Deepti's matured dialogue is very impressive... Mother's role is played effortlessly... Very nice. The End should have been better, making Rohit understanding mother better.. Planting a positive Node...!!!!
An important point of view has been conceptualized & weaved into a short story screenplay really well, and also executed very well, with sensitive acting, and easy, relatable dialogues, gestures. It's high time this gets normalised, and the privacy of "being an individual" first, and then a “mother”, is brought into the conditioning of Indian men. The background music was really good. Well done team!
18:21 to 18:25 exactly what deepthi told is a very notable point,think practically, if anything that doesn't hurt anybody is nothing to anybody..that's their personal, & everybody has personal feelings..aduthavangla kaayapaduththaatha entha visayamum thappe illa..amma tha,but உணர்வு இருக்கு இல்ல..but one thing privacy is important in this.good short film & Deepti & his name I don't know,their combo was nice.hero looks like slimmer version of actor kathir.
No, that wouldn't have seemed realistic or practical. The director had already portrayed Rohith as slightly immature, not in a negative way. If you had noticed the scene at 1:17 where Rohith is not even able to accept a minor change on the wall clock, how could you depict him as understanding by just having a small conversation with his girlfriend on this topic? Her advise was definitely impactful, but no one can change in a day. 19:48 is the first step towards understanding. It's just my perspective and it's completely fine to have multiple perspectives. According to me the writer has done a outstanding work.
It means he is a type of person who can't accept a small change like even a different clock .so for him that's hard to get that his mom become different as he come to know about that videos@@vishnuprasath1106
Amma kalukum manasu iruku aasai pasam ellame irukum idhe appa pathurundha thappe illa ivan patha mattum thappu illayama very well good scripted short film❤❤
@@Sankar1670 Yow Thapu Right nu one ila...un POV thapu nu sonna others POV la athu right...so its all about POV...Nee akka thangachiya mrg paniviya??? Muslim does so where is thapu right? Un POV athu thapu but muslim POV la nama panrathu thapu....1000exmaples intha mathiri iruku...Porn movies la act panravan mattum ena animals ah avannum una mathiri manusan than...
Menaka, I am truly blown away by your work! This short film is going to be an eye-opener for a lot of people. It's not easy to tackle such a sensitive topic, but you handled it with such ease and great maturity. You have amazing storytelling potential. I watched Kaathal-The core movie a couple of weeks ago. I really admired the way Joe Baby handled the story and the message. I see that maturity in you. Kudos to the whole team. I can't wait to see what you create next - Huge respect to you and your work. ❤
I don't know how I got this in my recommendation. Something like this happened to me last month, for the next 2 days I had the same reaction as him. Then, I understood her. It's not wrong. I convinced myself that me going through her mobile is wrong. Never touched her phone ever after that. I learnt that there's no need to judge anyone. Thanks for creating this video, I think every son needs to watch this. Thank you, Menaka mam❤@@menakaseenu9367
Same same like RJ balaji's movie vetla vishesham..nice concept... Parents and amma appa all are having their wish and desire..we have to give respect to them...
Making a short film is a challenging task; it involves establishing characters, narrating a story, and providing a beginning, middle, and end within a limited amount of time. I believe this film did justice to the process. The seed of the script was established so well without making it cringy; it's tough to address such a topic with the audience we have. The experienced actors, with their subtle acting, made the film even smoother to watch, especially the son and mother duo. Ultimately, the son never confronted his mom, yet we all understood him. Maybe he'll never be comfortable with what she did, but for him to eventually accept her as an individual simply by that smile in the last bit was powerful. I would love to see more of such interesting work from this team.
Loved every bit of it. In the end, pleasure is a personal choice and the script delivered that message beautifully! Excellent acting by Rohit, by Deepti and the who played mom. ❤ kudos.
Rohith Acting Was Very Super First Time Pakkura Rohith Acting Nice Work Man...Vinothini Mam And Deepthi Also Super Acting Than Short Film Super Iruthuchu Nalla Panirukaga Director Manaka Mam Gud Job Mam👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻 Nice... Work and All the best all of You...❤
Congratulations, Menaka, very well directed. You have masterd the art of direction. You will be reaching great heights. If it all, I produce a movie you would be my director. All the best for your future 🎉
Very nice acting, direction, and content.... But heroine call pesumbodhu thookathula pesramadhiri irundhadhu adhu okay... But meet pannambodhum yen thookkathulayea pesramadhiri dub pannirukinga... But it's a nice short movie.
In between he didn't believe his mother's words that, the clock was not working...he doubted that his mother was changing the clock & her behaviour for someone else...but finally he saw that the clock was not working and understood, his mother was not lying and did not change her behaviour!
the is why browsers have an incognito mode for private reasons! mother or not we should respect her boundaries we should not criticize!❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤ To be fair I have NEVER used an incognito mode even when I had internet but instead I use VPN 😜😜😜😜😜😜
Why this crew use a malayali character but she dont know that mich malayalam. You can use coimbatore instead of palakkad. Why using palakkad, otherwise cast a girl who know propar language. And the story and screenplay direction all are better... I loved it❤️
Malayalam pesara style. kevalama irukku.Enda deiii director neighbour paiyan varan andha maid ponnu edukkudhu phone ah use pannra nu sonnapuramum amma va doubt padarana..enna da story panreengaaa
I am a big fan of tamil short films and series and JWF is one of favourite creator and i like most of there contents and this one too but i have to say this not how a Kerala girl who speaks Tamil would talk, everything is nice but when you use another language pls try to put more effort to use general slang of speaking, mostly what i felt is like using some Malayalam words here and there to show she is an malayali character,This is my personal opinion so no offense,the works nice keep creating never before contents
I expected the ending as, the girl teaching the mother on how to use incognito mode😊
😂😂😂😂😂
😂😂❤
😂😂
😂😂😂😂😂
Me too😂
உங்க அப்பா பார்த்தாலும் இதே மாதிரி ரியாக்ஷன் தான் தருவியான்னு ஒரு டயலாக் வச்சிருக்கணும்.
இக்கதை 55 வருடங்களுக்கு முன்னால், 1969ல் ஜெயகாந்தன் எழுதிய 'அந்தரங்கம் புனிதமானது' சிறுகதையை நினைவுபடுத்துகிறது
Thanks for sharing. I read the story “andharangam punidhamanadhu” and it made me more aware of relationship in general.
That house in this movie is very nice 😍😍😍 I love that house more than everything
Same here
Aesthetically designed matched with interiors.. don't its naturally lit...but great source of ventilation
True , beautiful house and sofa
I constructed and got furnished a similar house 🏡 in Kerala
நல்லா இருக்கு மலையாளம் கலந்த தமிழ்❤
Deepti's matured dialogue is very impressive... Mother's role is played effortlessly... Very nice. The End should have been better, making Rohit understanding mother better.. Planting a positive Node...!!!!
absolutely agree, the ending was flat. 21 minutes long short movie with no ending!
An important point of view has been conceptualized & weaved into a short story screenplay really well, and also executed very well, with sensitive acting, and easy, relatable dialogues, gestures. It's high time this gets normalised, and the privacy of "being an individual" first, and then a “mother”, is brought into the conditioning of Indian men.
The background music was really good. Well done team!
Really nuanced and loved it. The symbolism!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!💯💯💯💯💯💯
A beautiful short film portrayed in a sensitive and subtle manner❤ All the actors have performed perfectly♥️ Congratulations to the whole team!
18:21 to 18:25 exactly what deepthi told is a very notable point,think practically, if anything that doesn't hurt anybody is nothing to anybody..that's their personal, & everybody has personal feelings..aduthavangla kaayapaduththaatha entha visayamum thappe illa..amma tha,but உணர்வு இருக்கு இல்ல..but one thing privacy is important in this.good short film & Deepti & his name I don't know,their combo was nice.hero looks like slimmer version of actor kathir.
Nice.. could've been even stronger in a way that Rohith understood things.
No, that wouldn't have seemed realistic or practical. The director had already portrayed Rohith as slightly immature, not in a negative way. If you had noticed the scene at 1:17 where Rohith is not even able to accept a minor change on the wall clock, how could you depict him as understanding by just having a small conversation with his girlfriend on this topic?
Her advise was definitely impactful, but no one can change in a day. 19:48 is the first step towards understanding. It's just my perspective and it's completely fine to have multiple perspectives.
According to me the writer has done a outstanding work.
@@Adks007 i kind of didn't get that 19.48 thingy, what does that clock indicate with the story and about his perspective shift?
It means he is a type of person who can't accept a small change like even a different clock
.so for him that's hard to get that his mom become different as he come to know about that videos@@vishnuprasath1106
Eye soothing
Colors✨️
And
Cinematography✨️
I was stuck in one situation with a different problem but the context is same. Thank you this film gave solution for that problem
What happened
I love deepthi😍and he is a acter kathir saayal👌concept 👌
She mentioned that neighbors son is using her phone. So he’s the culprit 😂😂😂😂😂
I too thought that same😂
Negative perspective as blaming the boys.
@@SUNSHINEARTS-NV💯
@@SUNSHINEARTS-NV❤
Amma kalukum manasu iruku aasai pasam ellame irukum idhe appa pathurundha thappe illa ivan patha mattum thappu illayama very well good scripted short film❤❤
Appan paththa thappu illa nnu sollalayea first porn hea thappu tha normalize pannathingha da porn paithiyangala😅
Seri da ne nallavan dha@@Sankar1670
@@Sankar1670 Yow Thapu Right nu one ila...un POV thapu nu sonna others POV la athu right...so its all about POV...Nee akka thangachiya mrg paniviya??? Muslim does so where is thapu right? Un POV athu thapu but muslim POV la nama panrathu thapu....1000exmaples intha mathiri iruku...Porn movies la act panravan mattum ena animals ah avannum una mathiri manusan than...
Parents yaru pathalum same reaction than irukum
In Part 2 of this short film, we learn that the mom gets kicked out by the apt community thanks to the camera recording everything (see 19:38)
Thats clock shows the trust of mother❤❤❤
Making is awesome - a very decent screenplay and rich look
Awesome 👍👍
Nice Personal matters remain personal until they hurt someone
arumai👍👍
എല്ലാം മായ... മായാലക്ഷ്മി... ❤️❤️❤️☺️🙏🙏🙏😁.
മഹാദേവന്റെ മായ, ഗോവിന്ദൻകുട്ടിയുടെ മായ, അപ്പുക്കുട്ടന്റെയും, തോമസൂട്ടിയുടെയും മായ.
രാ'മായാ'ണത്തിലും ഉണ്ട് മായ.
ലക്ഷ്മിമായ... ❤️❤️❤️🙏🙏🙏
Nice home. The interior is too good.
❤ wonderful
This white or ivory colour everywhere including flooring looks nice
Menaka, I am truly blown away by your work! This short film is going to be an eye-opener for a lot of people. It's not easy to tackle such a sensitive topic, but you handled it with such ease and great maturity. You have amazing storytelling potential. I watched Kaathal-The core movie a couple of weeks ago. I really admired the way Joe Baby handled the story and the message. I see that maturity in you. Kudos to the whole team.
I can't wait to see what you create next - Huge respect to you and your work. ❤
Means a lot. Thanks for watching.
I don't know how I got this in my recommendation. Something like this happened to me last month, for the next 2 days I had the same reaction as him. Then, I understood her. It's not wrong. I convinced myself that me going through her mobile is wrong. Never touched her phone ever after that. I learnt that there's no need to judge anyone. Thanks for creating this video, I think every son needs to watch this. Thank you, Menaka mam❤@@menakaseenu9367
@@menakaseenu9367 I tried finding you on Instagram, but I couldn't. Are you active on any platform where I can follow your work?
Same same like RJ balaji's movie vetla vishesham..nice concept... Parents and amma appa all are having their wish and desire..we have to give respect to them...
Rohith ❤ Deepthi pair semma super Vinothini Vaithyanathan as mother she lives the character
Making a short film is a challenging task; it involves establishing characters, narrating a story, and providing a beginning, middle, and end within a limited amount of time.
I believe this film did justice to the process. The seed of the script was established so well without making it cringy; it's tough to address such a topic with the audience we have.
The experienced actors, with their subtle acting, made the film even smoother to watch, especially the son and mother duo.
Ultimately, the son never confronted his mom, yet we all understood him. Maybe he'll never be comfortable with what she did, but for him to eventually accept her as an individual simply by that smile in the last bit was powerful.
I would love to see more of such interesting work from this team.
Wow!! Did not expect this topic.. Sensitive one & nicely done. The girlfriend looks toooo cute mainly coz of that mole on her chin
Very nice ..keep it up 👍. All the best for future projects..
Starting laye therinchuruchu ithaa climax nu 🙂
Loved every bit of it. In the end, pleasure is a personal choice and the script delivered that message beautifully!
Excellent acting by Rohit, by Deepti and the who played mom. ❤ kudos.
JFW - Well written concept.. Both men and women, they should understand & respect each other, irrespective of what relationship they have..
I thought he would fix the clock when he leaves towards the end...😅
Woow ! The moment Rohith found the clock tells everything about his Mom🥰😍
I didnt understand
Elegant one!!
Rohit 💙💙
V.well taken
Loved all the characters! A nice subtle-sweet story. I enjoyed watching it! all the frames were classy.. Great work Menaka and team👏❤
What does the director trying to convey. God knows
Hes trying to say use VPN and incognito
Rohith Acting Was Very Super
First Time Pakkura Rohith Acting Nice Work Man...Vinothini Mam And Deepthi Also Super Acting Than Short Film Super Iruthuchu Nalla Panirukaga Director Manaka Mam Gud Job Mam👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻 Nice... Work and All the best all of You...❤
Rare theme....but its really nice well said❤
Nice plot❤
Watching it 2× saves time btw 😂
Congratulations, Menaka, very well directed. You have masterd the art of direction. You will be reaching great heights. If it all, I produce a movie you would be my director. All the best for your future 🎉
No one can hurt in family anything was personal its ok ....
Everything had limits even affair also their personal any one can sure its was good😅
But where is the ending for it....could have been with a lot more meaning, looked like it has a part 2
Her slang of speech just make me 😇 the way she portrait the thing for he
Aawwh Beautiful one 💗
I never met a Malayali friend who speaks like this. Except that everything is good
Wow...subtle and elegant....
Super ❤ all times favorite vinothini mam acting in mother role❤...rohith bro perfect character of son😊 nice cinematography, music,lighting❤
As usual amazing short film JFW team ☺️❤️
Nice message and well made except Deepthi’s slang 🙈
Nice work rohit❤❤❤
Why her voice modulation is like half drunk 🥴 ? Something so off-putting. Otherwise lovely short movie. Loved the house
I expected a better ending. Doesn't convey the msg properly. Otherwise beautiful cinematography
20 நிமிஷம் கதையே இல்லாம உருட்டிக்கிட்டு இருக்கீங்க? சூப்பர்..
Bro ungaluku pudikalina ethuku pakaringa
Yaraiyum demotive panna tinga
Boomeru if you don't understand go watch kappalottiya thamizhan
😂@@AnanthNat
But not super
Title attakaasam❤
😂
Ada pavigala ahh last vara matter solla la da 😅😅
It's a very very good shot flim
a really good film
tavara yaaru senjaalum tavarudaa ,neenga solluradu ,kudikkuradu tavaru kidayaadu sigaret pudikkuradu tavaru kidayaadu,maari irukku.
His girlfriend looks smarter than him. lucky if someone in real life.😅
Very nice 😊
Wonderful marvelous extraordinary
Excellent short film
so she watched or someone else used her phone? i dont understand
Very nice acting, direction, and content.... But heroine call pesumbodhu thookathula pesramadhiri irundhadhu adhu okay...
But meet pannambodhum yen thookkathulayea pesramadhiri dub pannirukinga... But it's a nice short movie.
Very well done 🙏💐
Ending cld ve been better, though concept is good
What does the old clock denotes?
In between he didn't believe his mother's words that, the clock was not working...he doubted that his mother was changing the clock & her behaviour for someone else...but finally he saw that the clock was not working and understood, his mother was not lying and did not change her behaviour!
@@sasikumar9938 🫡🫡♥️
@@sasikumar9938also she preserved the dad’s clock as a sentimental value, that shows she loves her husband and misses him.
Very very nice I love mom ❤️ my mom is very nice so carrying me😊😢 I love you mom 💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖
the is why browsers have an incognito mode for private reasons! mother or not we should respect her boundaries we should not criticize!❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤ To be fair I have NEVER used an incognito mode even when I had internet but instead I use VPN 😜😜😜😜😜😜
Coping mechanism meaning ?
Just good handling the issue, fine making
Waiting for Deepti's big screen action❤
Beautiful 😍
Good one ❤
Thalaivi Deepthi come back in TH-cam
Super...❤ msg Nice ❤Movie 🌹Concept 🌹Congressional🌹 Your Team...
Enna thanya solla varinga 😂😮😊
athu onnum illinga purijikka mudiyathavanga intha short film ha pakka vendam nu soldranga😇
@@gopinathr9065 😅🥲ok
😂😂😂😂😂😂
Cinematography like Jailer sayal iruk
Why this crew use a malayali character but she dont know that mich malayalam. You can use coimbatore instead of palakkad. Why using palakkad, otherwise cast a girl who know propar language. And the story and screenplay direction all are better... I loved it❤️
Just wow....
Nice..❤
Feel good short film with crisp content delivered
Awesome feelings...❤❤❤❤
Intha clock seekiramaa ninrum eaana battery capacity long life varaathuu
What does that clock say? Enakku purila
Memories of his father I think so
Time of father's death...time frozen and locked.
Malayalam pesara style. kevalama irukku.Enda deiii director neighbour paiyan varan andha maid ponnu edukkudhu phone ah use pannra nu sonnapuramum amma va doubt padarana..enna da story panreengaaa
Second part pls
NICE MOVIE LAST VARAIKUM YAR PATHANGA THERILA, BUT CHINA PAIYA PATHA ITS A PROBLEM LA ?
Kaalaila dan idli thenga chutney saaptaan, marubadiyum dinner ki dosa thenga chutney aa.. Bore adikaadu?
Successfuly 21 minutes wasted 😅
Can any one tell what's this ringtone at 10:50
What is the take away from this short film?
Awesome . Good ways is to avoid expressions
I am a big fan of tamil short films and series and JWF is one of favourite creator and i like most of there contents and this one too but i have to say this not how a Kerala girl who speaks Tamil would talk, everything is nice but when you use another language pls try to put more effort to use general slang of speaking, mostly what i felt is like using some Malayalam words here and there to show she is an malayali character,This is my personal opinion so no offense,the works nice keep creating never before contents