New Canon New Republic: Pweaty pwease can we arrest you? Legends New Republic: Oh look its Imperial Warlord #35 with an oversized ego who murdered my ambassador....and looks like its the K-Wing's turn to kick ass
@@RomanumChristum Not at all. OP is also coping as all those K-wings did nothing when the Yuuzahn Vong came. These people are all the same idealists and naivety that makes the majority of the human population, clinging to false tales of eternal peace and bliss, yet when true darkness comes they wish they had listened to the mean people that said be wary of a lie draped in hope.
@@Crouzain both cases it was due to the enemy’s military superiority rather than incompetence by the NR In both cases the NR fought competently and efficiently but with Palpatine a massive surprise attack on numerous fronts caught them off, whilst simultaneously they were dealing with the immediate aftermath of the Thrawn Campaign, and numerous large scale terrorist raids by pro imperial paramilitary forces destabilized the New Republic. None of that is a consequence of incompetence The Vong had a MASSIVE military and their advanced bio-tech capabilities effectively rendered all traditional weapons and military strategies useless. Once the New Republic learned how to fight the Vong and adapted to their style of warfare the New Republic and Imperil remnants managed numerous counter offensives and defeated the Vong The fact that the NR eventually WON both of these conflicts despite being on the back foot show be all the proof you need of their competence
@@Crouza You say that with unusual confidence, as though the NR could prepare for either. The Yuuzhan Vong alone was something that no one could prepare for, Thrawn's own people weren't fully prepared for it and they were aware.
Disney's New Republic is so astronomically incompetent that not only did an ambassador get murdered and nothing was done, but they thought they could intimidate an Imperial loyalist with... words.
The New Republic underestimated the willpower and resolve of their enemy. Thinking a few soldiers and an ambassador would be enough to counter this threat was just as foolish as when the Jedi believed a few Jedi masters would be enough to stop Palpatine
The New Republic was literally designed to be like the old republic (without the flaws of what made it the Empire) but still having the problems caused it to decline. Infact, the New Republic was stated to be the Empire but with a coat of bright paint
They also didn't have the Jedi anymore as...essentially their enforcers. It's a harsh truth that the Old Republic got away with a LOT of its BS because the Jedi were running around enabling it for the most part. Now all they have is a stupidly scaled-back military run by pacifist doves that survived from the Old Republic era, who while having good intentions...essentially set them up to be frustratingly impotent.
So why didn’t the New Republic send out an entire army or police force to apprehend Morgan immediately? Her killing that official was a deliberate act of war. A war that the NR would have won if the writers of this show actually cared.
@@ArcticWolf00Alpha0most likely they like the Republic before the Empire felt that just because they say so means everyone should comply, and just like the Republic they feel that their “AUTHORITY” gives them enough safety to demand whatever they want
OK, how did she get away with murdering an ambassador from the ruling galactic government without ANY formal response or retaliation from said government?!
Do not patronise, nor assume, someone who has lived through hell, extermination and survival. Choose your words carefully, and know you should never corner a wounded wolf. It will tear you to shreds with its last dying breath.
I would have preferred the sequel trilogy conflict to be New Republic versus the First Order rather than Resistance versus First Order as Resistance was a rehash of the Rebel Alliance. The next big war in the Star Wars movies should have it be the New Republic versus whatever Empire successor or similar evil government crops off.
Maybe it will be the New Republic vs Thrawn and THEN the New Republic versus the Grisks. At that point I imagine the New Republic will be so worn out and demilitarized that it's one of the reasons the First Order rose to power so easily.
Yeah, why do the bad guys get all the advanced stuff while the good guys still need to look poor like in the rebellion? Why can it just be like in the prequel trilogy where they have more armor and equipment to fight fire with fire. Because unlike everyone else I didn’t grew up for the classics, the prequel is the only thing that keeps me motivated.
Disney's version of the New Republic was done so dirty in TFA that writers since then have had to write them to be ridiculously stupid and incompetent in an attempt to justify what happened to them in the Sequels.
@@yurabuchkov8138 ... it pretty much was, I'm afraid, and that was with the addition of the assumption that the Old Republic was more akin to our nation-states than the demilitarized dystopia we ended with.
@@rippingtons60 It also had some redeeming factors. Like powerfull post-Imperial industry and heroes in it's ranks. (Mind not often in command but sometimes they needed to take the rule so this overall pathetic construct called new republic even survived). Disnep version is even worse than the real new republic. Now that is an achievement. Disnep managed to make new republic more pathetic and cringier than the real deal was.
The new republic had so many loyal imperials in key locations they never realize it and the said they were better than the empire when they worst. At least the empire protected people from pirates the new republic didn't
Ah good so the New Republic actually does something! And…where’s the other thirty or forty soldiers they’ll need? Or the X Wing escorts? Or the… Oh… Oh dear… This will not work out well.
Ever since episode 7 came out, Disney made sure sure to make the new Republic look weak and lenient towards Fascism ideology. It kinda undid everything the original trilogy characters fought for and what George Lucas Created.
I think it makes sense. The Galaxy was tired and weary. It wanted reconciliation and peace. It's the same type of thinking that allowed fascism to rise in Germany before WW2. Nobody wanted another Great War, even though that's exactly what they received due to their inaction.
They already did that with the sequels, literally everything they did was for nothing. The empire comes back, the emperor comes back, the new republic gets pretty much wiped out by starkiller base, Han Solo pretty much loses most of his character development, and I don't even have to explain what they did to Luke.
Given that Anakin has been watching this whole thing unfold-especially during the Ahsoka series-I don’t even want to know how he’s having to explain this to Padmé in the netherworld of the Force. The Republic that Padmé and her delegation tried so hard to save was still in the Sith’s grasp, and as the sequel trilogy sadly revealed-Palpatine was still a million steps ahead of everyone. How does one begin to explain to a loved one that everything they have tried to aspire to/accomplish didn’t matter at all, because Palpatine and his Sith predecessors had already sunk their claws into the Republic for the past millennium?
@@mightyshockwave1993 we already witnessed the fall of the Republic and Jedi order in the early 2000s. We saw an underdog freedom fighters fight a galactic government. Disney copied and pasted from Lucas and legends, still did horribly. JJ Abrams, Kathleen, Rian Johnson and Disney ruined starwars. The final order being more unknown than the first was complete bullshit.
I find it hilarious that there are people in this comment section that try to defend this ‘Disney Republic’, they literally jump through hoops to try to justify why the ‘New Republic’ didn’t just send an army to deal with a character who no one cares about! I mean seriously no one asked for this, this is called tales of the empire! We see the empire in a few shots at best. I get what people are trying to say and that the new republic is incompetent however it is poorly done. The New Republic from legends was built much better as they had actual believable problems, from starting a new Government, dealing with warlords, trying to appease members of the Republic whilst still being in charge, trying to do the right thing, rebuilding the Jedi order, dealing with Thrawn, a reborn Emperor Palpatine who actually gets an explanation as to why he’s back and then the Vong and later another dark side user who just so happens to be the son of Leia and Han. Legends builds all this up right and gives it meaning and puts a lot of emotions for the characters to sort out over the course of the years after Endor, it’s really good
Maybe I’m misunderstanding, so this Ambassador who left Corvus and doesn’t legally represent them petitioned the senate to bring Corvus into the New Republic and since they approved, the legal ruler of Corvus has to step down or be arrested even though Corvus never agreed to this arrangement? Pretty imperial of them
They’re dealing with a fractured galaxy after destroying the galactic system, and just like the Jedi and previous republic they believed that their word would be enough to get what they want
The only thing remotely unique about this episode was that we saw the New Republic in Clone Wars Animation/Style something after the death of the Emperor and Vader. I'm not even surprised we see Mando and Luke in Clone Wars Animation
Elsbeth should really be thankful that she wasn't tangling with the Expanded Universe (Legends) New Republic. Oh they would've offered her a chance to come quietly, but they would've given her and her mercenaries a total beatdown if not.
Disney wants the New Republic to make the Galactic Empire look beneficial. That way less people would complain about the NR being destroyed in Episode 7.
Yeah, seems like a good idea to show off why everyone should want to join the New Republic: Just ask the criminal to stop being mean and go away. If that doesn't work, then try and scare them with jail time.
Disney’s New Republic is laughably incompetent. It’s nothing short of a miracle that they have even managed to remain a functioning government for 30 some odd years. And as a fan of and someone who grew up with the EU version of the New Republic, it’s frustratingly sad to see.
So this is how Elsbeth survived the Battle of Planet Dathomir, met Grand Admiral Thrawn and became loyal to him as his top devoted number 1 acolyte, and dominated and ruled Planet Corvus with an iron fist by bringing the capital city: Calodan under her tyrannical claws
The New Republic should have taken the same route of the NCR from Fallout. To wipe out the Empire and it's members just like how the NCR eradicated the Enclave in Navarro after the Oil Rig was destroyed. Letting them live or give them "fair trials" is an insult to all the Empire's victims.
The sad reality is that the leadership understood that perception is everything, and simply exterminating the Empire and its bureaucracy was very bad for perception. Even factions from several of my settings would balk at the idea you're proposing, and one of them has an edict that amounts to 'we have deemed you to be such a threat to the universe that *_genocide_* is the only answer' (and they only used it *_ONCE_* because the enemy they faced basically went 'Geneva Checklist' upon them... ending up with biosphere killing plagues on several planets).
@@aquatic4760 which is sad, because they learned the wrong lessons. Hell, there is a fanfic where Tarkin is a good guy (given that he consistently raised kids to have great morals in both canons... the guy got screwed over by Palpy) and joins the Rebellion; he outright states in a Rebellion leadership meeting that there needs to be an interim government to ensure that the needed reforms are undertaken. Some balk at the idea, but Mon Mothma isn't exactly opposed to the idea (because even she understood that reforms need to be made) but needed to have Tarkin basically explain himself on that... which leads to the other leaders understanding Tarkin's position.
Oh, look, someone thinks the New Republic is more than a bad joke and can actually stand up to the might of Empire. If the sequel trilogy was well written, that would be the case, but Disney would rather rehash the same story, even if it makes no sense.
@@moonquartzs "Your crimes are well known; come with us and you'll totally get a fair trial." The New Republic is as feckless as was the Old Republic; it deserves to lose.
That line is what really did for me I can help you get a fair trail so she wasn’t gonna get one in the first place and you say your better than the empire
the New Republic was still hilariously incompetent in the EU lol, Zsinj mopped the floor with them till a main character had to show up to save the day
Instead of making a tv show about characters that your audience care about, you give this? A jedi praxeum series set in the Legends continuity with this animation wouldve been golden. Oh how i wish i had a time machine.
For those complaining about how incompetent the new republic seems in this, I share your pain but this is a factor where never getting away from, the sequels had the new republic as incompetent and useless this unfortunately means any media tide to them also needs to show the republic is this light or it wouldn’t make sense on why their competent here but not there, which unfortunately means we’ll never see the glory of true republic again
I mean many governments irl are this bad to, the old republic was just as bad unable to help its citizens in its death throws, the New Republic is like the republics formed after a dictator or monarchy is over thrown, imagine how strong is a republic after it just gone through overthrowing one of the greatest tyrants in galactic history? They will be weak, they can’t take more stricter actions on its members since it could start a civil war everyone remembers what the Empire did. The government will be inherently weak it was 20 years the empire rule the galaxy, 20 years and more where people forgot how a democracy runs. The New Republic probably is mismanaged to heck due to inexperience leaders, soldiers can’t run a peace time government.
@ id find this a fair comment if we didn’t know that unfortunately the republic doesn’t get that far, the sequel movies seem to indicate that the republic got destroyed in the 7th film so there’s probably going no showing of a improved republic in future media not without at least a new spin off movie
This is like if in 2001, George W Bush went to Afghanistan with 5 marines and walked up to Bin Laden’s compound and asked him to peacefully surrender to the United States.
The sequel trilogy and Disney portrays the new republic is a spit in the face to George Lucas and all that Han, Luke, Leia and all the other characters fought for
In this universe the new republic of Disney wouldn’t need a yuzhan vong invasion lol they’ll be extinct within a decade (assuming the writers are incompetently competent)
I didn't like tales of the empire focused on minor characters we didn't need liek morgan or baross neither of them represented the empire well should've focused on thrawn and inquistors
Disney Star Wars is garbage, especially when it’s written by Filoni. I also hate this Sequel trilogy damage control. I’ll take the EU over this drivel any day
@@JayDuron-in1hj it not that Bad it really has good moments and scene fights of course there are moments like this one that are very bad but not all of them are the same :)
New Canon New Republic: Pweaty pwease can we arrest you?
Legends New Republic: Oh look its Imperial Warlord #35 with an oversized ego who murdered my ambassador....and looks like its the K-Wing's turn to kick ass
The new republic in legends was like America and their boats
Zsinj casually fucking over the New Republic time and time again:
Oh god its a republicaboo
@@RomanumChristum and the new republic in Disney is the European Union and it’s incompetent bureaucracy.
@@RomanumChristum Not at all.
OP is also coping as all those K-wings did nothing when the Yuuzahn Vong came.
These people are all the same idealists and naivety that makes the majority of the human population, clinging to false tales of eternal peace and bliss, yet when true darkness comes they wish they had listened to the mean people that said be wary of a lie draped in hope.
Y’remember how in legends the New Republic were actually competent and militarily effective? Pepperidge farm remembers…
Was that before or after the Palpatine Clone and Yuuzhan Vong were able to run a train on the whole galaxy?
@@Crouzain both cases it was due to the enemy’s military superiority rather than incompetence by the NR
In both cases the NR fought competently and efficiently but with Palpatine a massive surprise attack on numerous fronts caught them off, whilst simultaneously they were dealing with the immediate aftermath of the Thrawn Campaign, and numerous large scale terrorist raids by pro imperial paramilitary forces destabilized the New Republic. None of that is a consequence of incompetence
The Vong had a MASSIVE military and their advanced bio-tech capabilities effectively rendered all traditional weapons and military strategies useless.
Once the New Republic learned how to fight the Vong and adapted to their style of warfare the New Republic and Imperil remnants managed numerous counter offensives and defeated the Vong
The fact that the NR eventually WON both of these conflicts despite being on the back foot show be all the proof you need of their competence
@@Crouza You say that with unusual confidence, as though the NR could prepare for either. The Yuuzhan Vong alone was something that no one could prepare for, Thrawn's own people weren't fully prepared for it and they were aware.
Disney is woke, woke is a joke, therefore Disney star wars is a joke
@ hey do me a favor real quick buddy: what is “woke” can you define it for me?
What classifies when something is “woke” and when it’s not?
Disney's New Republic is so astronomically incompetent that not only did an ambassador get murdered and nothing was done, but they thought they could intimidate an Imperial loyalist with... words.
Haha yeah 😎
Indeed. What fools they were.
Something WAS done. Ahsoka showed up. My god you people are
I think that's the point
It’s that same hubris that opens the door for the rise of the First Order in 20 years.
The New Republic underestimated the willpower and resolve of their enemy. Thinking a few soldiers and an ambassador would be enough to counter this threat was just as foolish as when the Jedi believed a few Jedi masters would be enough to stop Palpatine
The arrogance is remarkable.
The New Republic was literally designed to be like the old republic (without the flaws of what made it the Empire) but still having the problems caused it to decline.
Infact, the New Republic was stated to be the Empire but with a coat of bright paint
They also didn't have the Jedi anymore as...essentially their enforcers. It's a harsh truth that the Old Republic got away with a LOT of its BS because the Jedi were running around enabling it for the most part. Now all they have is a stupidly scaled-back military run by pacifist doves that survived from the Old Republic era, who while having good intentions...essentially set them up to be frustratingly impotent.
So why didn’t the New Republic send out an entire army or police force to apprehend Morgan immediately? Her killing that official was a deliberate act of war. A war that the NR would have won if the writers of this show actually cared.
@@ArcticWolf00Alpha0most likely they like the Republic before the Empire felt that just because they say so means everyone should comply, and just like the Republic they feel that their “AUTHORITY” gives them enough safety to demand whatever they want
OK, how did she get away with murdering an ambassador from the ruling galactic government without ANY formal response or retaliation from said government?!
I thought that too but well its Disney after all
Even an ant has more willpower than the Canon New Republic
Because mando and ashoka shortly after over threw her
Episode 7 and "starwars: bloodline" will answer that question.
Who are you talking about?
“My world was burning since I was a child. Why should this one be any different?” Chills.
"Because this time you have the choice to not let it burn."
Legends New Republic: fk em imperials
Disney New Republic: “Step down peacefully”
Goes up to ruthless dictator: “Can you pretty please allow us to arrest you 🥺”
Do not patronise, nor assume, someone who has lived through hell, extermination and survival. Choose your words carefully, and know you should never corner a wounded wolf. It will tear you to shreds with its last dying breath.
Or just come with prepared plan and weapons and then this wounded wolf will add its head in your collection.👹
I would have preferred the sequel trilogy conflict to be New Republic versus the First Order rather than Resistance versus First Order as Resistance was a rehash of the Rebel Alliance. The next big war in the Star Wars movies should have it be the New Republic versus whatever Empire successor or similar evil government crops off.
Maybe it will be the New Republic vs Thrawn and THEN the New Republic versus the Grisks. At that point I imagine the New Republic will be so worn out and demilitarized that it's one of the reasons the First Order rose to power so easily.
Unfortunately they're gonna have to " demilitarize the Republic so the broke free dumb fight can fight the first order.
So first order failed again
Yeah, why do the bad guys get all the advanced stuff while the good guys still need to look poor like in the rebellion? Why can it just be like in the prequel trilogy where they have more armor and equipment to fight fire with fire. Because unlike everyone else I didn’t grew up for the classics, the prequel is the only thing that keeps me motivated.
The New Republic, haven’t seen a bigger joke of a government since Weimar
Disney's version of the New Republic was done so dirty in TFA that writers since then have had to write them to be ridiculously stupid and incompetent in an attempt to justify what happened to them in the Sequels.
I don’t think so, the New Republic in the original EU/Legends was also hopelessly corrupt and incompetent.
@@rippingtons60 but at list new republic in EU was not hella stupid as in new canon.
@@rippingtons60 but at list new republic in EU was not hella stupid as in new canon.
@@yurabuchkov8138 ... it pretty much was, I'm afraid, and that was with the addition of the assumption that the Old Republic was more akin to our nation-states than the demilitarized dystopia we ended with.
@@rippingtons60 It also had some redeeming factors. Like powerfull post-Imperial industry and heroes in it's ranks. (Mind not often in command but sometimes they needed to take the rule so this overall pathetic construct called new republic even survived). Disnep version is even worse than the real new republic. Now that is an achievement. Disnep managed to make new republic more pathetic and cringier than the real deal was.
Ah yes let's ask the dictator nicely to stepdown and be arrested. Surely that would work.
The new republic had so many loyal imperials in key locations they never realize it and the said they were better than the empire when they worst. At least the empire protected people from pirates the new republic didn't
"At least the trains ran on time"
Get the f*ck outta here!
Canon New Republic: Let's send them a gift basket with invites!
The Empire: Democ-racy? In MY Galaxy?? I don't think so!
Well at least the new republic troopers put up a fight here. Even if it wasn’t short
Yeah they died with honor
They didn't need to, they died because they were given an ill planned mission
@@normalplayer7377 No, I think that mission went exactly as planned.
Ah good so the New Republic actually does something!
And…where’s the other thirty or forty soldiers they’ll need? Or the X Wing escorts? Or the…
Oh…
Oh dear…
This will not work out well.
The feckless new republic deserves to lose. And lose it will at the hands of Grand Admiral Thrawn.
Ever since episode 7 came out, Disney made sure sure to make the new Republic look weak and lenient towards Fascism ideology. It kinda undid everything the original trilogy characters fought for and what George Lucas Created.
I think it makes sense. The Galaxy was tired and weary. It wanted reconciliation and peace. It's the same type of thinking that allowed fascism to rise in Germany before WW2. Nobody wanted another Great War, even though that's exactly what they received due to their inaction.
That's historically accurate to how Italy for example treated fascism. Look up the Togliatti Amnesty.
They already did that with the sequels, literally everything they did was for nothing. The empire comes back, the emperor comes back, the new republic gets pretty much wiped out by starkiller base, Han Solo pretty much loses most of his character development, and I don't even have to explain what they did to Luke.
Given that Anakin has been watching this whole thing unfold-especially during the Ahsoka series-I don’t even want to know how he’s having to explain this to Padmé in the netherworld of the Force. The Republic that Padmé and her delegation tried so hard to save was still in the Sith’s grasp, and as the sequel trilogy sadly revealed-Palpatine was still a million steps ahead of everyone.
How does one begin to explain to a loved one that everything they have tried to aspire to/accomplish didn’t matter at all, because Palpatine and his Sith predecessors had already sunk their claws into the Republic for the past millennium?
@@mightyshockwave1993 we already witnessed the fall of the Republic and Jedi order in the early 2000s. We saw an underdog freedom fighters fight a galactic government. Disney copied and pasted from Lucas and legends, still did horribly. JJ Abrams, Kathleen, Rian Johnson and Disney ruined starwars. The final order being more unknown than the first was complete bullshit.
I find it hilarious that there are people in this comment section that try to defend this ‘Disney Republic’, they literally jump through hoops to try to justify why the ‘New Republic’ didn’t just send an army to deal with a character who no one cares about! I mean seriously no one asked for this, this is called tales of the empire! We see the empire in a few shots at best.
I get what people are trying to say and that the new republic is incompetent however it is poorly done.
The New Republic from legends was built much better as they had actual believable problems, from starting a new Government, dealing with warlords, trying to appease members of the Republic whilst still being in charge, trying to do the right thing, rebuilding the Jedi order, dealing with Thrawn, a reborn Emperor Palpatine who actually gets an explanation as to why he’s back and then the Vong and later another dark side user who just so happens to be the son of Leia and Han.
Legends builds all this up right and gives it meaning and puts a lot of emotions for the characters to sort out over the course of the years after Endor, it’s really good
Honestly, just how much diplomatic power can an artichoke realistically wield?
Bro I’m dying lmao
First time we see the New Republic in a Clone Wars animation
Why TF they strolling and threating arrest like they already owned the place?
Doesnt seem like Morgan's territory was in their jurisdiction
The same blind New Republic hubris that led to the rise and takeover of the First Order 2 decades later.
Maybe I’m misunderstanding, so this Ambassador who left Corvus and doesn’t legally represent them petitioned the senate to bring Corvus into the New Republic and since they approved, the legal ruler of Corvus has to step down or be arrested even though Corvus never agreed to this arrangement? Pretty imperial of them
Kind of ironic that Morgan ends up setting the entire forest on fire.
They’re dealing with a fractured galaxy after destroying the galactic system, and just like the Jedi and previous republic they believed that their word would be enough to get what they want
The only thing remotely unique about this episode was that we saw the New Republic in Clone Wars Animation/Style something after the death of the Emperor and Vader. I'm not even surprised we see Mando and Luke in Clone Wars Animation
Elsbeth should really be thankful that she wasn't tangling with the Expanded Universe (Legends) New Republic.
Oh they would've offered her a chance to come quietly, but they would've given her and her mercenaries a total beatdown if not.
Disney wants the New Republic to make the Galactic Empire look beneficial. That way less people would complain about the NR being destroyed in Episode 7.
@@robertnelson9599*Disney is trying to program a generation of kids that democracy is weak (so embrace corporatism instead)
Yeah, seems like a good idea to show off why everyone should want to join the New Republic: Just ask the criminal to stop being mean and go away. If that doesn't work, then try and scare them with jail time.
New Republic deserved better in 2015. If bo katan or Luke accompanied the new Republic, Morgan would already be in custody.
For sure
Disney’s New Republic is laughably incompetent. It’s nothing short of a miracle that they have even managed to remain a functioning government for 30 some odd years. And as a fan of and someone who grew up with the EU version of the New Republic, it’s frustratingly sad to see.
The new republic needs a Napoleon figure to assert its dominance
I really wish The New Republic wasn't destroyed in EP 7. They had better equipment to battle the first order/final.
Star wars has only 6 episodes + the rogue one,
@@robertalmadi8422ye I thought those ep 7 or 9 or some shot was some fan fiction
The reason I can't respect the New Republic here is because any governing body has to exert authority. And that is the last thing they are capable of.
Telling her that she can “help” get a fair trail impulse they weren’t going to fair to begin with.
So this is how Elsbeth survived the Battle of Planet Dathomir, met Grand Admiral Thrawn and became loyal to him as his top devoted number 1 acolyte, and dominated and ruled Planet Corvus with an iron fist by bringing the capital city: Calodan under her tyrannical claws
I hated that she was killed
I have never seen a Star Wars character so beautiful
The New Republic should have taken the same route of the NCR from Fallout. To wipe out the Empire and it's members just like how the NCR eradicated the Enclave in Navarro after the Oil Rig was destroyed. Letting them live or give them "fair trials" is an insult to all the Empire's victims.
The sad reality is that the leadership understood that perception is everything, and simply exterminating the Empire and its bureaucracy was very bad for perception.
Even factions from several of my settings would balk at the idea you're proposing, and one of them has an edict that amounts to 'we have deemed you to be such a threat to the universe that *_genocide_* is the only answer' (and they only used it *_ONCE_* because the enemy they faced basically went 'Geneva Checklist' upon them... ending up with biosphere killing plagues on several planets).
That quite literally goes against all of the things the New Republic stands for in both EU and canon
@@aquatic4760 which is sad, because they learned the wrong lessons. Hell, there is a fanfic where Tarkin is a good guy (given that he consistently raised kids to have great morals in both canons... the guy got screwed over by Palpy) and joins the Rebellion; he outright states in a Rebellion leadership meeting that there needs to be an interim government to ensure that the needed reforms are undertaken. Some balk at the idea, but Mon Mothma isn't exactly opposed to the idea (because even she understood that reforms need to be made) but needed to have Tarkin basically explain himself on that... which leads to the other leaders understanding Tarkin's position.
Oh, look, someone thinks the New Republic is more than a bad joke and can actually stand up to the might of Empire. If the sequel trilogy was well written, that would be the case, but Disney would rather rehash the same story, even if it makes no sense.
It’s so pathetic and so obviously contrived. What did they think was going to happen? Morgan was 100 percent in the right.
I mean it all went south when they demanded her to willingly be arrested.
@@moonquartzs "Your crimes are well known; come with us and you'll totally get a fair trial." The New Republic is as feckless as was the Old Republic; it deserves to lose.
That line is what really did for me I can help you get a fair trail so she wasn’t gonna get one in the first place and you say your better than the empire
If this was the EU:
Morgan: "You cannot stop what has begun."
Ambassador: "Funny, I had the same thought about the incoming Y Wings."
the New Republic was still hilariously incompetent in the EU lol, Zsinj mopped the floor with them till a main character had to show up to save the day
Bruh pay for my warcrimes your so funny
Nice to get the new republic in something called tales of the empire otherwise not to bad and gave backstory to a mando episode
Disney made the new republic a joke.
i couldnt agree more :)
@@Chopper66811 yes😂😂😂.
Those four soldiers being sent was an execution. They had no chance
enjoy
Instead of making a tv show about characters that your audience care about, you give this? A jedi praxeum series set in the Legends continuity with this animation wouldve been golden. Oh how i wish i had a time machine.
For those complaining about how incompetent the new republic seems in this, I share your pain but this is a factor where never getting away from, the sequels had the new republic as incompetent and useless this unfortunately means any media tide to them also needs to show the republic is this light or it wouldn’t make sense on why their competent here but not there, which unfortunately means we’ll never see the glory of true republic again
I mean many governments irl are this bad to, the old republic was just as bad unable to help its citizens in its death throws, the New Republic is like the republics formed after a dictator or monarchy is over thrown, imagine how strong is a republic after it just gone through overthrowing one of the greatest tyrants in galactic history? They will be weak, they can’t take more stricter actions on its members since it could start a civil war everyone remembers what the Empire did.
The government will be inherently weak it was 20 years the empire rule the galaxy, 20 years and more where people forgot how a democracy runs. The New Republic probably is mismanaged to heck due to inexperience leaders, soldiers can’t run a peace time government.
@ id find this a fair comment if we didn’t know that unfortunately the republic doesn’t get that far, the sequel movies seem to indicate that the republic got destroyed in the 7th film so there’s probably going no showing of a improved republic in future media not without at least a new spin off movie
It’s honestly depressing how Disney “canon” made everything the original trilogy accomplished amount to nothing.
Democracy doesn't work on a galactic scale. Even the Legends New Republic was crippled fairly quickly.
Legends Cry's for you lost disney fans.
I saw Nadura in this and thought to myself…
Fuck, why haven’t I seen her species on the slave market yet?
I was hoping the new Republic with might come with people dressed as Republic troopers like the ones from the clone wars. Instead of looking too weak.
Creo que esa política se tomó demasiadas confianzas con Morgan
Y eso que vivió antes bajo su yugo
si se paso
Hay personas que solo entienden con violencia. Lamentablemente..,
This is like if in 2001, George W Bush went to Afghanistan with 5 marines and walked up to Bin Laden’s compound and asked him to peacefully surrender to the United States.
I'm confused, if they aren't in the republic how can they arrest her?
@@michaelfrench1019 because she is a criminal
The sequel trilogy and Disney portrays the new republic is a spit in the face to George Lucas and all that Han, Luke, Leia and all the other characters fought for
@@bman3794 very true how does a rebellion over trows an empire just for a new very weak republic to take its place
I'm getting tired of seeing the incompetent new republic.
Congratulations disnep.
You've made new republic even cringier then it already was. But this one is without redeeming qualities at all.
In this universe the new republic of Disney wouldn’t need a yuzhan vong invasion lol they’ll be extinct within a decade (assuming the writers are incompetently competent)
I have somehow completely missed this show didn't even know it existed did it release with tales of the Jedi??
@@teotron7913 yes this is tales of the jedi it on Disney+
She thought that a few republican guards with water pistols would be useful against the savage mercenaries.
This looks good
Where's magister damask? Of damask holdings
He was dead years before this scene
He’s been dead for decades lol
Wait how was she in Ashoka didn’t the mandalorian kill her?
I think that was before
This was just before her appearance in the Mandalorian.
I thought they just arrest her in mando?
The Real story is that the new Republic lasted thousands of years and was successful.
Not this: "OH nO tHE FIrST OrDeR!!!"
Xi jinping?
guys, something tell me THIS new republic are a bunch of idiots
Disney's incompetence.
it’s magistrate not magister
Its not Magister its Magistrate
Mando and Ahsoka did.
I didn't like tales of the empire focused on minor characters we didn't need liek morgan or baross neither of them represented the empire well should've focused on thrawn and inquistors
Along with tarkin, yularen
@ defintely
Why's Xi Jinping there?
@@reichtangleanschluss509 he Pay so he colud appear 😂
What a futile move.
Indeed
Disney Star Wars is garbage, especially when it’s written by Filoni. I also hate this Sequel trilogy damage control. I’ll take the EU over this drivel any day
I agree
😂😂
Pwetty pwease 🥺
The dialogue in Disney stuff is so cringe
Who have they got writing this crap these days???
@@l.s3340 no idea but i would like to knoe
Woman villians are so boring
Man the new Republic acts like how the US act in the Democrats era 😂😂😂😂 all talk, no guns 😂😂😂😂
@@Felix-gv1ij hahahaha 😂
I haven't watched this show, but holy crap is this boring. Peace ✌🏻
@@JayDuron-in1hj it not that Bad it really has good moments and scene fights of course there are moments like this one that are very bad but not all of them are the same :)
lame and cringe