Honourable Javaid Ahmad Ghamidi 's behaviour manifestly shows that he is one of the true preachers of Din e Islam. He knows how to argue; how to listen to others and how to reasonably react. The way he speaks indicates that he is a sincere Momin Muslim. May he live long!
Assalamu aleikum! There are quite a few teachings of janab Ghamidi sahab I don't understand but I have no hesitation in accepting the fact that he is real genius!
mashaAllah what a iolerance n explanation of ontoward n insolant way of addressing javid Ahmed ghamdi,hats off to his knowledge n convincing them with knowledgen great tolerance
There are two conclusions which I detected from this session of discussion: firstly, these three respected men, deliberately, didn't want to understand the perspective of Javed Ghamdi sahb. They had come only to criticize the religious thoughts of him. Secondly, Allah has given every human being a level of understanding, above and beyond they could not, even if they want, match. And I think these people could not reach the level to understand his arguments and religious thoughts. At least traditional Islamic scholars should learn from him how to craft a narrative and argue viewpoint without shoving them down anyone's throat.
Infact they are conventional mullahs and they are scared of Sir Ghamidi as hell. He has destroyed their centuries old blind and ignorant faith with reasoning and shere knowledge. These conventional mullahs can nomore mislead and use ppl for their own interests and gains..
Brothers! there is no point bashing the 3 questioners. Unfortunately, believe it or not they represent the majority mindset and patience is one of the biggest virtue we need to change the situation. Being an admirer or a student of Ghamidi sahab we should also act like Ghamidi Sahab and try to be patient with this mindset and reason with them with the best of your ability. Inshallah positive change will come
My Question to these Brothers! How can you challenge Syed Maududi? Your Madrasas Did. How can you challenge Imam Thimmiya? Your Madrasas Did. How can you challenge other sects? Your Madrasas Did. And I am not saying that Your Madrasas did something wrong. Daleel ko fitna kehne walon, Dusre se ikhtilaf oe kufr k fitwa lagane walon, Kia dosron ko ap ae ikhtilaf ka haq bhi nhi?
إِنَّا ِللّهِ وَإِنَّـا إِلَيْهِ رٰجِعونَ Good luck presenting Quran to non Muslims and expect they will agree with you. Quran and Hadees advice is to think , review , analyze in times and implement Quranic junctions in its fundamental base message.
These QA sessions clearly show difference between madrassah talim and islamic talim which is based on logic and research . secondly see the difference between language used by mullahs and ghamdi sb.
Good comment by the jeans clad Maulavi saheb....”jaan ne aur maan ne ka farq”...I think Ghamidi saheb could not really counter this difference. The basic issue is ordinary mortals like the majority of Ummah have to get on with their daily lives. We do not have the time nor the opportunity to dissect each and every thing. So we just accept what our parents, elders, teachers tell us...now what’s wrong with that...
The thing wrong with that is if someone is born in non muslim family will remain non muslim. If you have been taught incorrect concepts of Islam then you will remain in ignorance.
They are just students from Madaris & talk what they have been taught with limited knowledge & with the believe that they are the only & right custodian of Islam.. Ghamdi sb is not a moulvi but a great & learned islamic scholar who has indepth knowledge & vast research on all the sects even other religions.. They are just novice infront of him & way below his level of knowledge.
دلیل بحث کا دوسرا نام ہے اللّٰہ تعالیٰ کی توحید کو تو شیطان بھی مانتا ہے ہم مسلمان رسالت کے حوالے سے توحید کو مانتے ہیں کہ اللّٰہ ایک ہے اور محمد صلی اللّٰہ علیہ وسلم اللّٰہ تعالیٰ کے محبوب بندے اور رسول ہیں محبوب بندہ ہونے کی دلیل یہ ہے کہ اللّٰہ تعالیٰ اور اس کے فرشتے نبی کریم صلی اللّٰہ علیہ وسلم پر درود بھیجتے ہیں لہذا ہمارا کام بھی آپ صلی اللّٰہ علیہ وسلم پر درود بھیجنا ہے اللّٰہ تعالیٰ کا دین واقعی بہت آسان ہے اللّٰہ تعالیٰ کو اخلاص کے ساتھ سجدہ کریں اور قریب ہو جائیں جو اللّٰہ تعالیٰ کے قریب ہو تا ہے وہ اللّٰہ تعالیٰ کے بندوں سے نفرت نہیں کرتا ۔ اللّٰہ تعالیٰ سے معافی چاہتے ہیں تو اللّٰہ تعالیٰ کے بندوں کو معاف کردیا کریں اپنی زندگی سے گلہ نکال دیں خوش رہیں گے یہ Comments پڑھنے میں لگے ہوئے ہیں قرآن مجید کی آیات سمجھ کر پڑھیں آمید ہے کہ اللّٰہ تعالیٰ آخرت میں اندھا نہیں آٹھائے گا ۔ وقت مختصر ہے اسے ضائع نہ کریں کسی کے کام آئیں ۔
Those who are asking questions got lost. They couldn't hold on to the points they wanted to base their questions upon. They're poor in philosophy where Ghamdi sahab seems to be well versed with, they're struggling on the grounds of intellect, knowledge and logic... where Ghamdi sahab is clearly found to be a master.... and this is so one-sided...
Ye log swaal karne aye hain ya larnay aye hain? In logo se behas karna isilye bekaar hai. Ye log kabhi bhi khukay zehn ke sath argue karne nai atay. Inka sara zor is bat pe hota hai ke aglay ko ghalat kese sabit karna hai.
Even if the questions weren't originally by them, the way they are presenting and the tone with which they are presenting the questions makes it obvious that they completely agree with these questions. A medium remains impartial. So it is safe to say that these are their questions.
Obviously those questions will raise among other school of thoughts but unfortunately thier follwers thinks that thier thoughts can’t be objecct . Beside we got these type of madarsah chap arrogant generation . Allah pakistan ki khair hi karay bus.
I want to say something.ya jo b log ghamidi say batain phuch rahay Han.ya b asay hi nhe banaye.in ko b ek mudad k bad tayar kia gaya hai.ya log sawal phuchna hi gunah samjtay han.in k asi powerful brainwashing ki gaye hai k ab ek conservative say version rakhna in k personality k hisa hai..ab zahir hai jo in ko koi naye baat baataye ga ya in pa sakht naguzir guzray ge.agar kuch theek karna hai tu un madrrsoon ko thek kia jaye jahan asay khas product tayar hotay.afsos ab asay ketnay millions ma bachay hon gae jo is type k personality walay hon gae.agalay 200 years ma zawal hi zawal nazar araha..ab ek asa nazaria musalman macheray ma agaye hai k jis ka maqsad or focus hi janat hai.duniya aur science ma taraqee kahan say karni hai..
Bhai ilamo akal ki bunyaad pr hi koi ghair muslim hi mosalman hota hai apko tu by birth Islam mil gya apny apko koi tehkeek nhi krni pari. Lekin jo muslim nhi hai wo tu tehkeek kry ga or Ilmo akal sy hi har cheez smjhy ga ap jahilo ko 1 bunyadi baat hi nhi smjh ari. Ya ap smjhna hi nhi chahty
These 2 Molvis do not understand the purpose and efficacy of intellect in the understanding of Deen. Why does the Holy Quran state, " Wama Yazzakkaru Illa Ulul Albaab" Translation: ( None pay heed except people of understanding) Also on another occasion it emphasizes, " Afalaa Yatadabbaroon -Al Quran??". Translation: (Why do they not deeply reflect/ apply their minds in the understanding of the Holy Quran) These persons interrogating Mr.Ghamidi are seemingly educated but come accross as idiots when asking silly questions. They have no understanding of knowledge.
سلام ہے آپ کے صبر اور تحمل پر جس طرح آپ تنقئید سن کر استدلال کے ساتھ جواب دیتے ہیں ۔ہماری قوم کو آپ پر فخر ہے۔
beshak
واقعی آپ صحیح کہہ رہے ہیں
Our Ustaz give every explanation in very beautiful manner. I haven't seen such manners in a person. Allah bless him.
True
Honourable Javaid Ahmad Ghamidi 's behaviour manifestly shows that he is one of the true preachers of Din e Islam. He knows how to argue; how to listen to others and how to reasonably react. The way he speaks indicates that he is a sincere Momin Muslim. May he live long!
یہ سامنے اکھٹے بیٹھے دونوں بدتمیزی میں کمال کا فن رکھتے ہیں
غامدی صاحب کے صبر اور اخلاق کو سلام
Allah pak ghamidi shb ko salamat rakhy
Assalamu aleikum! There are quite a few teachings of janab Ghamidi sahab I don't understand but I have no hesitation in accepting the fact that he is real genius!
Lakhon sallam ap pr ustad e Muhtaram Ghamdi sahb...
ماشاء اللہ تعالی آپ جزاء خیر عطا فرمائے آمین یا رب العالمین
ماشا اللہ۔ اس درجہ کے عالم اور استاد صدیوں میں پیدہ ہوتے ہیں۔
aisa saber admi hy ye allah lambi umer dy ghamidi sahb ko
Aese Bacho wale Sawalo per mujhe Gussa ah gya lekin Salam Hai Mere Murshad ko jo aese be'tuky Sawalo Per B Daleel se jawab daite rahy...
Salaam hai Ghamidi saheb ko jo itnay bud-ikhlaaq aur nalayuq logon ko bardashat kar rahay hain.
8سے9 منٹ میں بہت اہم بات کی غامدی صاحب نے
Ghamidi saahab, Aap aqal se baa'laa'tar khubsurat shakhsiyat Hain. Aap ka ikhlaaq, SubhanAllah.
Well done Ghamidi sir
Ghamdi sahab is on another level. Everyone should understand his point of view. He has helped me a lot in my journey
Lakho salam Ghamidi sb ko. You are the real model what we need today
mashaAllah what a iolerance n explanation of ontoward n insolant way of addressing javid Ahmed ghamdi,hats off to his knowledge n convincing them with knowledgen great tolerance
May Allah bless you Sir Ghamidi. You are just a legend. You have saved this generation.
There are two conclusions which I detected from this session of discussion: firstly, these three respected men, deliberately, didn't want to understand the perspective of Javed Ghamdi sahb. They had come only to criticize the religious thoughts of him. Secondly, Allah has given every human being a level of understanding, above and beyond they could not, even if they want, match. And I think these people could not reach the level to understand his arguments and religious thoughts.
At least traditional Islamic scholars should learn from him how to craft a narrative and argue viewpoint without shoving them down anyone's throat.
Very well said!
it looks like less of a debate and more of a interrogation of ghamidi sahib
It is infact
Infact they are conventional mullahs and they are scared of Sir Ghamidi as hell. He has destroyed their centuries old blind and ignorant faith with reasoning and shere knowledge. These conventional mullahs can nomore mislead and use ppl for their own interests and gains..
Jawed Ahmed Ghamdi is indeed a very intelligent person , with modern Day knowledge we need Ulma like Ghamdi Sahib not Mullah anymore
Jahil molvi hain yea sab ... Great ghamdi sahab
The great scholar Javed Ahmad Ghamidi sahab ...we should feel honored that this man belongs to Pakistan....
Brothers! there is no point bashing the 3 questioners. Unfortunately, believe it or not they represent the majority mindset and patience is one of the biggest virtue we need to change the situation. Being an admirer or a student of Ghamidi sahab we should also act like Ghamidi Sahab and try to be patient with this mindset and reason with them with the best of your ability. Inshallah positive change will come
Masha Allah Masha Allah ghamidi shb zindabad
My Question to these Brothers!
How can you challenge Syed Maududi? Your Madrasas Did.
How can you challenge Imam Thimmiya?
Your Madrasas Did.
How can you challenge other sects? Your Madrasas Did.
And I am not saying that Your Madrasas did something wrong. Daleel ko fitna kehne walon, Dusre se ikhtilaf oe kufr k fitwa lagane walon, Kia dosron ko ap ae ikhtilaf ka haq bhi nhi?
At 8:09 key point. Everyone should listen.
sir you are just love
8:11🔥
Ustaad SB ka level ha bhai g
Es pury show ka title koi bta dy mjhe plz
Javed ghamdi sahb k knowledge ko aam molvi hazrat ni samjh sakty
👍
إِنَّا ِللّهِ وَإِنَّـا إِلَيْهِ رٰجِعونَ
Good luck presenting Quran to non Muslims and expect they will agree with you. Quran and Hadees advice is to think , review , analyze in times and implement Quranic junctions in its fundamental base message.
You are awesome sir
I’m learning patience from him.
Great Ghamidi sahib
Mashallah best Gamidi Sahb
Sir agar ap b ak sawal en 2 molviu sa kra yaqeen mana ena pta hea nae
So much respect for ghamdi sab
Ghamidi sb is a true scholar
U r the best
We need tons of patience for such people...They have come only to criticize him but i am sure that inside they must be feeling how to deny him
These QA sessions clearly show difference between madrassah talim and islamic talim which is based on logic and research . secondly see the difference between language used by mullahs and ghamdi sb.
8: 28 pa bath bhot zabardast ke ha
God bless ghamdi sahib
thanx
Good comment by the jeans clad Maulavi saheb....”jaan ne aur maan ne ka farq”...I think Ghamidi saheb could not really counter this difference. The basic issue is ordinary mortals like the majority of Ummah have to get on with their daily lives. We do not have the time nor the opportunity to dissect each and every thing. So we just accept what our parents, elders, teachers tell us...now what’s wrong with that...
The thing wrong with that is if someone is born in non muslim family will remain non muslim. If you have been taught incorrect concepts of Islam then you will remain in ignorance.
These Mullah's should not be allowed to even sit in front of a Genius like Ghamidi Sahab...
یہ حلم یہ بردباری اسی کا ثمرہ اج دیکھ رھے ھیں
They are just students from Madaris & talk what they have been taught with limited knowledge & with the believe that they are the only & right custodian of Islam..
Ghamdi sb is not a moulvi but a great & learned islamic scholar who has indepth knowledge & vast research on all the sects even other religions..
They are just novice infront of him & way below his level of knowledge.
They say define it then do not believe in definitions! Do they have definition of Knowledge!Do they have precise definition of logic/ rationality!
دلیل بحث کا دوسرا نام ہے اللّٰہ تعالیٰ کی توحید کو تو شیطان بھی مانتا ہے ہم مسلمان رسالت کے حوالے سے توحید کو مانتے ہیں کہ اللّٰہ ایک ہے اور محمد صلی اللّٰہ علیہ وسلم اللّٰہ تعالیٰ کے محبوب بندے اور رسول ہیں محبوب بندہ ہونے کی دلیل یہ ہے کہ اللّٰہ تعالیٰ اور اس کے فرشتے نبی کریم صلی اللّٰہ علیہ وسلم پر درود بھیجتے ہیں لہذا ہمارا کام بھی آپ صلی اللّٰہ علیہ وسلم پر درود بھیجنا ہے اللّٰہ تعالیٰ کا دین واقعی بہت آسان ہے اللّٰہ تعالیٰ کو اخلاص کے ساتھ سجدہ کریں اور قریب ہو جائیں جو اللّٰہ تعالیٰ کے قریب ہو تا ہے وہ اللّٰہ تعالیٰ کے بندوں سے نفرت نہیں کرتا ۔ اللّٰہ تعالیٰ سے معافی چاہتے ہیں تو اللّٰہ تعالیٰ کے بندوں کو معاف کردیا کریں اپنی زندگی سے گلہ نکال دیں خوش رہیں گے یہ Comments پڑھنے میں لگے ہوئے ہیں قرآن مجید کی آیات سمجھ کر پڑھیں آمید ہے کہ اللّٰہ تعالیٰ آخرت میں اندھا نہیں آٹھائے گا ۔ وقت مختصر ہے اسے ضائع نہ کریں کسی کے کام آئیں ۔
yh konsay madrassay say ay hai itnay baiwakoof .🤣🤣
ghamdi sahab ka hosla hi hae k ghado ko jawab de rahay hain
Those who are asking questions got lost. They couldn't hold on to the points they wanted to base their questions upon. They're poor in philosophy where Ghamdi sahab seems to be well versed with, they're struggling on the grounds of intellect, knowledge and logic... where Ghamdi sahab is clearly found to be a master.... and this is so one-sided...
Why our all molvis and muftis are not like tariq jamel and javed gamdi?
Ye halwa party kaha a gai ,,,great scholar of the time k samny .
sofee es ko samjy ga lekin jab peer qabar me hong,😃😃
3 jokers with closed minds questioning a real scholar. They should learn from him instead.
Ye log swaal karne aye hain ya larnay aye hain? In logo se behas karna isilye bekaar hai. Ye log kabhi bhi khukay zehn ke sath argue karne nai atay. Inka sara zor is bat pe hota hai ke aglay ko ghalat kese sabit karna hai.
People..try to understand...these questions are actually not theirs...these are questions raised on his thought, they are just a medium
Even if the questions weren't originally by them, the way they are presenting and the tone with which they are presenting the questions makes it obvious that they completely agree with these questions. A medium remains impartial. So it is safe to say that these are their questions.
Obviously those questions will raise among other school of thoughts but unfortunately thier follwers thinks that thier thoughts can’t be objecct . Beside we got these type of madarsah chap arrogant generation . Allah pakistan ki khair hi karay bus.
I want to say something.ya jo b log ghamidi say batain phuch rahay Han.ya b asay hi nhe banaye.in ko b ek mudad k bad tayar kia gaya hai.ya log sawal phuchna hi gunah samjtay han.in k asi powerful brainwashing ki gaye hai k ab ek conservative say version rakhna in k personality k hisa hai..ab zahir hai jo in ko koi naye baat baataye ga ya in pa sakht naguzir guzray ge.agar kuch theek karna hai tu un madrrsoon ko thek kia jaye jahan asay khas product tayar hotay.afsos ab asay ketnay millions ma bachay hon gae jo is type k personality walay hon gae.agalay 200 years ma zawal hi zawal nazar araha..ab ek asa nazaria musalman macheray ma agaye hai k jis ka maqsad or focus hi janat hai.duniya aur science ma taraqee kahan say karni hai..
Bhai ilamo akal ki bunyaad pr hi koi ghair muslim hi mosalman hota hai
apko tu by birth Islam mil gya apny apko koi tehkeek nhi krni pari. Lekin jo muslim nhi hai wo tu tehkeek kry ga or Ilmo akal sy hi har cheez smjhy ga
ap jahilo ko 1 bunyadi baat hi nhi smjh ari. Ya ap smjhna hi nhi chahty
These 2 Molvis do not understand the purpose and efficacy of intellect in the understanding of Deen.
Why does the Holy Quran state,
" Wama Yazzakkaru Illa Ulul Albaab"
Translation:
( None pay heed except people of understanding)
Also on another occasion it emphasizes,
" Afalaa Yatadabbaroon
-Al Quran??".
Translation:
(Why do they not deeply reflect/ apply their minds in the understanding of the Holy Quran)
These persons interrogating Mr.Ghamidi are seemingly educated but come accross as idiots when asking silly questions.
They have no understanding of knowledge.
Samajh nh ata ese jahel log kahan se uth k ajate hen. Ye paglo ka tola hy inko tu joto mein bhi jaga nh deni chahye thi. Solute to Ghamdi sb
Gamdi Sb ney in bachu ke tabyet thandi kerdi
Surprised to see intellect level of these people.
They are unable to simple things.
Inko teeno ko thori tameez seekhny ki zroort hy🤦🏼
Jahilo pehly tameez sekho aik bazurg ustad se bt krne ki jb adab nhi sekha to deen kya sekho ge
Sawalaat karnay walay ya jahil e matlaq hain ya mullaon kay per o kaar.
Sir ya molvi bachara madarsa ka han bs
السلام علیکم غامدی صاحب یہ جاھل لوگ ہیں آپ ان کے پاس ساری نشانیاں لے آئیں یہ اپنے پرانے قصے کہانیوں پر ہی ڈٹے رہیں گے
In jahilo ko samnay rakhna hi nahi chahiyay tha.
Itni chitrol or inte ilmi tareeqe se
😂😂😂