running a web server is long running process. terraform doesnt know whether it is successful or not. It terminates the command while closing the ssh session. We should run the process background and give some prompt to the terraform. I think we can do it using the nohup cmd
@@Geekgurlcode When you run a Terraform script to provision infrastructure, certain resources may involve long-running processes, such as deploying and configuring a web server. The issue you're encountering is that Terraform may not wait for these long-running processes to complete before closing the SSH session, leading to uncertainties about whether the process was successful or not. One approach to address this is to run the long-running process in the background and disassociate it from the current session. The nohup command is a useful tool for doing this in Unix-like systems. The nohup command stands for "no hang up" and is used to run a command immune to hangups, with output to a non-tty (non-terminal) that persists even after the user logs out.
as we run any command with "&" at the end , it run the command in backgroud , nohup is just for getting output of the commands in nohup.out files at same location.
@@suhasdhoke1735 I am also thinking the same. It should run in background right as we are using sudo command and & at last it should work. I searched and got this. I am not sure Shell Differences: The shell environment might behave differently between manual login and remote execution. Try explicitly setting the shell to /bin/bash or /bin/sh in your remote-exec command to see if it resolves any differences.
Abhishek, you saved my life...attending so many worst trainnings in devops, being unemployed with responsibilities for 6 months, I finally found my confidence back...Thanks, Thanks for such a great work. Finally decided to attend interviews
I am trying to understand the logic and the pain, he takes to explain. It made me feel that to my knowledge, none-other -other than he can guide people so sincerely. I will share the link with my friend. Hats off Abhishek!!!!
I have previous knowledge on provisoner but this much easily I never understood, This series helping me for revising Terraform concepts. Thank you Abhi Bro
You are awesome Abhishek , I followed different courses on terraform . Felt terraform is complex , By watching this Zero to Hero . I can feel its very interesting and easy to learn
I initially found Terraform to be a challenging tool to work with. However, after following your Terraform series, I've come to realize that it's actually quite straightforward and manageable. Thanks Abhishek 😊
Thank you for creating a Terraform Zero to Hero series it helped me a lot to learn & enhance my skills, I request you to create more real-time projects examples like this which will boost the confidence in gaining knowledge beginners & experienced people. Your content is worth learning & helps to build their career. Keep going..!!!
Abhishek, you are the Gem in all DevOps trainers. I am a senior software proffessional and following devops practice now. Your explaination is in very simple ways which I can understand without looking into screen (i can understand from audio only) I had a request about future series should cover complete product/software to be build under complete devops practice ie. Microservices to helm deployments, cicd, monitoring... This could be a final landing of any devops engineer
very well explaination i got the things so easily.. u really makes hard concepts into soft...this video helps me alot. even i executed it correctly tq abhishek
Thanks Abhishek. I have followed your videos and with my experience I got four offers . thanks a lot..please post more videos on kubernetes and terraform
Hi Abhishek , Please can you make at least one consolidated video on networking concepts for Devops engineer , may not be detailed but at least which covers most of the required concepts of enterprise networking (Cloud and on premises ).or may be a video which lists out imp concepts of networking.
"sudo python3 app.py &", removed "&" and "," the script was able to initiate the python application. Not sure on the usage of "&" after stopping the appkication, terraform returned this error, "remote command exited without exit status or exit signal."
Hi Abhishek, You made my day is very easy becuse even I am under impression that how to write terraform code, after watching your videos, I am confident that any one can learn the terraform. Kudos to Abhishek, helping many upskilling students like me. God bless you my dear.
I wish you could've used modules and backend concept in this video and explain it, Integration of concepts are missing. It would've given more clarity because when we use different concepts or previous topics , things will be real time and gives good knowledge.
After watching thiese video getting some questions in my mind. What is difference between tf and ansible? Upto packages installations the tf provisioners are Ok but in real time projects using more than that so how it will useful ? By using ansible we can manage all hosts/servers to different operations like installations/copy etc..
Hi @AbhishekVeeramalla Thanks for giving wonderful Terraform series to learn free in TH-cam. I have find clear cut solution in google "To run a shell script in the background, use the “&(ampersand)” bash control operator and the built-in “nohup” command line tool. Both these utilities almost perform the same job. The core difference between both of them is that the “nohup” command does not kill the background process at the session termination while the “&” symbol terminates all processes after the system logout" this is the correct solution for your assignment i think. If anything missing. Could you please suggest . Thanks in advance!!
Yes. the last line should be replaced with this "nohup sudo python3 app.py > /dev/null 2>&1 &" This will also run the app in the background and discard all output-error log of the app. Doing this it won't kill the process while session termination.
for me app was not running as I was using Amazon Linux ami and tried with ubuntu user. After using ec2-user it worked as expected. Thank you for providing great content.
userdata in ec2 instance and provisioner remote-exec both are the same, instead of defining in AWS console, we are defining in terraform inline remote-exec
Just ran into this tutorial series. You have done an amazing job, Abhishek !! Quick question on the connection block of code. Your example works because the EC2 is in a public subnet. How would you connect if the EC2 were in a private subnet ?
Hi Abhishek, I am getting this error while running the terraform apply "Error: file provisioner error │ │ with aws_instance.name, │ on main.tf line 86, in resource "aws_instance" "name": │ 86: provisioner "file" { │ │ Failed to read ssh private key: no key found" I would like to know how i can pass my private key of AWS in codespaces?
Hii Abhishek…. Your videos are amazing…. I joined one of the paid course but i did n’t get much knowledge now everyday i am following your videos… one small help now i want restart my career with devops as entrylevel do i need do any certifications please let me know i am in uk .. my education M. Tech((CSE)… Thanks in Advance….
Dear Abhishek, now a days most common question is-how you are deployment in Terraform IAC.Could you share a solid answer for this with an example. Pls Pls Pls
Hi Abhishek, thanks for the insightful session. I have one doubt, if in a case I want to delete only 2 resources among 8 resources which I created through terraform. Will it be possible to destroy only those 2 with terraform destroy command ?
@@AbhishekVeeramalla, But that does not completes the tf infrastructure creation process, it keeps running with "instance ...: Still creating...", & is required at the end to run the process in background and the infrastructure creation should complete successfully.
Hi Abhishek I am able to do it and all the resources are created but not able to access the public IP. I checked the IG and Subnet all looks good. Any tweak required? Thanks
Hello sir, thank you for providing this valuable content. I practiced this lesson, but I'm confused about one thing. In the main.tf file, I wrote "ap-south-1" for the region. instead terraform created resources in us-east-1
hi abhishek..i regularly follow your videos and it is very useful to me ...i had a doubt (is terraform execute the resources as a sequence what we mention in main.tf file or specific procedure) bcz aws flowchart starts with REGION then IG, VPC then AVIL ZONE,SUBNET and SECURITY GROUP and EC2 but at 11:41 IG is created after the SUBNET was created.
Abhishek, one thing i did not understand is that even though we have the CIDR block of the subnet is 24, the routing table we define for it has a suffix of 0. It seems it would result in much bigger routing table than necessary. Can you explain?
Thanks Abhishek, will data sources will be covered and if infrastructure is already created then how can we start terraform from there, is it possible to create state file for already created infra to have both desired and actual having same state?
How to generate public key file means directly from workspace or local machine (git bash) . Because i tried to create in workspace itself and it is getting generated as well but accepting the path while apply command of Terraform. Plz kindly update me on this
Hi Abhishek , I want to know if I have Ec2 module and I want to attach this EC2 instance created by a module , to a VPC created in main.tf file located at root then How would this VPC id would be referenced or pass on tp EC2 module , Can u pls help me here
Using wget in remote-exec and its not working. Replaced it with Curl still same problem. The instance is created. All commands before wget get executed, but when it comes to wget or curl, it shows creating and this goes on for infinity. Tried ssh into the same machine and ran the command from the console. It runs perfectly. That implies that this is not a problem of ports. Then what am I missing, or what is the solution if I want to copy a file into my created instance.
The same thing happens in the demo in this recording when running python app, when going to the instance running that command it's working perfectly, but from remote_exec, it is not, if we remove the '&' at end it is running fine, but again it shows creating infinitely..., it is dificult to debug what's going wrong. @Abhishek, do you have any input here?
running a web server is long running process. terraform doesnt know whether it is successful or not. It terminates the command while closing the ssh session. We should run the process background and give some prompt to the terraform. I think we can do it using the nohup cmd
😎😎
I am a beginner..can you elaborate more?
@@Geekgurlcode When you run a Terraform script to provision infrastructure, certain resources may involve long-running processes, such as deploying and configuring a web server. The issue you're encountering is that Terraform may not wait for these long-running processes to complete before closing the SSH session, leading to uncertainties about whether the process was successful or not.
One approach to address this is to run the long-running process in the background and disassociate it from the current session. The nohup command is a useful tool for doing this in Unix-like systems. The nohup command stands for "no hang up" and is used to run a command immune to hangups, with output to a non-tty (non-terminal) that persists even after the user logs out.
as we run any command with "&" at the end , it run the command in backgroud , nohup is just for getting output of the commands in nohup.out files at same location.
@@suhasdhoke1735 I am also thinking the same. It should run in background right as we are using sudo command and & at last it should work. I searched and got this. I am not sure
Shell Differences: The shell environment might behave differently between manual login and remote execution. Try explicitly setting the shell to /bin/bash or /bin/sh in your remote-exec command to see if it resolves any differences.
Abhishek, you saved my life...attending so many worst trainnings in devops, being unemployed with responsibilities for 6 months, I finally found my confidence back...Thanks, Thanks for such a great work. Finally decided to attend interviews
😍😍
EXCELLENT EXPLANATION AND VERY LEARNING !! WITH LOVE FROM NEWYORK USA !!
❤️
G.O.A.T in Devops , Best TH-cam Trainer award should be given to Abhishek Sir.
How come I am just meeting you!!!! Wow! Thank you.. You give confidence to the listener by your teaching. Thank you Abhishek👏
Most welcome
Abhi Anna You are some one who always makes complex topics very easy for the beginners..!
😍
I am trying to understand the logic and the pain, he takes to explain. It made me feel that to my knowledge, none-other -other than he can guide people so sincerely. I will share the link with my friend. Hats off Abhishek!!!!
I have previous knowledge on provisoner but this much easily I never understood, This series helping me for revising Terraform concepts. Thank you Abhi Bro
Great to hear!
Just removed the & in that command & application running in foreground able to access it from browser. It worked for me
🚀🚀
Completed...!
Thanks Abhishek for this great session. 38:40 just remove "&" at line 102 , it will work perfectly.
You are awesome Abhishek , I followed different courses on terraform . Felt terraform is complex , By watching this Zero to Hero . I can feel its very interesting and easy to learn
Glad to hear that
I initially found Terraform to be a challenging tool to work with. However, after following your Terraform series, I've come to realize that it's actually quite straightforward and manageable. Thanks Abhishek 😊
Yes it is very simple
I'm loving your series. I know you will bless us with a similar series for Ansible@@AbhishekVeeramalla 💌
Superb explanation..you made a complex concept into very simplified manner
THANKS FOR PUTTING YOUR EFFORTS
Thank you for creating a Terraform Zero to Hero series it helped me a lot to learn & enhance my skills, I request you to create more real-time projects examples like this which will boost the confidence in gaining knowledge beginners & experienced people.
Your content is worth learning & helps to build their career. Keep going..!!!
I will try my best
Thanks for giving deep dive knowledge in this topic and you are a great man.
Kudos Abhishek for creating this simple content for Provisioners .😊😎
Your are a simha, legend and akanda blockbuster in devops.
haha
We can use nohup &, Then it'll work properly.
Abhishek, you are the Gem in all DevOps trainers. I am a senior software proffessional and following devops practice now. Your explaination is in very simple ways which I can understand without looking into screen (i can understand from audio only)
I had a request about future series should cover complete product/software to be build under complete devops practice ie. Microservices to helm deployments, cicd, monitoring...
This could be a final landing of any devops engineer
Sure
Absolutely wonderful... Thanks a lot for this series.
Most welcome!
Thank you sir, you explained it in much easier and simple way thank you again
You are welcome
Thank you Abhishek!!!...so glad to have found you.🙏🙏🙏🙏
sir your talked about confidence at the end of this video so it is above the expections.
just waiting for the next session... and you are here today 😊thanks 😃🙏🏻
Thanks
very well explaination i got the things so easily.. u really makes hard concepts into soft...this video helps me alot. even i executed it correctly tq abhishek
😍
Thanks for this wonderfull video I have completed this and its working as per the code
Awesome
Hi Abhishek, Thanks for giving this wonderful Terraform series.
Thanks and wish you the same
hi abhishek i am able to successfully implement the task. thank you.
Great Script example and Great explanation ! :)
Thanks Abhishek. I have followed your videos and with my experience I got four offers . thanks a lot..please post more videos on kubernetes and terraform
Hearty Congratulations 🥂
@@AbhishekVeeramalla thanks
Good to see your consistency 👍
Thanks
You are doing a great job bro!! Keep it up
Thanks a lot for this series.
Hi Abhishek , Please can you make at least one consolidated video on networking concepts for Devops engineer , may not be detailed but at least which covers most of the required concepts of enterprise networking (Cloud and on premises ).or may be a video which lists out imp concepts of networking.
sure, noted
Thank you@@AbhishekVeeramalla, me too looking for the same
Thanks abhishek bhai
"sudo python3 app.py &",
removed "&" and "," the script was able to initiate the python application. Not sure on the usage of "&"
after stopping the appkication, terraform returned this error, "remote command exited without exit status or exit signal."
❤nice explained as usual Abhishek .
Thanks a lot
Udemy ❌ Abhishek Veeramalla ✅
😍😍
😍😍
😀
Hi Abhishek, You made my day is very easy becuse even I am under impression that how to write terraform code, after watching your videos, I am confident that any one can learn the terraform. Kudos to Abhishek, helping many upskilling students like me. God bless you my dear.
It's my pleasure
Waiting for your videos annaya 😊 now day's companies are asking splunk if possible pls do video on splunk from scratch to adv.. tq alot annaya
Yeah sure
@@AbhishekVeeramalla tqq alot annaya 😊
Thank you sir. Great video.
Most welcome !!
superb explanation
Thanks
Great explanation ❤
Thanks
Crisp and Clear !
Abhishek Anna OP❤
Most welcome
I wish you could've used modules and backend concept in this video and explain it, Integration of concepts are missing. It would've given more clarity because when we use different concepts or previous topics , things will be real time and gives good knowledge.
super super super explanation
Please include TERRAFORM VAULT also in this course it is very helpful to learners. 😊
Thanks for the provisioner concepts.....will you cover data sources also ??? please try to include this topic in your upcoming videos...
Sure 👍
Nicely Explain
After watching thiese video getting some questions in my mind.
What is difference between tf and ansible?
Upto packages installations the tf provisioners are Ok but in real time projects using more than that so how it will useful ?
By using ansible we can manage all hosts/servers to different operations like installations/copy etc..
THE BEST
Thank you ^^
You're welcome 😊
Hi @AbhishekVeeramalla
Thanks for giving wonderful Terraform series to learn free in TH-cam.
I have find clear cut solution in google "To run a shell script in the background, use the “&(ampersand)” bash control operator and the built-in “nohup” command line tool. Both these utilities almost perform the same job. The core difference between both of them is that the “nohup” command does not kill the background process at the session termination while the “&” symbol terminates all processes after the system logout" this is the correct solution for your assignment i think.
If anything missing. Could you please suggest .
Thanks in advance!!
Yes. the last line should be replaced with this "nohup sudo python3 app.py > /dev/null 2>&1 &"
This will also run the app in the background and discard all output-error log of the app. Doing this it won't kill the process while session termination.
for me app was not running as I was using Amazon Linux ami and tried with ubuntu user. After using ec2-user it worked as expected. Thank you for providing great content.
userdata in ec2 instance and provisioner remote-exec both are the same, instead of defining in AWS console, we are defining in terraform inline remote-exec
I will explianed the difference.. pls check
❤❤❤
Thanks a lot
Just ran into this tutorial series. You have done an amazing job, Abhishek !! Quick question on the connection block of code. Your example works because the EC2 is in a public subnet. How would you connect if the EC2 were in a private subnet ?
Nice
thankyou sir
Thank you so much 😊
Hi Abhishek, I am getting this error while running the terraform apply "Error: file provisioner error
│
│ with aws_instance.name,
│ on main.tf line 86, in resource "aws_instance" "name":
│ 86: provisioner "file" {
│
│ Failed to read ssh private key: no key found"
I would like to know how i can pass my private key of AWS in codespaces?
in connection in private key you have to remove pub from id_rsa
Hii Abhishek…. Your videos are amazing…. I joined one of the paid course but i did n’t get much knowledge now everyday i am following your videos… one small help now i want restart my career with devops as entrylevel do i need do any certifications please let me know i am in uk .. my education M. Tech((CSE)… Thanks in Advance….
Thanks a lot
❣❣
💙
Dear Abhishek, now a days most common question is-how you are deployment in Terraform IAC.Could you share a solid answer for this with an example. Pls Pls Pls
Terraform interview question please note quys we're attending :-
Terraform statefile ?
Terraform tiant ?
Terraform import ( when resource is delete) ?
Terraform destory ?
How to use Terraform file for multiple cloud ?
Hi Abhishek, I am eagerly waiting for conditional operators, functions and TF Cloud.
Am not sure whether they were part of this course.
Lets go step by step
What is the difference between Userdata and provisioner in terraform anna. Can you explain
Waiting for your EKS cluster creation video!!
Hi Abhishek, thanks for the insightful session.
I have one doubt, if in a case I want to delete only 2 resources among 8 resources which I created through terraform. Will it be possible to destroy only those 2 with terraform destroy command ?
Hi Abhishek, As & need to delete from main in terraform, will work fine.
😎
@@AbhishekVeeramalla, But that does not completes the tf infrastructure creation process, it keeps running with "instance ...: Still creating...", & is required at the end to run the process in background and the infrastructure creation should complete successfully.
Hi Abhishek I am able to do it and all the resources are created but not able to access the public IP. I checked the IG and Subnet all looks good. Any tweak required? Thanks
Hello sir, thank you for providing this valuable content. I practiced this lesson, but I'm confused about one thing. In the main.tf file, I wrote "ap-south-1" for the region. instead terraform created resources in us-east-1
Hi Abhishek,
Need to change instead of Day -4 To Day -5 on description Not Thumbnail...
Thanks for the correction
hi abhishek..i regularly follow your videos and it is very useful to me ...i had a doubt (is terraform execute the resources as a sequence what we mention in main.tf file or specific procedure) bcz aws flowchart starts with REGION then IG, VPC then AVIL ZONE,SUBNET and SECURITY GROUP and EC2 but at 11:41 IG is created after the SUBNET was created.
null resource and functions in terraform pls discuss bro....
27:42 sudo apt install python3-flask
Abhishek, one thing i did not understand is that even though we have the CIDR block of the subnet is 24, the routing table we define for it has a suffix of 0. It seems it would result in much bigger routing table than necessary. Can you explain?
Thanks Abhishek, will data sources will be covered and if infrastructure is already created then how can we start terraform from there, is it possible to create state file for already created infra to have both desired and actual having same state?
Hai Bro, Can you make the detail video on jeera ticketing tool..
For statefile locking why should we use dynamo any specific reason behind this?
👍👍👍💪👌
Sir show how we can provision resources using a CiCD pipeline
You are awesome bro and How to add terraform in our jenkins pipeline??
Easiest way is to just install terraform on the jenkins executors and run terraform in your pipeline
How to generate public key file means directly from workspace or local machine (git bash) . Because i tried to create in workspace itself and it is getting generated as well but accepting the path while apply command of Terraform.
Plz kindly update me on this
@Abhishek_veeramlla could you please tell me how to put particular concept in the resume
I am trying 1:1 on, but couldn't book slot for the same. I have texted earlier concerning same. Kindly provide best possible way.
Our subscribers are booking the slots. You can book the latest available slot if not there is a chance you will miss that too
After terraform apply completes, the SSH session closes, which terminate background processes
Hi Abhishek, I know this is not place for this question. Do you have any Idea about Developer Advocate role and is this a right career choice
Hi Abhishek , I want to know if I have Ec2 module and I want to attach this EC2 instance created by a module , to a VPC created in main.tf file located at root then How would this VPC id would be referenced or pass on tp EC2 module , Can u pls help me here
hi Abhishek instead of public key can we use private key with NAT gateway?
Using wget in remote-exec and its not working. Replaced it with Curl still same problem. The instance is created. All commands before wget get executed, but when it comes to wget or curl, it shows creating and this goes on for infinity. Tried ssh into the same machine and ran the command from the console. It runs perfectly. That implies that this is not a problem of ports. Then what am I missing, or what is the solution if I want to copy a file into my created instance.
The same thing happens in the demo in this recording when running python app, when going to the instance running that command it's working perfectly, but from remote_exec, it is not, if we remove the '&' at end it is running fine, but again it shows creating infinitely..., it is dificult to debug what's going wrong. @Abhishek, do you have any input here?
Hi @Abhishek sir,
I am currently working on AWS infra project,I failed in interview as a cloud engineer.please guide which couse good for me
In the interview,is it okay to use the terraform documentation or not?
For terraform statefile creation why should we use only s3 why can,t other db
can we pass value to module to make it dynamic
please come up with the video on data source and terraform vault
Already in the syllabus
1 plan to add when I run terraform plan , and the SSH connection also failed
Hi abhishek how to replace path with our public key files
Did not get the question, please eloborate.
Thanks for giving the replyback the issue is solved
can i configure the ubuntu on virtualbox as slave node and ubuntu on ec2 instance as master node. If yes how?
Hello I am not able to make key pair value using ssh what is the key name when we have to name it?
How do we use depends on to relate all these tiers