man
@Gerald, what about quantifying a focus breathing value? Does it really depend on Magnification factor and Minimal focus distance as they say in many blogs?
Better channel review in youtube, one more subscriber Gerald!
Hey Gerald, could you do a round up of cheaper Chinese manual focus lenses for video use? They look pretty decent.
For eg: 7artisans, meike, kamlan, ttartisan etc
People said you talk abiut focus breathing so I am'watching all your lens videos haha
Thanks Gerald!
So glad I watched this video, as I originally planned on getting this Sigma, but was unaware of these problems he mentioned.
I went back and watched his video on the best 35mm for Sony. In the beginning he mentioned why he didn't include the Samyang 35mm 1.4
I hope he looks into the version II of that lens! Apparently fixed some of those issues? Could be the best 35mm for the money?
I just bought the old Sigma 35mm F1.4 Art DG HSM for Sony E. I wonder how it compares?
Great Review. Nice you consider unconscious bias in your reviews too, not many youtubers do that I think.
You should review the Sigma 35mm 1.2
hi gerald, thank you for this explanation
i wonder what your view on sigma 35 mm 1.4 for nikon,
Bought the GM, just because of this review after selling the DG HSM.
I wish this was easier for me to decide but it's not. Gerald, Should I get a Sony FE PZ 28-135mm f/4 G OSS Lens or the 24-70mm f2.8 G-master if it's only going to be used for video?
All I see is people YouTubing with regular lenses but no one mentions the 28-135mm is it no good or is the 24-70 just superior for video?
Hi! What do you think of the Samyang 35 1.8 or Sigma 35 f2? Thanks!! 🙂
great review, but would have been a bit better if you showed us more outdoor images. I feel like most of the tests and comparisons were taken at very close focusing distances, which not everyone uses realistically all the time
I too love the 35mm focal length. I have to say, the best I've ever used is the Tamron 35mm f/1.4. Granted it was made for DSLRs, but even adapted to mirrorless, I find it's sharper right to the corners than native equivalents. Probably not your best choice for your system and what you do. With all the great improvement in optics in the last few years, it's great to have such an amazing option for my D850.
It is the Q2 35mm lens :-)
I wonder if Tamron will release a Q3 35mm lens. Thinking of it Zeiss too are lagging behind on new 35mm lenses. Sony offers 4 of them while Sigma and Samyang each have 3 models. Tamron and Zeiss drag their feet with only one 35mm lens per brand
I just watched Dustin Abbots video and it's like he's reviewing a completely different lens. Do you think your poor results might be down to sample variation?
Very Good, Thanks 🙏🏼
So crazy. I recently got the 35mm 1.2, because it out performed the Zeiss 35mm 1.4. Now there are like 5 more 35mm focal length options.
How long can Canon and Nikon continue to prevent Sigma and Tamron from making lenses? There is little enough reason to buy a Nikon already, but since neither of them can ship the few lenses they make, Sony is just that much more attractive to the remaining dslr shooters looking to jump.
Wondered about whether the new Sigma is an upgrade over the older Sigma 35 1.4. Is it sharper? Does it have more chromatic aberration? I know the older one was heavier and did not focus as well for video.
Perhaps a bit off topic but: how does this Sigma 35mm f/1.4 compare to the Sigma 40mm f/1.4, size/weight excepted?
SOOO many 35mm lenses for Sony E and they all have various drawbacks. It's almost funny that this focal length keeps having trouble while they pull off everything else really well like the 14/1.8
For general music video clips, what’s best? Sigma 35mm Art DG HSM, DG DN or Sony 35mm f1.8?
Great review. You should have a look at the Samyang 35mm f1.8 FE, it is a great lens
Thank you for the great review! Is it an option for you to test the new Samyang AF Series against the Sonys? Thanks and regards :-)
Okay... But how does the rokinon/samyang 35mm f1.4/f1.8 compare to these sigma and Sony lenses?
that layer of haze the lens has wide-open looks very similar to the Rokinon/Samyang 35 VDSLR. Same thing with the chromatic aberration.
If you want to focus close on a 35mm, get the Tamron, super sharp and 6” close focus. A 1:2 Macro.
Is it good for filming at very low light conditions with Sony fx3 ??
An old review, I know, and I have 35GM, but now looking for Leica mount... I have to ask, what is the purpose of focusing at f1.4 up close? Most often when I get that close, even 5.6 doesn't have enough depth of field. What am I missing?
Any update on this with production models?
Do you have a review for sigma 85mm 1.4 DG DN?
Hello Gerald, it's a great review. But I was skeptical about the Vignette of this lens while shooting the video. Can you please make a video on its Vignette Test? No TH-camr spoke about the Vignette issue of this lens.