Democracy, Elections and the Indian Muslim
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 23 พ.ย. 2024
- This is the fifth episode of Yeh Daagh Daagh Ujala, the long-form discussion series by Karwan e Mohabbat.
The theme of this discussion is Democracy, Muslims and the Indian Muslim. Writer and peace worker Harsh Mander speaks with three senior political scientists and commentators - Zoya Hasan, Professor Emerita of Jawaharlal Nehru University, Yamini Aiyer, formerly President of the Centre for Policy Research, and Mujibur Rehman, Professor in Jamia Millia Islamia University.
The discussion reflects first on the evolving and shifting representation of Indian Muslims in parliament since Independence. Muslims have from the first election been represented less than their share in the population in the Lok Sabha. But this touched a new low in 2024, when BJP put up only one Muslim candidate in the entire country, and even non-BJP parties have nominated Muslims in historically low numbers. While all discussants agreed that it is not just Muslims who should represent Muslim interests, there was some divergence about the extent to which this represents actually an erasure of Muslims from political representation, and the consequences of historically low Muslim representation in the Lok Sabha.
When you put the two words Muslim and Democracy together, you are making a riddle.
Lol that is just lie, nations likr Indonesia , Malaysia, Nigeria, turkey, Kazakhstan etc shows that muslim and democracy can work together,and their were much more functional vibrant democracy were there in past in muslim world before usa and western Allies threw out them for their own selfish interest
Islam and secularism is an even bigger riddle.
Mr Mandhar please always have atleast one panelist of opposing views also
But then it would be hard to listen to other views
I am not only a supporter of Partition (of India) but a champion and I consider it very essential. I find Savarkar's demand for an undivided nation (Akhand Bharat) with both Hindus and Muslims living together a very novice thinking. My only pre-condition is that every single Muslim must be moved to Pakistan and every single Hindu must be moved to India otherwise new nation will never be a stable nation which is an essential condition for progress and development. (BR Ambedkar in the book on Pakistan and Partition of India, written 7 years before actual partition. He remained supportive of this statement till the actual partition)
Give me an example of muslim majority area where Hindu is elected as a representative !!!
is anyone watching the NDA meeting in old parliament? what a load of crap!!! its like they are in living their delulu world and not wanting to face reality.. there is a BJP meet today evening and modi may not even be the PM candidate but all this meetings are saying otherwise.. this is just annoying AF
Peacefuls will always vote communally after getting subsidies and scholarships
42:55 Jaha muslman miniority me hai vaha. Vo jo seculer model nehru ka tha..
- Musalman bhi represent kar sakta hai musalman ko
- Hindu bhi represent kar sakta hai Musalman ko.
Note: He said this for constituencies where Muslims are in the minority. He does not believe in this logic where Muslims are in the majority. He did not express his discontent about the Kashmiri Muslim majority not electing a Hindu CM or the Old Hyderabad Muslim majority not electing Hindu MP.
Har jagah Muslim unki representation,unki reservation..no one interested about Hindu community....unhe kya cahiye no one is talking
Ye 2 auntion ko ghalat bula liya 😑
If muslim believe in democracy they could have voted as per personal understanding and candidate in their constituency like hindus do and not in block only to defeat BJP.
They are working on Gazwa e hind 2047 and BJP is a road block for them.
यह झूठ है कि मुस्लिम प्रतिनिधित्व का प्रश्न नहीं था क्योंकि जिन्ना की मांग ही यह थी कि मुसलमानों का प्रतिनिधित्व हिंदुओं के समान हो
Is desh mein 20% Musallmaan hai --- population ke hisaab se -- toh 20 % desh ka resources India ke Musallmaanon ko milnaa chahiyey --- par miltaa hai hardly 1 % yaa 2 % ---- 50 % jo General category ka reservation hai -- woh saara ka saara -- 3 % Brahman aur 7 % Kshatriya yaani oonchi jati jo sirf 10 % hai -- unke jeb mein jaata hai --- Kya yeh Indian Democracy aur Secularism hai ??? jahan 3 % aur 7 % desh ka saara maal aur resources aur zameen hadap rahey hain --- Naya SACHAR REPORT BANAO -- AUR AAP KO PATA CHALEGA KI MUSALLMANON KI HAALAAT PEHLEY SE BHI JYADA KHARAB HAI --- AUR UNKEY AGAINST BHED BHAV -- HATRED AUR DISCRIMINATION HO RAHA HAI --- AUR DENIAL OF RESOURCES --- DENIAL OF RIGHTS --- HO RAHA HAI -- Desh sabhi Indians ka hai --- naa sirf 10 % oonchi jaati ka ???\ 20 % reservation Musallmanon ko on basis of Religion milnaa chahiyey --- Providence by Grace of God has made the Muslims of India so abundantly self-sustaining that even the most cruel economic exploitation and forcibly pushing them towards Pakistan -- and bulldozing and destroying their business and property by administration and even by fanatic Hindus rioting mobs --- will not disable them beyond a certain limit.
Change hindhu mentality.
Yes ricebag.
group of jokers and terror minded discussion is in no use
खान मार्केट गँग
हरमंदिंर वामपंथी खान मार्केट गँग नफरत #अस्मानीकिताब से आया..... ऊसके बारे में कब बोलेगा....?