Metal Vocalist Reacts - BAND-MAID with The Warning / SHOW THEM (Official Music Video)
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 23 ต.ค. 2024
- Band-Maid x The Warning is freaking DOMINATE!!!! LETS TALK ABOUT SHOW THEM!!!!!!
#bandmaid #thewarning #bandmaidreaction #thewarningreaction
@bandmaid @TheWarning
Any other suggestions please post in the comments!
Become a Patreon - / johnreaveslive
Check Want to Follow me on Socials?
Instagram - / johnreaveslive
Twitter - / johnreaveslive
TikTok - tiktok.com/joh...
Twitch - / johnreaveslive
Join Our Discord - / discord
This is a non-commercial video, a genuine reaction for entertainment.
All rights go to the official owners.
*Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use.
I heard Kanami composed it, and in her typical fashion, she wrote it to push Saiki and Dani, just a little bit further.
Still disrespectful to Ale and Pow you want to get out there and show the world you need POW and Ale These to young Woman are miles better than those that have been in the business for decades. You get peoples attention by putting the work in yourself and giving 200% like POW and Ale do day in day.
I LOVE that The Warning invited them to Mexico to do another colab!!!!!
Did they? I really hope not. Collabs, in general, don't work.
@@v6jim2 really? this is a collaboration... what am i missing?
Was this the guitar-related interview with Dany?
@@v6jim2 the collaboration will continue
@@BlahBlah_13 Yup, just read earlier. Thanks.
Dany’s Lzzy opening is just awesome. The collab is HOLY FUCK!
How beautiful is Kanami's new PRS?!!! What an amazing performance! Every one of these woman absolutely killed!
The tone was perfect!
That's her old PRS. She has "Brush Stroke" Inlays on her new "Private Stock" guitar.
Yeah, she's had this one for a while. Her new Private Stock is a similar color though, but with the border around the headstock, darker hardware, and the stylized bird in-lays on the fret board.
Haha, that's right, I remember now she didn't get the new guitar till after. Thanks for the correction. Anyway..how beautiful is Kanami's old guitar?!! Hahaha
th-cam.com/video/LFJtoAiiLK0/w-d-xo.html
Kanami's new PRS. video from PRS Japan
Kanami with this knowing that Dany and Saiki would be pushed to his those notes...... And just kept it there 😅
Well, she does that to all of her other bandmates, so... ;)
"How can you be a fan of either band and not be cheesing ridiculously right now?"
Well, there's always the lactose-intolerant.
@@PaleHorseShabuShabu 😂😂😂 embrace the Cheesing!! Embrace the Farts!!
Comment is spot on
😂
@@JohnReavesLiveSomewhere on the darkish web is a video of Alvin and the Chipmunks having a dairy farts jam session. 😂
One thing about the vocals overall, the production is very bright on them with a strong reverb. That gives, shall we say kindly, a somewhat "tinny" (shimmery? shrill?) quality to all the vocals. That aside, listen to how powerful and meaty Dany's belt is to open the track on a high note. But notice for the bulk of the track, she uses a vocal production you won't hear on any other The Warning songs, very clean and clear, not tons of drive, no growl. She's doing this to match and blend with Saiki. It's crazy to me the variety of vocal variation Dany can produce throughout her range! She's also the queen of guitar tone, so it really reflects her sensitivity for serving the song with the sound that best suits it, both as vocalist and guitarist.
Don't forget about Miku, she's doing so much more in the background, holding it all together so everyone else can have their moment to shine. Great reaction as usual John. Thanks!
Dany does hit some really high notes in some TW songs, but not continuously like here, which is also higher than Saiki is comfortable with too. Kanami was the evil genius who set that challenge for both of them. There was a back-up plan to lower the range a semi-tone, but both ladies weren't going to back down.
Where did you hear this? Great background info.
Billboard interview with both bands.@@throwaway9389
@@throwaway9389 Billboard japan interview
I think Q+Q is in the same high note
@@gabrielalbertocastillomarq6120Hell You Call A Dream too. Specially in the last “colliding every time” lyric, that was even higher than in this song.
Thanks again from Japan 有難う。 I witnessed the live debut of this song 😍 that was played as the encore & finale of the special concert by Band-Maid & The Warning on June 12 in Roppongi, Tokyo . My seat was located on the 2nd floor but in the center meaning in front of the two drummers. I was in bliss! It looked to me that Paulina and Akane literally and happily competed to see which drummer can kick harder enough to break their bass drum in the joint performance. 🤣
Was there too! Such an amazing experience! dbl ♥
IMHO Dany matched Saiki's voice to a T. Come on, Pau and Akane, Ale and Misa, killers! You've got to love these girls - all of them!
Matched? I love Saiki, but Dany is a couple notches beyond, when it comes to power, rock belting, etc. I doubt she can match Saiki's spitfire delivery, but Dany is on level with Lzzy Hale, Ann Wilson, Joan Jett, and the legends of Rock, as a singer. I am delighted by how well their voices paired.
@@BishopSteinertheAutisticMechWa Well, I guess I should have written paired not matched 😀 like Day, english is not my first language
I think this video is now my favorite world-class jam sessions. Absolutely love how well they integrated with each other - and gave everyone a moment to shine. The respect and admiration they all have for one another shines through so clearly :)
I don't know exactly how high Dany can sing. In HYCAD she goes up to F5 or G5, but I have seen a video of a sound check, where she is playing around and hits some higher notes than that, so not sure what her actual range really is. That is a general observation about The Warning, as they do not showoff much, we do not really know what they can truly do technically speaking.
Dany hits F5 in both HYCAD and Apologize.
Some of her Dany-day vlogs have featured her falsetto going even higher, with impeccable clarity and tone
Great observation on Dany's vocals for this one. Love this tune and both bands together brought it. Plus, someone else brought this up, Alejandra doing a bit of a bass solo before Misa. Not a usual thing for her, but awesome! This song will be played repeatedly for a while.
I was hoping Ale might go barefoot in solidarity with MISA, but nope.😅
@@christopherscottdempwolf5759 Bwahaha! Excellent comment! I agree!
Ale's runs is THE jaw-dropping moment in this track.
I am long time maidiac, but I LOVE this combo, they are AWESOME together!! good analysis John👍 I always tend to listen to lyrics especially Band-Maid and NOW The Warning also! They can make all the colabs they want, I LOVE IT!!
apart from the technical analysis done well John, I do get in-to lyrics too:
I do want to say to the fans (and anyone else) to pay close attention to the lyrics. It is a powerful indictment of the world situation, I love these girls BOTH groups have created quickly a song directed at the current situation, encouraging positive and direct feelings. They are on the side of good for sure. it is no wonder they are all so loved by fans.
I love that MISA got the last notes of the song. 😉
I wonder if that she surprised Ale by finishing the song with a baseline from the first The Warning album.
I think I see in Mikus face how proud she is of the band she put together. I applaud her perserverance and expertise in showing off the talent that Band Maid is. I love this collab and this song!
Dani sings probably that high near the end of HYCAD
Kanami really pushed both their vocal envelopes on purpose. They complained but boss lady kanami said "deal with it". Dany said kanami had her fingers on every aspect.
People tend to refer to some imaginary (male) producer when criticising bandmaid songs and I've always said "nah mincho controls it all with an iron hand" it's true.
Like Danny needs to be pushed
@@jaguaron007 she said she was outside her comfort zone. Kanami has a sixth sense for people's limits and a compulsion to push. She does it with her pals and being treated like that is a sign of respect and sisterhood. She's so shy and humble otherwise.
She asked Akane what was her fastest pace and she said "200" so she writes "black hole" which is 220bpm and really proggy and complex. She wrote a special song for miku and set it's peak right in the sky. When miku arranged it for acoustic she dropped it a tad.
Saiki asked her for a song like "Chose me" a great romantic classic hard rock number she and miku wrote HGK which is named after a Turkish glide bomb and heavy as hell.
But the end result is always great and she welcomes all their input.
It's so good that they all gelled so well. They all really want to do a great job. There is no "good enough" for any of the eight, that's a rare thing.
I hear what you’re saying about Dany singing in a higher register (it’s not about what notes they can hit, Dany certainly has a powerful voice and can hit the big high notes) it’s about the tone. So it’s interesting that to challenge them Kanami asked her to sing in a higher register and for Saiki to hit higher notes.
I’m sure they both pushed themselves pretty hard to get it to harmonize as well as they did.
👍👍An awesomely awesome performance. Great collaboration. 🖖❤
I think the highest note Dany sings in this song is an E5. That note Dany sings in Choke is a D5, but she sings an F5 in Hell You Call A Dream.
NINE beautiful ladies playing ROCK music at its finest! Is this what heaven is? I’m a Maidiac at heart, but what a wonderful collaboration. These two bands show that women have definitely taken over the rock music scene. I LOVE BAND MAID…..and The Warning….❤❤
I don't think there has ever been so many talented rock musician women on a fully crafted track together. Not only that but apart from the trusty studio tech it is an all female creation at every level.
Aside from that bandmaid's long standing videographers did their usual outstanding job of making a visually compelling work but keeping the band members performing front and center.
Saw the PRS Japan interviews and they hinted of a future collab with a TW song featuring BM🤘⚡️💥
Watched a couple of your videos and had to sub. Dany's intro is insane. They are delivering such a positive and uplifting message.
@@jerrymathis5740 heck yes they are!! Thank you for being here Jerry!!
Fabulous song and performance. Only have one regret that Pau was not involved in delivering the backing vocals as she brings a real grit to the backing harmonies. Dany’s vocal range is insane from Choke which is quite low to parts of Hell you Call a Dream close to this pitch. Oh plus Misa’s bass is fire.
FCKEN GLORIOUS !!!! 👍🍻🍻🍻🍻
Was also lucky enough to be at their joint concert in Tokyo in June where they live debuted this song
Did catch the premiere of this video yesterday. Nice to get to read the lyrics on this one
Really hoping that they release an official live video of this from that concert too!
Great reaction dude! I wish we could relive this moment again at that show
@@pewbacca4177 dude same! That was lightning in a performance!
Awesome reaction John ! I was right there with you in Japan! It was epic when they rolled both drum kits out that night 🤘
Hey John! Great reaction brother. As always, love the to see you enjoying the song and the breakdown. Interesting point about Dani. I think this song is 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥!!!!! Enjoy the show...peace out. 🤘😆🤘
Yo It’s been pretty crazy I’m getting messages from reaction that are weeks old! Everybody’s reacting to the Maids! 🍺😁🤘🏻
Pretty cool how they sarted on the street and end up on the roof by the end of the song!! Two bands from opposite ends of the globe that are exploding
It is amazing how Band-Maid and The Warning put together this collaborated song. They did an incredible job of melding their musical styles to give us this rock banger. From Dani's opening wail, this song screams "Girl Power!". Band- Maid and The Waring are the next "Power Couple" in rock!!!!!!!!!
Every time I see this I find myself smiling from the beginning to the end. It's surprising (or not) how well the two bands mesh together. Great song.
Saiki's and Dany's vocals work very well together. Who knew?
Great song from 2 brilliant bands.
Dang, well explained... I didn't think about the high notes Dani was pushing. Cool man
The TW youtube channel posted a video of how the work on this song was going on behind the scenes. It shows the work on the song and the friendship of the girls
One of my takeaways from this song is the bass. You hear both Ale's distorted bass and MASA's clean bass all along the song. And, I heard that the shy MISA and Ale got super best friends.
The Warning and Band Maid...2 de las mejores bandas del mundo!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Absolutely EPIC song and music video!!
They did a superb job!
Viva Band-Maid and The Warning!! ⚡⚡⚡
Really impressed you saw.this song performed live.
Might wanna check Automatic Sun and Hell You Call A Dream. Dany's belts in both are among her highests I can recall.
Fun fact Band Maids first over seas concert was in Mexico.
Amo como la música trasciende todas las barreras, soy mexicana y conocí a John por sus videos de BTS 💜 y ahora estoy comentando en un video de la colaboración de una increíble banda japonesa con una increíble banda mexicana 🤯 🤘🫰
The SECOND incredible international collab this year, and I'm loving it! First Babymetal with Electric Callboy, and now this. More, we need more!
Just wanted to add that I was on that same street (with the lit up tower) albeit further down! 😊
Enjoy your concert tomorrow John!
!!!GOODISM¡¡¡ The Warning + BAND-MAID is 100% 🔥 !!!🎵Ole Ole Ole Oleeee Warning/BAND-MAID🎵¡¡¡. Greetings from Argentina.
Blame Kanami who challenges both Saiki and Dany to those high notes. Dany was close to those in Hell You Call A Dream and even more in some vlgos tho, but both described it to be very challenging in a recent article by Billboard. In the live performance of this song it was Saiki who struggled only 1 time but it might be because she sang it more times. Either way, they made it happen live and it was insane!
seeing Dany and Saiki on that roof top heli-pad gave me flash's of the Ghost In the Shell anime series!
I think the last notes played by Missa are the closing notes of The Warnings survive.
I feel like I got a great introduction to two groups who respect and like each other, and where all members shine and are important -- "meet us all -- pair by pair -- here we are". Dani and Saiki's charisma makes them ten feet tall -- and if the vocals had simultaneously catered to their face and heart-melting talents (a bit lower, more vocal colors) I might've been overwhelmed by them and overlooked the others, so vocals being a bit thinned out might've helped everyone be visible. I'm wondering about the next song maybe changing that... I think Kanami is capable of writing something like Black Hole with 3-4 more parts and it hurts imagining it -- not where I'm expecting things to go either!
Interesting. I thought Saiki was matching Dany's style of singing because this is the first time I have heard her sing this way. I remember a reactor didn't like Saiki because she sang monotone. I am assuming he wanted her to sing like this. Also liked the way the video was shot it made Akane's drumsticks with after images. It looked she was playing the drums with folding fans open.
I liked the groove of the song, but I think the vocal mix was weird. It was too far forward in the mix.
Saiki often sings with Hammer vibrato. But this is because Kanami's songs are too fast. They don't allow him to show off his more subtle technique.
Not since Run DMC did a cover crossover of Walk This Way with Aerosmith back in the 80s. This is the first time two all-girl rock bands duet a new song together. This new track would be a hit on rock metal stations. Sadly, my local rock station only plays classic rock.
My friend: DarWin, The Warning and Band Maid...3 Super Bands!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Everybody is great … but MISA is a freaking beast!
せっかくの２ドラムセット、二人のソロ贅沢なお願い。流石格好いい。
This made me so happy
🎀 W I N W I N !!!!!!!⚡Thx, John.
🤘🤘🤘 KONNICHIWA, HOLA, HELLO John how are you, It really felt like seeing the Avengers for the first time 🤘🤘🤘
great stuff this is bad ass
I agree with you on the vocals. Really neat song with a great message!🤘🏼🤘🏼🤘🏼
Holey smokes John, you're closing on 190K subscribers! Congrats!
An absolute masterpiece of producing from kanami. Recorded in two days ffs.
I think I read that what Kanami wrote was even high for Saiki, but she wanted to keep it where it was
Dany...fantastic entrada!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
It will be interesting to hear this song just with BM and just with TW.
The face offs are so great. My only complaint is that they aren't long enough!
This song was awesome. The only thing missing from the song was the double kicks from the drummers.
5+3= Awesome!
I, too, was at the show in Japan. This song rocked, andvyes, they traded off on the lyrics just like in the video. I do hooe they release the live recirding too.
Now, im gonna see the Warning five times in four cities over the next few months, starting with Plmina and Los Angeles in October. Will you be at one of these?
Dany's range has got higer over The years, that is why she is can hit thise notes with no effort, if You check The acústic set they've Made is more noticiable
From comments I read Dany did sing higher than she is used to.
Apparently Kanami deliberately raised the key for the vocals to push both Saiki and Dany. They talk about it in an interview for Billboard. And Pau is the drummer for TW...
@@ohTHATaaronbrown ahhhh lol dude that makes so much sense!! I need to watch that interview when I get home
@@JohnReavesLive Saiki said Kanami was a sadist. Dany was just smiling.
In HYCAD and Apologize she hits F5 but not continuos. Q+Q is her most continuos high note in a song
@@JohnReavesLivedon't know if there is video, but it's on the billboard website to read. I'd use the billboard Japan version and use Chrome to translate. It has several lines that seem to be removed from the English billboard version.
Kanami is known for such things, for example, she made Akane play the drums 200 bpm (although Akane had previously played 170 bpm max)
good work.
Magnifique 🇲🇽🇯🇵🤘
John, there are apps that can check the pitch/key/range. I don’t know which to pick. I looked. I also saw someone (a reactor) use one of these apps on their phone.
Has serious Manners vibe!!
Let’s go!
⚡️🔥🤘
This colab was about to happen 400 years ago, but you know, dutchies and brits always spoil everything they touch, this song should be in japañol.
🍺🥴🤘🏻
So there is a website/forum, The Range Planet, that tracks vocalists' ranges, based on vocal performances (so if the track has been altered in production it might not be accurate, they might not get the full range if the singer does not use their full range in the songs they sing), and they don't seem to distinguish between clean vocals vs harsh vocals vs throat singing (the one female Inuit throat singer is/was listed as having the lowest range, but depending on how you classify things you might disagree). The Range Planet lists Dany's vocal range as C♯3-G6 (they do list the songs where she hits the notes, but some of the songs they list are Pau songs so they might be mixing up the singers or counting backing vocals), they do not have a listing for Pau or Ale.
This site is known for its carelessness. However, why measure ranges, you either like the song or you don't like it
Actually no, Dany do sings that high at different songs, a good example is Hell You Call a Dream.
TW Drummer = Paulina (Pau)
I don’t know where and why the hate for Band Maid comes from. Mostly it just seems ignorance or just plain lies. I don’t see any Band Maid fans hating on The Warning. The bands are both great and have different styles. If you don’t like the style of BM thats valid. Any nonsense about their talent or brilliance is just hate. The Warning band members would be ashamed of such fans.
Sadly the hatred is from both fandoms. I have seen Band Maid fans who are criticizing TW a lot for their basic instrumental skills and their simple and generic compositions. They are criticizing that Band Maid has had to compose a basic song for TW. People don't understand that the 2 bands are from different genres and each is good in their own genre. Band Maid is hard rock with a metal influence and TW is alternative pop rock. Both are great bands.
@@Itzzy515 This. I’ve seen many comments from fans of Band-Maid or Japanese rock generally who dismiss TW because they’re not as technical, or don’t shred or play fast enough, as if one might not want other things out of music than that.
@@g.garcia7151 I don't think they were fans. There are many trolls who deliberately sow hatred, pretending to be fans or musicians. I recently caught one of them, after a while he admitted that he doesn't care about either band, he just has fun. You can usually spot them by the same posts under different reactors.
J-rock fans won't write like that either, in J-rock shredding is mostly found among metalheads. Japanese rock bands can manage without
@@Olkam-w5u In my experience, they weren’t all trolls. Every successful band has its share of overly antagonistic fans; J-Rock bands are no exception.
@@g.garcia7151 Antagonistic fans are a mental illness. It's easier for me, I'm a fan of 10 bands and 6 solo artists, and I don't have any problems.
Does it seem like Miku softens everything when her voice joins in? For me Miku's voice softens absolutely everything for me. Well except for one thing😊😊😊
IMO, it's a beautiful song, not a great song. This is a BANDMAID song and if you listen closely I notice that BM probably made her "solo" parts stand out a bit more. But it's not about who is better, it's more about the mutual respect and the fun that both bands obviously had. And that's ultimately what it's all about. I like it. Dany invited BM to Mexico and "jokingly" said that they should definitely do a song in Spanish hehehe that would be great Greets from Germany 💞❤🔥⚡⚡⚡
I see you copy and paste troll.
The ladies are having fun and that is good. After one day I have been on a roller coaster ride about what I think about the song. And I have come to the point where I think it´s catchy, there is a little to much of one thing and not enough of something else. When the song is over I don´t feel like listening to it again like I always do with songs The Warning have had their hand on. It´s to much screaming and an empty fast guitar. It has no soul, but it has great lyrics. So my score for this is a 7/10. None of the bands really shine. But they are on the sufficient scale.
Band Maid finally found a way to make me listen to them. 😆
😂 yeah, but it still didn't work for me.
@@v6jim2 🤣
I don’t listen to what I don’t like why would you? I am fortunate to really like both bands and their difference in styles. You’re missing out.
@@DaveRod76bas ic hears always bas ic hears o l d b i tt er m an
@@albertcornett7408 They collabed with The Warning, so gotta listen to the collab. lol
Not a fair comparison on Dany's vocals. Choke was recorded over 2 years ago.
Dany's voice has gotten even stronger since then. As has her range and technique.
She is quite flexible now in style and tone she can sing.
The crazy thing is that she is still maturing and improving.
TW does not need BM and viceversa! Hopefully this would be the last collaboration, obviously this song it’s going to be on BMs record I guess that’s why the members took longer times on the solos,
Did you remember the TW drummer name yet? Or you still don’t remember it?
Dany is 24 and her vocal skills are developing but if you delved deeper into her live videos covering songs during the pandemic you’d understand her range much better. Just because Dany doesn’t sing in her upper register doesn’t mean she can’t. The songs they wrote when younger are in that range for a purpose. They’re singing in a male dominated genre. It was deliberate. With Error, and Keep Me Fed, she is showing her range much more. The irony of your review is I’ve heard others say Saiki was pushing her voice and doesn’t usually sing in that range.
Saiki also doesn't usually sing high. Miku sings the high-note parts, she has a bigger range.
This is no Collab its BD saying look at me. Its discussing How Ale and Pow have been treated. They are there for show, It has none of high class playing and lacks their soul and magic too.
I want to love everything The Warning, but this song is meh.
I don't like the Band-Maid lead singer's vocal in this at all. It hurts my ears. Dany, as always, is amazing.
Just hate somewhere else. Saiki and Dany sounded almost identical. Dany would disagree with you.
@@albertcornett7408 I agree, if it wasn't for the video I wouldn't be able to tell who was singing. They were both outstanding.
Do you copy the same text under many videos on TH-cam?
Fingernails on a chalkboard. Love The Warning, though. And relax, folks, it's only an opinion. Nothing to get upset about.
@@Olkam-w5u I mentioned it one other place. You don't have to get butt hurt over it.
As for the guitars, it was tone vs skill.