Thanks. This is the only one that actually worked. I've tried other people's and none of them works. Also, they don't explain if they are using Java or Bedrock or using a mod. And when I do ask, I get no replies.
I'm glad to see this design working as great for other people as it does for me 🙂 I spent a long time searching for other designs but could only find bedrock ones so built my own. Haven't seen too many other ones for Java Edition since 1.19.4 came out but always interested to see what's out there
I had to use a redstone lamp instead of the second jukebox cause with the jukebox it was somehow not working (Version 1.20.2) but now it is and its really great! Thank you for the amazing tutorial
The second block is actually a noteblock 🎵 But any block (like a redstone lamp) that changes state with redstone will work so glad it’s working for you!
It is a custom pack, it is linked in the description 🙂 There are some issues with the 1.19.3 Creative menu changes but it’ll be fixed eventually EDIT: A 1.20 version is now available with a range of fixes!
It's completely random since the dropper just shoots a random disc out the 9 slots, you could try expanding the hoppers into a chest or something? I'd have to have a play around myself but some sort of external storage feed might help
That can’t be anything to do with the redstone as the jukebox will only change its state when the song is finished playing, I have noticed a couple songs seem to end differently than I remember when playing on my server, I wonder if it is a client desync issue
This is something I've really been meaning to play around with, I think if you rework the hoppers a bit you could add extra storage. I've also been playing around with adding other items into 4/5 slots of the top hopper feeding into the jukebox to stop discs getting stuck
sort of works, when the music has finished, it doesnt go into the hopper below and does its cycle it just keeps on playing but with no sound, im on java and its on a server
The only reason it wouldn’t go into the hopper below would be if the hopper wasn’t receiving power from somewhere, any other redstone sources nearby or is the lever in the wrong position? Are you on 1.19.4 or later?
I made it in a server when I am near the jukebox it works like a charm and works like it should but if I unload tha chunks or come after some time while its playing it just plays but doesn't give any sound, I want it to be playing non-stop in the server, will chunk loader work?
Unfortunately that’s just how jukeboxes function, they have a limited range for the volume of the music that decreases the further you get and if a track is started when you’re not within range you won’t hear any music when you do get close until the next song starts
@@udayanmallik0 A lot of the music discs can be found on TH-cam/Spotify/Apple Music, could be a solution if you wanted to listen to them non-stop anywhere while you’re playing
@@mcpeachpies You seem to have misunderstood what he said. I believe he is talking about deloading the chunk and then coming back. I also believe he is talking about being gone away from the jukebox and then the song stopping and then him coming back to the system not repeating due to the chunk not loading in.
@@disbe1ief2006 I have found that when I leave mine playing and leave the chunk sometimes it’ll be silent until the next track starts. But I wonder if it could be a problem depending on how it’s built within/on chunk borders maybe causing problems with the detection?
Clicking hoppers? You mean the dropper? Double check all your hoppers and observers are the right way around along with the solid and updating block the observers are checking. I've also found it tends to work best when there are multiple discs in the system otherwise it seems to get confused
Is it possible to take the disc out without clicking the jukebox? With redstone I want to have a button to play the next song without me having to click the jukebox itself
I'm afraid not, you can only remove a disc but right clicking on the jukebox. I've seen a few people trying stuff with hopper minecarts to catch the disc when you eject it
One problem I'm having (1.20.1) is the music disc isn't leaving the jukebox when it finishes. How do I fix? Edit: Nevermind it just happened to play stal twice in a row.
I built this on my server, and it works at first. But if I leave the area for a while and come back, I find it has stopped. Only starts playing again when I right click the jukebox to take out a disk manually.
Hmm that is odd, I have found other people have similar issues. I find that sometimes It'll start replaying by itself but after sometime, can't say that it's locked up for me like that though. I wonder if it has something to do with block updates in unloaded chunks?
@@mcpeachpiesafter a while I noticed that it actually starts playing again. I have to be patient. I think when I return, it's just silent for the rest of the song. Then when the next disk starts, it's all good again.
@@nathanielpillar8012 It's the exact same for me. I think it has something to do with chunks, because I stayed next to the jukebox during the whole song to see if it stopped, and it looped just fine.
@@grsnvin4773 i think it had something to do with all the slots on the dropper being full so the hopper under the jukebox couldnt empty so what i did was move some manually from the dropper to the hopper above the dropper leaving some space
@@squido_ Glad you've fix it for you, note that the observer is checking for a change in state of the hopper not the content of the discs. Essentially observer is triggered then the redstone/locked state of the hopper is power/unpowered by the jukebox playing a song. In that sense when the jukebox is done playing a song it will no longer output a redstone signal and unpower the hopper therefor changing its state and triggering the observer onto the dispenser I wonder if what you've encountered is if the bottom hopper is full, there will be nowhere for the music disc in the jukebox to go which might cause some problems with the state of the top hopper? I've found that it really works best if that bottom hopper doesn't get clogged up, could help to limit how many discs are in the system
A problem with this design, its shuffle doesnt work correctly, it will shuffle the songs randomly but some will get stuck in the hoppers. The disc that pops out the jukebox will be the first slot in the hopper which is then put into the dropper. The discs in slots 2,3,4,5 are just trapped there
@@drpatrickmorbius5966 I have noticed that happening too, as stated this is just a concept and I never claimed it to be perfect. I imagine it works alright with a reduced number of discs but very interested to hear your solution, something along the lines of adding more storage would be my approach at the lost of compactness
It's not working for me. I'm on the same version is you and I did it the exact same way you did, and it just when you flip the switch it goes up to the hopper but then doesn't go into the jukebox
Having the lever powered will lock any hoppers and stop new discs from playing, I wonder if you try putting the disc directly into the jukebox (with the lever turned off) if it will cycle correctly?
@@mcpeachpies welp, I tried putting it in the hopper turning on and off didn't work put it in the Jukebox turn it on and off then work ice is not working for me oh, I'm doing this on a server so maybe they've got something on here that's not allowing it to do that but that's okay. Maybe someday I'll try it on my survival world, keep doing what you doing man don't stop ever
@@labichefurtive2329 That sounds like an interesting way to do it, I’ll have to try it out! I tried to keep the jukebox as clear of redstone as I could so that it could still be on display, but very curious to see how your concept works
@@thelordofcringe Is it all discs or just ones in day the last 4 slots of the hopper? I’m wondering if maybe there are too many discs in the system it might get clogged
@@mcpeachpies I only have one disc, could that be causing the problem? Alternatively, I'm doing this on a realm with my friend. I've heard people say Realms can cause redstone issues every time you leave.
@@thelordofcringe Hmm maybe, I could see only one disc causing problems due to how it’s setup to trigger the dispenser (by checking for changes in the top hopper) I don’t think Realms should be an issue. I might do some testing later and get back to you!
I’m not 100% sure, unfamiliar with Bedrock’s redstone workings. I have a funny feeling it’s even easier in Bedrock due to lack of redstone budding issues.
I just tried making this on bedrock. It works if you replace the note block with another solid block, and replace the block above that with redstone dust.
It does work, as you can see in the video. It's a concept because it's the best I could figure out I'm sure there are others out there who might have better ideas to compact and simplify the required redstone 🙂
The way they implemented it is really stupid. It would have been so cool if they had made it possible to read out the disc playback progress with a comparator, and a redstone signal to eject the current disc. That way you wouldn't have the hopper blocking and quasi connectivity issues at all... Could also skip a disc without manual ejection and picking it back up.
This is awesome, thank you! I was able to basically flip your design to work vertically for a 2x4 space that I had.
Oh Awesome! Is that by checking the state of the hopper on the bottom? I didn't even think to try that but I suppose it works exactly the same
Thank you, I hid one in my friends base playing all the songs they hate
1.20 came out yesterday and this works like a charm! Thanks a lot!
It works on bedrock too if you replace the note block with any other solid block, and replace the block above that with a piece of redstone dust
Precisely the kind of thing my build needed
Music makes all the difference!
Excellent mechanism. Thank you very much!
Thank you! This is exactly what I was looking for, and it's easier to do than I thought.
Simple, yet effective. Absolutely love this, thank you mguy!
Glad it's doing the job for ya!
This helped me so much with my concert venue. Now i can play songs from the dj booth on stage. Thanks
Very good quick tutorial, like it ^^
So cool! :D
Blocks Needed:
2 Hoppers
2 Obeservers
1 Dropper
1 Note Block (with a block on top)
1 Juke Box
1 Lever
Don’t forget a lever! Unless you want music playing forever 🕺💃🪩
@@mcpeachpies lol i forgot (i fixed it now)
Hey, this worked great! Other than the discs duping themselves twice, I love it!
Duplicating? Do you mean playing the same discs multiple times in a row or do you mean actually duplicating the items in the hopper/dropper?
@@mcpeachpies Tried it on a friends server and it turns out to be an incredible duping machine! Did get me into a bit of trouble though!
Oh no 😅 Is it a Vanilla server? I haven’t had any other reports of it duplicating discs
Thanks, i wanted a bit less complicated tutorial, because i tried a really weird tutorial that didnt work, im gonna try this one. :-)
Nice video!
thanks man!
Thanks. This is the only one that actually worked. I've tried other people's and none of them works. Also, they don't explain if they are using Java or Bedrock or using a mod. And when I do ask, I get no replies.
I'm glad to see this design working as great for other people as it does for me 🙂 I spent a long time searching for other designs but could only find bedrock ones so built my own. Haven't seen too many other ones for Java Edition since 1.19.4 came out but always interested to see what's out there
thanks jimmy
dude ... finally !!!
cool!
I had to use a redstone lamp instead of the second jukebox cause with the jukebox it was somehow not working (Version 1.20.2) but now it is and its really great! Thank you for the amazing tutorial
The second block is actually a noteblock 🎵 But any block (like a redstone lamp) that changes state with redstone will work so glad it’s working for you!
So cool
Almost as cool as your TH-cam videos
Works
Nice contraption!
And I really like your texture pack! Where can i get it? Or can you tell us the name?
It is a custom pack, it is linked in the description 🙂 There are some issues with the 1.19.3 Creative menu changes but it’ll be fixed eventually
EDIT: A 1.20 version is now available with a range of fixes!
how do i make it so it stops playing the same 3 or 4 discs
It's completely random since the dropper just shoots a random disc out the 9 slots, you could try expanding the hoppers into a chest or something? I'd have to have a play around myself but some sort of external storage feed might help
i used your design and it works pretty well, but songs are being skipped when they are not finished and i dont know why. how do i fix this?
That can’t be anything to do with the redstone as the jukebox will only change its state when the song is finished playing, I have noticed a couple songs seem to end differently than I remember when playing on my server, I wonder if it is a client desync issue
1.20 fixes this, as songs will now only leave the jukebox once ended
I want to fit more than 9 discs and loop them by order, can it be done?
This is something I've really been meaning to play around with, I think if you rework the hoppers a bit you could add extra storage. I've also been playing around with adding other items into 4/5 slots of the top hopper feeding into the jukebox to stop discs getting stuck
sort of works, when the music has finished, it doesnt go into the hopper below and does its cycle it just keeps on playing but with no sound, im on java and its on a server
The only reason it wouldn’t go into the hopper below would be if the hopper wasn’t receiving power from somewhere, any other redstone sources nearby or is the lever in the wrong position?
Are you on 1.19.4 or later?
I made it in a server when I am near the jukebox it works like a charm and works like it should but if I unload tha chunks or come after some time while its playing it just plays but doesn't give any sound, I want it to be playing non-stop in the server, will chunk loader work?
Unfortunately that’s just how jukeboxes function, they have a limited range for the volume of the music that decreases the further you get and if a track is started when you’re not within range you won’t hear any music when you do get close until the next song starts
@@mcpeachpies ok thanks for the reply...
@@udayanmallik0 A lot of the music discs can be found on TH-cam/Spotify/Apple Music, could be a solution if you wanted to listen to them non-stop anywhere while you’re playing
@@mcpeachpies You seem to have misunderstood what he said. I believe he is talking about deloading the chunk and then coming back. I also believe he is talking about being gone away from the jukebox and then the song stopping and then him coming back to the system not repeating due to the chunk not loading in.
@@disbe1ief2006 I have found that when I leave mine playing and leave the chunk sometimes it’ll be silent until the next track starts. But I wonder if it could be a problem depending on how it’s built within/on chunk borders maybe causing problems with the detection?
The Hopper into the Jukebox only clicks, it won't send a disc into the Jukebox. Any tips?
Clicking hoppers? You mean the dropper? Double check all your hoppers and observers are the right way around along with the solid and updating block the observers are checking. I've also found it tends to work best when there are multiple discs in the system otherwise it seems to get confused
Is it possible to take the disc out without clicking the jukebox? With redstone
I want to have a button to play the next song without me having to click the jukebox itself
I'm afraid not, you can only remove a disc but right clicking on the jukebox. I've seen a few people trying stuff with hopper minecarts to catch the disc when you eject it
@@mcpeachpies that sucks
Would've been pretty nice to have that
One problem I'm having (1.20.1) is the music disc isn't leaving the jukebox when it finishes. How do I fix?
Edit: Nevermind it just happened to play stal twice in a row.
how did u fix it, mine isn't leaving the jukebox when it finishes
@@waffaruu1689 i didn't fix, it just sort of worked on its own, I'm not sure
Mine get stuck in the dropper 😂
@@Kael-Baelanyone know the fix? Same here.
I built this on my server, and it works at first. But if I leave the area for a while and come back, I find it has stopped. Only starts playing again when I right click the jukebox to take out a disk manually.
Hmm that is odd, I have found other people have similar issues. I find that sometimes It'll start replaying by itself but after sometime, can't say that it's locked up for me like that though. I wonder if it has something to do with block updates in unloaded chunks?
@@mcpeachpiesafter a while I noticed that it actually starts playing again. I have to be patient. I think when I return, it's just silent for the rest of the song. Then when the next disk starts, it's all good again.
@@nathanielpillar8012 It's the exact same for me. I think it has something to do with chunks, because I stayed next to the jukebox during the whole song to see if it stopped, and it looped just fine.
I think the observer isnt detecting the discs moving through the hopper and the dropper isnt being activated
nvm fixed it also thanks for the tutorial :D
@@squido_ how did u fix this i have the same problem
@@grsnvin4773 i think it had something to do with all the slots on the dropper being full so the hopper under the jukebox couldnt empty so what i did was move some manually from the dropper to the hopper above the dropper leaving some space
@@squido_ Glad you've fix it for you, note that the observer is checking for a change in state of the hopper not the content of the discs. Essentially observer is triggered then the redstone/locked state of the hopper is power/unpowered by the jukebox playing a song. In that sense when the jukebox is done playing a song it will no longer output a redstone signal and unpower the hopper therefor changing its state and triggering the observer onto the dispenser
I wonder if what you've encountered is if the bottom hopper is full, there will be nowhere for the music disc in the jukebox to go which might cause some problems with the state of the top hopper?
I've found that it really works best if that bottom hopper doesn't get clogged up, could help to limit how many discs are in the system
I love you
A problem with this design, its shuffle doesnt work correctly, it will shuffle the songs randomly but some will get stuck in the hoppers. The disc that pops out the jukebox will be the first slot in the hopper which is then put into the dropper. The discs in slots 2,3,4,5 are just trapped there
This can be fixed but is still a pretty large oversight
@@drpatrickmorbius5966 I have noticed that happening too, as stated this is just a concept and I never claimed it to be perfect. I imagine it works alright with a reduced number of discs but very interested to hear your solution, something along the lines of adding more storage would be my approach at the lost of compactness
thanks i want play cat and chirp forever so good song
Both great songs!
bonjour, ça ne marche pas les cd ne passent pas dans les entonnoirs en java eddition
salut, cela ne fonctionnera que sur l'édition Java version 1.19.4 et supérieure 🙂
doesnt work
@@trippietabz1516 Can you give any more specifics? Are you on Java Edition 1.19.4 or later?
Doesn’t work on Xbox unfortunately I’ve tried.
It's not working for me. I'm on the same version is you and I did it the exact same way you did, and it just when you flip the switch it goes up to the hopper but then doesn't go into the jukebox
Having the lever powered will lock any hoppers and stop new discs from playing, I wonder if you try putting the disc directly into the jukebox (with the lever turned off) if it will cycle correctly?
@@mcpeachpies ok, I'll try that tomorrow. I'll say then whether or not it works. Ty:)
@@mcpeachpies welp, I tried putting it in the hopper turning on and off didn't work put it in the Jukebox turn it on and off then work ice is not working for me oh, I'm doing this on a server so maybe they've got something on here that's not allowing it to do that but that's okay. Maybe someday I'll try it on my survival world, keep doing what you doing man don't stop ever
@@CharlieLitt That is strange, I might have a play around and see if I can recreate the same issue. Hopefully you can figure it out soon!
@@CharlieLitt it works, just check where are your dropper direction is and especially check hoppers directions, remember to shift click to stuff
you can do much simpler, juste 2 powered rails on top of the jukebox and hopper, 6 blocks total
alternatively, replace the top hopper with a dropper, torch on top of the jukebox and rail on top of the dropper
@@labichefurtive2329 That sounds like an interesting way to do it, I’ll have to try it out! I tried to keep the jukebox as clear of redstone as I could so that it could still be on display, but very curious to see how your concept works
Where do I plug in my headphones?
Bluetooth only sorry
@@mcpeachpies damn, I'll buy some of those soon then
i am using this to make a Minecraft map where every five minutes another instance of stal plays
That is amazing! Stal is one of the best songs by far 🐟
for me discs keep getting stuck in the hopper underneath the jukebox 💔
Are you on Java edition?
@@mcpeachpies Same problem, java edition.
@@thelordofcringe Is it all discs or just ones in day the last 4 slots of the hopper? I’m wondering if maybe there are too many discs in the system it might get clogged
@@mcpeachpies I only have one disc, could that be causing the problem? Alternatively, I'm doing this on a realm with my friend. I've heard people say Realms can cause redstone issues every time you leave.
@@thelordofcringe Hmm maybe, I could see only one disc causing problems due to how it’s setup to trigger the dispenser (by checking for changes in the top hopper) I don’t think Realms should be an issue. I might do some testing later and get back to you!
Your house looks cool, any tutorial for it?
Thanks! Nah just kind of threw it together, always fun to play around and see what works
I know it says Java but does it also work in bedrock??
I’m not 100% sure, unfamiliar with Bedrock’s redstone workings. I have a funny feeling it’s even easier in Bedrock due to lack of redstone budding issues.
I just tried making this on bedrock. It works if you replace the note block with another solid block, and replace the block above that with redstone dust.
Good to know!
It didn’t work for me
Can you be more specific?
Does this work in 1.19.2? :]
Sadly not, they only made the changes to jukeboxes in 1.19.4 I believe allowing them to interact with hoppers and output a redstone signal
@@mcpeachpies that's ok! Thank you for the tutorial!
Doesn't work anymore 1.20.4
Seems to be working fine for me, did you have it working on previous versions?
so it doesn't actually work? its only a concept?
It does work, as you can see in the video. It's a concept because it's the best I could figure out I'm sure there are others out there who might have better ideas to compact and simplify the required redstone 🙂
This works in Bedrock? It doesn't work for me!
i cant get this damned thing to work ._.
On Java Edition 1.19.4 or later? Got all the hoppers and observers facing the right direction? Those tend to be the easy things to miss
The way they implemented it is really stupid. It would have been so cool if they had made it possible to read out the disc playback progress with a comparator, and a redstone signal to eject the current disc. That way you wouldn't have the hopper blocking and quasi connectivity issues at all... Could also skip a disc without manual ejection and picking it back up.