Iam not in Nigeria, but l find Judge Funmi as a very calm and intelligent person. I didn’t realise there’s judge like this in Nigeria. May God bless you Ma.
The value of the phones are not supposed to be current value. You buy a car and use it for 1 year, will you sell it at the value of current year when there are new models. Please revisit this case
With all due respect, I disagree with you Busola for the following reasons. The judge did not award the plaintiff the value of new phones. She has not even taken into consideration the inconvenience of time spent without the use of her phones. She has not considered inflation. I realise justice Funmi does not attend to these technicalities. She tries not to complicate and agravate the issues further. Her objective is just to help the parties reach amicable settlement. In that regard, I am of the opinion that the judgment was fair to both parties, especially as the repayment schedule is an agreement between both parties. Kudos to you judge Funmi. May God continue to inspire you.
Wow. In the US the show actually pays 5,000 usd and the plaintiff and the defendant split whatever is left after there is an award given to the plaintiff. For example, if the plantiff wins 1500 US dollars there's 3,500 US dollars left in the pot and the two of them split the remaining difference
For someone who works around Festac, security should be paramount in your mind. To put the customers stuffs entrusted in your care in that place under a canopy leaves much to be desired. I am not particularly moved by the defendants story line which i believe Judge Funmi should try and explore more to make the case more fascinating. She appears easily swayed by their responses.
Who would take a brand new phone for repairs? She used it. But she bought it new. The Samsung. The other one phone was the one she bought as an already used phone!!
@@joyceiyunade3600 It's not a matter of being young. She dragged him to court so that he can man up and take responsibility for his negligence. She is very understanding that's why she agreed to that knowing that the man has piles of debt on his head. Even in life you don't get insured for some losses Sometimes.
The judgment was not well done, the screen of one of the phone was broken,so that should be deducted from face value. More so there is something we call depreciation value of good.You don’t calculate from the market value rather you depreciation the value.
I get your point but remember that, in such business you are liable to replace any missing clients item when it gets loss or stolen. If you insure an item and it get loss or stolen, it is replace with the market value not the state of the item, that's why people insure their goods, so it can be replace to the new state when it gets loss or stolen. Hopefully the country govt. would inact a law that would help the people with insurance companies because if the dude items were insured, the insurance company would be the one sorting her out and also replacing the dude stolen equipment but the insurance system is not friendly to an ordinary citizen.
@@optimusworld I am sorry but I don’t agree with some of the issue you highlighted, when a phone is broken even warranty doesn’t cover such. How can you add up the price of a phone before it was broken and ask the man to pay her damages. No I don’t agree with such judgment. The man just didn’t know how to present his case well. The price of the broken phone should be divided into two.
@@stellaomiyera4146 I agree with you but the issue is that the guy never document everything properly and signed so when such happens you only get the monetry value of your good if the physical item cannot be replaced. The lesson there is never do business with sentiments, treat everyone like stranger so at any point you will always be vindicated. People need to start using written agreements (Terms & Conditions) in all dealing to avoid unnecessary payouts.
thank you so much judge Fumi but pls ma I wish dat u can put some people's account details incase of somecases someone may want to make a donation to help some people to pay their Dept.
I think the Judge should have depreciated the Samsung phone by a year, since the defendant had used it atleast for a year, was in need of repairs and it was not brand new in the first place. my thoughts sha! N150,000 would have been a fair amount.
And the lady said she bought the used infinix 30k and she has used it for a year. The 2nd phone should have been 15k since he is refunding the money for repairs. Like wise the Samsung too.
I pity the guy but as soon as someone entrust you with thier property then you are responsible for the safety of the fone...but just try to get a plan to pay her back..
Lol. This judgment is funny. Even the lady said the phones were not new, and the judge is telling the guy to pay for new phones.. Haaa! This is wickedness o. Nothing to commend the lady for at all. The lady is very happy for getting a new phones for fairly used she bought.
Oh my honourable judge funmi!😢 this judgement doesn't seem fair. I have always loved you and your judgements but this one, I didn't see this coming. I see you did a research that gave you the current second hand value of the phones, but you didn't consider the fact that they were badly damaged, those phone are scraps at this point because he was to fix them with over 30 thousand, the screen of one is bad and the other was software problem, which I know the chances are 50/50 to get that phone up and running. I expected the case be adjourned, proper investigation and deductions done, then the judgement, the guy is paying the girl much more than the value of the phones. Well I hope he learns his lessons, though In the hard way.
Fear God for once,he used his careless and lost somebody property, and you are making this kind of statement on Media, the place he kept those properties,is not safe,why can't him take it to his house, this one would be a lesson to him,
The remove the value of the cracked screen 200k is a lot. The fairly used is 30k haba. This guy is poor. I don't understand what people mean by the lady is nice
The lady is a rubber and not nice. Where is her been nice when she said she bought used phone at 30k and heard the judge presenting the used phone as 50somethingk... Wicked lady
Stupidity and foolishness, how could you keep your stuffs at an open place without no security, no thing. He's now up to neck deep in debts to his customers. This is why these businesses should have insurance to cover for various issues that could cost loss. Unfortunately, Insurance isn't a thing in Nigeria.
@@emekaemeka36 Never by law depreciation is calculated before passing judgment. It tells you how in Africa people do not do their homework before putting people in a certain positions
@@ivillage5872 The judge calculated the prices of fairly used phones according to the items in question make and description as per the receipt and the photo.Both evidence have dates too. To my understanding she passed the verdict after calculating depreciation though that part of the video was cut off.Watch the session again.
@@lovemii3kids but even at that, the law is to make the victim or plaintiffs hole. in this case, the phones were even older than when she bought them, and they were both broken. I'm sure if that case was here in North America, the judgment would have been different. The phone with the broken screen, was fixable. The with the software issues, may not. She should should have been compensated for the value of the phone in the condition they were brought in.
The guy should at least let the judge know the phone is a broken screen fone and the infinix is a dead fone. First, he should deduct the current price of the Samsung screen. Likewise the infinix fone.
I feel the judge was biased. I'm not a judge but if he's paying the full value for the fairly used phone, it's expected that the phone would have no fault. So why is he paying her back the 12,000 workmanship fee? I think the judge should have asked him, or someone else in this work line, the value of the phone with ALL THE DEFECTS SHE WANTED FIXED. (the value would be expectedly lower than the 210,000 she proscribed) If she had done that, then it'd be fair for him to repay the 12,000. I'm not a judge but that's what I think
The judge did not award 12,000 against the defendant, watch the case again. Secondly at 8.05 minutes into the case the judge stated that she found out the current price of the phones. She usually refer to statements submitted to the court to complain and the response filed in court apparently she already made her research that's why she could say she found out the current price of the phones. I recommend you watch all over again so as not to mislead people with your comments. You obviously didn't state the correct position of what transpired. Just watch again.
@@olayinkajunaid9521 she did. the guy has to pay 210,000- that includes the 12,000 and the cost of the phone (at fairly used value). The phones cost, 198,000 total. When you add the 12,000 it becomes 210,000
@@olayinkajunaid9521 samsung price = 145,000 infinix price = 53,000 Making a total cost of 198,000. The judge asked the guy to pay 210,000- this includes the 12,000 workmanship fee. I just re-watched it. You can also watch it again for clarity
Setemi, I don't think she was. I believe when Judge Funmi said this is the current price of the fairly used, she has considered all the phone issues with it. Maybe it would have been clearer if Judge Funmi says, "this is the current value of a fairly used BROKEN screen Samsung Note 9", or "this is the current value of a fairly used UNFLASHED infinix S5". Remember the guy said broken screen and flashing are the repairs he's supposed to do. Since there is no way the guy can prove that he had completed the repair before his storage was burgled, then he must return the repair cost. It may even be better for him not to prove it because the 12k repair cost may save him from values that an unbroken screen Samsung Note 9 and flashed infinix 5 will add to the current price.
The phones were not working hence she took them to Wale foe repairs, they should hv divided d price into 2 or minus what it takes to fix them which is 38k cos d lady thou nice took 2 bad phones to Wale nd wl end up getting gus ones in d end
This man is speaking the truth you can sense it, that he wants to cry, they really stole those from him... Other people will want to ask for theirs too, this is too much... When the govt isn’t providing what the people need, they will try to ensure they fix themselves, no money to get a shop nah...
As much as I respect and love judge Asaolu, I believe this judgement was unfair. Firstly, the lady lied under oath and didn't get reprimanded for it. And the total price of the phones the defendant was asked to pay was unfair as the lost ones were damaged. Lastly, judge Asaolu didn't even allow the lady to consider the defendants first offer before shutting him down. Still a fan tho!
@@ubaniubani4054 where do I start to address your foolishness self cos it seems kind of complicated. If criticizing a public official makes you feel uncomfortable, then you need to reevaluate your life in general. Constructive riticism and diverse opinions make a society grow, but that's obviously too complex for you. Now crawl back to your hole and come back when you've received some sense.
is this a really court of law or is just acting comedy because in kenya we program like this in court but its an acting comedy but this one looks really court
The judge is starting to seem unfair to me because...for him to even make the money to be paying her he need to first replace some of what was stolen in the first place like his laptop...and then her phone is not the only one...idk..
![[TVC BREAKFAST] 'The Justice Court takes cases from outside Nigeria' - Judge Funmi Asaolu](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/CTV_yzH_Yxo/mqdefault.jpg)
![“อ.เบียร์ คนตื่นธรรม” มาตามคำเรียกร้อง แหกศาสตร์ฮวงจุ้ย เตือนสติอย่างมงาย | แฉ 7 พ.ย. 67 [1/3]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/5fc4S3xBNfc/mqdefault.jpg)
Love your problem judge, l live in USA and l am a Nigerian American hearing my people talk , brings back lots of memories
Iam not in Nigeria, but l find Judge Funmi as a very calm and intelligent person. I didn’t realise there’s judge like this in Nigeria. May God bless you Ma.
Watching from Accra as a law student....so inspiring
Very gentle judge, I wish all court rooms where like this
A good development in Nigeria! May God bless you Judge Funmi! Keep it up!!!
That Judge is the best I have ever known.God bless you my princes.
I'm so happy for this new show. Hi from St. Lucia in the Caribbean!
Aaaww, may God bless the lady. Such a good heart.
Judge Funmi u are Great Legend Icon Ma May U continued to increase in all ramifications Amen
The value of the phones are not supposed to be current value. You buy a car and use it for 1 year, will you sell it at the value of current year when there are new models. Please revisit this case
With all due respect, I disagree with you Busola for the following reasons. The judge did not award the plaintiff the value of new phones. She has not even taken into consideration the inconvenience of time spent without the use of her phones. She has not considered inflation. I realise justice Funmi does not attend to these technicalities. She tries not to complicate and agravate the issues further. Her objective is just to help the parties reach amicable settlement. In that regard, I am of the opinion that the judgment was fair to both parties, especially as the repayment schedule is an agreement between both parties. Kudos to you judge Funmi. May God continue to inspire you.
😅 I don't even remember the story again. Thanks for your contribution though
One thing about Judge funmi is this, after listening to the sob story of a debtor, her next line will always be "so when are you ready to pay?"
It because he agreed, he owed her.
If he said NO that he didn’t own her, the judge will give him the room to explain himself
There's no need to explanation from that guy, he did the racket to steal the phone.
Are you baby??😂😂😂😂mummy this one hot ooo lol
Wow. In the US the show actually pays 5,000 usd and the plaintiff and the defendant split whatever is left after there is an award given to the plaintiff. For example, if the plantiff wins 1500 US dollars there's 3,500 US dollars left in the pot and the two of them split the remaining difference
For someone who works around Festac, security should be paramount in your mind. To put the customers stuffs entrusted in your care in that place under a canopy leaves much to be desired.
I am not particularly moved by the defendants story line which i believe Judge Funmi should try and explore more to make the case more fascinating. She appears easily swayed by their responses.
The girl seems to be nice. Regards from Germany. nice and kind.
Sooo...wie geht es dir...i love this court too addicted ..
As someone rightly said, she is young and I'll add, yet to gain wisdom.
I wish I can help this guy chai. Heartbreaking
She's very kind... Bless her soul
That is why he should have a properly registered business with insurance covering it. The govt should ensure that.
I wish all judges in Africa should be like judge fanim
Who would take a brand new phone for repairs? She used it. But she bought it new. The Samsung. The other one phone was the one she bought as an already used phone!!
Tis is the first judgement actually didn't agree with,the phone is used so the amount was unreasonable but the girl wass nice too
She's too nice, I won't even take #10k a month.
That's a queen really. I stan
How can i met the guy to help any of them please to
Check them out in Facebook, they had their full names. Or better still contact the justice court crew.
The lady is really nice 🥺🥺🥺🥺
7k every month till what year ?😭
She's young. That's why!
Swears
@@joyceiyunade3600 It's not a matter of being young. She dragged him to court so that he can man up and take responsibility for his negligence.
She is very understanding that's why she agreed to that knowing that the man has piles of debt on his head.
Even in life you don't get insured for some losses Sometimes.
@@realtalkwithphil ok
The judgment was not well done, the screen of one of the phone was broken,so that should be deducted from face value. More so there is something we call depreciation value of good.You don’t calculate from the market value rather you depreciation the value.
I get your point but remember that, in such business you are liable to replace any missing clients item when it gets loss or stolen. If you insure an item and it get loss or stolen, it is replace with the market value not the state of the item, that's why people insure their goods, so it can be replace to the new state when it gets loss or stolen. Hopefully the country govt. would inact a law that would help the people with insurance companies because if the dude items were insured, the insurance company would be the one sorting her out and also replacing the dude stolen equipment but the insurance system is not friendly to an ordinary citizen.
@@optimusworld I am sorry but I don’t agree with some of the issue you highlighted, when a phone is broken even warranty doesn’t cover such. How can you add up the price of a phone before it was broken and ask the man to pay her damages. No I don’t agree with such judgment. The man just didn’t know how to present his case well. The price of the broken phone should be divided into two.
@@stellaomiyera4146 I agree with you but the issue is that the guy never document everything properly and signed so when such happens you only get the monetry value of your good if the physical item cannot be replaced. The lesson there is never do business with sentiments, treat everyone like stranger so at any point you will always be vindicated. People need to start using written agreements (Terms & Conditions) in all dealing to avoid unnecessary payouts.
God well continue to bless you ma
thank you so much judge Fumi but pls ma I wish dat u can put some people's account details incase of somecases someone may want to make a donation to help some people to pay their Dept.
Good people never lake I love that girl
I think the Judge should have depreciated the Samsung phone by a year, since the defendant had used it atleast for a year, was in need of repairs and it was not brand new in the first place. my thoughts sha! N150,000 would have been a fair amount.
And the lady said she bought the used infinix 30k and she has used it for a year. The 2nd phone should have been 15k since he is refunding the money for repairs. Like wise the Samsung too.
Didn't forget he will be paying this for 3 years
I pity the guy but as soon as someone entrust you with thier property then you are responsible for the safety of the fone...but just try to get a plan to pay her back..
This man sold the phones
The guy couldn't even tell the judge the state of the phones. Haba! The money he is to pay is just too much.
In Africa we take many things for granted until the reality is done on us.
Lol. This judgment is funny. Even the lady said the phones were not new, and the judge is telling the guy to pay for new phones.. Haaa! This is wickedness o. Nothing to commend the lady for at all. The lady is very happy for getting a new phones for fairly used she bought.
Look at d way d guy looked at d gal during entrance
That look was pure venom
You are very observant
Oh my honourable judge funmi!😢 this judgement doesn't seem fair. I have always loved you and your judgements but this one, I didn't see this coming. I see you did a research that gave you the current second hand value of the phones, but you didn't consider the fact that they were badly damaged, those phone are scraps at this point because he was to fix them with over 30 thousand, the screen of one is bad and the other was software problem, which I know the chances are 50/50 to get that phone up and running. I expected the case be adjourned, proper investigation and deductions done, then the judgement, the guy is paying the girl much more than the value of the phones. Well I hope he learns his lessons, though In the hard way.
The judge did not consider depreciation. This is bad judgment.
Good a good judgment
Fear God for once,he used his careless and lost somebody property, and you are making this kind of statement on Media, the place he kept those properties,is not safe,why can't him take it to his house, this one would be a lesson to him,
This girl is really nice oooo
Poor guy is very stressed out. Whilst the government enjoying.
Very concern lady .
Very considerate
Finish my data... I dey enjoy am
What about the 12,000 she paid him to fix the phones?! He should have to return that too!
The remove the value of the cracked screen 200k is a lot. The fairly used is 30k haba. This guy is poor. I don't understand what people mean by the lady is nice
The lady is a rubber and not nice. Where is her been nice when she said she bought used phone at 30k and heard the judge presenting the used phone as 50somethingk... Wicked lady
I would ask him if he reported the burglary to the Police. What if he is lying. The Judge needs to be more in-depth with these people.
Stupidity and foolishness, how could you keep your stuffs at an open place without no security, no thing. He's now up to neck deep in debts to his customers. This is why these businesses should have insurance to cover for various issues that could cost loss. Unfortunately, Insurance isn't a thing in Nigeria.
True! Even insurance won't cover something as careless as he did..
The call something Depreciation. the judgement is wrong in regards to the price. That's how it's done in the USA
You got it wrong. The judge checked the price of fairly used phones of the types involved before passing her judgment. It's the same way in U.S.
@@emekaemeka36 Never by law depreciation is calculated before passing judgment.
It tells you how in Africa people do not do their homework before putting people in a certain positions
@@ivillage5872 The judge calculated the prices of fairly used phones according to the items in question make and description as per the receipt and the photo.Both evidence have dates too. To my understanding she passed the verdict after calculating depreciation though that part of the video was cut off.Watch the session again.
I have never seen nor heard of such an unjust judgement in my life.
I hope he won't roun away
ARE YOU A BABY 👼 😂 😂 😂 😂 JUDGE BIKO LEAVE ME ALONE 😂 😂 😂 😂
She bought the phones used, but working. She brought them to broken. Why should he pay the price she paid.
Bc he should have made sure his shop was safely locked.
@@lovemii3kids but even at that, the law is to make the victim or plaintiffs hole. in this case, the phones were even older than when she bought them, and they were both broken.
I'm sure if that case was here in North America, the judgment would have been different. The phone with the broken screen, was fixable. The with the software issues, may not.
She should should have been compensated for the value of the phone in the condition they were brought in.
The guy should at least let the judge know the phone is a broken screen fone and the infinix is a dead fone.
First, he should deduct the current price of the Samsung screen.
Likewise the infinix fone.
Good evening
The girl said she bought d second phone 30k how come judge says 53?
Well,53k is the market value,that someone gave me a phone wouldn't changed the value of the phone to zero cause i didn't actually pay for it
If you enjoyed watching hit the like button
Oh how i wish i can just help that man
Yeah! it is really sad 😞
I feel the judge was biased.
I'm not a judge but if he's paying the full value for the fairly used phone, it's expected that the phone would have no fault. So why is he paying her back the 12,000 workmanship fee?
I think the judge should have asked him, or someone else in this work line, the value of the phone with ALL THE DEFECTS SHE WANTED FIXED. (the value would be expectedly lower than the 210,000 she proscribed)
If she had done that, then it'd be fair for him to repay the 12,000.
I'm not a judge but that's what I think
The judge did not award 12,000 against the defendant, watch the case again. Secondly at 8.05 minutes into the case the judge stated that she found out the current price of the phones. She usually refer to statements submitted to the court to complain and the response filed in court apparently she already made her research that's why she could say she found out the current price of the phones. I recommend you watch all over again so as not to mislead people with your comments. You obviously didn't state the correct position of what transpired. Just watch again.
@@olayinkajunaid9521 she did.
the guy has to pay 210,000- that includes the 12,000 and the cost of the phone (at fairly used value).
The phones cost, 198,000 total. When you add the 12,000 it becomes 210,000
@@olayinkajunaid9521 samsung price = 145,000 infinix price = 53,000 Making a total cost of 198,000. The judge asked the guy to pay 210,000- this includes the 12,000 workmanship fee.
I just re-watched it.
You can also watch it again for clarity
Setemi, I don't think she was. I believe when Judge Funmi said this is the current price of the fairly used, she has considered all the phone issues with it. Maybe it would have been clearer if Judge Funmi says, "this is the current value of a fairly used BROKEN screen Samsung Note 9", or "this is the current value of a fairly used UNFLASHED infinix S5". Remember the guy said broken screen and flashing are the repairs he's supposed to do. Since there is no way the guy can prove that he had completed the repair before his storage was burgled, then he must return the repair cost. It may even be better for him not to prove it because the 12k repair cost may save him from values that an unbroken screen Samsung Note 9 and flashed infinix 5 will add to the current price.
How can the George ask the guy to pay 210k for a used phone?
I don't believe his shop was burgled, he just sold the lady's phone and made up stories.
This to me, is a very lopsided judgement. How does one pay for brand new phones when what was brought was in bad condition? How abeg
Mummy. Please I can I get to reach you because somebody is hold me money but am not in Nigeria
Imagine 5,000 monthly haba u no show love oo lol
is it a movie or a true life story
The dispute is real and the judgement is binding.
Sweet girl.
Why would this guy live's people phone, in a place that is not secured as he's claiming?
I wonder
That's why the Judge made him pay a Hooge sum.....just for him to learn.
#7000 till eternity careless man
This judge is getting on my nerves. The girl said she bought the samsung brandnew and the othe phone used. She never said she gave him a new phone.
The phones were not working hence she took them to Wale foe repairs, they should hv divided d price into 2 or minus what it takes to fix them which is 38k cos d lady thou nice took 2 bad phones to Wale nd wl end up getting gus ones in d end
U we'll pay for the phone that is the law
Is stealing that serious in Nigeria?
This man is speaking the truth you can sense it, that he wants to cry, they really stole those from him... Other people will want to ask for theirs too, this is too much... When the govt isn’t providing what the people need, they will try to ensure they fix themselves, no money to get a shop nah...
Have you taking your phone to make if you do you will know what those guys can do
Nice girl
As much as I respect and love judge Asaolu, I believe this judgement was unfair. Firstly, the lady lied under oath and didn't get reprimanded for it. And the total price of the phones the defendant was asked to pay was unfair as the lost ones were damaged. Lastly, judge Asaolu didn't even allow the lady to consider the defendants first offer before shutting him down. Still a fan tho!
Really
Your kinds don't appreciate gud people, always complain...
@@ubaniubani4054 and your kinds don't appreciate criticism and diverse opinion, always crying.
@@habeebdapo5120stop being evaluator of people's lives and behaviours and putting yours behind...be useful to yourself and to us at large.
@@ubaniubani4054 where do I start to address your foolishness self cos it seems kind of complicated. If criticizing a public official makes you feel uncomfortable, then you need to reevaluate your life in general. Constructive riticism and diverse opinions make a society grow, but that's obviously too complex for you. Now crawl back to your hole and come back when you've received some sense.
is this a really court of law or is just acting comedy because in kenya we program like this in court but its an acting comedy but this one looks really court
The cases here are real cases and the judgements are binding.
@@JusticeCourtTV please how can I bring someone to this court please
The judge is starting to seem unfair to me because...for him to even make the money to be paying her he need to first replace some of what was stolen in the first place like his laptop...and then her phone is not the only one...idk..
Make stop buying China phone. Just one year phone don get problem .
I want to ask questions? How can this small girl using phone of 210,000?
the guy is a criminal
Love the girl God bless her for me
😀😀
This judge is confused so confused
Why don't they speak their native languages?
It's Nigeria ,Google
This guy sounds like an igbo guy and not yoruba
Does it matter?
@@JoJo-lh5ww it does not, he may have grown up in the east or lived with igbo's and picked up the accent
I admire you a lot, but I show too much sympathy for women always you’re too harsh with men. As a judge equality is very important,
Not true check her marriage cases. Even if their is domestic violence she is still advises the woman to go back to the relationship.
@@ifunanyaesther967 she doesn't advice any 1,pls stop misleading people
The guy couldn't even tell the judge the state of the phones. Haba! The money he is to pay is just too much.
Nice girl